15 Gauge Nailers Review | Dewalt VS Milwaukee | Watch before you buy...
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 июл 2024
- This is a review with my thoughts on these two 15 gauge cordless finish nailers.
Dewalt 15 Gauge Cordless Finish Nailer - geni.us/g3cmY (Amazon)
Milwaukee 2746-20 M18 FUEL 18 Gauge Brad Nailer - geni.us/irrrui (Amazon)
MILWAUKEE ELEC TOOL 2743-20 Milwaukee 15Ga Bare Nailer - geni.us/Zt2M7ut (Amazon)
BATTERY ADAPTER (milwaukee to dewalt) - geni.us/nHrKJQ
My Favorite Tools - Insider Carpentry Amazon Site - www.amazon.com/shop/insider_c...
Support more content like this by becoming a PATREON SUPPORTER - / insider_carpentry
INSTAGRAM - insider_carpentry 
Хобби
Thanks for supporting this channel by purchasing through these affiliate links:
Dewalt 15 Gauge Cordless Finish Nailer - geni.us/g3cmY (Amazon)
Milwaukee 2746-20 M18 FUEL 18 Gauge Brad Nailer - geni.us/irrrui (Amazon)
MILWAUKEE ELEC TOOL 2743-20 Milwaukee 15Ga Bare Nailer - geni.us/Zt2M7ut (Amazon)
BATTERY ADAPTER (milwaukee to dewalt) - geni.us/nHrKJQ
Hey Spencer thanks for the videos you put out! I'm the same as you and I'm heavily invested in DeWalt cordless tools have you had any issues with ruining batteries running the adapter?
I have the 18 gauge Milwaukee and it's terrific. As a remodelling contractor it's perfect. Sometimes I'm just doing 3-4 hours of trim for a job or just popping some new baseboards in a bedroom. It's really nice not to bring a compressor around for that. My framing nailer is cordless too. My other guns aren't used often enough to warrant cordless and I have a extremely quite California Air compressor for those.
I'm glad you did this comparison. I have an abundance of Milwaukee and Dewalt tools so I've been considering the battery trim guns for a while now. And that muzzle size on the Milwaukee is a deal breaker for me as well. Nail placement is paramount in finish work
Been using the Dewalt for a few years as well. I have the 18g and the crown stapler as well. Never had a problem with any of them. Always worked great. Have dropped off ladders more than once and fortunately still, no problems.
This is a great channel Spencer. Thanks for sharing your knowledge!
super glad you made this .... you can tell .... as someone that has zero time to make vids on my projects which i hope one day i will .... i appreciate you making the content
Appreciate the good information. Someone who have used the tools have the best evaluation. Thanks!
Totally agree with the verdict on the tips. I had all paslode nailers now on hikoki battery. The tip is so important and they suck on hikoki too! I tried to make my own to match the paslode 16g but kept coming off. Rafter hook is terrible too! They need to put these things through more testing on site before they release them to get rid of these problems
Excellent, detailed review. I can tell who actually uses the tools in many different ways and explain the issues in depth.
Thanks for this awesome review! Just purchased the Dewalt 15-Guage based on this video. Keep them coming!
Thanks dude! I really needed to hear this, I was close to buying the red 15g. I had 15/18 dewalt.. I was soo excited when I bought them! The 18g though almost immediately became inconsistent countersinking the nails. Spring tool became my best friend lol It was almost as if the drive pin wasn’t hitting the nail correctly so Every time it would leave the double hole W/ the nail head proud. It Became such an annoyance Bc I try to pay the work forward. Yellow 15g was great until we were doing a house (shortly after I bought it) w/extremely thick door jambs (mdf core sandwiched between two pieces of ply= 2-1/4” & pre-finished like kitchen cabinets. Might of been vice versa core/outer layers 🤔) it had so much kickback that I had to keep a hand on the back of it all the time to get the nail to fully sink. If not it would bounce off the work piece fairly easy & leave 1/8-1/4” sticking out 🤯 Then same house we were making jambs out of 5/4 mahogany for a bunch of walk throughs, & like clock work it would not sink the nail fully😳 my boss was turned off by it saying ehh it must not have enough power.. let’s use the paslode 16g, which had 0 issues. Then the 15g clip/slide stopped working correctly 🤦♂️ DeWalt factory service center wanted 120& 200 to fix the guns that weren’t more then 1.5 yrs old. (& I get made fun of Bc of how well I take care of my tools lol) so I said 👎🏽 I payed 220 & 250 on sale so that was just not worth it to me. I snatched up a Home Depot red gen2-18g bundle last summer &returned a battery same day so I ended up paying about 160 for it & have been truly enjoying it ever since! I was so close 2 buying a red 15g but said let me hit the tube & c what fellow carpenters have 2say. I trust your word, techniques & dedication! So I will b waiting 4the next gen version 2come out.. using a paslode & pneumatic in the mean time 🤷♂️
I prefer an angled 16ga. You can shoot 2 1/2" nails I use it to set doors, wood walls, and ceilings never had any problems. Been using a cordless dewalt for the last few weeks works great for me. I still use pneumatic guns for big projects much more productive.
