To be honest, many teenagers aren't terribly interested in any hobbies, outside sport, because of all the other things going on in their lives. I can (just) remember my teens (1980s), and I had hobbies (modelmaking and model railways) but I hardly spent any time or money on them, with friends, Cadets, school etc. taking priority. But I came back to hobbies when I 'needed' them. My dad made this honest comment some years ago - "Young people have the time and space, and the eyesight and motor skills to do modelmaking - but not the money; Young adults have the money but not the time or space; middle aged folk are losing their eyesight and dexterity, are too busy, but have the money and space, and by the time you're retired, you can't see, your hands have seized up, but you have all the time, money and space you need!" I think you're bang on - it's changing - not dying.
I have to agree with many of your points. One thing you mentioned briefly, the closing of train stores. Here in Montreal we are down to one from at least 8 in the past. Now I and many other local hobbyists are forced to shop online. I miss the personal connection from visiting my local hobbystore. The chance to engage with other modellers.😢
While you are 100% true in many of your points and especially the fact that many teenagers aren't terribly interested in this hobby, I am one of the few odd ones out, I became active in my local club at the age of 16 (currently 18 now), and while price is 100% an important factor, I think the biggest problem is how overwhelming it is to start out from square one and that's why I think joining a local club has a big advantage, when I started out there, I had so many questions because I was really starting at square one and I felt overwhelmed, but because I was a part of the local club I could get a lot of answers and help on even the most basic things, best example I have was how to install 8 pin decoders in a non-DCC ready locomotive, I asked one of the older members and he gave me a good two hour lesson about it, with us doing installations together and just because of that, I now know how to do that without any problems.
My take on modelling hobbies in general is this Many people make models as young kids but then lose interest in these type of hobbies. However many return to such hobbies later in their 30s or 40s. I think this is a fairly common pattern
I am a US model railway fan but married to a Brit. On trips over to the UK, I was struck by how popular the hobby is and how many magazines there are dedicated to the hobby! Thanks for the encouraging video. So many are touting the demise of the hobby.
When kids come in an exhibition, most modelers prevent them from coming close to the layout... I even saw people placing plexiglass or a kind of fence preventing them to come close to the diorama / layout. And most times, we stand behind the layout so we don't engage with the kids or the parents. We created a Timesaver on an ironing table with tons of animations. A sawmill with sound and trunks moving, a crane, a welder, a guy with a chainsaw, a fire and smoke in a chimney, a painter... a miniature film crew... and a hidden camera that shows video on a PC screen above the layout. "the smallest camera in the world" We stand in front of the layout. To the very small kids, I tell them I have problems with my finger, I need help to push on buttons. They stand on a chair, I select animations and they push on the "little green knob" to trigger the animations. Stars in their eyes as the miniature show unfolds triggered by their finger. For older kids, I hold the throttle with them, I handle the switches and decouplers and I ask them to move cars around. And for even older ones I explain, help and they do the whole switching alone. When there is a family with several kids, I have the small ones busy with the little green knob that triggers the animations, the others on the switches... and the parents play as well to give advice on the next moves... There are stars in everyone's eyes. 8 years this layout exists, we never ever had anyone break anything. Even if they would, we would repair... that was the deal. Sit in front of your layouts, engage with people, especially kids, propose them to drive trains. Not necessarily the super expensive locomotives. You will see...
That is brilliant, Alfred, and thank you for doing that ! I am involved in three rail O, and to hear the grumbling old fools who do things like modular layouts at shows, you would think that kids were the visigoths and huns come to sack rome (kind of ironic as something that started as kids toys). I go to train shows, and I see what you mention, not interacting with people, staying aloof, instead of interacting with people..and when they do, the (almost always) male members if they talk to people, tend to talk to men, not women. Kids and women are an untapped source of people into the hobby, and yeah, there are some women who think it is weird, but I know a lot who might be interested, who think it is fun.
I think more celebrities that have train layouts should share more and talk more about them. There are more than we know who have train sets running in their homes! If kids see that, they might be drawn more to it. The costs are another problem and when someone passes, they usually auction it off and the people with money, who already have layouts usually buy it all up for outrageous prices! Too bad kids don't have clubs anymore where they could share costs and have a layout at a youth center, museum or garage somewhere.
@@MartinKnifechief That is where train clubs come in. I have seen some where the kids have their own , relatively smaller layout, that they can work on and operate while of course having access to the big one. Here in the US there are groups like 4H that have train clubs for kids but it is rare. One of the problems is that the hobby doesn't do much to promote itself. You see ads by manufacturers in model magazines , but you don't see ads in places that might reach younger ppl. Not a marketing type, but they need to figure out where it would be visible. The attitude is kind of like 'if you build it they will come', but that doesn't work. Focus on parents of kids, have ads promoting the hobby and how it can have all kinds of learning with it, including electronics. One of the bigger mistakes I have seen? Using Facebook. It just isn't where young ppl are. Might be better on tik Tok or wherever else young ppl are. If you do train shows, have interest for young kids. At the three rail shows they have train races that kids seem to love. Having live animations that start by pressing a button, activates sound, starts a trolley line, it all gets the kids involved. A small layout where kids can take turns controlling trains would be great ( hint, limit the max speed of the engines).
There are train clubs in America, one is the Toy Train Operating Society, and the Train Collector's Association, Standard Gauge Module Association, Detroit 3 Railers Club. The problem is letting kids be kids, and attempt to play with the trains. Worse case scenario, a throttle control tests how a brand new lionel can punch through a sheetrock wall to add a new addition for $1,500 . . . which should be considered a bargain compared to paying a contractor to do the work! @@MartinKnifechief
I agree. It's about interacting and letting the kids be directly involved. I went to the Denver train show last year and I saw so many interactive layouts where they taught the kids and let them run the trains. In fact, I saw many teenagers running trains, no supervision.
I'm a member of Glasgow and the West of Scotland Model Railway Club , this time last year we had about 15 members in a very small clubhouse , we took the plunge and moved to bigger premises which enabled us to have multiple show layouts on show and our membership has more than doubled including some younger members . You are %100 correct that there is a still a thriving hobby out there and it was good to hear (and see) your video confirming that fact 👍
Hi Gerry - well done to you and your club members! That's great to hear. Could you send me some photos or may I take them from your website as it would be great to share your club news on my livestream this evening - the Wednesday Express (Not Stopping at Peterborough). We've visited a lot of model railway clubs over the past year - and what I've noticed is that clubs who do make the leap to have larger premises with layouts out and operating do find it easier to grow their membership. As you say, it's about having the confidence to take the plunge - but of course, finances are also a key consideration! Here's the link for tonight's livestream: ruclips.net/user/liveWzsqKLqhlpg?si=_gS-uQoj9hzE9nuq All the best, Dawn
Interesting video Dawn. I would argue that it’s not only the price, but also the stigma around railways as a hobby. I know plenty of teens who model, but are embarrassed going ‘public’ in school. If you could change that stigma, then you’d see a change
I agree - that's my question. How do we make the model railway hobby "cool" - I think the answer lies beyond traditional model railway layouts, and is a hybrid of tech, video gaming, social media and smart phones. The industry needs bosses with teens/younger children... and we're probably starting to see that happen.
@@modelrailwayquest I work in a high school, and I’ve found talking confidently to the pupils about my hobby has really helped, even to the point of one boy getting a second hand layout for Christmas! It’s great, but we’re talking small scale I guess
I love that! If we're nervous about talking about our hobby because we're worried we'll look like geeks, what message are we sending out to young people! Love your attitude!
My son is 13 and is a passionate modeller. Yes, it takes time to save enough money for purchases, but it's so worth it. His secondary school also runs a lunchtime model railway club which is fantastic and well attended. Through modelling he has learnt patience, the importance of research, creative skills, design etc and by visiting exhibitions he has gained in confidence. Fantastic hobby, just costly.
As an American who stepped back from the hobby, and I am just starting to return it seems to me that the prices have risen dramatically. There used to be an entire midlevel in the hobby, where you could spend some money but not a car payment every month. Yes, I am over 58, but I can still remember going to the local model railroad store and they had a wall of Athearn blue box kits for between $5.00 and $9.00. One Friday evening I bought 6 kits and spent the next day assembling them adding the right weights, replacing the couplers and wheels on some of them and then the next day I took them over to the layout a friend of mine and I shared and we had 6 new cars to put on the roster. This led us to lengthen a few yard tracks. The total of my purchase wasn't more than $70.00 and that's because I had to buy some weathering powders and pastels also. Now I look at an N scale car and it's $30.00. I'm presently assembling everything I need to build a layout and want a 130' turntable and a roundhouse with 6 stalls. If I buy it all new, that's going to be $500.00 at least. I found the turntable used so I'm going to use that extra $150.00 to buy some extra detailing parts for the roundhouse area, but still, that's a lot of money for a corner of a layout. Which means I won't be going to DCC. Thankfully I get many items off the marketplace and a few off eBay. I stopped going to train shows 2 years ago. I remember buying 8 N scale cars with Rapido couplers for $35.00, and when I looked at changing the couplers, well I didn't, I put that money towards a used Challenger with Rapido couplers, so now I'm going to have a long train with all Rapido couplers because I'd rather spend the money first on the layout. The last train show I went to had no good deals. I used to be able to find used H.O. and N scale buildings for $5.00-20.00. Now it's nothing but people reselling the same used buildings they bought a year ago for $10.00, and trying to sell them for a few bucks less than a new kit. I contemplated O gauge, but soon put that away when I saw the cost of O gauge rolling stock, even used.
Car payment? Engines now cost more than that. I get pushback, but DCC is one of the things that has damaged this hobby keeping many away due to the added cost.
I buy mostly used too, there are great new models but since I'm easily pleased in N scale I don't see the need. Been experimenting with DCC though, the cost of a starter set is negligible to the next loco. That's when it starts adding up. Speaking of Rapido, if that''s Arnold, their trackage has a great advantage. Power routing switches can be used to run several locos without the need for extensive wiring or DCC. Got some decent switchers of them too.
@@kevinmacomber1336 I bought a DCC set used and I like the oportunities it provides but to be honest, I couldn't justify it for myself if I bought locos for over 300 bucks. If people save up for a while and buy them, good luck to them but in a way that I can't really begin to describe it feels horribly decadent in this day and age.
Don't forget to add the impact of the exchange rate. My post is below, but now have almost no Canadian customers except the few who have PO boxes here or travel for vacation.@@crataeguscrusgalli
I remember I was a teen when DCC was a new thing... I didn't care about it, and couldn't afford it anyway. Kids need entry level products so they can experiment and even break stuff sometimes. I personally feel like the train store I went to as a kid is a bit sparse now... too much competition from online perhaps, but I think having a good brick and mortar store adds the magic of discovery and chance to the experience.
Well said Dawn, we need to push back against the negativity and promote what can be a truly multi-generational hobby. We agree that good local shows and engaging with the community are a great way to encourage wider participation.
I have experienced that sometimes some of the train modellers don't know how to talk with people that are new to the hobby. When they start to talk they immediatelly go to the very nerdy, very niche, and very detailed technical details of the real locomotives (often not even about the models), that are so overwhelming and so non-understandable to many new people in the hobby, that it makes them feel overwhelmed, and they would turn around and go away because it makes them not comfortable. With the kids nowadays every classical hobby has a huge competition in the phones and computers. It's the incredible interactivity that is making them so attractive. In the past the model trains were one of the most interactive toys the kids could have, and so it was so liked by many. But now the model trains have hard time to compete on the interaction level with the mobile phones or tablets. And sometimes it seems the kids are losing the fantasy, because the games on phones are providing them everything already finished and visualized, so they don't need to turn on their imagination so much as it was with the classical toys. If your kid played with the trains only once, and now it lies in the box, maybe it just didn't discover yet its full potential. Try to pull it out from the box by yourself and play with your kid as a parent. Show the kid what everything it can do with it. Think about a scenario and some goal, some tasks, like: "We need to build a house for the doll, lets bring the bricks to the construction site, and lets use our train for the transportation. We can load it here, and unload it there." Make it a game. Do it several times and show the kid that it's not only about running in a circle. Show them what can be achieved with it with a bit of imagination. With all the interactivity the modern techs bring us nowadays, looking (or running) a train on a circle layout at home may now even feel a bit boring for some young people. The idea of "gamification" is exactly what I too think can make the hobby more appealing to young audience. I saw not long ago a video from Denmark about a public model layout, where they did exactly this - they gamified the layout (ruclips.net/video/4V2QvfNx6f8/видео.html), providing it with an interface that gives you a throttle and a brake handle, gives you a scenario with a goal, and counts you a score (penalization for exceeding speed limit, or running through a red signal, etc). Your input is processed by computer, which simulates a weight of the cargo, an efficiency of train brakes, etc. based on your "player level". After seeing this I was thinking that something like this would be awesome if the train manufacturers would make for their DCC centrals. They already can connect to computer or tablet, so its probably just a matter of software to be made.
Thank you for that excellent video. I am as well as a railway enthusiast, a piano player, and am really pleased to see the increase in pianos being placed in public places for everyone to enjoy and try. Many Video Clips now show people performing for fun, and I can see that this encourages people to learn an instrument. Maybe having Railway layouts in public places would have the same positive effect and encourage people to try modelling their own layouts.
It is questionable whether Railway Modelling is correctly described as a hobby these days - for so many people it is a business! Over the years, the manufacturers have learned to tailor their products to the market which means limited production runs that drive up prices. Hatton's went out of business because what they used to do was buy up surplus inventory and sell it off cheap. Model trains have never been particularly cheap. It is high prices that are driving young people away from modelling. £300 for a loco is just ridiculous! Thanks for uploading.
i agree, if you go to exhibitions there are always kids looking around who would be interested in the hobby if it wasn't so ridiculously expensive. Even the Hornby railroad range which was meant to be a cheap alternative for kids isnt much cheaper than the proper stuff any more and if you want to get into scenery you can easily spend over £100 on products just to get started. even as an adult im scared to experiment with materials because of the cost in case i mess up and waste them.
