I'm currently researching the interwar period, and i'm starting off with the fall of the four empires, is there any resources you would recommend about the collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire?
CinnamonGamer the allies control in my game the balkans and greece despite greece fighting along the allies, now greece only controls an island and then there is poland which is a puppet of romania but is also in the allies despite that romania is not and tgen there is also the mess that poland had to release ukraine and belarus, meaning the democratic germany that joined the allies can't attack the soviets and has to fight tgrough the entire middle east and up the caucausus and central asia to enter the USSR.
1:06 What should Hungary do against a 3-front invasion? a) Set in favorable terrain and defend b) Set a defence around their capital c) Ask the Entente for help >(d)< INVADE SLOVAKIA REEEEEE
The Entente had forbade Hungary from moving troops to the areas occupied by Serbia and Romania, rendering both reconquest and defense infeasible. Romania took the opportunity to march basically uncontested straight to the capital. The hungarian government had envisioned that some kind of military success was still necessary, this is why they launched a pointless attack against the lightly defended Slovakia. All this was not part of the Entente's plan, so later they showed up and reassigned the territories according to their linking.
The islamic conquest of the parts of the roman empire, right up to toulouse and vienna seems to be hard to be remembered. When Rome crumbled, the bread basket (egypt) and many religious sites were conquered in a rather fast rate, shocking christianity at the time.
They are mentioned in middle school history books though. Very small mention. Literally just saying that the First World War led to the collapse of the three multi-ethnic empires: Russia, Ottomans and Austria-Hungary. That's all I've learned at least. I guess it depends where you live. I am pretty sure ex-Yugoslavs, Romanians, Hungarians and other people groups that were affected in the past by these events are taught about them in school. Mostly because the system wants them to learn about their country's past and possibly learn from its mistakes.
Andrew Vasirov yeah they always say that they collapsed but never go into detail of the other treaties of WW1. They only delve into the Treaty of Versailles and how the Europeans cheated the Arabs.
Lewis Irwin Techniaclly you can say that Austria was a participant in the Second World War with their annexation and Hitlers nationality. Hungary as well was a player on the eastern front. The collapse of the Ottomans meanwhile lead to the foundation of Turkey, the Armenian Genocide, and a lasting impact on the Middle East. Clearly they are important to study.
You're missing the Sopron Plebstice of December 1921, when a major Hungarian city ceded to Austria voted to return to Hungary. Your map already shows Sopron as part of Hungary after the signing of Trianon, even though (on paper) it was under Austran control between June 1920 and December 1921.
Watching this from Budapest. I have this theory that, to this day, Hungarians are a bit depressed because of Trianon. That's probably why they drink so much
Could Be Anybody Because it kept peace in the balkans,and for the most part it was stable,altleast the austrian side. Hungary never deserved so much land,but a federalized austria would’ve.
Read Margaret McMillan's 'The Peacemakers', it deals with with the Peace talks both chronologically and by geographical area. The whole thing was a fiasco, didn't really reflect well on the Western Powers at all.
I don't know if you are hungarian or not but the communist government that tried to rule then destroyed hungary by going to war with all of this nations at once
Idiot, Franz died in 1916 so he didn't die with the empire. Also Austria Hungary was gonna die any way because it had a lot of slovaks, Serbian, Bosnian and more who all wanted their independence.
@@ab.6573 well Ferdinand d'Este wanted to reform the Empire... if they would not shoot him he would reform the Empire into some kind of Federation and maybe it would survive in some form..
@@ab.6573 Go place your "austria only collapse..nationalism" somewhere else. If that was truely the case Austria would have collapsed years ago. No. Most people of the empires were content besides extremist nationalists,and the fact that the Croats,Czechs and Hungarians stood woth the empire until it’s fall shows there were lotal ethnics
One interesting oddity not shown on the map (because it was so small) was the city of Fiume, which was established as an independent state by a Italian poet who intended to turn the territory over to Italy. After his condemnation by the Italian government, he ruled it as a proto fascist state until the city was put under siege and bombarded by the Italian navy in December 1920. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gabriele_D%27Annunzio#Fiume
@@Medvelelet you dont know how you almost destroyed their culture and language? You tried to do that exactly same like austrians tried to germanise us(im Czech)
@@hannibalbarca7220 thanks for corrections, i thought that because hungarians often say that they are descedants of huns, some even say that they are turkic(probably very few hungarians)
@@iwillsalt3459 Transylvania is pure sacred Romanian land. Its ancestors, the Dacians have being there centuries before the Hungarians, the Hungarians weren't even the tenth in Transylvania. While they were trying to cross the Ural Mountains the Romans came along, the Bulgarians, Cumans etc. Demographicaly, Transylvania is Romanian. Great Hungary was 48,1% Hungarian in 1900, while Great Romania was 83,8% in 1927 you see.
@@saulenfischbearn7470 Yes, true, I can't hide the fact that the region mentioned has a Hungarian majority. Though there is a problem. Teaching the population Hungarian when they are in Romania is wrong, they should be allowed to speak their language between them, but the communication in hospitals, schools, or with the police and other public stuff should be in the national and official language. The Hungarian majority is also well-known for not serving anything at a shop because you spoke Romanian in Romania. Another problem is public signs, everything is also written below in Hungarian, anywhere where there is a 20% Hungarian population (alright, I understand, somewhere where Hungarians are majority, but in places like Hunedoara or Oradea, to have Hungarian translation on every public sign is exagerated, they don't even represent 25% of the population) ...Well weren't they the people who said they ruled over Transylvania for nine centuries, even if for some time they were conquered by the Austrians until 1867... They didn't wrote in Romanian below, even if it had in some places a total majority. They didn't give permission to teach Romanian in school... So...Yeah...I thought we were in Romania, they have citizenship, every single Hungarian in szeklerland has Romanian citizenship. They should be able to speak Romanian and shouldn't need translation on every sign.
