i- thank you I needed that laugh lmao this physically upsets me that we just leave smudge in the first few pages and he loses his friend and he dosnt get his own super edition.
@@alexaclawsister Hahah, sorry about the misunderstanding. I was saying that I *would* think about this comment, for the *next* 3 months. I didn't say that I had been thinking about that for the *past* three months.i hope I've cleared it up.
'Smudge gazed into the town. Many seasons ago, some workfolk had chopped down the entire forest, and replaced them with nests. Sure, it meant loads of new friends for Smudge, but what about Rusty? Firestar, actually. The ginger tom had visited him all those seasons ago, explaining to him that he was leader now. He told Smudge all about Clan life, and how he had two daughters of his own now: Squirrelpaw and Leafpaw. He'd promised Smudge he would bring him some of the forest prey to try, and some of the beautiful flowers that grew in the forest. So every day, he waited...and waited...and waited...and then the Clans had disappeared, with no goodbye, no explanation...like they disappeared, into the wind. "Smudge! Come with me: Ermine's telling us about how his housefolk made him sleep outside!" called a voice. Smudge glanced up. Pear, another domesticated cat, was standing on the fence. "No thanks, Pear. I'm old, your young. You won't want me ruining your fun." purred Smudge, his amber eyes glinting playfully. Pear looked saddened, but she nodeed and disappeared into another cat's garden. "You can't keep waiting, y'know. He probably forgot about you." snapped a voice. To Smuge's disgust, it was one of the bully cats, though he wasn't sure of the name of this specific one. "Rusty would *never* forget me! He's just...taking a while to pick the flowers." snarled Smudge, but from the way the two cats were looking at each other, they both knew it wasn't true.'
I think smudge & Princess at least deserve a novella where they meet and talk about Firestar and both their experiences and go to find him towards the 2-4 arcs to get some closure because firestar kinda kicked them sure he gave Princess and smudge A few visits but he kind of left them… that’s why I think they deserve a novella it would be nice to hear from both their sides Anybody agree with me? (Also could you credit the artist(s) please ?) Edit:HOLYYY- thanks for the likes lol
Smudge deservers more stories, the Sky clan visions were actually cool, it will be something awesome instead of Firestar it will be Smudge but more like the ghost of Skyclan guide him to the clan
It was nice that after the first arc, in Firestar’s quest Smudge did get some closure. He saw Firestar one last time and learned what happened to him, how he became leader and his adventures. I’m pretty sure I heard somewhere that after the clans let, smudge told others about the life Firestar told him about and with a combination between him and Barley, the stories are what inspired Warrior Clan.
And Princess! It’s really sad, tbh. The fact that 2 characters whon would have been really important to Firestar get left behind. However many likes this gets is how many times the Erins get pestered to make a Novella for Princess and Smudge >:]
I really want to know more about smudge. It physically hurts me when I think about how he's been forgotten, and his friend left him and how he was right, those cats in the forest did kill him, over and over again, actually and we never saw smudge again, and smudge never knew what happened, just that he had lost his friend. It physically hurts my heart. As well as the fact that he had so much character potential. Let's us scream at Erin and beg for Smudge's own super edition Edit: i..I... was gonna say something but GOD DAMN IT O FORGOT IT T
Actually I feel like Princess was the forgotten one, and that Smudge is living his best life. He didn’t want to join forest like Rusty, so I wouldn’t call him “poor”, or a character that deserves any book. Of course, if his personality and story were shown more it could be interesting. Sadly there are too many forgotten characters that sometimes even deserve a novella.
This made me cry I now feel so bad for smudge he lost his best friend and he waited and firestar promised he would visit every day but he didn't I'm sorry I need to go cry now 😢
Why am I actually crying over this? I honestly forgot Smudge existed since I’m so far into the series, and I can’t help but feel bad… I’ve honestly never really thought about how Smudge must have felt when Rusty left him, I couldn’t imagine losing my best friend…
man it gets me every time, its so sad really ngl!! I'm surprised how Cody, The kittypet that was stuck in a cage next to Leafpaw in the 2nd series of Warrior cat books, didn't even get to tell Firestar bout if he really did know Smudge. its so sad!!!
This is incredibly sad! Don't you think Firestar would've at least gone and told his old friend that they were leaving the forest in season two? This also makes you wonder how Princess feels! She could be worried sick along with Smudge, and both of them still haven't been informed on how he's doing. Let's get both of them a novella already!