I was quite big on model railways along time ago when I was a kid, but have recently been interested in how it's going (and how it's managed to survive) by watching RUclips videos and following channels such as Sam's Trains. I think a large factor is that real railways really aren't very interesting any more. Many much-older people remember the days of steam, and that drove the hobby back then and would explain its peak. Having said that, that "peak" is long gone. I also think due to computer games etc. that people's sense of entertainment is a lot more sophisticated now than it was. Just buying a model train set and watching them go round and round gets pretty tiring after about 10 minutes. Making anything more complex needs time, money and above all - passion. I agree with the idea that bringing a "gaming" element into it could spark interest, though I've no idea how. A good gaming app - e.g. build your own "world" - railway and scenery, and associated controls - could attract younger hobbyists. I'm afraid to say though that I think the whole demographic has just changed completely and there are no easy solutions. Ultimately it needs people to be passionate about it again.
Great video Dawn, may I say you're a voice of reason in this debate. Totally agree with the affordability issue and I guess this has come about because we, as modellers, have demanded ever more features and detail in our models and that's not just for locomotives but rolling stock too. Hornby's "Railroad" range has the potential to fill this gap but even this comes at a price. If there's ever been a moment where the hobby needs to take a good look at the direction it's heading then it's definitely now.
At 45, I'm getting back into my N scale a bit after I boxed it all up to raise some kids. What strikes me is that the structures and things haven't changed much since I was a kid! There's a huge offering for transitional stuff so boomers can model a time period that makes them nostalgic; there is some interesting modern stuff coming from the likes of Kato but it's very asia-centric. Shop shelves are all full of the same Walthers Cornerstone and DPM kits that I saw in the 90s. However, with 3D modeling and printing now, I can model an alternate history where the US didn't absolutely forsake rail service and treated everyone with respect, so I don't have to model that gritty looking industrial backlot. You can pull in some really neat models of art deco or modern architecture and make it beautiful instead.
Thanks for this excellent video and greetings from the United States, where I just subscribed to your channel. I'm 69 and had a Lionel train set as a child set up in my bedroom. Having retired to Route 66 in Oklahoma, I've opened a storefront museum where I will shortly be adding a long diorama that incorporates an HO scale American Freedom Train along with an HO scale "small town America / Route 66" display to get visitors interested in both how we celebrated our bicentennial in 1976 and how the values in small towns can help us think about making things better nationwide. I mention this because I think model railroads should have a theme, and I don't just mean a geographical reference point. I think they should tell a story. I've even found an American company that makes two different sizes of Saturn V rockets (at the launch pad ready to take off) that can be used to add a celebration of the space program to a model train layout. When you add water, steam is generated to make it look like the rocket is ready to take off! I wonder if other people ask themselves "What story is my layout trying to tell?" It just might help.
Well said. As a youngster myself (45 ahem) I'm just getting back into model railways. I've bought some bargains on eBay, N gauge, so it can be done cheaper than buying all brand new. I've been building models of all shapes and sizes of all descriptions. Had a layout when I was younger. When I was a teen to mid thirties I kept building the odd model. Trucks mainly. Through those years I was mainly interested in girls, going to the pub and seeing as many gigs as I possibly could. Not to mention two wheels. I'm sure this rings true with many people. Then along comes settling down and having a family. Only now do I have a little time to enjoy any hobby. I have many.
Dawn fantastic video well done everything you said was true, the hobby is not dying and people need to understand that they can build a big or small layout the choice is theirs and it can be whatever they want it to be
One aspect you don’t cover, which as a long term secondary school STEM teacher I have seen steadily increasing over the last 20 years, is that teens no longer want to, or have the basic tool handling skills to, make anything. Nothing. They don’t make anything at school and they don’t make anything at home. They also rarely see anyone make anything in those environments other than, if they’re lucky, grandparents. Developing the temperament, patience, skills and tolerance necessary to build something is a dying art. Folks under 25 no longer want to engage with this vital side of life. Its effects are already rippling through many trades and industries, not just in the construction hobbies and arts.
Look at what kids are making in creative games like minecraft, and you'll see that this is not entirely true. The patience and desire is there, but it's being spent online, not in the real world. Is this better? Probably not. However, I do believe that any statement that contains "the youth..." misses the mark no matter what. Growing up, we were all snotty, disinterested, rude, opinionated, crass, etc. This has never changed. The difference now is how most parents respond to those behaviors. Don't blame the kids for being kids. If you're going to blame anyone, blame the parents for not providing the tools at home to allow their children's interests to flourish into useful skills. Blame society for allowing rampant use of the internet from too young of ages, and blame the older generations for washing their hands of them because "the youth...". Nothing exists in a vacuum, and more often than not, children are a reflection of ourselves. If we don't like that reflection, then maybe some work needs to be done on our part.
I'm also in that area of work, a semi-retired Design and Technology teacher. One thing you mentioned, family members. How many people are now involved in a trade, or any branch of design or engineering, that can influence younger members of their families? My dad trained on radar during the war, and was good at several areas of DIY. I had a Hornby layout as a child, and a superb woodwork teacher at school, and I was later employed as a test engineer and service engineer in an electronics factory before doing a degree in industrial design, on a FULL GRANT...I also remember reading a letter in the Times about a manufacturer who said that he'd never met a politician who understood anything about manufacturing. It's a national problem, we are, as a nation, neglecting the whole business of designing and making things.
This. We farm off manufacturing to elsewhere now. You can buy lots of stuff cheap at the click of a button. The need to make or repair has dwindled. I'm pretty sure kids in those manufacturing countries probably still have a thirst for figuring how things work though.
Thank you for a thoughtful and well presented report. Now retired i recall as a child i had few toys, my parents could not afford the Hornby Range but they did manage to buy the Playcraft sets / range made by Jouef. These were HO and crude by comparison to the British and German made sets of the day but were affordable to expand on pocket money. It was in fact my only toy and responsible for my development understanding electricity, carpentry and system design and control. I went on to study Electrical and Electronic engineering as my career. Kato prove it can be done and Mike from Budget Model Railways regularly shows what can be achieved on a budget. It just takes imagination and time.
I just came across your channel. While I gave up model railroading when I was about ten, I retain an interest in the hobby. The realism of the train movements, compared to the real trains, is what captures my interests.
Hello, Thank you so much for your enthusiasm & energy in your video. Nearer eighty than seventy, I've never as an adult been without a model railway. A child receiving his Hornby Dublo, Christmas 1953, set me for life. Even before my wedding (I'm a widower now) 1968, buying our home, extensive thought was given, so encouraged by Pam. I want to encourage you, because the model industry as indeed the real thing was going through doldrums. The names Triang/Rovex, Trix-Twin, Hornby Dublo, had all disappeared. So I resorted to kit building. Wills, Ks, Romford, whilst Hornby & Wrenn started up, then early seventies the name Palitoy, that became Backmann. We've been here before. I do applaud your encouraging interest & analysis of the current state of affairs. Thank you so much
Excellent video and insights! I’m 40 and have been a fan of model railroading about 3-decades. I went from starter sets to more advanced models. I even built a shelf layout (videos are on my channel). I agree the hobby is changing, not dying, and it will thrive when it’s more open to people of all ages and skill sets. The advanced model railroaders like ourselves need to always nurture and encourage those just starting out.
Wow, very wise observations. Perhaps an annual design competition between railroad clubs to create a game using trains in the smallest scale possible (or practical). That could help inspire the masses. Replace tracks with bendable wire mounted to a game board that could be folded up and put away or reconfigured at any time. You make really useful videos. My kids grew up with Thomas.
My older brother had a small HO layout when I was younger, I 'inherited' it when he left for college. I'm 73 now and after a long time away from the hobby I bought a Woodland Scenics N-scale kit. Had fun building it, but decided to give it to a local club and took a break. My current solution for all of the problems stated in the video is a Bachmann HO DCC starter set and a lot of extra track. I set it up when I want to, use XtrakCAD to design a temporary layout, get it running and then decorate it with mini-scenes, similar to KATO's diorama idea, to add interest. When I don't have it set up, I can still build new mini-scenes for relaxation.
OK wow. This is the most inciteful honest video on the current state of the hobby I have seen. I have an 8 year old two 4 year olds and an 18 month baby. I am looking how to engage them in the hobby and everything you said is spot on. I think 3d printing is one of the answers. I would love to see a range of rtr blank chassis that have axles only. These if designed right could run on traditional wooden railway sets and then convert to oo. You could design and print basic bodies and clip them on. The companies could even do the printing.
Wow Dawn you're definitely an ambassador for this great hobby. Every point you so eloquently covered is one that I'm totally in agreement with you. This hobby is not dead and it's not dying but it is evolving . Bah humbug to the gloom mongers. When I exhibit my layouts at local shows I've found the most commented remark is "I haven't got space"! Understandable when modern housing has gotten smaller inside! My micro layouts change that perception! But the really big plus side that with today's high pressure life style/worries etc hobbies like ours are a good therapeutic way of easing the pressure and tension for all age groups. ( I do hope your monologue is watched by the manufacturers as well.)
This is something I've tried to convey in the hobby, that sometimes to get younger modellers involved is to engage their imaginations. Don't let the rivet counters stop you building that fictional railway be it based on reality or fantasy. I've also had to learn to model on a budget and there are definitely ways to save money through recycling/re-using materials in the scenery aspect like salvaging insulation foam from building skips (with permission from the builders of course!)
I agree with a lot of what Dawn says. My contribution to the hobby this Christmas was to make a baseboard for my Grandsons (4&6) to run their Dad's Thomas set which had sat in the loft for 30 years. I provided a controller, two extra locos I did up for them (by adding faces) and the most precious thing of all; time. Christmas Day was a great success. One of the greatest successes was the inclusion of a Peco level crossing which engendered lots of fun and arguments all with two move able gateshead! The layout has plenty of space to add things, some of which I'll 'find' from stock and, as their Dad is a Lego freak, they've got room to add structures of all kinds. Scale isn't important! Play value is.
I found it interesting to listen to your opinion about the model train hobby. I want to get back into it after leaving it in the late 70's and I've found it to be very expensive. I ordered some items off of eBay which are old and used and will need cleaning and repairs. You're 100% correct about time, space, and expense. I'm not sure where I'll build my layout, the cost is prohibitive which affects the amount of time I can actually run the trains because I'm having to spend time repairing them. You spoke of high tech which I see the hobby has become more high tech with DCC and other things. So the hobby has progressed somewhat since the 70's. Like many teenagers I got out of the hobby because of other interests which seems to happen to most teenagers. Not sure how you could bring "gaming" into the hobby, but for teenagers that would be huge if it was exciting and fun. Thank you for your thoughtful comments.
With the availability of different scales,although space is an issue,I think it’s price which is the biggest factor. I read a review today on a new Hornby loco which cost over £300,the issue is the price never goes down
Went to a local show last year and had similarly exciting thoughts re setting up my own layout. I only really just started in the hobby (and joined the Hattons staff in mid 2023, timing) so it's encouraging to see this take.
Good points well made Dawn. The hobby has evolved over many decades with bouts of “boom” and bouts of “doom” but there will always be a new norm. I think the intervention of some Rock stars, RUclipsrs, new manufacturers and new technologies helps the evolution to a new norm immensely. With regard to pricing, there is an American manufacturer who sells 3 grades of locomotives - “ Museum Quality”, Rivet Counter” and “Operator” which are self explanatory and have prices that are lower for the lower grades of fidelity. Hornby and their competitors might do well to emulate this rather than churn out older models in garish liveries.
I was born into model railways like a religion and enjoyed my childhood growing up with model trains along with my brother and father and many friends we made along the way. Work Girls cars sports families living abroad and other hobbies put pay to my model railway pursuits . Now I have returned from my 30 year sabbatical refreshed . You will be astounded the amount of people who are interested in model railways and many of them are younger than you think. They don't necessarily go in exhibitions or join model railway clubs but they are there . Given there is so many practical skills involved and so much more technology it's time to get universities involved and get students involved and there children's children, this is the way forward. Smaller scales are much better these days N , TT and even Z are making a comeback. With better electronics and ease of fitting into a smaller area .
The best analysis I've heard on the industry for a long time. Thank you for putting this together, your comments on sustainability, tech, gamification, affordability, etc make a lot of sense.
Very detailed and insightful video presentation. Well done and grateful for your contributions to the hobby. I live in the US and have been modeling in 3-rail O gauge for quite some time. Space is always a factor and O gauge certainly adds to the challenge, but I have found contentment in my 8x14 (feet) configuration. Not my dream layout, but it keeps me engaged and always looking to do more. Despite the various limiting factors you mentioned, there is continued strong interest for model trains in the US, particularly in the Northeast. Social media has helped the hobby with how-to videos, private FB groups and Instagram. People want to showcase their collections, projects, and layouts. This has been a huge driver for the hobby. There are a few you-tubers out there that have tremendous subscriber bases. Local train shows are serving larger crowds lately and the local hobby shops are always busy with repairs and taking pre-orders from customers for the latest product releases from the key manufacturers. Some manufactures do not require pre-payment with BTO orders and instead are allowing layaway plans or the option to pay in full once products are received by the retailer. As for developing interest for the younger audience, I think the parent-child connection is the ticket. Children engaging with model trains is directly proportional to the amount of time invested by the parents. I believe this hobby has a lot of runway and opportunity for growth. THNKS again for everything you are doing for the hobby!
Good points well made, and in a positive way, Ms Q. I guess I'm typical of many in the hobby, who left it in my early teens and have now come back to it in my mid/late fifties, but never turned my back on it completely. The danger today is that there are fewer boys and girls getting involved, meaning that in the future there will be no-one of my age with a desire to "re-visit" model railways, as they never "visited" them in the first place. Let's hope people with more vision and ability than I can, as you say, innovate to ignite the spark of interest in the kids of today, so even if they do take a vacation from the hobby in their teens, 20s, 30s & 40s, will feel a strong pull to return as they mature. PS: the point you make regarding 3D printing and other tech is interesting. That could well tempt people in their teens & 20s to give the hobby a try.
It seems during covid the hobby was storming, riding the crest of a wave. Yet now its seemingly slumped the other side, although from what I see as a someone who sells in to the hobby is that the last few years have been steady. I think with many of the points you raise and others in the comments section are very valid, it is now a hobby in change more than decline. It will come out the other side of this negative period with a very different look but it will need inventiveness and bravery to attract different generations from the many clubs and businesses out there.
I have two micro layouts that I take to local exhibitions in Scotland. Last weekend at Irvine we had lots of families with younger children who loved the layout. Also many adults were asking about the size and impresses with the amount of detail on it. The hobby isn’t dead yet. Great video btw.
You are spot on with everything you said. We all struggle with change. Targeting young people and listening to their feedback is crucial. The small community based shows, in my opinion, offer more opportunities to engage with and become part of the model railway communty.