I have a 16g Dewalt cordless nailer and I absolutely live the performance of that gun. I run a Dewalt platform too and use adapters for certain tools Dewalt doesn't offer.
I really appreciate the info on your videos!
I compared gen1 with gen2 and it’s like day and night. Consistency, feeling of the gun, knowing where the nail will sink and recoil. It’s like day and night. They really improved their tools and I can’t wait for 16 and 15 ga to be available in the Netherlands.
Glad I saw this. Bought the 18 gauge Milwaukee and considered the 15. Use the same hitachi and love it . Probably gonna just go back to all air though.
You always put out good info. Thanks
hands-down, best ask for a like in the history of RUclips videos
Very nice discription of the Dewalt 15 ga nailer I have one and love it!
Great comparison. Not a professional but come from a family of carpenters and love to work with wood now. Had Porter Cable for years as I needed tools but migrating to Dewalt.
Awesome video - great insights !
Started debating which way I wanted to go today, since the Makita is a fat cow... super helpful, best most thorough review video I’ve seen on that Dewalt! Thanks
I have the dewalts, 15 and 18. The 15 needs you to pop the casing apart and lube the depth wheel every now and then. The 18 has started to glance off the tip of the nail while firing, sometimes leaving the nails 1/8" proud
Good review, setting proud gun nails is a pain in the ass 👍
Excellent Review. You covered all the bases very well. Also I am happy I continue to purchase Dewalt since they have worked very well for me this far. The 15 Guage will be my next purchase so this Review was very helpful. I think all tool Manufacturers are going to have Lemons so far I haven't had one with DeWalt.
I been using Cordless nailers since years ago, I bought use from ebay 18v dewalt 18g, 16g and 15g used them for years and instantly drop the hose, and few years ago I upgraded to the 20v new line up and I'm use to the noise of the flywheel noise, they feel balanced, I tried the Milwaukee and hated the front nose heavy feel, so stuck to the dewalt for good
Like the Garand Thumb style intro 😄
For anybody watching this video now, the Gen 2 of Milwaukee has changed and improved on many of these points. at this moment, a new comparison is necessary
Gen 2 15g comes out in January. All problems you stated are fixed. I’m getting it.
Love hearing I can adapt Milwaukee tools to my Dewalt batteries. Thanks so much!
I’ve used both. 6,000 Senco 2” nails through my 1st gen Milwaukee & it’s been one of the more flawless tools in my collection. Can’t stand the sound & balance of the Dewalt. The Milwaukee hook is a joke, but I just retrofitted a rafter hook on to it. Had the opposite experience with nail setting. The Dewalt left way too many proud nails. Agree with the commentary about the tip size, but I don’t find that it diminishes the performance for my workflow.
That 18g Milwaukee will feel so much better with a 2 amp Milwaukee battery.
Ive been using my air nailer for big jobs again recently, the constant problems like proud nails and ugly holes get annoying. Hopefully they get better.
Good review man !!!
Thank you, great helpful video!
Great detailed review!
