I listen to this link every once in a while and never get tired of it. Just an amazing set of songs by an awesome band and an awesome Shirley! You keep rocking girl. !!
@Motosadik There's a reason why it's playback - the entire concert was a playback TV promo gig. Each band had 10 minutes on stage to perform two songs... and a minute of turnover time (the next band were going on as Shirley got interviewed). Garbage takes 3 hours to set up a proper live show so there was no choice.
Too bad for playback but look at 5.21... I think there's a guy who's not sure of his own smell... Too bad for him... The camera lingers over him ! Funny !!
@ABSOLUTgarbage Ok got it. But it would have been better if it that fact was mentioned from the beginning (in the description or title) not to create any ambiguity.
I think she needs some matters to dream, and to make us to dream: the first song is not so much researched, looks like done in colaboration with a psy-profiler (just enough good for the psy-profiler :-) But the seconde song: for that one she has twisted her brain to draw out the suck, oh woman is good.
Hang on, she's miming.....at 3.34 you can hear her voice but she's not got her mouth near the mic...then she suddenly realises and pretends to sing. Not on, it's not fucking right.
The whole concert was mimed - it's a three-hour teens TV show special filmed on a windy beachfront. Every act had six minutes on stage to run through two of their recent hits and the stage was set up for the next act while the last act was being interviewed. It's a promo opportunity, not an artists showcase.
@@therepublicofcynica In the UK, music shows broadcast in the morning or afternoon will generally always be playback. Every single performer at this show did playback, there was no actual live set up. Garbage were on stage for all of 8 minutes. It was a pop concert for teenagers, literally Top of the Pops on a beach, it's not that deep.
@@ABSOLUTgarbage Firtsly, what other performers did isn't relevant here. Secondly, I watched Garbage and commented on Garbage, not the others (which I didn't watch). Thirdly, the time of day is irrelevent. Fourthly, the period of time they were on stage is, again, irrelevant. Fiftly, it doesn't matter if it's for teenagers or pensioners. Sixthly, whether it was on a beach, a mountain or anywhere else for that matter doesn't matter. Seventhly, I know it's not Top of the Pops, never said it was. Eighthly, I know it's not deep - again, never said it was. How many irrelevant useless, pointless comments can you make in defence of what is clearly one of your favourite bands (your moniker kinda gives it away). You have made no salient points to counter my original contention and that it essentially pretending you're playing 'live' when your not is ridiculous and she can't even mime properly. Have a nice day!
![Garbage - Only Happy When It Rains + Push It [Voodoo Music Experience 2002]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OICS6P1J620/mqdefault.jpg)
![Garbage - Only Happy When It Rains + Push It [Voodoo Music Experience 2002]](/img/tr.png)
![Garbage - Paris Parc des Princes [June 18, 2005, FULL CONCERT]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YkecXaj1MO8/mqdefault.jpg)
She still rocks and the band sounds great!!
LOL, It is playback LOL 03:07 Guitar players didn't even make the effort to plug in just a whatever cable. 03:32 poor Shirl!!!
@@chesterbalboa191 Also if you watch the drummer the hi-hat is playing double time while he just sort of casually bops it
I listen to this link every once in a while and never get tired of it. Just an amazing set of songs by an awesome band and an awesome Shirley! You keep rocking girl. !!
en France aussi on t'adore Shirley...😘
@Motosadik There's a reason why it's playback - the entire concert was a playback TV promo gig. Each band had 10 minutes on stage to perform two songs... and a minute of turnover time (the next band were going on as Shirley got interviewed). Garbage takes 3 hours to set up a proper live show so there was no choice.
❤️My Friends Garbage🖤
Waooo she is so beautiful
VERY COOL HERE BRASIL 🇧🇷 😎 👌 📻 🎼 🎶
So sorry for expletives, but I love this woman. So want to, you know. Drives my libido friggin wild.
Me too mate
such a great stage!!!
never seen them doing playback before
Shirley is worried about the guests getting sunburned, love it.
great !!!!!
@Motosadik I thought I had wrote that in the description, but it didn't seem to have saved when I uploaded! :)
it´s playback!...really her legs are so beautiful
The sexiest playback ever!!!
Que pena que tenga playback, cuando ella tiene una voz espectacular sin play back :/
essa e a graça de viver
95% of the crowd is thinking who the f*ck is garbage. 14 year olds don't appreciate good music..
que buena que esta shirley en este video lastima el playbak pero se le perdona a una banda asi
🔥🔥🔥❤️❤️❤️
Too bad for playback but look at 5.21... I think there's a guy who's not sure of his own smell... Too bad for him... The camera lingers over him ! Funny !!
🎉🎉🎉🎉
Puro playa back pero no importa a ella se le perdona todo porque de verdad ella es muy talentosa....i love garbage
@METALHasIt What is playback?
what beach is this on?
Weston Super Mare
@ABSOLUTgarbage
Ok got it. But it would have been better if it that fact was mentioned from the beginning (in the description or title) not to create any ambiguity.
At 3.33 .... am I the only one who smells playback ???
i bet radfems hate this..................
I think she needs some matters to dream, and to make us to dream: the first song is not so much researched, looks like done in colaboration with a psy-profiler (just enough good for the psy-profiler :-) But the seconde song: for that one she has twisted her brain to draw out the suck, oh woman is good.
This is totally playback. Its a shame, Garbage are a great live band too.
Yeah it’s a shame:( but they normally never use it and she sings really well. I think the festival wanted it that way idk
sad playback :(
its a TV set with a two minute artist changeover . Explained below. Nothing wrong with a playback perf if the band rock it.
She is lip singing
disappointed she was lip syncing.
They don't usually but bands are forced to these for these sort of tv things
Playyyyyyback
It does explain above why its playback
Lip Synch.....waste of bandwidth.....blah
Playback? Seriously? hahahaha
It's a two song set for a TV show.
Playback 👎🏻
It's a TV promo concert. Everybody gets 7 minutes on stage. No time to set up.
@@ABSOLUTgarbage thanks 👍🏻
Hang on, she's miming.....at 3.34 you can hear her voice but she's not got her mouth near the mic...then she suddenly realises and pretends to sing. Not on, it's not fucking right.
The whole concert was mimed - it's a three-hour teens TV show special filmed on a windy beachfront. Every act had six minutes on stage to run through two of their recent hits and the stage was set up for the next act while the last act was being interviewed. It's a promo opportunity, not an artists showcase.
@@ABSOLUTgarbage Bollocks....every 'performance' is an artists showcase...why else would they be there?
@@therepublicofcynica In the UK, music shows broadcast in the morning or afternoon will generally always be playback. Every single performer at this show did playback, there was no actual live set up. Garbage were on stage for all of 8 minutes. It was a pop concert for teenagers, literally Top of the Pops on a beach, it's not that deep.
@@ABSOLUTgarbage Firtsly, what other performers did isn't relevant here. Secondly, I watched Garbage and commented on Garbage, not the others (which I didn't watch). Thirdly, the time of day is irrelevent. Fourthly, the period of time they were on stage is, again, irrelevant. Fiftly, it doesn't matter if it's for teenagers or pensioners.
Sixthly, whether it was on a beach, a mountain or anywhere else for that matter doesn't matter. Seventhly, I know it's not Top of the Pops, never said it was. Eighthly, I know it's not deep - again, never said it was.
How many irrelevant useless, pointless comments can you make in defence of what is clearly one of your favourite bands (your moniker kinda gives it away).
You have made no salient points to counter my original contention and that it essentially pretending you're playing 'live' when your not is ridiculous and she can't even mime properly.
Have a nice day!