So true. As any normal anime fan would, I watched a frame by frame version of eva, slowed, fourteen times. I hated this specific problem so much that I burned down my neighbors house and fled to Guam.
@@lavalodong2473 could have been a simple mistake? i've watched the movie like 5 times and never noticed it and it looks like it's only missing a frame or two lol
I dont see why everyone's at war with this guy. It's a wierd jump between the two frames for sure, and it's not like he's trashing the movie over it. He's just making a valid observation.
But they should, because it's not just about the struggles of depression, and the importance of overcoming self-doubt, it's also a personal statement about the Mecha genre itself. HEY ASUKA!
Me: expects a deep analysis on Asuka's demeanor and nonverbal communication that has a lasting impact on her character and the movie as a whole. Video: hEaD teLePoRTs lmao
@@corneliusbinglebottom4749 this was during the end of the show when they were under major constraints. This was also before stuff like photoshop made it so that editing images could be done quickly.
They saw three or four comments saying its how animation works and the readers didnt know that but they agreed because its what the three or four people said
An animator must have miscalculated the positions of the head in time and tried to make the movement when it was too late, so that overall movement became rough. Seems like a production mistake, and it blends in nicely. It’s fine imho
@@RedDragon_093_dn8 it’s not a budget problem, when you watch the rest of the movie, considering this is right before the Third Impact scene Prolly just a frame error
This was back in the era of hand-drawn animation. CGI use was limited to only specific parts of the movie (namely all the souls during Third Impact). You see little errors like this in any hand-drawn animation.
How is that an error? Heads move, what's wrong with that? Would it be better than TV anime where it's a still frame with only the character mouth moving?
I noticed this too but it doesn't bother me. They just needed another in between frame to make the movement consistent and smooth. It's really difficult to animate dynamic shots like this one and regardless of that small jerky movement this scene is beautifully drawn and beautifully animated.
Considering the overall quality, this is inline with what’s to be expected. You can see the way Asuka moves around, her movement is very expressive and even complex. This is not the only one in the series as well. Evangelion the TV series used a lot of still frame, but then goes full blast for a few scene. That’s why the fight scenes are so well done, and some scenes are much more dramatic than others. The infamous elevator scene for example, had an extremely long still frame, followed by pretty expressive movement on Asuka’s to portray her frustration. It is very very well done, and in my opinion few studios or director was able to match its creativity and qualify for a while. It’s very hard to tell someone how great animation look and feel if they have never done any themselves, but I think shows like Evangelion who did it so well, people just like it without really realising how brilliant it was done. It’s the same case with Miyazaki’s works. His strength from visuals don’t come just from very beautifully designed character’s model, but mostly from the brilliant way things move. The spider legs movement from most of his movies were extremely satisfying. Spirited away dragon’s body who slither around like a snake with a dog’s jaw is so mesmerising to see. You don’t see that level of movement much anymore because it takes some special attention to achieve that. Even in 3D, you still have to animate the creature. Ask a 3D animator how they feel about those creatures movement, they’ll tell you how great that looked. That’s why 90s and early 2000s were magical, the level of experiment studios were willing to do was very impressive. Too bad today in small margin world, they had to squeeze everything out of the animators.
@@adityasaharkar9344 Yea it was more the direction, then the actual animation itself. Naruto Shippuden was pretty serious in nature, and the stakes in that fight were super serious. So the looney toon like moments were really detrimental to that fight.
It's a head tilt. She's tilting her head forward. It was done with a purpose. And if what bothers you about this is it being a one frame transition then you likely have never watched anime before or cartoons for that matter
at first I was on the side of the comment section, but after rewatching it started to bug me, then annoy me, then completely irritate me. I don't dislike this video for being nitpicky, but because it made me notice how fucking annoying half of asuka's head appearing out of nowhere is
everyone mentioned the obvious already but notice how complicated of a shot this is with the perspectives and the character moving deeper into the shot. shots like these are really complex to draw so it makes perfect sense little things like this would happen.
