An easy trick to understand if subjunctive or not in French
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 окт 2024
- link , which allows you to purchase me a coffee, no obligation but gratefully received
ko-fi.com/logic...
logiclanguagelearning@gmail.com
available for private tuition on skype
+447899732838
Information on grammar podcasts
• NEW GRAMMAR PODCASTS A...
Information on vocab podcasts
• EASY-LEARN FRENCH VOCA...
Information on 1-2-1 French lesson podcasts
• 100 PODCASTS OF 1-2-1 ...
information on listening podcasts
• FRENCH LISTENING PODCA...
Follow short conversation videos on
/ logiclanguagelearningf...
or www.tiktok.com/@logiclanguagelearning
logiclanguagelearning@gmail.com for classes
Subjunctive fully explained and revised in these podcasts available to buy
• NEW GRAMMAR PODCASTS A...
This concept was completely overwhelming to me. I couldn’t comprehend the idea on any level but this video has finally made it comprehendible to me. Thanks!
lovely to hear, come along to the live class some time, even just to watch x we do say to comprehend, which is a good word for understand, but the adjective is more commonly 'comprehensible' . Thanks Becka x
It's funny that we seem to struggle with the idea of SUBJUNCTIVE (me too), but we use the word SUBJECTIVE in terms of judgement, quite happily. Almost one and the same. Thanks for the videos - keep it up.
Thank you so much for teaching this. It has helped me tremendously. I wish all teachers could be this engaging and funny.
That Girl that is so sweet!! Where are you from and how long have you been learning?
No problem! I'm from the States, specifically Missouri, and this is my second year. :)
Hello from the lockdown! I have an online mock French exam tomorrow. Binge watching this guy's videos.
Merci beaucoup pour cette video! Finalement j'ai compris!
In the beginning was it a bit confusing, but after understanding the hole theatre-scene, it is really helpful. So THANK YOU VERY MUCH for that!!!
You are one of the best french teachers I had a chance to watch online, wish I had a teacher like you in my school :) cheers and thank you for your great videos!
After watching so many videos from so many tutors, today my idea about subjunctive and its purpose is very clear. Thank you very much.
Aw bless you. Email me for the grammar podcasts. That’s what I live for…. to make it feel natural
i can studying english or french forever with your face and voice ,pourtant cest un bon lecon ! merci
god bless you, i have a french midterm tomorrow morning on this and freaking out!! thank you
Do you get it now? Have you seen the other subjunctive videos?
French Classes from LogicLanguageLearning yes i have! i understand the best i could!! its a tough understanding especially in another language :p
If you find this useful please go to
ko-fi.com/logiclanguagelearning/commissions
I guess this is a very old video, but it's still very useful. Thank you. Up to now I had been convinced that you can talk your way around needing the subjunctive by structuring sentences to use the indicative whenever possible. That's certainly the English preference. But, you convinced me that doing so isn't really French. To express things the way the French would express them, you really need the subjunctive. Fortunately, it's not that hard, at least from an oral conjugation perspective. It's more a question of when to use it.
@@slicksalmon6948 thanks. If you find this useful you might like the podcasts. Otherwise here are some other videos on the topic subjunctive part 1
ruclips.net/video/7q8J4BKk1bw/видео.html
subjunctive part 2
ruclips.net/video/BEmDxEEvJr0/видео.html
subjunctive part 3
ruclips.net/video/7ph0ZSgodq4/видео.html
with avoir and être
ruclips.net/video/Nq5wtCZxrLw/видео.html
with avoir and être part 2
ruclips.net/video/umkz_YqY8cI/видео.html
subjunctive irregs
ruclips.net/video/SHa3il6hzlo/видео.html
subjunctive irregs part 2
ruclips.net/video/ynebvAefpKM/видео.html
subjunctive irregs part 3
ruclips.net/video/ng9yhosHi70/видео.html
Thank you so much for the video.
I now understand the main part.
I still struggle with one little thing:
Why is the subjonctif not after "penser, croire, espérer and dire" ?
If I hope that something happens, it doesn't have to mean that it really is taking place.
