Rogan, Chappelle, Peterson, & Rowling helped break the cancel culture fever. Rowling never stopped taking punches and props to her for standing up for human females.
Ricky Gervais was a key player also. The Oscar's rant was ground breaking at the time in speaking against the Hollywood celebrity virtue signal grand standing.
@ Maybe. I don’t follow Gervais very closely and he will certainly speak freely to power, but was he actually protested against with the intent to deplatform him? My question is in good faith. I just don’t follow Gervais that closely.
When they go after someone hard and that person comes out the other side, it weakens their power. Everyone just saw them fail. It's like you got bit by a mean looking dog but that exposed the fact it has no teeth.
@@venalleader2909well now Twitter is about 50/50 in terms of liberal/republicans… and for sone funny reason they think that it’s been taken over now that it’s actually balanced for once… they are just shocked that their echo chamber of deception and propaganda has been destroyed.
Yeah they are over there screaming where did 10M votes go?!?!? We went right, far right actually. And we were welcomed with open arms because conservatives are actually tolerant and nice people!
@@NiaLaLa_Vno one moved to the right, the left just left us all by going far left.. also the right has slightly moved to the left in the last 20 years.. if you are a 90's- 2000's Democrat and hold the same views you are now Republican.
"Transphobic?" An irrational fear of men who dress as women or a women who dress as men? Having an opinion on this whereby you don't agree with this is not an irrational fear. It is merely a person's opinion based on their experience.
Them dismissing my experiences just turns me more against them. Every time I have gotten close to a trans person or any LGBT actually, bad things happened to me and children around me and I was unable to protect those children because CPS is a scam.
Rowling's views on so-called Trans Issues are not in any way controversial. Wokeists are somewhere around fifteen percent of most western societies. They do not represent society in any way. She is relatively Woke on other issues, so many of her allies on this will be unpleasantly surprised, when the series premieres. I will watch it, if it's not too bad. I like Harry Potter (even if I am a fifty year old man), and I like Rowling. The most important thing is that no two thinking persons agree on everything, and inclusion means nothing, unless it means including those who think something other than you do. Besides, I am not on X or any other platform except this, but I like how she argues her case there, whenever I see it. She is pretty cool.
At 0:34, Nial uses the "filum" pronunciation of the word film, which is typical for people of Celtic heritage in the UK/Ireland (the Irish, Scottish, Welsh). Just for anyone interested in those types of things. 🙂
I heard him say that and wondered if my internet lagged for just a fraction of the second, a stutter in the stream, but then thought perhaps he said it that way on purpose. Thanks for the note!
......yes, Nail is a non-American EU-raised leftist with a smooth demeanor who propagandizes in a subtle, sly, yet reasonable-sounding manner......just listen to his commentary 2-3 times and it becomes very clear he is a Globalist and not an America-First proponent.....
What do you mean they came to their senses? HBO never accused Rowling with anything. When they got the right to show all the movies, they already defended her. HBO never really gave in into the woke nonsense. If you look at their shows, they are far less as woke as the Netflix shows for example.
@mfoltz3720 sure. A tariff is a tax on the poor. It's when a country (e.g., China) is charged with a tax for making imports to another country (e.g., USA), and so they raise the costs of goods to cover the new higher cost to market their goods. The consumer pays the price when they buy the goods, and despite consumers having different incomes and financial situations, they all pay the same, so those with the least money are hit the hardest, unlike a tiered income based tax system which was invented to replace what was seen as unjust tariffs 100 years ago. Do you need more information? It sounds like a nice idea to control competition for American manufactured goods, but unfortunately, America does not manufacture the goods that will be taxed; the infrastructure isn't there.
@@gw7120 JK has Intellectual Rights which will only expire 70 years after her death and Trademarks have to be renewed every 10 years, so JK still has creative control over Harry Potter
I would like to ask a question. Is there any documented incident or series of incidents of trans people being denied health care, or employment, or social services, or service in a restaurant, car dealership or applying for a mortgage? I keep hearing about these incidents of widespread discrimination against trans people. However, I have yet to be presented with any empirical evidence that these incidents are actually happening. In fact, the only video evidence i have seen presenting problems with trans persons and others are ones where the trans person is losing it over being identified as 'the wrong gender'...as if calling someone in a dress, long hair, makeup and heels a woman is now akin to progressive heresy. I would also like to point out that it is much easier for an individual to adapt to society than it is for a society to adapt to an individual, which in my view is the core of this whole issue.