Yeah I want that but I can I have a theory. What if smudge didn’t recognize rusty because his name is fire star and he hasn’t seen him in years. And if fire star did go see him and try to talk with him the clans would hate him Plus maybe smudge family moved? But I really hope they make a book about smudge.
The thing is, I’m pretty sure when Fire’Star left the forest to go to the lake, he didn’t tell smudge- Or princess He just left, without telling either of them..
Ya’ll are right but like think about it, Firestar’s first arrival and he already got beef with tigerclaw, then he was sent on a mission to find windclan, then driving Brokenstar out of shadowclan while saving a litter of kits, more tiger claw drama AND Graystripe romeo and Juliet thing followed by the is Mistyfoot and stonefur the lost kits of thunderclan type of thing, then he became deputy after exposing tigerclaw which requires A LOT of work for him since bluestar was a wreck in those times, more tigerclaw drama THEN he became a leader and then MORE tigerclaw drama bonus Riverclan and Bloodclan THEN he found out that there was 5 clans instead of 4 and was called to revive Sky clan and so on… so obviously he doesn’t have much space to visit them, well at least he did try making time i guess-
I'm literally crying right now this is so sad I love Smudge so much and I had a cat who looked like him who got lost a while ago and I'm so saddddd Also I love the art-
I'm reading Firestar's Quest atm and I feel like Smudge should've gone with Firestar and Sandstorm bc he's such a sweet boi💜💖 YEAH DON'T THINK I FORGOT ABT HATTIE
I’m literally crying now 😭 whenever I was reading the book and dusty left him I literally burst out crying. But can’t he visit though? A year later still crying from this
This is just sad, I feel bad fro smudge the fact most his life he's been freinds with rusty now He's turned into Thunder clan lead and will never come back
I'd love to see this song put over Fallen Leaves, the elders they left behind before the Great Journey, or Ashfur when Squirrelflight chooses Brambleclaw
My man barely gets any time in the books and doesn't even get a Super Addition or Novella in return, HES MY FAVORITE CHARACTER. #GiveSmudgeANovella #SmudgeSuperAddition Yes I am literally putting hashtags in my comment, that's how much I like him.
Imma be real- I kinda think that Princess and Smudge think Firestar is dead. Because, he hasn’t visited them in YEARS and the forest was destroyed. They don’t know where he is (unless they saw him leaving for the lake, which I don’t remember)
I like to imagine Fire’stars owner got a new cat that smudge is best friends with, then that cat goes to the forests and tries to join but isn’t allowed to which makes smudge wonder if rusty is dead.
Spoilers! Don’t read if you don’t want spoilers and haven’t read past the first arc. I feel so bad for smudge. Firestar left him for some rando cats he just met (Frozen vibes lol) but smudge felt safest back at kp, even thought rusty was his bff. At least he got another friend when he left. Plus, Princess, once they saw each other, gave cloudtail to him. Now that they went to the lake, smudge nor Princess will ever see the cats important to them, unless they go to the lake aswell, which by the way I see the books, that won’t happen, especially now that firestar was dead! They deserve so much more..
I love this, but I just..wanna cry so badly, then I get anxiety because Smudge is probably on the fence still, telling himself after the forest is destroyed, "If he doesn't come soon...I'll believe he's dead...." Poor Smudge!
Alright...I'm only on book 4 in the first arc....but I feel so bad for poor Smudge. He deserves way better and I feel like he should play a bigger part in the books...
omg this is actually really sad, im still crying. Firestar left the forest only thinking of his Clan and Greystripe (leaving him behind) and he forgot all about Smudge and Princess! He promised to visit Smudge more often but never did 😭
Smudge deserves much more love from Firestar and instead of visiting his sister (sorry for spoilers anyone who hasn’t read that book), he could also visit Smudge. He’s lonely too.
Noooo, that's so sad, especially with the music, which reminds me of another animation I saw about smudge and Rusty(now Firestar) with the song two birds on a wire.
