Is This Catan Strategy Secretly OP?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 янв 2025

Комментарии • 73

  • @Ashwath-p8c
    @Ashwath-p8c Год назад +129

    That mono before roll was genius move. But still wonder if you would have gotten 2 wheats anyways for a city, not sure if opponents would have dumped all the wheats.

    • @miriushaefliger5412
      @miriushaefliger5412 Год назад +29

      i doubt they would be good enough to recognise it but the mono wheat gauranteed the win whereas not monoing didnt

    • @scottieballew6149
      @scottieballew6149 Год назад +11

      I had no clue you were allowed to mono before your turn

    • @riquelme54181
      @riquelme54181 Год назад +3

      @@scottieballew6149 all development cards can be played before rolling the dice

    • @shivakumarshivashankar4994
      @shivakumarshivashankar4994 Год назад +2

      @@riquelme54181 I don’t think you can play road building or YOP before rolling

    • @riquelme54181
      @riquelme54181 Год назад

      @@shivakumarshivashankar4994 you can play ANY development card before rolling the dice

  • @jabbysammich
    @jabbysammich Год назад +26

    It's clear you're a lot more relaxed now. Excited to see how far this new level headed mentality gets you this season!

  • @Hope41656
    @Hope41656 Год назад +1

    23:35 "alright i gotta be quiet.." *Clicks text box menacingly*

  • @LightShady
    @LightShady Год назад +59

    Welcome back - please can you number your episodes (eg. Season X Episode 1 or w/e) so it's a bit easier to follow?

    • @DayZilya
      @DayZilya Год назад +4

      Great suggestion

  • @crazymudman123
    @crazymudman123 Год назад +7

    Playing the mono in preparation for a 7 was a 200 iq call to make well done

  • @pablooroz581
    @pablooroz581 Год назад +3

    I was checking for new vid yesterday and lastest was 2m old, good to see a video back, hope you do more soon

  • @ShadowInTheSky2
    @ShadowInTheSky2 Год назад +10

    Somebody was shit talking you on your weird tourney rules vid you released today. They say "you call yourself internet's Catan coach but haven't uploaded in 2 months 😂" Then BOOM! Homie walks up 2 hours later with the gameplay! Stay awesome.

  • @Alex-hh9su
    @Alex-hh9su Год назад +7

    A DyLighted video 😍

  • @nafnosseb
    @nafnosseb Год назад

    Holding thumbs for you. Keep those vids coming, they make some of my best entertainment.

  • @hungerbunger5985
    @hungerbunger5985 Год назад

    Just had the most ballsiest game of all time. I just went OWS build where all the other three kept putting it solely on my wheat. Still won. Mostly cause red was too blind to steal longest road from me lol Thanks for all your tips and tricks. They help a lot when the other plays go against you

  • @Colbyzero4three
    @Colbyzero4three Год назад +3

    Post daily king!!! Lol I know that’s a lot to ask for you got a life but I really enjoy the vids fam

  • @CNDEFaca
    @CNDEFaca Год назад +12

    Would love a subscriber tournament! I feel the level is pretty high amongst your followers

    • @miriushaefliger5412
      @miriushaefliger5412 Год назад +2

      i would play probably but time zones tough for me

    • @DyLightedCatan
      @DyLightedCatan  Год назад +5

      Maybe one day! It's just logistically difficult. But yes the skill ceiling would be very high for sure.

  • @shivakumarshivashankar4994
    @shivakumarshivashankar4994 Год назад +7

    Welcome back! I think the thumbnail of pure OWS VS hybrid OWS is misleading. You were only really considering 9-4-11 vs 6-2 which are both pure OWS. The better question/debate would have been choosing 9-4-11 vs 5-4-11 (which would be pure OWS vs hybrid OWS)

  • @caseyw9864
    @caseyw9864 Год назад +1

    "Delusional" - Orange

  • @ZzZ-qd1zo
    @ZzZ-qd1zo Год назад +2

    2 months gone, then just drops a vid like it's your average Wednesday, lol.

