Evolution of the Final Fantasy Victory Theme (UPDATED TO INCLUDE XVI)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
  • To celebrate the release of FINAL FANTASY XVI, I decided to redo my video on the evolution of the victory fanfare.
    Enjoy!
    This is for my baby, Aura Snowbean. Baby, you've been waiting for XVI since 2016 when you finished XV. I know you have been wanting to play this since it was announced. And now it's here...
    I know you're gonna love it

Комментарии • 286

  • @JAY1GHOST0ELITE
    @JAY1GHOST0ELITE Год назад +197

    Final Fantasy: 0:37
    Final Fantasy 2: 0:55
    Final Fantasy 3: 1:11
    Final Fantasy 4: 1:29
    Final Fantasy 5: 1:47
    Final Fantasy 6: 2:05
    Final Fantasy 7: 2:23
    Final Fantasy 8: 2:39
    Final Fantasy 9: 2:55
    Final Fantasy 10: 3:15
    Final Fantasy 11: 3:36
    Final Fantasy X-2: 3:41
    Final Fantasy 12: 4:02
    Final fantasy 13: 4:20
    Final Fantasy 14 1.00: 4:42
    Final Fantasy XIII-2: 5:02
    Final Fantasy 14 2.00: 5:20
    Lightning Returns Final Fantasy 13: 5:41
    Final Fantasy 15: 5:58
    Final fantasy 16: 6:06
    TNTMinecart54: 6:14

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  Год назад +10

      Thanks! I was gonna put in chapters at some point. You helped big time!

    • @JAY1GHOST0ELITE
      @JAY1GHOST0ELITE Год назад +5

      Of course! I was taking a break with 16 anyway. I recommend you pin. Anyway have a good day bud!👋

    • @mattytaco3542
      @mattytaco3542 Год назад +3

      wholesome moment

    • @aa-tx7th
      @aa-tx7th Год назад +2

      nice vid but no tactics?
      no dissidia?
      no ff7 compilation?
      no mobile spinoffs like revenant wings or 4 heroes?
      what are we even doing here man?
      no tactics...
      im gonna need your final fantasy gatekeepers' pass right now buddy.
      god damn he got 10-2 and the entire 13 trilogy and missed freaking tactics...

    • @walterrose3520
      @walterrose3520 11 месяцев назад

      Perfect! Very much appreciated

  • @psychogamer7213
    @psychogamer7213 8 месяцев назад +148

    It went from a cute little jingle from the first game to really catchy in VI and VII to straight up Epicness and glory in XVI.

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  8 месяцев назад +8

      100% Agreed

    • @davidsam445
      @davidsam445 7 месяцев назад

      Agreed! And I feel they got lost for ff13 and 15

    • @Glitchedpixel5
      @Glitchedpixel5 6 месяцев назад +2

      I kinda like ff13 Victory theme(specifically part 2)

  • @claudevalentine8657
    @claudevalentine8657 7 месяцев назад +160

    VII just hits different.

  • @sealguy155
    @sealguy155 7 месяцев назад +30

    Look the "Dun dun dun dun, dun dun dun dun" will always be a classic and I get it but X-2's guitar riff fucking makes me smile every time

  • @WillieManga
    @WillieManga Год назад +123

    One of my favorite parts about its use in 16 is that after the tutorial it is reserved for after boss fights. It makes overcoming a major milestone on your journey feel more rewarding.

  • @welks13
    @welks13 Год назад +421

    Some may call it recency bias but the one from FFXVI is easily my favorite

    • @JordanJumpin
      @JordanJumpin Год назад +29

      the epicness,

    • @MrGeorge102
      @MrGeorge102 Год назад +24

      Btw the lyrics of the fanfare is in Ancient Greek!

    • @OmegaEnvych
      @OmegaEnvych Год назад +5

      I like how it sounds like further development from FFXIV theme (one used now) - no wonder considering same composer but man.

    • @welks13
      @welks13 Год назад +1

      @@MrGeorge102 Really? I'm from Greece but I didn't notice that
      Do you know what it says?

