BTW this song means more than just the wails. When Ann Wilson sings this song, she is not just going through the motions she is singing with EMOTION! And to be fair please check out this great video compilation of Ann Wilson's wails for Alone. Search "Alone Wails" It is the first video selection. And while you are at it listen to all of Ann Wilson's recordings you will not be disappointed she is truly AMAZING!
okay, people there are some good attempts here but no one can match the power and passion of the one and only Ann Wilson. She's still singing this song today like she did 30 yrs ago and no one can touch her.
Celine. With ease she went higher and hit at least an 8 note melisma, then the rest of the notes that everyone else hit. Carrie was spot on and powerfull. Charice seems like its at the top of her range and she just gets it. Regine was pitchy and almost went into metal scream voice.
It *almost* sounds as if you're saying that with good breath control, anyone should be able to hit any note. In reality, a high Eb to E is considered a very respectable belt. Of course a high G is nothing in a woman's head voice, but to hit that note in any kind of belt is something to be proud of.
Wellll... the money note in All By Myself (the any MOOOOOrrrrreeee after the instrumental break) is an F natural--a half step lower than the Gb here. "Love You Forever" does touch a G natural (one half step higher than this note), but it really just touches it--for about half a beat... the money note is a D natural, which is a minor fourth below this note. So, if you say those notes are high, then this one surely qualifies as a high note.
i agree...ann cuz its ann wilson. regine because i think she's the only one that started at the F#5 not and F5 and went up to it. carrie has the best tone because she's sang this song more than the others, with exception of ann, so she's more comfortable. charice is amazing but i prefer her hitting the G#5 when she was practicing this song. celine doesn't always hit this note in chest like she can. she sometimes goes mixed voice which is a shame.
try serching for Mitoy and Chuchay and lets see what you think,you'll notice that they are joking around at first but wait till you hear them sing Alone, you'll be blown away and take note they are comidianes.
hem yes so?! Did I say anything about that? I'm just saying it didnt help her in that contest and I still think she wins. Also her note gets higher than the other ones.
For the record, Carrie won this IMO, with Regine a DISTANT LAST. Sure, the note was effortless for her, but it sounded pretty darn bad, as i believe most of her singing does. If that 'songbird' was singing outside my window, i would probably shoot it. lol, jks. Of course, i respect and appreciate that others do not feel the same way. It's all good. =)
The problem is this is a bullshit comparison because it doesn't have Anne doing it in her prime. Celine and Carrie are probably just as pretty as Anne on it but they don't bring the Rock n Roll to it like Anne.
Yes in a terrible recording Ann did not sound particularly great. Listen to her in her prime and like I said she BURIES the rest of these performers. Ann is the ultimate Rock Goddess.
The last voice wins ANN WILSON!!!!! and your footage of her vocals wasnt fair at all because you do not have the sound as high as the others and you did not even show her face! Lets go with Ann Wilson because she is known as the Queen of Rock n Roll because of her amzing pipes! Also other people need to go find the Ann Wilson version of Alone, how about the original video. Look up (Heart Ann Wilson Alone) And while you are at it listen to all of Hearts music because they have had a long career!
all i can say that we the filipino can JUDGE SINGERS!! BETTER THAN OTHER NATION!! AND CHARICE WILL NEVER BE BETTER THAN REGINE!!! "LETCHE!!!" CAN YOU PLEASE DON'T UNDERESTIMATE THE NUMBER ONE SINGER AND THE BEST SINGER OF OUR COUNTRY!! AND CHARICE SHOULD LEARN MORE TO BEAT REGINE, EVEN SARAH, KYLA! OR THE OtHER BEST singer of our country!! don't say that charice is the best!!
i really believe that charice is not that good enough to beat regin, sarah, kyla! why? kasi i just observed when she sings, masiyado siyang pasigaw MINSAN!! and hndi yun maganda sa tenga! pero i also believe that charice is a good singer kaso di niya kayang lampasan narating ni regine! kahit na mas sikat siya sa ibang bansa!
In these recordings Ann is not the best because it is a terrible recording of her. Compare Ann in a good recording and she buries the rest. Ann Wilson is the ultimate Rock Goddess.
@MrWwerealwrestler lmao, you're delusional. carrie's was crystal clear and effortless. almost sounded like a bell. a "male hitting high note"?? makes no sense. if anything, celine's sounds like that, because she's the only one who used a TON of head voice to achieve the note. the others used their chest.
Once again I need to point out that this is a bullshit comparison because it is a crappy recording of Ann doing it 30 years after she created it. Everybody else is just copying her creation. Still in the original recording and in Ann's early live performances she is still better than all of these very talented copy cats.