I think the space issue is understated. Sharehouses seem to be requiring everybody live with less and less space while rent continues to skyrocket. Half my friends wouldn’t have space for an N-gauge layout at present, let alone OO. Before I got back into the hobby, I also assumed it was dying literally only because of the progressively smaller shoeboxes we’re being forced to share. :/
I am 72 years old and have been involved in railway modelling for a long time. My interest is based around the 1950s/60s and my memories of railways when I was a youngster. Yes I can just about remember that far back. I was never a "train spotter" but loved seeing the real trains. Perhaps the youngsters of today do not experience real trains in the way that older people did. A trip to the seaside or going on holiday then quite often involved a train journey. Also industries all over the country used the railways so there were lots of trains to see. Myself and my school age friends would quite often watch the coal trains going to and from the local colliery. I don`t have any answers to the lack of interest by youngsters today as we cannot turn back the clock to an age that has gone. I really do hope that people cleverer than me can come up with something. At least we have a clever youngster in Dawn and others doing their best for this wonderful hobby. ❤
terry, I have heard that argument, that trains don't mean as much to the younger generations. The thing is, especially here in the US, there are few people other than people in their 70's and up, who remember passenger train travel. I am 60, and in my generation it was already cars and planes, not trains.Funny thing is, one of the most popular modelling item in the hobby is steam engines, yet again few other than the very older models ever saw them in active use. I think that leaving out teenagers (who always seem to have lost interest in trains!), the answer is having kids and older people having access to model trains. Open houses at clubs, modular layouts at community centers, malls (I know, another dying thing), train shows, are all huge. I was just reading that gen z or whatever they call them, are helping revitalize shopping malls, apparently they are in a sense looking back to when malls were social gathering places (also they like shopping in person). So having a display at a mall may actually work. I think many people have an interest in trains, the Greenberg Toy and train shows often are mobbed.
Sound and sensible analysis Dawn, and well-presented. I think model railway clubs have a huge opportunity (if only they would all accept it) to engage with younger people and promote the hobby - maybe another video on this topic as I know many of them do exactly that. Also, there is clearly a problem to do with the alarming rate of closures of model shops. Perhaps some of those remaining might need to consider changing their ways too, to encourage young and older modellers to develop their skills and interests in the hobby. Thanks for expressing your thoughts so well.
My Mrs and I (62 & 59 respectively)are off to Canterbury model railway show today. I started an N gauge layout last year and we both enjoy the hobby, we sit for hours making metcalffe kits and stuff and find it very relaxing. We only got into the hobby by chance, while I was ferreting about in the loft I rediscovered a Hornby Harry Potter train set we bought for our daughter many years ago so took it down and set it up on the lounge carpet. It didn’t work, so I set about trying to fix it via RUclips vids (thanks 00Bill 👍🏻) it now runs like a burglar but because of lack of space it now sits back in it’s box. Hence why we now fiddle about in N gauge, 4.5 x 2.5 is more suitable for the amount of space we have available. Good vid 👍🏻
No Nonsense - Maybe you should take the OO scale Harry Potter Train Set to a train show and see about working out a trade deal with a seller for N scale items?
As a 40 year old I feel sidelined by the market. I see a lot of effort from traditional manufacturers to bring out some rare long since scrapped kettle. But when it comes to diesels and electrics in particular, I'm left wanting. Accurascale seems to get it. A 92 with working pantograph and all the toys is just for me. To be fair the Bachmann 90 is pretty slick too. But where's the coaches? Having bought Oxford Rail the only Mark 3 and 4 producer is Hornby - and their coaches leave the modeller wanting. I see your point about affordability but I'm not keen on pushing round rolling stock that looks like it was designed in the 1980s. Maybe it's just me but the HST and 91s are very good; they need the rest of the train to match!
Lots of good points raised here Dawn. I am a very young nearly 70 year old. Built first model for my young son and daughter over thirty years ago. Still running and great fun. Last year I got the bug again and built four models. Two in N and two in 00. I am lucky, I have a huge and dry garage where I can model to my hearts content in a safe and warm environment. I am also fortunate enough to have a disposable income that allows me to spend on the hobby whereas others are not so well blessed. However, I make do with items from the bargain box at my local model shop and occasional forays to shows/E-Bay. I have learned lots of artistic and scenic skills of late and much enjoyed making do with the bits and bobs around the house be they cardboard or foam, carpet tiles or other items headed for the bin. I hope my two (soon to be three) young grandsons will in time enjoy the interest too. At the moment their youth makes them clumsy and breakages are costly. They also have lots of competing interests and of course school. The latter always takes priority as you would expect. Both parents work and are therefore not able to invest hours in helping them. I am not local to them so visits are difficult. In summary, lots of barriers and I guess many are in the same boat. Living near to Stamford, we know what some young folk can get up to when they get the opportunity! Modelling takes time, money and patience as well as knowledge. Many youngsters struggle with these attributes. I thought that in the spring I would throw open the garage and have a model day to attract some local interest. But that raises its own issues around security and all the other risks of allowing the public into your personal space. At the end of the day no easy answers but perhaps as others have said, draw folk in through the local shows and clubs, make people feel welcome and involved and show them you need not be rich or a craftsman to get enjoyment and pleasure from the hobby and all the life skills it can teach.
Another excellent (as usual) video Dawn and I agree with all you said. My observations at our local shows, and the club's (Silver Fox) show is the younger generation, particularly those pre-teens, want to see movement and lots of it. The older groups of young adults, and those 'returners' want to know all about DCC, control by WiFi, and often are eager to have a go when this is offered. I have also noticed many with SEN are drawn to movement and are seemingly enthralled by moving trains. I find the cost prohibitive (I'm a pensioner) but would pay for reliable and good quality mechanics and less 'hidden' detail which I cannot see at over 1m distance anyway! I've got 4 UM locos, and 4 Minitrix and all run better than many modern locos at the club, and can pull a lot more as well. Keep on with your quest!
As a visitor from Ireland to warley for the last 10 years its was one of the highlights of the year. Surley this event can be saved.There must be another model club who can step in and save it.
Amazing video and insights! How could I not know your channel until now? Couldn't agree more on all your arguments, especially on tech and pricing. I personally would also consider marketing as a major vital point, especially marketing to younger generations. It's becoming harder to "discover" model trains: train stores are closing, and regular toy stores are not carrying train sets anymore (with rare exceptions in the UK for Hornby, or Märklin's My World quite successful range). At the same time anyway, all physical stores are being replaced by online shopping everywhere, it's a universal trend: soon there will be no way to "stumble upon" model railroading in real life. So we need the brands to be about 10000 times more active online. We need more model railway influencers. We need more sponsored posts. We need more collabs. We need young people, older people, middle aged people, men, women, from all continents and walks of life slowly reminding people that model railways exist, and - as you rightfully say - is a rich hobby. Thanks for the video and the positivity!
This sort of discussion was ongoing during the 1960s. The threat then was Scalextric and now it's probably computer games, or somesuch. It's worth some serious thought, but not panic.
I am making sure to build all of my models to be very " pick up and examine" friendly, by building them from styrene with any fiddly bits be made in brass. It is also to show people that you can scratchbuild models that look just as good as mass market ones for a fraction of the price.
Nice video! It would be great to see what ways the hobby can grow. I just got into the hobby after getting myself a set for my 25th birthday last month. Seeing people have fun with trains on social media got me inspired. People my age threw the word nostalgia around and its true!
Interesting Video, Dawn. Certainly you are right with your main arguments. Luckily it feels very different here at my end in Germany, as a lot of us are active in clubs running huge modular layouts to prototype operation with planned schedule. Have you ever heard about FREMO? This not only solves the space and the affordability problem but also inherits the gaming aspect. For me, model railroading has become a big roleplay game, played with up to 50 players as train crew, station personal, freight dispatchers to model prototype operation. This keeps young and old attracked alike: we are running a station with a team of seven: four adults, two teens and one child. I'd be happy to show you around auch a meeting, get in touch if you are interested.
Not just the young...women too. Been with my partner a couple yrs and we've only just admitted to each other we both love model railways, she loves them....Get more women involved and the entire thing will just become more inclusive all round.
Love it! I have a video on women in railway modelling in the works - watch this space. In the meantime, would your partner like to join my FB group for women in railway modelling? facebook.com/groups/womenrailwaymodellers
What makes you think model railways has not been inclusive? I doubt that women have been deliberately excluded. In the past most women may not have been particularly interested. If more women are interested now that’s great, but please let’s not bring divisive feminist dogma into model railways.
I think there are two types of people in the hobby, neither type appear to me to be sexist. One group is welcoming. However there is a strong crowd that is not. That strong crowd may be the minority but you do remember that minority. My pregnant wife was denied a seat in the cafe at Ally Pally when she asked an group of people if she could take a spare seat at their table. The answer was a one word "no" and no one else joined their group (she had to sit on the floor close to them for half an hour). At the great electric train show show a "no" was also the answer when we asked an elderly guy who had 'elbows out' (ie taking up space for 2) on the railing in front of pete watermans layout if he could make space for our 3 year old to view alongside him who could not see over the heads in front of him. I have a reasonable passion and knowledge for trains and model railways but theres a certain crowd who do look down at you unless you are encyclopedic in your knowledge - one slip up in your facts and you're not a 'proper' enthusiast. Maybe it's because certain people are less comfortable mixing in group/social situations themselves but it does create a first impression to new people to the hobby that I think puts a number of people off. My wife now does not like going to shows, not because she doesn't like trains or models (she not a huge fan of the subject mattet, but she is supportive and open minded), but because the people are rude and look down on her. Again, its probably a minority, but that's what makes all the difference. On the flip side, the are some good eggs and, of particular note, the crew of hornby magazine and accurascale stand out for being super approachable
So glad I saved some of my old stuff from 20-30 years ago for my kids. Lack of space, time, and funds are definitely issues these days. However, I think one of the biggest problems is perfectionism. I see it with many other hobbies too such as Legos, sports, theme parks, etc. Kids need to be 'allowed' to experiment and sometimes break stuff to really get a feel for the hobby, and I think adults who want to relive a perfect version of their childhood hobby can sometimes get in the way of children's enjoyment of the hobby at the entry level. To me, that entry level has to happen, though... that is where the "spark" of imagination is. It doesn't have to be perfect. Model trains can be a breath of fresh air for kids in a world of screens and I think the ability to train young minds to directly manipulate a model can be more rewarding than a virtual model. That said, that 3d printing idea seems like an awesome opportunity for the industry... maybe to help local hobby shops stay afloat. On a practical note... I find that the classic layouts with loops take too much space, is there any chance for more products that can keep keep things more linear (whether reversing polarity at the ends of the line or some other kind of simple control that can be achieved with basic electronics)?
First time I've ever seen your channel, but this is so interesting to me as a business mentor/saint. I've been looking at returning to hobbying (at 62!) and have considered slot racing, 'Airfix' (generically) and...model railways. It's been 40 years at least since I last paid any attention to the model railway world and what I've seen 1. Shocks me and 2. Makes it blindingly obvious why it seems to be in crisis. Where has the middle ground gone? 40 years ago you had players like Lima (now gone I understand?) who made a more affordable product than Hornby/Fleischman etc and it let you build a layout and get a reasonable selection of locos and coaches etc quickly. There seems to be a big dark hole between 'kids toy trains' and highly accurate models (if you've got £300 a pop!). The other is a cultural shift - we are living in smaller homes. 40+ years ago most people I knew lived in 3 bed semis or where working hard to be in one. Now- even at 62 - most people I know live in apartments or smaller homes. The result being LESS SPACE - and like it or not, model railway layouts use space! When you see social media bombarded with reels from Minatur Wonderland etc it makes the viewer feel totally inadequate! Rather than stimulating interest in the hobby, huge layouts like that are actually counter productive. There needs to be MUCH MUCH more emphasis on achievable layouts, along the lines of the 'IKEA shelf layout' idea - which IS achievable if you live in an apartment. As you rightly say Dawn, the industry/hobby is going through change, not facing oblivion. But it needs to take a good long look at itself and realise what the impression being given to someone like me actually is. Make it more obviously accessible in today's world and you WILL have an NEC show again.
As a store owner and modeler I agree about the tech aspect. If you can show the kids and even adults how to run trains via your phone as well as the different ways you can incorporate Arduinos and such into their model it goes a long way. Plus, encouraging wives to enter the hobbies with their spouses. I've seen a huge resurgences in the hobby but mainly because I try and get new people excited about having fun. It is about running trains, not this train doesn't run with this train and such. Those who want to excel will, but to encourage new people and answer their questions. For the longest time many didn't want to share their knowledge or as a few posted you'd walk into a train store or show and couldn't touch anything. Our motto is, For the Love of Trains. Not everyone is a Master Model Railroad, in fact very few are, but they all love to see trains run. So the more companies make it so the system because plug and play with easy, buildings built and detailed for affordable pricing the longer or more likely people will stay in the hobby. As you stated, the hobby demographics are changing, the problem is most stores, haven't changed. Plus, most stores were owned by an older generations just running the stores like a hobby and not a business. There is a fine line and balancing act, but as store owners change hands, and new stores pop up this hobby with thrive. As I said, I've seen a huge increase in those looking to get back into the hobby and enter the hobby for the first time. It is on us in the hobby to encourage anyone who wants to get into this hobby, even if they just want a simple oval on their floor just to enjoy running trains.
You make some very valid points. What I see in the model railway hobby in Britain is an emphasis on construction, which is great, but when it comes to what they do with their beautifully constructed layout when it's finished is ..... well nothing much really. Whenever I ask what they do with it, they say "Oh I just run trains", which means they basically run trains round and round in circles until something falls off, or they nod off :) In America I think the emphasis is on operations. Americans tend to have big basements, and have more scope for operations, but operations can also be achieved with small layouts. I do see many British layouts that model a need, an industry, and they operate it like a working railway (except leaving out the big time gaps between trains like on the real thing), but I think mainly, especially when trying to encourage younger members, there is no thought about operations. For instance, my dream would be to create an exhibition layout that would allow visitors, young and old, to drive it ... BUT ..... drive it with a purpose. I would set them shunting puzzles. I would present them with a train of wagons that are a mix of coal, tankers, whatever and I would say "We need to make up a train of just those coal wagons. How do you reckon we could extract just those wagons out of that mix and make up a train of just the coal wagons? Without using your hands of course", and I would let them drive the loco.