  • @mohammadjadallah9813
    @mohammadjadallah9813 Год назад +12

    Since when were you able to mono before rolling?! I never knew that I thought the knight was the only devy you can use before rolling.

    • @TheBrownMan01
      @TheBrownMan01 Год назад +6

      You can play any dev at any point in your turn. Usually it just makes no sense to use them before in case you 7 out or you roll something which changes the need for something like a yop.
      That move is why Dylan is the goat

    • @mohammadjadallah9813
      @mohammadjadallah9813 Год назад +1

      @@TheBrownMan01 I think colonist updated the game because I was never able to do that before except with the knight.

    • @riquelme54181
      @riquelme54181 Год назад

      @@mohammadjadallah9813 they fixed that like 2 years ago. now you can play any development card before rolling the dice

    • @juliantaffa4089
      @juliantaffa4089 Год назад +1

      @@TheBrownMan01 even road building or year of plenty?

    • @cruizin_usa2361
      @cruizin_usa2361 Год назад +2

      Yes any dev can be played before rolling. It’s always been there in the rule book

  • @miriushaefliger5412
    @miriushaefliger5412 Год назад

    damn that mono was so smart

  • @timothyyoung409
    @timothyyoung409 Год назад +1

    Wow he’s actually back

  • @ballaking1000
    @ballaking1000 Год назад

    22:12, this is a prime example of what people mean about you 'talking fast, playing slow'.. Great game nonetheless : )

  • @matthewandkristyvandelden6368
    @matthewandkristyvandelden6368 Год назад +1

    Another season! Awesome

  • @garantiert9761
    @garantiert9761 Год назад

    i have no idea who you are, what youre doing or what youre saying, but i like it

  • @anonymous_magic1750
    @anonymous_magic1750 Год назад

    Finally a few more Videos ;)

  • @flatman91
    @flatman91 Год назад +3

    Why not just go on the 6 wheat with the sheep port rather than the 6-2? 2 is useless anyway! Plus the sheep port is a great port to have for the excess sheep.

    • @shadesonbroadway
      @shadesonbroadway Год назад

      If you take the 6, then orange can cut your 3:1 port if they get lucky rolls with road, or pull development cards. The 62 locks orange from attempting to build through you, while also starting you with an additional wheat.
      You never are porting sheep in this game anyway.

    • @matthewwells9366
      @matthewwells9366 Год назад +2

      ​@@shadesonbroadway
      What no

    • @Funglutton
      @Funglutton Год назад

      Orange builds through you along the 10-2. It doesn't make sense to spend 3 roads instead of 2 to get to the 3:1 port.
      The Pros for building on the 6-2 is that the 2 is never blocked, you get an extra starting Wheat making your first city faster. You probably get one Wheat roll from the 2 during the game, which could happen while your 6 Wheat is blocked.
      But I still prefer the 6 Sheep port because it makes Blacks first settle take a lot longer, meaning they probably go City then 8-3 after. With an Early City Black becomes the Robber target, probably on the 6 Wheat, but you have the flexibility of the Sheep port to work around that. The Sheep port also gets you to the 3:1 port faster.

    • @CreepyBlackDude
      @CreepyBlackDude Год назад

      @@Funglutton Black's settlement doesn't come slower, they actually just go to the wood port instead, which is probably what they should have done in the first place. Going to the sheep port was a defensive move but not really that beneficial to Black, they should have went to the wood port with all that wood they were on, and then prioritized getting to the 5/6/11 afterwards.
      But that's why Dylan didn't take the sheep port straight away, because he figured black would do that since it was so good to their game.

