I wish she wouldn’t filter it so much. This looks like a totally different palette than the promos. I actually like it more now. I’m still gonna wait for a sale but it’s really nice. I wish she would’ve played with blues, gray, and silvers because we are talking about the moon lol. Pink doesn’t make a lot of sense to me
Yes!! I also hate how she makes the metallics look so much better than they actually are. Yes the blitz astral shades are awesome but in the pics they all look like they'll be as blingy even the regular metallics. Is it too much to ask to post realistic swatches?
If PMG is going to continue with “safe” palettes I would love to see one that is TRULY neutral… like if you’re trying to appeal to the mass market, give us a a palette with neutral brown mattes of varying depth, champagnes, taupes, bronzes, and maybe ONE rosy shimmer if she must. I feel like the way her palettes have been going, it’s not really appealing to color lovers OR basic neutral wearers. I would buy a quad of the 4 blitz shades because I feel like they’d be nice for my lighter skin tone but nothing else about this palette is appealing to me.
Can I be honest? I absolutely love the Pat McGrath formula. It’s one of my favorites. But all of her eyeshadow palettes look the same and the color story is super random. They’re all filled with pink, rose gold, and reddish tones that I can’t wear because I’ll look like I have the plague.
If I was gonna get one, which should I get? I’m interested in trying the formula but only wanna splurge on 1 palette. I don’t want a rose gold tone palette but something unique and one of a kind.
Man I can’t seem to help but get caught up in the magic that is her mothership palettes. I totally agree with the repetition of shades and would LOVE a very bold colour story. Some matte purples would be a dream!! 💜💜💜💜
Passing hard on this palette. I have ALL her palettes and I’m content to miss out on this one. Waiting for a truly different palette with blues, purples, greens and anything else besides this. I’m not mad at all because I save my money for something in the future truly special 💜💙😊😊
I have every single palette and this is the first time I haven’t gotten mothership on launch since the first three dropped. I am frustrated because I couldn’t figured out what eyeshadows looked like. Also I had high expectations for mothership x. I’m going to get this eventually, but I wanted something fresh too.
This pallet is my everything, I am mixed with a tanner complextion . These colors match my undertone PERFECT😂. Im living for these reddish/pink shades . Finally something that matches my yellow/Carmel/honey undertones🎉
Totally agree Morgan, I’m so tired of the red pinky transition shades! They don’t work for me at all which is why I haven’t bought a big Mothership yet. Sigh praying for different shades next time! 💕
I think this is one of my favorite color schemes she has done although I could do without always putting in rosy mattes! Can’t wait to get mine soon 🙌🏻
Obviously Natasha Denona has her own gorgeous formula but imagine if she curated the color story for a Pat McGrath Mothership palette. It would be magic! 🤩
The way I ran to this video 😂😂😂 that palette has me in a chokehold. 😅😅😅 but honestly, I like the colour story. I wasn't interested in a Mothership since since Divine Rose. But I don't like it full price enough. I probably would use different mattes (except the brown) with the shimmers. I'm somehow into the icyness of the shimmers.
I really love how authentic you are Morgan. Some other RUclipsrs seem really saccharin and giggly about this palette, and I felt like they were exaggerating how much they liked it to get PR or something. Keep being you, your viewers really appreciate it.
When is Pat going to give us just a totally neutral, mid-tone matte brown?? Lol I know she has midtown browns, but the all lean very cool/taupe , very warm/orange, or very pink/rosy
Dang lol I actually love this palette so much more in person than I expected to and I think it’s way more unique to her line than it looked in the promo pics. I thought you’d really like this one for the fall (rather than spring) color story. Always thankful for your honesty though!!❤️
@@Fallenangle9 Same! Since that's her forte, maybe it's just not my thing. I've only purchased one, and it is beautiful...but I don't get enough use out of it to keep.
I'm with you on this palette. As they say in Thailand same same but different. Make of that what you will. Slight variation isn't enough for me. I would rather have seen purples greens blues with a couple of nice neutral on the brown side.
This last release I have yet to study it well, but I am very annoyed by the constant presence of warm tones or undertones (they are a cold and deep armochromatic complex). It is also not acceptable that palettes with a cost of 140€, have mattes of mediocre quality, when they are not even of low quality (the shade aubergine in Mothership V for example). For now I bought the only cool available :the Subliminal and a quad. Surely they will be my Subversive and Decadence.... But by exclusion!!! Natasha Denona doesn't always bring out excellent products, but she remains my favorite. Congrats for your amazing job Morgan. Love, from Italy
I wish we could purchase the last quad of the palette (blitz formula)😒 I have enough of those matts 100 times over as well as the highlight shade and never use them lol
Thanks for the review! I wish she would introduce some interesting matte browns like mustards or khaki etc. I have so many pinky/mauve toned palettes and both those mauve shades look the same. Also I am not going to be swayed by the glittery shades this time LOL! I have several of her palettes and I end up not wearing the glitteres because they look too over powering unless im going for a night out on the town. That duochrome shade though is a true beauty.
I'm a cool tone girl, and in the promos, this palette looked much more cool toned. I'm a bit disappointed, but thankful I watched your review before purchasing. As a PML collector, I'm still debating if I want to pick this up or not.
I watched Beauty and the Frizz video with this palette last night. Now I am excited to see what everybody does with this palette! It does look deeper in person.
I wish that more brands, incl PML, would create some of their palettes by eye colour. I always view new palettes through the perspective of a green/hazel-eyed eyeshadow user.
You look phenomenal! And I love the honesty. Completely agree! Gorgeous palette, but so redundant to her own line. I miss when her and ND would have unique releases.
I just recently got this palette and I do love it and it is of course super beautiful, however, I can def agree with the fact that from palette to palette, some of the Matte shades either look too similar, and or sort of throw off the color story of the pallete itself, but Morgan you did an incredible job with creating this gorgeous look!!
I knew this was going to be a mix of warm and cool tones! I really wish the top matte had been a teal, imagine how beautiful that would have been? I would have loved to have seen something like a super reflective gunmetal shade or a black astral shade with many different coloured reflects. It would still technically be 'neutral' and 'wearable' while also going with moon theme.
