‘Modi Govt Interfering in Judicial Appointments, Wants to Subvert Republic, Establish Hindu Rashtra’
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/...
In an interview that will no doubt be criticized by the Modi government and its supporters and very possibly also annoy them, one of India’s foremost legal scholars has said the Modi government is interfering in judicial appointments adding “it happens in many ways - subtle, not so subtle, explicit or implicit”. More importantly, Prof. Mohan Gopal adds this interference is happening because “this government (has) an explicit mission to overthrow the present Republic and establish a Hindu Rashtra”. Therefore, going one step further, he says “it will be very dangerous to give this government … any role in judicial appointments”. He concludes “we must preserve and protect the Collegium because that is our best hope for now.”
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
This interview really shook my faith in literary and civilised society of this independent nation. Have lived full life but what our children/grand children are going to face is really very scary.
I worry about children who are witnessing divided and intolerant views. When they see it all-around it maybe normal for them as that is what is around them.
When old their parents and others may get it back not out of spite but that was the normal their children grew up to.
It saddens me because we grew up surrounded by love and tolerance and without divide.
That must be the reason why a lot of educated and wealthy people are leaving the country.
@@ht5389 lol...what a joke
@@causalityismygod2983 Maybe it will not be a joke when it reaches you.
@@ht5389 True, it's sad 😢 scary
This is one of the best interviews I've come across in recent times!!!! Illuminating.
The Supreme court has failed the Indian people and justice in general with the recent judgements mentioned in this video. Great work!
Brother it's not the sc but the individual judges he mentioned, SC is doing their best introducing more transperancy and speaking out whenever they feel the need to don't you remember cji said that" we will do something that the government will not like " during the last appointment saga.
@@baratthuj Individual judges constitute the court. From a bunch of odd judgements, it's not clear whether there is any entity called SC that stands for anything. In particular, take the judgement upholding PLMA's most draconian provisions. This neither fits with constitutional principles nor with the basic Hindu dharma. This could only be politically driven. I'm not that optimistic that these judges are driven by principles alone.
@@rigeshyogi hindu Dharma!????? 😂😂😂🤦 Dear friends courts run based on constitution not dharam btw pmla case is still going on next hearing is on 19 i think (not sure about the date) definitely it's draconian by according to the constitution not because of dharma 🤦
@@baratthuj What I meant was even those judges going by theocratic principles should find PLMA antithetical to those principles, even if they don't want to follow the constitution. So, the law cannot be justified based on Hindu dharma was my point.
@@rigeshyogi oh sorry i thought you meant something else 😂 i agree theoretic judges are really becoming huge problem for the judiciary , i belive judiciary is only tolerating them maybe because they think it could be seen as violation of their rights(theocratic judge) but for me only theocracy i want inside our courts is constitutional theocracy and letting any other theocracy continue is a huge mistake and very dangerous for our country and courts good thing is that their numbers have started to dip down and we are seeing more and more constitutional judges holding key positions in judiciary starting with uu lalit's appointment as CJI , from outside we can only hope things get better over there. lets see what happens in the next hearing of the pmla case such laws really need some serious reforms.
I am absolutely convinced that there is a 'sanatana dharma' that has been bought into constitution and reduced the constitution to statutory document only. My god, I really want my Indian constitution to be above all, much above sanatana dharma. Brilliant analysis Prof Gopal 🙏. How I wish everyone understands the agenda of RSS. Karan as usual, keep doing this for us, keep bringing these debates to us.
sanatan dharm is based on peace,love & non violence.dont talk rubbish its not sanatan its satanic regime presently.
Santana darhma.
All liars come in The Wire. Nothing is being done against Constitution. BJP Jindabad.
@@Mee_Nishant aur yeh khulasa tum jaisa rs5/comment chindichor kar raha hai.
@@sagaronline265 Tere jaise chawanni chhap ko bhi av jawab dena padega....🤣😂
Dark clouds not so far away. Wake call for Indians. Karan and Prof Gopal have together brought out the game plan beautifully.
Big standing ovation to both of you !
