Have you played puzzle chess yet? Let me know how it goes for you or if you have any questions. You can use any puzzle, but if you want any that I showed in this video, I linked all of them in the video description. Plus, if you want to watch the extended cut of the game at the end of the video, it is up on Patreon right now!
Might be a great idea to collab with chess content creators out there like Gothamchess, introducing the 2 communities together. Both games have shared recent history in which both games exploded during the pandemic.
When I was a child in the 1950's, my father and I would do something similar, usually on 500 piece puzzles. If you picked up a piece and it fit, you got a point, but if you picked up a piece and it didn't fit, you lost a point. You could go way down in the negatives, if you weren't careful. So it wasn't a matter of speed, but of accuracy.
Of course you played puzzle chess with Tom... he also popularized chess clock Jenga, or at least made a video about it, which looks much more stressful than this does. I love that you two know each other, it's so nice to see crossovers that feel genuinely like friends hanging out rather than two people trying to boost their popularity.
Yeah when I saw he was in the video I actually guessed he might have brought to you the idea of Puzzle Chess himself, considering he and Matt are the only people I've ever seen applyijg a Chess Clock to non board games.
A Tom Scott crossover where he learns something new, I'm here for it. This Puzzle Chess thing looks like fun. I might have to get my nieces some puzzles as an excuse to do this.
there are few joys in life greater than seeing Tom being exasperated by the expertise of someone else. "invite someone to play a game and kick their ass with it" tom's done that once or twice I think.
In Chess there is a 2 vs 2 - variation called "Hand & Brain". You could adapt it to Puzzle Chess: So one player has to choose the piece which the teampartner has to place this turn. The team which is more in sync (Brain's choosing the same piece the hands-player thought off aswell) should be faster. So that's a nice touch :)
Tom Scott seems like such a genuinely nice, humble, and sweet guy, and he shows a remarkable level of sensitivity in everything he does. I would love to play board games with him like this and I love seeing two utter sweethearts have a good time like this.
Suggestion from a parent. When playing with a child you could place 2-3 pieces to each one your child places. Or you could look away during your child’s turn so that you can only find pieces while you are actually on the clock.
As someone who was once a child, I hated it when the adults immediately assumed I had no chance in a fair game. Maybe only give the child an advantage if they get discouraged and are clearly losing.
@@celloafterdark4173 Exactly. If you teach your child that thye only win, how they will manage their loss further in life? Later nobody will pick up two pieces instead of one for them to win
My family won’t play against me unless I have restrictions so I use my left hand, they put the box/reference image somewhere so I can’t see it and they can, and I close my eyes whenever it isn’t my turn so that I can’t search for pieces. It levels the playing field a bit 😅 great video Karen, Thankyou!! ☺️
I had the same thought. Chess clocks should be able to do this. I've seen Chess matches between players of different skill level that were handicapped by time.
A decent chess clock can absolutely do this. The app they are using, I don't know. A decent chess clock can be had for $25 ish or so on Amazon. I would go one step over the Leaf ones. I don't think those can do handicapped times.
I'm a fan or your channel as well as a longtime chess player (about fifty years) who has competed in hundreds of chess tournaments. I want to give you a rule clarification you may not be aware of. In chess, it is a requirement to hit the clock with the same hand that you moved your piece with. It's considered cheating to use your free hand to hit the clock. You might want to consider incorporating that practice into your game.
I did not know that was a rule. Genuinely curious, how would that be considered cheating. I don’t see how that would affect anything. So would they be disqualified if they accidentally use the wrong hand?
@@Preciouslynnette because you can use your right hand for moving a piece and immediately press the clock with left, hovering over it. It saves loads of time if you do it like that considering you press the clock every turn. I believe you get a warning if you do it wrong. You also write down your turns/which pieces moved where (during the other's turn).
@@Preciouslynnette No disqualification. It's a very minor infraction, so at worst you'd get a mild "don't do that again." Frankly it is so ingrained in chess players from when they learn the rules and etiquette that they would never think to do it the wrong way.
The thumbnail including Karen, Tom Scott, Puzzles, and Chess is so emblematic of my year that I'm partly wondering if this video was generated by AI solely for my consumption.
You got me with Tom Scott, I just recently started watching your videos and seeing a collab with Tom Scott, wow, first congrats, and keep on doing awesome videos.
A variation could be that you are only allowed to place a piece connecting to the one previously placed. That may open possibilities for strategies as it is in theory possible to « checkmate » your opponent before ending the puzzle by purposefully create a hole where you put your piece (as all connections to this piece has already been made, your opponent cannot continue). Another possible game with puzzles would be to play with two identical small puzzles sets. Both players try to place as many pieces on the same board from their set before the end, the one with the least remaining pieces win.