My four sons all had a part in the building of our fairly large model railroad. My grandchildren also run trains now. We have a fleet of roughly 160 steam and diesel locomotives with a price range of $50 to $1,000. They know the simple rules, don’t handle the locomotives and cars unless they’re derailed, and don’t run them like a race car. Working on big scenery projects helps to keep the grandchildren involved. We work together on most of it.
How about this for an idea - a manufacturer ( let’s say Hornby ) makes one or two simple, generic chassis with easy to use mounting points for a body - then they have a few downloadable files for people ( youngsters? ) to 3D print their own body , at home , at school or at the local club where they could use their 3D printer. Make the files editable ( open source ) so you could make your own unique version and paint it in your own paint scheme etc. Have a free to join club where every month you could get a free download for a body , a wagon body to fit a generic wagon chassis or a simple building , people , even trees ? Competitions on the ‘club’ website for best creation this month etc. etc. This is of course a new twist on an old idea - there must have been countless white metal kits that went on an oem chassis way back when. I am most certainly not the target age group but it sounds so much fun I would have a go myself.
Some good points were raised there, Dawn. Cost is becoming more of a factor, and also I think that some youngsters can be put off by the attitude of some older modellers as well. They should be encouraged to have a go no matter what they start off with, make it fun and interesting. Some will move on to other interests as with any other hobby. But some will stay and become the future of the hobby. They may prefer the modelling side of thing's, building house's, trees, walls, and other scenery. After all, there's plenty that do fantastic job's of building and creating landscapes, building spaceships, and painting figures for warhammer and others. It's a transferable skill, and once involved, they might learn other skills, soldering, electrics, track laying and maybe running trains. Whatever let it be fun.......cheers James 🙂👍
Just read your comment with interest especially with young people. Though not relating to MR This attitude happened to my granddaughter who was taking rock and roll lessons So I decided to take her to the local rock and roll disco night. They were all from the 50 and 60 era two weeks later told that she was not welcome due to being under 18 Well she was only 9 at the time. My thoughts were just how long will this club survive. Anyway have a nice day. Regards Martin
@martinrowlands3622 Hi Martin, I agree with you there. How do they expect clubs to keep going if they alienate the youngsters who are possibly the next generation to keep whatever the hobby is going . I'm recently new to model railway's and my grandson is very interested at the moment, he's 12, and I've taken him to exhibitions and model shops. He's about to start building a 009 layout and has started his own RUclips channel Dylington Model Railway, which I hope encourages him to keep going with the modelling. He operates the trains and films all of his videos, edits them, and then adds them to RUclips. Have a look, I don't think he's doing a bad job with them. This brings me back to the start, due to his age and not wanting any silly comments from the type of people we've mentioned, we've turned off the comments for his protection. That's with the exception of the Christmas video, if you decide to have a look, let me know on here or the Christmas video what you think......cheers James 🙂👍
@DYLINGTONMODELRAILWAY Congratulations to your grandson for taking up such a wonderful hobby. Yes, there are stupid people writing messages on all aspects relating to one interest or hobbies. I only commented as I felt it was a relivent comment on age and young people and relating to the death of such groups. I can only admire people who invest their time in being creative, whether modelling. Ballet/dance, playing a musical instrument, etc. I hope that your grandson can inspire some of his school friends take care Regards Martin
@martinrowlands3622 Thank you, Martin, for your comments and response, I will always endeavour to encourage not just youngsters but anyone who is having a go at something, whatever their interest is. Especially if it keeps the youngsters of off the streets. Take care, James 🙂👍
A very interesting video, with relevance to other hobbies too, including the focus on the role of tech and gaming. I often hear similar issues raised among historical wargamers. As a teenager, I turned away from railways towards military modelling and gaming because of the lack of narrative once a layout was complete. I don’t know how common this is, but the popularity of fantasy gaming suggests that many teenagers are interested in miniatures if they can use their imaginations and do something with them, once they’re complete. At the younger end of the ‘market’, as you mention, is the huge popularity of Thomas, which is partly due to the story and presentation of engines etc as characters but that doesn’t seem able to transfer to the ‘grown-up’ version of the hobby in any way. I wouldn’t argue for all engines to have faces, though machine qualities interest many people as do the lives of inventors and developers but perhaps they’re not represented much in the hobby. On the price issue, it might be useful to compare railways with radio-controlled vehicles or aircraft, where the level of tech is similar, but the sense of control over the machine is greater. Who knows, that might also be an obstacle to attracting younger people as well. The strengths of model railways for me, as an outsider, are the modelling skills and terrain that I often see featured in Utube videos. But Chandwell is the only one I’ve found so far that also incorporates humour and narrative, with characters and history regularly emerging from the developing layout. I’ve also noticed the Luton club depiction of the Great Train Robbery has attracted a lot of attention. Perhaps there’s something from history to be gleaned from that. As for the media, it always seems to be an easy story for lazy journalists to say this or that activity is dying but books, vinyl records and even cassettes are making a comeback so I'm sure our hobbies will also continue to thrive.
Good morning. I've heard what you say about model railways for a long time (I'm 50). That said, I also practice radio experimentation (amateur radio, duly licensed). And, in this hobby, the observation is the same, although with a very different situation. the price is no longer a problem, we find very valid products for beginners (thank you, Asian manufacturing!). a transceiver is not very bulky, a vertical antenna is easily mounted. space is therefore not an issue. the radio license is easily obtained (no more need for Morse code), and actual devices do not require any technical skills (apart from tuning the antenna). In addition, we can find high-performance measuring devices at a ridiculous price, unimaginable only 15 years ago! and yet, we too, we are getting older, among us too, few young people are interested, despite super fun creations which combine radio and computers. where are the young people? in front of their consoles? becoming an Instagram star? Maybe, we should call the flute player of hamelin to get them out...
Great article. I’ve been banging on about the change that’s now here for many years. Everything changes over time. So let’s not be down beat. Grab the nettle firmly and fight back. I’m hoping to get the local schools involved via the STEM system because as you say, this hobby involves Design, Engineering, etc. etc. More and more it’s programming. Thus utilising Arduino or Pye, like a worm we’ve got youngsters hooked.
You can do a lot with arduino and raspberry pie that I think younger people would eat up, you can automate animations, do all kind of cool things. I was at a train show where they were demonstrating things they did with an arduino circuit board that was impressive and young kids in the area seemed really impressed.
When I was a young person, I would probably have given up if it wasn't for my local shop having an area with second hand structures, track, locomotives and rolling stock. Plaster of Paris was my affordable option for scenery
I think that 3D printing and getting 3D files to make the geografi with houses and different terrains is a thing that can be a great thing to keep it alive.
Hornby got it right to a point with the railroad range if you're not bothered about detail , Rails of Sheffield have announced a cl 60 for a price of £194 and £294 dcc , very nice too but pricing wow . In your vid you came up with some really valid points,
Hi great video, i agree with a lot of what you have said especially about the cost. I have 2 boys of 10 & 13, the eldest has always been into trains and got his first set anout 3 years ago. I decided to get a train for myself to join in with him. We now have a combined collection of around 40+ locos and various rolling stock. 95% of this is used because of the cost of even the most basic models is out of our reach.
Continuing from my previous comment, 1 reason for purchasing mostly used locos and rolling stock apart from the cost of new is to learn from trying to make what we have bought run better and to learn about how they work, teaching ourselves along the way with watching videos to aid out knowledge.
Nice to hear someone with a rational outlook. I think affordability is becoming more of an issue at present. Limiting younger and mature people equally. The model railway clubs are definitely a good way of introducing people into the hobby. But at the same time I think there is still a gap in-between the two. There needs to be something that piques the curiosity in the first place and gets people of any age to look for an inroad into the hobby.
Thank you for posting this informative video. The main issue is that of affordability the prices have risen beyond the reach of the average model railroader.
Amazing! I think you were saying something? Something about model railroading. I kept getting lost. There was this absolutely beautiful lady with long sculptured fingers, no rings. I'm sorry I was so lost in her. Oh! Im sorry were you saying something❤
Cost is the major factor, it’s not just the cost of locos and rolling stock, it’s the cost of materials to build the baseboard. Then it’s the space, modern houses are smaller, and the roof space is not very usable with how they are constructed.
I don't know where the negativity comes from. I belong to several clubs, that continue to have new members joining up. I also run a craftsman kit business, and I can't keep up with demand, which shows the hobby is alive and well. Keep the positivity message going!
We started a modular model RR club here in Kalispell Montana and meet once a month in a local mall... Yes, in a public space where the public can actually see a model railroad! We have several younger members and find interested parties all the time. Why? because we are not hiding the hobby in a remote basement. A 2ft x 4ft or 2ft by 6ft module doesn't take a lifetime to get up and running and you can easily store it in a closet...Modules are built light weight so they can be carried by one person. It's time for model railroaders to take a fresh view, socialize, and get out of the basement. Vance
Now that all of my 6 kids are grown, and 3 are producing grandbabies for me, I have just one 18 year old at home. He likes gaming, but we don't have video games at home. I can finally afford to accumulate components for a model railroad. I had to build a room in my garage for it. I have a strategy to involve my son. He is interested in miniature tank war-gaming, and so I intend to let him use my railroad landscape when we play these dice-rolling games. I'll be teaching him to build trees and buildings that we can use for cover in our battles. He'll grow out of the tank games as he gets busier being an adult, and the grandkids will be next. That is how I'm involving the youth in the hobby by adapting to their gaming interests.
I initially started about 10 years ago (give or take) with my first Bachmann HO scale train set, the Chattanooga. (with the 0-6-0 steam loco). I had fun for a little bit but with being in school, having therapy after school, I hardly had time... nor the money. During that short time when I was first interested, I did manage to buy an old Lifelike Amtrak F40PH for 19 dollars and that was it... It wasn't until summer of 2022 when I was organizing downstairs, I stumbled upon my set. I set it up; ran my old 0-6-0 and my F40ph, then it hit me... I have money now... So then began the revival. Currently I have over 40 locomotives, 50+ pieces of rolling stock, and an assortment of passenger cars from different railways across the USA. From the Denver & Rio Grande to the Chicago Northwestern (CNW is my fav). I also joined my local club and there are a few young adults like me. I hope to see many years in this hobby and maybe if I have kids, I can pass the torch on.
My club has a layout we take to shows (including Warley) for us to enjoy running and showing off our live steam narrow gauge trains. However when we get our battery powered Thomas and Percy stuff on the track pretty quickly every youngster at the show turns up. Model trains are, and need to be, fun.
Thank you for this video. It is astonishing to think of how much could help to revive this hobby. There is no single solution but this can all help. Speaking as someone in their late 20's, I used to be into railway modelling. But back in my teens I stopped with the hobby. Not so much lack of interest, but just the lack of space. It did not help that I have other hobbies that demanded much space (Lego I am afraid-a similar kind of hobby as it requires imagination). But I have started to get back into the hobby. It has been a blessing to get back into it. I found the ideal scale for now-009 of all things-but I can create a nice layout in a small space with it. And at my preferred scale of 1:76 (I always loved OO but N was tempting me for space. 009 is the best of both worlds).
Thank you for providing such a balanced take on the situation. It seems every news article is sensationalised nowadays, a situation is unprecedented and it seems it has to be negative news. No wonder everyone I know tries to limit their exposure to news reporting and watch silly cat videos instead. Ian
I agree with Dawn the clubs ,and others need to think differently. I live in Calgary, Alberta Canada. 25 years ago the 5 main clubs decided to pool their resources and with over 100 non club (people who model by themselves) members created a new group to put on a train show. 25 years later this show fills an area about the size of 5 indoor soccer fields, 60,000 sq ft or around 6,000sq meters. Last year 11,500 people attended of which 4,500 were younger than 16. Every type of layout is welcome from expert to novice. Within a 2 hour drive you would only find 2million people so not a huge catchment area. One of the main problems is the car park being full and people not being able to find a parking spot. This is all possible because it is not the same people having to organize year after year.
Good morning. I've just watched your video very well argued and interesting. I try to use my local model shop, Tennants Trains, in Halesowen. Also, Hattons sadly lost. Even basic train sets are expensive things need to be put in place to attract youngsters of all ages. Best regards Mark vickery
A great presentation of a great hobby, I am not into trains etc, but am an avid Rc plane flyer, a sport and hobby i love, yet at 63 yr young ! i am one of the youngest in our club, and despite adverts, etc we just can not get new blood into our great (weather dependent) hobby, youngsters can do all this stuff on there phones, and in my case crash, and fly again in a click, so why invest time, and money as you say, in real stuff/toys, and for clarity, i have four grand kids, ranging from 9-23 yet NONE of them are even slightly interested in RC planes, its sad, that these fantastic hobbies and pastimes, are dwindling
To be honest, many teenagers aren't terribly interested in any hobbies, outside sport, because of all the other things going on in their lives. I can (just) remember my teens (1980s), and I had hobbies (modelmaking and model railways) but I hardly spent any time or money on them, with friends, Cadets, school etc. taking priority. But I came back to hobbies when I 'needed' them.
My dad made this honest comment some years ago - "Young people have the time and space, and the eyesight and motor skills to do modelmaking - but not the money; Young adults have the money but not the time or space; middle aged folk are losing their eyesight and dexterity, are too busy, but have the money and space, and by the time you're retired, you can't see, your hands have seized up, but you have all the time, money and space you need!" I think you're bang on - it's changing - not dying.
so true
I have to agree with many of your points. One thing you mentioned briefly, the closing of train stores. Here in Montreal we are down to one from at least 8 in the past. Now I and many other local hobbyists are forced to shop online. I miss the personal connection from visiting my local hobbystore. The chance to engage with other modellers.😢
Young kiddies are more interested in the mobile phones. Shame.
While you are 100% true in many of your points and especially the fact that many teenagers aren't terribly interested in this hobby, I am one of the few odd ones out, I became active in my local club at the age of 16 (currently 18 now), and while price is 100% an important factor, I think the biggest problem is how overwhelming it is to start out from square one and that's why I think joining a local club has a big advantage, when I started out there, I had so many questions because I was really starting at square one and I felt overwhelmed, but because I was a part of the local club I could get a lot of answers and help on even the most basic things, best example I have was how to install 8 pin decoders in a non-DCC ready locomotive, I asked one of the older members and he gave me a good two hour lesson about it, with us doing installations together and just because of that, I now know how to do that without any problems.