My humble request to all the commenting communities who feel that we should save our constitution at any cost should share this video as much as we can. We should respect all religions.
It is a great interview . Hats off to both Mr Karan Thapar and the learned professor for brilliantly analysing the motivation of the present government
for establilishing a Hindu Rashtra in India through the
Judiciary . It is a wake up
call for all Indians .
Judiciary and brave independent journalism is our last hope
actually WE. are our last hope. - they are just trying to hammer the point in. -
Words without action is of no use
Modi is following thr footsteps of congress .no need dor opposition and their media friends to cry
@@jotendrakumar2852 So you voted for change...and that is following footsteps of Congress? In that case why a change. Congress should have continued.
Many thanks, Mr Karan Thapar, for this interview with Prof Mohan Gopal. It's an eye-opener and scary how the structure is slowly being destroyed brick by brick...
A wonderful interview. Hats off to Prof. Mohan Gopal for beautifully articulating an opinion, which many Indians already sense - that the present government's sole agenda is Hindutva even at the cost of democratic values. India is heading towards unimaginable disaster but our ignorant masses, who voted this government to power, are blind to this.
Wow just Wow this is probably the best interview Karan has conducted. This is because it's not something everyone knew. Prof explanation of how the appointment of judges the way judges deliver their judgements and the two pronged strategy of the govt to make this country a Hindu Rastra is an eye opener. Sir your are indeed a genius and your analysis is something that I hadn't heard or read anywhere. Thank you for enlightening us.
Prof.Madan Gopal is so interesting in his thought process...thanks
𝙿𝚛𝚘𝚏 𝙼𝚘𝚑𝚞𝚗 𝙶𝚘𝚙𝚊𝚕
This is the most important video for our country citizens to watch right now. I'm very grateful to you, Mr Karan Thapar.
Thanks for educating us ,the public, on what the threats are in the judicial system today
Great interview. Simply great. It's worth watching once again. Professor Mohan Gopal was frank and upright.
Such interviews should make their way to the mainstream janta. Please also dub such interviews in Hindi and other prevalent local languages to reach more people. 🙏 RUclips now supports multiple audio tracks on the same video; please explore.
This is critically important and relevant if we are to somehow create a groundswell of both understanding and support for all that Prof Gopal Mohan is analysing and brilliantly arguing.
Well. This is a gem for the ones who are upholding freedom and democracy in the formation of our country.
I know I am no one, but ; If I were to choose between 'secularism' vs 'hindu-rastra'; for my people, for my society, for my family I would go with Secularism. 🙏🙏🙏. I really want the viewers to watch this interview till the last, do not skip a second.
Oh God. True secularism is Sanathana dharma only. I can't see any other guide for human being other than Sanathana Dharma. Since some westerners gave this name Hindu. I do not see anything wrong by using the same name Hindu Rashtra to differentiate so called mis interpreted secularism prevailing in the political circles of India.
@@venkatramangopalakrishnan1989 Hindus means Swavarna ..
No more "WE THE PEOPLE".
Cry more.😂🤣
@@venkatramangopalakrishnan1989 shame no people like u who consider old litrature as the best to govern a modern nation. But will enjoy all the benifits bought about though continuous upgrade in morality, wisdom,knowledge and management principles that enable our modern life .
@@devdevan9091 Change your name first. It looks your parents and grand parents thought that you would justify for at least naming you with this name, I am sure they would be highly upset about you.
People like Prof. Gopal are the true champions of our society … His views must be heard by atleast the educated … Thank U for this very insightful analysis …
🤣🤣 u believe in heaven journey of muhammad on a winged donkey????😂
sorry but muslims are least educated people of india 😂 so before teaching others plz educate your community first .. you are here just bcoz you want to listen what your leanings are ..
Pehle hijab fir kitab vali koum to kuch na he bole
Great conversation , eye - opening informative video , thanks The Wire team. 🙏
This shakes us to the core ..the nation is in totally unsafe hands. ...