TristanandIsolt You are aware that the song WAS NOT originally a heart song, so Ann was just as much of a "copy cat" as anyone else as your so petulantly and childishly pointed out. It's a song, anyone has the right to sing it. GET OVER YOURSELF.
BTW this song means more than just the wails. When Ann Wilson sings this song, she is not just going through the motions she is singing with EMOTION! And to be fair please check out this great video compilation of Ann Wilson's wails for Alone. Search "Alone Wails" It is the first video selection. And while you are at it listen to all of Ann Wilson's recordings you will not be disappointed she is truly AMAZING!
We know Ann dominates! Her vocals are beyond amazing!
I think Ann and Celine. They both have the type of voice required for this type of song.
i prefer the way celine does it nowadays live, most recently. the way she belts 'till now' after the high note does it for me! :D
okay, people there are some good attempts here but no one can match the power and passion of the one and only Ann Wilson. She's still singing this song today like she did 30 yrs ago and no one can touch her.
Celine Dion & Carrie Underwood
Celine. With ease she went higher and hit at least an 8 note melisma, then the rest of the notes that everyone else hit. Carrie was spot on and powerfull. Charice seems like its at the top of her range and she just gets it. Regine was pitchy and almost went into metal scream voice.
It *almost* sounds as if you're saying that with good breath control, anyone should be able to hit any note. In reality, a high Eb to E is considered a very respectable belt. Of course a high G is nothing in a woman's head voice, but to hit that note in any kind of belt is something to be proud of.
Ann totally dominates EVERYONE!
celine of coz the best here. she creative in hittin high note.
They're all great, but I got to say: Ann is the original, and the best... She gives me goosebumps!
Celine's melisma is the best one.
celine and regine
then carrie
charice
ann
Celine has a clear voice
Regine!
Clear and powerful..Controlled pitch and loudness.
of course ann!!!!watch heart-alone live in seattle 2003!!
celine
Wellll... the money note in All By Myself (the any MOOOOOrrrrreeee after the instrumental break) is an F natural--a half step lower than the Gb here. "Love You Forever" does touch a G natural (one half step higher than this note), but it really just touches it--for about half a beat... the money note is a D natural, which is a minor fourth below this note. So, if you say those notes are high, then this one surely qualifies as a high note.
Carrie sounds like a rocker.
CELINE DION!! The greatest singer/vocalist of ALL TIME!
Carrie
Celine
Charice
Regine aww
Heart
CELINE and CHARICE
i agree...ann cuz its ann wilson. regine because i think she's the only one that started at the F#5 not and F5 and went up to it. carrie has the best tone because she's sang this song more than the others, with exception of ann, so she's more comfortable. charice is amazing but i prefer her hitting the G#5 when she was practicing this song. celine doesn't always hit this note in chest like she can. she sometimes goes mixed voice which is a shame.
Ann Wilson
Regine
Charice
Carrie
Celine
Charice and Carrie hold the top spot for me
carrie underwood
my vote is 1)Ann(always) 2)Regine 3)Carrie 4)Charice 5) Celine
try serching for Mitoy and Chuchay and lets see what you think,you'll notice that they are joking around at first but wait till you hear them sing Alone, you'll be blown away and take note they are comidianes.
It says... every opinion is right!!!!!! therefore replying is not essential and necessary.
Carrie has the best note. then Celine. both were really good.
Carrie definitely
carrie!! why? she doesnt sang it as a diva,but she sang it straight from rock
CARRIE, thats her note, dude
Regine and Celine...
charice kicks all of theree asses and she is younger... lol she hits the f# so easy while the other singers struggless a bit
Celine Dion
celine!
A belted high Gb is not a "piece of cake".
hem yes so?! Did I say anything about that? I'm just saying it didnt help her in that contest and I still think she wins. Also her note gets higher than the other ones.
i prefer regine,and celine..
celine definately she went higher.
then regine next highest
then carrie ok
then charice
then ann
Ann Wilson will always be number one. However one of the girls I work with can hit it better than all of them combined. Sorry Ann. I STILL LOVE YOU!
carrie
probably carrie and celine nailed it....regine i don't even know why she's here!!!hehe
Regine ;)
il go with regine then celine then carrie then the original singer .
of course Anne Curtis
No fair! Charice only is singing with a karaoke :-)
ANNE CURTIS!!!
for me. . .#1 regine.. effortless,, #2 carrie sitting position,, hehehe
lupet ni regine!