Sander Skovly Germans weren't expelled from South Tyrol. And after World War II they were treated very well by the government, to the point where South Tyrol had the highest GDP per capita in Italy.
Sander Skovly I'd argue with the reason that South Tyrol is richer is that it is part of a Special Statute Region, so they pay less taxes and other things. Interestingly, both Italy and Austria had the same problem, industry-wise, it was concentrated in a specific part of the country, the North in Italy and Austria proper and Bohemia in Austria, with the rest of both countries being more agriculture-based. Also, didn't know pre-WW1 South Tyrol had much industry, though it would be kind of hard to build, considering it's on the Alps.
Sander Skovly The ones who have that autonomy are Sardinia, which more or less needed it, as part of that autonomy is language rights, and Sardinia is a pretty distinct language, and Sicily, which, if I'm remember correctly, the government was forced to grant autonomy by America, because the Sicilian Mafia helped them during the invasion of Sicily. Thing is, South Tyrol is in the north, while Sicily and Sardinia are in the south, the south was mismanaged for generations, and is still recovering, as a result of that, industry isn't very developed, and the major industriali center in the south (Taranto, also the main military port) is Italy's most polluted city. And then there's the Mafia, and the Camorra, and the 'ndrangheta, and the general corruption found in all the the country. Altough, prices are generally lower in the south, both housing and goods, so it's not like the South is poor, Campania, the poorest of the regions per capita, has a higher GDP per Capita than Turkey, for example. The main problem, though, is that the country is deeply divided into North and South, with one resembling France or Germany and the other resembling Greece, respectively.
Sander Skovly No, but the electoral results show that divide, the Five Star Movement won the majority of the votes in the entire South (and Sardinia), while in the North, the votes were more mixed.
wow, i had literally no idea that the breakup of austria-hungary was so chaotic (in retrospect, it should have been obvious, it is the balkans). i was very surprised that hungary was socialist
I watch these videos and I think they're so cool seeing the conquests of nations and dominant emperors. But I take for granted that for every territorial change, a son was killed, a daughter was raped. Let's never forget that life should never be taken for granted.
As a Slovenian I see two mistakes here: 1. The state of SHS stands for State of Slovene, Croats and Serbs, after merging with Serbia we took the name Kingdom of SHS and then the SHS stood for Serbs, Croats and Slovenes. 2. There were missing occupations of Austria in late 1918 (Maribor and loverly styria) and may on parts of the disputed territory of Carinthia
Who would win? A great and powerful empire Some slavic boi's Yes i know romanians and italians are not slavic if i include all of them it wont be as funny, to many butthurt people.....
Mervan _Canoglu Slavic boys here: -Serbs -Montenegrians Not slavic: -Italians -Romanians I wrote the people who fought against A-H, Czech and polish didn't do an amazing job
Exactly, you cannot see deported people from Hungary in our history of the thousand year. Every Hungarian family were concerned in this. And we have got it from ... I can only see flags with the same colours... but, but Hungarian-speaking nations, where are they? Székelys Csángós. Why their numbers are reduced? I was only six, when my grandmother took us to our relatives to Csallóköz (Slovakia now) and there everybody understood our language, and they warned me: "Please, you should not use the Hungarian language outside in for example in the markets!..." Why? -I asked. They did not want problems... - in 1978. One, who, do not feel or can not feel this here, it is only a red internationalist.
For stability, there was a high percentage of Germans in Czechia and of Hungarians in Slovakia. A ``Czechoslovakian`` country was a good solution, Slovaks weren't against this union as there wasn't a true Slovak identity yet and Germans and Hungarians communities were much smaller in this new country, preserving it from a secession. Sadly Hitler came and we know what happened.
There was also a theory at the time that nations of under 8 milion just could not survive. This sparked many movments to form larger slavic nations. Czechoslovakia worked out far better than the other one; Yugoslavia (That idea was critisied even at that time).
I think yugoslavia is a great idea. It should exist today as well. Croatian, Bosnian and Serbian languages are identical. Religoius differences should matter. Look at Germany. The bavarian dialect and hamburger dialect are radically different even morethan croatian and serbian. Protestants in the north, catholics in the south. Yet a single country for all germans is a succes story! why not for south-western slavs? It should have worked.
I believe Ivan Cankar the slovene writter said it best in 1917. " We are brothers by blood, cousins by language (he was a slovene), and complete strangers by history." All south slavs never shared a common state and 500 years of Ottoman rule in the south and Habsburg rule in the North created a massive cultural devide. Germans had a common state for most of their history (HRE and the german confederation). While the HRE was never as unified as France or Russia it was still common ground. It is not about language or religion. It is about history and culture. I belive a slovene-croatian union would have worked as well as Czecho-slovakia, and a southern Greater Serbia with Montenegro and Bosnia could have worked better. But by history it made more sense for Slovenia to be a part of Austria, than to be in a country with serbia.
Some of my ancestors are from western Ukraine, around Lviv. My great-great-grandfather knew he would be conscripted by someone, he just wanted to know which army it would be, and that was why he left.
Richard Roberson You do realize how long it took them to “beat them”, how much equipment and munitions were lost, and how many casualties it costed, right?
You missed the existence of Zakopane republic (Rzeczpospolita Zakopiańska)which was located between Poland and Slovakia (part of Czechoslovakia) and existed from 13th october to 16 th november (for 35 days) and soonly after Poland was formed it became annexed by it
I really love this video!!! This is something I was really interested in but also really confused about what actually happened. I really appreciate this
Austria-Hungary was not a country. It was an empire. They occupied neighboring countries for centuries. Those populations never asked to be occupied. It's like an Indian today would say: My grandparents were from England, weird they came from a country that doesn't exist anymore. What country?!?
