The Walking Dead Discussion Love Or Hate Shane?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 окт 2024
- We discuss the topic of Shane Walsh on The Walking Dead TV show. People either love him or hate him. Check out the video and let us know what you think of Shane.
MY BOOK ON AMAZON
www.amazon.com...
TWD COMMUNITY FACEBOOK PAGE
/ wearetwdcommunity
TWD COMMUNITY FACEBOOK GROUP
/ 265867570439067
Thank you for watching The PT Channel
Like Share Subscribe & Comment
Let's Keep This Channel Growing!
All images/graphics/video clips are property of AMC and used under the fair use principal for commentary, education, and criticism
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commentary, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. 
Развлечения
Shane was a character ahead of his time
dodi354 you can't deny that him trying to kill Rick was a unnecessary thing to attempt
Mr Bob The only thing I wish that he hadn't have done. But would have been nice to see him and Rick going up against Negan together
I loved Shane. He understood this world.
Happywife Taylor 100% people saw him as a threat but he was really doing what he could've to protect everyone
Scott Cho I understand. I also agree with you about Lori. She was literally the devil on Rick's shoulder in that tent egging him on to do something about Shane.
Miguel Avila he was a threat. Lori made it worse though. I'm satisfied with how his story played out but I think he a frustrated with the group. That's why he wanted to leave. But of course here comes Lori convincing him not to leave.
Happywife Taylor I don't think Shane would last long with Negan and Saviors. I honestly think he would of gone crazy struggled to cope with losing people and tried to take out Negan on his own without thinking about a solution. He wouldn't of listened to Rick and made another bad decision getting himself killed
shooterace247 I agree
Shane was a great character, Lori was the ongoing problem.
I loved shane he was awesome in my opinion I feel he really couldn't kill rick he loved rick and I do blame lori.fir his death she wanted to keep both men around so if one died she had a backup
Shane was an excellent antagonist for the show; every character was impacted by him in some way. Every show needs characters like that. Shane was before his time...he was built for the apocalypse as it is now, not how it was in the beginning. Leaving his story open for a return, especially since we know Judith is his now, would've been interesting and cool.
Shane was the guy Rick is now. Rick was even more dangerous than Shane was after awhile. As time went on Rick realized Shane was right, you can't be the good guy anymore. If Shane was alive today than Rick and him would make a badass team but that would never happen because of Shane's head over hills for Lori.
I wish they kept Shane alive. They could've done so much with his character and he could've been redeemed. Imagine him in All Out War. What happened with Otis was a split second decision, and if he hadn't left Otis, both himself and Carl wouldn't have made it. I would've done the same thing if it meant saving somebody I loved.
I bought your book yesterday. I can't wait to read it. Thank you. Love your videos
Awesome. Thank you so much Michelle
If they wanted to bring back "Shane" they could bring back Jon bernthal and have him be Shane's twin brother. I know it's very cheesy but it could work
Zombie 101 that wouldn't work.
That would be great.
Its all about survival after apocalypse and rebuilding society. Characters like Shane are a must in the show.
Absolutely loved Shane. Better to have audiences feel strongly about him either way than to be indifferent. As a viewer, I always felt conflicted how I felt about Shane but even his craziest actions and ideas came from a place where he felt he was justified in them and even if the way he went about executing them was wrong, I could always see where he was coming from. He connected with viewers good or bad, and that strong emotion makes him memorable, therefore, awesome. 😀
I've been on team Shane from day one ...he was a great character .....
They ruined Lori and Shane's character in the story line
no they made it better
I think they killed him off way too early. They could have waited until Laurie died, in which would resolved the friction between him and Rick. Shane was so determined to kill the young man because of him belonging to another group that posed an imminent threat… I just wonder if the young fellow belonged to the Saviors and if so, then that speaks volumes considering the trouble they are all in now with Negan. Shane wasn't entirely a bad guy, he only did what needed to be done the same way that Carol did/does. He loved his new family (Laurie and Carl) and was going to protect them no matter what even if it meant Rick had to go. Besides, Rick did make stupid decisions like going back to Atlanta after he just reunited with them... In this world, it's not about who's married to who but who can protect who and I wonder also, if Laurie would have died the way she did if Shane was around. After all, that was his baby and he knew it.
shane was great.. merle too
ballztodawallz 420 Merle was awesome. I wish he had lived more than Shane bc I think with Daryl Merle woulda came around and been an asset.
The bitch is back ! merle was prob one of my favorites! funny as hell and a badass. agreed if he didnt go on a suicide mission then i think he would've been an asset
Still my favorite character
I would much prefer shane and andrea leave like you said becaise it would possibly change andrea to a better character, like learning how to shoot better and shane would not have lori to fight over. wish that happened because i liked shane and andrea in season 2.
Great character, wish he was still around.
Shane isn't a bad guy, he just made a bad split decision when killing Otis. It was at that moment he turned evil
Matty_S Gaming I totally agree! Carl, Shane and Otis would've died if he hadn't left Otis for bait.