“I don’t want fancy things Nor fancy shmancy things Not even fancy shmancy wancy things I don’t even want fancy shmancy take-a-trip-to-francey things. What I want is wasting your time and mine.” - Norm Macdonald
I'm so happy with the dislike ratio. It's just comforting to know that I'm not alone in seeing the logic of a casual expression change in earlier animation. Teleport? Ya mean tasteful facial expressions changing by world renown artists at their peak?
No I see what he was talking about now, it looks awkward, it probably could've had some more inbetween frames. This whole movie is well animated though, but I'm not gonna sit here and act like it doesn't move weird either.
I finished rewatching ‘Evangelion’ and ‘The End of Evangelion’ some days ago and when I arrived to this part, I remembered you and I clearly saw it. Xd
This has to be satire, come on. "That one moment when you put the water on the gas and after a little while something happens with the water and it bugs me" "Bruh, water BOILS"
1:07 If you look in the bottom left corner you’ll notice Shinji’s hand seems to teleport as well, first it’s just hovering by the wall then it’s magically gripping it.
@@harms123 he's explaining the oddity of its movement not how it works. The frames weren't placed well which made it look like Shinji teleported instead of walked
The funniest part is that people are taking this seriously and some of them are actually like ''you're right it is a little off!'' as if you couldn't do this with nearly any scene in any animated series.
She tilted her head more forward? So what? Edit: Oh well rewatching from the start again the transition isn't smooth at all yeah. I never noticed it though.
The key animation for this cut appeared in the groundwork of eva movie 2 book so I can offer some explanation. Why this happens is simply, well, the key animator didn't draw how her head turn would work and just left it to the inbetweeners, its also why the length and placement of her neck kept on changing, because inbetweeners were simply interpolating between the keyframes and not thinking her head as a 3d object, usually doing this kind of thing is somewhat standard in anime since inbetweens tend to smooth inconsistencies out a little, but in this case it was a bit too noticeable to not be jarring. it also seems like a silly mistake to leave in given that its very easy to fix by simply by retaking 1-2 frames, but I guess they didn't have time and prioritized other scenes instead. It's a glass haft full haft empty situation since it wasn't bad enough to warrant doing it again but not good enough to escape heavy scrutiny.
I’ve seen animation errors 10x more obvious than this on other things that didn’t bother anyone else. No matter how hard I tried I didn’t notice it until you very clearly pointed it out. I think you were the only person who noticed it bro.
It's not the best transition from one key frame to the other but it's still just her bring her head down exposing more a more amount of hear And putting a line between her neck and head But the rest of the movement is great I think they could've approached it better by rotoscoping an actors movements Then this entire movement would feel nore natural
I mean yeah I saw it the first time too, I also thought it was weird, but then i thought "that's just an animation trick they use for smoothing it out" it's just an animation trick.
When i saw the slow mo I didn’t really get what was wrong because I’ve seen things with barley any moving frames that look amazing but when I went back to see the original, I kinda realized the head actually teleport.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Use me as a dislike button
You noble creature
Mans a one man army against his comment section.
Based
I will use you,
I’m liking this comment not for the use of disliking the video, I’m liking this comment because it’s creative.
So out of that whole movie, THIS is what bugged you? 😭🤣
LMAO
its a joke
He himself is a joke?
@@kamilpalka7837 where's the funny
@@FumetsuNoAnataE right there, just look up, just because YOU didnt laugh doesnt mean it isnt funny
So true. As any normal anime fan would, I watched a frame by frame version of eva, slowed, fourteen times. I hated this specific problem so much that I burned down my neighbors house and fled to Guam.
can we get this to 1k likes
@@JettPistol I'm pretty sure he's being sarcastic lol imagine not knowing how animation works
@@rocky8454 of course he is
Now this is shitposting!
@@JettPistol ur a pretty cool guy no lie
This the type of people that complain about smear frames. It’s literally how animation works
@LordConnord Smear frames are necessary if you don't want to hand animate every single frame of someone moving.