"Princess!" Her house folk called her back to her nest, though she couldn't come. She staring out, watching as the huge trucks tore apart the trees of the forest. Somewhere out there was Firestar, living his life as a Clan leader. And her son, Cloudtail, probably clan deputy by now. She sighed as she couldn't bear the thoughts and memories filling her head. She hoped they were ok. Maybe he'll visit me? What about Smudge? "Princess!" A different call cut her thoughts as a she cat trot towards her. "Hi, Cody." She meowed at last, not taking her gaze off of the roaring destruction. "It's sad isn't it? I hope Leafpaw will be okay..." Cody sighed "Leafpaw? Firestar's daughter?" "I think so...she rescued me from the mean old house folk that held me captive." Cody finished. "Have you talked to them? Are they okay?" Princess meowed in a hurry, tearing her gaze towards Cody Cody looked away. "They're half starved. And- and-..." Worry dropped into Princess's belly "They're going to leave the forest, Princess." Cody told her. Sadness rose into her throat. "Firestar never told me," She could just choke the words out. "Did he-did he forget about me?" She wanted to cry out loud. "Of course he didn't, hell say goodbye, I'm sure of it." Cody's empty words couldn't fill her heart. She swung her head down to stare and the ground. "At least he's going to be safe." Princess murmured. (Thx for reading, that was a lot)
Despite everything I think smudge would move on. He chose to stay for a reason, he likes being a KittyPet. Even when having dreams of the clans he was terrified to join. He missed Rusty but not so much he couldn’t move on and make new friends. I think its princess who‘d really struggle knowing her reckless son was out there, not knowing if both of them were safe by the lake.
Poor Smudge :(( At first when I was reading into the wild I was happy that Rusty is going to the forest but when I realised how Smudge Has to be sad I feel sorry for Him :((
Poor smudge, and princess. If only they knew Firestar was happy in Starclan, and his own clan. I bet they were so horrified and worried seeing the Forest torn down knowing he lived there.
We need more on Smudge. I mean, he was just *left* there. His best friend went to clan life, then they moved away. Far far away. And he’d never see his best friend again. I mean it’s just heartbreaking 😢 Smudge is one of my fav characters 😭😭 my poor baby.
I never actually thought of how Smudge felt. I, to be honest, kinda forgot about him. 😬😅 But now that I watch this, it does make me kinda sad. I mean, Firestar told him that he’d come and visit, yet he never did. I also wonder what Princess and Smudge felt like, seeing the forest torn down. They both knew that their friend/brother was in the forest. One thing that makes me sad, was that the cats left everything they knew behind. Firestar left behind Smudge and Princess, and all the clans left the burial places of some of the cats they loved behind. I also wonder if Cloudtail ever felt sadness because he left behind his mother. Edit: I know this comment was kind of a jumbled up comment of things that might not have to do with this video, but they’re just my thoughts :3
Poor Smudge. My man literally lost his balls and he doesn't even get a novella in return 😔
What!? Lmao
i- thank you I needed that laugh lmao this physically upsets me that we just leave smudge in the first few pages and he loses his friend and he dosnt get his own super edition.
Hes still waiting
Yeah so sad 😔😔😅
I bet he doesn't even know FireStar left him for the lake. He needs his own book, at least a manga.
Smudge and princess must’ve been so horrified seeing the forest torn down.
God it physically make my heart hurt thinking about it.
Cody told them what happened though so hopefully that gave them hope for Firestar
@@Ara-gq7sb I was about to think about this comment for next 3 months non-stop, until you said that. Thank you.
Oh yes 😭.
@@alexaclawsister Hahah, sorry about the misunderstanding. I was saying that I *would* think about this comment, for the *next* 3 months. I didn't say that I had been thinking about that for the *past* three months.i hope I've cleared it up.
damn i feel bad for smudge whenever i think of him, because rusty left him for some strangers in the forest
And then Firestar never thinks about smudge ever again while smudge was left behind
@@Plxgue_D0c yeah
Though it must be stressful being a KITTYPET in a clan especially when you're the clan leader
@@Peachthefox90 yes I bet
Well he did warn him if he didn’t come back his house folk will maybe get another cat he can hang out with
Yeah
'Smudge gazed into the town. Many seasons ago, some workfolk had chopped down the entire forest, and replaced them with nests. Sure, it meant loads of new friends for Smudge, but what about Rusty? Firestar, actually. The ginger tom had visited him all those seasons ago, explaining to him that he was leader now. He told Smudge all about Clan life, and how he had two daughters of his own now: Squirrelpaw and Leafpaw. He'd promised Smudge he would bring him some of the forest prey to try, and some of the beautiful flowers that grew in the forest. So every day, he waited...and waited...and waited...and then the Clans had disappeared, with no goodbye, no explanation...like they disappeared, into the wind.
