The butler did it! Watch Studio C Mondays at 10pm ET/8pm MT on BYUtv. Watch full episodes of Studio C online here: byutv.org/studioc Like Studio C on Facebook: / studioctv
This one was was a tough nut to crack, I investigated the video thoroughly for nearly 3 hours but I still couldn't figure it out. I got my team of expert detectives to work on it and even called the FBI. After all of this work I can now safely say that there is a lamp in the background.
From what I could deduce, there could only be one possible culprit capable of committing all these murders... THE BUTLER!!! I came up with this conclusion thanks to your discovery of that lamp in the background. Who cleans the lamp everyday? Answer: The Butler
Someone else says narrorator! I spell it differently, but it’s actually narrator. It totally sounds like that though! I thought it was spelled like this for the longest time.
IT REALLY COULD BE THE BUTLER 1st kill: The Food was poisonous, the knife was not a killing blow(if anything it could have stopped the poison, if the butler didn't remove the knife, letting the blood flow, instead of clogging up. 2nd Kill: The shot actually missed, she was given med to increase a heart attack instead ones to preventing it, med were provided be the butler. 3rd kill. The phone was a trick gun phone which killed him instantly. The wench completely missed him but the movement covered the noise. 4th kill. A quick Stab in the dark 5th. kill. The gun had no bullets left so did not fire, the shot actual came from the butler shoe WHICH IS ALSO A GUN.
IT REALLY COULD BE THE BUTLER 1st kill: The Food was poisonous, the knife was not a killing blow(if anything it could have stopped the poison, if the butler didn't remove the knife, letting the blood flow, instead of clogging up. 2nd Kill: The shot actually missed, she was given med to increase a heart attack instead ones to preventing it, med were provided be the butler. 3rd kill. The phone was a trick gun phone which killed him instantly. The wench completely missed him but the movement covered the noise. 4th kill. A quick Stab in the dark 5th. kill. The gun had no bullets left so did not fire, the shot actual came from the butler shoe WHICH IS ALSO A GUN.
But you're stating that the butler did it, and I made a point against your claim. If the knife was pulled out by anyone other than the butler then he didn't do it...
For the second kill, that's not how a heart attack works. People don't just die on the spot because of a heart attack, it actually takes quite awhile with large amounts of thrashing and screaming .
The butler is actually the murderer, but he didn't kill anyone in this scene. He murdered Jason's friends before, but sadly there was no actual proof it was the butler, so the butler was still a free man. Out of hatred for the butler and vengence for Jason's friend, Jason decided to impersonate some very rich guy, that he killed and then stole his identityand went to a noble party, where he knew the butler would be. At the party, he saw the butler and he was ready to kill, but he wanted to frame him, so all of the other people would turn on him as the butler would suffer, since this time he's actually innocent. When arriving to the party, Jason found a weird thing about the host's mansion: Whenever lightning strikes, the lights would turn off for some time. With this information, he thought he could execute his plan of framing butler, but alas as you see in this video, it didn't go as Jason planned.
*picks up knife* "It literally has your name on it." *Captain Literally appears* *Takes knife from Natalie* *Looks at Knife* *Gives knife back* "BALANCE RESTORED!!!!!"
Please make a second part!!! I've been dying for a second part ever since I've watched this!!! This would make really good videos if you just continued it. Am I right?!?!?!?!
It was Mallory! 1. When Jason "stabs" the professor you don't see the knife in his hand, so Mallory could have very well put his childhood knife in his hand leading him to belive the butler did it since the butler was closest to him. 2. Mallory is the one pointing out his killing strategy flaws, perhaps trying to shift the blame from her onto Jason. 3. Notice how Mallory seems to be shielding something from the camera in her hands while Jason shoots Natalie. Also notice how Jason's gun is not aimed directly at Natalie, and more at the window. Perhaps he was shooting Mallory's accomplice whilst believing that it was the butler's leaving Mallory to shoot Natalie. 4. Jason says "So close!" while he is hitting Stacey. He could have been trying to deflect Mallory's bullet that was coming right at Stacey. 5. By now, Jason knows that the disbelievers get killed, so that when Mallory finally kills Jason, the blame won't be shifted onto her. Jason runs to save him, accidentally choking him because he didn't know that he was grabbing his neck. 6. See how Mallory's hand is against the black part of her dress at the end so she could be holding a gun aimed at Matt. Jason, for once, was trying to kill him, but he had a look of frustration for a second before realizing his actions and blaming the butler, while in reality Mallory had shot him. So I'm telling you, it was Mallory!!