Thank you so much for your honest review. I was disappointed at having rosy mattes yet again and does anyone else think the cover art just looks like she copy and pasted from Huetopian Dream? I like to collect her palettes, but this has made me get off the Pat train.
As a collector, it's definitely disappointing in terms of variety. But as a stand alone palette, it's super pretty. I would like to see a Pat McGrath nudes palette, with taupe and mauve shades in the blitz astral formula. And an all blitz astral version of Decadence. I would absolutely pay big dollars for that!
This palette is really pretty but I have the hardest time creating looks with her palettes and I have a lot of them. You always make such beautiful looks and I try to recreate and I look like a muddy man! Congrats on 101K subs!
Yay!! This is the first video I’ve seen on this palette. Can’t decide yet if I’m going to get this one In my opinion , you, Alicia Archer, and Patty Alonso are the three queens of PMG palette reviews lol.
@@AllinOne-l5x I get that. Patty might not call out as many negatives a product may have, but she does an awesome job with swatches and multiple looks. It helps me see how the colors actually look and how I might use them
I have a huge PMG collection but I didn't buy this palette for 2 reasons. 1/ I find this color story kinda boring (but this is just my opinion, it is a beautiful palette though). 2/ the value of euro against USD is very bad, which means that now a PMG palette costs 160 EUR. Imagine if you had to pay 160 $ for this palette, I guess you would think twice before buying it. This price is too much for me for 10 shades, even if the quality is good. Thanks for your review Morgan, I was waiting for it 🤗🙏
Have fun with your parents and in-laws! I’m sure they are going to love visiting you both in Miami. Maybe do a video doing makeup on your Mom and Jose’s Mom!!! I would love to see that.
Very excited to see your review, Morgan! 💖 I received it yesterday morning, probably before almost every RUclipsr 🫣😁 Really love it. It is very glamorous and very wearable at the same time. Those pink/plum colors are not making me look sick, yey, surprisingly. I love new formula of these new special shades. It has less fallout and feels silky.
I agree with you about wanting something different. It feels like so many of my favourite cosmetic brands are going through a rut. What is on offer for consumers feels so boring and uninspired right now. If their goal is to encourage me to spend less, it's working!
I have been trying to purchase less makeup since the beginning of June and I thought that I was definitely going to purchase this palette but nope. It's not special enough for me. Too boring. It's good news for my wallet though....lol.
Honestly, watching this video is making me want to return mine and it hasn’t even gotten here yet. It looks sooo different than all the promo pics and the color story seems more random than usual.
The sexstacy shade reminds me of the Duochrome shade (Alien moon) in the Deep space Divinity quad, but brighter. Overall I'd say this mothership palette looks like an extended version of that Deep Space Divinity Quad. I'm sitting this one out - hard pass for me. I would have loved to See more innovative pops of color with bright colors (imagine a duochrome lime green shifting to a soft pink, something different!)
I was thinking the exact same thing about alien moon! I’m so disappointed with this palette. I am dying for greens and maybe a teal or something. This is the first mothership I didn’t get immediately, and I’m really conflicted.
@@Kika6104 Me too! I was like wow that shade looks sooo familiar and I have that quad. I have most of her palettes and all of the Motherships. I’ll probably still get this one eventually but on sale.
@@Kika6104 I know, I share the feeling. I got so excited when I saw another mothership was coming out, but then I saw what it really was and I felt so disappointed in a way. Dont get me wrong, I know the looks are gonna be gorgeous and the quality will speak for itself, but I was really hoping for some innovation. I'd even say the matte shades are too similar to the ones in the the Bridgerton palettes with slight tone differences. I just can't with this mothership pallette. I guess it reminds me too much of her recent releases all in one palette.
Great review Morgan. I also used the word safe to describe this palette. It is beautiful, however as a collection the story didn’t give me the excitement! The look you made is beautiful! I would also like some different mattes for the transition shade. It would really change up the look! This palette is a great everyday palette and would also be great if it’s someone’s first mothership!!!!
So excited to see your review go up! Mine arrived at my door about 20 minutes before this video went up. I can’t wait to use it! Yes, it is a safe color story, but…. I’m all about safe. 😂 I’m just so happy to hear the formula is the same great formula we come to expect from Pat!
Dear Morgan, thank so much for the detailed review. Can you please tell how the formula of the new special shades compares to the existing once? Is it true that they are not in her backed formula/typical astral shade formula, which we know?
Im so happy I wait because I really don’t love this palette just the last 2 shades lilac and the one on top I love you compare and dupes with another pat pallets 😘
I critiqued the Heutopean dream last year of beginning to be repetitive within the Mothership range, but this is even worse in that regard. I own the Divine Rose 1 and 2, so I will happily just skip this palette. Maybe just wait for what she comes out in holiday season, because I really liked the big palette she came out with last year. The stand-out duochrome shade in the palette is something I have in my indie palettes.
I would love to see you use this palette, specifically the blitz shades, paired with mattes from another palette or brand. Maybe that will make it look better.
I was waiting for your your review!!! It was really hard to resist getting it in the first place... Will definitely have it in my collection 😉 Love your reviews 💞
Another great video and I completely agreed I’m a collector of her mothership palettes so I will eventually buy it but I was soo sad about the color story being the same ol same ol. So I’ll pick it up when it eventually hits a sale hava
I understand the complaints about PMG color stories recently, however I don’t own all of her palettes so I do kinda like this one, especially because it’s less pink (so divine rose and huetopian dream didn’t appeal as much to me besides the astral shades). Her mattes do end up seeming similar and the skin show colors all serve the same purpose but with different undertones, but I love these blitz astral shades in this one. I’ll prob wait for a sale though!