My take on modelling hobbies in general is this
Many people make models as young kids but then lose interest in these type of hobbies. However many return to such hobbies later in their 30s or 40s. I think this is a fairly common pattern
I am a US model railway fan but married to a Brit. On trips over to the UK, I was struck by how popular the hobby is and how many magazines there are dedicated to the hobby! Thanks for the encouraging video. So many are touting the demise of the hobby.
Quite a buzz going on about that.
There surely is no lack of interest in the UK, i can just for hours watching videos of their shows.
At last! A positive attitude for once. Thank you Dawn for giving us the will to carry on. Well done👍
Thanks Steve - will see you at Canterbury tomorrow.
@@modelrailwayquest Looking forward to it👍🚂🚂
Agreed👍
When kids come in an exhibition, most modelers prevent them from coming close to the layout... I even saw people placing plexiglass or a kind of fence preventing them to come close to the diorama / layout. And most times, we stand behind the layout so we don't engage with the kids or the parents. We created a Timesaver on an ironing table with tons of animations. A sawmill with sound and trunks moving, a crane, a welder, a guy with a chainsaw, a fire and smoke in a chimney, a painter... a miniature film crew... and a hidden camera that shows video on a PC screen above the layout. "the smallest camera in the world" We stand in front of the layout. To the very small kids, I tell them I have problems with my finger, I need help to push on buttons. They stand on a chair, I select animations and they push on the "little green knob" to trigger the animations. Stars in their eyes as the miniature show unfolds triggered by their finger. For older kids, I hold the throttle with them, I handle the switches and decouplers and I ask them to move cars around. And for even older ones I explain, help and they do the whole switching alone. When there is a family with several kids, I have the small ones busy with the little green knob that triggers the animations, the others on the switches... and the parents play as well to give advice on the next moves... There are stars in everyone's eyes. 8 years this layout exists, we never ever had anyone break anything. Even if they would, we would repair... that was the deal. Sit in front of your layouts, engage with people, especially kids, propose them to drive trains. Not necessarily the super expensive locomotives. You will see...
That is brilliant, Alfred, and thank you for doing that ! I am involved in three rail O, and to hear the grumbling old fools who do things like modular layouts at shows, you would think that kids were the visigoths and huns come to sack rome (kind of ironic as something that started as kids toys). I go to train shows, and I see what you mention, not interacting with people, staying aloof, instead of interacting with people..and when they do, the (almost always) male members if they talk to people, tend to talk to men, not women. Kids and women are an untapped source of people into the hobby, and yeah, there are some women who think it is weird, but I know a lot who might be interested, who think it is fun.
I think more celebrities that have train layouts should share more and talk more about them. There are more than we know who have train sets running in their homes! If kids see that, they might be drawn more to it. The costs are another problem and when someone passes, they usually auction it off and the people with money, who already have layouts usually buy it all up for outrageous prices!
Too bad kids don't have clubs anymore where they could share costs and have a layout at a youth center, museum or garage somewhere.
@@MartinKnifechief
That is where train clubs come in. I have seen some where the kids have their own , relatively smaller layout, that they can work on and operate while of course having access to the big one. Here in the US there are groups like 4H that have train clubs for kids but it is rare.
One of the problems is that the hobby doesn't do much to promote itself. You see ads by manufacturers in model magazines , but you don't see ads in places that might reach younger ppl.
Not a marketing type, but they need to figure out where it would be visible.
The attitude is kind of like 'if you build it they will come', but that doesn't work. Focus on parents of kids, have ads promoting the hobby and how it can have all kinds of learning with it, including electronics.
One of the bigger mistakes I have seen? Using Facebook. It just isn't where young ppl are. Might be better on tik Tok or wherever else young ppl are.
If you do train shows, have interest for young kids. At the three rail shows they have train races that kids seem to love. Having live animations that start by pressing a button, activates sound, starts a trolley line, it all gets the kids involved. A small layout where kids can take turns controlling trains would be great ( hint, limit the max speed of the engines).
There are train clubs in America, one is the Toy Train Operating Society, and the Train Collector's Association, Standard Gauge Module Association, Detroit 3 Railers Club. The problem is letting kids be kids, and attempt to play with the trains. Worse case scenario, a throttle control tests how a brand new lionel can punch through a sheetrock wall to add a new addition for $1,500 . . . which should be considered a bargain compared to paying a contractor to do the work! @@MartinKnifechief
I agree. It's about interacting and letting the kids be directly involved. I went to the Denver train show last year and I saw so many interactive layouts where they taught the kids and let them run the trains. In fact, I saw many teenagers running trains, no supervision.
I'm a member of Glasgow and the West of Scotland Model Railway Club , this time last year we had about 15 members in a very small clubhouse , we took the plunge and moved to bigger premises which enabled us to have multiple show layouts on show and our membership has more than doubled including some younger members . You are %100 correct that there is a still a thriving hobby out there and it was good to hear (and see) your video confirming that fact 👍
Hi Gerry - well done to you and your club members! That's great to hear. Could you send me some photos or may I take them from your website as it would be great to share your club news on my livestream this evening - the Wednesday Express (Not Stopping at Peterborough). We've visited a lot of model railway clubs over the past year - and what I've noticed is that clubs who do make the leap to have larger premises with layouts out and operating do find it easier to grow their membership. As you say, it's about having the confidence to take the plunge - but of course, finances are also a key consideration!
Here's the link for tonight's livestream: ruclips.net/user/liveWzsqKLqhlpg?si=_gS-uQoj9hzE9nuq
All the best, Dawn
Interesting video Dawn. I would argue that it’s not only the price, but also the stigma around railways as a hobby. I know plenty of teens who model, but are embarrassed going ‘public’ in school.
If you could change that stigma, then you’d see a change
I agree - that's my question. How do we make the model railway hobby "cool" - I think the answer lies beyond traditional model railway layouts, and is a hybrid of tech, video gaming, social media and smart phones. The industry needs bosses with teens/younger children... and we're probably starting to see that happen.
I play with toy soldiers so I feel your pain :) Luckily I run a Geek club in my primary school, but i really do get where you are coming from.
@@modelrailwayquest I work in a high school, and I’ve found talking confidently to the pupils about my hobby has really helped, even to the point of one boy getting a second hand layout for Christmas! It’s great, but we’re talking small scale I guess
@@stephenrenwick8781 that’s great, do you have a name for the club?
I love that! If we're nervous about talking about our hobby because we're worried we'll look like geeks, what message are we sending out to young people! Love your attitude!
My son is 13 and is a passionate modeller. Yes, it takes time to save enough money for purchases, but it's so worth it. His secondary school also runs a lunchtime model railway club which is fantastic and well attended. Through modelling he has learnt patience, the importance of research, creative skills, design etc and by visiting exhibitions he has gained in confidence. Fantastic hobby, just costly.
As an American who stepped back from the hobby, and I am just starting to return it seems to me that the prices have risen dramatically. There used to be an entire midlevel in the hobby, where you could spend some money but not a car payment every month. Yes, I am over 58, but I can still remember going to the local model railroad store and they had a wall of Athearn blue box kits for between $5.00 and $9.00. One Friday evening I bought 6 kits and spent the next day assembling them adding the right weights, replacing the couplers and wheels on some of them and then the next day I took them over to the layout a friend of mine and I shared and we had 6 new cars to put on the roster. This led us to lengthen a few yard tracks. The total of my purchase wasn't more than $70.00 and that's because I had to buy some weathering powders and pastels also. Now I look at an N scale car and it's $30.00. I'm presently assembling everything I need to build a layout and want a 130' turntable and a roundhouse with 6 stalls. If I buy it all new, that's going to be $500.00 at least. I found the turntable used so I'm going to use that extra $150.00 to buy some extra detailing parts for the roundhouse area, but still, that's a lot of money for a corner of a layout. Which means I won't be going to DCC. Thankfully I get many items off the marketplace and a few off eBay.
I stopped going to train shows 2 years ago. I remember buying 8 N scale cars with Rapido couplers for $35.00, and when I looked at changing the couplers, well I didn't, I put that money towards a used Challenger with Rapido couplers, so now I'm going to have a long train with all Rapido couplers because I'd rather spend the money first on the layout. The last train show I went to had no good deals. I used to be able to find used H.O. and N scale buildings for $5.00-20.00.
Now it's nothing but people reselling the same used buildings they bought a year ago for $10.00, and trying to sell them for a few bucks less than a new kit. I contemplated O gauge, but soon put that away when I saw the cost of O gauge rolling stock, even used.
Car payment? Engines now cost more than that. I get pushback, but DCC is one of the things that has damaged this hobby keeping many away due to the added cost.
I buy mostly used too, there are great new models but since I'm easily pleased in N scale I don't see the need.
Been experimenting with DCC though, the cost of a starter set is negligible to the next loco.
That's when it starts adding up.
Speaking of Rapido, if that''s Arnold, their trackage has a great advantage.
Power routing switches can be used to run several locos without the need for extensive wiring or DCC.
Got some decent switchers of them too.
@@kevinmacomber1336 I bought a DCC set used and I like the oportunities it provides but to be honest, I couldn't justify it for myself if I bought locos for over 300 bucks.
If people save up for a while and buy them, good luck to them but in a way that I can't really begin to describe it feels horribly decadent in this day and age.
Don't forget to add the impact of the exchange rate. My post is below, but now have almost no Canadian customers except the few who have PO boxes here or travel for vacation.@@crataeguscrusgalli
I remember I was a teen when DCC was a new thing... I didn't care about it, and couldn't afford it anyway. Kids need entry level products so they can experiment and even break stuff sometimes. I personally feel like the train store I went to as a kid is a bit sparse now... too much competition from online perhaps, but I think having a good brick and mortar store adds the magic of discovery and chance to the experience.
Well said Dawn, we need to push back against the negativity and promote what can be a truly multi-generational hobby. We agree that good local shows and engaging with the community are a great way to encourage wider participation.
I have experienced that sometimes some of the train modellers don't know how to talk with people that are new to the hobby. When they start to talk they immediatelly go to the very nerdy, very niche, and very detailed technical details of the real locomotives (often not even about the models), that are so overwhelming and so non-understandable to many new people in the hobby, that it makes them feel overwhelmed, and they would turn around and go away because it makes them not comfortable.
With the kids nowadays every classical hobby has a huge competition in the phones and computers. It's the incredible interactivity that is making them so attractive. In the past the model trains were one of the most interactive toys the kids could have, and so it was so liked by many. But now the model trains have hard time to compete on the interaction level with the mobile phones or tablets. And sometimes it seems the kids are losing the fantasy, because the games on phones are providing them everything already finished and visualized, so they don't need to turn on their imagination so much as it was with the classical toys.
If your kid played with the trains only once, and now it lies in the box, maybe it just didn't discover yet its full potential. Try to pull it out from the box by yourself and play with your kid as a parent. Show the kid what everything it can do with it. Think about a scenario and some goal, some tasks, like: "We need to build a house for the doll, lets bring the bricks to the construction site, and lets use our train for the transportation. We can load it here, and unload it there." Make it a game. Do it several times and show the kid that it's not only about running in a circle. Show them what can be achieved with it with a bit of imagination.
With all the interactivity the modern techs bring us nowadays, looking (or running) a train on a circle layout at home may now even feel a bit boring for some young people. The idea of "gamification" is exactly what I too think can make the hobby more appealing to young audience. I saw not long ago a video from Denmark about a public model layout, where they did exactly this - they gamified the layout (ruclips.net/video/4V2QvfNx6f8/видео.html), providing it with an interface that gives you a throttle and a brake handle, gives you a scenario with a goal, and counts you a score (penalization for exceeding speed limit, or running through a red signal, etc). Your input is processed by computer, which simulates a weight of the cargo, an efficiency of train brakes, etc. based on your "player level".
After seeing this I was thinking that something like this would be awesome if the train manufacturers would make for their DCC centrals. They already can connect to computer or tablet, so its probably just a matter of software to be made.
Thank you for that excellent video. I am as well as a railway enthusiast, a piano player, and am really pleased to see the increase in pianos being placed in public places for everyone to enjoy and try. Many Video Clips now show people performing for fun, and I can see that this encourages people to learn an instrument. Maybe having Railway layouts in public places would have the same positive effect and encourage people to try modelling their own layouts.
Hi Dawn, we have just had our two day show in Bognor Regis.
We are pleased to say that we had record attendance with an increase of 40%.
That is fantastic news! Good for you - lots of hard work on your part! Hope to come along next year.
it needs....
more atypical folk like you! wonderfully positive, fresh and fluent.
It is questionable whether Railway Modelling is correctly described as a hobby these days - for so many people it is a business! Over the years, the manufacturers have learned to tailor their products to the market which means limited production runs that drive up prices. Hatton's went out of business because what they used to do was buy up surplus inventory and sell it off cheap. Model trains have never been particularly cheap. It is high prices that are driving young people away from modelling. £300 for a loco is just ridiculous! Thanks for uploading.
i agree, if you go to exhibitions there are always kids looking around who would be interested in the hobby if it wasn't so ridiculously expensive. Even the Hornby railroad range which was meant to be a cheap alternative for kids isnt much cheaper than the proper stuff any more and if you want to get into scenery you can easily spend over £100 on products just to get started. even as an adult im scared to experiment with materials because of the cost in case i mess up and waste them.
attitude doesnt help when people try to start up and get ridiculed for there efforts
L300 is a deal. In the US you can double that on key engines. It's cooked.
In my humble opinion, your best video to date, not knocking the previous BTW. A very realistic view of the issues.
Thanks.
I was quite big on model railways along time ago when I was a kid, but have recently been interested in how it's going (and how it's managed to survive) by watching RUclips videos and following channels such as Sam's Trains. I think a large factor is that real railways really aren't very interesting any more. Many much-older people remember the days of steam, and that drove the hobby back then and would explain its peak. Having said that, that "peak" is long gone. I also think due to computer games etc. that people's sense of entertainment is a lot more sophisticated now than it was. Just buying a model train set and watching them go round and round gets pretty tiring after about 10 minutes. Making anything more complex needs time, money and above all - passion. I agree with the idea that bringing a "gaming" element into it could spark interest, though I've no idea how. A good gaming app - e.g. build your own "world" - railway and scenery, and associated controls - could attract younger hobbyists. I'm afraid to say though that I think the whole demographic has just changed completely and there are no easy solutions. Ultimately it needs people to be passionate about it again.
I’ve been in the hobby for 35 years and it’s been dying for every one of those years.
Amen!
It’s too expensive….
