It's cute how much the panelist gushes about Ohira. Personally, I think his scenes Howl, followed by GITS 2, are his best work. Sometimes his sense of weight comes across as inconsistent, like in the xxxHolic sequence shown; the bunny alternates between seemingly weightless to massive. This could very well be deliberate on his part, but I think his work is at it's best in Howl.
It was copyright claimed but someone else uploaded it with the same title and russian subtitles, you can find it by searching "sakuga pt.7 mitsuo iso" :)
+Matt Berger Yeah sure... Have you ever bother looking at actual rotoscoped animations? Rotoscope can't escape from live person's constant subtle movements and actual body proportion. Unless you can find those factors in above mentioned animations, your claim is invalid
I have seen many rotoscoped animations. It's all depending on the animation director's guidelines. You can escape any "person's constant subtle movements" if you use are knowledgeable in animating anything. For example, the film A Scanner Darkly has many parts that deter from the source on several occasions. I wasn't saying those shows were completely rotoscoped. There are hints of it in them. Kid's Story you can see it is highly stylized/rotoscoped. Also, next time you comment, try to be nicer. Some people may see you as a rude troll.
+Matt Berger I'm sorry about my tone, but I don't agree with your assertion. If something is rotoscoped, whether it's moving or not, a lot of unwanted visual elements sticks out like sore thumb. Since you brought up a rotoscoped movie, I watched Flowers of Evil and rotoscope in that show made it hard to watch even though it tweaked a lot. I'm defending Ohira's work because I also check my Japanese resources along with English resources.
Sakuga pt.7- Shinya Ohira's Expressionistic Animation
ITS MISSING :C
can you please re upload it?
its really interesting conference. love it!
blocked in country for some reason
Thank you for uploading new videos :)
I was looking forward for this.
It's cute how much the panelist gushes about Ohira. Personally, I think his scenes Howl, followed by GITS 2, are his best work. Sometimes his sense of weight comes across as inconsistent, like in the xxxHolic sequence shown; the bunny alternates between seemingly weightless to massive. This could very well be deliberate on his part, but I think his work is at it's best in Howl.
thank u !!!
Did he do the Linkin Part song Breaking the habit
This is great! I notice part 7 in this series is missing....? Will we be getting it back?
It was copyright claimed but someone else uploaded it with the same title and russian subtitles, you can find it by searching "sakuga pt.7 mitsuo iso" :)
Midsummer Night's Dream, Kid's Story and Black Heaven are all rotoscope animated. This is why are of high quality.
+Matt Berger Yeah sure... Have you ever bother looking at actual rotoscoped animations? Rotoscope can't escape from live person's constant subtle movements and actual body proportion. Unless you can find those factors in above mentioned animations, your claim is invalid
I have seen many rotoscoped animations. It's all depending on the animation director's guidelines. You can escape any "person's constant subtle movements" if you use are knowledgeable in animating anything. For example, the film A Scanner Darkly has many parts that deter from the source on several occasions. I wasn't saying those shows were completely rotoscoped. There are hints of it in them. Kid's Story you can see it is highly stylized/rotoscoped. Also, next time you comment, try to be nicer. Some people may see you as a rude troll.
+Matt Berger I'm sorry about my tone, but I don't agree with your assertion. If something is rotoscoped, whether it's moving or not, a lot of unwanted visual elements sticks out like sore thumb. Since you brought up a rotoscoped movie, I watched Flowers of Evil and rotoscope in that show made it hard to watch even though it tweaked a lot. I'm defending Ohira's work because I also check my Japanese resources along with English resources.
Matt Berger im sorry,but where did u get this fact?
They aren't facts, as I'm sure you're aware. You can literally watch the making of process for Kid's Story and there is no rotoscoping.
How do I find which animator is involved in a specific scene? Where are the English sources?
+Juana Alcantara Nowadays Sakugabooru is a significant database of sakuga scenes.
I may be wrong, but did Hashimoto direct GTO's second opening?