Please take the time to enjoy these special visits with both sets of parents. YT is just YT, your families are something else 😊 As for this palette, nope. I'm bored stupid with the repetitive matte shades, they in every palette and they're difficult to make easy looks with. I think makeup artists, like you, really know how to work a palette - numpties like me, struggle 😅 Love yooooooooooo 🧡💚🧡💚🧡
Your eye looks are beautiful, Morgan! Then again, you always have such flair with your eye techniques! The palette is gorgeous, even with a few redundant transition shades. I myself would like to see a few more neutral transition shades as well. But I’m pleased that she didn’t inundate us with the brassy gold this time! I think this is overall a much more neutral palette.
I totally agree with Morgan. I have one PM pallet and every other one just looks the same! Not paying 129 bucks for a few special shades and repeat mattes!
I just got my pallette today absolutely stunning. Very flattering. Formula is A1. This is definitely not a pink/ rosy pallette. The name matches the color story perfectly. This is only my 2nd mothership pallette. I have 2 quads, a mininlab pallette, and one holiday pallette. It's unique in my collection. Stunning. So happy to have it!! I'm of a deeper collection and it looks stunning on me!! That versatility. Icy is the right description. Not cool but icey!!
I would have loved a green and lilac Matte shade instead of the plum/rose. This colour story is very similar to the Natasha Denona Star palette however. I’m also glad I skipped the two Bridgerton palettes in favour of waiting for the mothership as it is a similar colour story.
I ordered on Friday and received mine today as well! Honestly I love it, it's my very first mothership palette. Yes it's basically a neutral palette, but the colors and finishes she chose are 10/10, so sophisticated and elegant. I can't wait to wear it!! 😍
I've placed my order after watching your last video on the release. As much as i agree that I'm getting bored of the plum n pink shades, i still love her eyeshadow formula especially when i just love shimmers & bling products! Her formula was one that is so easy to work with, and will not create a mess even with those matte shades. Love all your videos and thank you for spending so much time on creating contents! do enjoy your family time💕
It’s my first mothership palette none of her more recent ones haven’t appealed as too warm or pink. Was waiting for a more cool toned to spend the money on
Totally agree with you about the mattes. But I still have the Cocoa Mirage and the Viseart pro neutral 1 and the cool toned neutral pallet. I will get this during next crazy sale, for the shimmers, plus, I have all the other Motherships. Appreciate that you are the first to review and I seem to agree with you, most of the time. Your knowledge of the formulas is fantastic.
I just purchased tom ford's cocoa mirage but haven't played with it yet. I had to get my hands on it because Mel Thompson raved about all the time. Really miss Mel and her videos 😢
I have wanted a Pat Mcgrath palette but couldn't commit to any, but I think this may be it. I love how icy this palette is, and more importantly, it's such an everyday palette. I'm so excited to own this one. I agree with you about the red and purple tones.
My new PM palette will be here tomorrow and I’m super excited, however I too am a collector and am sick of the pinks…however, this one luckily has a few cool tones in it so I think I’ll def be using it more than my Devine rose 2! But I really hope Pat starts listening to her loyal customers…..we need some fun bright pops of colors….just so over the rosey tones.
Honestly, it looks great! I may finally get a Pat McGrath palette next month but I’m not so sure which one to get. I want the one with the most gold tones… thought I am tempted by number 4 because of the shade names.
She upped the price for European shoppers. It is $155 for me or 155 euro so I'll wait for a sale as yeah that's a lot of money, it is cooler toned then I expected though and I do love the shades
I am waiting years and years and years for a Pat McGrath palette which is worth the money for me. I love all the palettes a little and i really wanna try the quality, but i think for over 130€ every shade has to be 💥BAM!! And in every palette are 3-5 boring shades
Morgan-thanks for this honest review. That is why we trust you!!! We all admire Pat but I do have to say that I’m not liking the direction her brand is taking right now. I thought Mothership X would blow me out of the water but that is just not the case. Xoxo✨✨-Molly-
I always think I neeeed these palettes but I could just get some similar indie sparkly shades for way cheaper since I have these mattes several times over. Her sales pull me in!
After purchasing almost all of the Motherships I discovered indie brand multichromes. I have some from terra moons and adept cosmetics plain Jane remastered. The fallout is next to nothing compared to pats Motherships.
@@jbriggsstuff sadly I'm in Europe so my options are limited due to the price of shipping but glam shop is eu based and the shimmers are just as good if not better, and so much more affordable with loads of options :D. Yes, some PMG blitz astrals do have a lot of fallout indeed
This is my favorite palatte! So happy I got it for my 40th this year lol. All the gurus hate it lol except dear Charlotte. I have mothership. 1 and 9 and now 10. I love, love this one. And they all play together. But I get why some are dissapointed.
you're always the first to review these PMG palettes!! I've been looking forward to this video :) even though the color story from the pictures didn't wow me.
Hi Morgan, Thank you so much for this video. And I appreciate you spending your money on this palette, because I wasn't going to get this palette . I 100% at this point agree with you about the fact that the burgundy cherry matte flat mat it's been done too many times now. I did get the Utopian dream ballot. I also own the midnight Sun palette. And I just don't understand why she has to keep doing this with this cherry burgundy and they're not even pretty and there's some sort of gold that Pat has to put in every one of her collections. There's also silver it looks like so I don't mind it. But then pinkish rosish burgundy sick of it. I now feel free to get that bridgeton six-pan palette I am going to get that That's looking extremely off on guard now compared to this. But it's all good I am liking the Danessa Myricks pallets. Plums kind of look similar honestly the two matte shades look similar I'm going to I would love to have that divine rose too, and I think it's bronze seduction with that gorgeous ruby red shimmer in it and then I be fine I'd be fun but it would have beyon sale. Gorgeous blitz shades. But thanks again for this video I appreciate it can't wait to see some looks more looks from you. Take care Morgan 🙏🌟💖🤗
Wow. This is giving me Interstellar Icon vibes!! I am so OVER all of the filters she uses to promote her products. This looks so much richer than what I thought. You are RIGHT ON about everything you are saying. Can we get something new?! This looks just like so much we have already seen. This was the very first mothership that I did not purchase. Since getting my first Adept palette, and getting into indie.. I cannot imagine spending that much for the SAME THING!! Yawn. Great video!!! 💖💖 Indie is where it's at!