A minor handicap is for the better player to be the one to work the puzzle from the upside down orientation and the less advanced to view the puzzle tight side up (have the puzzle sideways for peers). The non-dominant hand handicap is a good one. Also have the better player close their eyes/look away from the puzzle when it isn't their turn. There are a number of possibilities.
Others would be that: -the weaker player can see the image on the box but the stronger can't. -2 for 1. Stronger player must place 2 pieces but the weaker only places one. -The weaker player is allowed to make any legal move, but the stronger player must attach their piece to the last piece placed (unless impossible because the last piece placed was filling a "hole" -some chess clocks allow for the players to have different time controls (although that is unlikely on the free versions and probably would require an upgraded download) so possibly give the weaker player an extra 3 seconds per piece.
In chess you are supposed to push the button on the clock with the same hand that you made your move with. Some people just hover their hand over the clock and get an unfair advantage by moving with the other hand, maybe even pushing the button before they make their move.
The easiest handicap is to let the slower player start with more time. Experiment to see how much time you want to give. You can add the handicap bonus time after the game is over.
Oh my god! My two favorite youtubers coming together! I’m so excited to see you expand your puzzling content! That aside, if I had a nickel for every time Tom gets taught about a game and gets his ass absolutely destroyed, it would be two nickels which isn’t a lot but it’s funny lol
Only discoverered your channel a week ago, and been devouring the videos - so addictive and then just now Tom Scott appears - Wow! I started puzzling during the Covid lockdown, and been doing at least one 1000 piece puzzle a month since. Will definitely try puzzle chess with my puzzling friend.
Yay! Excited to share this video with friends and fam - I've been making some of them puzzle chess with me ever since I saw it in your puzzle camp video. I still haven't had any great uptake on play partners but I'm hoping I'll get some more games in during the holiday break. My nieces have a ton of 100 piece puzzles we could use (my 11 year old niece was the first person I was able to get to play with and she legit beat me, haha). Thanks again!
Karen Puzzles and Tom Scott are two of my favourite RUclipsrs and it was a surprise to find them together in this. When I was younger I had a favourite puzzle I had done several times so I made a sort of game of it by putting all the pieces in a bag and drawing one at a time. If it didn't connect to one already on the table it went back into the bag which was shaken to prevent pieces remaining on top.
Thank you for introducing this to me. I have shared this with family and now we are having a blast puzzling. I even brought this into my after care programs!🎉
Speaking of your puzzles. Bought them back in august after finally finding them here in Sweden. Started with the smaller and finished it quickly. Brilliant concept with puzzles in a puzzle. The big one however gave me a challenge but a fun one. Was satisfying and rewarding to slowly see it being assembled. Hope you get more opportunities in the future to design puzzles 😊
They have been friends for some time already and she helped him out with the footage of his bear videos. So for me not so much a surprise, but a nice little fun occurrence.
Ooooh! I love this! What if you have a super small puzzle and flip the pieces so it’s a sort of memory game too. I’m definitely going to try puzzle _chess_ in the future! Lovely video always
You could adapt the chess touch-move rule for added challenge/handicapping. If you touch a chess piece during your turn, you have to move it, so that if you pick up a piece, then realize where you wanted to put it would be a blunder, you still have to move that piece (to any legal square). So for puzzle chess, if you pick up a piece but it doesn't fit where you first try, you would be able to try different spots but not another piece. And then if you can't, either you give up your move, or if you're going hard-mode, you lose.
For a puzzle chess improvement: If you aren't actively taking your turn, you can't look at the table. I think Tom is right that the person who has all the time to sit there and figure out a piece placement will have the advantage the whole game. You can place that piece quickly, leaving no time for the other person to find a new piece placement... which means they are always stuck spending more time per turn while you are spending less time per turn.
memory puzzle would be my suggestion. I guess you'd need a fairly easy puzzle for that but you do the border first as you did before can you lift up one of the remaining puzzle pieces and look at it if you can fit it you can put in the puzzle otherwise you put it back face down on the table
What a great idea! My family is coming over for the holidays, we all love doing puzzle, so I will definitely be trying this idea out. Thanks for sharing! :)
So fun! Thank you for explaining how to play puzzle CHESS. I had wondered whenever you mentioned it before! I'm definitely going to try this over the winter break!