Matt: And so we leave you, tune in next week for the exciting conclusion to this baffling mystery, was it the butler, the fair lady, or perhaps that man "Jason". Jason: "shoots Matt" Matt: Ow "faints"
this sketch was hilarious!!!!!! all of yours are. everyone rocks! ive been addicted to this show after my best friend recommended it to me. i love you guys!!!!!!!!!
"It literally has your name on it."
BALANCE RESTORED!
Loooooooolllll #CaptainLiterally
GryffindorDemigod101 *BALANCED MAINTAINED*
GryffindorDemigod101 😂
GryffindorDemigod101 but it's already on there
it was already on there tho so he doesn't need to restore the balance
Plot twist: The man was actually trying to protect the people from the butler's sneaky attacks.
but fails horribly
Harry Potter baby
This comment is underrated
This one was was a tough nut to crack, I investigated the video thoroughly for nearly 3 hours but I still couldn't figure it out. I got my team of expert detectives to work on it and even called the FBI. After all of this work I can now safely say that there is a lamp in the background.
I want my tax money back.
laughed way to hard at this comment
You are the greatest detective in the world to figure that out!
From what I could deduce, there could only be one possible culprit capable of committing all these murders...
THE BUTLER!!!
I came up with this conclusion thanks to your discovery of that lamp in the background.
Who cleans the lamp everyday?
Answer: The Butler
Raiyan Raza (plot twist) there's not one buT TWO LAMPS *DUN DUN DUUUUUUUUUNNNN* CASE CLOSED!!!!!
I LITERALLY died when Matt said "Ow".
Hey... No... I didn't mean to say li--
*BANG*
"BALANCED RESTORED!"
Lol
Ha ha
*You Dead man*
This is literally the best comment here
IT WAS THE BUTLER DRESSED AS CAPTAIN LITERALLY!!!
He's simply one HELL of a butler.
OMG FINALLY SOMEBODY ELSE HAS SEEN BLACK BUTLER!!!!!
+Silver Stargirl haha we all should talk
+Lizbeth Chavez Yes, my lord
+Lord Voldemort YAY! Black Butler buddies!!!!!
+Lord Voldemort and most people won't get that pun unless they watch Black Butler because technically Sebastian is a Demon and one HELL of a butler
The Among Us chat after people walked in on the imposter killing a crewmate:
White is sus lol
I like how the two comments I see are from 4 Years ago and the other 4 Weeks ago
@@emifish7405 idk butler is more sus tho tbh
Kaif says it was Butler
so true, it always happens to me as an imposter
Where's the next episode??? I WANT TO KNOW WHO THE KILLER IS!!!!!
+Michael Valdes there were actually 4 killers: the knife the gun the wrench and the hands
Then there's one word, 'murica'
It's the Butler!
It was the butler
no it wasn't it was the guy in white.
When Jason’s daughter is older she’s going to laugh so hard when she sees this
Daughter:Daddy are you a murderer?
Jason: It was the butler!
@@matthewbest5421 Plot twist. It was actually me.
@@midnight-user12 man your a good killer, you took everyone out without actually being in the video
@@midnight-user12 reality is often disappointing.
💀
plot twist, actually it is the butler lol
IT was??
it's true
MrBbouas HOW???
Sylvia Welson the butler hired the murderer
Buts that's just a theory A COMEDY SKETCH THEROY aaaanndd cut!