@@m.dewylde5287 holy crap this comment is almost 2 years old, do you have nothing better to do with your time? Well I edited my comment to appease you anyway.
@@jdftrains3507 So, aren't you curios what country they did come from? Austria, Hungary, Croatia, Slovenia, Czechia, Slovakia, Romania, Ukraine? These were all in the empire that you called a country and a state, which was neither.
@@m.dewylde5287 I already know where they are from because of my mothers maiden name, and the word state can be used to describe any sovereign land regardless of location and government. For example "Narrowly defined, an empire is a sovereign state whose head of state is an emperor" ~from Wikipedia
So... Why isn't D'Annunzio's adventure saluti in Fiume/Rijeka represented? It was a pretty important event for both Italy and Europe. And D'Annunzio is also a pretty interesting character.
Everyone’s saying it looks so ugly after Austria Hungary collapsed, and yes, it does for a bit, when the fighting continues, but come on. After it is settled and modern day too the borders do NOT look messy. The borders are very clean and generally I prefer more countries in a map than less, it makes it better
Gott erhalte Franz, den Kaiser, Unsern guten Kaiser Franz! Lange lebe Franz, der Kaiser, In des Glückes hellstem Glanz! Ihm erblühen Lorbeerreiser, Wo er geht, zum Ehrenkranz! Gott erhalte Franz, den Kaiser, Unsern guten Kaiser Franz! Gott erhalte Franz, den Kaiser, Unsern guten Kaiser Franz!
Hungary was accepted as an entity separated from the empire, but not independent It was still a regional power for the other nations oppresed in the empire
Bogdan you are just a tipical stoupid nationalsit kido just dont write anything please. You only write stoupid things . You had mroe rights than hugnarians right now in the 21th centoury. And what you say then? :D think of transylvania you were accepted , hungarians didnt hate you. Maybe for 1848 13000 hungarian was killed by romanians.
Romanians were for centuries "tolerated" in their homeland. They were seen as how we see gypsies Should i really bring up the forced magyarization and everything that happened...? but noooo, the Hungarians sure had no problem with the Romanians, i mean they were totally fine
It gives you the right to humiliate a country having a civilwar and no army?With 3 or 4 other? And take Northern transylvania and vojvodia and the stouhern parts of slovakia where the hungarians were in majority? It gives you any right to rob? This is your rass , it is not asian or anything else , this is called romanian and you are suprised , that all of hungary and people through europe call you thieves? Remember what did the french prime minister said or governor after trianon. We wished that he had never let romania take so much land, and the others from Hungary. This is why they said , that trianon will only we accepted if they give rights to every hungarian. So in reality you didnt own transylvania till the peace of Paris after the ww2 because you have never fulfilled that point.
I was always under the impression that the Sudetenland was kind of manufactured by the Nazis for a casus belli to invade. Interesting to see it was added onto Czechoslovakia after the country was formed.
On 24 November 1918 Srem/Srijem separated from DSHS and connected with Serbia. PS Thanks for video. I was thinking about similiar (from Armistice of Bulgaria to 31 XII 1918) watching your World War I just 3 days ago :)
The only reason I liked Austria-Hungary being there was because it made Europe look clean and there wasn't 10 billion countries in the Balkans and instead it was 7
First, State of Slovenes, Croats and Serbs included Bosnia and Herzegovina. Second, that state didn't have control of most of its territory so serbian army continued offensive. Serbian army even fought some battles in Austria.
I'm sorry SE Asia keeps taking so long. So here's this to make up for it. I've gotten requests for this for a while now.
I'm currently researching the interwar period, and i'm starting off with the fall of the four empires, is there any resources you would recommend about the collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire?
History of Southeast Asia ??????????????????
Nah mate I understand you fam just keep it going well for you
How far are you?
EmperorTigerstar wait... Didn't AustriaHungary collapsed by the treaty of the end of WW1? I thought the end of AH was peaceful... I was wrong
This reminds me of the horrors of a peace deal in Hoi4
*Traumatic memories*
The end is like using console commands to fix it.
Player lead peace conference boi
*Spanish Crimea PTSD*
CinnamonGamer the allies control in my game the balkans and greece despite greece fighting along the allies, now greece only controls an island and then there is poland which is a puppet of romania but is also in the allies despite that romania is not and tgen there is also the mess that poland had to release ukraine and belarus, meaning the democratic germany that joined the allies can't attack the soviets and has to fight tgrough the entire middle east and up the caucausus and central asia to enter the USSR.
1912: 4 countries.
2019: 15 countries. The border gore is real
1/2 of them ex yugoslavian👌👌👌👌👌🅱️🅱️🅱️
yep
@Alex like half of the 15 countries are the ones that popped up after Yugoslavia collapsed.
2050 : 50 countries
@King Victor Emanuele no dude real life isnt a paradox game theres a reason why austria fell
WW1: "War to end all wars"
2 seconds after it ends: *n O*
THE SUN IS A DEADLY LAZER
Do not confuse war with the scale of WW1 and "simple" war
@@nahlokin6509 Considering it had never happened before, I’m going to go ahead and assume the person who coined the phrase really meant *all* wars.
@@CraftsmanOfAwsomenes I mean, there was the 7 years war but idk much about it.
Nice pfp
1:06
What should Hungary do against a 3-front invasion?
a) Set in favorable terrain and defend
b) Set a defence around their capital
c) Ask the Entente for help
>(d)< INVADE SLOVAKIA REEEEEE
KnownNiche Czech had to take Slovakia by force in 1918-1919
KnownNiche
>Hungary
>favorable terrain
I don’t think so buster
The Entente had forbade Hungary from moving troops to the areas occupied by Serbia and Romania, rendering both reconquest and defense infeasible. Romania took the opportunity to march basically uncontested straight to the capital. The hungarian government had envisioned that some kind of military success was still necessary, this is why they launched a pointless attack against the lightly defended Slovakia. All this was not part of the Entente's plan, so later they showed up and reassigned the territories according to their linking.