i think with a small puzzle it might be fun to treat it like a card game, aka you each draw 4-7 pieces into your "hand" that are only accessible to you, but you can *only* play those. if you can't place any of them as a non-island, then you must discard 1+ pieces (you decide how many) and pull an equal amount from the "deck" (probably facedown pieces). maybe you get to play them on that turn, maybe not, you can make house rules. maybe you can play more than one piece per turn, if your hand is really good, and you draw replacements for each of them, but you can't play the replacements on the same turn. maybe the scoring in this case is "who puts the most pieces in", but like, weighted somehow based on the time competition? or maybe every person gets a turn of a fixed length (let's say 30 sec) and you can do any combination of plays, discards, replacements, and replacement plays that you can manage to do in that time, and it's about who puts the most pieces in. or maybe you divide all the pieces of the puzzle into halves and it's whoever gets rid of their half first? SO MANY POSSIBILITIES!
A possible variation: leave all pieces facing downwards (separating maybe the pieces by sections/colors to avoid picking always the floating/middle ones). That way, you won't be able to get advantage planning your next move if your opponent takes some time for a piece.
Oh my gosh! I had this exact idea watching your video on racing the fastest solvers a few days back! Literally even down to using a chess clock! so cool to see it being done!
@@Seff2 They're literally friends :D Can't recall which vids, but he's made casual appearances like this before :) Might be his first time in the Patreon, though, haha
Really fun video. Your excitement and enjoyment is palpable and contagious! Like Tom Scott I haven't touched a jigsaw puzzle in decades but this seems like a lovely lighthearted but intense game to try 😃 (chess for the codeword)
Love the concept of puzzle chest!! Can't wait for some new uploads! (I'm sure everyone agrees) we would like more content soon! I'm about to start my 3rd 1000 pc thanks to you & your insightful videos!
that sound realy cool. one twist i think could be added to add a bit of strategy to the game is seperate the pazzle to different areas and say that each time a player puts the last piece of an area in they mark the area as their own, and for each area a player owns they get a few seconds added to their time total(the areas could be either of similar size - 4 quorters for example, or different sizes based on what is on the puzzle, both can be interesting in different ways).
thats a fantastic idea , the interactive element , and every child has a phone that can use a timer app. Tom Scott, one of my favourites. its the more engaging version of shapes in a box. GALT wooden jigsaws might be fun for children vs adult at christmas gatherings.
Fitting that @tomscott is here (nice stunt getting him to visit!), as I was going to comment regardless on his having done a video about playing _Jenga_ with a chess clock.
Chess, you can also start with a grid like a chessboard / checkerboard, where all the black cells are already made. Start with a made puzzle. Take 1 piece out, stay 1 piece, take 1 piece... as starting point.
Dollertree had a bunch of really cute 100/350/500 piece puzzles that I picked up for stocking stuffers. I think I may introduce my kiddo to puzzle chess in hopes that he’ll love making puzzles into a competition. Last time we did a 300 piece together he complained it was too easy.
do libraries in the US have puzzles? I live in Berlin (Germany) if I wanted to get a puzzle, at least one for kids, I would get one easily at my public library.
HI KAREN !!! I was waiting for one of your videos to come out ! I HAVE to tell you : Me and my family did christmas early this year, so now i have a nex puzzle , IT'S YOURS !!!! I got the 3000 pieces one ,i'm so happy !!
Love this idea. Just wondering, wouldn't it be better to have a clock that counts up instead of down, then who has the lower time wins? That way you can't possibly end up with a timer that runs out. Unless running out of time is added as a loss condition. Which might be fun in some times when you want some more high stakes play. Can see both work now that I think about it, want more casual feel have the clock run up. Want a more stressful time get a tighter timer that counts down.
Thanks for the video! Also a tip for playing with a non puzzler is to set the chess clock at different starting times so that the other player starts with an advantage. I have some questions if anyone would know the answer: 1. What happens if in the end it turns out that there is a false fit in the puzzle that was not recognised before? 2. Might it not be unfair depending on if the puzzle piece count is even or uneven (many puzzles do not actually have the exact piece count that the box states) that the person to start has an advantage and gets a shorter finish time? Do you check the exact puzzle count to begin with? Looking forward to trying puzzle chess with the family over the holidays! Happy Christmas all! 🎄
I think the person who put in the false fit would fix it while it's their turn, or let the clock run for a few seconds to give themselves a slight penalty. I've never worried about counting pieces when it's only two people playing, but if you play with more than two like some people have suggested, you might want to check that the number is a multiple of the number of players. You could always put it one piece before starting so the number is even if you're too worried about it.
There's a touch move rule in chess where when you touched a piece you have to move it somewhere. I think you can put it into this, and if that piece couldn't fit on the current frame you get -20 seconds penalty or something like that.