It's in safe hand because of modi we have 5 th largest economy in world. If we handover to pappu we will be another Pakistan remember
Modi is following thr footsteps of congress .no need dor opposition and their media friends to cry
@@doraibabu1894 abe bhag yaha se andhbhakt
@@doraibabu1894instead of bjp if it was congress like Manmohan singh leader 2nd largest economy in the world, modi sab say bada pheku that is why in 5th largest , modi ku hatav nahi to srilanka banjayega.
Jai hind.
@@mohammedabdulnasar4270 achha 😂
Thank you Karan Thapar for this most wonderful interview with Mr Gopal - it must be made compulsory viewing by all Indians!
One of the best interviews you have done Mr. Karan Thapar. A real eye opener to us lay people.
Very well explained.. wish we have such interviews in our sarkari media channels.. we will have some comments demeaning such thought provoking interview.. salute Karan Thapar you are better than the best.
Yeh amritkaaal hai bhai
What about rape convicted pastor????
@@SK-fs1gd you tell me
What an eye opening and intellectual interview. Thanks to Karan Thapar and team of The Wire.
End of democracy
Modi is following thr footsteps of congress .no need dor opposition and their media friends to cry
@@amberheardrose7144 He Is a Bot..and verse
Great interactive with Dr. Gopal, thanks to Mr. Karan... I only hope you all👍 save our constitution..
Thank you, Karan and Prof. Gopal, for this enlightening discussion. It has clearly outlined the judicial framework that the ruling government is promoting to realize their vision of a Hindu rashtra, and how this agenda can potentially be thwarted by the current judicial system. As an ordinary citizen, I could have easily misconstrued the government's move as an attempt to increase their control over the only constitutional institution that has maintained its independence in the face of eight years of rule. However, thanks to this interview, I now understand the larger agenda at play.
From this conversation i gather the impression that we the people of this country has a Great moral responsibility to help the judiciary and defend the constitution of this country
This can only be done when the larger society is fairly literate. Rss Is being able to execute their agenda by forming govt. in states and more importantly at the centre. And how does anyone from the govt at the centre, through the states of U.P and Bihar. Whosoever wins these two states can form the union govt., at least by forming a coalition. And these two states are largely uneducated. For people in these two states in particular religion matters the most. Therefore, there's no way rss can be stopped.
@@mehroseemehrosee3887 absolutely this is hindu majority country and always be hindu majority country no court no judiciary can or ever stop this remeber my words
@@pipipupu5104 that's not true. It will take some time but things will change.
We knew something was up in judiciary. Some inner turmoil, some sort of conflict. But we didn’t know the elaborate subterfuge of the RSS in subverting our Constitution. This is an eye opening interview. Salute to the scholarship of Professor Madan Gopal and appreciation for Karan to make the interview happen.
Mohan Gopal, not Madan.
Given me goosebumps while watching this interview, little feeling of depression but also hope we will save our democracy ultimately❤
This depends on the Indian citizen placing common humanity over petty religious, caste matters
ONE OF THE BEST.. INTERVIEW.
SEEN ALMOST ALL.
JAI CONSTITUTION JAI HIND JAI BHARAT 🙏.
😂🤣😂🤣 Jai Bharat. Bharat Mata Ki Jay. Vande Mataram. Jai Sanatan. Jai BJP.
Every time I listen Mr Karan Thapar's this program, I feel enlightened every time... it is so much enlightening.. Thanks, Mr Thapar and his guest today.
What a informative discussion, an eye opening. I appeal to all those who re listening, please listen it 2-3 times. By this video today I came to understand why SC is so rigid and taking firm stand for collegium in spite of attacks from cabinet ministers
Modi is following thr footsteps of congress .no need dor opposition and their media friends to cry
@@jotendrakumar2852 hi bot
@sanjay sharma thanks. MODI BJP r following the path taken by congress. I am so happy for the congress party . Jai Hind
Outstanding interview! Great work Mr. Thapar & Prof. Gopal.
In a long time Karen ji you interviewed someone who has all the solutions to the clear and present danger to our mortal lives. My deepest respect Mohan Gopal Sir. 🙏 the civilizations in our sub continent has survived and spread despite many odds - Diversity is our 🔑
General Zia. Ul Haq changed Pakistan in to Muslim State.