My favorite eyeshadow ever was a now discontinued pink by Chanel so I am not against pinks. But after the Bridgerton pinks, I was ready for some different transition shades. I still ordered it, even though I was going to wait (ha, who was I kidding).
I bought this I'm loving it but, I think the key to being happy with the pallets is making absolutely sure the mattes work for your skin tone. I would never consider Sublime or Bronze Seduction cause the mattes look too warm for me. Also do not pay full price because first of all it's not worth it and secondly they have at least 4 big sales a year at 30%-40% off. Save your cash!
Omg I’ve been waiting for this video 😍 I think I’ll wait for the sale to pick this up. The color story doesn’t excite me that much but, I collect all her big motherships so, it’s still on my list ❤️
As a shimmer lover with a fair skin tone, I am in love with those icy special shades. I'll probably be patient, wait until the palette goes on sale and then grab it :)
This is the first mothership palette I could see myself wanting enough to consider buying. When I looked through my collection to see if I have anything to try to "dupe" the color story for a test run I was amused to find my WetnWild comfort zone 10 pan is surprisingly similar. I also find comfort zone to be an exceptionally useful color story so it actually adds to my interest in trying a super high end version. Gonna sit on it and see how I feel if it goes on sale
I find it very interesting that PML already ran a 10% off sale on this one. Personally, it does not excite me but I probably will pick it up at a higher discount.
I think it would be interesting to see you pair this palette with another one you have. Many of us, especially if we're getting her palettes, will have some sort of collection. So I'd love to see what looks you come up with by pairing it with other mattes or pops of color, etc.!
It's just not exciting enough to me to justify $128, even on sale I don't see anything here I don't have elsewhere from Pat or other brands. I mean we just got a nice blue/brown from ABH. I'm a little sad and hope Pat will change things up soon!
I think a matte forest green instead of the warmer reddish matte would have been the perfect mix of complimentary and contrasting shades in the palette
I 100% agree with you. I don’t care for two of the three mattes. I LOVE the taupe, but the other two do not work with the color story and are truly redundant of her other palettes. I would also have loved a dark brown and a different color for the two other mattes. I don’t think the other mattes go with the other colors either. I really only see myself using the taupe. I will likely combine this with other PML palettes. Yesterday I wore the Taupe with the Platinum shade (not the special one, the regular metallic) and it was VERY dark and dramatic - not great for every day, but thankfully my peeps are used to my Va Va Voom eyeshadow looks!
I completely agree. Way too many pink/reddish tones as far as the mattes at this point. I love Midnight Sun, because it has those browns and different colors of metallics, green and taupeish bronze as well as the purple and copper. it has so many different directions you can go. I wish she would release another Mothership that would have a color story with variety like that. We need a change.
Hi Morgan, I was kinda hoping that this palette would of been different. But I had a big feeling it was going to look like her other palettes. Now to be honest I have the 2 holiday palettes and then I have Bronze seductions and I have Divine rose 1 & 2. Now I want to ask you Morgan if you were me and you had what I have would you get Mothership 10? I’m would love to know. I have to say I love the look you did, very pretty. I’m glad you put up your video. I was waiting to see who out of the RUclipsr’s I watch who was going to put up there video on this palette. I want to Thank you for always being honest and for your thoughts on this palette. I know all of us here appreciate it a lot. Enjoy you time with your family. Till the next one bye.
I feel like this palette looks more like a bronze seduction 2. The mattes and shimmers look very similar, especially the two green shimmery shades in those palettes. I’d love to see you do a video dedicated to swatching similar shades from her collection and trying a create the same eye look with them💜
I wish she wouldn’t filter it so much. This looks like a totally different palette than the promos. I actually like it more now. I’m still gonna wait for a sale but it’s really nice. I wish she would’ve played with blues, gray, and silvers because we are talking about the moon lol. Pink doesn’t make a lot of sense to me
Yes , looks completely different!!
Yes! I need the online pictures to look exactly like the product.
Yes you are totally right !!
Yes!! I also hate how she makes the metallics look so much better than they actually are. Yes the blitz astral shades are awesome but in the pics they all look like they'll be as blingy even the regular metallics. Is it too much to ask to post realistic swatches?
Totally agree with you she filters too much
If PMG is going to continue with “safe” palettes I would love to see one that is TRULY neutral… like if you’re trying to appeal to the mass market, give us a a palette with neutral brown mattes of varying depth, champagnes, taupes, bronzes, and maybe ONE rosy shimmer if she must. I feel like the way her palettes have been going, it’s not really appealing to color lovers OR basic neutral wearers. I would buy a quad of the 4 blitz shades because I feel like they’d be nice for my lighter skin tone but nothing else about this palette is appealing to me.
Totally agree with you!!
Yes! A true neutral palette without the rosy neutrals would be amazing
🤞🏼
Yes, 100%!
Absolutely! Would buy neutral palette definitely
Can I be honest? I absolutely love the Pat McGrath formula. It’s one of my favorites. But all of her eyeshadow palettes look the same and the color story is super random. They’re all filled with pink, rose gold, and reddish tones that I can’t wear because I’ll look like I have the plague.
Same here! I’ll skip this one
If I was gonna get one, which should I get? I’m interested in trying the formula but only wanna splurge on 1 palette. I don’t want a rose gold tone palette but something unique and one of a kind.
I feel as though the color story of this one is a bit random as well!
@@_Claudia72 same skip yay
@@hirry.p #3 subversive
if you don’t want pink shades
Man I can’t seem to help but get caught up in the magic that is her mothership palettes. I totally agree with the repetition of shades and would LOVE a very bold colour story. Some matte purples would be a dream!! 💜💜💜💜
Passing hard on this palette. I have ALL her palettes and I’m content to miss out on this one. Waiting for a truly different palette with blues, purples, greens and anything else besides this. I’m not mad at all because I save my money for something in the future truly special 💜💙😊😊
I have every single palette and this is the first time I haven’t gotten mothership on launch since the first three dropped. I am frustrated because I couldn’t figured out what eyeshadows looked like. Also I had high expectations for mothership x. I’m going to get this eventually, but I wanted something fresh too.