I think a better handicap would be something like, Karen can't look at the pieces while Tom is playing? So the better rated person doesn't get the "the longer your opponent takes, the quicker you can be" effect, but the lower rated person can still be getting some catch up time.
ok i need to interject a bit on the naming - chess is its own game that by default has nothing to do with a clock then there are variations like classic(+- 120 + 30sec increment) blitz(3 to 10 mintues) bullet (
Fair enough, and Tom said a similar thing in a clip that's in the Patreon cut. Though I think that's something to take up with the people who created it and named it. You're welcome to call it whatever you want through!
I've seen quite a few videos about puzzle chess. Unfortunately there is no-one with whom I could do this. 🙁 I suppose I could try a solo version whereby I can only place pieces that fit from the edge in. I can then see how long that took. Not quite the same but better than nothing I guess. Look forward to your next video.
It would also be interesting if the person starting the game also chooses the first piece the puzzle needs to be built out from. So something like the building out from a central island, but the first player chooses the island piece.
Have you played puzzle chess yet? Let me know how it goes for you or if you have any questions. You can use any puzzle, but if you want any that I showed in this video, I linked all of them in the video description. Plus, if you want to watch the extended cut of the game at the end of the video, it is up on Patreon right now!
Not yet but will soon♟️🤍✌🏿
Chess
Now, I did! This evening, with my boyfriend. Off course I won! 😊
Might be a great idea to collab with chess content creators out there like Gothamchess, introducing the 2 communities together. Both games have shared recent history in which both games exploded during the pandemic.
I'm 100% doing this with my family!
When I was a child in the 1950's, my father and I would do something similar, usually on 500 piece puzzles. If you picked up a piece and it fit, you got a point, but if you picked up a piece and it didn't fit, you lost a point. You could go way down in the negatives, if you weren't careful. So it wasn't a matter of speed, but of accuracy.
I love this I’m definitely saving this to play with my puzzling friend.
That sound so incredibly fun!
And math connection!!!!
I love this idea lot more because I don't like games that are about time and speed, it just makes me stressed.
Oh I like this variant a lot better! Thanks for telling
Of course you played puzzle chess with Tom... he also popularized chess clock Jenga, or at least made a video about it, which looks much more stressful than this does. I love that you two know each other, it's so nice to see crossovers that feel genuinely like friends hanging out rather than two people trying to boost their popularity.
It's the crossover I had been waiting for ever since Karen popped up on Tom's podcast! Love these two! ❤
Yeah when I saw he was in the video I actually guessed he might have brought to you the idea of Puzzle Chess himself, considering he and Matt are the only people I've ever seen applyijg a Chess Clock to non board games.
Tom proves time and again that he's up for all sorts of the best possible nonsense going. This looks like great fun.
A Tom Scott crossover where he learns something new, I'm here for it. This Puzzle Chess thing looks like fun. I might have to get my nieces some puzzles as an excuse to do this.
there are few joys in life greater than seeing Tom being exasperated by the expertise of someone else.
"invite someone to play a game and kick their ass with it" tom's done that once or twice I think.
In Chess there is a 2 vs 2 - variation called "Hand & Brain". You could adapt it to Puzzle Chess: So one player has to choose the piece which the teampartner has to place this turn.
The team which is more in sync (Brain's choosing the same piece the hands-player thought off aswell) should be faster. So that's a nice touch :)
I love that!
Tom Scott seems like such a genuinely nice, humble, and sweet guy, and he shows a remarkable level of sensitivity in everything he does. I would love to play board games with him like this and I love seeing two utter sweethearts have a good time like this.
He is.
Suggestion from a parent. When playing with a child you could place 2-3 pieces to each one your child places. Or you could look away during your child’s turn so that you can only find pieces while you are actually on the clock.
Great ideas! Also for family members who never do puzzles but want to try it out.
I was thinking you could also let the kid mix up some of the pieces at the start of your turn, which I feel like they'd probably enjoy
As someone who was once a child, I hated it when the adults immediately assumed I had no chance in a fair game. Maybe only give the child an advantage if they get discouraged and are clearly losing.
Why is it so important to let a kid win? Maybe encourage them in other ways? Or have them play with peers?
@@celloafterdark4173 Exactly. If you teach your child that thye only win, how they will manage their loss further in life? Later nobody will pick up two pieces instead of one for them to win
My family won’t play against me unless I have restrictions so I use my left hand, they put the box/reference image somewhere so I can’t see it and they can, and I close my eyes whenever it isn’t my turn so that I can’t search for pieces. It levels the playing field a bit 😅 great video Karen, Thankyou!! ☺️
A good handicap would be a clock where Karen gets 15:00 and Tom gets maybe 17:00. If one doesn't exist, then just say K has to win by 2:00.