@LordConnord smooth animation is not equal better animation
@LordConnord its just a one second scene no need to be angry about it
@LordConnord Oh yeah nobody's angry here but still no need to take this one second scene to an argument.
@LordConnord you still are arguing tho because of this :p
It's such a shame that the dislike count no longer shows.
get the extension bro
9.5k dislikes bro
9.5k dont worry
It sucks, I can't even see it on the YT Studio app, and I'm the damn creator of the video
@@JettPistol this is honestly so based. You made the video and yet you still wanna know how many people hate it
I mean, I was too worried with my Mental Breakdown than with the animation
Then get inside the fckin robot
Im fucking saying why are people so fickle about the tiniest things😂😂
Why don't yalll have drawings pfp
@@IDKWhattop66t please shut up, no one cares
@@IDKWhattop66t shut up
Now this is just Death the Kid levels of nitpicking
HAHAH RIGHT
Truly
"I hope someone got fired over that blunder!"
FACTS?????
Personally it ruined it for me, now my Eva merch is in the trash. Good riddance.
thats literally how animation works😭😭😭this is so funny
Yeah but it is weird how the quality drops then
@@lavalodong2473 could have been a simple mistake? i've watched the movie like 5 times and never noticed it and it looks like it's only missing a frame or two lol
@@distinguishingremark it is a simple mistake, i meant quality of frames because i dont think drop is the right word
Me I dent see what u was talking about but I tend to don't see that because it is a good anime
u do realize this vid is a joke
I dont see why everyone's at war with this guy. It's a wierd jump between the two frames for sure, and it's not like he's trashing the movie over it.
He's just making a valid observation.
I liked the part where she said “Shinji, it’s you. You are the Neon Genesis Evangelion”
Thanks, I haven't slept yet and it's already 5 AM now and with your joke, I'll probably stay up until tomorrow.
It's evangelin' time
But they should, because it's not just about the struggles of depression, and the importance of overcoming self-doubt, it's also a personal statement about the Mecha genre itself. HEY ASUKA!
They actually did this
He didn’t say that
Me: expects a deep analysis on Asuka's demeanor and nonverbal communication that has a lasting impact on her character and the movie as a whole.
Video: hEaD teLePoRTs lmao
Hahaha, same
LMAO
Dead laughing
Episode?
Imagine being so stupid you took this seriously.
Ah yes, animation being animation. How truly amazing
Bad animation.
@@corneliusbinglebottom4749 literally picturing a moving head but lacking 3 frames bruv
@@corneliusbinglebottom4749 traditional animation*
@@corneliusbinglebottom4749 bro what you want for them to animate each small motion that you won’t see
Looks fine to me. The angle of her head changes as her gaze follows Shinji from the left of the screen to the right. Not a smooth transition though.
It's a missing key frame, so what? It's totally insignificant to the overall experience. The poster of this vid is ocd ridden.
And arguably it not being smooth is better. It sells the anger she's feeling more than a smooth movement would.
@@fuadjaganjac9193 Very shoddy and low quality looking. It's a movie, you'd think they'd create enough to double check.
Tbh its true it misses 2 or 3 frames, not a big problem but still annoys me
@@corneliusbinglebottom4749 this was during the end of the show when they were under major constraints. This was also before stuff like photoshop made it so that editing images could be done quickly.
0:16 you're right, there's two aliens in the dark room and a gnome under the table
this is fucking hilarious I don't know why people are getting so upset lmao
Ikr lol
They saw three or four comments saying its how animation works and the readers didnt know that but they agreed because its what the three or four people said
Or you're talking aabout the animation. Yea i didn't give a shit about it either
Obvious bait
because they cant handle it when someone doesnt like their precious evangelion
An animator must have miscalculated the positions of the head in time and tried to make the movement when it was too late, so that overall movement became rough. Seems like a production mistake, and it blends in nicely. It’s fine imho
Well the budget was at the limit so what can they do
@@RedDragon_093_dn8 bruh budget doesn't have to do with drawing a head in the right place
@@RedDragon_093_dn8 it’s not a budget problem, when you watch the rest of the movie, considering this is right before the Third Impact scene
Prolly just a frame error
Or they just missed out a frame
This was back in the era of hand-drawn animation. CGI use was limited to only specific parts of the movie (namely all the souls during Third Impact). You see little errors like this in any hand-drawn animation.