Great video Dawn, may I say you're a voice of reason in this debate. Totally agree with the affordability issue and I guess this has come about because we, as modellers, have demanded ever more features and detail in our models and that's not just for locomotives but rolling stock too. Hornby's "Railroad" range has the potential to fill this gap but even this comes at a price. If there's ever been a moment where the hobby needs to take a good look at the direction it's heading then it's definitely now.
At 45, I'm getting back into my N scale a bit after I boxed it all up to raise some kids. What strikes me is that the structures and things haven't changed much since I was a kid! There's a huge offering for transitional stuff so boomers can model a time period that makes them nostalgic; there is some interesting modern stuff coming from the likes of Kato but it's very asia-centric. Shop shelves are all full of the same Walthers Cornerstone and DPM kits that I saw in the 90s. However, with 3D modeling and printing now, I can model an alternate history where the US didn't absolutely forsake rail service and treated everyone with respect, so I don't have to model that gritty looking industrial backlot. You can pull in some really neat models of art deco or modern architecture and make it beautiful instead.
Thanks for this excellent video and greetings from the United States, where I just subscribed to your channel. I'm 69 and had a Lionel train set as a child set up in my bedroom. Having retired to Route 66 in Oklahoma, I've opened a storefront museum where I will shortly be adding a long diorama that incorporates an HO scale American Freedom Train along with an HO scale "small town America / Route 66" display to get visitors interested in both how we celebrated our bicentennial in 1976 and how the values in small towns can help us think about making things better nationwide.
I mention this because I think model railroads should have a theme, and I don't just mean a geographical reference point. I think they should tell a story. I've even found an American company that makes two different sizes of Saturn V rockets (at the launch pad ready to take off) that can be used to add a celebration of the space program to a model train layout. When you add water, steam is generated to make it look like the rocket is ready to take off!
I wonder if other people ask themselves "What story is my layout trying to tell?" It just might help.
Well said. As a youngster myself (45 ahem) I'm just getting back into model railways. I've bought some bargains on eBay, N gauge, so it can be done cheaper than buying all brand new. I've been building models of all shapes and sizes of all descriptions. Had a layout when I was younger. When I was a teen to mid thirties I kept building the odd model. Trucks mainly. Through those years I was mainly interested in girls, going to the pub and seeing as many gigs as I possibly could. Not to mention two wheels. I'm sure this rings true with many people. Then along comes settling down and having a family. Only now do I have a little time to enjoy any hobby. I have many.
Dawn fantastic video well done everything you said was true, the hobby is not dying and people need to understand that they can build a big or small layout the choice is theirs and it can be whatever they want it to be
One aspect you don’t cover, which as a long term secondary school STEM teacher I have seen steadily increasing over the last 20 years, is that teens no longer want to, or have the basic tool handling skills to, make anything. Nothing. They don’t make anything at school and they don’t make anything at home. They also rarely see anyone make anything in those environments other than, if they’re lucky, grandparents. Developing the temperament, patience, skills and tolerance necessary to build something is a dying art. Folks under 25 no longer want to engage with this vital side of life. Its effects are already rippling through many trades and industries, not just in the construction hobbies and arts.
Spot on.
Look at what kids are making in creative games like minecraft, and you'll see that this is not entirely true. The patience and desire is there, but it's being spent online, not in the real world. Is this better? Probably not.
However, I do believe that any statement that contains "the youth..." misses the mark no matter what. Growing up, we were all snotty, disinterested, rude, opinionated, crass, etc. This has never changed. The difference now is how most parents respond to those behaviors.
Don't blame the kids for being kids. If you're going to blame anyone, blame the parents for not providing the tools at home to allow their children's interests to flourish into useful skills. Blame society for allowing rampant use of the internet from too young of ages, and blame the older generations for washing their hands of them because "the youth...".
Nothing exists in a vacuum, and more often than not, children are a reflection of ourselves. If we don't like that reflection, then maybe some work needs to be done on our part.
I'm also in that area of work, a semi-retired Design and Technology teacher. One thing you mentioned, family members. How many people are now involved in a trade, or any branch of design or engineering, that can influence younger members of their families? My dad trained on radar during the war, and was good at several areas of DIY. I had a Hornby layout as a child, and a superb woodwork teacher at school, and I was later employed as a test engineer and service engineer in an electronics factory before doing a degree in industrial design, on a FULL GRANT...I also remember reading a letter in the Times about a manufacturer who said that he'd never met a politician who understood anything about manufacturing. It's a national problem, we are, as a nation, neglecting the whole business of designing and making things.
This. We farm off manufacturing to elsewhere now. You can buy lots of stuff cheap at the click of a button. The need to make or repair has dwindled. I'm pretty sure kids in those manufacturing countries probably still have a thirst for figuring how things work though.
Great observation my friend 👍
Thank you for a thoughtful and well presented report. Now retired i recall as a child i had few toys, my parents could not afford the Hornby Range but they did manage to buy the Playcraft sets / range made by Jouef. These were HO and crude by comparison to the British and German made sets of the day but were affordable to expand on pocket money. It was in fact my only toy and responsible for my development understanding electricity, carpentry and system design and control. I went on to study Electrical and Electronic engineering as my career.
Kato prove it can be done and Mike from Budget Model Railways regularly shows what can be achieved on a budget. It just takes imagination and time.
That is a great thing about the model railway hobby - you learn about various things!
I just came across your channel. While I gave up model railroading when I was about ten, I retain an interest in the hobby. The realism of the train movements, compared to the real trains, is what captures my interests.
Hello,
Thank you so much for your enthusiasm & energy in your video.
Nearer eighty than seventy, I've never as an adult been without a model railway. A child receiving his Hornby Dublo, Christmas 1953, set me for life.
Even before my wedding (I'm a widower now) 1968, buying our home, extensive thought was given, so encouraged by Pam.
I want to encourage you, because the model industry as indeed the real thing was going through doldrums. The names Triang/Rovex, Trix-Twin, Hornby Dublo, had all disappeared. So I resorted to kit building. Wills, Ks, Romford, whilst Hornby & Wrenn started up, then early seventies the name Palitoy, that became Backmann.
We've been here before.
I do applaud your encouraging interest & analysis of the current state of affairs.
Thank you so much
Excellent video and insights! I’m 40 and have been a fan of model railroading about 3-decades. I went from starter sets to more advanced models. I even built a shelf layout (videos are on my channel). I agree the hobby is changing, not dying, and it will thrive when it’s more open to people of all ages and skill sets. The advanced model railroaders like ourselves need to always nurture and encourage those just starting out.
I have HO and the layout is 10' x 10' and have a about 150 locomotives and about 200 railcars and working on it awesome hoppe❤
Sounds great! 150 locos - are they DC/DCC?
Wow, very wise observations. Perhaps an annual design competition between railroad clubs to create a game using trains in the smallest scale possible (or practical). That could help inspire the masses. Replace tracks with bendable wire mounted to a game board that could be folded up and put away or reconfigured at any time. You make really useful videos. My kids grew up with Thomas.
My older brother had a small HO layout when I was younger, I 'inherited' it when he left for college. I'm 73 now and after a long time away from the hobby I bought a Woodland Scenics N-scale kit. Had fun building it, but decided to give it to a local club and took a break. My current solution for all of the problems stated in the video is a Bachmann HO DCC starter set and a lot of extra track. I set it up when I want to, use XtrakCAD to design a temporary layout, get it running and then decorate it with mini-scenes, similar to KATO's diorama idea, to add interest. When I don't have it set up, I can still build new mini-scenes for relaxation.
OK wow. This is the most inciteful honest video on the current state of the hobby I have seen. I have an 8 year old two 4 year olds and an 18 month baby. I am looking how to engage them in the hobby and everything you said is spot on. I think 3d printing is one of the answers. I would love to see a range of rtr blank chassis that have axles only. These if designed right could run on traditional wooden railway sets and then convert to oo. You could design and print basic bodies and clip them on. The companies could even do the printing.
Wow Dawn you're definitely an ambassador for this great hobby. Every point you so eloquently covered is one that I'm totally in agreement with you. This hobby is not dead and it's not dying but it is evolving . Bah humbug to the gloom mongers. When I exhibit my layouts at local shows I've found the most commented remark is "I haven't got space"! Understandable when modern housing has gotten smaller inside! My micro layouts change that perception! But the really big plus side that with today's high pressure life style/worries etc hobbies like ours are a good therapeutic way of easing the pressure and tension for all age groups. ( I do hope your monologue is watched by the manufacturers as well.)
This is something I've tried to convey in the hobby, that sometimes to get younger modellers involved is to engage their imaginations. Don't let the rivet counters stop you building that fictional railway be it based on reality or fantasy.
I've also had to learn to model on a budget and there are definitely ways to save money through recycling/re-using materials in the scenery aspect like salvaging insulation foam from building skips (with permission from the builders of course!)
I agree with a lot of what Dawn says. My contribution to the hobby this Christmas was to make a baseboard for my Grandsons (4&6) to run their Dad's Thomas set which had sat in the loft for 30 years. I provided a controller, two extra locos I did up for them (by adding faces) and the most precious thing of all; time.
Christmas Day was a great success. One of the greatest successes was the inclusion of a Peco level crossing which engendered lots of fun and arguments all with two move able gateshead! The layout has plenty of space to add things, some of which I'll 'find' from stock and, as their Dad is a Lego freak, they've got room to add structures of all kinds. Scale isn't important! Play value is.
Sounds fantastic! Well done you - am sure you're grandsons loved it!
I found it interesting to listen to your opinion about the model train hobby. I want to get back into it after leaving it in the late 70's and I've found it to be very expensive. I ordered some items off of eBay which are old and used and will need cleaning and repairs. You're 100% correct about time, space, and expense. I'm not sure where I'll build my layout, the cost is prohibitive which affects the amount of time I can actually run the trains because I'm having to spend time repairing them. You spoke of high tech which I see the hobby has become more high tech with DCC and other things. So the hobby has progressed somewhat since the 70's. Like many teenagers I got out of the hobby because of other interests which seems to happen to most teenagers. Not sure how you could bring "gaming" into the hobby, but for teenagers that would be huge if it was exciting and fun. Thank you for your thoughtful comments.
With the availability of different scales,although space is an issue,I think it’s price which is the biggest factor. I read a review today on a new Hornby loco which cost over £300,the issue is the price never goes down
Went to a local show last year and had similarly exciting thoughts re setting up my own layout. I only really just started in the hobby (and joined the Hattons staff in mid 2023, timing) so it's encouraging to see this take.
Good points well made Dawn. The hobby has evolved over many decades with bouts of “boom” and bouts of “doom” but there will always be a new norm. I think the intervention of some Rock stars, RUclipsrs, new manufacturers and new technologies helps the evolution to a new norm immensely.
With regard to pricing, there is an American manufacturer who sells 3 grades of locomotives - “ Museum Quality”, Rivet Counter” and “Operator” which are self explanatory and have prices that are lower for the lower grades of fidelity. Hornby and their competitors might do well to emulate this rather than churn out older models in garish liveries.
You hit the nail on the head on all your points! I own a small electronics company owner in the states that is dedicated to model railroading.
Lower prices…. Some loco sets are heading up to the $1000 mark which is crazy and that’s before you add in track, a controller etc
I was born into model railways like a religion and enjoyed my childhood growing up with model trains along with my brother and father and many friends we made along the way.
Work Girls cars sports families living abroad and other hobbies put pay to my model railway pursuits .
Now I have returned from my 30 year sabbatical refreshed .
You will be astounded the amount of people who are interested in model railways and many of them are younger than you think. They don't necessarily go in exhibitions or join model railway clubs but they are there .
Given there is so many practical skills involved and so much more technology it's time to get universities involved and get students involved and there children's children, this is the way forward. Smaller scales are much better these days N , TT and even Z are making a comeback. With better electronics and ease of fitting into a smaller area .
The best analysis I've heard on the industry for a long time. Thank you for putting this together, your comments on sustainability, tech, gamification, affordability, etc make a lot of sense.
Thank you - your feedback means a lot.
Well said. Hope the men running the model railway business and hobby just didn’t listen but heard what you said.
Very detailed and insightful video presentation. Well done and grateful for your contributions to the hobby. I live in the US and have been modeling in 3-rail O gauge for quite some time. Space is always a factor and O gauge certainly adds to the challenge, but I have found contentment in my 8x14 (feet) configuration. Not my dream layout, but it keeps me engaged and always looking to do more. Despite the various limiting factors you mentioned, there is continued strong interest for model trains in the US, particularly in the Northeast. Social media has helped the hobby with how-to videos, private FB groups and Instagram. People want to showcase their collections, projects, and layouts. This has been a huge driver for the hobby. There are a few you-tubers out there that have tremendous subscriber bases. Local train shows are serving larger crowds lately and the local hobby shops are always busy with repairs and taking pre-orders from customers for the latest product releases from the key manufacturers. Some manufactures do not require pre-payment with BTO orders and instead are allowing layaway plans or the option to pay in full once products are received by the retailer. As for developing interest for the younger audience, I think the parent-child connection is the ticket. Children engaging with model trains is directly proportional to the amount of time invested by the parents. I believe this hobby has a lot of runway and opportunity for growth. THNKS again for everything you are doing for the hobby!
Excellent video and food for thought - will take up the challenge with my model railway club……
A lot of good points, I've only just got into the hobby through TT 120 and am really enjoying creating a new layout.
Good channels with well done content about trains and the hobby in general may be a good key 🗝️
At the same time, you can't forget that good clients are people who just love trains.
Wonderful presentation with inspirational enthusiasm for a most rewarding hobby. Thank you.
Thank you!
Good points well made, and in a positive way, Ms Q.
I guess I'm typical of many in the hobby, who left it in my early teens and have now come back to it in my mid/late fifties, but never turned my back on it completely.
The danger today is that there are fewer boys and girls getting involved, meaning that in the future there will be no-one of my age with a desire to "re-visit" model railways, as they never "visited" them in the first place.
Let's hope people with more vision and ability than I can, as you say, innovate to ignite the spark of interest in the kids of today, so even if they do take a vacation from the hobby in their teens, 20s, 30s & 40s, will feel a strong pull to return as they mature.
PS: the point you make regarding 3D printing and other tech is interesting. That could well tempt people in their teens & 20s to give the hobby a try.
It seems during covid the hobby was storming, riding the crest of a wave. Yet now its seemingly slumped the other side, although from what I see as a someone who sells in to the hobby is that the last few years have been steady.