KnownNiche What capital defence because in 1 weak Romanians occupied the BUDA(in romanian means wc)pesta
Chill my dudes, I was just joking around
I wonder why the division of Austria and the collapse of the Ottomans are never mentioned in most history books.
The islamic conquest of the parts of the roman empire, right up to toulouse and vienna seems to be hard to be remembered. When Rome crumbled, the bread basket (egypt) and many religious sites were conquered in a rather fast rate, shocking christianity at the time.
They are mentioned in middle school history books though. Very small mention. Literally just saying that the First World War led to the collapse of the three multi-ethnic empires: Russia, Ottomans and Austria-Hungary. That's all I've learned at least.
I guess it depends where you live. I am pretty sure ex-Yugoslavs, Romanians, Hungarians and other people groups that were affected in the past by these events are taught about them in school. Mostly because the system wants them to learn about their country's past and possibly learn from its mistakes.
Andrew Vasirov yeah they always say that they collapsed but never go into detail of the other treaties of WW1. They only delve into the Treaty of Versailles and how the Europeans cheated the Arabs.
Probably because those two didn't try to take over Europe 20 years later.
Lewis Irwin Techniaclly you can say that Austria was a participant in the Second World War with their annexation and Hitlers nationality. Hungary as well was a player on the eastern front. The collapse of the Ottomans meanwhile lead to the foundation of Turkey, the Armenian Genocide, and a lasting impact on the Middle East. Clearly they are important to study.
You're missing the Sopron Plebstice of December 1921, when a major Hungarian city ceded to Austria voted to return to Hungary. Your map already shows Sopron as part of Hungary after the signing of Trianon, even though (on paper) it was under Austran control between June 1920 and December 1921.
So you are Hungarian or Croatian?
He also missed the Zakopane Republic (Rzeczpospolita Zakopiańska) which existed from october to november of year 1918 and was annexed by Poland
Guys be grateful you even got maps this detailed in the first place let’s see you do what tigerstar does
@@theboirokossovsky7081 There is always room for constructive criticism and improvement
@@theboirokossovsky7081 yeah be greatful all you want, we are just giving some improvements
Watching this from Budapest. I have this theory that, to this day, Hungarians are a bit depressed because of Trianon. That's probably why they drink so much
agreed
Can you imagine what the Austrians are feeling?
Well, Trianon is your guy's version of Versailles. Unacceptable to anyone it is enforced appon.
@@masterm3487 Saint-Germain aswell
@@R3L4X97 Austrians are just Germans in denial. After abolishment of monarchy there is no good reason for them to not unite.
Dad: why are you crying so damn loud?!
Yes why do you approve of austria-hungary lmao.
Could Be Anybody Because it kept peace in the balkans,and for the most part it was stable,altleast the austrian side. Hungary never deserved so much land,but a federalized austria would’ve.
Does your name mean Algorithmen & Wahrscheinlichkeit?
@@awormnamedscoobis3419 peace in the balkans? Say that to a 19th bosnian.
Austria-Hungary gave only tension and disorder in the balkans.
@@awormnamedscoobis3419 Peace?! Austria litterally caused the WW1!
Lay down
Try not to Cry
*_Cry alot_*
i one day shall return my child
wrg, idts. doesnt matr
Austrian Monarchist Lol, This makes me smile rather than cry
Filipeczeg
Commie
@@mecha7419 not commie, just a Polish guy :)
13 year-old Kid: Fortnite is the best battle royale !
Me:
I am 13 yo but i think that this is Best batteroyal lol
I'm 14 and Minecraft is the best battle royal gams
"Brazillian Kaiser":
Me, an intelectual
Well it is a good game ngl
NOOOOOOO!!!! Austia-Hungary! WHY!!! YOU MADE SOUTH-EAST EUROPE LOOK SO NEAT AND FINE LOOK AT IT NOW!!! IT`S MESSIER THAN MY ROOM!!!
OzonGames :D
But my borders!
Comment Review and then it gets even messier afterwards :(
Genghis please invade Eastern Europe and take Hungary and Poland and take Rome and put the popes hhead on a pike
I know. I'm born in an allied country during world war 1 but damn after world war 1 the borders got bad
Golden Memes Genghis don't work for soros
I never knew Hungary got invaded so thoroughly at the end of WWI. Certainly explains a lot of things I had questions about.
questions like? :O
Ping well actually there was some coalition of nations Hungary ruled before that if Hungary attacks one all will attack Hungary.
You don't understand anything. Hungary is a little country, nobody cares. Hungary had no real army for example, the "revolution" deleted it.
Read Margaret McMillan's 'The Peacemakers', it deals with with the Peace talks both chronologically and by geographical area. The whole thing was a fiasco, didn't really reflect well on the Western Powers at all.
I don't know if you are hungarian or not but the communist government that tried to rule then destroyed hungary by going to war with all of this nations at once
1:11 Gotta love the Slovak Soviet republic. Amazing country, long, rich history, truly incredible.
@@Ahavagy what about samo's kingdom, greater moravia etc.
A long 2 century of history.
Austria-Hungary:collapses
Serbia, Romania and Czechoslovakia: What a time to be alive!!
@@AmarEcd1233 Serbia.
Croats, Bosnians, Macedonians, Slovenians, Albanians in YUGOSLAVIA: "Am I a joke to you?"
@@vojtechlansky86 yes they are
Yes it must have felt great getting independence from someone that has occupied you for 500 years
@@vojtechlansky86 Yes, they got absorbed into an even more repressive country than Austria-Hungary, lol.