"Smudge! Come with me: Ermine's telling us about how his housefolk made him sleep outside!" called a voice. Smudge glanced up. Pear, another domesticated cat, was standing on the fence.
"No thanks, Pear. I'm old, your young. You won't want me ruining your fun." purred Smudge, his amber eyes glinting playfully. Pear looked saddened, but she nodeed and disappeared into another cat's garden.
"You can't keep waiting, y'know. He probably forgot about you." snapped a voice. To Smuge's disgust, it was one of the bully cats, though he wasn't sure of the name of this specific one.
"Rusty would *never* forget me! He's just...taking a while to pick the flowers." snarled Smudge, but from the way the two cats were looking at each other, they both knew it wasn't true.'
Oh my gosh no! This is perfectly written though!
This is beautifully written!! I felt like I was reading a book from the Erin’s themselves!!
Here is what to do about this comment:
Like it
Lay on your bed and try not to cry.
Cry.
No cause you’re making me cry, say sorry rn
Apology with tears rn
Fun fact that kinda relates to this:
Princess still sits on the fence to this day wondering where Firestar is and if he is ok
:0
Oh did he die?
I'm still reading new prophecies
@@Peachthefox90 He does eventually but not until many books later
that's not true. Leafpool's kittypet friend (i forgot her name) promised she'd tell Princess that the clans were leaving the forest
@@RoseyStar24 oh alright
I think smudge & Princess at least deserve a novella where they meet and talk about Firestar and both their experiences and go to find him towards the 2-4 arcs to get some closure because firestar kinda kicked them sure he gave Princess and smudge A few visits but he kind of left them… that’s why I think they deserve a novella it would be nice to hear from both their sides Anybody agree with me? (Also could you credit the artist(s) please ?)
Edit:HOLYYY- thanks for the likes lol
I agree with you man
I agree
Agreed
I agree
Yes
Smudge deservers more stories, the Sky clan visions were actually cool, it will be something awesome instead of Firestar it will be Smudge but more like the ghost of Skyclan guide him to the clan
Oo yeah!
Yeah!
Poor Smudge…
WE NEED SMUDGE TO JOIN THE CLANS!!!
Smudge: Damn... I'm lonely
Skyclan: **Casually commits stealing**
Honestly, Smudge deserves an Ultimate Edition of his own, with him being the narrator, watching as things go by.
It was nice that after the first arc, in Firestar’s quest Smudge did get some closure. He saw Firestar one last time and learned what happened to him, how he became leader and his adventures. I’m pretty sure I heard somewhere that after the clans let, smudge told others about the life Firestar told him about and with a combination between him and Barley, the stories are what inspired Warrior Clan.
They also met in into the wild
dude i feel so bad for smudge... and rusty said "i'll come back and visit".... sad.. 😥
Yeah, he lied about coming back
@@Gh.stedPines he did though, just like a few times
@@Gh.stedPines I mean he couldn't really come back after the clans moved
@@CircusSabre He had a lot more freedom to when he was still a warrior and not a leader, he just never really did.
@@CircusSabre I know,just saying
And Princess! It’s really sad, tbh. The fact that 2 characters whon would have been really important to Firestar get left behind.
However many likes this gets is how many times the Erins get pestered to make a Novella for Princess and Smudge >:]
Yeah, but you need to remember that Cody, the kittypet from The New Prophecy, was confirmed to have explained everything to Princess.
I really want to know more about smudge. It physically hurts me when I think about how he's been forgotten, and his friend left him and how he was right, those cats in the forest did kill him, over and over again, actually and we never saw smudge again, and smudge never knew what happened, just that he had lost his friend. It physically hurts my heart. As well as the fact that he had so much character potential. Let's us scream at Erin and beg for Smudge's own super edition
Edit: i..I... was gonna say something but GOD DAMN IT O FORGOT IT T
Let's do it!
Actually I feel like Princess was the forgotten one, and that Smudge is living his best life. He didn’t want to join forest like Rusty, so I wouldn’t call him “poor”, or a character that deserves any book. Of course, if his personality and story were shown more it could be interesting.
Sadly there are too many forgotten characters that sometimes even deserve a novella.
This is so sad I feel so bad for smudge!!