I think with many of the points you raise and others in the comments section are very valid, it is now a hobby in change more than decline.
It will come out the other side of this negative period with a very different look but it will need inventiveness and bravery to attract different generations from the many clubs and businesses out there.
I have two micro layouts that I take to local exhibitions in Scotland. Last weekend at Irvine we had lots of families with younger children who loved the layout. Also many adults were asking about the size and impresses with the amount of detail on it. The hobby isn’t dead yet. Great video btw.
You are spot on with everything you said. We all struggle with change. Targeting young people and listening to their feedback is crucial. The small community based shows, in my opinion, offer more opportunities to engage with and become part of the model railway communty.
I think the space issue is understated. Sharehouses seem to be requiring everybody live with less and less space while rent continues to skyrocket. Half my friends wouldn’t have space for an N-gauge layout at present, let alone OO.
Before I got back into the hobby, I also assumed it was dying literally only because of the progressively smaller shoeboxes we’re being forced to share. :/
I am 72 years old and have been involved in railway modelling for a long time. My interest is based around the 1950s/60s and my memories of railways when I was a youngster. Yes I can just about remember that far back. I was never a "train spotter" but loved seeing the real trains. Perhaps the youngsters of today do not experience real trains in the way that older people did. A trip to the seaside or going on holiday then quite often involved a train journey. Also industries all over the country used the railways so there were lots of trains to see. Myself and my school age friends would quite often watch the coal trains going to and from the local colliery. I don`t have any answers to the lack of interest by youngsters today as we cannot turn back the clock to an age that has gone. I really do hope that people cleverer than me can come up with something. At least we have a clever youngster in Dawn and others doing their best for this wonderful hobby. ❤
terry, I have heard that argument, that trains don't mean as much to the younger generations. The thing is, especially here in the US, there are few people other than people in their 70's and up, who remember passenger train travel. I am 60, and in my generation it was already cars and planes, not trains.Funny thing is, one of the most popular modelling item in the hobby is steam engines, yet again few other than the very older models ever saw them in active use.
I think that leaving out teenagers (who always seem to have lost interest in trains!), the answer is having kids and older people having access to model trains. Open houses at clubs, modular layouts at community centers, malls (I know, another dying thing), train shows, are all huge. I was just reading that gen z or whatever they call them, are helping revitalize shopping malls, apparently they are in a sense looking back to when malls were social gathering places (also they like shopping in person). So having a display at a mall may actually work. I think many people have an interest in trains, the Greenberg Toy and train shows often are mobbed.
Sound and sensible analysis Dawn, and well-presented. I think model railway clubs have a huge opportunity (if only they would all accept it) to engage with younger people and promote the hobby - maybe another video on this topic as I know many of them do exactly that. Also, there is clearly a problem to do with the alarming rate of closures of model shops. Perhaps some of those remaining might need to consider changing their ways too, to encourage young and older modellers to develop their skills and interests in the hobby. Thanks for expressing your thoughts so well.
My Mrs and I (62 & 59 respectively)are off to Canterbury model railway show today. I started an N gauge layout last year and we both enjoy the hobby, we sit for hours making metcalffe kits and stuff and find it very relaxing. We only got into the hobby by chance, while I was ferreting about in the loft I rediscovered a Hornby Harry Potter train set we bought for our daughter many years ago so took it down and set it up on the lounge carpet. It didn’t work, so I set about trying to fix it via RUclips vids (thanks 00Bill 👍🏻) it now runs like a burglar but because of lack of space it now sits back in it’s box. Hence why we now fiddle about in N gauge, 4.5 x 2.5 is more suitable for the amount of space we have available.
Good vid 👍🏻
Sounds great! I’m exhibiting Brief Encounter Monochrome at Canterbury today - pop by and say Hi!
Come and say hi at the show!
Are there hobby shops that have used equipment shelves to make it easier to trade OO scale equipment for N scale equipment?
Good question! I'd like to know too.
No Nonsense - Maybe you should take the OO scale Harry Potter Train Set to a train show and see about working out a trade deal with a seller for N scale items?
As a 40 year old I feel sidelined by the market.
I see a lot of effort from traditional manufacturers to bring out some rare long since scrapped kettle. But when it comes to diesels and electrics in particular, I'm left wanting.
Accurascale seems to get it. A 92 with working pantograph and all the toys is just for me. To be fair the Bachmann 90 is pretty slick too.
But where's the coaches? Having bought Oxford Rail the only Mark 3 and 4 producer is Hornby - and their coaches leave the modeller wanting.
I see your point about affordability but I'm not keen on pushing round rolling stock that looks like it was designed in the 1980s.
Maybe it's just me but the HST and 91s are very good; they need the rest of the train to match!
Lots of good points raised here Dawn. I am a very young nearly 70 year old. Built first model for my young son and daughter over thirty years ago. Still running and great fun. Last year I got the bug again and built four models. Two in N and two in 00. I am lucky, I have a huge and dry garage where I can model to my hearts content in a safe and warm environment. I am also fortunate enough to have a disposable income that allows me to spend on the hobby whereas others are not so well blessed. However, I make do with items from the bargain box at my local model shop and occasional forays to shows/E-Bay. I have learned lots of artistic and scenic skills of late and much enjoyed making do with the bits and bobs around the house be they cardboard or foam, carpet tiles or other items headed for the bin. I hope my two (soon to be three) young grandsons will in time enjoy the interest too. At the moment their youth makes them clumsy and breakages are costly. They also have lots of competing interests and of course school. The latter always takes priority as you would expect. Both parents work and are therefore not able to invest hours in helping them. I am not local to them so visits are difficult. In summary, lots of barriers and I guess many are in the same boat. Living near to Stamford, we know what some young folk can get up to when they get the opportunity! Modelling takes time, money and patience as well as knowledge. Many youngsters struggle with these attributes. I thought that in the spring I would throw open the garage and have a model day to attract some local interest. But that raises its own issues around security and all the other risks of allowing the public into your personal space. At the end of the day no easy answers but perhaps as others have said, draw folk in through the local shows and clubs, make people feel welcome and involved and show them you need not be rich or a craftsman to get enjoyment and pleasure from the hobby and all the life skills it can teach.
Another excellent (as usual) video Dawn and I agree with all you said. My observations at our local shows, and the club's (Silver Fox) show is the younger generation, particularly those pre-teens, want to see movement and lots of it. The older groups of young adults, and those 'returners' want to know all about DCC, control by WiFi, and often are eager to have a go when this is offered. I have also noticed many with SEN are drawn to movement and are seemingly enthralled by moving trains. I find the cost prohibitive (I'm a pensioner) but would pay for reliable and good quality mechanics and less 'hidden' detail which I cannot see at over 1m distance anyway! I've got 4 UM locos, and 4 Minitrix and all run better than many modern locos at the club, and can pull a lot more as well. Keep on with your quest!
As a visitor from Ireland to warley for the last 10 years its was one of the highlights of the year.
Surley this event can be saved.There must be another model club who can step in and save it.
Amazing video and insights! How could I not know your channel until now? Couldn't agree more on all your arguments, especially on tech and pricing. I personally would also consider marketing as a major vital point, especially marketing to younger generations. It's becoming harder to "discover" model trains: train stores are closing, and regular toy stores are not carrying train sets anymore (with rare exceptions in the UK for Hornby, or Märklin's My World quite successful range).
At the same time anyway, all physical stores are being replaced by online shopping everywhere, it's a universal trend: soon there will be no way to "stumble upon" model railroading in real life. So we need the brands to be about 10000 times more active online. We need more model railway influencers. We need more sponsored posts. We need more collabs. We need young people, older people, middle aged people, men, women, from all continents and walks of life slowly reminding people that model railways exist, and - as you rightfully say - is a rich hobby.
Thanks for the video and the positivity!
This sort of discussion was ongoing during the 1960s. The threat then was Scalextric and now it's probably computer games, or somesuch. It's worth some serious thought, but not panic.
I am making sure to build all of my models to be very " pick up and examine" friendly, by building them from styrene with any fiddly bits be made in brass. It is also to show people that you can scratchbuild models that look just as good as mass market ones for a fraction of the price.
Nice video! It would be great to see what ways the hobby can grow. I just got into the hobby after getting myself a set for my 25th birthday last month. Seeing people have fun with trains on social media got me inspired. People my age threw the word nostalgia around and its true!
Interesting Video, Dawn. Certainly you are right with your main arguments.
Luckily it feels very different here at my end in Germany, as a lot of us are active in clubs running huge modular layouts to prototype operation with planned schedule. Have you ever heard about FREMO?
This not only solves the space and the affordability problem but also inherits the gaming aspect.
For me, model railroading has become a big roleplay game, played with up to 50 players as train crew, station personal, freight dispatchers to model prototype operation.
This keeps young and old attracked alike: we are running a station with a team of seven: four adults, two teens and one child.
I'd be happy to show you around auch a meeting, get in touch if you are interested.
Sounds fantastic - I'd love to come visit.
@@modelrailwayquest awesome! I've sent you some details via your website.
Not just the young...women too. Been with my partner a couple yrs and we've only just admitted to each other we both love model railways, she loves them....Get more women involved and the entire thing will just become more inclusive all round.
Love it! I have a video on women in railway modelling in the works - watch this space. In the meantime, would your partner like to join my FB group for women in railway modelling? facebook.com/groups/womenrailwaymodellers
What makes you think model railways has not been inclusive? I doubt that women have been deliberately excluded. In the past most women may not have been particularly interested. If more women are interested now that’s great, but please let’s not bring divisive feminist dogma into model railways.
Great idea if you can find the right woman. My wife of 51 years can't wait to throw my collection in a skip!
I think there are two types of people in the hobby, neither type appear to me to be sexist. One group is welcoming. However there is a strong crowd that is not. That strong crowd may be the minority but you do remember that minority. My pregnant wife was denied a seat in the cafe at Ally Pally when she asked an group of people if she could take a spare seat at their table. The answer was a one word "no" and no one else joined their group (she had to sit on the floor close to them for half an hour). At the great electric train show show a "no" was also the answer when we asked an elderly guy who had 'elbows out' (ie taking up space for 2) on the railing in front of pete watermans layout if he could make space for our 3 year old to view alongside him who could not see over the heads in front of him. I have a reasonable passion and knowledge for trains and model railways but theres a certain crowd who do look down at you unless you are encyclopedic in your knowledge - one slip up in your facts and you're not a 'proper' enthusiast. Maybe it's because certain people are less comfortable mixing in group/social situations themselves but it does create a first impression to new people to the hobby that I think puts a number of people off. My wife now does not like going to shows, not because she doesn't like trains or models (she not a huge fan of the subject mattet, but she is supportive and open minded), but because the people are rude and look down on her. Again, its probably a minority, but that's what makes all the difference. On the flip side, the are some good eggs and, of particular note, the crew of hornby magazine and accurascale stand out for being super approachable
Agreed I love it❤ but we need more support 🎉Elizabeth
So glad I saved some of my old stuff from 20-30 years ago for my kids. Lack of space, time, and funds are definitely issues these days. However, I think one of the biggest problems is perfectionism. I see it with many other hobbies too such as Legos, sports, theme parks, etc. Kids need to be 'allowed' to experiment and sometimes break stuff to really get a feel for the hobby, and I think adults who want to relive a perfect version of their childhood hobby can sometimes get in the way of children's enjoyment of the hobby at the entry level. To me, that entry level has to happen, though... that is where the "spark" of imagination is. It doesn't have to be perfect. Model trains can be a breath of fresh air for kids in a world of screens and I think the ability to train young minds to directly manipulate a model can be more rewarding than a virtual model. That said, that 3d printing idea seems like an awesome opportunity for the industry... maybe to help local hobby shops stay afloat. On a practical note... I find that the classic layouts with loops take too much space, is there any chance for more products that can keep keep things more linear (whether reversing polarity at the ends of the line or some other kind of simple control that can be achieved with basic electronics)?
First time I've ever seen your channel, but this is so interesting to me as a business mentor/saint. I've been looking at returning to hobbying (at 62!) and have considered slot racing, 'Airfix' (generically) and...model railways. It's been 40 years at least since I last paid any attention to the model railway world and what I've seen 1. Shocks me and 2. Makes it blindingly obvious why it seems to be in crisis. Where has the middle ground gone? 40 years ago you had players like Lima (now gone I understand?) who made a more affordable product than Hornby/Fleischman etc and it let you build a layout and get a reasonable selection of locos and coaches etc quickly. There seems to be a big dark hole between 'kids toy trains' and highly accurate models (if you've got £300 a pop!).
The other is a cultural shift - we are living in smaller homes. 40+ years ago most people I knew lived in 3 bed semis or where working hard to be in one.
Now- even at 62 - most people I know live in apartments or smaller homes. The result being LESS SPACE - and like it or not, model railway layouts use space! When you see social media bombarded with reels from Minatur Wonderland etc it makes the viewer feel totally inadequate! Rather than stimulating interest in the hobby, huge layouts like that are actually counter productive. There needs to be MUCH MUCH more emphasis on achievable layouts, along the lines of the 'IKEA shelf layout' idea - which IS achievable if you live in an apartment.
As you rightly say Dawn, the industry/hobby is going through change, not facing oblivion. But it needs to take a good long look at itself and realise what the impression being given to someone like me actually is. Make it more obviously accessible in today's world and you WILL have an NEC show again.
Very insightful. Thank you.
As a store owner and modeler I agree about the tech aspect. If you can show the kids and even adults how to run trains via your phone as well as the different ways you can incorporate Arduinos and such into their model it goes a long way. Plus, encouraging wives to enter the hobbies with their spouses. I've seen a huge resurgences in the hobby but mainly because I try and get new people excited about having fun. It is about running trains, not this train doesn't run with this train and such. Those who want to excel will, but to encourage new people and answer their questions. For the longest time many didn't want to share their knowledge or as a few posted you'd walk into a train store or show and couldn't touch anything. Our motto is, For the Love of Trains. Not everyone is a Master Model Railroad, in fact very few are, but they all love to see trains run. So the more companies make it so the system because plug and play with easy, buildings built and detailed for affordable pricing the longer or more likely people will stay in the hobby. As you stated, the hobby demographics are changing, the problem is most stores, haven't changed. Plus, most stores were owned by an older generations just running the stores like a hobby and not a business. There is a fine line and balancing act, but as store owners change hands, and new stores pop up this hobby with thrive. As I said, I've seen a huge increase in those looking to get back into the hobby and enter the hobby for the first time. It is on us in the hobby to encourage anyone who wants to get into this hobby, even if they just want a simple oval on their floor just to enjoy running trains.