    • @cl20v87
      @cl20v87 Год назад

      Came here just for that one

  • @ignisofficialgaming
    @ignisofficialgaming Год назад +86

    You missed Prompto’s rendition from XV. That is tied with XVI as my favourite version of the victory theme

  • @thecedex
    @thecedex Год назад +126

    everything since the beginning has lead to FFXVI's epic rendition

    • @Ishin69
      @Ishin69 5 месяцев назад +2

      too bad 16 sucks as a game, the theme is epic

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  2 месяца назад +3

      ​@@Ishin69Hey ho hold on. I understand FFXVI isnt for everyone. Is it a good game? Yes! In my opinion it is, and i respect that you probably dont like it cause of whatever reason.
      If its the battle system, which is your favorite then?
      Honestly id guess your fave is either FFVI or VII.

    • @Ishin69
      @Ishin69 2 месяца назад

      @@MinecartWithTNT i didn't enjoy FFXVI for various reasons (i finished the game btw), for me the combat was just mindnumbing, it was just mash mash until the enemy's guard breaks, spam skills, repeat. it got dull so fast, there was no need for strategy because even on the highest difficulty the fights felt trivial. also the lack of any rpg elements in the game just disappointed me. next was the grim story, i can see a lot of people liking it but for me it was just depressing because humor always was a big part of FF games but here it's almost non-existant. and it didn't help that clive had the charisma of a brick wall. sorry for the long text but i hope that explained my point of view

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  2 месяца назад

      @@Ishin69 I got you. At least we can all agree that the music was killer!

  • @Dcali1
    @Dcali1 Год назад +44

    The ones before 16 sound like success music when I win In rock paper scissors, and 16 sounds like I just killed an elder God

    • @consumerjtc5835
      @consumerjtc5835 Год назад +5

      When it plays after defeating(or killing) an eikon after a long battle it feels cathartic.

    • @Oddfosshaugbagi
      @Oddfosshaugbagi Месяц назад

      @@consumerjtc5835not neasecery that but basiclly a boss like a big one that takes long, but why the hell dident it play when we killed ultima

  • @elwinbu5926
    @elwinbu5926 Год назад +185

    Ff16 one just sounded so much more epic😍

  • @BankaiFever
    @BankaiFever Год назад +41

    They’re all so good it’s hard to have just one favorite especially if you’ve played all the mainline numbered games. Favorite series ever

  • @williamsanborn9195
    @williamsanborn9195 Год назад +26

    FFIX is my all-time favorite. Even for as iconic as FFVII’s rendition is. I also like FFV.

  • @KagusakiUrufu
    @KagusakiUrufu 11 месяцев назад +15

    FFVI will always be my favorite cause it got that disco feels to it due to the four on the floor beat

    • @lpstweetytv5242
      @lpstweetytv5242 8 месяцев назад +2

      Yeah! I love going to the disco after every fight :)

  • @jinn8465
    @jinn8465 9 месяцев назад +14

    14 (2.0) is by far my favorite tbh. Especially when you've just nailed a hard fight with a friend or two. It's so damn satisfying. Not to mention hearing the start every time you level up.
    (VII is also a fuckin' bop, of course.)

    • @ArthurTheQuasar
      @ArthurTheQuasar 8 месяцев назад

      Yup - that is also one of my favorite ones. Aside from X, that is 😉

  • @OceanSSShark
    @OceanSSShark Год назад +75

    I love FF16's victory theme, but the classics are always a joy to hear

  • @LoryTheCableGuy
    @LoryTheCableGuy 4 месяца назад +3

    The ones from X-2, XIII-2 and Lightning Returns are my all-time favorites

  • @megamanblack4309
    @megamanblack4309 Год назад +23

    14 (2.0) & 16 are my favorites!

  • @arkane9b
    @arkane9b Год назад +17

    XIII is like: "Look, mom! I'm special!
    Mom:...yes. Yes, you are...

  • @igm1571
    @igm1571 21 день назад +1

    VII and XVI seriously hit different.