Yes ,this is the problem isn't it, do we sacrifice our morals or lack there-of, to conform to society, or do we live our lives forever second class, outcast , or taboo. I guess every journey is different. What's a guy to do , eat, work, sleep, don't judge and just carry on 😊. Namo Buddyah
Please keep Niall! He does a great job talking with both Amber and Robbie. Respectful dialogue and discussions around different views are nice to listen to.
JK didn’t say anything controversial. Neither did she make it a focal point of her online presence. This was DONE TO HER. She stood up to the trans bullies… she was targeted. Nothing she has said was offensive. If ppl get offended over the truth, that is on them. JK has done more to demonstrate how crazy these ppl are by just maintaining her right to speak and let the trans ppl show us how bizarre they truly are.
When you think of all the good she did though challenging power, I think you will see what a huge loss it is that she's gone. Not to mention that she drew viewers to the show who were then exposed to the opposite view, from robbie and amber for example, which is exactly what this show is about.
Controversial views? Couldn't it be said that it is more controversial to take the position that has been accepted in society in the last 10 minutes of history?
If the actor's are moaning then why do they want to get paid to be in her films, nothing makes sense . The actor's are not forced to appear they are paid to appear that's how it works
"... made some controversial, to say the least, comments in the past about transgender people." - Niall You mean stating common sense verifiable facts?
Do you know what controversial means? It means it caused controversy. It is not a judgement like "bad" on her comments, and it doesn't even reflect Nialls views. They were objectively controversial, hence the endless reporting in it and cancelation, and loss of support for her show, etc etc etc. Ask JK Rowling's wallet if he comments were controversial.
Rowlings comments were totally benign - her real “crime” was not bending the knee after the failed cancellation attempt. They basically just nicked her ear, and like Trump she’s coming back stronger. Good for her, she has incredible courage in the face of a small but loud group of online trolls whose days are numbered.
It's always been about money. When they thought it was financially beneficial to "cancel" her, they did so. Now, they see the majority of America went to Trump so they bring her back.
It’s so crazy to me, JK created one of the coolest, inclusive,and with a message of love fantasy environments and story for the ages. A woke mob wants to rip it down for the sake of “she said mean things”, I just don’t understand this mentality.
@themadnessofmadara4883 Some people at her publisher tried to cancel her and the higher ups told them to F off if they had a problem with their best selling author.
Niall stated, "People, have a right to be treated fairly." And who will decide whether this "right" is satisfied? The Ministry of Truth? No, Niall, there is no such right.
She makes an excellent point. No one needs to protect Rowling and Chappell. It’s the associate professor who conducts a study that produces results leftists don’t like who needs support.
What's ironic is that it's a gold mine for HBO. Rowling will never tolerate sensitivity revisions and editing, which is a blight on popular entertainment. That will make the new series startling and fresh in a way that's practically impossible for a new work to be. It will be a massive audience pleaser. HBO will be able to defend itself from the critics by saying Rowling forced their hand and everyone is allowed to get rich! win-win.
maybe these companies need to just realize that we want them to focus on making the best product in whatever field they're in instead of playing politics
Dear Hill, just make this show informal. This isn't TV, it's the internet. It doesn't need TV lighting and format. Relax a bit, just make it chill. No teleprompter. Improve your cams and sound over time.
Imagine Woke ideas being pushed into HP series that doesn't make sense. There is some cultural diversity in HP. More than others I have seen. As Asian male, I lve choo 😅
Yes, we just have the status quo Dem moderate man with predictable answers and no surprises, and no challenges to your presumptive thinking, and biases. Welcome to America- where everyone has The Answer, and no one cares to learn about different viewpoints.
This woke nonsense got Trickster cancelled. Trickster was teaching me and all the other fans about a culture we had never heard of before. We were diving into supernatural stories that we didn't know existed and they let us into the world of real indigenous people. We were loving it, and then the wokies said nope you shall not pass. So sick of them.
