‘Debt-ridden mess’: Melbourne pitted against Sydney as new Metro line opens in NSW
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 сен 2024
- Sky News host Steve Price discusses the “debt-ridden mess” of Victoria against Sydney’s new Metro line.
“Something very different has happened … Victoria, and I live there, is a debt-ridden mess,” he said.
“Right now, as of tomorrow, the example of how Sydney has roared ahead of a busted … Melbourne, comes to life when Sydney’s Metro-City Southwest project springs to life.”
Victorians voted Andrew and his Labour team back in after covid, and there still screaming
Seriously who Gives a FK about them.
Trouble is it's the second biggest city in the cuntree.
The again, only our iron ore, coal and gas matter now - for foreigners, not for us, and they aren't in Mel or Syd.
And I am afraid the ALP will lose in 2026.
Why on earth should Australia accept people from Gaza when there are over 20 Muslim countries to which those people could go ??
They are not accepting these Palestinians
Because we have a Labor government and not a good government
Australia shouldn’t accept Israelis either as they are from a war zone.
They don't want them.
They don't want them mate. They get a bit explodey to try to kill kings.
It's not Australia's responsibility to save the world and its citizens. Edit: the Australian government is more concerned with foreigners than it is with its own people.
Managerial class wants a larger tax base for the welfare state. It is a worldwide phenomenon.
@@notsure1135 It's actually a western phenomenon and it's a one way road to hell.
Where you from bub?
@@Deljron777 yep, better way to say it.
@@CalciumHat I'm an OG Aussie If you're asking me :)
No Arab Nation will take them, Speaks volumes.....,.
Will you not learn from the USA, UK and France?
No our political leaders are globalists and low resolution thinkers. This nonsense has been sweeping western governments for quite a few years now. Looks to have WEF DNA all over this trend., 🤔
This is what they want. It's the globalists agenda
Yeh we learnt there is a ruling class that controls sovereign governments around the world.
Same globalist plan obviously
"Learning" implies a certain "intelligence" - Labor and intelligence in the same sentence is an oxy-moron, "without the oxy"!!!!
Hahaha 😅! Daniel Andrews pathetic failures continue.
while he laughs in our faces while collecting his massive pension.
He lives rent free in Steve Prices head. What an idiot
Yet Victorians elected Dan more times than I have toes!!!
Omg 😮what a mistake. Our kids are gonna pay for this blunder.
You and your kids and their kids are gonna pay
Melbourne is the Laughing stock of Australia 😂
That must be why so many people want to live in Melbourne.
@@user-pj5ub5cp9kThird World Shithole 🤣
@@user-pj5ub5cp9k Indians and somalis seem to love it.
@@user-pj5ub5cp9k I bet lots of unemployed people in 3rd world countries want to live in Melbourne.
@@user-pj5ub5cp9konly third worlders
The Melbourne level-crossing project for one train line has taken 5 plus years already. Still not finished.
@@carlsbadventures mister,, sydney got rid of all its level crossings many years ago ,so I've been told. Young Robert
it is for almost every line what are you talking about?
Labor is abusing the integrity of the visitor visa. This should not happen.
the hunchback of melb town got us into this mess. IN DEBT for the next 5 generations
I keep asking why did andrews just up and retire. He always said that he was determined to get things done..the insane idiot andrews has finally realised the mess Victoria is in and does a runner
Another thing we need to think about is the underground rail tunnel that is supposedly going to be operating in a years time I saw a video of 2 foxes running around in the tunnel so what is going to happen is the network will shut down as. The drivers are not going to carry on with the animals stuck in a tunnel and the animal justice party will have something to say about it to..
Wrong. You assume that the next 5 generations will repay the debt. Not so. The system is designed so that the debt can only go up.
@@fabiogasperini5868leave them for the Aboriginal people to pay for, Aboriginal debt trap 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
@@fabiogasperini5868 $23 million PER DAY is the debts interest rate
You forgot to mention it was the State Liberal government that started the Sydney Metro project.
Goes without saying. In my time in Sydney early 2000s Labor built nothing but despair and corruption when i returned the LNP had built so much infrastructure with so much vision. Why on earth did they vote the ALP back in?