Franz joseph I: don't cry my friend...
Me: ok.... * try not to cry*
Franz joseph I: *die with the empire*
Me: *Cry*
Idiot, Franz died in 1916 so he didn't die with the empire. Also Austria Hungary was gonna die any way because it had a lot of slovaks, Serbian, Bosnian and more who all wanted their independence.
@@ab.6573 well Ferdinand d'Este wanted to reform the Empire... if they would not shoot him he would reform the Empire into some kind of Federation and maybe it would survive in some form..
@@ab.6573 Go place your "austria only collapse..nationalism" somewhere else. If that was truely the case Austria would have collapsed years ago. No. Most people of the empires were content besides extremist nationalists,and the fact that the Croats,Czechs and Hungarians stood woth the empire until it’s fall shows there were lotal ethnics
franz joseph I actually died in 1916
Tragedy. If it were around today I'd be 290383678th in line for the throne.
flyingkoopa45 Lol a true king doesn't wait in line! Seize the throne for yourself! I'll back you in exchange for land
Tragic.. 9,728,382,282,
I'm related to a holy Roman emperor so I would possibly be 78th in the throne for holy Roman emperor
Aaryan Bhatia yep. A holy roman emperor (charlemagne btw) is my 32nd great grandfather
Lloyd Nix aye aye captain
Transylvania is Portuguese since ancient times!!!one!
no u
PS.: ur gay
That's World possible is just an american.
I mean aye literally said "one" there as an exclamation mark. How can you not be sure whether they're joking.
hrotha Thank you.
(reminder that Portugal is BLACK)
One interesting oddity not shown on the map (because it was so small) was the city of Fiume, which was established as an independent state by a Italian poet who intended to turn the territory over to Italy. After his condemnation by the Italian government, he ruled it as a proto fascist state until the city was put under siege and bombarded by the Italian navy in December 1920. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gabriele_D%27Annunzio#Fiume
Imagine living there and every morning you realize your county is collapsing
AH collapses
Everyone else: It's free real estate!
Those people were living there before it collapsed and those nations before it conquered them...
1:45 You forgot that Southern Dobruja was also part of Romania
Exactly
Yes, I was wondering where it was
Southern Witch
Hungary: I've still got some land of my own land since I was sliced up!
Romania+Yugoslavia+Czechoslovakia: Not on our watch!
Czechs had their land before, slovakians never liked hungary and hungarians treated them bad, so good for hungary. I dont care about these asians.
@@kubajcz they have some asian genes, but they're mostly european genetically
@@Medvelelet you dont know how you almost destroyed their culture and language? You tried to do that exactly same like austrians tried to germanise us(im Czech)
@@hannibalbarca7220 thanks for corrections, i thought that because hungarians often say that they are descedants of huns, some even say that they are turkic(probably very few hungarians)
@@kubajcz they are basically finns and estonians long lost cousins
Me: *cries*
Emperortigerstar : i'll give you something to cry about
*laughs silently*
You are a saver thank you so much
The true hero of south Slavs
@@justaserbiandoomer497 He literally killed the only Habsburgh that loved Slavs.
Sucks di. Ck. Silently
@@jozefmasny8349he shulnt have
The Emus from Australia would have sorted this shit out within a week!!
Look how they massacred my boy
Italy: I'm gonna make him a treaty he can't refuse
Romania: I'm about to end Hungary's whole Transylvania.
@@iwillsalt3459 Transylvania is pure sacred Romanian land. Its ancestors, the Dacians have being there centuries before the Hungarians, the Hungarians weren't even the tenth in Transylvania. While they were trying to cross the Ural Mountains the Romans came along, the Bulgarians, Cumans etc. Demographicaly, Transylvania is Romanian. Great Hungary was 48,1% Hungarian in 1900, while Great Romania was 83,8% in 1927 you see.
@@Dani-ld3yc but you cant hide, that the szeklerland is not romanian
@@saulenfischbearn7470 Yes, true, I can't hide the fact that the region mentioned has a Hungarian majority. Though there is a problem. Teaching the population Hungarian when they are in Romania is wrong, they should be allowed to speak their language between them, but the communication in hospitals, schools, or with the police and other public stuff should be in the national and official language.
The Hungarian majority is also well-known for not serving anything at a shop because you spoke Romanian in Romania.
Another problem is public signs, everything is also written below in Hungarian, anywhere where there is a 20% Hungarian population (alright, I understand, somewhere where Hungarians are majority, but in places like Hunedoara or Oradea, to have Hungarian translation on every public sign is exagerated, they don't even represent 25% of the population) ...Well weren't they the people who said they ruled over Transylvania for nine centuries, even if for some time they were conquered by the Austrians until 1867... They didn't wrote in Romanian below, even if it had in some places a total majority. They didn't give permission to teach Romanian in school... So...Yeah...I thought we were in Romania, they have citizenship, every single Hungarian in szeklerland has Romanian citizenship. They should be able to speak Romanian and shouldn't need translation on every sign.
It is surely one of the most interesting periods in history.
Really sad that the Republic of German-Austria wasn't allowed to reunification with Germany. Might have prevented many bad events.
Sander Skovly Germans weren't expelled from South Tyrol. And after World War II they were treated very well by the government, to the point where South Tyrol had the highest GDP per capita in Italy.
Sander Skovly I'd argue with the reason that South Tyrol is richer is that it is part of a Special Statute Region, so they pay less taxes and other things.
Interestingly, both Italy and Austria had the same problem, industry-wise, it was concentrated in a specific part of the country, the North in Italy and Austria proper and Bohemia in Austria, with the rest of both countries being more agriculture-based. Also, didn't know pre-WW1 South Tyrol had much industry, though it would be kind of hard to build, considering it's on the Alps.