I genuinely thought this was going to be a Rick roll and I don't know why
breaking news: weeb *shoots* his friend because his friend rick rolled him
i wish this was a Rick roll
Would be way better
honestly that would have been better
@@lukyjuvl8126 yeah
I noticed it right away, but it's a simple animation error. I did not attach any importance to this, it happens.
I didn’t notice the first viewing of it. Also aren’t you supposed to be dead Yuri?
@lolmanda She has a good gaming chair, that's why she's still alive
@@safent4001 Gotcha.
It doesn’t even look like an error
How is that an error? Heads move, what's wrong with that? Would it be better than TV anime where it's a still frame with only the character mouth moving?
This is so dramatic I'm crying 😭😭😭😭 that's literally how animation works I can't
Im 9 months late, but i think they were joking
On another note 0:05 If looks could kill,
this is my favorite frame in the whole movie if I were Shinji I would have started running a mile lol
if looks could kill BABY I’M THE FASHION DEMON
Im the fashion demon
this the look of she’s done with his bullshit
i feel like if you have to zoom and put it in slow motion to notice a mistake, it doesn’t matter as much as you think it does
you're telling me distance is covered between frames?
Congratulations! You discovered how Animation works!
It should be considered a crime to waste people time like this
You know, by then end I thought you were being a bit ridiculous. But now I cannot unsee it when watching the clip again.
I noticed this too but it doesn't bother me. They just needed another in between frame to make the movement consistent and smooth. It's really difficult to animate dynamic shots like this one and regardless of that small jerky movement this scene is beautifully drawn and beautifully animated.
Considering the overall quality, this is inline with what’s to be expected. You can see the way Asuka moves around, her movement is very expressive and even complex. This is not the only one in the series as well. Evangelion the TV series used a lot of still frame, but then goes full blast for a few scene. That’s why the fight scenes are so well done, and some scenes are much more dramatic than others. The infamous elevator scene for example, had an extremely long still frame, followed by pretty expressive movement on Asuka’s to portray her frustration. It is very very well done, and in my opinion few studios or director was able to match its creativity and qualify for a while. It’s very hard to tell someone how great animation look and feel if they have never done any themselves, but I think shows like Evangelion who did it so well, people just like it without really realising how brilliant it was done. It’s the same case with Miyazaki’s works. His strength from visuals don’t come just from very beautifully designed character’s model, but mostly from the brilliant way things move. The spider legs movement from most of his movies were extremely satisfying. Spirited away dragon’s body who slither around like a snake with a dog’s jaw is so mesmerising to see. You don’t see that level of movement much anymore because it takes some special attention to achieve that. Even in 3D, you still have to animate the creature. Ask a 3D animator how they feel about those creatures movement, they’ll tell you how great that looked. That’s why 90s and early 2000s were magical, the level of experiment studios were willing to do was very impressive. Too bad today in small margin world, they had to squeeze everything out of the animators.
"That one scene in The End of Evangelion that has always bugged me"
*Plays the entire movie*
Now i can only focus on Asuka's head and nothing else whenever i am seeing this scene. Great
Adulation loathes Shinji because he's a gamma and won't give her the attitude adjustment that she needs.
"There are no accidents"
Oogway
~ master oogway
God oogway
-master accident
yep-
That’s called animation lol
But if you watch it at the normal speed, it can be noticed a lot, too.
@@Japonesbello So?
@@d.c.741, so it must be an error.