Everyone can see their State of Affairs.
An historical interview Mr Thapar. If not risen now as Mr Gopal ji said , a big catastrophe is awaited for sure. Save constitution, Save India 🇮🇳
Best and very transparent analysis of judiciary system discussed. Thanks to the Prof.,Gopal sir and Karan Thapar.
Whether we have the desired representative judiciary or not, this interview with Prof. Mohan Gopal was simply outstanding. Imagine if the entire judiciary had such people. Mr. Karan Thapar, thank you very very much for providing us with some fresh air in this otherwise increasingly strangulating autocratic atmosphere.
What a Classy eye-opening Interview 🙏🏼 both are very brave, thank you Sirs
🤣😂🤣😂
Sir karan Thaper it's great to hear you on RUclips. I am very much glade taking different people's interview.
Thank you Prof for having spoken on all the subjects that are being debated among a few lawyers accross india. You have provided so many new perspectives of the vast array of vital subjects main and incidental. Many thanks again as your perspectives are so very full of wisdom.
listening the useful discussion between sh.karan Thapar n prof sh Mohan Gopal,I am very motivated, impressed.n glad.Our country is a land comprising of multy religious, language, castle.In this complex situations his advice to have representative govt as well as judiciary Our country is ruled by law ie constitution n it is the supreme duty of the people to protect the constitution n not the
religious ethos.
Really shocking what is happening. Thanks for enlightening us and making us aware of what we can expect in the future from our judgements from the last bastion that is standing tall in these troubled times
Is there any channel/platform where there is neutrality and rationality? Either you support present regime or attack the regime in every possible manner which Wire is doing very sincerely.
One of the best interview from you Mr Thapar
THE BEST.
Eye opening discussion
Blessed to have come across such an amazing interview by Thapar Sir ❤ love from Bihar 🙏 I vouch for dalit representation in our Supreme Court 🇮🇳🙏
The Collegium should set a time limit within which the govt should send their decision on collegium 's recommendation and if govt doesn't respect the time limit the collegium should go ahead with the appointment.
supreme court is not a law making body .. reading polity will help
Vote for bjp ☝🏻
lol sorry but in indian constitution parliament is supreme not the judiciary ... when SC gave judgement against sc/st act then these same constitution supremacy holders went against supreme court and said parliament is supreme and now crying abt govt powers ...
Jai bhim thapar ji sahab, 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Hi Karan Sir .
Very Nice To See You.
This interview is extremely disturbing. Almost so disturbing that you need a trigger warning. The most disturbing, of course, is the very idea that today's judges need to be branded as "constitutionalist" as though constitutionalism were merely an option.
What an eye opening interview from two esteemed well informed panelists . Even Hindus don't want an unhappy disharmonious country .
Karan Thapar Sir you are a rare gem of Generalism
Was very late to listen to such an in-depth analysis, of the modus operandi to surreptitiously replace brick by brick from the constitutional edifice & give the constitution a new look interpretation, was to say the least an eye opener. Prof.Gopal was brilliant & as usual Karan ji brought out the best brilliantly.
Very rational interview & views. Constitution must be above all & should be protected.
Also say during that period ' I have interviewed unpad people who shamefully walked away.
Outstanding interview.we the people salute u Prof Mohan Gopal for giving correct advice to the present Supreme Court and the people of India to have representative Supreme Court to protect India as secular ,democratic ,socialist ,republic .Excellent interview by Mr Karan Thapar.Must call such intellectuals on your program in future.
Excellent interview.
Wonderful argument. Very knowledgeable information for a layman. How is this going to reach out to the majority of uninformed Indians?
Karan, your apprehension is real. The moment India deviates from the present structure of polity- the 'secular' part, India will plunge into anarchy and massive scale oppression against untouchables.
Many thanks to Mr. Mohan Gopal and Karan for this very intelligent discussion and efforts to preserve Constitutional Democracy.
Thank you both for awakening discussion.
