Hey, I love your channel. Could you see my cover and give me your opinion please? I would be very grateful to you ruclips.net/video/DUEb2UVVd3E/видео.html
@@iworshipgaysandsatan6822 Just cuz someone can reach C6 dosen't mean they are suitable. Ofcourse sohyang is impeccable in upperbelts. But natalie's agility will smash sohyang in that criteria sohyang is nothing in front of natalie when it comes down to agility. Also her astounding low register.
Avantika Roy you guys assume that because she’s more agile she’s a better singer then? Better lows, yeah, I’m saying sohyangs range is more expansive and she is belting B5s with great technique, the past few years the highest note Natalie has hit is a G#5 and I’m not saying “Sohyang has higher notes thus she is better” I’m saying she’s hitting higher notes with great technique consistently over a long period of time. She does a similar thing to Natalie, just higher. Isn’t natelie a Mezzo? Whatever fache she is, it of course means her lows are better and mids are so resonant. Sohyangs high belts are so resonant because her tessitura is so high. Also the quality of natelies clips will alter the amount of resonance natelie is actually outputting, cameras back then have a resonance peak and will cap out and make her voice sound more powerful and more resonant. Agility isn’t everything, by that logic Christina Aguilera is one of the best vocalists ever.
@@iworshipgaysandsatan6822 first of all wtf are you srsly starting? I said "Natalie can beat Sohyang in the AGILITY criteria" this does not mean she is better than her or worse. Sohyang is agile as well but not as Natalie. Just as Sohyang's tessitura allows her to belt stong and supported upperbelts ...Natalie's agile voice allows her to beautify her songs on the basis of that. The person in the original comment said that "Sohyang can belt upto C6#" which clearly had no base in it's meaning and just shows that the person is comparing the on the basis of range. Range is not everything that was what I was implying. Just like Natalie shines in mid and upper too Sohyang's upperbelts are of no match to Natalie cuz they (sohyang's) are that good. And ofcourse as you mentioned, even if natalie is a mezzo props to her belting above F5-F5# with this ease and support and resonance, which brings me to think that she is probably not a mezzo. Natalie's lower register is much prominent and better than Sohyangs who is clearly developing recently, just as sohyang's upper register is greater than natalie. Pls READ the comment properly before answering. I'm a huge Sohyang fan too but I acknowledge her weakness and appreciate her improvement instead of just coming at ppl who appreciate it too. And I think that is sooo stupid of you to compare a remarkable vocalist like Natalie to oversinging strainer like christina. You could do better. Show some respect atleast.
Avantika Roy you’re twisting my argument. I said what I said about you two basing the quality of a singer on agility because the only thing you two mentioned basically was how natelies agility is better than Sohyangs as a response to who is better as a vocalist. Yeah natelie can belt and have her headvoice high because she was trained in opera and broadway which is pure technique and how to make everything powerful etc. I wasn’t saying Christina is comparable to Natelie, you’re twisting what I said I said “by that logic (in reference to agility making a good singer of which you both implied) Christina is one of he best vocalists” which the subtext is “Christina is not one of the best vocalists ever, agility does not make a good singer, that is frail logic “ I was not genuinely comparing the two. Clearly.
In my opinion: C5: SoHyang C#5: Tie D5: Tie Eb5: Natalie E5: Natalie (SoHyang's Fate E5 would have been good here) F5: SoHyang First F#5: Natalie Second F#5: SoHyang First G5: SoHyang Second G5: SoHyang G#5: Natalie A5: SoHyang Bb5: SoHyang
Both of their belting techniques are technically flawless and then both have incredible resonance all the way up to Bb5so it's basically a tie. But preference wise I'll give the win to SoHyang just due to the fact that I find her belts to be a lot more intense and more powerful.
+RyderC Daniels True, in this case SoHyang has a more interesting tone, besides that she has more vocal stamina and vocal range. Natalie has a slight piercing tone but she sounds a little "bored"? I mean, she just sounds like a vocal technique teacher who performs covers. SoHyang sounds like a true vocalist, singer and artist on stage. Anyway I think this is a good comparison because both are incredible vocalists with perfect techniques. In this case you and I have the same opinion, but you already know that everything is "subjective" and that each person has your own preferences. I am very proud and happy that you see my videos, so from the bottom of my heart, I say thank you so much Dear 💕 I invite you to subscribe to my channel!