Rogan, Chappelle, Peterson, & Rowling helped break the cancel culture fever. Rowling never stopped taking punches and props to her for standing up for human females.
Ricky Gervais was a key player also. The Oscar's rant was ground breaking at the time in speaking against the Hollywood celebrity virtue signal grand standing.
@ Maybe. I don’t follow Gervais very closely and he will certainly speak freely to power, but was he actually protested against with the intent to deplatform him?
My question is in good faith. I just don’t follow Gervais that closely.
Courage is contagious just like fear is
@TheSlackrguy Oh god, yes, the mob wanted him gone. Much like Chapelle, he just didn't care and kept saying what he believed was right.
When they go after someone hard and that person comes out the other side, it weakens their power. Everyone just saw them fail. It's like you got bit by a mean looking dog but that exposed the fact it has no teeth.
J.K. Rowling has said absolutely nothing controversial. Unless...... you're a lunatic
well, the lunatic fringe has been running rampant for a while. We've regained control of Twitter and so they're kind of in retreat now.
Nothing then.
@@venalleader2909well now Twitter is about 50/50 in terms of liberal/republicans… and for sone funny reason they think that it’s been taken over now that it’s actually balanced for once… they are just shocked that their echo chamber of deception and propaganda has been destroyed.
It’s because she’s got her IP locked down and they can’t make anything Harry Potter related without her. Sanity starting to prevail.
JK ROWLING IS A HERO, its so hard to speak against the herd.
She hasn't made any controversial comments, just common sense ones. Hence liberals losing voters.
Yeah they are over there screaming where did 10M votes go?!?!? We went right, far right actually. And we were welcomed with open arms because conservatives are actually tolerant and nice people!
@@NiaLaLa_Vno one moved to the right, the left just left us all by going far left.. also the right has slightly moved to the left in the last 20 years..
if you are a 90's- 2000's Democrat and hold the same views you are now Republican.
"Transphobic?" An irrational fear of men who dress as women or a women who dress as men? Having an opinion on this whereby you don't agree with this is not an irrational fear. It is merely a person's opinion based on their experience.
Them dismissing my experiences just turns me more against them. Every time I have gotten close to a trans person or any LGBT actually, bad things happened to me and children around me and I was unable to protect those children because CPS is a scam.
Same with "h*mophobic."
What a fantastic example of a civil discussion--I'd take a longer one of these with these two!
Please keep this liberal. He is very resonable, unlike most that were in his place before.
Aw, there's so much to be said for presenting stupidity.
100% agree. He’s the best so far
Niall out of the Liberals are by far the best. Reasonable guy. The lefty ladies are painful.
Rowling is brilliant.
and brave 🎉
Rowling's views on so-called Trans Issues are not in any way controversial. Wokeists are somewhere around fifteen percent of most western societies. They do not represent society in any way. She is relatively Woke on other issues, so many of her allies on this will be unpleasantly surprised, when the series premieres. I will watch it, if it's not too bad. I like Harry Potter (even if I am a fifty year old man), and I like Rowling. The most important thing is that no two thinking persons agree on everything, and inclusion means nothing, unless it means including those who think something other than you do. Besides, I am not on X or any other platform except this, but I like how she argues her case there, whenever I see it. She is pretty cool.
At 0:34, Nial uses the "filum" pronunciation of the word film, which is typical for people of Celtic heritage in the UK/Ireland (the Irish, Scottish, Welsh). Just for anyone interested in those types of things. 🙂
I heard him say that and wondered if my internet lagged for just a fraction of the second, a stutter in the stream, but then thought perhaps he said it that way on purpose. Thanks for the note!
......yes, Nail is a non-American EU-raised leftist with a smooth demeanor who propagandizes in a subtle, sly, yet reasonable-sounding manner......just listen to his commentary 2-3 times and it becomes very clear he is a Globalist and not an America-First proponent.....
Controversial !. Telling the truth should never be controversial.
Telling the truth to/about people committed to lying is always controversial.
Love how these two are always able to have a productive and friendly conversation.
Her haters haven't actually read what she wrote. Standing up for women's rights is not hateful or vile.