That's like my small sister blaming everything at home
Lps Doglover
and no matter what Everyone believes her/him
Lps Doglover omg yeeesssss.
your sister just goes, "Da butler did it!"
And getting away with it
Plot twist: it was the butler.
What if he is the butler
2:32 Jeremy was also laughing😂
he was supposed to... he's not breaking the character
The narrarator did it
Totally
+Noelle Jones But it was the butler
He killed them with his awesome alliteration
Someone else says narrorator! I spell it differently, but it’s actually narrator. It totally sounds like that though! I thought it was spelled like this for the longest time.
Here’s a plot twist to the plot twist: it was James
Jason: *shoots the narrator*
Jason: why would the butler do this?
I NEED A SEQUEL OF THISSSSSSS! I NEED IT!
MEE TOO!
I AGREE
IT REALLY COULD BE THE BUTLER
1st kill: The Food was poisonous, the knife was not a killing blow(if
anything it could have stopped the poison, if the butler didn't remove
the knife, letting the blood flow, instead of clogging up.
2nd Kill: The shot actually missed, she was given med to increase a
heart attack instead ones to preventing it, med were provided be the
butler.
3rd kill. The phone was a trick gun phone which killed him instantly.
The wench completely missed him but the movement covered the noise.
4th kill. A quick Stab in the dark
5th. kill. The gun had no bullets left so did not fire, the shot actual
came from the butler shoe WHICH IS ALSO A GUN.
noura.147 SAME!!!!!!
mastersleib Sad they never did a second one.
I love the fact that while Jason is strangling Jeremy in plain sight, no one does anything to stop him.
E
I love the semi-bad acting to go along with the old TV show theme.
***** yes!
Ikr!
Noah Gregory WHAT DO YOU MEAN BAD?!?!?! NOTHING THEY EVER DO IS BAD!!!!
Zebra wuz here he means they are acting like they are bad actors to go along with the old fashioned movie thing. (They are great actors)
@@thewafflepig1944 Oh, thank you for the clarification
“Ow.” MY FAVORITE PART OUT OF ALL THIS SCETCH!! MATT SAID IT SO MATTER OF A FACTLY I LOVE IT!!!
mine too XD
IT REALLY COULD BE THE BUTLER
1st kill: The Food was poisonous, the knife was not a killing blow(if anything it could have stopped the poison, if the butler didn't remove the knife, letting the blood flow, instead of clogging up.
2nd Kill: The shot actually missed, she was given med to increase a heart attack instead ones to preventing it, med were provided be the butler.
3rd kill. The phone was a trick gun phone which killed him instantly. The wench completely missed him but the movement covered the noise.
4th kill. A quick Stab in the dark
5th. kill. The gun had no bullets left so did not fire, the shot actual came from the butler shoe WHICH IS ALSO A GUN.
You do realize if the butler had pulled out the knife he would have it in his hand afterwards...
knife was removed either way.
But you're stating that the butler did it, and I made a point against your claim. If the knife was pulled out by anyone other than the butler then he didn't do it...
"cough"killjoy"Cough"
For the second kill, that's not how a heart attack works. People don't just die on the spot because of a heart attack, it actually takes quite awhile with large amounts of thrashing and screaming .
The butler is actually the murderer, but he didn't kill anyone in this scene.
He murdered Jason's friends before, but sadly there was no actual proof it was the butler, so the butler was still a free man.
Out of hatred for the butler and vengence for Jason's friend, Jason decided to impersonate some very rich guy, that he killed and then stole his identityand went to a noble party, where he knew the butler would be.
At the party, he saw the butler and he was ready to kill, but he wanted to frame him, so all of the other people would turn on him as the butler would suffer, since this time he's actually innocent.
When arriving to the party, Jason found a weird thing about the host's mansion:
Whenever lightning strikes, the lights would turn off for some time.
With this information, he thought he could execute his plan of framing butler, but alas as you see in this video, it didn't go as Jason planned.
you should have more than 54 likes...
That’s some good Studio C Cinematic Universe lore right there.