@@smiddysmidton8313 because people are stupid and lefties never learn.
They didn't forget. They intentionally want to avoid bringing it up. Not very convenient for the agenda they're pushing!
@@smiddysmidton8313The ABC told them too because LNP is the evil boogeyman to leftists. 😆
Healthcare in NSW was going down the toilet. iPads instead of doctors in the emergency ward, women giving birth in an ambulance because there isn't enough doctors, not enough dentists for school kids to see, our best talent jumping ship to other states - and that's just the start of the issues in the health sector in NSW.
Well, what makes me an outlier I guess! I am 57 year-old English immigrant, with zero interest in tech or stocks, and yet I am 110% committed to Bitcoin. I would describe myself as an extreme conservative/libertarian. I have been involved in UK politics for some time, and the main thing that drove me to study Bitcoin and ultimately recognize its value to Humanity was the threat posed by an over-weening government, first in the UK and lately in the US also. I regard the CBDC as the final brick in the wall of the totalitarian prison the world's governments are building for us. And Bitcoin is the ultimate defence against a tyrannical government.r.....I've been engaged in active trading and managed to grow a nest egg of around 2.3Bitcoin to a decent 24Bitcoin....I'm especially grateful to Aria Cookings, whose deep expertise and traditional trading acumen have been invaluable in this challenging, ever-evolving financial landscape.
Aria Cookings program is widely available online
She often interacts on Telegrams, using the user-name.
@Ariacookings
Aria Cookings strategy has normalized winning trades for me and it’s a huge milestone for me looking back to how it all started.
Aria Cookings was my hope during the 'bear summer' last year. I did so many mistakes but also learned so much from it, and of course from Aria Cookings. She is my number one source when it comes to crypto and TA.
Sydney's always been a less lefty city than Melbourne. It had authoritarian roots as a literal jail and to this day, b.s. will find itself stomped out at a certain point because there's work that has to happen. Melbourne not so much. Which is, I guess, why the state of Victoria seems to go broke with a certain regularity, last time in the early 1990s, now once more.
Yes, but only marginally. Mostly it's the same 💩 in both cities.
But, come on, mate.
You must admit the topography of Sydney beats Melb.
The harbour, the beaches, the mountains, the surrounding national parks, the summer.
@@RUHappyATM nah, we're boxed in, limiting future expansion, and a lot of it is a floodplain or swamp.
@@Boababa-fn3mr
If referring to SYD, yes, it's boxed in. But that's the beauty of it. You have at least 3 National Parks surrounding it.
There are surrounds much better than SYD, IMHO. The Southern Highlands/Tablelands, Central Coast and the near-South Coast.
@@RUHappyATM The surroundings of Sydney are beautiful. The city itself is fast becoming a major sh¡thole.
i think Australia should assist Israel not Palestinians
How about Australians?
Where do you think the money comes from? Do you think it grows on trees? Neither is the better answer.
How about we focus on ourselves for once ffs. My tax money shouldn’t be going overseas
The problem is that they aren't even Palestinians anymore! Hamas overthrew the Palestinian government in 2007 and have been in control as their own country ever since! They are only now saying that they are Palestinians to gather sympathy from the rest of the world. If the Palestine government doesn't care about it's own citizens then why are we caring about a country that has been a terrorist group for the last 17 years!
I think we should help 122 000 homeless Australians, not wars somewhere.
So sick of this government caused division among Australians and doesn’t care about Australians safety
No to Labor No to Greens and No to independent which is lately added to my list!
In Melbourne they cannot even get a ticketing system to work and it still costs billions. You cannot pay for your ticket with an apple phone. I mean is this really 2024?
There is your first mistake. The suburban rail loop is not for the people of Victoria.
obviously. how could connecting the rail lines to make travel easier, be for the citizens. wait… who is it for?
the great thing about melbourne’s rail system is it’s government owned, just a bummer it’s owned by the hong kong/china government. thanks for that one conservatives.
