I'm actually opposite to you. I really rate Young as a key defender. Always impressed with his one on one contests backing up Weitering in the Nlues defence. Strong mark, reads it well. If we're looking to shore up the defence, id be happy with Young. I don't rate Kennedy at all and see him as a list clogger. He'll be keeping Finn & Allan out of the team and possibly seeking opportunities elsewhere the following year.
There is a player from port Adelaide he’s young forward he’s name is ollie lord he made his debut last year he 22 he played 19 games and kicked 22 goals I reckon we should get him he’s from Victoria also if we do get rid of Joe Richard’s we can do a swap of him
The number one priority is midfield depth. Guys with footy smarts, composure and competitiveness. We’re two mids short. We have the finishers like Daicos, DeGoey and Pendles. We need a bull and a speedy two way runner. Reckon go hard for Perryman, get Kennedy for a 3rd round pick and the Garcia from the Dogs as another option. Plays the Libba role and finds the ball.
If collingwood trade for these players whats the go with fin macrae. Do they persist with him because if other players come in he will just spend the season in the seconds again..
Im all in on both, Kennedy in the middle suits us, and Lewis Young has been solid in the second half of the year, Young is better than Frampton and or Dean
If we want a long term replacement for Mitchell other than Ben Hobbs, Flynn Gentile from Coburg is worth a look, he’s the favourite to win the FRM Medal And for the key forward, Hudson Garoni is the guy you’d want, be a good CHF, strong, accurate kick, smart in contests, like Jesse Hogan and JJ Kennedy
Kennedy would be worth it. Plays with a lot of heart. Lewis Young has also been good in defence but I agree that he isn't worth trading picks for. I'm surprised that the Blues want to trade both these guys. We'll find out why soon enough.
Lewis Young absolute shit kicker Kennedy is slow we need speed the game is changing to a run and gun game if the club picks up Young I will be fkn peaking.
Jack mcrea just nominated St kilda I think we have to forget about all these shit kickers and focus on our list we are a premiership list our boys just need to find their testicles again.
Hey champs..I think that if Kreugs goes to another club, we should definitely make a play for Kennedy to help Nick out either in the midfield or half back.
Between you and Swoop, l'm just wondering who else you have coming to Collingwood? So far those mentioned and talked about include Petracca, Smith, Barrass, Stringer, Houston, Wardlaw, Cerra, McGovern, Lynch, Peatling, Lukosius, Membery, Kennedy, Grainger-Barrass, etc, etc, etc. At some stage all these players have been mentioned plus a few others and the chances of getting any of them seem fairly remote. Just a 'Click Baiter' perhaps?
At certain points, the pies were interested in most of those players, and eventually those players have either recommitted to their current club, or committed elsewhere. I will always talk about available players for the pies, I feel it’s a way to educate our community on what these players are about. If you don’t like it mate, you don’t have to watch… I’m not holding my breath for Mr.Grant King to watch my videos 😂😂
@@PiesFooty Oh but l will, just to see you to continue to make a fool of yourself, but breathe easy, wouldn't want to see you going blue in the face because that'd most probably make you a Carlton supporter!!!
What are you talking about calling Allen not a Big Bodied mid. I went to the last HW game and he looked big to me and with another Pre Season he will be fine. Wouldn’t give more than a 3rd round pick for Kennedy
I said he can do some work inside, but to extend my point, he is still very slender and won’t be a true inside mid for at least another season or two. Until then, he will be wing/mid/half forward
Don’t think we should waste picks on these guys. Let’s get players from the pool of guys that don’t require picks and maybe see what 3way trades can get us. Don’t think we have to roll the dice on guys that don’t make us a better team/list . We only really need an inside midfielder and tall defender our forward line is top notch when everyone is available. Rather give Krueger and AJ and reef a real go before we look at recycled hacks
As a Blues supporter, please take Young, he is not even a good VFL player, couldn't make it at the Dogs and ended up at Carlton. The guy is totally rubbish.
@@PiesFooty 25yr 202cm, he's like Roughead, ruckman size but mobile enough for defence. The 200cm+ usually take a little longer to mature and his last game 2 weeks ago he got 16 disposals 9 marks in a losing final, Frampton isn't doing that anytime soon. I reckon Carlton are crazy getting a broken down Haynes in to replace a promising kid about to enter his prime.