@@Kika6104 I couldn’t agree more. Hopefully Mother Pat and team see all these sentiments her fans have and create one for her devoted fans 😊🤍
Yes. I'm really over the rosey colors.
@Amber Deen I actually have that one. It’s lovely 🥰
This pallet is my everything, I am mixed with a tanner complextion . These colors match my undertone PERFECT😂. Im living for these reddish/pink shades . Finally something that matches my yellow/Carmel/honey undertones🎉
Totally agree Morgan, I’m so tired of the red pinky transition shades! They don’t work for me at all which is why I haven’t bought a big Mothership yet. Sigh praying for different shades next time! 💕
I think this is one of my favorite color schemes she has done although I could do without always putting in rosy mattes! Can’t wait to get mine soon 🙌🏻
😊
Obviously Natasha Denona has her own gorgeous formula but imagine if she curated the color story for a Pat McGrath Mothership palette. It would be magic! 🤩
The way I ran to this video 😂😂😂 that palette has me in a chokehold. 😅😅😅 but honestly, I like the colour story. I wasn't interested in a Mothership since since Divine Rose. But I don't like it full price enough. I probably would use different mattes (except the brown) with the shimmers. I'm somehow into the icyness of the shimmers.
The icyness is my favorite part! just wish we had diff mattes😭
I really love how authentic you are Morgan. Some other RUclipsrs seem really saccharin and giggly about this palette, and I felt like they were exaggerating how much they liked it to get PR or something.
Keep being you, your viewers really appreciate it.
When is Pat going to give us just a totally neutral, mid-tone matte brown?? Lol
I know she has midtown browns, but the all lean very cool/taupe , very warm/orange, or very pink/rosy
Yes!! I would be so happy to see some variety of browns. Khaki, mustard, classic mid Browns etc.
@@weatherandsky yes exactly!
Dang lol I actually love this palette so much more in person than I expected to and I think it’s way more unique to her line than it looked in the promo pics. I thought you’d really like this one for the fall (rather than spring) color story. Always thankful for your honesty though!!❤️
Imagine a day when we could customize our own PM palette...
I want a mix of this, Divine Rose, and the first two ❤️❤️
Yes. I don’t like the special shades, and the chunky glitter shadows. I’ve stopped purchasing her palettes because I can’t use them regularly.
@@Fallenangle9 Same! Since that's her forte, maybe it's just not my thing. I've only purchased one, and it is beautiful...but I don't get enough use out of it to keep.
@@Fallenangle9 do you have the decadence? It’s all metallics! If you have a palette of mattes it would be good for that
I'm with you on this palette. As they say in Thailand same same but different. Make of that what you will. Slight variation isn't enough for me. I would rather have seen purples greens blues with a couple of nice neutral on the brown side.
This last release I have yet to study it well, but I am very annoyed by the constant presence of warm tones or undertones (they are a cold and deep armochromatic complex). It is also not acceptable that palettes with a cost of 140€, have mattes of mediocre quality, when they are not even of low quality (the shade aubergine in Mothership V for example). For now I bought the only cool available :the Subliminal and a quad. Surely they will be my Subversive and Decadence.... But by exclusion!!! Natasha Denona doesn't always bring out excellent products, but she remains my favorite.
Congrats for your amazing job Morgan.
Love, from Italy
I wish we could purchase the last quad of the palette (blitz formula)😒 I have enough of those matts 100 times over as well as the highlight shade and never use them lol
Thanks for the review! I wish she would introduce some interesting matte browns like mustards or khaki etc. I have so many pinky/mauve toned palettes and both those mauve shades look the same. Also I am not going to be swayed by the glittery shades this time LOL! I have several of her palettes and I end up not wearing the glitteres because they look too over powering unless im going for a night out on the town. That duochrome shade though is a true beauty.
I'm a cool tone girl, and in the promos, this palette looked much more cool toned. I'm a bit disappointed, but thankful I watched your review before purchasing. As a PML collector, I'm still debating if I want to pick this up or not.
I watched Beauty and the Frizz video with this palette last night. Now I am excited to see what everybody does with this palette! It does look deeper in person.
I'm surprised that the colors in real life are actually deeper which that sparks my interest for the palette. 😳🤍
We’ll have to check out that channel
😊
These plum shades can be found in her first holiday palette. Man the 10th palette was supposed to speak for itself.
I wish that more brands, incl PML, would create some of their palettes by eye colour. I always view new palettes through the perspective of a green/hazel-eyed eyeshadow user.
You look phenomenal! And I love the honesty. Completely agree! Gorgeous palette, but so redundant to her own line. I miss when her and ND would have unique releases.
I just recently got this palette and I do love it and it is of course super beautiful, however, I can def agree with the fact that from palette to palette, some of the Matte shades either look too similar, and or sort of throw off the color story of the pallete itself, but Morgan you did an incredible job with creating this gorgeous look!!
I knew this was going to be a mix of warm and cool tones! I really wish the top matte had been a teal, imagine how beautiful that would have been? I would have loved to have seen something like a super reflective gunmetal shade or a black astral shade with many different coloured reflects. It would still technically be 'neutral' and 'wearable' while also going with moon theme.
The fact that i saw an add for this makeup and my first thought was to check your page for a review and you delivereddddd thanks girl!!
Thank you so much for your honest review. I was disappointed at having rosy mattes yet again and does anyone else think the cover art just looks like she copy and pasted from Huetopian Dream? I like to collect her palettes, but this has made me get off the Pat train.
As a collector, it's definitely disappointing in terms of variety. But as a stand alone palette, it's super pretty. I would like to see a Pat McGrath nudes palette, with taupe and mauve shades in the blitz astral formula. And an all blitz astral version of Decadence. I would absolutely pay big dollars for that!