@@jirhoud So spending $40b to connect Box Hill to Cheltenham is real value for money, considering it is only expected to carry 20,000 passenger trips a day? The money would have been better spent carrying passengers from satellite cities (Geelong, Ballarat, Bendigo, etc) via fast rail. No, this is not for the people of Victoria but all to line the pockets of Labor's CFMEU benefactors. The fact that the government refuses to provide the business case to the feds in return for funding says it all. But go ahead and continue to defend the economic vandals that infest our state parliament.
@@easyz6654 it would be a lot more expensive to do it in 20 years when it’s more needed. investment in the future is a novel idea in australia, but glad we’re getting some things right. metro needs to be expanded and more interconnected.
your ideas are great too. if only we better taxed resource extraction, we’d be the wealthiest nation on the planet, with the best infrastructure.
@@easyz6654 the point of infrastructure, especially large mega projects like the suburban rail loop is that you are building for tomorrow, and not today. 20,000 today, but how many in 30, 40, 50 years' time? Melbourne is in desperate need of radial train lines, hence is why the suburban loop is being constructed. Yes, its expensive, but who's going to care about the cost of the project in 30 years. No one most likely. Because the only thing that matters is that it will be able to efficiently transport tens of millions of people a year.
@@jirhoud It is for the people who can purchase the 1 bedroom dogboxes that will be built and owned by (unknown foreign funding) and the people who can afford to buy in said corridor (after the knockdown rebuild of existing property allows foreign purchases), devoid of issues now a planning overlay has been put in place taking it out of councils hands, to get their children to and from (unspecified tertiary establishment)
Victoria, congratulations on your newest catch phrase for your number plates- Victoria the place not to be!!!
Victoria.
The state of the communists
It’s not even that anymore and hasn’t been for ages but I like the joke nonetheless 😂
Apparently it’s The Education State now 😒 🙄 🤦🏻♀️
@@sareenac9348 the Re-education state maybe 😉
@@mr_jdes The Lack of Education State. Check out its Naplan results. Wow. The dumbest kids in the country. Just how Labor wants them. Easier to control.
Victoria the corruption state.
I'm a conservative but I quite like Minns. He has similar aims to me; a strong and free family and economy. We may not always agree on how to achieve that but at least we don't have to wonder if he's trying to destroy the country.
Thank the people of Victoria who voted Chairman Dan back in.
they got sucked in bad.
And they'll vote Labor back in again. It's almost as if lefty brains are incapable of processing logic - such as cause-and-effect, and consequences of your actions.
It would have been cheaper to keep Australians population to a level of 20 million people
No UBI for you!
Better for the environment for sure and lifestyle. They are using population growth to drive the economy and there are powerful lobby groups from the big end of town pushing it.
Australia’s AngloCeltic population is 20m.
@@advanceaustralia3513 That's good. Any idea about the numbers of our Continental European cousins?
@@Westyrulz
Many have intermarried with the AC population over two or three generations. I’ve counted their offspring as AC.
ABS reports there would be under 0.5m born in Europe in Australia, counting citizens and permanent residents. The largest group is Italian at 160k in 2023, down from 200k in 2013.
Including all the non intermarried Europeans, there may be 1.5m altogether in Australia.
The next largest foreign born group is India at 845k and China at 655k.
The largest foreign born population is England(excluding the rest of the UK and Ireland) at 960k.
Other than affordable housing, Sydney is well ahead in many metrics compared to Melbourne. That includes superior public transport infrastructure.
If housing in Sydney can be made more affordable and close to public transport & amenities, it’s game over for Melbourne.
Not going to happen mate, as long as you are in the eyes view of the beach prices will never come down.
no need to bring any won .. we don't need more delivery drivers stupid politicians! we need to manufacture & export all around the world like we used to!
Yeah. In Melbourne dopey Dan's legacy is the eyesore of HUGE concrete structures with trains in the sky.....every efficient city puts em under ground.
Bloody facts, it’s beyond ridiculous!
Disney world has sky trains and people love them.
@@rolback5055 Mickey Mouse and Dan both have big ears, however, rumour has it that Mickey owns up when he has a car accident....
