Well, of course it can never BE the Beatles, but these AI songs do serve to give us an idea of what modern Beatles songs might have been like if they had continued. These don't sound like vintage Beatles to me -- they really sound like the Beatles would have with new songs and modern production. So, these are cool from a "What if?" standpoint. Wonder what Paul and Ringo would think of these? :-)
You’re very critical, aren’t you? Not sure what you mean by the above remark. It’s a good song, a good arrangement and a good recording. As for your Dylan comment- it is Dylan’s voice but there was no intent by the singer to sound like Dylan, so the phrasing, accent, pronunciation etc are that of a 60 year old Englishman, not a 26 year old American. Meanwhile, I’ll look up some of your stuff for inspiration
This is a great song! I really enjoy listening to it! I have a question for you. I really hope you can see this comment still. With the A. I technology you are using, could it be used to clean up tracks too? The reason I asked, I got my hands on a copy of "She's My Baby" by Wings, which has the full ending (album version cuts into Beware My Love) but the problem is the quality is poor with alot of hiss. Is it possible to clean it up with what you're using!?
@@Trevornator Rip it and save as an mp3 or wav and email it to me. My email is now under "more about this channel" or "about". Let me know if you see it
@@urasam2 I sent it😃 I hope it works on your end. It was a M4A file so I hope thats fine. I was having laptop problems earlier so by the time i got it running, I forgot about converting it to MP3. Just let me know if it doesn't work and I will try again!
it's not bad at all. There is a couple places I can tell it's not really Paul singing. I especially like the part about the bird talking to him. Reminds me of my day yesterday after getting a good workout in the woods.........mocking bird swooping in on me and watching.....I did my best personification of a derelict asking for bus money. "Hey Boss man......I need 71 cent to catch the bus to go uptown". The bird seemed to be thinking my request over.
@@mcmusicm All my samples were from 1967-70, mainly the White Album and Sgt Pepper. I’m not confident enough yet to use sovits so I use an online site that trains from your samples
I for one don't like the slippery slope this AI is bringing us down, and there's also the issue of the voices and images being used without permission.
@@zee4798 So, do you consider that tribute acts like The Bootleg Beatles are “guilty of theft”, acts who actually play songs by the Beatles, dress as the Beatles and pretend to be the Beatles?
@@urasam2 they do that under licence pal your using there names there brand to profit from it and your not the only one . It's not even good it's crap this is a good example of AI steeling from from original artists . It's only a matter of time before one of the remaining Beatles or there family see one of these rip offs . And I don't think they'd be very happy they also have a lot more money than you do and lawyers. The Beatles are a brand pal not just a band
@@urasam2 you enabled comments, it don't mean you have to like them. Or do you only want to read positive comments? The AI voices are amazing its just the song which was terrible may I suggest putting AI voices to a song called sub-rosa subway by a rock band called Klaatu this sounds like a beatle song already but with AI voices it would sound amazing.
😂, good point and no not opposed to it, but I don't like those. But there is a difference I think. AI-music uses your AI-voice in a song you maybe would not approve to sing in real life. Tribute bands are covering the original songs of the bands. I do think artists should have control over how their voice will be used as AI, that's all
@@frankkortstee9877 Yes, but tribute bands, some anyway, try to impersonate the artist down to clothes, appearance and even talk like them, saying things the original artist of course wouldn't say. Same goes for impressionists - John Culshaw, Rory Bremner, Steve Penk have all pranked people over the phone pretending to be someone else. And what about Stevie Riks? I think it's OK as long as people are transparent about it and aren't trying to deceive.
I posted a link to an article "Here comes AI: fans rejoice in new Beatles music, however, it raises copyright questions" but was deleted. It contains exactly what I meant "vocal license" and copyright issues.
Well, of course it can never BE the Beatles, but these AI songs do serve to give us an idea of what modern Beatles songs might have been like if they had continued. These don't sound like vintage Beatles to me -- they really sound like the Beatles would have with new songs and modern production. So, these are cool from a "What if?" standpoint. Wonder what Paul and Ringo would think of these? :-)
Another nice job, Peter and Tony. I hope there will be more to come.