I remember that rusty said he will visit but he lied☹️☹️☹️
This made me cry I now feel so bad for smudge he lost his best friend and he waited and firestar promised he would visit every day but he didn't I'm sorry I need to go cry now 😢
Smudge deserves a book i say!!
I feel so bad for Smudge because idk why but I love him 😭
Ngl I was about to cry when I watched this. Like not Firestar saying just for a look, then comeing back and leaving! Like poor Smudge!😭
Why am I actually crying over this? I honestly forgot Smudge existed since I’m so far into the series, and I can’t help but feel bad… I’ve honestly never really thought about how Smudge must have felt when Rusty left him, I couldn’t imagine losing my best friend…
Speaking Of Smudge,
*Smudge Super Edition Now*
man it gets me every time, its so sad really ngl!! I'm surprised how Cody, The kittypet that was stuck in a cage next to Leafpaw in the 2nd series of Warrior cat books, didn't even get to tell Firestar bout if he really did know Smudge. its so sad!!!
I feel so bad for smudge😞. He should have a novella or something
Awwwwww, poor smudge 🥺 i wanna give him a hug
Smudge is my favorite. I wish there was more about him 🥺
For a brief moment my super big megamind brain confused Smudge with Scourge
Edit: English is hard sometimes
10,000 IQ
same- i always do that
Ah, when I looked at the title then clicked on the video I was like: “wait- Fire’Star didn’t have a close relation with scourge.. oh right.
Same
SMUDGE SHALL NOW RULE THE KINGDOM OF THE SAD KITTYPETS *Gives Smudge a crown*
The sad part is the Smudge didn't know that Rusty( aka Fire'Star) was crushed by a tree.
He wasn’t
This is incredibly sad! Don't you think Firestar would've at least gone and told his old friend that they were leaving the forest in season two? This also makes you wonder how Princess feels! She could be worried sick along with Smudge, and both of them still haven't been informed on how he's doing. Let's get both of them a novella already!
Yeah I want that but I can I have a theory. What if smudge didn’t recognize rusty because his name is fire star and he hasn’t seen him in years. And if fire star did go see him and try to talk with him the clans would hate him Plus maybe smudge family moved? But I really hope they make a book about smudge.
Smudge should have his own story, and Firestar should visit him more often
YOOOOOO This shouldn’t hit me in the feels as bad as it does, got me tearing up man…
CAN WE TALK ABOUT HOW PRETTY THE ART IS THOUGH? LIKE THE SMUDGE ART IS STUNNING
The thing is, I’m pretty sure when Fire’Star left the forest to go to the lake, he didn’t tell smudge- Or princess
He just left, without telling either of them..
Ya’ll are right but like think about it, Firestar’s first arrival and he already got beef with tigerclaw, then he was sent on a mission to find windclan, then driving Brokenstar out of shadowclan while saving a litter of kits, more tiger claw drama AND Graystripe romeo and Juliet thing followed by the is Mistyfoot and stonefur the lost kits of thunderclan type of thing, then he became deputy after exposing tigerclaw which requires A LOT of work for him since bluestar was a wreck in those times, more tigerclaw drama THEN he became a leader and then MORE tigerclaw drama bonus Riverclan and Bloodclan THEN he found out that there was 5 clans instead of 4 and was called to revive Sky clan and so on… so obviously he doesn’t have much space to visit them, well at least he did try making time i guess-
Poor Smudge. For me he is nostalgic
"Please don't go Rusty. I might never see you again."
Something funnier is my irl cat is named smudge and hes the same color but more fluffy.
Wdym funnier? If you have bad English I’m just pointing that out, just make sure that your cats (smudge) best friend doesn’t get lost in the forest!
Yes, Firestar develops his loyalty with Thunderclan. But Erin Hunter ( probably ) never mentioned about him forgetting his childhood friends.
Everyone talking about Smudge:
Meanwhile Princess: ._.
smudge is one of my favorite cats ever!
Who gives you the RIGHT TO MAKE ME CRY!?
But seriously, Smudge deserves his own book.
YOU HAVE TO CREDIT THE ARTISTS! I HAPPEN TO KNOW WHO MADE THE ART OF SMUDGE!
who? /gen
That almost made me cry...Poor Smudge😭..and the song made it even MORE sadder😭
Smudge deserves a novella!
But we have to remember that Firestar told him that he joined the clans! At least that :))
This just *sniff* breaks my heart now I'm really sad but smudge deserves more, I also vote on him getting his own book.