Learn from the UK
They are, by copying every "mistake"
Which is pretty much what Sydney has done with their metro system, considering everyone that worked on the project is English and were formerly employed with TFL
As a Victorian I am appalled at how useless our Labour State Government is, and has been. Dictator Dan and his cohort Jacinta Allen have RUINED this state and Melbourne. We HAVE to VOTE THEM OUT on their butts next election people….
And replace them with the dopey Coalition. Victoria is screwed.
The metro is indeed a world class piece of infrastructure.
Minns has better lap up the opening of these new infrastructure projects, started by the previous government.
As it can be guaranteed that there will be no new infrastructure undervthis Labor government,the same as the last time they were in government in NSW.
Weird how neighbouring Muslim country’s won’t take in Gaza “refugees”………. 😢😢😢😢😢
Do they know something we don't?
The difference between the brilliant Gladys compared to Dan Andrews. Labor v coalition. One gets things done and the other talks about it. It’s never been any different yet fools keep voting labor back in.
Gladys ran one of the most corrupt governments in Australian history... but then so did Dan.
If you think that down here in Victoria we have any Liberals of the calibre of the marvellous Ms Berjiklian, then I want what you are smoking. The Liberals are utter gits down here.
Left in 2008 never going back
@Thunderlips2235. Can quite well understand that and what's more I don't blame you at all. Cheers Michelle
Catching double decker bus in Melbourne worst traffic to the airport…. Must be a win for labor😂
Make it free in Melbourne. Reduce inspectors and get rid of myki
I've spent plenty of time in Melbourne and classier than Sydney was never the impression I got.
Escaped Melbourne in 2021. Best thing ever. The writing was on the wall for years regarding the demise of Victoria.
The fact that Melbourne is still forcing people to use physical Myki cards like its 2008 is bad enough.
Though Sydney has the Opal card, I never carry it - easier to use Apply Pay.
Sydney is booming with massive infrastructure projects including the massive metro train system which is also going to be further exteñded immediately,,,.sydney also has its second international airport soon to open,, sydney also has the worlds most modern tram system ,including parramatta and western suburbs as well as the city centre and inner city suburbs and this tram system is already been approved for further extension. New country passanger trains are on order, new motor ways ètc. Young Robert
still relies on ferries to cross the harbour.
and what does the rest of the state get while Sydney is getting all of this new infrastructure ? New country passenger trains where are they actually going to go to they ripped up all the rail lines that serviced country areas ?
@@Davo-i1s no, there are many country passanger train services. Eg to armadale,, to Tamworth,,,to Bathurst, Albury,, Kyogle,, the nsw North coasr , Dungog,, Newcastle, parks,Dubbo and more. The new trains will enter service in 2026 according to The Government. Also many new roads have been built in the country areas ,and bridges and improved hospitals. Also trains go to Moree às well. I hope this answers some of your questions.. But remember Sydney is the life force and economic power house for the whole country.,and Australia's only Global city. Young Robert
@@davepowelldrumz other cities have ferries. Sydney as having the world's largest and most beautiful harbour has also the largest ferry service..one would expect a city on a large to ferries,and Sydney has the worlds most efficient and modern ferry system as well. From young Robert
Not to mention a new harbour tunnel being built.
Just goes to show how much the CFMEU has their fingers in the pie in Vic compared to NSW
Sydney stage 1 metro project connects outer suburbs to the city.
Melbourne metro tunnel is designed to remove 2 lines from the city loop.
And there is only around a $10 billion cost difference between the widely different projects.
It's not stage 1 of the Sydney metro. Stage 1 was finished in May 2019, this is an extension all the way into the city. Previously Metro passengers changed to regular trains at Chatswood. After this there is one more stage to go which will be finished next year. Currently 21 stations over 52km and as a senior in NSW it only costs me $2.50 a day.
Staffer: "Victorians have needed a train line to the Airport for decades".
Premier Allan: "Tough shit, they're gonna get a train tunnel from Cheltenham to Box Hill".
Staffer: "WTF!! How much will that cost? Nobody wants that!".
Premier Allan: " Well the CFMEU does, and when they say jump, I say how high?".
(Could have been an episode from Working Dog's TV show "Utopia". But unfortunately for Victorians, it's not comedy, it's true).