And yet again, we have another 10 minute video talking about a player, and absolutely no vision of the player. Only ten minutes of the RUclipsr front and centre for the entire video. How about adding some footage of the players you are talking about?
Ed Allen 194cm and on the way to mid 90's kgs, he's a frickin monster
He will be, just not in the immediate future
@@PiesFooty No we got a glimpse in the last game, another pre season and he's terrorizing Tokyo
@@steve8510definitely looked very good against Melbourne.
@@PiesFooty Just admit your wrong
@@peternut358 1 game sample size come on guys be real
I think Peter Wright is another player that should get looked at, I am surprised he hasn’t been talked about.
I’m not a big fan of the idea… he has had one good season, and wouldn’t come cheap!
I think Wright is on a stupid contract
Probably cause he’s on huge money lol
I'm actually opposite to you. I really rate Young as a key defender. Always impressed with his one on one contests backing up Weitering in the Nlues defence. Strong mark, reads it well. If we're looking to shore up the defence, id be happy with Young. I don't rate Kennedy at all and see him as a list clogger. He'll be keeping Finn & Allan out of the team and possibly seeking opportunities elsewhere the following year.
There is a player from port Adelaide he’s young forward he’s name is ollie lord he made his debut last year he 22 he played 19 games and kicked 22 goals I reckon we should get him he’s from Victoria also if we do get rid of Joe Richard’s we can do a swap of him
I totally agree with Ollie , he is a good player
YES , get ollie Lord , for sure
The number one priority is midfield depth. Guys with footy smarts, composure and competitiveness.
We’re two mids short. We have the finishers like Daicos, DeGoey and Pendles. We need a bull and a speedy two way runner. Reckon go hard for Perryman, get Kennedy for a 3rd round pick and the Garcia from the Dogs as another option. Plays the Libba role and finds the ball.
Word is we are pushing hard for Perryman. But what is he worth in your eyes? Both trade and salary wise
you cant tell a player to look around and expext a second rounder. That would be ridiculous
Yeah it is an interesting one. I'd still be surprised if Kennedy goes for a 3rd rounder...
Frampton? I thought he'd been delisted? No.....? End of 25 then
6 3ft Inside bull, perfect to replace Mitchell. Allows Nick and Ed Allen to be the outside players.
Don’t mind it mate!
If collingwood trade for these players whats the go with fin macrae. Do they persist with him because if other players come in he will just spend the season in the seconds again..
Screw new players, we need to give the young players a PROPER go, not 1 or 2 games then being dropped. We are good enough.
Im all in on both, Kennedy in the middle suits us, and Lewis Young has been solid in the second half of the year, Young is better than Frampton and or Dean
They’ll be lucky to get a late 3rd rounder imo for Kennedy
If we want a long term replacement for Mitchell other than Ben Hobbs, Flynn Gentile from Coburg is worth a look, he’s the favourite to win the FRM Medal
And for the key forward, Hudson Garoni is the guy you’d want, be a good CHF, strong, accurate kick, smart in contests, like Jesse Hogan and JJ Kennedy
The fothergill round medal was won last night by a Richmond player lol.
Collingwood could be cooked in 2025. Dont think we can avoid a full on rebuild.
We were too old last year too, and Geelong is way too old right?
Yeah, what about Geelong mr.Madison?
@@steve8510 Geelong is an anomaly
@@MadisonTalarico BWAHAHAHAHAAAAA and so inconvenient for your argument 🤣
@@steve8510 I don't have an argument just my opinion
Tom mitchell has had injuries and was great in 2023 we don't need a replacement
Kennedy would be worth it. Plays with a lot of heart. Lewis Young has also been good in defence but I agree that he isn't worth trading picks for. I'm surprised that the Blues want to trade both these guys. We'll find out why soon enough.
Yeah massive statement made by the Blues
Lewis Young absolute shit kicker Kennedy is slow we need speed the game is changing to a run and gun game if the club picks up Young I will be fkn peaking.
Jack mcrea just nominated St kilda I think we have to forget about all these shit kickers and focus on our list we are a premiership list our boys just need to find their testicles again.