Killing Rick was a dumbass decision too
Matty_S Gaming Shane wasn't capable of being leader because of his decision making. He didn't like the way Rick was taking over because he thought his actions would put the group at risk with Walkers. When in reality it was Shane himself who put the group in danger and not of listened to anybody
aquateen77723 well 2/3 of those people are
Matty_S Gaming. he was evil when he decided to fuck is best friends wife. perd
I loved Shane and miss his character.
Loved Shane. Wish he was still around.
I love him! The first episode, when he stole Ricks ketchup from his hamberger, I knew they were for warning us about his character. I thought it built a lot of color to the show. bad or good, a lot of interest was added by him .
Loved Shane. My favorite character
I would have loved to see Shane as leader of a diff. group (like he got separated from Survivors on Season 2) and he meets up with Rick and Survivors for All Out War
Shane would've been awesome in all out war. But if he was in the line up i think he would've been picked to die because I can't see Shane getting on his knees when simon told them too and he would've had the same look on his face that Abraham did and that's what would've gotten him chosen.
Sydni Taylor couldn't have said it better myself. He definitely would have gotten Lucilled.
Shane was a good guy really now the only bad thing is that he turned against Rick,but another thing is that they were like 2 leaders and 2 leaders for 1 group was not good thats a reason why they killed Shane,and the problem with Lory...he losed his family to save Lory because he loved her,thats why he was crazy and when he find out Lory is pregnant he got even more crazy caz he knew its his child and the parental instinct comes out and bla bbla bla ...gets even crazy.
I liked Shane because he was a go getter and he did make a lot of sense where I felt Rick was too soft. However, I think if he was alive, Rick would be dead and there would be a completely different group dynamic going on -- much less compassionate and handling situations with brute force. Glenn would have left, Daryl would have left, they would have never met Abraham and Co. and made their way to D.C. and eventually settling in at Alexandria. So even though I liked Shane, I'm glad he went the way he did.
I love Shane! He made season 2 awesome. Without him they would be just wandering around a farm for 16 episodes. Oh wait that happened anyway..ha. Season 2 is one of my favs because of Jon Bernthal!
i missed him as soon as he was dead what a waste, he would have been handy against negan
Only problem with saying Shane was trying to help the group survive is that he really wasn't. Everyone else was 'expendable' except Lori, Carl & himself. He would have sacrificed every single one of them to keep that group alive.
He wasn't wrong about "fighting for it!"; I detested what he did to Otis but I did understand it; He was a stereotypical Alpha male so the rape did not surprise; I thought he could have found a more 'humane' way to show Hershel what he was protecting (one unrelated walker, a deliberate set-up) and I got that he was torn between his love for his PARTNER (in cop speak that is VERY important) and his emotional love for Lori... but he was only concerned with himself, Lori & Carl. That would have ultimately endangered them... even Daryl knew you needed a group to survive. Lori got on my last nerve too but Shane was a grown man and she was the wife of his friend, he could have backed off.
Shane is the GOAT 🏆
I think Shane was ahead of his time for TWD.
I love him
They should've brought back Shane for a hallucination with rick where Shane is like you gonna let him push you around him being negan and Shane should start to motivate rick a little bit
The PT Channel yessss I would've loved that
That would have been great. Like Shane saying, "You're soft Rick. Your boy is weak."
I think he was wise about the world. The only thing that bothered me was him trying to kill Rick. I think him leaving and running into Michonne instead of Andrea, only because Michonne and Shane would have been awesome against both the governer and Negan! However, the power struggle against Shane and Rick would have imploded.
Shane was an adapter. If you watch Rick in season 5, he's all Shane. He even wears the same shirt Shane had on during the farm. The dirty brown t-shirt. Rick encompasses all the people he killed. So technically, Shane is alive and well...in Rick.
hated him while he was still alive... but seeing how Rick sort of morphed into him, i regret my hatred toward him :p
Love Shane
love best good/bad guy ever
He clearly went way too soon in the show and they probably know that now. If they knew back then how big the show was to become I feel he would of been around much longer
the best, he was great in wolf of wall street
I still hate him, but you make a good case - he WAS a great character from a story-telling perspective. All the 'what-if's you mentioned are precisely WHY he was such a great plot device. I would've loved to see him and Negan on screen together...talk about fireworks!!!!! *insert Eugene's humming here.... lol!!
I like that Shane takes no shit off anyone and if you hurt the people he cares about he will kill you but I don't think he could keep a level head like Rick has in certain situations i think he would get people killed if he was still alive
In the beginning Shane seemed like a hero almost. But then he drew his gun on Rick and Dale caught him and that was it for me. I hated him after that.
Hey PT I love ur vids bro and I love Shane lol he was such a kl character , I did a Daryl Dixon music video that's doing well, could u check it out mate and leave feedback ? Thanks and keep up the great work :)
InTheNickOfTime nice will check out
I'm both here.