I’ve watched quite a few of your videos and I have to say I have enjoyed most of the content but regarding these electric nail guns I felt that I should make a comment. For the last 33 years I’ve been a finish carpenter and I’ve had to use a number of different kind of nail guns. About 15 years ago I switched over to the Paslode nail guns. I’ve had pretty good success with them and I feel these guns are not only capable of shooting into whatever material I present to them I also like that they are lighter in weight than electric guns like your presenting. The only issue I’ve had with them is they require maintenance and when my workers drop them and I have to repair them I’ve learned to fix them myself. For my money I’m going to stay with the Paslode guns as I still feel they out perform the full electric guns.
If you’ve never tried one contact the factory rep and usually they’ll give you a loaner to try to see how it works. They did that for me in the past with the frame nailer that they sell.
One of the tool reviewers on RUclips did "real world" test and tried to 1000 nails in 5 min with a Paslode. He died of carbon monoxide poisoning and the greenhouse gases had his neighborhood under a tornado warning for weeks. Just kidding. Time tested as no other cordless nailer. They just work.
I'm with you on the Paslode gas guns ; you can't kill those things
@@stevebengel1346 I had one and the large cylinder cracked in half after about 6 months of use. I cleaned it every 4 canisters, more often than paslode requires in their manual. Not sure what happened but Lowe's offered a refund on the gun so I took it and stayed with pneumatics until the Milwaukee gen 2 Brad nailer came out. Thing is a beast.
I have the older 16 Gauge and the framer,can't find the nails for the 16 up here in western canada, only on amazon.
I wish DeWalt or even Milwaukee would come out with both FN & DA style 15-gauge nailers. I have used the flatter angle 15 gauge nails for years; in production the lower angle nailers hold more nails and have to be reloaded slightly less often, while they don’t get into as many places as the steeper angled nailers can, they work great for most all jobs. I have 10s of thousands of the flatter 15s and would love a battery nailer to fit them; right now I am still using air for 15 gauge while having the DeWalt 16 gauge and 18 gauge battery nailers which make life so much easier. While I typically run an electric pancake I have started using the DeWalt 60V compressor on smaller jobs as it works for quick things but just can’t keep up with some jobs.
Awesome in-depth review! Curious what your thoughts are on the m4 hammer...
Thank you for explain very clearly continue the same way. You help me to much before I by tools thanks Temecula Ca 👍
Great explanation thanks
I had a home owner give me a ryobi 15gauge nailer, it wasn't feeding properly so I lubed it up, he had already bought a new one. So I bought a $15 millwaukee battery adapter and was actually impressed. I plan on buying a m18 15guage nailer and having the ryobi as backup, or when my partner needs a gun so were not passing one back and forth while doing a t&g ceiling or something.
I have the original version Dewalt 16g. About 20 years old and, is still going strong. There is no noticeable ramp up time to fire a nail and I can't see a difference in speed from my pneumatics. This thing is bullet proof. I had purchased the hitachi/metabo 16g last year as a backup incase the dewalt finally quit. It was unusable for all the reasons you have mentioned. I even sent it in for service thinking it needed a recharge. They said it was operating as it should. Had to sell it. Love the dewalt but I'm a little a skeptical about the newer model. I don't keep the compressor in the van anymore.
Terrific review, so thorough and comprehensive. I’m sticking with air powered nailers.
I'm liking your channel, good true reviews from a guy in the field. My cordless nailes is jut for light nailing, like touch ups or when I go up on elevators but if I machine nailing half a day or more I prefer the pneumatic over any brand.
Hey Spencer aside from everything else you do, very impressed with your cadence of upload especially considering you're on holidays, keep it up, these videos are extremely valuable from an information and inspiration perspective🤙
Thanks man. I try and get a video out every week. That means uploading in advance and scheduling the publish time before vacation.
I appreciate your expert advice to save us money!
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 I learned something today thanks
Isn't that milwaukee 15 gauge their gen 1 version? The 18 gauge is the gen 2. They haven't come out with the 15 gauge gen 2 yet. Milwaukee has a framing nailer with gen 2 technology and people seem to love it... so I dont think its the nail size, more the technology
The gen 1 had so many problems
I am definitely waiting for the gen 2 finish nailer.
I have the gen 2 Brad nailer and it is awesome!!
Another carpenter I work with just purchased this Milwaukee 15 GA Nailer. It has been good for a couple applications, but I agree with every point made in this video about the Milwaukee.
I would add that it is also quite heavy in comparison to the DeWalt.
