Tribalism vs Nationalism | South Sudanese Diaspora Perspective 🇸🇸

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 янв 2025

Комментарии • 41

  • @demo8431
    @demo8431 9 месяцев назад +9

    It feels so bad when you find these beautiful smart young South Sudanese talking about the country and still getting less views 😢😢
    Anyway shout out to y'all ❤❤

    • @Huhn-Bruh
      @Huhn-Bruh 4 дня назад

      Because South Sudan don't really have connecting cousin countries and in reality should have no relation with Sudan. If this was about "the tallest darkest people" they would have 250,000 more views in one day but it seems like South Sudan is a stand alone country

  • @Tonyman-m4
    @Tonyman-m4 10 месяцев назад +7

    You're Damm right let me just make an explain for myself I start following your ladies sosa because you guys are just south sudanese

    • @ladiesofsosa
      @ladiesofsosa  10 месяцев назад

      Love that! 🇸🇸🫶🏿

  • @acholnyuon2695
    @acholnyuon2695 10 месяцев назад +4

    Beautiful ladies and loved this episode. I’m Dinka Bor and definitely agree that Dinka privilege is real. I have witnessed it personally. Sadly it does nothing but add more division to our community.

  • @Chimaoges_Comments
    @Chimaoges_Comments 5 месяцев назад +1

    ✨🌴✨This Was An Interesting Discussion. It Is Nice To Know About The Different Tribal Dynamics In Different Countries Around The World. I Would Like To Research South Sudan’s Tribal Dynamics Further. Thank You For The Information🙏🏿✨🌴✨

  • @NysholObang
    @NysholObang 8 месяцев назад +1

    The young man is very knowledgeable and reasonable in his talkings. This topic will always be an ongoing topic. We as a country need to catch up. We are getting left behind in the continent. South Africa, Kenya, and Rwanda learned how to work around the tribes and be prideful. There can be a middle ground. Thanks for this. In addition, can we please let people finish their thoughts because there are real good thoughts.

  • @david________
    @david________ 5 месяцев назад +2

    10:00 only Khartoum was developed. West, east, far north, and kordofan was also heavily underdeveloped

  • @PS-vc6ef
    @PS-vc6ef 10 месяцев назад +5

    I enjoyed the conversation my dear brothers and sisters. I believe each and any man or woman from any of our 64 tribes is capable of moving our country forward. Tribalism (mother of Corruption) is the only issue holding South Sudan down from taking charge of Africa.

  • @angelikadepelika3758
    @angelikadepelika3758 10 месяцев назад +7

    The young guy in white did great! New generation mindset

    • @PS-vc6ef
      @PS-vc6ef 10 месяцев назад +3

      You are right! I agree with his viewpoints. If you are not preforming regardless of whether you are my blood brother or not, you got get out of the office and let a professional do the job. You can't preform, you don't deserve the salary one bit.

  • @arnabiarnab3037
    @arnabiarnab3037 9 месяцев назад

    10:35 I meant Port Sudan…not Omdurman does have oil refineries…. But to ship the oil out…it needs to go to port Sudan

  • @Cypher_Ngor
    @Cypher_Ngor 10 месяцев назад +1

    Major reason for separation was definitely conflict of interests on Oil but other factors also contributed , one of them being religion. It’s good to hear different perspectives, One Love My People ❤️🇸🇸 Can’t wait for next episode.

  • @UnstoppableJefe
    @UnstoppableJefe 10 месяцев назад +3

    An interesting topic. My take on it, if a mass of people want to be identified as a sovereign nation state there needs to be a strong sense of nationalism, common interests and values. Inherently there's nothing bad about tribalism, it is a natural part of social rearing and self identity. The problem begins when tribalism permeates into political power structures and encites devision. Nationalism supersedes tribalism - the prosperity of the group should outweight the interests of the few.

  • @emanlive7832
    @emanlive7832 10 месяцев назад +8

    Nation states from which nationalism derives are a construct foreign to most of Africa, this is mainly a European construct that developed in the 18th and 19th century. Majority of Sub-saharan Africa do not meet the pre-requisite of what constitutes a nation state. That is Africa has countries but not nations. What we call countries now in Africa are arbitrary borders that were created by European powers to delineate one powers region of exploitation vs another. To meet the criteria there must be common language and sense of a common history and ancestry this is simply not the case in South Sudan. Majority of Sub-saharan African countries except for maybe Rwanda and Somalia are not homogeneous enough meet the pre-requisite of what constitutes a nation state. If we look at the country of South Sudan historically the only entity that resembled a state was the Shilluk Kingdom. Africa definitely has states which we call countries but within them there exists many different peoples with their own historical lands that may stretch across multiple borders, languages, and history i.e. nations. Each people in South Sudan to the extent that they actually have a history should have pride in their own languages and history.

  • @BM-dr4eu
    @BM-dr4eu 9 месяцев назад +1

    Wait...Christine was born in Zimbabwe? Please give us an entire storytime

  • @dennisstampleycali
    @dennisstampleycali 10 месяцев назад

    South Sudan is so so rich country in natural resources and the people are so much of how families are so much like!

  • @thechocolatedelegate9830
    @thechocolatedelegate9830 10 месяцев назад +2

    Groups show their true nature when they have the numbers.