This palette is really pretty but I have the hardest time creating looks with her palettes and I have a lot of them. You always make such beautiful looks and I try to recreate and I look like a muddy man! Congrats on 101K subs!
Never been more bored and looks like a Christmas palet haha thanks for the video!
Yay!! This is the first video I’ve seen on this palette. Can’t decide yet if I’m going to get this one
In my opinion , you, Alicia Archer, and Patty Alonso are the three queens of PMG palette reviews lol.
Sameeeee! I love them all!
I totally agree with you. I think the three are so full of knowledge when it comes to mama pat.
I disagree w patty I feel like she just loves everything and is bias … Morgan and Kinky I feel keep it real…. My thoughts 🫶🏼
@@AllinOne-l5x I get that. Patty might not call out as many negatives a product may have, but she does an awesome job with swatches and multiple looks. It helps me see how the colors actually look and how I might use them
💖
I have a huge PMG collection but I didn't buy this palette for 2 reasons. 1/ I find this color story kinda boring (but this is just my opinion, it is a beautiful palette though). 2/ the value of euro against USD is very bad, which means that now a PMG palette costs 160 EUR. Imagine if you had to pay 160 $ for this palette, I guess you would think twice before buying it. This price is too much for me for 10 shades, even if the quality is good. Thanks for your review Morgan, I was waiting for it 🤗🙏
In Canada, it’s $175! So, nope.
Have fun with your parents and in-laws! I’m sure they are going to love visiting you both in Miami. Maybe do a video doing makeup on your Mom and Jose’s Mom!!! I would love to see that.
I would love to see a grwm with the older ladies!
Very excited to see your review, Morgan! 💖 I received it yesterday morning, probably before almost every RUclipsr 🫣😁 Really love it. It is very glamorous and very wearable at the same time. Those pink/plum colors are not making me look sick, yey, surprisingly. I love new formula of these new special shades. It has less fallout and feels silky.
Good to know 😊
I wish the pink/red mattes were swapped for a grey and more neutral tones to match the silver shimmers better.
I agree with you about wanting something different. It feels like so many of my favourite cosmetic brands are going through a rut. What is on offer for consumers feels so boring and uninspired right now. If their goal is to encourage me to spend less, it's working!
I have been trying to purchase less makeup since the beginning of June and I thought that I was definitely going to purchase this palette but nope. It's not special enough for me. Too boring. It's good news for my wallet though....lol.
Honestly, watching this video is making me want to return mine and it hasn’t even gotten here yet. It looks sooo different than all the promo pics and the color story seems more random than usual.
If only we could get single shades!! That blue green pink one is so beautiful
This palette is so pretty to me. I don’t have any of her palettes though, so I feel that way about most of them, from afar. 🤣
The sexstacy shade reminds me of the Duochrome shade (Alien moon) in the Deep space Divinity quad, but brighter. Overall I'd say this mothership palette looks like an extended version of that Deep Space Divinity Quad.
I'm sitting this one out - hard pass for me. I would have loved to
See more innovative pops of color with bright colors (imagine a duochrome lime green shifting to a soft pink, something different!)
I was thinking the exact same thing about alien moon! I’m so disappointed with this palette. I am dying for greens and maybe a teal or something. This is the first mothership I didn’t get immediately, and I’m really conflicted.
@@Kika6104 Me too! I was like wow that shade looks sooo familiar and I have that quad. I have most of her palettes and all of the Motherships. I’ll probably still get this one eventually but on sale.
@@Kika6104 I know, I share the feeling. I got so excited when I saw another mothership was coming out, but then I saw what it really was and I felt so disappointed in a way. Dont get me wrong, I know the looks are gonna be gorgeous and the quality will speak for itself, but I was really hoping for some innovation. I'd even say the matte shades are too similar to the ones in the the Bridgerton palettes with slight tone differences. I just can't with this mothership pallette. I guess it reminds me too much of her recent releases all in one palette.
Very similar to Divine rose 2 so I will probably wait for a sale since I have that one already. Enjoy your visit with your family. 🥰
Great review Morgan. I also used the word safe to describe this palette. It is beautiful, however as a collection the story didn’t give me the excitement! The look you made is beautiful! I would also like some different mattes for the transition shade. It would really change up the look! This palette is a great everyday palette and would also be great if it’s someone’s first mothership!!!!
So excited to see your review go up! Mine arrived at my door about 20 minutes before this video went up. I can’t wait to use it! Yes, it is a safe color story, but…. I’m all about safe. 😂
I’m just so happy to hear the formula is the same great formula we come to expect from Pat!
Dear Morgan, thank so much for the detailed review. Can you please tell how the formula of the new special shades compares to the existing once? Is it true that they are not in her backed formula/typical astral shade formula, which we know?
Im so happy I wait because I really don’t love this palette just the last 2 shades lilac and the one on top
I love you compare and dupes with another pat pallets 😘
I agree green would be very nice. Hoping the green from midnight sun works well with these special shade’s
I critiqued the Heutopean dream last year of beginning to be repetitive within the Mothership range, but this is even worse in that regard. I own the Divine Rose 1 and 2, so I will happily just skip this palette. Maybe just wait for what she comes out in holiday season, because I really liked the big palette she came out with last year. The stand-out duochrome shade in the palette is something I have in my indie palettes.
This palette is soooo boring!! 😴😴
Yes. The standout shade is nothing new. Mac has been doing blue brown pigment for ages. And many other companies.
I would love to see you use this palette, specifically the blitz shades, paired with mattes from another palette or brand. Maybe that will make it look better.
I was waiting for your your review!!! It was really hard to resist getting it in the first place... Will definitely have it in my collection 😉
Love your reviews 💞
Another great video and I completely agreed I’m a collector of her mothership palettes so I will eventually buy it but I was soo sad about the color story being the same ol same ol. So I’ll pick it up when it eventually hits a sale hava
I understand the complaints about PMG color stories recently, however I don’t own all of her palettes so I do kinda like this one, especially because it’s less pink (so divine rose and huetopian dream didn’t appeal as much to me besides the astral shades). Her mattes do end up seeming similar and the skin show colors all serve the same purpose but with different undertones, but I love these blitz astral shades in this one. I’ll prob wait for a sale though!