Lol, Niall. I'm not gonna call a dude in a dress and makeup with a beard "she/her" because he demands I do. Call me rude if you wish.
I concur !
Glad HBO came to its senses. British have lost their minds attacking Rowling and Harry Potter.
🎯
$ talks. Her other book series has an ongoing BBC adaptation. And decent audience.
What do you mean they came to their senses? HBO never accused Rowling with anything. When they got the right to show all the movies, they already defended her. HBO never really gave in into the woke nonsense. If you look at their shows, they are far less as woke as the Netflix shows for example.
Trump's victory is so liberating. Everybody was suffocating
He had no impact in relieving it.
We'll see how liberating it is after the tariffs kick in.
@@ailiicatplease explain what a tariff is and how Trump plans to implement them tarifphobe.
@mfoltz3720 sure. A tariff is a tax on the poor. It's when a country (e.g., China) is charged with a tax for making imports to another country (e.g., USA), and so they raise the costs of goods to cover the new higher cost to market their goods. The consumer pays the price when they buy the goods, and despite consumers having different incomes and financial situations, they all pay the same, so those with the least money are hit the hardest, unlike a tiered income based tax system which was invented to replace what was seen as unjust tariffs 100 years ago. Do you need more information? It sounds like a nice idea to control competition for American manufactured goods, but unfortunately, America does not manufacture the goods that will be taxed; the infrastructure isn't there.
@@mfoltz3720😅 @tarifphobe
Well she owns all the rights to Harry Potter , she is the author , so everybody else can cry 😂
I wouldn't say "all" rights. I believe she sold the film rights to WB.
@themadnessofmadara4883 it expires , read a contract
@@themadnessofmadara4883 JK Rowling has Intellectual Property Rights which means she retains creative control, Warner Bros only has Trademark Rights
@@gw7120 JK has Intellectual Rights which will only expire 70 years after her death and Trademarks have to be renewed every 10 years, so JK still has creative control over Harry Potter
I would like to ask a question. Is there any documented incident or series of incidents of trans people being denied health care, or employment, or social services, or service in a restaurant, car dealership or applying for a mortgage? I keep hearing about these incidents of widespread discrimination against trans people. However, I have yet to be presented with any empirical evidence that these incidents are actually happening. In fact, the only video evidence i have seen presenting problems with trans persons and others are ones where the trans person is losing it over being identified as 'the wrong gender'...as if calling someone in a dress, long hair, makeup and heels a woman is now akin to progressive heresy. I would also like to point out that it is much easier for an individual to adapt to society than it is for a society to adapt to an individual, which in my view is the core of this whole issue.
Yes ,this is the problem isn't it, do we sacrifice our morals or lack there-of, to conform to society, or do we live our lives forever second class, outcast , or taboo. I guess every journey is different. What's a guy to do , eat, work, sleep, don't judge and just carry on 😊. Namo Buddyah
No, no examples.
The definition of discrimination has changed to “not liked.”
@@AlonzoAguilar-j2h Unnatural creatures should be quiet or deemed Outlaw.
“Misgendering” is genocide according to them 🙄
Please keep Niall! He does a great job talking with both Amber and Robbie. Respectful dialogue and discussions around different views are nice to listen to.
JK is a hero.
JK Rowling is what bravery in the face of hysterical zelotry looks like!
Absolutely love this civil discourse! Thank you, thank you thank you
None of JKs tweets are offensive .transwomen are men
JK didn’t say anything controversial. Neither did she make it a focal point of her online presence. This was DONE TO HER. She stood up to the trans bullies… she was targeted.
Nothing she has said was offensive. If ppl get offended over the truth, that is on them.
JK has done more to demonstrate how crazy these ppl are by just maintaining her right to speak and let the trans ppl show us how bizarre they truly are.
There is nothing "controversial" in her remarks.
It's interesting to see the collective sigh of relief that is happening, post election.
Mr. Strange: Ms. Rowling is not the one who is controversial. She respects the science of human biology.
Reading some of her comments, she may as well have said "the earth isn't flat". The hysteria around her is absurd.
I'm kind of Glad Brianna is gone. She was vulnerable to mental breakdowns over simple issues like this.