I agree. And yes, Sohyang has a strongest voice because of her vocal Fach, She is a Full-Lyric Soprano while Natalie is a (pure) Lyric, aka Light-Lyric, that's why her upper register sounds girly/youthful, while SoHyang's sounds more womanly. Love them
Angel Frost its the opposite for me. Sohyang’s tone is very average (plain tone without character) for an asian singer. And sohyang is actually the one more piercing due to her nasal resonance.
@@rydercdaniels4475 Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? I'm not a singer, but I love to sing xD Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
C5: tie leaning to Natalie (SoHyang wasnt being belty but I love the tonal balance) C#5: tie (same as the C5, Natalie's beltier but SoHyang is rounder and more tonally balanced) D5: SoHyang (SoHyang is more open and resonant) Eb5: Natalie (no doubt that Eb5 from Natalie is divine. It was more resonant than SoHyang's Eb5 here and more open) E5: SoHyang (SoHyang is more resonant and more open) F5: SoHyang (same here) F#5 (2): SoHyang (SoHyang's is not only more resonant & open, it's also excellently dynamically controlled and it had an absolutely FLAWLESS heady mix to balanced mix transition) From this point on there is no need for an explanation bc it's the same stuff👇 F#5 (2): SoHyang G5 (1): SoHyang G5 (2): SoHyang G#5: SoHyang A5: SoHyang Bb5: SoHyang Cracked up at the end😂😂😂😂 Great video👍
Marios POS kinda wrong like on the f5 sohyang was not more open it was equal and the g#5 Natalie sounded fuller with more resonance and the a5 equal both great but about f#5 I think the second one Natalie bc sohyang was nasal and the bb5 is equal unless u think held for longer = better I mean the stamina
Sohyang for upperbelts, but when phrasing midbelt lyrics she tends to get nasal excluding the twang thing. But natalie's tone is extremly beautiful and she's one of the most agile singers of this gen. A category which sohyang isn't that good at. But its a 50-50 for me.
Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? I'm not a singer, but I love to sing xD Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
Sohyang isn’t actually putting in any effort. Her facial expressions are for the sake of emotion and showmanship. If you watch her rehearse, she can belt B5s with a face so relaxed that you’d just assume she’s breathing. Sohyang also opens her mouth wide to provide for the largest resonance possible and a darker tone. Natalie tends to lighten her mix and resonance the higher she goes. Sohyang isn’t putting forth more effort. She’s just optimizing her resonance and projection.
I think the only thing I don't like about Natalie is her vibrato. It's a little bit slow for my taste. When it comes to volume control Sohyang is far better.
Sohyang. Easy. N somebody here said, natalie shows less struggle, umm, it doesnt mean they are "better". Natalie has her good points of c, great range great pitch strong notes good agility but thats it. Sohyang not only has a true connected voice but an overall revolutionary technique of full range that she uses excluding her lows. Her technique is the reason her middle belts are not thaat strong bcz its actually her bridge. No other singer in that technique or a truly connected voice can produce such controlled, balanced, resonant notes. N her technique is also why her notes of mid belt dont require her to shout like any chesty singer. Sohyang is on a completely different lvl i think.
Natalie has resonant in her range but So Hyang is more brighter in resonance and fully supported and without a sound of tension in her upper range belt from C5 until Bb5 even B5 to highest soprano C6 and C#6 in full voice in mix.
i Disagree so much with all of these comments. I think there are more factors in this, most of the natalie vocals are live phone recordings, sohyang could be processed (not saying they are, just could be) because of the tv production. Also, i dont really think Sohyang is the best at the highest parts. E5 SH was a bit pushy. F5 i would call them equally good, f#5 SH was a bit pushy, G5 Natalie was a bit pushy, G#5 SO was just a tiny more pushy than natalie but both were kinda pushy, and A/Bb5 was equal. When is comes to technique and sound quality of the voice. Rest is perferance from the listener, i think.
They both have great mixed ranges (with slightly different approaches) and are really well-matched in this part of their voices. Of course, Natalie is far better in her chest range and lower register, so she's more complete, but I agree that she comes across as "boring." lol So although she's better technically, I couldn't imagine myself listening to her. Nothing against her personally, though. Both of these ladies are fantastic.
technically better? I think they are almost on par with an edge to Sohyang due to her having more dynamic range (volume control) and stamina. Sohyangs stamina is just from an other world.
