Interview With Justice Madan B Lokur On Collegium System- Transparency In Judicial Appointments
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 авг 2024
- #supremecourtofindia #collegium #supremecourt
Interview of Justice Madan B Lokur, former judge of the Supreme Court, with Manu Sebastian, Managing Editor of LiveLaw.
LiveLaw brings you the latest legal news and updates from India and beyond.
We are into fact based legal journalism.
Endeavour of LiveLaw is to play an active role for a transparent and democratic legal ecosystem, in the larger public interest.
Stay updated. Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/2pskgB3
Support Us: bit.ly/35qFj6A
Visit Our Website: www.livelaw.in/
hindi.livelaw.in
Facebook: / livelawindia
/ livelawhindi
Twitter: / livelawindia
/ livelawh
Instagram: / livelaw.in
/ livelawhindi
Linkedin: / livelaw
/ livelaw-hindi
Live Law app is India's fastest legal news app that will keep you updated on the latest law/legal news from India and across the world. Download now.
Android: bit.ly/2toaimp
iOS: apple.co/39dQ0vh
live proceedings of all courts should be livestreamed. Increase transparency. Absolutely agree
That will reduce the arrogance, ranting from bench and other stupidities
Public scrutiny is the safeguard against biased decisions. The collegial system must go.
This is really shameful ,tht judges for apex court are appointed in close door manner..why this cover up, people should know how the so called God temple of justice are appointed and how they deliver justice
The foremost requirement is progeniosis and second is Chamchagiri. The selection has to be open, candidates must be announced and all complaints examined publicly.
Very pointed questins and very polite answers by resp. J. Lokursir. He is very modest.
Transparency is needed from collegium as well
Madan you have to give your resignation when your name is recommended by the collegium for supreme court judge.when you people get office as supreme court judge than at that you have to give voluntary resignation and protest against the collegium system.after completion of tenure it looks meaningless
The collegium should go transparency should maintain
Excellent as ever! Keep it up Manuji
Collegium is the wrost system not 1scheduled tribe judge in 75 year's in supreme court
Judges selecting Judges is incorrect. A judicial appointments commission has to be set up.
Mr. Madan … who the hell these collegium judges appointing judges. Who is going to make you accountable. You appoint yourself and then ask who is executive accountable.
Executive are accountable every five years through elections.
Your knowledge and bias towards judges appointing judges proves your knowledge and understanding of democracy.
Nowhere the world judges appoint other judges.
Don’t lecture after retirement.
I am still waiting for Justice Quereshi to be CJI
That wont happen because our HM does not like him.
@@MASH6666 chup kar basdk .. Terra ma ki ..
Let us have his comments on transparency in what is happening in the deliberations happening in their meeting,, on appointments and other vital discussions..
.
They will take high moral ground on unwarranted encroachments...
They take duplicity on all issues...
As a citizen I know one thing ,be it supreme court or the executive,Unless the system of selection by the collegium is not transparent how & why you blame the executive for withholding names or whatever. Justice Locur seems to suggest that whoever is recommended by Supreme court's collegium system,which is not transparent,has to be accepted by the government. Is not this a dictatorship of the court that 5 wise men are selecting fellw judges without any laid down procedure and processes.
How do you think that politicians can recommend or comment on efficieny of judges?
Very candid conversation...thnx lordship
Who are the other members of judicial service commission of Fiji.
Excellent.
Brilliant
Judicial system is saying through collegium system that they are the law of land, their judgement over and above constitution and the will of people !!
NJAC should come. Judges should be selected through Indian Judicial services. How can Judges appoint themselves. What's the merit?
To be really independent pillar, executive should have no role. But to make it impartial, it should be made more broad based ie instead of at present 3 judges it should be 9 and if possible all judges of SC to select by anonymous remarks (for transparency right to information) and secret ballot yes /no, With live video recording.
Similarly for HC appointments.
Collegium process can be more transparent..
Collegium knows better that how capable has been a judge in the past, so the power to appoint judges should be in hands of collegium only...
Central govt. should only have the role to check backgrounds of judges via their agency reports..
What about the Caste Based Systemic Discrimination. Even Judiciary is not exempt .
is it ? what is your experience
When Government jobs and good private sector jobs are given after written examinations and interviews ;why lawyer to High court judges and to Supreme court judges are made through recommendations of few people . Written examinations and interviews should be introduced for appointment of judges .
People shall not have right to appoint judge in a democracy. He is by product of collegium....
Oneside should not give reasons for sake of reputation and at same time we should know, why not recommened, indicates want to know but don't want, Trasparency in all levels possible or what extent possible at every level not clear yet to great intellectuals
Sir I have only one question why questions are raised after you retire from the chair. You take Suo moto cognizance to the issues which suits ........
He is now in Fiji working
Let's say every judge being deliberated has a file with 500 pages of various data.
Has CJI circulated those pages with collegium?
Collegium is the only system that is conforming to the procedures as laid down in the constitution.The legislatures or any other person who is not necessarily impartial and wiser or knowledgeable like lawyers are not competent to be as judge of the superior courts
After the retirement hon'ble the high court and supreme court judges were not practice but they're lot of resources in law hence the govt provide such opportunity to hon'ble judges to guide youth advocates and state legal services to free service their satisfaction it's usefull to our poor people and youth advocate.. It's my opinion only..
no more courts this week? this day?
Does the ecourts committee come under RTI. ?
It should. It is born out of a government project, under Ministry of Law and Justice. Under the RTI, 'any citizen', may request information from a public authority. (A body of government and instrumentality of state), set of by the constitution. Although, whether the purview extends to bodies formed under policy action remains to be seen.
Ye lokur jab khud judge tab isko RTI act accha nahi lgta tha. Ab ye transparency ki baat karke humko hutiya bna raha hai
BJP gunda sarkaar gunda raj andha kanoon
This is version of an ex-Judge only. The Interviewer should take the views of the other side as well to balance the deliberations. This is just one sided biased views without any introspection...
मौजूदा व्यवस्था बडी कोशिशो के बाद स्थापित की गयी है।
क्या वास्तव मेँ कोई परिवर्तन चाहता है इसमेँ?
No need for lecture. Like case disposed in d court tell in one or two sentences....my dear lords!