Mindblowing. Merci beaucoup
Oh bless you !!! If you like the tricks and tips email me for the podcasts. I’ll give you a third off for being so complimentary. Logiclanguagelearning@gmail.com
I feel like I'll will begin to finally understand when the subjunctive is. I love the idea of idea of the theatre and the reporter. Amazing. My teacher has been trying to teach us the subjunctive. I get it but then soon forget about it. But this is a great way to teach the subjunctive and have it stick in my mind. Thanks.
1Dudette4Ever you are most welcome. Where are you from?
England
Bravo prof, je suis content que je comprenne tout. Merci pour cette vidéo !
All the subjunctive tenses and tricks are explained in these podcasts ruclips.net/video/8QHSNK4PWuY/видео.html
This caused me a big lightbulb moment!! Thank you so much!!
It’s a good trick isn’t it ! If you like this kind of thing email me about the grammar podcasts. It’s the ‘trick’ for so many different things in no more than four minutes. Best
Thank you good sir! It certainly helps to learn proper French sentence structure from someone who primarily speaks English. Naturally, it's been a challenge to mentally translate English to French when the sentence structure is vastly different. I detest that most of my translations into French sound adolescent but I'm beginning to understand more. Merci beaucoup!
A fantastic method ... very useful.
Aw bless you. If you like these ‘tricks’ email me logiclanguagelearning for the grammar podcasts. Remind me I promised you this and I’ll offer you a discount. Best
Okay, this is the best explanation I’ve heard so far! Thank you!! I subscribed!
Thank you very much for your help. I had my exam today and it went awesome!!! I wish you all the best with this RUclips chanal!
Thank you so much!! This is the only resource that has truly helped me with this idea!!
Cordelia Mutter wonderful. Where are you from and how long have you been learning?
French Classes from LogicLanguageLearning I took 7 years of french throughout middle and high school but it was not very thoroughly taught, and after 3 semesters in college without a class I’ve stepped back into a 200 level (...with struggle). With a teacher who speaks entirely in French and a textbook written entirely in French, it’s been hard to put new concepts together in a way that truly makes sense and sticks in my head.
Hello,
In many of your videos the writing on the board is very difficult to read. Not sure if it’s the angle of the camera, or the markers. Great language instruction, just difficult to read the board.
Amazing explanation! Best out there so far.
When teaching Latin to middle schoolers (and, yes, it is maddening and futile, thanks for asking), I stress that
Indicative indicates reality, what's really going on, happening "for reals"
but subjunctive means possibility, hope, dream, desires, wishes, and "would-if's"
It only helps a few, so thanks for a better alternative!
My darling your use of the word middle schoolers suggests America so for now focus on teaching them English haha x
Well it’s the same. Imperative vs indicative vs subjunctive. There’s obviously difference. Italian is much more subjunctive ready. Or congiuntivo. Etc. want need doubt fear impersonal emotional works. But this is more subtle. It also starts to understand which conjunctives take it. Etc xxx keep up the good work with your middle schoolers. Might I suggest compulsory head shave, a lunge whip and a glass of red wine. for you
The tutor is super handsome! I understand quickly this lessonThanks
Sigit Untoro nice thing to say. Xxx
J'aime votre métaphore. Je comprends ça. Merci beaucoup.
So glad I found this channel!!
Aw bless you for saying that. Don’t forget I have podcasts on offer!
Thank you very much for the beautiful video .. please do more and more❤
this made it make complete sense
Best explaination 👍👍 thankyou so much
Very useful and clear ❤️
That’s what we aim for. Thank you x
Really good explanation. Thanks!
To me if you say "I think something or I like something" can be of certainty so you could use indicative. Because you know what you think or what you want.
Well think is indicative yes.
Thank you so much sir you r really an inspiration🌹
You know what’s really funny... I’m from Germany so my first language is German so now I’m watching an English video to understand French although I’m German - confusing :)))
more than half of my followers are second language English. I do not think it is 'funny' - I think it is wonderful Lilly x
thx for this vid its brilliant and makes everything much easier. go on like this youre ma hero for this evening
That is nice of you, why not come to our LIVE CLASS on the weekend
Green light indeed 5:35
Thanks again sir.
Subscribing just because of this video....:)
How would you translate: You can stay for dinner, unless you want to go out? Struggling with this. thanks
Thank you for simplifying this topic for us! Quick question, why don't we use subjunctive when saying ' j'espère que tu vas bien? '
It’s a common question. Different Romance languages treat it differently. For example it is subjunctive in Spanish. Italian is even stronger, even think is Subjunctive haha.