Wow, this is so deep
@Claire Murphy if only he were brighter...
and before that Jason's father had the butlers family evicted from there homes so that he could use the land.
MORE MURDER MYSTERY!!! COME ON GUYS!!!
+Dylan Grace Seriously!
yeah do more murder mystery
+Phoebe Carter agreed do more
Yep tots agree😆
yup more!!
This is literally every imposter in Among Us
"BALLANCE RESTORED!!!"
Guys, the video literally ended with the butler holding the weapon! It was SO obviously him!
*picks up knife* "It literally has your name on it." *Captain Literally appears* *Takes knife from Natalie* *Looks at Knife* *Gives knife back* "BALANCE RESTORED!!!!!"
I love how Matt imitates Rod Serling from the Twilight Zone!
Same I 😍 him so much
Matt you rock
I love the twilight zone 😍
+Sara Lizz
I love the twilight zone two!
Bob Schoch gasp Scott Terling
Coincidence or not
Rod serling? Scott... Sterling?
Please make a second part!!! I've been dying for a second part ever since I've watched this!!! This would make really good videos if you just continued it. Am I right?!?!?!?!
Raj Rani dying you say? I have butler for that job
Slim chance now, with the show down the tubes and the original cast gone I don’t really see it happening.
Honestly, I'd rather blame it on the rain.
True dat
+Dj Quinn The lightning convinced White Tux to commit a not so successful murder spree.
+Isaac Kim
Jason
Punching Ponies Thanks, This whole Studio C is still new to me.
Yup
Still one of my favorite skits.
I have to say.... I'm absolutely positive it *was* the butler!
Yep. Definitely the butler.
Exactly!
#SOPROUDOFASHFORACTUALLYFIGURINGSOMETHINGOUT :troll:
I agree with that.:)
Totes the butler.
indeed
Note to self: don’t watch studio C while brushing teeth
Oh dear
Dont drink anything either
Jeremy: HOW CAN YOU POSSIBLY EXPECT US TO BELIEVE YOU but his voice
Butler was voted out.
Butler was no an Imposter
"Gun shot! Now we know it's the butler!"
Lol
It was Mallory!
1. When Jason "stabs" the professor you don't see the knife in his hand, so Mallory could have very well put his childhood knife in his hand leading him to belive the butler did it since the butler was closest to him.
2. Mallory is the one pointing out his killing strategy flaws, perhaps trying to shift the blame from her onto Jason.
3. Notice how Mallory seems to be shielding something from the camera in her hands while Jason shoots Natalie. Also notice how Jason's gun is not aimed directly at Natalie, and more at the window. Perhaps he was shooting Mallory's accomplice whilst believing that it was the butler's leaving Mallory to shoot Natalie.
4. Jason says "So close!" while he is hitting Stacey. He could have been trying to deflect Mallory's bullet that was coming right at Stacey.
5. By now, Jason knows that the disbelievers get killed, so that when Mallory finally kills Jason, the blame won't be shifted onto her. Jason runs to save him, accidentally choking him because he didn't know that he was grabbing his neck.
6. See how Mallory's hand is against the black part of her dress at the end so she could be holding a gun aimed at Matt. Jason, for once, was trying to kill him, but he had a look of frustration for a second before realizing his actions and blaming the butler, while in reality Mallory had shot him.
So I'm telling you, it was Mallory!!
"We literally saw you kill him!""Impossible! It was dark."
how did Jeremy only have one line in the whole thing and it was still the most iconic thing ever
Where's pt 2?
Ikr!
Mr. M for real!
Mr. M there can't be part two since the butler killed the narrator
Aimer Coal right.
This sketch had me *DYING* This really had me *CHOKED* up.Jason truly is amazingly clever. He really *KILLED* the show.
Yep, Jason's the star of Studio C! I'm so glad he's coming back in 2022!
now I wanna watch the Smith Family sketch again lol
Matt: And so we leave you, tune in next week for the exciting conclusion to this baffling mystery, was it the butler, the fair lady, or perhaps that man "Jason".