On the other hand, I purchased my DeWalt in November (2020) of last year as my Paslode had died. It’s now March (2021), and the thing keeps on misfiring. And not just every so often, the frequency is about every 3rd or 4th nail.
It will refuse to fire a nail for about the same amount of shots, before it picks up the next nail again.
I’m about to take it back to the shop to see if I can get it repaired or replaced.
@@davesch1512 holding out for the 2nd gen too. Don't know why it's taking so long
He is using a gen 1, the gen 2 is the 2745-20. Everyone else testing the gen 2 shows it sets nails far better than the present Dewalt model. www.milwaukeetool.com/Products/Power-Tools/Woodworking/Nailers-and-Staplers/2745-20
I thought gen 2 was already out?
thanks for sharing your experience.
Thank you for the insights.
The Milwaukee Gen 2 15ga. has the smaller tip like the Dewalt. It looks like the Milwaukee you have in the video is the older Gen 1 15ga. nailer. I had the 18ga. Dewalt brad nailer for two weeks. I hated the fly wheel so I sold it and grabbed the Milwaukee. Never been happier.
I use the 15 gauge Milwaukee at work and actually use Milwaukee batteries, and it seems to work just fine for me. It sometimes won’t sink all the way in bump fire mode, but I don’t use that very often anyways.
I was wondering if his battery retrofit was causing problems. I run the hell out of that Milwaukee 15g with a 2.0Ah battery with zero issues.
Lots of video’s on youtube
That gun with milwaukee batteries has the same problems
I was also disappointed with the milwaukee nailer 16 GA but with regards to the double hole, I find that the nails aren't stiff enough for their length and the firing pin slides off the nail head as the nail bends going through the timber.
I have air fired my gun and it bends a 63mm long 16 gauge nail if anything the gun is too powerful.
I find using shorter nails say 38 to 50mm the and removing the protective end gun works ok.
Also changing brand of nails has helped heaps, I was having heaps of issues with senco then dewalt and now I use airco, they seem better suited the to gun, not sure why as yet.
Great channel, Cheers from Australia.
I do miss my 18 gauge porter cable air nailer. My 18 ver 2 Milwaukee(on my 2nd one) leaves a way bigger hole in my finish trim. LUV my 15 gauge Bostitch 15g air nailer
Thank U Spencer for another in depth pro info video!
Just a few issues however?
I spent all day in glue-ups & Sanding!
I hv glue up the wazoo !
I seen your demo & what do I see???
Glue on your hands!
Now I hv PTSDCS (post traumatic stress disorder carpenter style)?
Also where did you get that table saw stand? How did you jig it up???
Of course I am kidding! Your the best!
I need a nail gun and specifically a Brad gun! So I will Oder thru your page! I need more note pads and pinch dogs also!
I just hv a hard time parting with my Hitachi air nailers w/ my Calif Air Compressor? It’s very dependable!
I hv notice most pros will not totally part either! Especially framers!!
Thank u Brother!
Spencer, your dedication to the trade and willingness to share and teach is very inspiring. I always look to your vids for trustworthy insights. Would love to meet up for a beer sometime. Appreciate your contributions!! Thanks buddy.
My Milwaukee 15ga is model 2839 which is the newer model. It works great, no complaints at all.
This is strange because I had a large trim and door remodel last fall. The only gun that was not cordless was my 15ga. So I bot the fuel 18 v. It worked flawlessly. I’m not sure why after watching this video!!!🤔
The 15G and 16G milwaukee are still the first generation model and suck just like the first generation 18G. For this reason I still run Cordless Paslodes or Air for 15/16G.
The 2nd generation 18G is amazing. I can sink 2inch nails in Maple all day long with it if I need to. Once they update those other nailers they'll be solid.
The M18 framer is good, a little heavy if you're coming from Paslode. Also, another guys framing crew was only getting 8000 nails out of the M18 Framers before the strikers went bad and were sent for repair (they had half a dozen guns sent back)
Man I'm glad I found you on here you're just like me I hate when nail guns leave nails proud it gets under my skin I've had every one of those guns but my favorite one of the cordless is the DeWalt 18 gauge battery operated I use that everyday I love it I just don't wish they made it smaller but can't always get what you want and I do not ever like to use 16 gauge at all truly I'm not a fan of 16 gauge I think they leave too big of nail holes I use 18 for everything pretty much even my crown I know some people think that's stupid but I like it and setting doors I use my 18 gauge and then just pop the hinges and put screws in I'm not a big fan of the 16 gauge trim guns at all
Thank you I'm just about to buy one and this helps.