  • @Miyao05
    @Miyao05 Год назад +10

    I didn't realize how very close 16 was to 14... similar to the whole voice thing. Nice touch Yoshi p and Sokken :)

  • @LelloDalamiq
    @LelloDalamiq 10 месяцев назад +5

    I think of the most established, FF V is probably the most developed version of the Victory Fanfare. It makes sense that S-E would use this version in later retro cameo moments like the Data Install success for Dissidia FF on the PSP.
    I think FF XVI's new fanfare is short but captures the traditional touch.

  • @MariusBoss11458
    @MariusBoss11458 Год назад +24

    6:06 for FF16

  • @adrianridgway4333
    @adrianridgway4333 25 дней назад

    I was surprised, but this was my time hearing the victory theme from both major versions of 14 and I can't lie, I think the v1 was my favourite of them all! So bombastic!

  • @zyedelric
    @zyedelric Год назад +8

    I like it when I can bop with the Victory theme, IV, VI VII gives me that 😄

  • @woljay9362
    @woljay9362 Месяц назад +1

    Still love VIII’s theme. Makes me dance even ❤

  • @soobawoo392
    @soobawoo392 Год назад +33

    bruh ffxvi feels so grand

  • @Yanquii
    @Yanquii Год назад +12

    My favorite ones are LR and FFXVI (it’s like barbie and oppenheimer being next to each other)

  • @AnotherCamilo
    @AnotherCamilo Год назад +20

    You had to include the fanfare from FFVII Remake: Barret singing "Dah-dah-da-da da da da dah-DAHHHH!!!"

    • @animefan8591
      @animefan8591 Месяц назад

      Introduce him to Prompto. Also Yazoo's ringtone in Advent Children

  • @arumea5418
    @arumea5418 5 месяцев назад +1

    the results half of VIIIs always hits for me, that jazzy feel is so good. but also IXs return to the original style after VII and VIII changed the results half is a breath of fresh air.

  • @darkwinter8
    @darkwinter8 10 месяцев назад +3

    The amount of hours I spent on FFXIV (2.00), I will always love that victory theme.

    • @theghostgam3r269
      @theghostgam3r269 5 месяцев назад

      It is my favourite game and the soundtrack always floors me no matter how much I hear it example being steal reason the theme for garlean leader boss fights

  • @AresLodin
    @AresLodin Год назад +14

    16 hard to top man. That shit is too good

  • @Gtboy_Editz
    @Gtboy_Editz Год назад +12

    Ff7 gotta be my personal favorite

  • @happymago1
    @happymago1 Год назад +21

    FFXII theme is the best without a doubt

  • @jaromx57
    @jaromx57 Год назад +22

    Anybody else hoping that they would've included Prompto singing the victory theme for 15? 😂

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  Год назад +3

      I kinda wanted to. But my rule was one per game, unfortunately. I didn't want this video to drag on for so long

    • @DoeRecompense
      @DoeRecompense Год назад +4

      @@MinecartWithTNTDrag it on dude we don’t care. We’re Fanatics!!!

    • @thekiss2083
      @thekiss2083 Год назад

      Or Barret from 7 Remake?

    • @DKS3A
      @DKS3A 10 месяцев назад

      Or yuffie from ff7 intermission

    • @quocbinhvo6084
      @quocbinhvo6084 7 месяцев назад

      @@MinecartWithTNTwe have timestamp man dw. Also 6 minutes is too short for greatness

  • @GoddamnBatman1
    @GoddamnBatman1 Год назад +22

    From the Nintendo era: FF4
    From the PS1/PS2 era: FF7
    From the current era: FF14

    • @brytilaar
      @brytilaar 7 месяцев назад

      I like the Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba!

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  2 месяца назад

      Heres mine:
      NES: FFIII
      SNES: FFVI
      PS1: FFIX
      PS2: FFXII
      PS3: Lightning Returns
      PS4: FFXIV
      PS5: FFXVI

  • @lpstweetytv5242
    @lpstweetytv5242 6 месяцев назад +2

    I always groove 6's disco beat XD
    I also really like 13-3'S victory theme

  • @kelzk
    @kelzk 27 дней назад +1

    XII will forever hit with the ferocity of a lion

  • @glennparker7028
    @glennparker7028 7 дней назад

    6:09 I love that chanting!!!