@@Japonesbello it’s not
@@isaackim3385 yes it is? Asuka turning her head to Shinji has a missing frame of animation
As a guy that had witnesses naruto's "my pain is far greater than yours" and 7DS meliodas vs escanor:
*pathetic*
@@adityasaharkar9344 Yea it was more the direction, then the actual animation itself. Naruto Shippuden was pretty serious in nature, and the stakes in that fight were super serious. So the looney toon like moments were really detrimental to that fight.
@@adityasaharkar9344 the animation was either overly smooth or choppy af. It felt wierd, still it was good. That pain frame was to provide fluidity
Girl rlly pissed off till her hairs bops
It's a head tilt. She's tilting her head forward. It was done with a purpose. And if what bothers you about this is it being a one frame transition then you likely have never watched anime before or cartoons for that matter
My time was wasted and I'm disappointed, yet somehow struggling to breath from laughter at this. explain
Alternate title: Asuka tilts her head 😂😂😂
Yeah🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
There wasn't an in between frame when the head changed expressions so it looks like it skipped and wasn't smooth like the previous animation
damn its actually pretty noticeable after the fact. liked!
this is like that one episode of spongebob where he freaks out after finding one tiny stain on mr. krabs’ first dollar
Bro i legit cant unsee it wth
Ah yes the 180th law of animation, heads must not move up or down between frames.
at first I was on the side of the comment section, but after rewatching it started to bug me, then annoy me, then completely irritate me.
I don't dislike this video for being nitpicky, but because it made me notice how fucking annoying half of asuka's head appearing out of nowhere is
its called "looking downwards slightly". Don't know if you've ever heard of it
Relax this was probably animated on a Friday afternoon
....... no, they're right. now that it's pointed out, it *does* look pretty strange.
Im convinced this whole video was made just for the last 2 seconds of the vid
"Skibidi Sigma discovers Ohio Rizz in Fannum Framerate animation. Gonk secret jelqing technique." 😢
I was so confused of that was happening and then read the comments xD
It's just animation?
ikr
😭😭😭😭💀🤦♂️
It's all just within Shinji's imagination, nothing to worry about.
I mean, better worry something else...
That's an interpretation
everyone mentioned the obvious already but notice how complicated of a shot this is with the perspectives and the character moving deeper into the shot. shots like these are really complex to draw so it makes perfect sense little things like this would happen.
“I don’t want fancy things
Nor fancy shmancy things
Not even fancy shmancy wancy things
I don’t even want fancy shmancy take-a-trip-to-francey things.
What I want is wasting your time and mine.”
- Norm Macdonald
I'm so happy with the dislike ratio. It's just comforting to know that I'm not alone in seeing the logic of a casual expression change in earlier animation. Teleport? Ya mean tasteful facial expressions changing by world renown artists at their peak?
And now the dislikes are gone, goooood job RUclips you're a lifesaver
Yeah it kinda feels teleport,if the animator use 1 frame more it would be more natural
No I see what he was talking about now, it looks awkward, it probably could've had some more inbetween frames. This whole movie is well animated though, but I'm not gonna sit here and act like it doesn't move weird either.
Animation is hard, especially when constructing parts of the body as 3d objects in 2d space. Accidents happen.
She broke her own neck before Shinji could 😂
Local man discovers animation
I can't believe you have the same voting power as me
plato was right
I finished rewatching ‘Evangelion’ and ‘The End of Evangelion’ some days ago and when I arrived to this part, I remembered you and I clearly saw it. Xd
This has to be satire, come on. "That one moment when you put the water on the gas and after a little while something happens with the water and it bugs me"
"Bruh, water BOILS"
1:07 If you look in the bottom left corner you’ll notice Shinji’s hand seems to teleport as well, first it’s just hovering by the wall then it’s magically gripping it.
Yes but that's going frame by frame. If you don't look at it frame by frame it looks natural
Asuka's head snaps into frame
that's how animations work what are you on about
@@harms123 he's explaining the oddity of its movement not how it works. The frames weren't placed well which made it look like Shinji teleported instead of walked
I like to think this is a shitpost made to piss off random people and im here for it
I thought it was going to be something, but that's actually normal.