ANOTHER BRILLIANT JOB....JUST KEEP THEM COMING ....THICK AND FAST !💥🇬🇬🎵🥳💖👍🔥🙏👏😂🇬🇧🐐🐐🐐🐐👑😱😱😱😱😱😱
You are incredibly talented song writers and I hope that comes through to thousands of music lovers
Thanks you!
You really really are!!!!!!!!!!!@@urasam2
Brilliant. thank you for this gift.
Beautiful harmony! The whole song is fantastic!!!
I LOVE this!!!
Je suis fan des Beatles depuis toujours .... C est du bon travail👍🎵🎸
Merci beaucoup!
Превосходно!Мне очень нравится.
Love it! Love the video! Love the song!
Glad you used Yellow Submarine Beatles in the video, did you know that movie is 55 years old?
That´s nothing! I´m 56...
That I can experience this... Very best regards from Germany!
THIS IS BRILLIANT
wonderful job. I hope its ok to post on FB
Not ready for prime time. Keep at it.
You’re very critical, aren’t you? Not sure what you mean by the above remark. It’s a good song, a good arrangement and a good recording. As for your Dylan comment- it is Dylan’s voice but there was no intent by the singer to sound like Dylan, so the phrasing, accent, pronunciation etc are that of a 60 year old Englishman, not a 26 year old American. Meanwhile, I’ll look up some of your stuff for inspiration
wonderful...
This is a great song! I really enjoy listening to it! I have a question for you. I really hope you can see this comment still. With the A. I technology you are using, could it be used to clean up tracks too? The reason I asked, I got my hands on a copy of "She's My Baby" by Wings, which has the full ending (album version cuts into Beware My Love) but the problem is the quality is poor with alot of hiss. Is it possible to clean it up with what you're using!?
Hard to say without hearing it. That wouldn’t really be using AI so much as EQ. Is the track to have available to download or at least hear anywhere?
@@urasam2 I have it on a CD. Is there a way I could send it to you if I were to rip it on my computer?
@@Trevornator Rip it and save as an mp3 or wav and email it to me. My email is now under "more about this channel" or "about". Let me know if you see it
@@urasam2 sounds great! Thank you so much!
@@urasam2 I sent it😃 I hope it works on your end. It was a M4A file so I hope thats fine. I was having laptop problems earlier so by the time i got it running, I forgot about converting it to MP3. Just let me know if it doesn't work and I will try again!
it's not bad at all. There is a couple places I can tell it's not really Paul singing. I especially like the part about the bird talking to him. Reminds me of my day yesterday after getting a good workout in the woods.........mocking bird swooping in on me and watching.....I did my best personification of a derelict asking for bus money. "Hey Boss man......I need 71 cent to catch the bus to go uptown". The bird seemed to be thinking my request over.
Genial
Maybe they could have another go at Paul's most disliked song, "That Means A Lot". They gave up on it. This song sounds similar.
Well, you win a point for that because I based the drums on Ringo’s playing on That Means A Lot
I love song ❤
you should add a note in the video that if its not on your channel its bootlegged and to let you know
Good idea, but I don’t think I can change the video now it’s up
I couldn't find John. Paul was there. Was John removed or did you do your own version?
That's correct, I had to pay for them to create a John voice model from a dataset that I made.
Nice
Great Tony! Did you use John's 70s model?
I created my own, didn’t know where to find one
@@urasam2 Great! I'm really bad at training models. Yours sounds really good!
@@mcmusicm All my samples were from 1967-70, mainly the White Album and Sgt Pepper. I’m not confident enough yet to use sovits so I use an online site that trains from your samples
Este tema es para la voz de George, suena muy a él, y coros de John y Paul
yes friki
Ah, buena idea. Pero no tengo modelo AI de George, desgraciadamente
@@urasam2 aún no mi amigo, pero se que lo tendrás, muy buen trabajo por cierto, felicidades a tu hermano y a ti
@@NefiMiranda_ElProfesor_Oficial¡ Muchísimas gracias! Me alegro mucho que te guste
Es verdad. Suena muy George!!!