Yes I think I’m going to wait for a sale too. Have a good day.
Please take the time to enjoy these special visits with both sets of parents. YT is just YT, your families are something else 😊
As for this palette, nope.
I'm bored stupid with the repetitive matte shades, they in every palette and they're difficult to make easy looks with. I think makeup artists, like you, really know how to work a palette - numpties like me, struggle 😅
Love yooooooooooo 🧡💚🧡💚🧡
Your eye looks are beautiful, Morgan! Then again, you always have such flair with your eye techniques! The palette is gorgeous, even with a few redundant transition shades. I myself would like to see a few more neutral transition shades as well. But I’m pleased that she didn’t inundate us with the brassy gold this time! I think this is overall a much more neutral palette.
I totally agree with Morgan. I have one PM pallet and every other one just looks the same! Not paying 129 bucks for a few special shades and repeat mattes!
I just got my pallette today absolutely stunning. Very flattering. Formula is A1. This is definitely not a pink/ rosy pallette. The name matches the color story perfectly. This is only my 2nd mothership pallette. I have 2 quads, a mininlab pallette, and one holiday pallette. It's unique in my collection. Stunning. So happy to have it!! I'm of a deeper collection and it looks stunning on me!! That versatility. Icy is the right description. Not cool but icey!!
I feel like I can get similar looks minus a couple of the special shades with my tiny marvel’s 🐛 🐞 palette
I would have loved a green and lilac Matte shade instead of the plum/rose. This colour story is very similar to the Natasha Denona Star palette however. I’m also glad I skipped the two Bridgerton palettes in favour of waiting for the mothership as it is a similar colour story.
Definitely seems like she made an everyday cool tone rose palette. I like this one
Beautiful look 😍 you’re so talented Morgan!
These are the type of looks I find pretty at least they have something interesting more than more neutral ones which I love too
I ordered on Friday and received mine today as well! Honestly I love it, it's my very first mothership palette. Yes it's basically a neutral palette, but the colors and finishes she chose are 10/10, so sophisticated and elegant. I can't wait to wear it!! 😍
I don't plan on buying this palette, but you created a beautiful look. Happy for you and Jose that your family is visiting. Enjoy your time with them.
I've placed my order after watching your last video on the release. As much as i agree that I'm getting bored of the plum n pink shades, i still love her eyeshadow formula especially when i just love shimmers & bling products! Her formula was one that is so easy to work with, and will not create a mess even with those matte shades. Love all your videos and thank you for spending so much time on creating contents! do enjoy your family time💕
It’s my first mothership palette none of her more recent ones haven’t appealed as too warm or pink. Was waiting for a more cool toned to spend the money on
Totally agree with you about the mattes. But I still have the Cocoa Mirage and the Viseart pro neutral 1 and the cool toned neutral pallet. I will get this during next crazy sale, for the shimmers, plus, I have all the other Motherships.
Appreciate that you are the first to review and I seem to agree with you, most of the time. Your knowledge of the formulas is fantastic.
I just purchased tom ford's cocoa mirage but haven't played with it yet. I had to get my hands on it because Mel Thompson raved about all the time. Really miss Mel and her videos 😢
@@jbriggsstuff
Miss Mel too. It’s a super blendable neutral pallet. Great in the crease and outer corner.
I use it with different shimmers, mostly.
I have wanted a Pat Mcgrath palette but couldn't commit to any, but I think this may be it. I love how icy this palette is, and more importantly, it's such an everyday palette. I'm so excited to own this one. I agree with you about the red and purple tones.
My new PM palette will be here tomorrow and I’m super excited, however I too am a collector and am sick of the pinks…however, this one luckily has a few cool tones in it so I think I’ll def be using it more than my Devine rose 2! But I really hope Pat starts listening to her loyal customers…..we need some fun bright pops of colors….just so over the rosey tones.
Honestly, it looks great!
I may finally get a Pat McGrath palette next month but I’m not so sure which one to get. I want the one with the most gold tones… thought I am tempted by number 4 because of the shade names.
The first palette that came to my mind was the Colourpop Disney midnight masquerade. So many similarities
Thanks for getting it to review so we can live our shopping lives through you! I’m skipping this one, but I still looooveee to see it!
Bronze Seduction V is still one of my favorites of all times!
She upped the price for European shoppers. It is $155 for me or 155 euro so I'll wait for a sale as yeah that's a lot of money, it is cooler toned then I expected though and I do love the shades
I am waiting years and years and years for a Pat McGrath palette which is worth the money for me. I love all the palettes a little and i really wanna try the quality, but i think for over 130€ every shade has to be 💥BAM!! And in every palette are 3-5 boring shades
You have to want to use every single shade at that price point.
Oh my gosh!!! Looks sooooo much better “in person” but yeah I understand your thought but still haven’t lost my WANTING this 😂😂😂😂
Morgan-thanks for this honest review. That is why we trust you!!! We all admire Pat but I do have to say that I’m not liking the direction her brand is taking right now. I thought Mothership X would blow me out of the water but that is just not the case. Xoxo✨✨-Molly-
What a gorgeous result! Love this makeup look!
I always think I neeeed these palettes but I could just get some similar indie sparkly shades for way cheaper since I have these mattes several times over. Her sales pull me in!
After purchasing almost all of the Motherships I discovered indie brand multichromes. I have some from terra moons and adept cosmetics plain Jane remastered. The fallout is next to nothing compared to pats Motherships.
Which do yo I recommend?
@@xoxjelloxox Indie shadows or motherships?
@@jbriggsstuff sadly I'm in Europe so my options are limited due to the price of shipping but glam shop is eu based and the shimmers are just as good if not better, and so much more affordable with loads of options :D. Yes, some PMG blitz astrals do have a lot of fallout indeed
This is my favorite palatte! So happy I got it for my 40th this year lol. All the gurus hate it lol except dear Charlotte. I have mothership. 1 and 9 and now 10. I love, love this one. And they all play together. But I get why some are dissapointed.
you're always the first to review these PMG palettes!! I've been looking forward to this video :) even though the color story from the pictures didn't wow me.