Sander Skovly Yeah, sorry, my fault.
Sander Skovly The ones who have that autonomy are Sardinia, which more or less needed it, as part of that autonomy is language rights, and Sardinia is a pretty distinct language, and Sicily, which, if I'm remember correctly, the government was forced to grant autonomy by America, because the Sicilian Mafia helped them during the invasion of Sicily.
Thing is, South Tyrol is in the north, while Sicily and Sardinia are in the south, the south was mismanaged for generations, and is still recovering, as a result of that, industry isn't very developed, and the major industriali center in the south (Taranto, also the main military port) is Italy's most polluted city. And then there's the Mafia, and the Camorra, and the 'ndrangheta, and the general corruption found in all the the country.
Altough, prices are generally lower in the south, both housing and goods, so it's not like the South is poor, Campania, the poorest of the regions per capita, has a higher GDP per Capita than Turkey, for example.
The main problem, though, is that the country is deeply divided into North and South, with one resembling France or Germany and the other resembling Greece, respectively.
Sander Skovly No, but the electoral results show that divide, the Five Star Movement won the majority of the votes in the entire South (and Sardinia), while in the North, the votes were more mixed.
*Top Ten Saddest Anime Deaths*
*who said it was sad*
*Austrian and Hungarian fanboys said it was*
mr ms paint I’m sad
Stupid weeabo
Why does this video immediately remind me of Pumpkin Scissors?
I always wondered why Romania had such a large Hungarian minority whenever I looked at the maps, this video really helped in answering that.
wow, i had literally no idea that the breakup of austria-hungary was so chaotic (in retrospect, it should have been obvious, it is the balkans). i was very surprised that hungary was socialist
Top 10 saddest anime moments....
this hurts to watch, Austria-Hungary is my favourite Old-Country
*Laughs in Serbian*
Top 10 Happiest Events in the World
@@negujmosrpskifudbal9913 *Laughs in Hungarian*
*has no effect*
i want to know your country, so i can "cry" for some empire or country that occupied you.
I watch these videos and I think they're so cool seeing the conquests of nations and dominant emperors. But I take for granted that for every territorial change, a son was killed, a daughter was raped. Let's never forget that life should never be taken for granted.
When the good old ostrich couldn't run any more. :(
*osterreich
@@hogndog2339 ostrich*
Ostrich got so Hungry it died.
@@stormcloudtheory punny
Always was curious about the end of Austria Hungary.
Great Video Emperor, thank you!
Don't cry because it ended, smile because it happened
Don't cry because it happened, smile because it ended*****
Shut
:))
:(
mintbreathingdragon
The problem is, that we were humiliated after the dualism.
Oh, Serbia, oh, Croatia, oh,
**BANAT**
yeah i wonder how it even existed
"Dont be sad cause its over smile because it happened"- Karl von Habsburg
yea rip old empire, I'm smiling right here coz know millions of ppl died
As a Slovenian I see two mistakes here:
1. The state of SHS stands for State of Slovene, Croats and Serbs, after merging with Serbia we took the name Kingdom of SHS and then the SHS stood for Serbs, Croats and Slovenes.
2. There were missing occupations of Austria in late 1918 (Maribor and loverly styria) and may on parts of the disputed territory of Carinthia
Who would win?
A great and powerful empire
Some slavic boi's
Yes i know romanians and italians are not slavic if i include all of them it wont be as funny, to many butthurt people.....
OzonGames :D never said it was.
Mervan _Canoglu + some romanian bois
Or some romanians bois
Mervan _Canoglu Slavic boys here:
-Serbs
-Montenegrians
Not slavic:
-Italians
-Romanians
I wrote the people who fought against A-H, Czech and polish didn't do an amazing job
I’m gonna say... Some Slavic Bois
Dad:" why are you crying so loud?!"
me: The Collapse of Austria-Hungary: Every Day
LOL
Dad : "Why Are You Laughing So Loud!?"
Me : *_The Collapse Of Austria - Hungary._*
poor Hungary
gibb sohn they were kind of saved from comunism by romania so i think it is better this way
They became communist after WW2 anyway
Exactly, you cannot see deported people from Hungary in our history of the thousand year. Every Hungarian family were concerned in this. And we have got it from ... I can only see flags with the same colours... but, but Hungarian-speaking nations, where are they? Székelys Csángós. Why their numbers are reduced? I was only six, when my grandmother took us to our relatives to Csallóköz (Slovakia now) and there everybody understood our language, and they warned me: "Please, you should not use the Hungarian language outside in for example in the markets!..." Why? -I asked. They did not want problems... - in 1978. One, who, do not feel or can not feel this here, it is only a red internationalist.
*Hungry
Come on, stop that joke
I cry every time.
Austalia-Hungary was such a beutiful country
Vladimir Putin Russian President ur right :D xD
Vladimir Putin It was very bad country which deserved to be destroyed
Are you jokin when you're sayin Australia-Hungary?
Štěpán Pytlík and in turn you got rolled over twice by the even worse Nazis and soviets.
Yeah, it was great, but Austria-Ethiopia is better.
Austria: Draws hungary into war.
Also Austria: Gets land from hungary after ww1 cuz why not.
Why did the Czechs and Slovaks decide to unite together instead of becoming 2 separate countries?
For stability, there was a high percentage of Germans in Czechia and of Hungarians in Slovakia.
A ``Czechoslovakian`` country was a good solution, Slovaks weren't against this union as there wasn't a true Slovak identity yet and Germans and Hungarians communities were much smaller in this new country, preserving it from a secession. Sadly Hitler came and we know what happened.
There was also a theory at the time that nations of under 8 milion just could not survive. This sparked many movments to form larger slavic nations. Czechoslovakia worked out far better than the other one; Yugoslavia (That idea was critisied even at that time).