Yes is great decision
I have one and the only issue I ever have with it is setting a nail in extremely hardwood but in those situations I just get out the air gun
once companies make those cordless nailers better and more affordable, then il start getting into them...compressor and nailers have worked just fine all this time for me
I spent around $1500 getting my cordless framing nailer 18 15 and pin nailer. A lot of money but I have no cords no loud compressor no hoses no forcing owners and neighbors to listen to that 90dba growl at 7:30 in the morning and they have every bit as much power as pneumatic. If you’re waiting for the price to come down keep dreaming companies don’t really lower prices especially not tool companies. Their prices only go up with each generation of tool
I was the same way. I thought, why change of my compressor setup still works. But after a few small jobs where I'm only there for a couple hours, the cordless come in handy!!!!!
@@kennethwalton6 I'm sure it does, I've used them just don't own one. I use my compressor to blow dust away from me and my work, have needed for air in my tires, alot cheaper to have this setup. I'd love to have all cordless tools eventually but for the price of cordless guns it should be indestructible imo and their not. Between them breaking down and having no gun, and maintenance it still isn't logical for me to switch. I hope I can someday tho
@@itkills9251 after I bought my cordless nailer, that's when I decided to go all out. They definitely come in handy
The Hitachi/metabo are the best cordless nailers out. Still no substitute for an air nailer. Flex eel hose and and a new small and quiet Rolaire compressor improve the hose nailer experience.
You scare me man!
You been looking at my tools? Lol
I mounted a JC10 to a piece of 3/4” plywood, then mounted stealth mounts to the bottom of the plywood. I can then snap that into the Milwaukee pack out rolling dolly. A medium pack out for guns, a slim pack out for nails, with the compressor on top is a super-tidy, mobile setup. 👍🏻
Very good video thanks for sharing 👍👍
Do the cordless framing nailer I agreed with you on the 15 gauge I just got one of those last week and not the happiest with it
I trim houses here in Florida you are very good bro I’ll keep watching your videos pretty good
Hopefully they release a gen2 soon seems like they do get those bugs worked just like the 18g and framers
There's a new Milwaukee, I love it, would love you ro review that one.
Have you tried the Paslode 16 angled nailer? I love mine!
very in-depth review
I’m very happy you did this review. After switching to the miluakee 18ga. And loving it.
I considered switching from Dewalt to miluakee 15. Ga.
I will definitely not be making the switch after seeing the tip size on that thing. 👎👎👎
You should check out the Dewalt 16ga cordless nailer. It is the best production cordless nailer I've used and own.
The same technology in the Milwaukee 18/15g nail is in there framing gun just on a bigger version, it’s not the nitrogen tank that’s the problem it’s the older style technology
Milwaukee 15g is still old gen. 18g 2nd gen and framing nailer both work fantastically. Until they upgrade 15ga to 2nd gen. we just have to live by either air or dewalt
Thanks for this, wasn't aware! I hope Spencer sees your comment. As a Milwaukee fan boy with thousands invested this review was very disappointing, especially because I was looking to buy this nailer to replace my 15 gauge air nailer. Now I will wait for an updated 2nd gen. I do have the Milwaukee framing nailer and it is absolutely fantastic.
Very true.
It is 9 months later and I think the 2nd generation is here, if it is anything like the 18 gauge brad
Nailer I am ditching the air immediately
I bought a dewalt 15. & 18 on amazon and the 15 died completely after about 8 shots . It’s my first cordless since the pasloade . I was worried neither gun was any good so i returned both guns . considering another one . still looking
I've had the 18v Senco Fusion guns with Nitrogen technology you talked about for 5-6 years and always felt like the 18g works awesome every time but the 15g is always spongy and never sets nails consistently. Now I know why. Thanks!