Great video. Love the hobby
Hi Dawn. Totally agree with everything that you said 👍
You make some very valid points. What I see in the model railway hobby in Britain is an emphasis on construction, which is great, but when it comes to what they do with their beautifully constructed layout when it's finished is ..... well nothing much really. Whenever I ask what they do with it, they say "Oh I just run trains", which means they basically run trains round and round in circles until something falls off, or they nod off :) In America I think the emphasis is on operations. Americans tend to have big basements, and have more scope for operations, but operations can also be achieved with small layouts. I do see many British layouts that model a need, an industry, and they operate it like a working railway (except leaving out the big time gaps between trains like on the real thing), but I think mainly, especially when trying to encourage younger members, there is no thought about operations. For instance, my dream would be to create an exhibition layout that would allow visitors, young and old, to drive it ... BUT ..... drive it with a purpose. I would set them shunting puzzles. I would present them with a train of wagons that are a mix of coal, tankers, whatever and I would say "We need to make up a train of just those coal wagons. How do you reckon we could extract just those wagons out of that mix and make up a train of just the coal wagons? Without using your hands of course", and I would let them drive the loco.
My four sons all had a part in the building of our fairly large model railroad. My grandchildren also run trains now. We have a fleet of roughly 160 steam and diesel locomotives with a price range of $50 to $1,000. They know the simple rules, don’t handle the locomotives and cars unless they’re derailed, and don’t run them like a race car. Working on big scenery projects helps to keep the grandchildren involved. We work together on most of it.
How about this for an idea - a manufacturer ( let’s say Hornby ) makes one or two simple, generic chassis with easy to use mounting points for a body - then they have a few downloadable files for people ( youngsters? ) to 3D print their own body , at home , at school or at the local club where they could use their 3D printer. Make the files editable ( open source ) so you could make your own unique version and paint it in your own paint scheme etc.
Have a free to join club where every month you could get a free download for a body , a wagon body to fit a generic wagon chassis or a simple building , people , even trees ?
Competitions on the ‘club’ website for best creation this month etc. etc.
This is of course a new twist on an old idea - there must have been countless white metal kits that went on an oem chassis way back when.
I am most certainly not the target age group but it sounds so much fun I would have a go myself.
Love it. This is the type of thinking we need!
Some good points were raised there, Dawn. Cost is becoming more of a factor, and also I think that some youngsters can be put off by the attitude of some older modellers as well. They should be encouraged to have a go no matter what they start off with, make it fun and interesting. Some will move on to other interests as with any other hobby. But some will stay and become the future of the hobby. They may prefer the modelling side of thing's, building house's, trees, walls, and other scenery. After all, there's plenty that do fantastic job's of building and creating landscapes, building spaceships, and painting figures for warhammer and others. It's a transferable skill, and once involved, they might learn other skills, soldering, electrics, track laying and maybe running trains. Whatever let it be fun.......cheers James 🙂👍
Absolutely James - well said.
Just read your comment with interest especially with young people.
Though not relating to MR
This attitude happened to my granddaughter who was taking rock and roll lessons
So I decided to take her to the local rock and roll disco night.
They were all from the 50 and 60 era two weeks later told that she was not welcome due to being under 18
Well she was only 9 at the time.
My thoughts were just how long will this club survive.
Anyway have a nice day.
Regards Martin
@martinrowlands3622 Hi Martin, I agree with you there. How do they expect clubs to keep going if they alienate the youngsters who are possibly the next generation to keep whatever the hobby is going . I'm recently new to model railway's and my grandson is very interested at the moment, he's 12, and I've taken him to exhibitions and model shops. He's about to start building a 009 layout and has started his own RUclips channel Dylington Model Railway, which I hope encourages him to keep going with the modelling. He operates the trains and films all of his videos, edits them, and then adds them to RUclips. Have a look, I don't think he's doing a bad job with them. This brings me back to the start, due to his age and not wanting any silly comments from the type of people we've mentioned, we've turned off the comments for his protection. That's with the exception of the Christmas video, if you decide to have a look, let me know on here or the Christmas video what you think......cheers James 🙂👍
@DYLINGTONMODELRAILWAY Congratulations to your grandson for taking up such a wonderful hobby. Yes, there are stupid people writing messages on all aspects relating to one interest or hobbies.
I only commented as I felt it was a relivent comment on age and young people and relating to the death of such groups.
I can only admire people who invest their time in being creative, whether modelling. Ballet/dance, playing a musical instrument, etc. I hope that your grandson can inspire some of his school friends take care
Regards Martin
@martinrowlands3622 Thank you, Martin, for your comments and response, I will always endeavour to encourage not just youngsters but anyone who is having a go at something, whatever their interest is. Especially if it keeps the youngsters of off the streets. Take care, James 🙂👍
A very interesting video, with relevance to other hobbies too, including the focus on the role of tech and gaming. I often hear similar issues raised among historical wargamers. As a teenager, I turned away from railways towards military modelling and gaming because of the lack of narrative once a layout was complete. I don’t know how common this is, but the popularity of fantasy gaming suggests that many teenagers are interested in miniatures if they can use their imaginations and do something with them, once they’re complete. At the younger end of the ‘market’, as you mention, is the huge popularity of Thomas, which is partly due to the story and presentation of engines etc as characters but that doesn’t seem able to transfer to the ‘grown-up’ version of the hobby in any way. I wouldn’t argue for all engines to have faces, though machine qualities interest many people as do the lives of inventors and developers but perhaps they’re not represented much in the hobby.
On the price issue, it might be useful to compare railways with radio-controlled vehicles or aircraft, where the level of tech is similar, but the sense of control over the machine is greater. Who knows, that might also be an obstacle to attracting younger people as well.
The strengths of model railways for me, as an outsider, are the modelling skills and terrain that I often see featured in Utube videos. But Chandwell is the only one I’ve found so far that also incorporates humour and narrative, with characters and history regularly emerging from the developing layout. I’ve also noticed the Luton club depiction of the Great Train Robbery has attracted a lot of attention. Perhaps there’s something from history to be gleaned from that.
As for the media, it always seems to be an easy story for lazy journalists to say this or that activity is dying but books, vinyl records and even cassettes are making a comeback so I'm sure our hobbies will also continue to thrive.
Well said Dawn I will try and share this vid with the boys at Romford MRC
Good morning.
I've heard what you say about model railways for a long time (I'm 50). That said, I also practice radio experimentation (amateur radio, duly licensed). And, in this hobby, the observation is the same, although with a very different situation. the price is no longer a problem, we find very valid products for beginners (thank you, Asian manufacturing!). a transceiver is not very bulky, a vertical antenna is easily mounted. space is therefore not an issue. the radio license is easily obtained (no more need for Morse code), and actual devices do not require any technical skills (apart from tuning the antenna). In addition, we can find high-performance measuring devices at a ridiculous price, unimaginable only 15 years ago! and yet, we too, we are getting older, among us too, few young people are interested, despite super fun creations which combine radio and computers. where are the young people? in front of their consoles? becoming an Instagram star? Maybe, we should call the flute player of hamelin to get them out...
Great article. I’ve been banging on about the change that’s now here for many years. Everything changes over time. So let’s not be down beat. Grab the nettle firmly and fight back. I’m hoping to get the local schools involved via the STEM system because as you say, this hobby involves Design, Engineering, etc. etc. More and more it’s programming. Thus utilising Arduino or Pye, like a worm we’ve got youngsters hooked.
You can do a lot with arduino and raspberry pie that I think younger people would eat up, you can automate animations, do all kind of cool things. I was at a train show where they were demonstrating things they did with an arduino circuit board that was impressive and young kids in the area seemed really impressed.
When I was a young person, I would probably have given up if it wasn't for my local shop having an area with second hand structures, track, locomotives and rolling stock. Plaster of Paris was my affordable option for scenery
From Colorado..Well done!
I think that 3D printing and getting 3D files to make the geografi with houses and different terrains is a thing that can be a great thing to keep it alive.
My 3D resin printer arrived yesterday, never before has it been as possible to model the prototype you want to model.
Hornby got it right to a point with the railroad range if you're not bothered about detail , Rails of Sheffield have announced a cl 60 for a price of £194 and £294 dcc , very nice too but pricing wow . In your vid you came up with some really valid points,
Hi great video, i agree with a lot of what you have said especially about the cost. I have 2 boys of 10 & 13, the eldest has always been into trains and got his first set anout 3 years ago. I decided to get a train for myself to join in with him. We now have a combined collection of around 40+ locos and various rolling stock. 95% of this is used because of the cost of even the most basic models is out of our reach.
Continuing from my previous comment, 1 reason for purchasing mostly used locos and rolling stock apart from the cost of new is to learn from trying to make what we have bought run better and to learn about how they work, teaching ourselves along the way with watching videos to aid out knowledge.
Nice to hear someone with a rational outlook. I think affordability is becoming more of an issue at present. Limiting younger and mature people equally. The model railway clubs are definitely a good way of introducing people into the hobby. But at the same time I think there is still a gap in-between the two. There needs to be something that piques the curiosity in the first place and gets people of any age to look for an inroad into the hobby.
Thank you for posting this informative video. The main issue is that of affordability the prices have risen beyond the reach of the average model railroader.
Amazing! I think you were saying something? Something
about model railroading. I kept getting lost. There was this absolutely beautiful lady with long sculptured fingers, no rings. I'm sorry I was so lost in her. Oh! Im sorry were you saying something❤
Great video...👍
Cost is the major factor, it’s not just the cost of locos and rolling stock, it’s the cost of materials to build the baseboard. Then it’s the space, modern houses are smaller, and the roof space is not very usable with how they are constructed.
I don't know where the negativity comes from. I belong to several clubs, that continue to have new members joining up. I also run a craftsman kit business, and I can't keep up with demand, which shows the hobby is alive and well. Keep the positivity message going!
We started a modular model RR club here in Kalispell Montana and meet once a month in a local mall... Yes, in a public space where the public can actually see a model railroad! We have several younger members and find interested parties all the time. Why? because we are not hiding the hobby in a remote basement. A 2ft x 4ft or 2ft by 6ft module doesn't take a lifetime to get up and running and you can easily store it in a closet...Modules are built light weight so they can be carried by one person. It's time for model railroaders to take a fresh view, socialize, and get out of the basement. Vance
When did you start that? I moved away from the Flathead Valley a year ago and do not recall ever hearing anything about it.
Now that all of my 6 kids are grown, and 3 are producing grandbabies for me, I have just one 18 year old at home. He likes gaming, but we don't have video games at home. I can finally afford to accumulate components for a model railroad. I had to build a room in my garage for it. I have a strategy to involve my son. He is interested in miniature tank war-gaming, and so I intend to let him use my railroad landscape when we play these dice-rolling games. I'll be teaching him to build trees and buildings that we can use for cover in our battles. He'll grow out of the tank games as he gets busier being an adult, and the grandkids will be next. That is how I'm involving the youth in the hobby by adapting to their gaming interests.
I initially started about 10 years ago (give or take) with my first Bachmann HO scale train set, the Chattanooga. (with the 0-6-0 steam loco). I had fun for a little bit but with being in school, having therapy after school, I hardly had time... nor the money. During that short time when I was first interested, I did manage to buy an old Lifelike Amtrak F40PH for 19 dollars and that was it... It wasn't until summer of 2022 when I was organizing downstairs, I stumbled upon my set. I set it up; ran my old 0-6-0 and my F40ph, then it hit me... I have money now... So then began the revival. Currently I have over 40 locomotives, 50+ pieces of rolling stock, and an assortment of passenger cars from different railways across the USA. From the Denver & Rio Grande to the Chicago Northwestern (CNW is my fav). I also joined my local club and there are a few young adults like me. I hope to see many years in this hobby and maybe if I have kids, I can pass the torch on.
My club has a layout we take to shows (including Warley) for us to enjoy running and showing off our live steam narrow gauge trains. However when we get our battery powered Thomas and Percy stuff on the track pretty quickly every youngster at the show turns up. Model trains are, and need to be, fun.
Thank you for this video. It is astonishing to think of how much could help to revive this hobby. There is no single solution but this can all help.
Speaking as someone in their late 20's, I used to be into railway modelling. But back in my teens I stopped with the hobby. Not so much lack of interest, but just the lack of space. It did not help that I have other hobbies that demanded much space (Lego I am afraid-a similar kind of hobby as it requires imagination).
But I have started to get back into the hobby. It has been a blessing to get back into it. I found the ideal scale for now-009 of all things-but I can create a nice layout in a small space with it. And at my preferred scale of 1:76 (I always loved OO but N was tempting me for space. 009 is the best of both worlds).
Thank you for providing such a balanced take on the situation. It seems every news article is sensationalised nowadays, a situation is unprecedented and it seems it has to be negative news. No wonder everyone I know tries to limit their exposure to news reporting and watch silly cat videos instead. Ian
That's exactly what I do. News is not news anymore ,it is someone's opinion talked about for hours.
I agree with Dawn the clubs ,and others need to think differently. I live in Calgary, Alberta Canada. 25 years ago the 5 main clubs decided to pool their resources and with over 100 non club (people who model by themselves) members created a new group to put on a train show. 25 years later this show fills an area about the size of 5 indoor soccer fields, 60,000 sq ft or around 6,000sq meters. Last year 11,500 people attended of which 4,500 were younger than 16. Every type of layout is welcome from expert to novice. Within a 2 hour drive you would only find 2million people so not a huge catchment area. One of the main problems is the car park being full and people not being able to find a parking spot. This is all possible because it is not the same people having to organize year after year.
Good morning. I've just watched your video very well argued and interesting. I try to use my local model shop, Tennants Trains, in Halesowen. Also, Hattons sadly lost. Even basic train sets are expensive things need to be put in place to attract youngsters of all ages. Best regards Mark vickery
A great presentation of a great hobby, I am not into trains etc, but am an avid Rc plane flyer, a sport and hobby i love, yet at
63 yr young ! i am one of the youngest in our club, and despite adverts, etc we just can not get new blood into our great (weather dependent) hobby, youngsters can do all this stuff on there phones, and in my case crash, and fly again in a click, so why invest time, and money as you say, in real stuff/toys, and for clarity, i have four grand kids, ranging from 9-23 yet NONE of them are even slightly interested in RC planes, its sad, that these fantastic hobbies and pastimes, are dwindling