When you think of all the good she did though challenging power, I think you will see what a huge loss it is that she's gone. Not to mention that she drew viewers to the show who were then exposed to the opposite view, from robbie and amber for example, which is exactly what this show is about.
Way to go HBO and bravo to Rowling for standing up for her common sense opinions. 🤙🏾
Controversial views? Couldn't it be said that it is more controversial to take the position that has been accepted in society in the last 10 minutes of history?
May be Julius was a woman and Cleopatra was a man?
Or both were states men?
You can thank the American people for that cause without them voting for Trump this would never have happened🎉🎉❤❤
If the actor's are moaning then why do they want to get paid to be in her films, nothing makes sense . The actor's are not forced to appear they are paid to appear that's how it works
I am looking forward to the new series. I also hope Gina Carano wins her lawsuit against Disney.
Yes!!! Me too. Gina is awesome ❤
Niall is so refreshing. He admits when he doesn’t know something instead of pretending he has a detailed understanding. I wish everyone did that.
"... made some controversial, to say the least, comments in the past about transgender people." - Niall
You mean stating common sense verifiable facts?
Do you know what controversial means? It means it caused controversy. It is not a judgement like "bad" on her comments, and it doesn't even reflect Nialls views. They were objectively controversial, hence the endless reporting in it and cancelation, and loss of support for her show, etc etc etc. Ask JK Rowling's wallet if he comments were controversial.
Rowlings comments were totally benign - her real “crime” was not bending the knee after the failed cancellation attempt. They basically just nicked her ear, and like Trump she’s coming back stronger. Good for her, she has incredible courage in the face of a small but loud group of online trolls whose days are numbered.
It's always been about money. When they thought it was financially beneficial to "cancel" her, they did so. Now, they see the majority of America went to Trump so they bring her back.
It’s so crazy to me, JK created one of the coolest, inclusive,and with a message of love fantasy environments and story for the ages. A woke mob wants to rip it down for the sake of “she said mean things”, I just don’t understand this mentality.
Her detractors are embodying a sexist/misogynist agenda, wrapped in an enigma... ;) Some hate never dies, no matter how cleverly it is packaged..
I didn’t even know she was “cancelled” 😂
They tried to cancel her.
They tried to... Repeatedly. Failed every time.
@themadnessofmadara4883 Some people at her publisher tried to cancel her and the higher ups told them to F off if they had a problem with their best selling author.
More like people that enjoyed HP stuff were cancelled.
Can’t really cancel a billionaire.
The problem with cancel culture is it punishes people without a jury trial which is not an American value.
Then why do the Right want so many things to be Boycotted? The BBC, Disney....
Niall stated, "People, have a right to be treated fairly." And who will decide whether this "right" is satisfied? The Ministry of Truth? No, Niall, there is no such right.
Exactly. Who determines what is “fair”?
The majority should never have bent the knee to a tiny group of people. Its time to right the ship and sail on.
It's about time... Phew. I thought we were all doomed! Now Disney needs to hire back Gina Carrano, so she can QUIT!
Niall is the best left host we’ve had. Give him a permanent contract. Please!
She makes an excellent point. No one needs to protect Rowling and Chappell. It’s the associate professor who conducts a study that produces results leftists don’t like who needs support.
So true.
What's ironic is that it's a gold mine for HBO. Rowling will never tolerate sensitivity revisions and editing, which is a blight on popular entertainment. That will make the new series startling and fresh in a way that's practically impossible for a new work to be. It will be a massive audience pleaser. HBO will be able to defend itself from the critics by saying Rowling forced their hand and everyone is allowed to get rich! win-win.
Never been a Harry Potter fan, but I am a JK Rowling fan.
JK Rowling hasn't done anything but speak the truth .
She's been treated unfairly for far too long. Good to see the mainstream media crawling back, cap in hand.
Niall is a huge step up. Please keep him on.
maybe these companies need to just realize that we want them to focus on making the best product in whatever field they're in instead of playing politics
Yes I agree that Niall is a keeper.
Hogwart Legacy was a success. She is uncancellable.
Oh... did the wind change direction??
Good to know there are some grown-ups in HBO management.
Finally, a reasonable and thoughtful discussion. I'm glad the drama queen is gone.