I had the same thought. Chess clocks should be able to do this. I've seen Chess matches between players of different skill level that were handicapped by time.
Beat me to this comment, handicap by time is common in chess and would work better than left handed which isn't too much of one.
Or maybe the "expert" has to put two pieces in per turn?
A decent chess clock can absolutely do this. The app they are using, I don't know. A decent chess clock can be had for $25 ish or so on Amazon. I would go one step over the Leaf ones. I don't think those can do handicapped times.
@@SybotCBSays in the description for the app that it allows handicapping 👍
I'm a fan or your channel as well as a longtime chess player (about fifty years) who has competed in hundreds of chess tournaments. I want to give you a rule clarification you may not be aware of. In chess, it is a requirement to hit the clock with the same hand that you moved your piece with. It's considered cheating to use your free hand to hit the clock. You might want to consider incorporating that practice into your game.
I didn't know that rule! I'll try to use that for future games.
Was about to say this too!!😅
I did not know that was a rule. Genuinely curious, how would that be considered cheating. I don’t see how that would affect anything. So would they be disqualified if they accidentally use the wrong hand?
@@Preciouslynnette because you can use your right hand for moving a piece and immediately press the clock with left, hovering over it. It saves loads of time if you do it like that considering you press the clock every turn. I believe you get a warning if you do it wrong. You also write down your turns/which pieces moved where (during the other's turn).
@@Preciouslynnette No disqualification. It's a very minor infraction, so at worst you'd get a mild "don't do that again." Frankly it is so ingrained in chess players from when they learn the rules and etiquette that they would never think to do it the wrong way.
The thumbnail including Karen, Tom Scott, Puzzles, and Chess is so emblematic of my year that I'm partly wondering if this video was generated by AI solely for my consumption.
Omg wasn't expecting Tom Scott to pop up on your channel but I love it! It's such an unexpected crossover within my sub box but i'm here for it 🙌
I learned about Karen from Matt Parker, so she already has a connection with the nerdy British educational channel space.
OMG Tom Scott with you ! Didn’t expect that 😍😍
How bad is it that I can recognize him through the blurring
Helped a little by his customary red tshirt :)
@@ryanoftinellb oh definitely
You got me with Tom Scott, I just recently started watching your videos and seeing a collab with Tom Scott, wow, first congrats, and keep on doing awesome videos.
I’ve been dying for an official break down of puzzle chess rules since you started showing it in your puzzle vlogs! Love this!
A variation could be that you are only allowed to place a piece connecting to the one previously placed. That may open possibilities for strategies as it is in theory possible to « checkmate » your opponent before ending the puzzle by purposefully create a hole where you put your piece (as all connections to this piece has already been made, your opponent cannot continue).
Another possible game with puzzles would be to play with two identical small puzzles sets. Both players try to place as many pieces on the same board from their set before the end, the one with the least remaining pieces win.
A minor handicap is for the better player to be the one to work the puzzle from the upside down orientation and the less advanced to view the puzzle tight side up (have the puzzle sideways for peers). The non-dominant hand handicap is a good one. Also have the better player close their eyes/look away from the puzzle when it isn't their turn. There are a number of possibilities.
Others would be that:
-the weaker player can see the image on the box but the stronger can't.
-2 for 1. Stronger player must place 2 pieces but the weaker only places one.
-The weaker player is allowed to make any legal move, but the stronger player must attach their piece to the last piece placed (unless impossible because the last piece placed was filling a "hole"
-some chess clocks allow for the players to have different time controls (although that is unlikely on the free versions and probably would require an upgraded download) so possibly give the weaker player an extra 3 seconds per piece.
In chess you are supposed to push the button on the clock with the same hand that you made your move with. Some people just hover their hand over the clock and get an unfair advantage by moving with the other hand, maybe even pushing the button before they make their move.
The easiest handicap is to let the slower player start with more time. Experiment to see how much time you want to give. You can add the handicap bonus time after the game is over.
Oh my god! My two favorite youtubers coming together! I’m so excited to see you expand your puzzling content!
That aside, if I had a nickel for every time Tom gets taught about a game and gets his ass absolutely destroyed, it would be two nickels which isn’t a lot but it’s funny lol
Ur!
The fact that I own "The Royal Game of Ur" due to this last incident means I need to buy some 100 piece puzzles now, doesn't it? 😂
@@patrickhanft most definitely! Your life will be the better for it.
you and tom were such an entertaining duo to watch play! what a delightful watch
Love the colab and Tom Scott is one of my faves!