  • @CanonessEllinor
    @CanonessEllinor 4 месяца назад +1

    Probably an unpopular opinion, but the post-fanfare parts of VII, VIII and X sound like the backing music for the weather report on a news channel. There is something about them that just screams “you are in a hotel room in 1998 watching CNN.” I can almost see the cgi globe spinning around to give me today’s temperatures in Hanoi and Addis Ababa when I listen to them.

  • @MrFitzonic
    @MrFitzonic 5 месяцев назад +1

    All this joy and energy in the first few games!
    ..then 7 and 8 take all the fun out of it lmao

  • @Neelo_Angelo
    @Neelo_Angelo Год назад +10

    FXVI IS JUST MAJESTIC

  • @jureigeeksoutoccasionally
    @jureigeeksoutoccasionally 5 месяцев назад

    13 sound absolutely awesome. Like Akiba’s Beat meets Trauma Center meets Chrono Trigger

  • @EX7Sonic
    @EX7Sonic 4 месяца назад +4

    I didn't know whose idea it was to not have the classic victory theme in the FF 13 games but that, like most of the game, was yet another shitty decision. Shame too cause the OST in general is pretty good.

  • @Pictavienne
    @Pictavienne Год назад +2

    I didn't know the Loporrits were using the 1.0 victory fanfare when they come out of their shell/house thing in Endwalker

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  Год назад

      Yeah they reuse it for certain events and moments in game still. But it's not the main victory theme anymore

  • @thecedex
    @thecedex Год назад +15

    Also not sure why 13 was so hesitant to use the FF fanfare nor any of the pieces the franchise was known for. It was as if the developers decided not to include them in fear of being compared to the songs from previous games in the franchise

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  Год назад +5

      My guess is because it was a new generation of consoles at the time (X360/PS3) and they were trying to change things up for the newest game. Now that I think about it, Final Fantasy VII did the same thing and then they said Final Fantasy IX was returning to the series roots. Maybe the same idea here? Not sure entirely

    • @jaedenriley3409
      @jaedenriley3409 Год назад +6

      i thought all the 13s were so so good even tho they strayed from the source material

  • @darthacez
    @darthacez Год назад +8

    XVI is definitely my favorite and even more if you know what the lyrics mean

  • @ApexCalibre
    @ApexCalibre Год назад +16

    I mean even 7 and 13 lovers have to admit...16's music is the best lol

    • @islandboy9381
      @islandboy9381 Год назад +2

      7 got the unmatched vibes

    • @lucas.lagoriaa
      @lucas.lagoriaa 7 месяцев назад +1

      Final Fantasy VIII and XV have the best soundtracks in the franchise, but XVI is in top 5 for sure

    • @lpstweetytv5242
      @lpstweetytv5242 6 месяцев назад +1

      16 is alright, but honestly, the choir is so loud I can't hear it most the time

    • @doggyfizzle719
      @doggyfizzle719 4 месяца назад

      Drums and synth too cold in 7 to be second to any of the other themes

  • @darkwarrior5149
    @darkwarrior5149 8 месяцев назад +2

    Kingdom Hearts got me into final fantasy
    OBviously I played 7 and 8, and also my mom got me 10
    Good stuff to always come back to
    Helps slow my brain down from the (what I thought was fast paced back then) combat of Kingdom Hearts 1
    Waiting for ff16 pc release (dont have a ps5 LMAO)
    I hope its worht the wait!

  • @rvmaika5815
    @rvmaika5815 Год назад +16

    Of all of these, I think my favorite is the one from FF8

  • @dainnbam6222
    @dainnbam6222 Год назад +2

    4:20 Tonight on Primetime Square Enix News.... a Lightning storm is arriving in the overworld...

  • @rathalos143
    @rathalos143 Год назад +4

    My favourites were probably XIV 1.0, 3, 6 and 9.

  • @SMCwasTaken
    @SMCwasTaken 4 месяца назад +2

    I prefer the classic ones over the new ones

  • @supermetroid009
    @supermetroid009 Год назад +3

    There ya go 16 brought the fanfare back

  • @Ubeenblind
    @Ubeenblind 2 месяца назад

    16 theme majestic AF

  • @abztraktt6403
    @abztraktt6403 6 месяцев назад +1

    Damn I forgot how 8 used to thump!