Eles teve suas marcas eslusivas. Ben rhodes
tony what ai do you use please
Hi Peter. Send me a message on Facebook, I won't go into a detailed explanation here
@@urasam2 ok will do
how will i know which one is you there are a few
@@peterchrissie probably wearing a hat and playing guitar
I could imagine George doing this song more than John or Paul.
Love this song but does remind me of''When the red red robin come bob bob bobbing along'.
Haha! Good one!
❤️
Everybody knows the song lyrics?
Very Beatles like song. I can imagine it on the Sgt. Pepper album.
I for one don't like the slippery slope this AI is bringing us down, and there's also the issue of the voices and images being used without permission.
Nice song, but.. seen elsewhere: "I really don't think AI understands John's singing. I have yet to hear a really good John voice from any AI."
My first attempt of a solo John voice, it’s a case of singing in his style and register. Thanks for the comment. Will keep trying
Agree
No! Don’t keep trying! Just because we can do something doesn’t mean we SHOULD. You’re making the voices and talents of real humans into a commodity.
Stop ripping off the Beatles
It’s an original song and an original arrangement with a production nothing like any Beatles track. In what way is it “ripping off” anybody?
@@urasam2 your using there names there brand pal your steeling from them you can put it any way you like it's theft
@@zee4798 So, do you consider that tribute acts like The Bootleg Beatles are “guilty of theft”, acts who actually play songs by the Beatles, dress as the Beatles and pretend to be the Beatles?
@@urasam2 they do that under licence pal your using there names there brand to profit from it and your not the only one .
It's not even good it's crap this is a good example of AI steeling from from original artists .
It's only a matter of time before one of the remaining Beatles or there family see one of these rip offs .
And I don't think they'd be very happy they also have a lot more money than you do and lawyers.
The Beatles are a brand pal not just a band
Utter sacrilege.
The only problem is the song sucks.
Well, you can’t win ‘em all
No where near as a genuine catchy Lennon McCartney number in fact its musically boring... Oh god was it boring
Who said it was supposed to be like a Lennon/McCartney composition?
@@urasam2 you enabled comments, it don't mean you have to like them. Or do you only want to read positive comments? The AI voices are amazing its just the song which was terrible may I suggest putting AI voices to a song called sub-rosa subway by a rock band called Klaatu this sounds like a beatle song already but with AI voices it would sound amazing.
@@yell50 No, you're right, I'll try to do better next time.
I think it would appeal to Parrotheads.
@@fasillimerick7394 What does that mean?
If I was Paul or the Lennon estate I would sue all these AI fake songs they would never sing themselves. I stick with the real stuff
Fascinating! Are you also opposed to tribute acts, Elvis impersonators etc?
😂, good point and no not opposed to it, but I don't like those.
But there is a difference I think. AI-music uses your AI-voice in a song you maybe would not approve to sing in real life. Tribute bands are covering the original songs of the bands.
I do think artists should have control over how their voice will be used as AI, that's all
@@frankkortstee9877 Yes, but tribute bands, some anyway, try to impersonate the artist down to clothes, appearance and even talk like them, saying things the original artist of course wouldn't say. Same goes for impressionists - John Culshaw, Rory Bremner, Steve Penk have all pranked people over the phone pretending to be someone else. And what about Stevie Riks? I think it's OK as long as people are transparent about it and aren't trying to deceive.
I posted a link to an article "Here comes AI: fans rejoice in new Beatles music, however, it raises copyright questions" but was deleted. It contains exactly what I meant "vocal license" and copyright issues.
Yes the deceiving part is the most important issue here, you are correct about that. We will see how this will evolve
very bad more like Peter & The Penguins
Thank you. Please direct me to a track you feel more worthy of your praise
How very kind. Actually, I didn’t write it for you
Um, so when does John sing?
Fan of The Prisoner?
I could imagine George doing this song more than John or Paul.