I think yugoslavia is a great idea. It should exist today as well. Croatian, Bosnian and Serbian languages are identical. Religoius differences should matter. Look at Germany. The bavarian dialect and hamburger dialect are radically different even morethan croatian and serbian. Protestants in the north, catholics in the south. Yet a single country for all germans is a succes story! why not for south-western slavs? It should have worked.
Bram06 Czech had to liberate Slovakia, not as shown in this video. Czechoslovakia also liberated Sudetenland much sooner than in this video
I believe Ivan Cankar the slovene writter said it best in 1917. " We are brothers by blood, cousins by language (he was a slovene), and complete strangers by history."
All south slavs never shared a common state and 500 years of Ottoman rule in the south and Habsburg rule in the North created a massive cultural devide. Germans had a common state for most of their history (HRE and the german confederation). While the HRE was never as unified as France or Russia it was still common ground. It is not about language or religion. It is about history and culture.
I belive a slovene-croatian union would have worked as well as Czecho-slovakia, and a southern Greater Serbia with Montenegro and Bosnia could have worked better. But by history it made more sense for Slovenia to be a part of Austria, than to be in a country with serbia.
Some of my ancestors are from western Ukraine, around Lviv. My great-great-grandfather knew he would be conscripted by someone, he just wanted to know which army it would be, and that was why he left.
Fantastic video, thank you!
The end of a great Empire
Delta Empire FUCK OFF
Fitting ending to Benny Hill music on the Italian front.
Марио Тутњевић you do realize the Austrians beat the Serbs right
Richard Roberson You do realize how long it took them to “beat them”, how much equipment and munitions were lost, and how many casualties it costed, right?
Mmmm no invadio y asesino a sus vecinos eso si maximiliano si es uno delos mejorcitos personajes de mexico
Hungary was robbed of so much of it's territory it actually makes me angry.
BANANA _ me too
DailyRaptorMailman Well yeah but wasn't that Austrian?
BANANA _ Yeah it wasnt really that fair, but those minorities deserved their independence i think
DailyRaptorMailman V4 forever ;)
Robbed ? Its called war
You missed the existence of Zakopane republic (Rzeczpospolita Zakopiańska)which was located between Poland and Slovakia (part of Czechoslovakia) and existed from 13th october to 16 th november (for 35 days) and soonly after Poland was formed it became annexed by it
Of course peacefully annexed. "The parliament's principal goal was to join an independent state of Poland."
So sad that austria and hungary lost so much territorry...
Even more sad that Deutschösterreich (German austria) couldnt unite with germany...
Hazzmati i would be for it if only the german speeking territorrys of Elsass-Lothringen would be Part of germany.
Not so sad the lost of teritories but with the second point I am with you.
Yes it is sad. We even lost German speaking areas in Czesk and SOUTH TYROL
Austrian Mapping Sudetenland were rightfully part of Czech kingdom for centuries!
Štěpán Pytlík it wasn't called Bohemia back in the days, you know, centuries ago.Cehia is not a new name?
I really love this video!!! This is something I was really interested in but also really confused about what actually happened. I really appreciate this
my great grandparents were from Austria-Hungary, weird to think they came from a state that doesn't exist anymore.
Austria-Hungary was not a country. It was an empire. They occupied neighboring countries for centuries. Those populations never asked to be occupied. It's like an Indian today would say: My grandparents were from England, weird they came from a country that doesn't exist anymore. What country?!?
@@m.dewylde5287 holy crap this comment is almost 2 years old, do you have nothing better to do with your time? Well I edited my comment to appease you anyway.
@@jdftrains3507 So, aren't you curios what country they did come from? Austria, Hungary, Croatia, Slovenia, Czechia, Slovakia, Romania, Ukraine? These were all in the empire that you called a country and a state, which was neither.
@@m.dewylde5287 I already know where they are from because of my mothers maiden name, and the word state can be used to describe any sovereign land regardless of location and government. For example "Narrowly defined, an empire is a sovereign state whose head of state is an emperor" ~from Wikipedia
RIP 🇦🇹-🇭🇺
>Litteraly 50% of Kingdom of Hungary's territory never having a hungarian majority
>HURR DURR SACRED HUNGARIAN LAND STOLEN BREEEEEEEE
But those borders were good though
@@brandonproductions8401 the new ones are even better xd
1910 It has 54% hungarian majority. But before turkish wars Hungary was 80% hungarian.
@@brandonproductions8401 new borders are better hungarians wouldnt hold them for long because majority of people were other nations
@@9_9876 Ameno.
So... Why isn't D'Annunzio's adventure saluti in Fiume/Rijeka represented? It was a pretty important event for both Italy and Europe. And D'Annunzio is also a pretty interesting character.
0:21 looks like a hoi4 peace deal when you forget to turn on player-led conferences
Fantastic work, I'll reference it for my future videos :D
I am not crying.
I am not sad.
I am not feeling bad.
I AM FROM ROMANIA
yeah we know
now go back to the rice fields
Your map contains an error. Romania had southern Dobruga all along, and it kept it until 1940.
It's sad to see Austria-Hungary dying
*Australia-Hungry
@@danieltrusca2556 the Australia Austria joke was long gone m8, no need to do It agian
@@oldplatinum9526 can you shut up already? I see your comments everywhere and what is happy about one of the best unions collapse?
@@Sceptonic ok but everyone needs a bit of patriotism in its life ;)
Nice work bro!!
One of the more interesting videomaps I've seen for a long while!
0:30 top ten saddest anime deaths
This video is so powerful. I'm holding back tears.
Top 10 saddest anime endings
Perfect video,as always
I told my grandpa, hey today plays Czech-Slovakia and Austria-Hungary, he asked "against who"
I hate it when these things fall apart
Its crazy how WW1 ended in November 1918 but fighting still continued all over Europe until 1921.