  • @yeetskeet3
    @yeetskeet3 9 месяцев назад +1

    X-2, xiii and XVI are my favorites

  • @sian22
    @sian22 2 месяца назад

    Why did 7 get a totally different treatment from the rest?.. wow it hit’s differently

  • @blazzer
    @blazzer Год назад +3

    16, legendary bgm

  • @Thedownliner2015
    @Thedownliner2015 Год назад +4

    Liked VII the best. X-2 is cool as it reminds me of the Dreamcast interface music for some reason lol.

  • @tontj
    @tontj Год назад +1

    FF16 be like
    YoshiP = the player just killed some freaking eikon. We need some glorious music.
    Soken : say no more. Here is a glorious rendition of the iconic fanfare.

  • @NateTheOhioan
    @NateTheOhioan 6 месяцев назад +1

    Man why doesn’t final fantasy X get any appreciation

  • @fdsetianto8253
    @fdsetianto8253 3 месяца назад +1

    final fansty X

  • @stevenhoang2239
    @stevenhoang2239 Год назад +6

    I know FFVII Remake is a remake of a main game but still should be included no?

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  Год назад +2

      I was only including mainline, no remasters, remakes, or side games

  • @Waterbottlez_
    @Waterbottlez_ Год назад +2

    My favorites are definitely 6, 7, and 14

  • @olaraongee8313
    @olaraongee8313 9 месяцев назад +2

    Nah ff13 goes the hardest for me🔥

  • @sinzspades733
    @sinzspades733 8 месяцев назад

    3 from SNES days is my favorite growing up :)

  • @persefone98
    @persefone98 Месяц назад

    Why the oven of the kitchen where I was working had a sound like this?😂

  • @kirosrazer2222
    @kirosrazer2222 Год назад +1

    4 was my favorite.

  • @Vayne_Solidor
    @Vayne_Solidor 5 месяцев назад

    Prompto shall not be forgotten!!

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  5 месяцев назад

      I know, in the latest one of these evolution videos, I added him under the bonus ones near the end. Same for Barret in VII Remake/Rebirth

  • @Scarface1491
    @Scarface1491 10 дней назад

    8 and 16 the most epic 4sure

  • @Hexstasy100
    @Hexstasy100 Год назад +5

    FF12's and FF16's are the best. 16 just matches the tone of the game so well

  • @YangBalanceYin
    @YangBalanceYin 8 месяцев назад

    16's is without a doubt the best one. There's an intense epicness to it.

  • @monjay6255
    @monjay6255 Год назад +2

    Prompto singing the victory fanfare on FFXV is basically us 😂😂😂

  • @nekogamer2508
    @nekogamer2508 5 месяцев назад

    For me 7 , 15 and 16 are my favorites

  • @VRLaser
    @VRLaser 11 месяцев назад +1

    Good video. I have FF XVI fanfare as ringtone.

  • @renren47618
    @renren47618 Год назад +1

    6,7, 9 and 15 have the best ones

  • @retepoteil
    @retepoteil Год назад +2

    Final fantasy 16…. That’s gonna be hard to top that one

  • @dragoncrashhero12
    @dragoncrashhero12 5 месяцев назад +1

    Where my FF12 fanfare boys at

  • @DrawingwithMangaSoul
    @DrawingwithMangaSoul 29 дней назад +2

    Can someone tell me which versions the ones in the Intro are?

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  29 дней назад +1

      The intro music itself is the Prologue Theme from Final Fantasy IV DS, the first part of the Victory Theme is taken from a rearrangement done by Nobuo Uematsu for FF's 30th Anniversary I believe. And the second part is taken from the "Rivals" version of the victory theme from Dissidia NT.

    • @DrawingwithMangaSoul
      @DrawingwithMangaSoul 29 дней назад

      @@MinecartWithTNT Thank you very much kind sir!

  • @NateTheOhioan
    @NateTheOhioan 6 месяцев назад +1

    Idk how or where, but I’m trying to remember. I never played any of the final fantasy games growing up but for some reason a version of this exact song was the victory music. It was an electric guitar sounding thing with the only real distinction being that the last 3 notes are a bit drawn out, but then the after part also was the same. It was some obscure flash game or whatever those games on random websites were called back then like agame and miniclip and armor gams. But for the life of me I can’t remember where.