Liked Shane until they messed up his character by having him becoming a killer of his friend and a stalker. Didn't like Laurie either. Before that I still liked him even though he was over stepping.
I Love Shane I Am Still Sad That He Died But I Realised That It Had To Happen To Progress The Story
i think he should've left and its revealed in season 5 he is now residing in alexandria and the reunion with him and rick mirrors the one in 1x03
I loved Shane mainly because no matter what he tried protecting laurie. I think after some time everyone started making stupid decisions. I mean come on its Darwinism now. I feel like some characters would have been alive or the antagonists would have died a bit earlier.
Love him. If he were still around the Governor would have never made it to season 4, let alone kill Hershel.
Neither for me, what he did to Odis was true evil.
6:14 That would have been GHHREAT
Hated him gradually. If he could let go of Rick wife he would not have gone off the deep end.
Best or peep
tyresse was a good character
Do you think their will ever be Richonne baby
Ryno Productions thats the dumbest idea ive ever heard
Possibly at the end of the series
Shane wan't the right things for the Group but the way that he made it was wrong
Hate this guy. I do like that he was good friends with carl, I also like that he beat Ed's face in when Ed hit Caryl
I just rewatched all the last seasons of the walking Dead( 1-7.) I standby my feelings towards shane. Which I hate Him and he was a narcissist, egotistical douchebag. You could tell that from the very start that Shane feelings/Obsession for his friends wife, even before the apocalypse. You can just tell by the way he looked at Rick's wife and his son. Yes He and Rick had been bestfriends their whole lives, But you could just tell with his character's Demeanor. And no this is not a good guy. I truly believe that Shane and Lori started having an affair while Rick was in a coma, if you go back to that episode of Shane and Rick in the hospital. You can clearly see Rick's heart moniter shows he had a strong heart beat and pulse. So I don't believe Shane thought rick was dead, I truly believe When this happened he purposely left Rick for dead. So he could take his place in Carl and Lori's lives. And No He wasn't a good leader either. He tried to force his way of thinking on to the others in his group. He showed no concern, care for the well being of the people under his leadership with expectations of Lori, Carl and Himself. Everyone Else is expendable to him including the other children, The fact he was more then willingly to let his people die in the city with no remorse and was nonchalant about it. That how little he cares for well being of everyone else. Back the Cdc I'm sorry But don't excuse any kind of sexual assault, or attempted rape. My mother always told me that a drunk man tells no lies. The moment he attacked Lori and attempted to rape her. I'm not gonna over look that just because he was drunk and say he's not a bad guy because he is. The First time he was in the Woods with Rick alone, He had his locked and loaded point right at rick. If Dale haden been there than he would have shot and killed Rick( Yes Rick is his Bestfriend, his partner and he loved rick. But his Obsession with Lori was that much more greater.) Shane said" himself all he cares about his Lori, Carl and Himself". He prove this when he was willing to Sacrifice Otis just to save himself and He lied about it. That tells you right how many more innocent people would die because of him? How many more innocent people would he be willing to Sacrifice for his own selfish gaine? Also he's tried on numerous occasions to get Rick eaten by Walker. Bascly threatened Dale. When Dale discovered the truth about what really happened to Otis. What he did at Hershel' s farm( yes he had a barn full of walker, But it was still his land and Shane didn't need to handle things that way. Causing of Emotional pain on to Hershel, His and family.) He was more than willing to leave Sophia to fend for herself at the hands of walkers. He set the Trap by killing Randall and making up that false story to lure Rick deep into the woods to kill, Dale Knew of this and tried to hide Shane's weapons from him. Shane was real a threat, a hothead and real Danger to the lives of everyone in the group. Plus he would have left everyone to die, or gotten the group in worser life, or Death situations. And more and more people would have died. It wouldn't have mattered rather Lori died or not. The Fact that her Baby could possibly be Shane's or Rick's. Would have made the conflict between him and Rick worse. Shane trying to kill Rick in order to what he wanted. Which is Rick's wife and to replace him as Carl's father, now the baby. Yes I hated Shane by time season 2 rolled around.
Love him, way better leader than Rick
Spencer Loudog but trying to kill Rick was a pretty silly and unnecessary thing to attempt.
I'VE SAID THIS BEFORE, IF SHANE WAS STILL ALIVE THE WHOLE GROUP WOULD BE DEAD WITH DEALING WITH NEGAN
Hey
Shane got hate because he was with Lori and he got her pregnant really shane
6th like and 7th Comment
LORI WAS THE WORST
Andrea was also shit , the show is so much better now
Lets be honest Shane wouldn't of lasted 5 mins with Negan and Saviors around. He was such an interesting character in Season 1 but his stupid decision making is what let him down as a capable leader. Rick had no choice but to kill him because he was a threat but had he still been alive definitely would of made a bigger impact for the show
1st comment
second
First
hey