I love when people find new ways to use things they already have. I think this is great!
Only discoverered your channel a week ago, and been devouring the videos - so addictive and then just now Tom Scott appears - Wow! I started puzzling during the Covid lockdown, and been doing at least one 1000 piece puzzle a month since. Will definitely try puzzle chess with my puzzling friend.
My daughter and I played puzzle chess this afternoon... Absolutely loved it! Thank you.
Thanks!
Tom really is a natural presenter, able to be articulate and composed even while frustrated.
Yay! Excited to share this video with friends and fam - I've been making some of them puzzle chess with me ever since I saw it in your puzzle camp video. I still haven't had any great uptake on play partners but I'm hoping I'll get some more games in during the holiday break. My nieces have a ton of 100 piece puzzles we could use (my 11 year old niece was the first person I was able to get to play with and she legit beat me, haha). Thanks again!
Hello! Will you be at the Minnesota puzzling competition? Hope to see you there!
Puzzle chess legitimately looks so fun!! I loved watching that whole video of puzzle camp, and it’s so cool seeing Tom Scott here too!
Karen Puzzles and Tom Scott are two of my favourite RUclipsrs and it was a surprise to find them together in this. When I was younger I had a favourite puzzle I had done several times so I made a sort of game of it by putting all the pieces in a bag and drawing one at a time. If it didn't connect to one already on the table it went back into the bag which was shaken to prevent pieces remaining on top.
Thank you for introducing this to me. I have shared this with family and now we are having a blast puzzling. I even brought this into my after care programs!🎉
I am so grateful for this video!What a great idea for me and two family members who puzzle!I cant wait to play with this with them soon!Thank you!
Didn't expect to see Tom Scott here but I'm happy he accepted the challenge!
Love the idea of starting puzzle chess with a block in the middle and working outwards... will have to give that a try
Speaking of your puzzles. Bought them back in august after finally finding them here in Sweden. Started with the smaller and finished it quickly. Brilliant concept with puzzles in a puzzle. The big one however gave me a challenge but a fun one. Was satisfying and rewarding to slowly see it being assembled. Hope you get more opportunities in the future to design puzzles 😊
Can't believe you got Tom Scott in your video. I have been wanting this since you were on Lateral. I love chess and puzzles!
They have been friends for some time already and she helped him out with the footage of his bear videos. So for me not so much a surprise, but a nice little fun occurrence.
This looks like so much fun! I could see playing with more than two people, everyone just keeps their own time on their own phones.
Ooooh! I love this! What if you have a super small puzzle and flip the pieces so it’s a sort of memory game too. I’m definitely going to try puzzle _chess_ in the future! Lovely video always
Great idea!
Tom Scott is a treasure. Glad you guys had a good time puzzling!
You could adapt the chess touch-move rule for added challenge/handicapping. If you touch a chess piece during your turn, you have to move it, so that if you pick up a piece, then realize where you wanted to put it would be a blunder, you still have to move that piece (to any legal square). So for puzzle chess, if you pick up a piece but it doesn't fit where you first try, you would be able to try different spots but not another piece. And then if you can't, either you give up your move, or if you're going hard-mode, you lose.
For a puzzle chess improvement: If you aren't actively taking your turn, you can't look at the table. I think Tom is right that the person who has all the time to sit there and figure out a piece placement will have the advantage the whole game. You can place that piece quickly, leaving no time for the other person to find a new piece placement... which means they are always stuck spending more time per turn while you are spending less time per turn.
Thanks for posting this CHRSS video. I'm excited to try it!
Ok, I did not expect a Tom Scott crossover nor did I know that I wanted one but I did and I do. Amazing to see your channel grow!!!
Chess😊 start with all pieces face down. Makes it much more challenging! Good luck
Love that! Good idea!
I love this it would be like playing Memory and puzzle at the same time
memory puzzle would be my suggestion. I guess you'd need a fairly easy puzzle for that but
you do the border first as you did before
can you lift up one of the remaining puzzle pieces and look at it if you can fit it you can put in the puzzle otherwise you put it back face down on the table
Tom is here.. I've been a big fano this for years
Recently started watching this channel awesome to see Tom here
1:44 Why would heads be the back of the piece and not the front?
What a great idea! My family is coming over for the holidays, we all love doing puzzle, so I will definitely be trying this idea out. Thanks for sharing! :)
So fun! Thank you for explaining how to play puzzle CHESS. I had wondered whenever you mentioned it before! I'm definitely going to try this over the winter break!
The cross overs i never expected, but learned i needed.
