Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
#PartitionAt70
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 авг 2017
- In this short documentary, we spoke to four Muslims to understand the kind of political and communal atmosphere that had swept across north India in 1947. They talk about the reasons their families decided to stay back and what compelled their relatives and other Muslims, cutting across different socio-economic backgrounds, to migrate to Pakistan.
Each of their four distinct stories helps us understand the kind of questions that Indian Muslims were grappling with at that time and form a better picture of the changing social and political fabric of India seventy years ago.
At the time of partition my grandfather was preparing to leave for Pakistan from Agra all the Hindus gathered and said u can't leave us like this my grandfather said everywhere is riot going on I don't want any harm and at that time people laid on ground and said just go over our bodies if u didn't trust us and if u trust us stay here we will protect u and everyone if any rioters came to kill u or any other Muslim
Umar Khan this was soo beautiful to read.
I wish our generation is also fortunate enough to see this unity and contribute in d development of our beloved nation India.
IN SHAA ALLAH AAMIIN
Umar Khan Well said Sir. trust me if unfocunatly siutation like This arise again We will against stand united and defete Fear.
Arjun Jaiswal yes brother we will Happy independence day
They saved your lives. You should be forever greatful to them!
Muslims 1st divided india took away 30% of land mass and then said half them changed their mind and stayed back to play victim card about how they choose india like they did favour on us if they really loved the country soo much they should have fought against the partition instead they supported it and the muslim league
only 16% of Muslims could vote, and those were the rich ones. 90% of poor muslims didnt want partition
Victim card
I'm not hating but I hope secularism come from muslims too. Stop calling us KAFIR
If everyone was willing to stay in Homeland then, who was responsible for partition?
Hindu Mahasabha propounded the 2 nation theory before Jinnah did. Saavarker was in favor of partition.
Mohammed Ibrahimuddin waaahhhhh😂😂😂😂, hindu hi zimmedar pakistan bnne ke liye wah, magar aaj bhi pakistan bnane wale india me hi rehte hn,afsos jo hinduo ko har pal gali bakte hn
@Vishnu N
Instead of worrying who treats whom to be what, just read what Saavarker had to say about partition (And about RSS) in his autobiography.
@Jai Chauhan
When Hindu Mahasabha promulgated the two nation theory, Sir Syed Ahmed khan wasn't even 20. Anyways, just like I oppose Jinnah and the Hindu Mahasabha (Now RSS), I equally oppose Sir Syed Ahmed khan as well, as far as partition is concerned. But what makes him stand out, compared to Hindu Mahasabha and the RSS, is that he was a freedom fighter, while the Hindu Mahasabha had pledged unconditional allegiance to the Britishers, including AB Vajpayee and Savarkar. They were against the independence of my beloved country India.
@@mohammedibrahimuddin5871 Hindu mahasbha got nothing to do with this it was created to counter Muslim league when Muslim demanded partition you getting your history wrong
And I'm not Hindu or Hindu supporter
I am proud to be an indian.my grandfather served for Indian army insaAllah I will serve also
Alauddin Khan my brother and grandfather also served.
Proud of your family. Jai Hind. Jai Bharat!
Proud of my Muslim Brothers, Jai Hind
Sid Gaur ...chup be chutiye
Good for you. That means you are a Bharteeya, not a musalman, because muslalaam is AHSAAN FARAMOSH & DOES NOT RESPECT THE LAND as the mother. I only hope you do not turn against & ask for the blood of the country in return for "working for the military," the way the RaGa & MANY people have done & the way the CURRENT MUSLIMS are doing in India..
Majority of muslims stayed where they were.
I often think why their grandfathers first raised demand and then voted for pakistan with overwhelming majority if they had no intention to go there?
Why?
@@wikipediawikipedia5626
It's was independence for Panjabistan🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰 on Islamic nationalism
There is no connection between south india and pakistan
@@coconutpunch123but now, it has a strong religious connection..