All love smudge 😔
@HawkStrik3 yes we should everyone that votes on smudge getting his own book should help
I'm literally crying right now this is so sad I love Smudge so much and I had a cat who looked like him who got lost a while ago and I'm so saddddd
Also I love the art-
They didn't make it
I'm reading Firestar's Quest atm and I feel like Smudge should've gone with Firestar and Sandstorm bc he's such a sweet boi💜💖
YEAH DON'T THINK I FORGOT ABT HATTIE
I’m literally crying now 😭 whenever I was reading the book and dusty left him I literally burst out crying. But can’t he visit though?
A year later still crying from this
This is just sad, I feel bad fro smudge the fact most his life he's been freinds with rusty now He's turned into Thunder clan lead and will never come back
😢 poor baby..he was honestly one of my favorite
I'd love to see this song put over Fallen Leaves, the elders they left behind before the Great Journey, or Ashfur when Squirrelflight chooses Brambleclaw
This is the sadest thing I've ever seen omg - I never looked at it like that 😭
My man barely gets any time in the books and doesn't even get a Super Addition or Novella in return, HES MY FAVORITE CHARACTER. #GiveSmudgeANovella #SmudgeSuperAddition
Yes I am literally putting hashtags in my comment, that's how much I like him.
They meet again but they say one last goodbye in one of the series I read
Smudge still waits for his friend ❤️.
I don’t cry at much, but this made me cry and for you that’s a good review well done
I feel for smudge.
fire star sees his sister more then his best freind that is mest up i feel so bad for smudge
Imma be real- I kinda think that Princess and Smudge think Firestar is dead. Because, he hasn’t visited them in YEARS and the forest was destroyed. They don’t know where he is (unless they saw him leaving for the lake, which I don’t remember)
Smudge will wait forever. Firestar Sadly passed due to wounds
I like to imagine Fire’stars owner got a new cat that smudge is best friends with, then that cat goes to the forests and tries to join but isn’t allowed to which makes smudge wonder if rusty is dead.
Spoilers! Don’t read if you don’t want spoilers and haven’t read past the first arc.
I feel so bad for smudge. Firestar left him for some rando cats he just met (Frozen vibes lol) but smudge felt safest back at kp, even thought rusty was his bff. At least he got another friend when he left. Plus, Princess, once they saw each other, gave cloudtail to him. Now that they went to the lake, smudge nor Princess will ever see the cats important to them, unless they go to the lake aswell, which by the way I see the books, that won’t happen, especially now that firestar was dead! They deserve so much more..
I always loved smudge, but he was then forgotten and I’ve always wanted him to return to help in the story.😞
Smudge was my fav and he been in the book for 5min😭😭.Poor smudge😓😞 i hope he gets new freinds
Imagine smudge seeing the forest fire. Poor smudge he must had been horrified
I JUST HAD TO WATCH IT AGAIN!? I CANT STOP CRYING ABOUT THIS VIDEO!😭😭😭
I love this, but I just..wanna cry so badly, then I get anxiety because Smudge is probably on the fence still, telling himself after the forest is destroyed, "If he doesn't come soon...I'll believe he's dead...." Poor Smudge!
i forgot that Smudge was still waiting and princess. This touched my heart and made me cry 😖😭😭
Damn..I’m crying rn..
Alright...I'm only on book 4 in the first arc....but I feel so bad for poor Smudge. He deserves way better and I feel like he should play a bigger part in the books...
omg this is actually really sad, im still crying. Firestar left the forest only thinking of his Clan and Greystripe (leaving him behind)
and he forgot all about Smudge and Princess! He promised to visit Smudge more often but never did 😭
I wan’t a super edition For him, the only story we really get from him. Is graystripe’s vow
Smudge deserves much more love from Firestar and instead of visiting his sister (sorry for spoilers anyone who hasn’t read that book), he could also visit Smudge. He’s lonely too.
Noooo, that's so sad, especially with the music, which reminds me of another animation I saw about smudge and Rusty(now Firestar) with the song two birds on a wire.
Tbh I think smudge deserves a super addition it’d be interesting to see his perspective and get to understand him better
"Princess!"