Andreanata Noivan They are not almost on par. Natalie at least competes with Sohyang throughout her mixed range, but Sohyang cannot compete at all in her chest register, especially in the lower range.
KoreanMusicSubs nope. They're more or less on par as overall. Nice try with that overused & repetitive, but pathetic argument you keep using against Sohyang tho.
Andreanata Noivan Nice try at trying to make it look like you have something useful to say. The fact of the matter is, the evidence bears me out. There's no evidence that Sohyang is anywhere near Natalie in the chest range, especially the lower register. Natalie, however, has a body of work showcasing great skill throughout her mix register.
Lordu It's not inconsistent, she just only has two lol. She also has a few supported D3s in her BDTR videos. I'd be willing to give her C#3/D3 - Bb5/B5 - D6 because her C#3s had far too much connection and projection to sound like they were just happy accidents and she has never sung above D6 for some reason.
in terms in agility,Natalie can easily shattered Sohyang,because Sohyang's agility is so limited not to mention the riffs,runs,vocal transition and melismatic control,Sohyang is only great in upper belts and head voice.
There's some bias opinions in here Natalie is great wtf y'all talking about everyone choosing sohyang because they're Korean In most of the people in the comments are Chinese Korean or whatever
If you think that perfect technique equals to boring then I recommend you to listen to Christina Aguilera. Probably checking out my video of her would be a start!
@@terilloss lol, i'd rather hear christina aguilera's strained than natalie weiss "perfect technique" u just can sit and watch her belting every single time, meanwhile i can hear soul, emotion, rasp, pain in xtina's voice.
That was not even close. Sohyang blew her away. Sohyang is more technically perfect,and has much better pitch control. Natalie's pitch wavered too many times to even be considered in the same league as Sohyang. There are many many singers who can attempt and hit those same notes, but nobody is as perfect as Sohyang. I have watched every one of these battle videos from so many different posters, and I have yet to find one that Sohyang loses.
pickin4you Dude sohyang has pitch correction in all of these clips, if you can't hear that then you can't tell that Natalie is pitch perfect. I lovw sohyang but her pitch is bad and her only real flaw.
Sorry, but I will kindly disagree with you. I have ALMOST perfect pitch myself. Also noticed by music teachers all of my life. If we were playing a tune, and the director stopped, he would ask me who was out of tune, and I could pick them out every single time. There is also a vocal coach in Turkey who has critiqued her singing and has never heard a single note off. His is not one of the new so called Vocal coaches we see so many of now on RUclips. He has been around awhile, and he just does not do a reaction. He will stop the video and EXPLAIN why she does what she does, and what she does that he wished all singers could do.. He calls her MASTER. Go look him up. I am not commenting about you having bad hearing, i am just saying that mine is better than yours. Sohyang's pitch is the most perfect pitch I have ever heard, and I am 57 years old. Think what you wish, and I will KNOW what I KNOW.
Actually, many of Sohyang's performances on TV shows are pitch-corrected. Her intonation issue starts to appear more in live non-broadcasted performances. Your comment make it sounds like Sohyang is pitch perfect when she's entirely not. But that's not a bad thing tho bcuz she's human. She bound to make mistakes. Her pitch flaws is the most obvious when she's sick & when she goes to upperbelts area. & it's not necessarily her flaw since she rarely goes off-pitch for the entire performance, or it's very often showing. Nonetheless, it's still there & she's getting it improved. I'd say Natalie's intonation is less flawed consistently tho.
That wavering is called vibrato and sohyang's vibrato isn't even close to natalie's. Natalie's videos are taken through mobile cam's. Both are great tho but Natalie is an all rounder from lows to mids and then highs also marvelous agility, precision and tone and amazing resonance and support throughout the register. Sohyang is amazing too and her upperbelts are flawless.
![[8K] 소향 Sohyang - I Have Nothing(전율-서울5, 20240511)](/img/1.gif)
Natalie’s Eb5 is the best thing ever omg. This isn’t a battle actually, it was more likely a preference. They are sooooo good.
Hey, I love your channel. Could you see my cover and give me your opinion please? I would be very grateful to you ruclips.net/video/DUEb2UVVd3E/видео.html
Perfect singers!!!!