Hey champs..I think that if Kreugs goes to another club, we should definitely make a play for Kennedy to help Nick out either in the midfield or half back.
Matt Kernnedy yes and Perryman from GWS. Both can be gotten cheaply and can play mid, back of forward
Yes.
Love the content, and your right, other than the Noble trade we’re in top up market,
Favourite channel
Go Pies
Between you and Swoop, l'm just wondering who else you have coming to Collingwood? So far those mentioned and talked about include Petracca, Smith, Barrass, Stringer, Houston, Wardlaw, Cerra, McGovern, Lynch, Peatling, Lukosius, Membery, Kennedy, Grainger-Barrass, etc, etc, etc. At some stage all these players have been mentioned plus a few others and the chances of getting any of them seem fairly remote. Just a 'Click Baiter' perhaps?
At certain points, the pies were interested in most of those players, and eventually those players have either recommitted to their current club, or committed elsewhere. I will always talk about available players for the pies, I feel it’s a way to educate our community on what these players are about. If you don’t like it mate, you don’t have to watch… I’m not holding my breath for Mr.Grant King to watch my videos 😂😂
@@PiesFooty Oh but l will, just to see you to continue to make a fool of yourself, but breathe easy, wouldn't want to see you going blue in the face because that'd most probably make you a Carlton supporter!!!
Hi, is the Kahoot happening
What are you talking about calling Allen not a Big Bodied mid. I went to the last HW game and he looked big to me and with another Pre Season he will be fine. Wouldn’t give more than a 3rd round pick for Kennedy
I said he can do some work inside, but to extend my point, he is still very slender and won’t be a true inside mid for at least another season or two. Until then, he will be wing/mid/half forward
Agreed. Blokes gonna be playing inside next season, or should be anyway.
yes for Kennedy no for Young. Agree re Marchbank
Interesting thanks
Anytime mindofown!
Please No No No No.
Collingwood Ranks number 1 team for clangers.
Kennedy Ranks number 1, for the worst inside 50 kick.
It's a disaster if we get him
I understand that, however, we wouldn’t be using him for his kicking inside 50.
Yes.....no brainer
Even Lewis Young?
@@PiesFooty yep him too thanks....as a priority.....check out his highlights as a bulldog youngster.. he would play chb for us straight up
Don’t think we should waste picks on these guys. Let’s get players from the pool of guys that don’t require picks and maybe see what 3way trades can get us. Don’t think we have to roll the dice on guys that don’t make us a better team/list . We only really need an inside midfielder and tall defender our forward line is top notch when everyone is available. Rather give Krueger and AJ and reef a real go before we look at recycled hacks
Anth look at steve8510 comment.
I think Allan is abig body mid
He is tall, but hasn’t filled out yet. Will not be a bull inside mid just yet
As a Blues supporter, please take Young, he is not even a good VFL player, couldn't make it at the Dogs and ended up at Carlton. The guy is totally rubbish.
why do people keep talking about krueger besides delisting, bloke is a massive potato
Young yes, Kennedy solid but slow.
Wow, yes to Young? Thoughts behind that idea?
@@PiesFooty 25yr 202cm, he's like Roughead, ruckman size but mobile enough for defence. The 200cm+ usually take a little longer to mature and his last game 2 weeks ago he got 16 disposals 9 marks in a losing final, Frampton isn't doing that anytime soon. I reckon Carlton are crazy getting a broken down Haynes in to replace a promising kid about to enter his prime.
You mrntioned membrey ......again!!!! Stop it please
And yet again, we have another 10 minute video talking about a player, and absolutely no vision of the player. Only ten minutes of the RUclipsr front and centre for the entire video.
How about adding some footage of the players you are talking about?
Noted mate, but no need to be passive aggressive about it. You sound like a little girl who didn’t get her toy in her cheeseburger meal at Maccas 😂😂
Collingwood sux
No
Thoughts on why not Kennedy?
@@PiesFootyLewis Young is another Billy Frampton and Kennedy is too slow and is a mediocre kick
@@TheLaughingMagpieHe’s better than Frampton
@@PiesFooty Kennedy doesnt need to be quick, just needs to do the mitchell role