☹
why box hill ? it's a shithole with nothing there.
@@davepowelldrumz Agreed. Nobody from Cheltenham wants or needs to travel to Box Hill or vice versa. But it will stop at Monash University Clayton, where you can get a quick lecture on "How to vote Labor & embrace Economic Poverty through Communism 101". 🧐
The really scary thing in Melbourne is that this premier will not build the airport rail link which everyone wants and is funded to $10 billion. She is hell bent on the SRL which nobody will ever use. To change from an SRL station to a train station, you have to walk 500m. Such a shambles and vanity project of Allan who builds the platforms at Deer Park 10m too short and tries to say it’s designed like that to be a phased approach. Someone needs to get her to answer questions.
$10 Billion is too much for the Airport line. They could do it for half the price.
@@mjcats2011there's a train line that runs right beside the airport. Just install a platform and a shuttle bus and be done with it. Cost $100k tops
@@hifivaliant8937 If you can build a platform for 100k I want what you are smoking.
Under the previous Liberal Government in NSW, there was a lot of investment into road tunnels! And I recently drove a lot around Europe, and they've got an extensive network of road tunnels too! In Victoria though, the inept Government couldn't build East West Link and seem to be dragging their feet with North East Link and West Gate Tunnel! Victoria has additional challenges of corruption and unionisation of the construction industry, leading to cost blowouts under current and previous Labor Governments! If Victoria had completed infrastructure projects on time, on budget and to a proper standard, and got our infrastructure priorities right, we could have been discussing other big projects that people haven't talked about yet by now! And it's not just transport infrastructure that Melbourne is lagging when compared to Sydney, we are falling behind in dealing with law and order issues, attracting investors and entrepreneurs, our health and education systems and attracting major global events! I will never ever support any Labor Government under any circumstances!
I will never vote for the Coalition no hopers in Victoria many of whom are too busy worrying about Transexuals and Drag Queens.
How irresponsible the Labor dumb ministers can be by simply compromising our Aussie safety for fast tracking to grant ppl coming to our soil without proper scrutiny! So worrying with this policy!
They can't even build an airport line, even little ol Perth just opened one, along with a brand new north east line opening soon.
Don’t forget in Perth we have the Metronet project which is having a huge impact on the city with new lines , extensions and rebuilding a legacy line as elevated rail.
Labor......the enemy within.
The actions of federal Labor is criminal
Thanks Gladys for actually making it happen.
Guess What…. They are not going back……🤔🤔🤔🤫🤫🤫😵💫😵💫😵💫😳
The UN recommends refugees find safety in the closest country not get flown half way around the world, and how can you select refugees from the millions in Gaza
No it doesn't
Minis should not take all the credit for this infrastructure project. It was begun by an LNP Government.
why did they put a clip up of minns and mention “what a good job” hes doing when he nor his government had anything to do with the metro in sydney?
Apparently Israel isn't letting them leave.
If this is tru we have to be grateful to Israel for saving Australia from terrorists
Jesus Christ Melbourne is in deep shit
Far deeper than that
The Melbourne Metro tunnel electromagnetic interference issue around Parkville station is another disgrace for infrastructure in Australia.
Much like Snowy Hydro 2.0 the incomplete and ignored initial studies are leading to far reaching and costly repercussions.
The speed of the trains being reduced and the safety risk to patients and staff in the surrounding medical facilities because of ignored reports is unacceptable.
Another Andrews related bungle.
😎🇦🇺
When are the Melbourne Airport train services starting?
@@RUHappyATM Melbourne is broke,you will never have a train to your airport ,mister.. Sydney,, Perth,, Brisbane do young Robert
@@robertbusuttil7848
Oh, I thought they were just dilly-dallying.
I know I'm on the right news channel when the anchor uses the term busted ass HAHAHAHA 😂 😂 STRAYA
Arse
Easy fix, ask the federal Government to print more money or tax the people some more.
If we want to reduce the traffic jams and pollution remove the high tax from the Airport Metro and let people ride off airport by train for $4-5, not $25-30 as it’s now!
The cost is eye watering.