Could you see my new cover and tell me your opinion please? Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
They’re both equal in technique, it all comes down to preference
I Worship Gays And Satan And Natalie has more resonance on her mid belts, better vocal agility and an incredible and well projected low register...
@@iworshipgaysandsatan6822 Just cuz someone can reach C6 dosen't mean they are suitable. Ofcourse sohyang is impeccable in upperbelts. But natalie's agility will smash sohyang in that criteria sohyang is nothing in front of natalie when it comes down to agility. Also her astounding low register.
Avantika Roy you guys assume that because she’s more agile she’s a better singer then? Better lows, yeah, I’m saying sohyangs range is more expansive and she is belting B5s with great technique, the past few years the highest note Natalie has hit is a G#5 and I’m not saying “Sohyang has higher notes thus she is better” I’m saying she’s hitting higher notes with great technique consistently over a long period of time. She does a similar thing to Natalie, just higher.
Isn’t natelie a Mezzo? Whatever fache she is, it of course means her lows are better and mids are so resonant. Sohyangs high belts are so resonant because her tessitura is so high.
Also the quality of natelies clips will alter the amount of resonance natelie is actually outputting, cameras back then have a resonance peak and will cap out and make her voice sound more powerful and more resonant.
Agility isn’t everything, by that logic Christina Aguilera is one of the best vocalists ever.
@@iworshipgaysandsatan6822 first of all wtf are you srsly starting? I said "Natalie can beat Sohyang in the AGILITY criteria" this does not mean she is better than her or worse. Sohyang is agile as well but not as Natalie. Just as Sohyang's tessitura allows her to belt stong and supported upperbelts ...Natalie's agile voice allows her to beautify her songs on the basis of that. The person in the original comment said that "Sohyang can belt upto C6#" which clearly had no base in it's meaning and just shows that the person is comparing the on the basis of range. Range is not everything that was what I was implying. Just like Natalie shines in mid and upper too Sohyang's upperbelts are of no match to Natalie cuz they (sohyang's) are that good. And ofcourse as you mentioned, even if natalie is a mezzo props to her belting above F5-F5# with this ease and support and resonance, which brings me to think that she is probably not a mezzo. Natalie's lower register is much prominent and better than Sohyangs who is clearly developing recently, just as sohyang's upper register is greater than natalie. Pls READ the comment properly before answering. I'm a huge Sohyang fan too but I acknowledge her weakness and appreciate her improvement instead of just coming at ppl who appreciate it too. And I think that is sooo stupid of you to compare a remarkable vocalist like Natalie to oversinging strainer like christina. You could do better. Show some respect atleast.
Avantika Roy you’re twisting my argument. I said what I said about you two basing the quality of a singer on agility because the only thing you two mentioned basically was how natelies agility is better than Sohyangs as a response to who is better as a vocalist.
Yeah natelie can belt and have her headvoice high because she was trained in opera and broadway which is pure technique and how to make everything powerful etc.
I wasn’t saying Christina is comparable to Natelie, you’re twisting what I said I said “by that logic (in reference to agility making a good singer of which you both implied) Christina is one of he best vocalists” which the subtext is “Christina is not one of the best vocalists ever, agility does not make a good singer, that is frail logic “
I was not genuinely comparing the two. Clearly.
That ending though with Demi Lovato at 3:31 was priceless 😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
natalie's voice is really sweet and powerful!wow!
In my opinion:
C5: SoHyang
C#5: Tie
D5: Tie
Eb5: Natalie
E5: Natalie (SoHyang's Fate E5 would have been good here)
F5: SoHyang
First F#5: Natalie
Second F#5: SoHyang
First G5: SoHyang
Second G5: SoHyang
G#5: Natalie
A5: SoHyang
Bb5: SoHyang
Both of their belting techniques are technically flawless and then both have incredible resonance all the way up to Bb5so it's basically a tie. But preference wise I'll give the win to SoHyang just due to the fact that I find her belts to be a lot more intense and more powerful.