Brilliant discussion.
Eye opening interview. People must be alarmed by this intellectual information and time has come to react to these judicial blunders in order to protect our incredible Constitution.
@Suriyha Prakhas only indoctrinated Modimaniac rodents always cry foul when caught red handed at least what else a rodent can do?
@Suriyha Prakhas your upbringing values morals visible in your language
Now that is a great and important interview.
With an intellectual smile you were delivering your legal pronouncements of greatest calibre Heartfelt congratulations for your great crusade for Social Justice and against the traditional theocratic forces
We are always with neutral and intellectual media.
By far one of the best interviews ever, Prof. Mohan Gopal is a national treasure.
And treasure is best buried
The executive is also a litigant, a major one, so it should not have any say in the selection and appointment of the judiciary.
Very valid point.
Perfect is the govt as the litigator has says so should we the people but not through the so called elected reps.
Very informative and bold...
What happens when majority of judges in a collegium are of theocratic impulse and start recommending of same time, of course then we are done.
brilliant.. many thanx.. Indian judiciary in recent years deteriorate justice.. instead of and India should have been improving justice with reforms by bringing technology, participation, quality, efficiency, transparency, international standards and processes.. to resolve hugely pending court cases, shamefully large undertrials, languishing justice, inaccessibility of justice to a common Indian etc
The Constitution must be followed by all Indians in letter and spirit.
Excellent analysis
Such an amazing discourse and alarming state for judiciary. It is vital now that the lawyers take a strong stand against the government.
Excellently And Accurately Stated Based On The Issues Brought Up
Sir your great man in India 🇮🇳 👍
Eye-opening conversation. Never thought we had Ayatollahs on the bench. We could see hints of this in various judgments, but my suspicion was more about coercion by the executive, and some amount of quid pro quo (like plum positions after retirement). How someone can be a judge while violating their oath to uphold the constitution is baffling.
Ram Mandir would be considered the worst Judgement of modern India 🇮🇳
Hat's off you Sir Karan Thapar ji good interview with Prof Mohan Gopal sir
You are the Stalwarts of journalism
Very valuable information for the people about the Constitution.
I suppose very few people in India knows this strategy to overthrow the constitutional values enshrined in our system. Indeed a harsh reality brought to the fore...
Brave journalism is the need of the hour
Why do they wish the future of our country to become bleak and uncertain, by interfering in the Constitution.
Our constitution of India is very strong, democratic, progressive, protective and non communal foundation based. It has to be saved and preserved by us all Indians.
Salute to Prof Mohan Gopal for showing the future to the world. The people are stuck under the friendly games of BJP-AAP-CONGRESS under RSS.
Thank goodness India has intellectual and moral men and women like the Judge
It is ominous. Dangerous road is ahead. All right thinking people must come together to stop the looming disaster.
EVERY Indian, irrespective of his faith, State or his personal belief should listen once!
Excellent questions and superb answers!!
A great programme!!
( .. alarming )
Cheers!!
Biggest concerned issue now a days
Very simple RSS/BJP/Modi/Mohan Bhagwat/Shah, will declare India to be a Hindu Rashtra and replace the constitution with Manusmriti. India will seize to become a secular state. Finally minorities will become a second class citizen.
What an amazing academic work!!!!! Loved the conversation.
Modi is following thr footsteps of congress .no need dor opposition and their media friends to cry
@@jotendrakumar2852 and you are following Modi wahhhh!
@@saharasathi6264 he's a bot..just that
👌🙏After listening this interview still there is a hope
Interesting interview. Interesting points on Addendum of Ayodya judgement. I guess the other judges didn't go through the addendum at all. They should have ensured that it is signed and should have endorsed or not based on their own judgement.
The bench had no courage to say NO or recuse. This can said to be the solitary judgement from The Apex Court.
Thank you Dr. Mohan Gopal. You were fearless and clear.🙏🙏
Excellent interview which helps to understand contemporary ongoing issues in judiciary
Very good informative conversation .
Intriguing presentation.Great work!
Brilliant. Very bold.