Melbourne verses Sydney... is it the special olympics already?
Not funny☹!!!
@@chairmandan1794 I'm surprised the comment is still up... 🤣😂
@@chairmandan1794 Mind you, I'm not the one with a picture of a short bus for an avatar... 🤔
Why should Australia take Gazan supposed refugees when all the Islamic countries won't?
Like him or not, Minns got it finished. Like her or not, Gladys was the best transport minister we ever had, but wth was Baird doing there……not much I can say about him while he was in office and after
This new metro maybe an outstanding piece of infrastructure for the state of Sydney it doesnt do much for those of us who live in the rest of NSW.
BUT everyone drives their EV's ????
Melborn's train sounds like Kalifornistan's "high speed" spending of tax money.
I can get to Brisbane quicker than I can get to penrith
The new Sydney Metro looks exactly like the Seoul Subway - the only thing missing is the KFC aka Korean Fried Chicken.
Australians safety first, then whatever welfare of people of other regions
I’ll never use it lol
With the Palestinians, sure, visitor visa the women and children and let the men got through refugee visa.
None should be accepted there are plenty of other countries that should accept these people like Iran or Yemen or even Afghanistan
None, we already have so called children from Africa robbing and killing our people
@@stephenkirton9921 Except NO Muslim country wants them. What does that tell you?
Melbourne Airport 🤢
Daniel Andrews is still haunting Victoria and will be for the next 2 decades
We have an expensive Sydney, everyone wants to leave and yet still outgoing and shining, and a delusional ‘best city in the world’ Melbourne. The gap is maximising, free trade > protectionism.
$21 billion is not a bad price.
exactly Dan andrew made all those debt
Australia gets far sexier press with "save the world" headlines.
Whatever happened to Airbus Albo? He was far more tolerable when he was never here.
No love for taxpaying citizens 😮
The Melbourne 'big build' Rail Loop is the outer suburbs' 'yellow (golden) brick road' to education for students : all concession card holders!! 😍
But…..now you need to stand in peak hour, each way, each day. Is this an improvement?
Driverless train is the way. Look at singapore and Japan!!
Trains aye campbelltown to Parramatta used to take 40 min now 2.30 hours 😢 historical
Doctor exactly
Yeah - that’s right. Same applies to the Ukrainians
SKY congratulating Sydney installing socialist welfare public transport?
Hahahaha so public transport is socialist welfare hahahaha. What do you call Melbournes transport system?
Congratulations you are now in the running for the Annual Stupid Comment of The Year Award.
After this video, I'm your fan
💙
Myki 2.5 Billion.$
Half works.
Good government will try to attract foreign investments, allow foreign talents to fill the gap in labor market, then only can it create new high paying jobs for its residents. Many countries are unable to attract foreign investment and talent into their economies and labor market. Don’t loose sight of the big picture. Don’t be xenophobic. Don’t ruin the future of Australia.
No Melbourne behind by around 300,000 in population
The Chinese debt trap? Or Aboriginal debt trap? 😂😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉🎉
I lived in London. We should copy the London Underground system.
The thing about that is - it was built a very, very long time ago, when governments had vision and money had value. Look at the mess over there with Crossrail - years of delays, cost blowouts, and a large section cancelled. It's par for the course these days that infrastructure roll-outs become a nightmare. Sydney got off lightly this time, and the new airport seems to be going ok. I don't know what Melbourne can do from here, but they have to make a start.
Ffs 🤦🏻♂️
Central station looks hideous.
The heritage inside Central has been destroyed.
The original sandstone buildings, original station signs and grand concourse are all still there
@@deanl4575 i know,but inside has been gutted,and there was just as much heritage and nostalgia inside as there was out.
What they've done to it is horrendous.
Melbourne's HS0.2 Railway
Sick of steve price bitching about melb. So leave! Sydney project also was a blowout! 12bn over budget to 25 bn.
You look impervious to laxatives…
How much has Sky made from Raygun already?
Raygun. The laughing stock of the world 🤦♂️
@@ACDZ123 Sad you need a Raygun to care or give perspective about anything around you?
No question, you are stuck with them. Allahu Akbar!