+RyderC Daniels True, in this case SoHyang has a more interesting tone, besides that she has more vocal stamina and vocal range. Natalie has a slight piercing tone but she sounds a little "bored"? I mean, she just sounds like a vocal technique teacher who performs covers. SoHyang sounds like a true vocalist, singer and artist on stage. Anyway I think this is a good comparison because both are incredible vocalists with perfect techniques. In this case you and I have the same opinion, but you already know that everything is "subjective" and that each person has your own preferences. I am very proud and happy that you see my videos, so from the bottom of my heart, I say thank you so much Dear 💕 I invite you to subscribe to my channel!
The Mermaids Of Tartarus¡ XTINAJENNIDEMIARIMIMI I agreed and I'll definitely subscribe.
I agree. And yes, Sohyang has a strongest voice because of her vocal Fach, She is a Full-Lyric Soprano while Natalie is a (pure) Lyric, aka Light-Lyric, that's why her upper register sounds girly/youthful, while SoHyang's sounds more womanly. Love them
Angel Frost its the opposite for me. Sohyang’s tone is very average (plain tone without character) for an asian singer. And sohyang is actually the one more piercing due to her nasal resonance.
@@rydercdaniels4475 Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? I'm not a singer, but I love to sing xD Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
I vote for Sohyang, but i would use different notes for her, like the E5 from Fate, or D5 in Home, or Eb5 from fate as well....
I prefer Natalie
Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
My favorite singer is sohyang but natalie is gooood too!
Trinity of this generation : Natalie, Sohyang, Beyonce
I love both
C5: tie leaning to Natalie (SoHyang wasnt being belty but I love the tonal balance)
C#5: tie (same as the C5, Natalie's beltier but SoHyang is rounder and more tonally balanced)
D5: SoHyang (SoHyang is more open and resonant)
Eb5: Natalie (no doubt that Eb5 from Natalie is divine. It was more resonant than SoHyang's Eb5 here and more open)
E5: SoHyang (SoHyang is more resonant and more open)
F5: SoHyang (same here)
F#5 (2): SoHyang (SoHyang's is not only more resonant & open, it's also excellently dynamically controlled and it had an absolutely FLAWLESS heady mix to balanced mix transition)
From this point on there is no need for an explanation bc it's the same stuff👇
F#5 (2): SoHyang
G5 (1): SoHyang
G5 (2): SoHyang
G#5: SoHyang
A5: SoHyang
Bb5: SoHyang
Cracked up at the end😂😂😂😂
Great video👍
Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
Marios POS kinda wrong like on the f5 sohyang was not more open it was equal and the g#5 Natalie sounded fuller with more resonance and the a5 equal both great but about f#5 I think the second one Natalie bc sohyang was nasal and the bb5 is equal unless u think held for longer = better I mean the stamina
And the first g5 sohyang did not sound free of tension but Natalie sounded better
I mean in the first g5
@@l.a.a.c2055 im a Natalie stan too
Sohyang for upperbelts, but when phrasing midbelt lyrics she tends to get nasal excluding the twang thing. But natalie's tone is extremly beautiful and she's one of the most agile singers of this gen. A category which sohyang isn't that good at. But its a 50-50 for me.
Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? I'm not a singer, but I love to sing xD Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
I think the g5 should be from bridge over troubled water
So hyang Resonance Queen 👸🎶🎼🎤 Bb5가 소향님이 가볍게 불러서 😅
Upto Eb5 Natalie then Sohyang
Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
C5: Natalie
C#5: Natalie
D5:Sohyang
Eb5: Tie
E5: Natalie
F5: Natalie
F#5: Natalie
G5: Sohyang
G#5:Natalie
A5:Sohyang
Bb5:Sohyang
JSJSJSJW THE END 😂😂😂😂😂, Demi Q18 ended sohyang and Natalie at the same time
Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
The fact that Natalie included this in her playlist called fan compilation makes me so happy that she is aware of Sohyang's existence.
Natalie has this video in her "fan compilations" playlist !
what? seriously? 😱😱😱
@@angiefrost4805 yes !
And natalie's ease is like....piece of cake. Sohyang is goddess but there is not a sting of effort in natalie's face tho. Bothe are monsters.
Sohyang is just like being emotional. Have you ever heard her effortless version ?
LM5hassnatchedme already Maybe you should check clips when SoHyang is rehearsing. She like smiles when belting an A5.