Thank you.
i think with a small puzzle it might be fun to treat it like a card game, aka you each draw 4-7 pieces into your "hand" that are only accessible to you, but you can *only* play those. if you can't place any of them as a non-island, then you must discard 1+ pieces (you decide how many) and pull an equal amount from the "deck" (probably facedown pieces). maybe you get to play them on that turn, maybe not, you can make house rules. maybe you can play more than one piece per turn, if your hand is really good, and you draw replacements for each of them, but you can't play the replacements on the same turn. maybe the scoring in this case is "who puts the most pieces in", but like, weighted somehow based on the time competition? or maybe every person gets a turn of a fixed length (let's say 30 sec) and you can do any combination of plays, discards, replacements, and replacement plays that you can manage to do in that time, and it's about who puts the most pieces in. or maybe you divide all the pieces of the puzzle into halves and it's whoever gets rid of their half first? SO MANY POSSIBILITIES!
There are a lot of good ideas in there! You need to start workshopping some of them!
@@KarenPuzzles i would, but i have no one to play with 😭 my family are not into puzzles and all my friends live abroad
🤯😊
A possible variation: leave all pieces facing downwards (separating maybe the pieces by sections/colors to avoid picking always the floating/middle ones). That way, you won't be able to get advantage planning your next move if your opponent takes some time for a piece.
I've never tried this, but it sounds like fun. I always play board games with family at Christmas, so maybe we'll have to try this this year.
I was half expecting Tom Scott to at the end go "Ok so now I'm challenging you to a game of Boggle"
Oh my gosh! I had this exact idea watching your video on racing the fastest solvers a few days back! Literally even down to using a chess clock! so cool to see it being done!
what a fun idea to combine puzzling and CHESS. Great video! :) Now I'm going to hunt down some fun minipuzzles to try this with my friends :D
What a fun idea! I will try this with my family during our Christmas gathering.
Did you change editors or get a new plug in? the title cards and timing feels different?
7:55 Oh! Well hello there Tom Scott!
The most unexpected Collab....
@@Seff2 They're literally friends :D Can't recall which vids, but he's made casual appearances like this before :) Might be his first time in the Patreon, though, haha
there was a Myst board-game that had a competitive jigsaw-puzzle mechanic to it, red pieces vs blue pieces.
yellow, not red
Really fun video. Your excitement and enjoyment is palpable and contagious!
Like Tom Scott I haven't touched a jigsaw puzzle in decades but this seems like a lovely lighthearted but intense game to try 😃
(chess for the codeword)
Love the concept of puzzle chest!! Can't wait for some new uploads! (I'm sure everyone agrees) we would like more content soon! I'm about to start my 3rd 1000 pc thanks to you & your insightful videos!
For handicaps one can give time odds, or moves odds (put two pieces rather than one)
Thank you Karen. I am not puzzler but i liked puzzle after watching your videos.Thank you again & God bless you.
that sound realy cool. one twist i think could be added to add a bit of strategy to the game is seperate the pazzle to different areas and say that each time a player puts the last piece of an area in they mark the area as their own, and for each area a player owns they get a few seconds added to their time total(the areas could be either of similar size - 4 quorters for example, or different sizes based on what is on the puzzle, both can be interesting in different ways).
I love this idea, another way to enjoy those puzzles
thats a fantastic idea , the interactive element , and every child has a phone that can use a timer app. Tom Scott, one of my favourites. its the more engaging version of shapes in a box. GALT wooden jigsaws might be fun for children vs adult at christmas gatherings.
I love this!! I’m gonna have to try this with the family on Xmas eve for sure!
I have to admit, watching you collaborate with Tom Scott was fantastic. Watching you kick Tom Scott's @$$ however was incredibly satisfying. 😀
If it was.linguistics or engineering or computer science or pretty much anything except puzzles, the roles definitely would have been reversed 😂
@@KarenPuzzles You join an elite club alongside Irving Finkle.
I can't believe Tom Scott and Karen are in a video together! I'm so happy right now
Fitting that @tomscott is here (nice stunt getting him to visit!), as I was going to comment regardless on his having done a video about playing _Jenga_ with a chess clock.
When I was telling him about puzzle chess off camera, he brought up Jenga. That one seems too stressful for me.
@@KarenPuzzles You should have challenged him to _Blokus_ - I'd pay money to watch that.
This is such a unique way to do a pyzzle going to introduce this to my parents they are big puzzlers. And nice to see Tom drop in 😊
Wow! Tom Scott is in the video
I think that it was Tom who first introduced me to Karen's stream. CHESS!
Ngl I thought you have to play chess and solve a puzzle in a sequence. Also, the Spanish really are quite the pioneers of puzzling.