1923*
Südtirol ist Österreich!
@Denis Diderot ben detto
@Fedor von Bock Nazi Germany is now Merkelistan
Ravex giustissimo,ora il Trentino-Alto Adige è nostro
Austria is Germany!
And South Tyrol too!
Yes, It is definite...Ops, no: still Italy.
Finally somebody makes a video about this! Thank you!
Congrats on 400k
Everyone’s saying it looks so ugly after Austria Hungary collapsed, and yes, it does for a bit, when the fighting continues, but come on. After it is settled and modern day too the borders do NOT look messy. The borders are very clean and generally I prefer more countries in a map than less, it makes it better
Yes, but there are no ethnic borders at all... They were drawn by ego.
@@azuraviation2599 Yes they are ethnic, at least somewhat. Not all of Austria-Hungary was German or Hungarian lol, only about half of it.
@@dodolulupepe i doubt it was half.
@@kingdomoftransylvania5744 germans: 25%, hungarians: 20%
@@dodolulupepe thats less than half
A bit of a nitpick but it was called State of Slovenes, Croats & Serbs in that order until the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats & Slovenes was created
Next video:
The Collapse of My Parent's Marriage: Every Day
Great video
❤️🇬🇷🇷🇴🇷🇸🇵🇱🇨🇿❤️
Love from a Greek-Romanian!
Gott erhalte Franz, den Kaiser,
Unsern guten Kaiser Franz!
Lange lebe Franz, der Kaiser,
In des Glückes hellstem Glanz!
Ihm erblühen Lorbeerreiser,
Wo er geht, zum Ehrenkranz!
Gott erhalte Franz, den Kaiser,
Unsern guten Kaiser Franz!
Gott erhalte Franz, den Kaiser,
Unsern guten Kaiser Franz!
Everyone: OmG tHiS Is So sAd
Me: *laughs* *in* *slavic*
Ikr i cant believe people are actually sad because of this
Romanians: me too bro
I'm Austrian....
@@justarandomnerd3360 because they didnt survive the horrors as we did.
I feel bad for hungary
i say you should feel bad for those who were opressed in all this time
There were many souls trapped in this cage called Austro-Hungary
Hungary was accepted as an entity separated from the empire, but not independent
It was still a regional power for the other nations oppresed in the empire
Bogdan you are just a tipical stoupid nationalsit kido just dont write anything please. You only write stoupid things . You had mroe rights than hugnarians right now in the 21th centoury. And what you say then? :D
think of transylvania you were accepted , hungarians didnt hate you. Maybe for 1848 13000 hungarian was killed by romanians.
Romanians were for centuries "tolerated" in their homeland.
They were seen as how we see gypsies
Should i really bring up the forced magyarization and everything that happened...?
but noooo, the Hungarians sure had no problem with the Romanians, i mean they were totally fine
It gives you the right to humiliate a country having a civilwar and no army?With 3 or 4 other? And take Northern transylvania and vojvodia and the stouhern parts of slovakia where the hungarians were in majority?
It gives you any right to rob? This is your rass , it is not asian or anything else , this is called romanian and you are suprised , that all of hungary and people through europe call you thieves?
Remember what did the french prime minister said or governor after trianon.
We wished that he had never let romania take so much land, and the others from Hungary.
This is why they said , that trianon will only we accepted if they give rights to every hungarian.
So in reality you didnt own transylvania till the peace of Paris after the ww2 because you have never fulfilled that point.
Romania: ultra, mega, super STONKS!!!
Traitor nation, Romania betrayed its allies six times, in sixty years.
@@Abyss.44 Transylvania :*
@@Abyss.44 I smell someone being salty.
@@Abyss.44 cope Magyar go back to Russian steppes and bring your Turkish cousins with you.
Nice video!
The West: finally the war has ended
Austria Hungary, Italy and all of Central / east Europe: *peace was never an option*
I was always under the impression that the Sudetenland was kind of manufactured by the Nazis for a casus belli to invade. Interesting to see it was added onto Czechoslovakia after the country was formed.
Oh damn. Wish my country (Slovenia) stayed in Austria that time, we would live a better life! :(
You shouldn't
You damn shouldn't.
Oh wow I had no idea most of this happened, thanks for making this video so much
On 24 November 1918 Srem/Srijem separated from DSHS and connected with Serbia.
PS Thanks for video.
I was thinking about similiar (from Armistice of Bulgaria to 31 XII 1918) watching your World War I just 3 days ago :)
Could you please make a video about the 2018 Hungarian Elections? It happend yesterday and if you are already doing it than thanks in advance :)
Viva Trianon
Long live Big Romania
Vesszen Trianon!
Gott strafe Rumänien!
The only reason I liked Austria-Hungary being there was because it made Europe look clean and there wasn't 10 billion countries in the Balkans and instead it was 7
"10 billion" lmfao exagerate
This just plays "stage 6, a place in the world faces away" in my head
Great job as always. The only thing i found missing was Yugoslavia occupying parts of Carinthia and Klagenfurt from early June until September 1919.
0:21 BANAT!
yes we know
First, State of Slovenes, Croats and Serbs included Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Second, that state didn't have control of most of its territory so serbian army continued offensive. Serbian army even fought some battles in Austria.
Its a yugoslav army not serbian
@@emelgiefro that was before Yugoslavia
this is the most sad video on youtube :(
For me, it's the happiest.
@@theczechoslovakiankamerad7340 you are truly a sadistic person dear sir.
@@BaDitO2
When Austro-Hungarian kaiserboos are concerned, I'm pretty sadistic too.
Great video!
@EmperorTigerstar, is there any particular reason for actually ignoring Polish-Ukrainian War in Nov 1918 - Jul 1919?