Her face is her feeling the song
Sohyang isn’t actually putting in any effort. Her facial expressions are for the sake of emotion and showmanship. If you watch her rehearse, she can belt B5s with a face so relaxed that you’d just assume she’s breathing. Sohyang also opens her mouth wide to provide for the largest resonance possible and a darker tone. Natalie tends to lighten her mix and resonance the higher she goes. Sohyang isn’t putting forth more effort. She’s just optimizing her resonance and projection.
I think the only thing I don't like about Natalie is her vibrato. It's a little bit slow for my taste. When it comes to volume control Sohyang is far better.
Sohyang. Easy. N somebody here said, natalie shows less struggle, umm, it doesnt mean they are "better". Natalie has her good points of c, great range great pitch strong notes good agility but thats it. Sohyang not only has a true connected voice but an overall revolutionary technique of full range that she uses excluding her lows. Her technique is the reason her middle belts are not thaat strong bcz its actually her bridge. No other singer in that technique or a truly connected voice can produce such controlled, balanced, resonant notes. N her technique is also why her notes of mid belt dont require her to shout like any chesty singer. Sohyang is on a completely different lvl i think.
Oh and Natalie's stamina n support fails nor she is as consistant as sohyang even in mid belts. No cmnts needed on the difference in "mix".
Zaid Khan what are you even talking about?
Both are Flawless singers, Sohyang range is wider, but she’s too shouty
so I’ll give it to Natalie
NICOLAS CAILLABET did you just say sohyang was shout- ok nvm i won’t start
Joseph Davis Yh that was stupid she has a perfectly balanced mix
Natalie has resonant in her range but So Hyang is more brighter in resonance and fully supported and without a sound of tension in her upper range belt from C5 until Bb5 even B5 to highest soprano C6 and C#6 in full voice in mix.
Natalie has no tension???
oh ma god, my two favourite singers 💀
Natalie has much more resonance, in the entire range
bitch i dont need introduction Not really, SoHyang is much more resonant from G5-Bb5
Cash Cow no, Natalie is. Just listen to her G#5 and Bb5 and then listen to SoHyang's
bitch i dont need introduction Did and it's like I said, SoHyang is more resonant.
Cash Cow you're not a good listener then
bitch i dont need introduction
Did you even hear so hyangs Bb5?
Sohyang is the best
Natalie Weiss
The end 😂😂😂😂😂
Sohyang for me
i Disagree so much with all of these comments.
I think there are more factors in this, most of the natalie vocals are live phone recordings, sohyang could be processed (not saying they are, just could be) because of the tv production.
Also, i dont really think Sohyang is the best at the highest parts.
E5 SH was a bit pushy. F5 i would call them equally good, f#5 SH was a bit pushy, G5 Natalie was a bit pushy, G#5 SO was just a tiny more pushy than natalie but both were kinda pushy, and A/Bb5 was equal. When is comes to technique and sound quality of the voice.
Rest is perferance from the listener, i think.
do you know where i could find Natalie's Bb5 :)
1:33 song?
Natalie is better hands down. She is too good
They both have great mixed ranges (with slightly different approaches) and are really well-matched in this part of their voices. Of course, Natalie is far better in her chest range and lower register, so she's more complete, but I agree that she comes across as "boring." lol So although she's better technically, I couldn't imagine myself listening to her. Nothing against her personally, though. Both of these ladies are fantastic.
technically better? I think they are almost on par with an edge to Sohyang due to her having more dynamic range (volume control) and stamina. Sohyangs stamina is just from an other world.
Nope. Natalie isn't technically better. They're actually almost on par.
Andreanata Noivan They are not almost on par. Natalie at least competes with Sohyang throughout her mixed range, but Sohyang cannot compete at all in her chest register, especially in the lower range.
KoreanMusicSubs nope. They're more or less on par as overall. Nice try with that overused & repetitive, but pathetic argument you keep using against Sohyang tho.
Andreanata Noivan Nice try at trying to make it look like you have something useful to say. The fact of the matter is, the evidence bears me out. There's no evidence that Sohyang is anywhere near Natalie in the chest range, especially the lower register. Natalie, however, has a body of work showcasing great skill throughout her mix register.
what is the natalie's nationality? America?
Lordu She has supported C#3s too.
Lordu It's not inconsistent, she just only has two lol. She also has a few supported D3s in her BDTR videos. I'd be willing to give her C#3/D3 - Bb5/B5 - D6 because her C#3s had far too much connection and projection to sound like they were just happy accidents and she has never sung above D6 for some reason.