Thanks !!
Really great explanation! Just one nit picky question: since the video is about differentiating between subjunctive and indicative, wouldn’t it also be grammatically correct to say ‘je ne pense pas que tu comprends?’ (One of the examples was ‘je ne pense pas que tu comprennes’)
No, even if you are sure of it not being the case it cancels you understanding being indicative. Glad you enjoyed the video. Have you seen my grammar podcasts? Also. if it helped you by all means buy me a coffee ko-fi.com/logiclanguagelearning/commissions
Think is funny. People use it in doubtful ways and opinion ways but grammatically, regardless of mood penser I use indicatively ne pense pas subjunctive. Whether you are saying that in a doubtful way or in a firmly giving a negative opinion way. Interesting fact. In Italian think uses the subjunctive! Every time.
C'est fantastique!!
When you ask your girl what she wants and she says 2:48
So when we say in french " im happy that u are here " it means , using the theatre trick, that the actor on the stage is happy but the person who the actor is happy bec is not there on the stage ? Sorry if my question seems abit stupid but neither english nor french is my mother language and i couldn't really get that part while watching the video
However i have to admit i think i have understood everything else and so far ,after scrolling the internet for hours, u are from the very rare who actually says why we use subjunctive with emotions .........rather than just throwing the key words bec seriously even after those key words it almost depends on what the speaker believes;the speaker can use one of the subjunctive key word and don't use the subjunctive bec he is somewho certain .
So really I can't thank you enough
May God bless you.
manar Ahmed yep
Thank you for your kind message. where are you from? how long have you been learning?
From Egypt
For french actually since i was in grade 3 but i will be honest my school french curriculum wasn't improving me at all it just left me from level zero to level 1 ,literally,however i have always loved french so i tried to take so i didn't gave up so long story short i ended up as a self-learner and improved alot
Thank you.
Glad you are loving the channel so much x I do have a KOFI account as logiclanguagelearning where you are welcome, but not obliged, to buy me a coffee to say thanks for anything you find useful x
the way you explained was very helpful but I have a little doubt
If It is very clear that I am happy that you come " je suis content que tu vienne" here still using subjunctive why is it so?
Firstly, in English it is more common to say ‘I am very happy that you are coming as a single action’ I am happy that you come would be reserved for say a regular event. You come to the club and I am very happy that you come. Every week. Secondly it isn’t the clarity. It is the emotion. Watch the main video on the subjunctive my friend. Want need doubt fear impersonal and emotional. The hypothetical thing often overtakes things
This was great 🙂
Aw what a lovely thing to say. If ever you order any of my podcasts show me this comment and I’ll give you half off. That’s lovely x thank you
Bonjour Monsieur 🇨🇵👋🏾 Je M'apelle Chrissy 🇺🇸 je parle une français et je veux apprendre français
Brilliant!!
Aaron Picking what a lovely comment! Where are you from and how long have you been learning?
Sorry from recommenting 😂😂 but i have another question
Why a sentence like this will be in the subjunctive
"Il est toujour gentil jusqu'a ce que tu arrives"
For me it does not seem like sb's opinion or someone trying to influence another ,doubt, possiblity,order, emotion or hypothesis .
It seem to me like a fact so why do we use the subjunctive in it ? Or Does the sentence simply means the speaker has got some doubts and it can also be in the impartive if he was sure
It's basically guessing when to use subjunctive or indicative in French. No way to know for sure one way or other
I disagree totally, I think you missed the point of the video
Wasn't the French Revolution about whether or not to keep the subjunctive? Apparently the ayes won! :)
Omg I love this ! Haha
cmon bruh 4:45
youre a beauty
what earned me this high praise?
Okay, I just stumbled upon this. I therefore retract my last comment! Thanks man.
Kevin McGuinness good so you can delete it please
Sure, and can delete the video too. :D
Doesn’t make sense for I think. I think you are coming. Not subjunctive but it’s only a thought that might not be happening.
Goodness does it ? I had no idea ! HahaI did say it was a rule of thumb. One of them.
@@logiclanguagelearningFrench is this sarcasm?
Think is an action. It is really happening, whether or not the conclusions/consequences/thoughts are real or not.
@@TheNutmegStitcher well you can say that about anything then. lol