    • @Funglutton
      @Funglutton Год назад

      @@CreepyBlackDude it's slower because the 8-3 is significantly better for their game, so they would double road to that. Settling on only the 3 is helping flexibility but doesn't do much in the way of production. After they get that they need to wait for a 5 or 3 to roll four times (or a 12) to road to the 5-6-11 to really take advantage of the Wood port.
      I think the way to play it is to City the Wheat-Ore because those spots will be blocked a lot so you want to maximise their income for Dev cards and future cities, plus the Wheat is very tradable. Use Dev cards to help secure the 8-3 (RB, rob, YoP) and then get the 5-6-11 if still available. Instead of the city you can just focus on devs to keep a lower profile but I honestly think you get blocked anyway on the Ore Wheat, so may as well grab the city if you can.

  • @TheRealAT
    @TheRealAT Год назад +1

    You were very lucky in that one

  • @sanj9278
    @sanj9278 Год назад +1

    Wow. Didn’t know you could play any dev card before rolling. Thought just knights. Had to Google that.

  • @katievanmeter6922
    @katievanmeter6922 Год назад

    I think black got greedy going for that sheep port. He prob could have won if he went for that 5-6-11 first and to the wood port. And what was with orange trying to give him the plow to the sheep port if needed? Weird table for sure.

  • @tobiasobermayr501
    @tobiasobermayr501 Год назад

    blue not pointing towards woodport is the idiocy.

  • @Kristor333
    @Kristor333 Год назад

    Only one minute into the video I realized it was Dylan talking…didn’t recognize your new voice!

  • @at5598
    @at5598 Год назад

    Where has he been?

  • @Beep-Boop78
    @Beep-Boop78 Год назад +1

    were so back

  • @robertommb
    @robertommb Год назад

    If you didnt had other options, woudnt the 6 wheat + sheep port be better than 6/2 ??

    • @alexandernater6284
      @alexandernater6284 Год назад

      Probably not, since the second starting wheat is very valuable here.

  • @arimorrison7816
    @arimorrison7816 Год назад

    why didn't you take 4511 with second spot?

  • @JTRAP1000
    @JTRAP1000 Год назад

    I need help with 3 player games of Catan. Can you please help in any shape or form?
    I'd even potentially consider paying for coaching
    Ps love your work mate

  • @slickvik4508
    @slickvik4508 Год назад

    I really think black threw this game going after that sheep port

  • @conneranbeek8302
    @conneranbeek8302 Год назад

    This guy just regularly uploading on a daily basis after a 2 month silence??? Fine by me I guess

  • @artofknives1094
    @artofknives1094 Год назад

    Just caught 3 dubs on Catan universe vs some noobs tonight

  • @TheRealAT
    @TheRealAT Год назад +1

    Is dandy alive?

  • @noahclipp2553
    @noahclipp2553 Год назад

    Where you been?

    • @DyLightedCatan
      @DyLightedCatan  Год назад +3

      I've been traveling a lot. I'm in Thailand and considering moving there permanently instead of the US. Things have calmed down for me a lot and will be back to a normal schedule.

    • @noahclipp2553
      @noahclipp2553 Год назад

      Thanks for the reply! Love your videos and wish you the best.@@DyLightedCatan

  • @bjornlindqvist8305
    @bjornlindqvist8305 Год назад

    insane game

  • @humanbloger5533
    @humanbloger5533 Год назад

    I don't mean to insult this video or anything but Dylan, what the hell happened to your microphone ? I understand it maybe wasn't the best before but now you just sound awful. The difference is really clear

  • @SlackerNerd
    @SlackerNerd Год назад +1

    y mic bad hurt head

    • @DyLightedCatan
      @DyLightedCatan  Год назад

      Is the mic quality poor for you? I might have to adjust some settings if it is.

    • @rudyroker3
      @rudyroker3 Год назад

      @@DyLightedCatan it's like scratchy and peaking for me a lot. hard to listen to but I love your videos.

  • @liams-h
    @liams-h Год назад

    w video

  • @miriushaefliger5412
    @miriushaefliger5412 Год назад

    🖐

  • @dundeedideley1773
    @dundeedideley1773 Год назад

    Why are you saying "inside of this position" so much? Doesnt even make sense

    • @nafnosseb
      @nafnosseb Год назад

      He is inside of this your head.