Bill Jordan told me he carried a 1917 when he was in the Marines in the second world war he modified it a shorter barrel an action job, served him well.
Great video guys. Love the old history and keeping it alive. Elmer Keith would be proud to see our younger generation still as excited about these revolvers as they were back in the day. Those Keith loads and skeeter loads in them old revolvers are all we could ask for.
IMO smith and Wesson needs to come out with a 6.5” 44 magnum, fixed sight N Frame as an homage to the triple lock in their Classic line. A 6.5” Triple Lock is one of the sexiest revolvers they ever madeX
A great collection of historical firearms to be proud of. Thank you gentleman for sharing and I look forward to more videos of old Smith and Wesson hand ejector 's , heavy duties and others. Thanks again for the history.
Great video! I got a commercial 1917 a few years back. I sent S&W the serial number and they sent me a letter saying it was produced in the 1920s (can't remember the exact year off the top of my head). It's a pretty cool revolver! If you guys ever talk about the hand ejectors again you could mention the 1917 he used in Raiders of the Lost Ark (and the hi-power used).
@@PearceBrothersGearGuide that and a post war model 21 or Pre 21 in 44 special with a 6.5” barrel. There have been occasions I’ve seen pre and post model 21s go for more money than a shooter grade British marked triple lock.
@@PearceBrothersGearGuide the most gut twisting thing I ever saw though was in a news article about a buy back in some big city and one of the photos showed a side shot of a some of the guns they had “gotten off the streets” and one them them was a either a triple lock target model or a third model hand ejector target. It had a shrouded ejector rod and the bore was too large to have been a 38/44 Outdoorsman.
I would like to know were you got your hat jake . I’ve worn one similar to that for over 40 yrs . It’s getting thin so to speak . As sad as it makes me I need to replace it . Will be buried with the original along with my mountain gun in 44 mag . Thanks for the great videos.
Casually passes the registered magnum across the table like it was a common ruger gp. Can't wait for more information I didn't know about the rifling machinery from sharps. I have a newer model 21 44 special 4 inch that I put a set of herrets trooper Jordan stocks on. And i have a Brazilian model 1917. The smiths are light smooth and balanced nicely. The colt new service /1917 are just bigger heavier and robust. And i feel like they recoil heavier than the Smith. I would love to have model 27 eventually. I wonder if the popularity of the registered magnum will fade as more younger people start collecting because I feel like it's something that you have to be in the know to appreciate.
Thanks! You can't go wrong with a pre war Smith and Wesson! It might be a fun video to compare the 1917 to the Colt new service. Hopefully the Registered Magnum gets less desirable but we will see. Both of the ones we used in the video belong to our Dad and we would like to have some of our own haha
Wait only 2,000 commercial guns? Just picked up a nickeled 1917 for $400. No US Property marks anywhere on the gun. One of my gunsmiths looked up the number and said it’s from 1926. Put another $100 into a new set of service grips, lanyard loop, and the action was slightly outta time. Honestly though I’m a little perplexed why the 1917 wasn’t a bigger success in the interwar period. It’s not K frame M&P light but it’s very well balanced and much easier than any of the 38 caliber N frames. The star/moon clips make reloading much faster and easier. You’d have ammo compatibility with the government and could purchase surplus guns and parts from government stores as well as ammo for training. With standard 230 grain loads it’s not that much more difficult to shoot or to train to shoot than a typical K frame or the Colt Official Police. Like did smith just promote the K frame over the 1917 or was it just too awkward a revolver for its time?
Good question. My take on this is that between the wars there were a lot of Surplus 1917 Revolvers on the market that were surplused out after ww1. Another factor is that the Great Depression really affected new gun sales in the 30s.
Nothing! They are great handguns. This video was mostly focusing on the 44/45 pre war n frames. We will have a video on the future on registered magnums, heavy duty's,, outdoorsman's etc
Bill Jordan told me he carried a 1917 when he was in the Marines in the second world war he modified it a shorter barrel an action job, served him well.
Great video guys. Love the old history and keeping it alive. Elmer Keith would be proud to see our younger generation still as excited about these revolvers as they were back in the day.
Those Keith loads and skeeter loads in them old revolvers are all we could ask for.
Thank you! We do love those old Smith and Wessons! There's just something special about those pre war guns.
Love the Smith & Wessons! Keep em coming please. I would also like to see something on the .38/44 outdoorsman.
That will be coming! Thanks
IMO smith and Wesson needs to come out with a 6.5” 44 magnum, fixed sight N Frame as an homage to the triple lock in their Classic line. A 6.5” Triple Lock is one of the sexiest revolvers they ever madeX
That would be a cool gun!
A great collection of historical firearms to be proud of. Thank you gentleman for sharing and I look forward to more videos of old Smith and Wesson hand ejector 's , heavy duties and others. Thanks again for the history.