I went through 3 of the senco 15 gauge under warranty. The are prone to an electronic malfuction the renders them useless also. At least it was a problem when I was using them a handful of years ago.
I use the ryobi one and have felt the power was really good
I thought the huge holes were something I was doing wrong. I agree with the massive tip, weird.... I just bought a Gen 2 18g nailer and the tip is super weird but at least the hole size doesn’t appear to be an issue.
I'm impressed with the Ryobi 15 ga.
The dewalt I use has a built in pencil sharpener. The sharpener sucks but it’s the thought that counts
I run cordless Ryobi Airforce 18 guage and angled 15 for trim. They are solid guns and more reliable than the Dewalts I used to have. Rarely misfire, but battery hogs and heavy. I just bought the Milwaukee framing nailer last month and it's an absolute beast. The nitrogen cylinder tech sure works on it.
My m18 18guage has been great. With the framing nailers, the funniest thing about comparing these 2 brands, is the relentless mocking Dewalt got for being so heavy, yet the Milwaukee gets lots of praise even though it’s 25-30% heavier.
Its really interesting, sometimes the actual weight doesn't matter as much as the ergonomics and feel.
Thr Ryobi 18g nailer beats everyone. Milwaukee removed their Gen 1 off the shelves to reinvent from the ground up, they couldn't compete.
I have the 30⁰ Milwaukee framing nailer and it shoots perfectly fine, it's not the nitrogen cell causing your problem, it's just that generation of the 15 gauge nail gun.
Agreed, I shouldn't have made that point.
Hopefully by the time my current 15 gauge Dewalt dies Milwaukee will have a new version of their 15 ga. The fly wheel sound of the Dewalt drives me nuts. I love the 18 gauge Milwaukee with my adapter and deWalt battery. Can you pull off the rubber tip and have a small metal tip surface like the Dewalt?
great review
The metabo Hitachi 16g also suffers from a bit of a large tip guard.
Appreciate the review. I have been been wanting to pickup some cordless finish nailers for small jobs. I’m glad to here the 15ga dewalt flywheel worked. I have the dewalt framing nailer with flywheel and it’s the worst tool I have ever owned. No one battery platform/brand is the answer I guess. Time to mix it up
Have the 15g Milwaukee nailer and agree with everything you have said. It’s not a BAD nailer, but can 100% guarantee you, Milwaukee been designing a gen 2 nailer like they did for the 18g brad, AND if they are not. Well, THEY BETTER BE😅.
As it “gets job done”, SADLY, I’m reaching for my others nailers first....instead of the Milwaukee 15g 🤦🏼
Cheers✌🏻
I've had same bad luck with my 15 gauge Dewalt. Even on casing it won't always set nail.
Just got the matabo/hitachi/kocoi 15 Guage, seem to be a fair tool
Welcome Back
Great channel, how do you store your nailers for mobility?
I'll have a video coming. But I just changes everything over to the new packout drawers and am loving that setup.
Spencer, you have to try the Ryobi 15 gauge air strike.. best gun I own.. it's a nail sinking beast. Best 200$ you will spend. Had every platform to try and for 15 gauge Ryobi is the boss. You won't be disappointed.
Its 2 times as heavy as the dewalt
Way to heavy for a carpenter
I have same problem with my 16 Guage makita was very disappointed. But still better when doing one window. I'd rather come back and set nails than drag air compressor, hoses, gun, and maybe extension cord. But when doing bigger jobs still have to get compressor out cause to many nails to set.
Hi Spencer, have you tried out the new gen 2 Milwaukee nailer yet? I figured that you would get first dibs and let us know. My trigger finger is getting itchy and I want to know your opinion. Thanks.
gen 1 aint really an excuse for being crap
Ive been thinking of buying a cordless finish nailer. Ive got the GEN2 18g milwaukee and its WONDERFUL . But my 15g pneumatic dewault nailer is freaking FLAWLESS. Its gonna be hard to switch to something that is inferior just to fully be free from my compressor!! AHHHH!
I'm a Milwaukee guy all the way but I gotta say you speak the truth about the 15ga. Wish I would've known this when I bought mine.
My Rep said that the Gen 2 15ga will be out soon.
They just came out with their pin nailer which seems to be good.
Lovely...now that I've bought the gen 1 that makes sense.