    • @hwanniggles187
      @hwanniggles187 5 месяцев назад

      Might be the Dissidia games from the PSP

  • @dummmi_balls9424
    @dummmi_balls9424 Год назад +4

    FFX has the best victory theme. Fight me

  • @jessechen6612
    @jessechen6612 9 месяцев назад +1

    what happened to X-2? It seems to be totally different from others.

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  9 месяцев назад

      Since it's a side game technically, SE decided to not use the main victory theme in it. I guess. I really don't know lol

  • @mujitomulia8743
    @mujitomulia8743 Год назад +1

    I though I'll hear Barret's humming from VII-R

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  Год назад

      I only chose one from each game. And I didn't include remakes, remasters, or side games. Just mainline games and their sequels

  • @InfinityOnHighx1
    @InfinityOnHighx1 6 месяцев назад

    10 and 7 are just too good

  • @blastchaos4286
    @blastchaos4286 Год назад +3

    13's are all so goated damn, I should play that game

    • @Tunneltoo
      @Tunneltoo 6 месяцев назад

      You should play it. Not that I ever have.

  • @MultiTrollface999
    @MultiTrollface999 4 месяца назад

    didn't there used to be a huge, almost hour video with all the fanfares, from every release?

  • @Alkonium
    @Alkonium 6 месяцев назад

    I noticed XI and XV's fanfares are kind of quiet here.

  • @nghtspawn651
    @nghtspawn651 11 месяцев назад +1

    Ff15 has a unique one for defeating Omega.

  • @awesomegamer5141
    @awesomegamer5141 10 месяцев назад

    7 and x and x-2 are my favorite

  • @HungNguyen-vh8rp
    @HungNguyen-vh8rp Год назад +3

    I think you should add the one in Monster Hunter World after Behemonth fight.

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  Год назад

      This video was mainline games only and their sequels, no side stuff or collabs. Besides, the one used at the end of that fight is the one from FFXIV 2.0 anyway

    • @CGsoufiane
      @CGsoufiane Год назад

      I think it's the same one as 14 no?

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  Год назад

      @@CGsoufiane yup

  • @control4230
    @control4230 Год назад +3

    Final Fantasy X was my first Final Fantasy and so is my favourite fanfare. I loved every "Traditional" version espescially Procto from 15 humming it out loud and woud love the newest version had the final note note been changed....it just sounds wrong to my ear.

  • @devindye9072
    @devindye9072 4 месяца назад

    12 is my favorite

  • @mrmafiaism
    @mrmafiaism 9 месяцев назад

    No cap 16 is the best! Absolute banger!

  • @Hi-Im-Gib
    @Hi-Im-Gib Год назад +3

    This is coming from a casual but my Favs are FFVII just love the beat after the classic jingle.
    Makes me feel like a badass who just took down some fodder and made it look cool.
    FFXVI makes me feel like I just killed God.
    And personally my fav is FFXIII 2s one, but it's weird cause I don’t think it should be a victory theme. Sounds more like an overworld theme.

  • @PG-20
    @PG-20 11 месяцев назад +1

    X-2 sounds like Gran Turismo

  • @WildDancer101
    @WildDancer101 Год назад

    Sounds like 16 took a page from 14 2.0 while throwing in a British feel to it.

  • @oneandonlyjark
    @oneandonlyjark Год назад +1

    No 12: Revenant Wings or FF7R ?

    • @MinecartWithTNT
      @MinecartWithTNT  Год назад

      I said in the video that I'm only covering Mainline games (that includes their sequels), no side games, remakes, or remasters

  • @firestarneosoldierprime729
    @firestarneosoldierprime729 4 месяца назад

    There’s something about 7 and 16 they just hit different 7 has that you are an utter badass and nothing can stop you and 16 just screams utter GLORY.

  • @sam.houseworth
    @sam.houseworth 6 месяцев назад

    Man, they really lost their way after 9... but refound themselves in 14