Hi Morgan, Thank you so much for this video. And I appreciate you spending your money on this palette, because I wasn't going to get this palette . I 100% at this point agree with you about the fact that the burgundy cherry matte flat mat it's been done too many times now. I did get the Utopian dream ballot. I also own the midnight Sun palette. And I just don't understand why she has to keep doing this with this cherry burgundy and they're not even pretty and there's some sort of gold that Pat has to put in every one of her collections. There's also silver it looks like so I don't mind it. But then pinkish rosish burgundy sick of it. I now feel free to get that bridgeton six-pan palette I am going to get that That's looking extremely off on guard now compared to this. But it's all good I am liking the Danessa Myricks pallets. Plums kind of look similar honestly the two matte shades look similar I'm going to I would love to have that divine rose too, and I think it's bronze seduction with that gorgeous ruby red shimmer in it and then I be fine I'd be fun but it would have beyon sale. Gorgeous blitz shades. But thanks again for this video I appreciate it can't wait to see some looks more looks from you. Take care Morgan 🙏🌟💖🤗
I saw a video of someone duping this palette with bronze seduction and last year's holiday palette. Its a pass for me but it is pretty.
Cristina Brooke did that.
Wow. This is giving me Interstellar Icon vibes!! I am so OVER all of the filters she uses to promote her products. This looks so much richer than what I thought.
You are RIGHT ON about everything you are saying. Can we get something new?! This looks just like so much we have already seen. This was the very first mothership that I did not purchase.
Since getting my first Adept palette, and getting into indie.. I cannot imagine spending that much for the SAME THING!! Yawn.
Great video!!! 💖💖
Indie is where it's at!
Isamaya's recent palette is more intriguing to me. I want some more interest, edge from PMG.
My favorite eyeshadow ever was a now discontinued pink by Chanel so I am not against pinks. But after the Bridgerton pinks, I was ready for some different transition shades. I still ordered it, even though I was going to wait (ha, who was I kidding).
I bought this I'm loving it but, I think the key to being happy with the pallets is making absolutely sure the mattes work for your skin tone. I would never consider Sublime or Bronze Seduction cause the mattes look too warm for me. Also do not pay full price because first of all it's not worth it and secondly they have at least 4 big sales a year at 30%-40% off. Save your cash!
Omg I’ve been waiting for this video 😍 I think I’ll wait for the sale to pick this up. The color story doesn’t excite me that much but, I collect all her big motherships so, it’s still on my list ❤️
As a shimmer lover with a fair skin tone, I am in love with those icy special shades.
I'll probably be patient, wait until the palette goes on sale and then grab it :)
This is the first mothership palette I could see myself wanting enough to consider buying. When I looked through my collection to see if I have anything to try to "dupe" the color story for a test run I was amused to find my WetnWild comfort zone 10 pan is surprisingly similar. I also find comfort zone to be an exceptionally useful color story so it actually adds to my interest in trying a super high end version. Gonna sit on it and see how I feel if it goes on sale
An in-depth swatch comparison video would be so amazing 🤩 thank you!
I find it very interesting that PML already ran a 10% off sale on this one. Personally, it does not excite me but I probably will pick it up at a higher discount.
She always offers 10% off at launch if you sign up for notifications for every palette launch.
This would be a great 1st mothership for someone I hate the pinks though. But it looks everyday wearable if you want it
Thanks Morgan! Hello beautiful people 😁 I hope everyone is well and happy 😊
I think it would be interesting to see you pair this palette with another one you have. Many of us, especially if we're getting her palettes, will have some sort of collection. So I'd love to see what looks you come up with by pairing it with other mattes or pops of color, etc.!
It's just not exciting enough to me to justify $128, even on sale I don't see anything here I don't have elsewhere from Pat or other brands. I mean we just got a nice blue/brown from ABH. I'm a little sad and hope Pat will change things up soon!
Seeing it next to the other two rose palette, this is definitely my fav. I really like all the colours wouldn’t mind a mini/4 pan of this.
I want my mattes neutral brown or taupeish not a fan of reds.
I think a matte forest green instead of the warmer reddish matte would have been the perfect mix of complimentary and contrasting shades in the palette
I 100% agree with you. I don’t care for two of the three mattes. I LOVE the taupe, but the other two do not work with the color story and are truly redundant of her other palettes. I would also have loved a dark brown and a different color for the two other mattes. I don’t think the other mattes go with the other colors either. I really only see myself using the taupe. I will likely combine this with other PML palettes. Yesterday I wore the Taupe with the Platinum shade (not the special one, the regular metallic) and it was VERY dark and dramatic - not great for every day, but thankfully my peeps are used to my Va Va Voom eyeshadow looks!
I completely agree. Way too many pink/reddish tones as far as the mattes at this point. I love Midnight Sun, because it has those browns and different colors of metallics, green and taupeish bronze as well as the purple and copper. it has so many different directions you can go. I wish she would release another Mothership that would have a color story with variety like that. We need a change.
Hi Morgan, I was kinda hoping that this palette would of been different. But I had a big feeling it was going to look like her other palettes. Now to be honest I have the 2 holiday palettes and then I have Bronze seductions and I have Divine rose 1 & 2. Now I want to ask you Morgan if you were me and you had what I have would you get Mothership 10? I’m would love to know. I have to say I love the look you did, very pretty. I’m glad you put up your video. I was waiting to see who out of the RUclipsr’s I watch who was going to put up there video on this palette. I want to Thank you for always being honest and for your thoughts on this palette. I know all of us here appreciate it a lot. Enjoy you time with your family. Till the next one bye.
I feel like this palette looks more like a bronze seduction 2. The mattes and shimmers look very similar, especially the two green shimmery shades in those palettes. I’d love to see you do a video dedicated to swatching similar shades from her collection and trying a create the same eye look with them💜