I don't think she was so much a drama queen as an unhinged lunatic.
No, no Robbie will be around still! xD
She's never made a controversial statement
I disagree with Niall on so, so much, but I mean the man is just a delight.
Dear Hill, just make this show informal. This isn't TV, it's the internet. It doesn't need TV lighting and format. Relax a bit, just make it chill. No teleprompter. Improve your cams and sound over time.
I am a conservative and I love Niall.
There is a reason why when journalists reference JK and what she said, they NEVER actually quote anything she said . . .
So, Rising, have the people spoken, or do you INSIST on having Nomiki back?
Society is healing.
Cancel culture didn’t stand against the desire to make money. Capitalism wins in the end.
Her comments WERE NOT controversial!
What she has said was and is NOT controversial. The vast majority of people agree with her.
This show is so much better without the unhinged liberal ladies.
Imagine Woke ideas being pushed into HP series that doesn't make sense.
There is some cultural diversity in HP. More than others I have seen.
As Asian male, I lve choo 😅
I really miss Bri😂😂😂😂
@ yikes! Hahahaha
Yes, we just have the status quo Dem moderate man with predictable answers and no surprises, and no challenges to your presumptive thinking, and biases. Welcome to America- where everyone has The Answer, and no one cares to learn about different viewpoints.
@@javiersayshi disagree but funny comment
5:00 💯, Amber!
Keep Niall. Finally an inteligent and honorable leftist host.
Niall keep up the great job to provide another point of view fairly ! So good to have you back
Favorite combo with these two. Good discussion.
I can completly disagree with Nial and still respect his views not many on this show I could have said that about!
While I rarely agree with Niall, his argument is always made in good faith.
I believe he believes what he says he believes and that's really all I need from a good host which Niall most certainly IS! VERY well raised lad! :D
A week ago I was at a Walmart and saw a People magazine with Liam Neeson on the cover. That's my indicator that Cancel Culture is pretty much over.
Excellent! It’s about time
Oh my free speech 🎤 is back?
JK Rowling’s a Hero and a legend for her series
I'd love to see JK Rowling debate Tim Dillon while he's dressed up as Meghan McCain. And have Whoopi officiate.
Niall should dance an Irish Jig for the audience.
I haven''t seen Nobrainy for a while. I hope it means she is no longer on here.
When logic finally prevails....yay!!!!
Common sense making a comeback.
Controversial should not be based on the reactivity of those that refuse to grow up.
Hero.
Is it safe to say Jessica is gone? I am not holding my breath but really hoping Nomiki is no longer hosting
Wow, Amber is on fire! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I’m afraid of saying the wrong hung at work and of being “cancelled.” It’s power is overlooked, sadly
Great segment, great chemistry.
Her statements are only controversial because they’re based on empirical evidence.
Also Biological FACT.
I like Niall hope he's stays
If it wasn't for JK Rowling, Daniel Radcliffe & Emma Watson would still be unknown. That's gratitude for you.
I cant wait to watch her show
Hmmm ,, maybe ill start watching again
JK Rowling is the epitome of "Stand your ground". Don't apologise. Don't grovel. Don't even shirk. Hold firm and you will beat the madness.
This woke nonsense got Trickster cancelled. Trickster was teaching me and all the other fans about a culture we had never heard of before. We were diving into supernatural stories that we didn't know existed and they let us into the world of real indigenous people. We were loving it, and then the wokies said nope you shall not pass. So sick of them.
Rowling rhymes with bowling.
Everybody do Tony
Tony, Tony, bo-bo-ney
Bo-na-na fanna, fo-fo-ney
Fee-fi-mo-mo-ney
Tony!
Pretty sure it's Rao ling
@@kelleygreengrass no, it’s “rolling.” She has said it herself a hundred times.
@m-alexandria-g ah, well I'm wrong if that's true. Can you source it?
@ one of hundreds, easily accessed in her own words via Google: “JK Rowling on how to pronounce her name - video,” The Guardian
Great see you… great team ❤
You have the right to do any damage thing you want to, I don’t have the duty to acknowledge your mental health illusions.
"Any damage thing" I'm sorry what
Your title is misleading... should be "fighting back Woke forces"
This is the Trump effect