Well hasn't she also supported some B5s too? I checked in some vocal range videos of her.
SuperPianogirl123 where are the D3’s?
omgggg
piece of TRASH SCREAMER! Filipino Just
And you’re rude Korean who hates any Filipino singer
Natalie’s focused, pure tone…sohyang everything else. Natalie’s vibrato really annoys me because it seems so contrived and slow.
in terms in agility,Natalie can easily shattered Sohyang,because Sohyang's agility is so limited not to mention the riffs,runs,vocal transition and melismatic control,Sohyang is only great in upper belts and head voice.
@Dena QuewNatalie upper belts was good actually,she can easily improved in that area.
There's some bias opinions in here
Natalie is great wtf y'all talking about
everyone choosing sohyang because they're Korean
In most of the people in the comments are Chinese Korean or whatever
Sohyang's G5 in Bridge over the water should be used in this video
Natalie for sure!
they are bith so good, but i prefer Natalie, since her voice overall is better i think. She gets abnormally low and her riffs are out of this world.
Natalie it is obvious
3:26 😆
Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
Sohyang 100%.
Is it just me or is Natalie just really incredibly boring??
Yeah, definitely just you
If you think that perfect technique equals to boring then I recommend you to listen to Christina Aguilera. Probably checking out my video of her would be a start!
@@terilloss lol, i'd rather hear christina aguilera's strained than natalie weiss "perfect technique" u just can sit and watch her belting every single time, meanwhile i can hear soul, emotion, rasp, pain in xtina's voice.
@@vikavanesya3611 yeah the pain is definitely in her voice, that shitty technique just HAS to hurt
Both are really amazing but I prefer Natalie's tone over Sohyang. I just don't like her nasally thin voice.
Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
Misha Dreamer Its not thin considering that shes a full lyric soprano
Natalie's voice is lighter though. Sohyang's is anything but thin.
That was not even close. Sohyang blew her away. Sohyang is more technically perfect,and has much better pitch control. Natalie's pitch wavered too many times to even be considered in the same league as Sohyang. There are many many singers who can attempt and hit those same notes, but nobody is as perfect as Sohyang. I have watched every one of these battle videos from so many different posters, and I have yet to find one that Sohyang loses.
pickin4you
Dude sohyang has pitch correction in all of these clips, if you can't hear that then you can't tell that Natalie is pitch perfect. I lovw sohyang but her pitch is bad and her only real flaw.
Sorry, but I will kindly disagree with you. I have ALMOST perfect pitch myself. Also noticed by music teachers all of my life. If we were playing a tune, and the director stopped, he would ask me who was out of tune, and I could pick them out every single time. There is also a vocal coach in Turkey who has critiqued her singing and has never heard a single note off. His is not one of the new so called Vocal coaches we see so many of now on RUclips. He has been around awhile, and he just does not do a reaction. He will stop the video and EXPLAIN why she does what she does, and what she does that he wished all singers could do.. He calls her MASTER. Go look him up. I am not commenting about you having bad hearing, i am just saying that mine is better than yours. Sohyang's pitch is the most perfect pitch I have ever heard, and I am 57 years old. Think what you wish, and I will KNOW what I KNOW.
Actually, many of Sohyang's performances on TV shows are pitch-corrected. Her intonation issue starts to appear more in live non-broadcasted performances. Your comment make it sounds like Sohyang is pitch perfect when she's entirely not. But that's not a bad thing tho bcuz she's human. She bound to make mistakes. Her pitch flaws is the most obvious when she's sick & when she goes to upperbelts area. & it's not necessarily her flaw since she rarely goes off-pitch for the entire performance, or it's very often showing. Nonetheless, it's still there & she's getting it improved. I'd say Natalie's intonation is less flawed consistently tho.
That wavering is called vibrato and sohyang's vibrato isn't even close to natalie's. Natalie's videos are taken through mobile cam's. Both are great tho but Natalie is an all rounder from lows to mids and then highs also marvelous agility, precision and tone and amazing resonance and support throughout the register. Sohyang is amazing too and her upperbelts are flawless.
@@avantikaroy5146 i disagree. Natalie's vibrato too slow, it's not a technical flaw, but for me it is an stilistic one.
Neither... I pick Demi at the outro lmao