  • @nyaruonwiyualruot8525
    @nyaruonwiyualruot8525 10 месяцев назад +1

    As usual, I very appreciated the topic and all of your take on it🤗I would like to know why there aren't any Nuer youngsters on this fantastic podcast. Are they simply not invited at all, or do they just decline to participate in these kind of discussions? Also, I'm well aware Sarah is mixed Nuer and Dinka but y'all get what trying say here. I'm from Canada btw and I'm here for unity and peace :)

    • @ladiesofsosa
      @ladiesofsosa  10 месяцев назад +1

      Hi! Thank you for the comment 🤎 We put out a casting call on our social media, but honestly there’s not a huge Nuer community in Dallas, so it is challenging at times to find a panelist for the podcast. We would love to have more Nuer representation in the future even as a virtual guest.

  • @MrMakingcake
    @MrMakingcake 8 месяцев назад +2

    Do you guys still keep your tribe and nationalism when you come to America will your kids drop these things to assimilate more into America culture.

  • @marcodeng7138
    @marcodeng7138 4 месяца назад

    Mama Amiira was responding to some Equatorians like:Babylon AKA Dongulu...Bashiir Bashiir...DJ Hakeem ...etc,,but peoplefrom other tribes don't see what these individuals have said towards Dinka Tribe but they only focus on what siad by Mama Amiira towards Equatoria tribes 😢

  • @marcodeng7138
    @marcodeng7138 4 месяца назад

    Forget about Konye,but Nomadic Arabs AKA Almraheel which call them today as Rapid suport Army or Janjaweed have don't alot of atrocities more than Sudanese Army, specially in the Northern areas who bordered the North:Northern Baherelgazal...Abyei...Twich ....Rueng....Panrieng all the way to Northern Uper Nile:Renk and Maluth,they have burnt a lot of villages,killed a lot of people and abducted a lot of kids and use them as slaves😢

  • @marcodeng7138
    @marcodeng7138 4 месяца назад

    It ain't about oil, because oil just got discovered in 70s while the civil war started 1955

  • @abbasreex0
    @abbasreex0 10 месяцев назад +2

    I love you guys please have a north Sudanese guests

  • @bkzarok
    @bkzarok 10 месяцев назад +3

    I enjoy the conversation but you guys don't really understand what's going on with South Sudan.

    • @a.m8218
      @a.m8218 9 месяцев назад +2

      I hate when people like you say this. Even if they’re not living in South Sudan, they clearly still educate or keep up on the issues happening in SS. So instead of saying they don’t know what’s going on, let them know from the topic they’re speaking on where they may have miss understood.🙄

  • @BM-dr4eu
    @BM-dr4eu 9 месяцев назад

    I really missed Koyom Koyom on this one

  • @Ayla.a7a
    @Ayla.a7a 10 месяцев назад

    There’s a secession movement happening as you all speak.

  • @marcodeng7138
    @marcodeng7138 4 месяца назад

    There is Dinka in power privileges and Bari in power privileges...Nuer in power privileges and Cholo in power privileges too,you can't tell me that the government of South Sudan will treat me well more than the son of Mabotu Mamour or more than Tut Keu son,it will never happen

  • @malodol1234
    @malodol1234 10 месяцев назад +1

    The image of John Garang isn’t the same amongst everyone in the Country of South Sudan and i’ll say that because the genesis of how He became the leader of the SPLA is also what greatly sparked and made worse the issues between Dinka and Nuer itself and the we need a way to reconcile that for the Country to move forward and I also think their isn’t enough Nuer people representation in this podcast although Sarah is Part Nuer and Dinka. regardless we have a long way to go as a country no doubt since us people Young and Old don’t trust each other enough to really support and work together effectively and it’s a black person problem where ever you go amongst the Black American diaspora to the people in the African Continent and most tellingly in South Sudan and Junubiin as a whole across the world

    • @ladiesofsosa
      @ladiesofsosa  10 месяцев назад

      Hello! We hear you on more Nuer representation. We put our casting calls on our social media, but the Nuer community in Dallas is quite small. We would love to have more Nuer voices on the panel even if it’s virtual. For anyone interested on being on a future panel, our email is ladiesofsosa@gmail.com 🤎🇸🇸

  • @dowbul5552
    @dowbul5552 5 месяцев назад +1

    You all stop and study your history before taking on it

  • @real8551
    @real8551 10 месяцев назад +6

    One ask, please stop talking over each other. It's so distracting and annoying

  • @peterreat5091
    @peterreat5091 6 месяцев назад +2

    Go back to History of the country my young people, you are in the right direction but you need to nourished your knowledge about history of our country.

  • @davidchol2237
    @davidchol2237 10 месяцев назад +1

    Interesting topic and great discussion. I also believe we as younger generations have to grow up and be a bit wiser, constructive criticism is good if we want to move forward as a nation. When we look deep into the tribalism there are way in which we can handle it better but the moment we give attention to those that are not willing to have that understanding we have to start looking into the mirror and take accountability.
    The issue for tribalism is the lack of accountability, if more and more take a stand against their own community in the direction we want it to run then we can go a long way.
    When I mean take a stand, different ways through social media, organisations, you got the paris olympic coming up yes it’s great we are supporting the team but what about the children in SS who don’t have food, school, lack of security.
    We are very fortunate and God has blessed us lets use it to our advantage. 🙏🏿🤲🏿🤍