Celine Dion =)
Check out the video response that I posted above...It just prooves that ann wilson dominates above all the rest!
regine is the best
Carrie wins.
the guitar
try Searching Mitoy and Chuchay Superb singing
just try alone by Warmen
Regine!!!!
regine is the best! but all of them were good
I'm a Reginian (one of ultimate Regine fans)
but
for this part of the song, she's not my best...
coz she just hit the note with no difficulty...
Celine!!!, even though the sound quality of her video is the worst and not as loud as the others.
of course regine wins!
Yeah, you gotta put a better clip of Ann in there. You can barely hear her.
charice!
The original is still the best, the rest of them just wanna be like hearth.
regine
celine
i like charice =)
Um, that's OBVIOUSLY because it, unlike all the others, is from a tour and filmed by an amateur. What else would you expect?
1. regine! ! - very clean and powerful
2. celine
3. carrie
4. heart
5. charice - still sound like an amateur singer ( sori to the fans)
ARNEL PINEDA!!!!!!!!!!!!
si regine...
ibubuka lng bibig niya, makakanta n niya hehehe
For the record, Carrie won this IMO, with Regine a DISTANT LAST. Sure, the note was effortless for her, but it sounded pretty darn bad, as i believe most of her singing does. If that 'songbird' was singing outside my window, i would probably shoot it. lol, jks. Of course, i respect and appreciate that others do not feel the same way. It's all good. =)
The problem is this is a bullshit comparison because it doesn't have Anne doing it in her prime. Celine and Carrie are probably just as pretty as Anne on it but they don't bring the Rock n Roll to it like Anne.
REGIN *****
chjarice ako.. mas clear yung voice nya..
Ann and Celine, no doubt. I really didn't like Carries, and I hated Regines. Charice's was okay for her but amaturish. [Probably because she is, lol]
parang si regine, talo nya pa rin yung mga veterans at new ones sa biritan, sa totoo lang.
"every opinion is right"...? lol
You just proved that's wrong. If Carrie can't belt, who can?
Yes in a terrible recording Ann did not sound particularly great. Listen to her in her prime and like I said she BURIES the rest of these performers. Ann is the ultimate Rock Goddess.
ASIAS SONG BIRD
Lmao! the bass guitar was the best
@matt8691 Yeah so, whats your point? lol
The last voice wins ANN WILSON!!!!! and your footage of her vocals wasnt fair at all because you do not have the sound as high as the others and you did not even show her face! Lets go with Ann Wilson because she is known as the Queen of Rock n Roll because of her amzing pipes! Also other people need to go find the Ann Wilson version of Alone, how about the original video. Look up (Heart Ann Wilson Alone) And while you are at it listen to all of Hearts music because they have had a long career!
I think Ann sounds EASILY the worst out of all of these.
Ann hands down and it's not even the best I've heard her do.
The version you have isn't even Anns best.
all i can say that we the filipino can JUDGE SINGERS!! BETTER THAN OTHER NATION!! AND CHARICE WILL NEVER BE BETTER THAN REGINE!!! "LETCHE!!!" CAN YOU PLEASE DON'T UNDERESTIMATE THE NUMBER ONE SINGER AND THE BEST SINGER OF OUR COUNTRY!! AND CHARICE SHOULD LEARN MORE TO BEAT REGINE, EVEN SARAH, KYLA! OR THE OtHER BEST singer of our country!! don't say that charice is the best!!
i really believe that charice is not that good enough to beat regin, sarah, kyla! why? kasi i just observed when she sings, masiyado siyang pasigaw MINSAN!! and hndi yun maganda sa tenga! pero i also believe that charice is a good singer kaso di niya kayang lampasan narating ni regine! kahit na mas sikat siya sa ibang bansa!
charice will be the best...
carrie is the worst...
In these recordings Ann is not the best because it is a terrible recording of her. Compare Ann in a good recording and she buries the rest. Ann Wilson is the ultimate Rock Goddess.
@MrWwerealwrestler lmao, you're delusional. carrie's was crystal clear and effortless. almost sounded like a bell. a "male hitting high note"?? makes no sense. if anything, celine's sounds like that, because she's the only one who used a TON of head voice to achieve the note. the others used their chest.
Carrie...
Regines awful... xD
Once again I need to point out that this is a bullshit comparison because it is a crappy recording of Ann doing it 30 years after she created it. Everybody else is just copying her creation. Still in the original recording and in Ann's early live performances she is still better than all of these very talented copy cats.
TristanandIsolt You are aware that the song WAS NOT originally a heart song, so Ann was just as much of a "copy cat" as anyone else as your so petulantly and childishly pointed out. It's a song, anyone has the right to sing it. GET OVER YOURSELF.
Ann Wlson sounds really really bad, easily the worst.
carrie