Her house folk called her back to her nest, though she couldn't come. She staring out, watching as the huge trucks tore apart the trees of the forest. Somewhere out there was Firestar, living his life as a Clan leader. And her son, Cloudtail, probably clan deputy by now. She sighed as she couldn't bear the thoughts and memories filling her head. She hoped they were ok. Maybe he'll visit me? What about Smudge?
"Princess!"
A different call cut her thoughts as a she cat trot towards her.
"Hi, Cody." She meowed at last, not taking her gaze off of the roaring destruction.
"It's sad isn't it? I hope Leafpaw will be okay..." Cody sighed
"Leafpaw? Firestar's daughter?"
"I think so...she rescued me from the mean old house folk that held me captive." Cody finished.
"Have you talked to them? Are they okay?" Princess meowed in a hurry, tearing her gaze towards Cody
Cody looked away. "They're half starved. And- and-..."
Worry dropped into Princess's belly
"They're going to leave the forest, Princess." Cody told her.
Sadness rose into her throat.
"Firestar never told me," She could just choke the words out. "Did he-did he forget about me?" She wanted to cry out loud.
"Of course he didn't, hell say goodbye, I'm sure of it."
Cody's empty words couldn't fill her heart. She swung her head down to stare and the ground.
"At least he's going to be safe." Princess murmured. (Thx for reading, that was a lot)
Not to mention Hattie, she's a reminder of Rusty/Firestar to Smudge every time he sees her
I legit cried seeing this- 🥺
My heart sank as soon as I saw the "what about me" with smudge.
Dang,rusty/firestar left smudge for strange naked forest cats
BRO I AGREE!
Aww... feel for him... I kinda felt like Smudge at one point, but I've found my place now, like I've found my clan ^^
Despite everything I think smudge would move on. He chose to stay for a reason, he likes being a KittyPet. Even when having dreams of the clans he was terrified to join. He missed Rusty but not so much he couldn’t move on and make new friends.
I think its princess who‘d really struggle knowing her reckless son was out there, not knowing if both of them were safe by the lake.
cough cough *Princess* cough cough
that last part hit me hard..
it felt like that my cat was still waiting to be free and come back to earth..
POOR SMUDGE, IT WOULD BE A DREAM COME TRUE TO SEE SMUDGE AND PRINCESS REUNITE WITH FIRESTAR
It’s heartbreaking I feel bad for smudge
Poor smudge, if I ever get a cat like him I will name him smudge
Poor Smudge :(( At first when I was reading into the wild I was happy that Rusty is going to the forest but when I realised how Smudge Has to be sad I feel sorry for Him :((
I feel so bad for smudge:(, and princess is there too, wondering how Firestar is, knowing she'll never see him again:(
This almost made me cry and I just started reading the first book a week ago-
In FireStars quest smudge does go into the forest! To find Rusty, but I haven’t finished it so I don’t know if he goes back to a kitty pet..
Poor smudge, and princess. If only they knew Firestar was happy in Starclan, and his own clan. I bet they were so horrified and worried seeing the Forest torn down knowing he lived there.
Yo can you credit the artists?.. i See you do alot of edits and not really your own stuff which is a bit weird?
We need more on Smudge. I mean, he was just *left* there. His best friend went to clan life, then they moved away. Far far away. And he’d never see his best friend again. I mean it’s just heartbreaking 😢 Smudge is one of my fav characters 😭😭 my poor baby.
but dang how could he betray smudge like that
I think Smudge had a good life, he probably enjoyed his time as a kittypet and most likely just vibed lmao
If I remember correctly, didn’t smudge get a new friend next doors where Firestar used to live? And Smudge has princess.
It would be a cool twist if smudge became a 'villain' of the story
I never actually thought of how Smudge felt. I, to be honest, kinda forgot about him. 😬😅 But now that I watch this, it does make me kinda sad. I mean, Firestar told him that he’d come and visit, yet he never did. I also wonder what Princess and Smudge felt like, seeing the forest torn down. They both knew that their friend/brother was in the forest. One thing that makes me sad, was that the cats left everything they knew behind. Firestar left behind Smudge and Princess, and all the clans left the burial places of some of the cats they loved behind. I also wonder if Cloudtail ever felt sadness because he left behind his mother.
Edit: I know this comment was kind of a jumbled up comment of things that might not have to do with this video, but they’re just my thoughts :3
I'm so glad I'm not the only one who's been wondering about Smudge and his thoughts. It always just makes me so sad.
stop- this is making me cry-