Praying this doesn't get taken down, I know mine did.
The funniest part is that people are taking this seriously and some of them are actually like ''you're right it is a little off!'' as if you couldn't do this with nearly any scene in any animated series.
Criticisms aside this made me realize how much effort this must’ve taken to animate.
discovers the existence of frames:
'what is this strange device?'
She tilted her head more forward? So what?
Edit: Oh well rewatching from the start again the transition isn't smooth at all yeah. I never noticed it though.
This is so damn mind-blowing I can’t believe I missed this important detail
zz
I was too busy thinking how good this scene is to notice that lol
lmao is a frozen frame they do this in anime all the times,but not every single time they do it easy to notice
I clicked on this video, very curious, expected something with a deep meaning. Still, somehow I'm not disappointed.
I was too distracted by the mental breakdown to notice that lmao
this feels so much longer than a minute and a half.
I cant unsee it now
I can't unsee this thank you
Bro give me my minute and a half back!
i was worried.
then i just wheezed really fucking hard.
I just wasted 1:29 minutes of my life on this.. Animes abound with little blips like this. They’re on a budget after all.
Wow! Mindblowing! Next they’ll tell us those aren’t two actual giant mech pilots, one of which holds the fate of the world in his hands…
Lol, the description, very based
Jesus , I was expecting some sort of Mandela Catalogue conspiracy video thing about her facial expressions hidden in the animation 🤣🤣
The key animation for this cut appeared in the groundwork of eva movie 2 book so I can offer some explanation. Why this happens is simply, well, the key animator didn't draw how her head turn would work and just left it to the inbetweeners, its also why the length and placement of her neck kept on changing, because inbetweeners were simply interpolating between the keyframes and not thinking her head as a 3d object, usually doing this kind of thing is somewhat standard in anime since inbetweens tend to smooth inconsistencies out a little, but in this case it was a bit too noticeable to not be jarring. it also seems like a silly mistake to leave in given that its very easy to fix by simply by retaking 1-2 frames, but I guess they didn't have time and prioritized other scenes instead. It's a glass haft full haft empty situation since it wasn't bad enough to warrant doing it again but not good enough to escape heavy scrutiny.
Also Anno's signature appears in the layouts for this scene in particular so you know who to blame kek.
0:36 Goof: Asuka's Head Jolts Downward
Holy Shit, this kid is a future animator!
This is the one thing that bugged you?
I’ve seen animation errors 10x more obvious than this on other things that didn’t bother anyone else. No matter how hard I tried I didn’t notice it until you very clearly pointed it out. I think you were the only person who noticed it bro.
this is actually the best video on the internet
I thought there was some hidden ghost in this scene or something but thank god it was just an animation error
Every time a dollar is cut from animator's salary
It's not the best transition from one key frame to the other but it's still just her bring her head down exposing more a more amount of hear
And putting a line between her neck and head
But the rest of the movement is great I think they could've approached it better by rotoscoping an actors movements
Then this entire movement would feel nore natural
**wasted 1 and almost half minutes watching this*
Why tf are people not seeing the obvious satire 💀💀💀
Cause it’s not satire, read the description
I mean yeah I saw it the first time too, I also thought it was weird, but then i thought "that's just an animation trick they use for smoothing it out" it's just an animation trick.
When i saw the slow mo I didn’t really get what was wrong because I’ve seen things with barley any moving frames that look amazing but when I went back to see the original, I kinda realized the head actually teleport.
Earlier in the movie he whacked the tube steak over her unconscious body...but now this is the most traumatic part of this movie....
Tube steak- 😭😭🤣
my guy said tube steak
Bro they perfectly animated little stuff like shinji’s shirt moving when he stands up but this is enough to bug you?
Welcome to the fascinating and utilitarian world of animation!
That's how animation works.
That is kinda weird I guess? But it's only one "bad" frame, if the whole movie was badly animated then it would be a bigger issue