Chess, you can also start with a grid like a chessboard / checkerboard, where all the black cells are already made. Start with a made puzzle. Take 1 piece out, stay 1 piece, take 1 piece... as starting point.
This looks like great fun! Definitely going to try it
Dollertree had a bunch of really cute 100/350/500 piece puzzles that I picked up for stocking stuffers. I think I may introduce my kiddo to puzzle chess in hopes that he’ll love making puzzles into a competition. Last time we did a 300 piece together he complained it was too easy.
Tom was a great addition to this video. This looks like fun
Chess! What a fun way to enjoy the game. Thanks for the ideas
I had my first go on building a 3D jigsaw using an Oculus yesterday. Really fun if you get the opportunity.
Yay, Tom Scott!
Oh, and puzzles too!
Tom!!! I did not know we needed this crossover but ohhh its good 😁
OMG you're a beast Karen. Love watching you in the lead and still pushing and finding more ways to win
That looks like a lot of fun.
do libraries in the US have puzzles?
I live in Berlin (Germany) if I wanted to get a puzzle, at least one for kids, I would get one easily at my public library.
I think it depends on the library! There's a big variety in funding and services across the country.
looks like a lot of fun! glad you were the one to take tom scott down a few pegs lmao
oh my god a tom scott x karen puzzles crossover is something i never knew i needed 😭😭
HI KAREN !!!
I was waiting for one of your videos to come out ! I HAVE to tell you :
Me and my family did christmas early this year, so now i have a nex puzzle , IT'S YOURS !!!! I got the 3000 pieces one ,i'm so happy !!
I hope you like it!
@@KarenPuzzles i'm pretty sure it's going to be awesome !
I'm waiting to start it because i don't have anywhere to put it for now 😅
Love this idea. Just wondering, wouldn't it be better to have a clock that counts up instead of down, then who has the lower time wins? That way you can't possibly end up with a timer that runs out. Unless running out of time is added as a loss condition. Which might be fun in some times when you want some more high stakes play. Can see both work now that I think about it, want more casual feel have the clock run up. Want a more stressful time get a tighter timer that counts down.
Thanks for the video!
Also a tip for playing with a non puzzler is to set the chess clock at different starting times so that the other player starts with an advantage.
I have some questions if anyone would know the answer:
1. What happens if in the end it turns out that there is a false fit in the puzzle that was not recognised before?
2. Might it not be unfair depending on if the puzzle piece count is even or uneven (many puzzles do not actually have the exact piece count that the box states) that the person to start has an advantage and gets a shorter finish time? Do you check the exact puzzle count to begin with?
Looking forward to trying puzzle chess with the family over the holidays! Happy Christmas all! 🎄
I think the person who put in the false fit would fix it while it's their turn, or let the clock run for a few seconds to give themselves a slight penalty. I've never worried about counting pieces when it's only two people playing, but if you play with more than two like some people have suggested, you might want to check that the number is a multiple of the number of players. You could always put it one piece before starting so the number is even if you're too worried about it.
There's a touch move rule in chess where when you touched a piece you have to move it somewhere. I think you can put it into this, and if that piece couldn't fit on the current frame you get -20 seconds penalty or something like that.
I think a better handicap would be something like, Karen can't look at the pieces while Tom is playing? So the better rated person doesn't get the "the longer your opponent takes, the quicker you can be" effect, but the lower rated person can still be getting some catch up time.
So wonderful to see Tom Scott on the channel.
ok i need to interject a bit on the naming -
chess is its own game that by default has nothing to do with a clock
then there are variations like classic(+- 120 + 30sec increment) blitz(3 to 10 mintues) bullet (
Fair enough, and Tom said a similar thing in a clip that's in the Patreon cut. Though I think that's something to take up with the people who created it and named it. You're welcome to call it whatever you want through!
I saw Tom Scott in the thumb nail and I was like “is that Tom Scott?” And it is!
I've seen quite a few videos about puzzle chess. Unfortunately there is no-one with whom I could do this. 🙁 I suppose I could try a solo version whereby I can only place pieces that fit from the edge in. I can then see how long that took. Not quite the same but better than nothing I guess. Look forward to your next video.
So fun too see how frustrated Tom Scott become on a 100 piece jigsaw puzzle
This is so much fun! Thank you!
Stellar Factory Pizza Puzzles allow people to compete by each person completing a slice of the pizza --- no chess clock is needed!
It would also be interesting if the person starting the game also chooses the first piece the puzzle needs to be built out from. So something like the building out from a central island, but the first player chooses the island piece.
Great Scott! What a crossover!