Thank you! We will have more videos out soon.
Maybe a full video soon on all of the n frame 357s? Like registered magnums 27s 28s and such?
Yes we have that one our list for future videos! Thanks
Great video! I got a commercial 1917 a few years back. I sent S&W the serial number and they sent me a letter saying it was produced in the 1920s (can't remember the exact year off the top of my head). It's a pretty cool revolver! If you guys ever talk about the hand ejectors again you could mention the 1917 he used in Raiders of the Lost Ark (and the hi-power used).
Sweet! We are going to do a Pearce Brothers top 10 movie guns and I'm we will definitely mention Indiana! Great movies!
@@PearceBrothersGearGuide Right on!
Damn you guys have a nice S&W Collection.
Thank you! There are some beauties in here.
A triple lock target model in either 44 special or 45 colt is my holy grail gun.
They are hard to find... and not cheap!
@@PearceBrothersGearGuide that and a post war model 21 or Pre 21 in 44 special with a 6.5” barrel. There have been occasions I’ve seen pre and post model 21s go for more money than a shooter grade British marked triple lock.
@@PearceBrothersGearGuide the most gut twisting thing I ever saw though was in a news article about a buy back in some big city and one of the photos showed a side shot of a some of the guns they had “gotten off the streets” and one them them was a either a triple lock target model or a third model hand ejector target. It had a shrouded ejector rod and the bore was too large to have been a 38/44 Outdoorsman.
@Ben_not_10 that's terrible! And they probably only gave then like 200 for it 🤦♂️
Cool video guys, you’re lucky to have all those great old smiths. Definitely would like to see 38/44 heavy duty/ outdoorsman video
Thank you we appreciate that! We will definitely do a 38/44 video
@@PearceBrothersGearGuide awesome
I would like to know were you got your hat jake . I’ve worn one similar to that for over 40 yrs . It’s getting thin so to speak . As sad as it makes me I need to replace it . Will be buried with the original along with my mountain gun in 44 mag . Thanks for the great videos.
Good choice. Those 4” smiths are 1 I’d never sell
Good video guys, love a N frame Smith
Thank you! Those N Frames sure are classy!
Nice job guys!
Glad you enjoyed it
Well done...
Thank you!
Casually passes the registered magnum across the table like it was a common ruger gp. Can't wait for more information I didn't know about the rifling machinery from sharps. I have a newer model 21 44 special 4 inch that I put a set of herrets trooper Jordan stocks on. And i have a Brazilian model 1917. The smiths are light smooth and balanced nicely. The colt new service /1917 are just bigger heavier and robust. And i feel like they recoil heavier than the Smith. I would love to have model 27 eventually. I wonder if the popularity of the registered magnum will fade as more younger people start collecting because I feel like it's something that you have to be in the know to appreciate.
Thanks! You can't go wrong with a pre war Smith and Wesson! It might be a fun video to compare the 1917 to the Colt new service. Hopefully the Registered Magnum gets less desirable but we will see. Both of the ones we used in the video belong to our Dad and we would like to have some of our own haha
Wait only 2,000 commercial guns? Just picked up a nickeled 1917 for $400. No US Property marks anywhere on the gun. One of my gunsmiths looked up the number and said it’s from 1926. Put another $100 into a new set of service grips, lanyard loop, and the action was slightly outta time.
Honestly though I’m a little perplexed why the 1917 wasn’t a bigger success in the interwar period. It’s not K frame M&P light but it’s very well balanced and much easier than any of the 38 caliber N frames. The star/moon clips make reloading much faster and easier. You’d have ammo compatibility with the government and could purchase surplus guns and parts from government stores as well as ammo for training. With standard 230 grain loads it’s not that much more difficult to shoot or to train to shoot than a typical K frame or the Colt Official Police. Like did smith just promote the K frame over the 1917 or was it just too awkward a revolver for its time?
Good question. My take on this is that between the wars there were a lot of Surplus 1917 Revolvers on the market that were surplused out after ww1. Another factor is that the Great Depression really affected new gun sales in the 30s.
What you got agaist the Heavy duty?
Nothing! They are great handguns. This video was mostly focusing on the 44/45 pre war n frames. We will have a video on the future on registered magnums, heavy duty's,, outdoorsman's etc
You guys are great! Love the content. Love the guns. But PLEASE lose that annoying background noise! Cymbals?
We've upgraded the mic since this video and our editing skills have greatly improved! Thanks for watching!
@@PearceBrothersGearGuide Great! Look forward to seeing (and hearing) lots more from you guys! Always a big fan of your dad’s writing as well!
@@pauldonner9707 thank you! We appreciate the support!
Dick had to go and ruin that poor 1917!
Haha yup!
That’s a Dandy!
Thanks!