Jason: "shoots Matt"
Matt: Ow "faints"
***** Who knows?
Twist the butler spiked his drink with a potion that will fill him with murderous rage
i just have ONE question , why did the butler keep killling people ?
I guess we will never know.
The butler didn’t kill anyone
Karnnaphat vanichchayasakul No! Really?
@@karnnaphatvanichchayasakul7816 r/wooosh
Because he's Jason Bourne
What a classic! These people are utter geniuses.
I wonder who it could be? hmm? I suspect mallory
+Summer Ralls It Was The Butler!!!!!
+Bobson Tim obviosly
No it was the invisible flaming puppy!
+naddertribute seriously?
No, it was the butler who killed everyone! The guy who killed everyone said so!
I can totally see Jason actually getting it right and then everyone say "IT WAS THE BUTLER!!!"
I have this odd feeling that the butler will walk away alive...
I like how they calmly let him take them out one at a time. Just 3 more to go and the he can pin it all on the butler
*shot* "ow" *fall*. best part. oh, and "alliteration is awesome." Matt's the best ❤
This is my Favorite Sketch out of the rest of them.
Jeremy and Jason must’ve had a lot of fun with that scene 😂
I love Matt as Rod Sterling! xD
"Alliteration is awesome," LOL
This is by far the best sketch Studio C has ever done, I wish they would make another version
"Ow." My favorite line in this video!
Muder Mystery Mansion of Murder😂
Still my favorite skit of all time
I like how they all have very different accents
All I can think is, "I am one hell of a butler." GOO SEBASTIAN!!
Sherlock himself couldn't have solved this one
*GASP* the professor!
My favorite line in the whole video. The delivery is hilarious.
easily one of my favorite sketches. Jason did an amazing job writing this
Who brings murder weapons to a dinner party without knowing who or how your going to kill?
The butler obviously
2:05
You can see the wrench jiggling🤣
Me: It was the butler!
Mom: We don’t have a butler.
.........GET HIM! *(Insert angry mob here)*
The world deserves more of Matt playing Rod Sterling
Among us impostor in a nutshell
2:18 Wow Jermey you can really do a fake voice
the orignal mannequin challenge
I need more of this MMM series!!
these guys did the mannequin challenge years before it was a thing
I would watch this show in a heartbeat
I think it’s the lampshade.
One of the most iconic studio c videos
Plot twist: This is exactly how among us logic was made lol
Warning: don’t go to electrical. I learned that the hard way
0:56 Me when I want to get out of class
You Seem To Be Unable to Grasp The Concept of Waiting Until it is Dark Before You Kill
I LOVE STUDIO C!!!!!!!!
Stephens face at the end 😂 He just looked so done
0:00-0:21 Matt looks SO GOOD in a suit!!
They all do!
Impossible. It was dark.
What a Red Herring!
I never would have thought it was Jason!
2:43 it was studio c that started the mannequin challenge.
We need more of this kind of video
Among us in a nutshell
Steven looks so offended yet classy. XD AND JEREMY'S FACIAL EXPRESSIONS. I can't get enough of this channel, I swear.
Did... Did Jason just self-report?
"You seem unable to grasp the concept of waiting until it's dark before you kill"
I know i'm late but......
I love how none of them care that all of these people are dying
I loved Jeremy’s voice
I love how Matt acted like Rod Serling from “The Twilight Zone.”
Love the rod sterling impression
We're is the second one of these I have been looking for it forever?!?!
The announcer died.
This is probably my favorite episode EVER. 😆 😂 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
you guys make everything funnier! LOL ;)
this sketch was hilarious!!!!!! all of yours are. everyone rocks! ive been addicted to this show after my best friend recommended it to me. i love you guys!!!!!!!!!
TH- THIS IS EVERY AMONG US GAME EVER
By far one of my favorite sketches.
This is how EVERY among us game goes
I miss this
The Real Among Us
I laughed so hard at this, Stacey and handing the gun to butler. 😂😂🤣🤣🤣😭😭😭