Still the hindus and sikhs were brutally thrown out of West Punjab, their properties, businesses everything was taken eventually making them extinct in West Punjab, we must not easily forget it
Muslim majority country became islamic and hindu majority became secular ,democratic,socialist,republic and what not......isliye differences hai isiliye tension hai isiliye hatred hai....
That is what makes our India unique. Our India's main concept is 'university in diversity' , if there is no diversity then there is no unity...🙏 Every community has good and bad. Let's love all just the way they are❤️❤️🙂.
@@saffiyabikodalayil2646 oh venda no thanks
Not you that means india is hindu majority @@saffiyabikodalayil2646
In pakistan hindu minority populations reduced to 2 percent from 12 percent...
Whereas in India muslim community increased from 7 percent to 15 percent.....
This tells whole story.....
@@MohiuddinR12 true religion ....of terrorist ,hence islamophobia is rising , mashallah.
yeap
This tells us that Many Hindus are converting to Islam
No Muslim will answer these Muslim takes sympathy when they are in minority when they become majority they start converting minority into Muslim
The only difference between Pakistani muslims and Indian Muslims is Pakistani muslims kept their promise.
What do you mean?
Fail to understand when almost all Muslims voted Jinnah and his Muslim league why only a handfull of them left India for Pakistan.
It's not like that they wanted to live here. They couldn't leave because of the violence and many couldn't afford to leave
The elites who funded muslim league left.. Though Nehru and Gandhi are to be blamed largely for not being as cut clear as Jinnah.. They Both wanted to secure a place in history books as 'great founders of India'...
@@ismt101 just shut up when do you have history about this my grandfather migrated and some of his friends who where poor still came because they wanted to do it for there generations long live Pakistan and hope Indian Muslims realize what they did wrong
@@syedabdan6895 a terrorist nation is asking us to look upon our selves... Shame on pakistanis what u have done to your country... Jahiliyat bht hain aapke yhnnn... Hindustan ka lutf kuch aur hai sahab..,, yhn ki tehzeeb kuch aur hai... Aur sab ke barabar rights hain.. Pakistaan to firqawariyat mein hi jal rha. Hai
@@abc..6533 thanks brother
May this communal hatred go away. 70 years into independence, we want a developed nation not the one which is still marred by communal tensions and uncertainty. Can we all stay united as one. I pray.
Azeem Zaidi Saudi Arabia,Iraq, Syria me log India se behtar ..prospers ... Hai na to kya hua ??? Only Money won't give peace .. what is people ideology also mater's.
There is no Justice in India or in the subcontinent because our constitution does not follow human right and in the above comment I have mentioned few aspects of Human Rights, one of the problem is Blasphemy law that punishes people for hurting religious sentiment and that is why today there are people who are killing / lynching people and putting people in jail for hurting religious sentiment. In a secular country there should be no law on hurting religious sentiment and we can not call us secular until we atleast remove that, and we need to learn secularism form country like French, Sweden, China etc.
@nameless977 Again you are judging people by cast, colour, religion and ethnicity ... that is the problem, we are human being. I am a humanist and I recognize myself as a human being and I have no cast, religion, race or any other specific thing other than a human being. I don't belong to any cast or religion so where will you put me if you divide people like this. You may hate Mamata Banerjee for being bramhin or love Modi for being lower cast, but it is your narrow minded thinking and mentality, so you want to remove Mamata Banerjee just because she is bramhin??
We need to remove cast system from the mind of the people and a day when people will not even know which cast they belong to is the day we will succeed to eradicate cast from this country.
mamta is just fighting for her own power...
@nameless977 you just said that in politics lower cast people should represent more and now you are flipping, see your ideology is proven wrong by you only. Exactly that was my point one should be recognized for their work not cast, race, religion etc. Because we are all human being. But you hate Bramhin and that is wrong, just because a person belong to certain cast or religion one should not be removed for the job if he/she is best suited for that.
My family had to leave Lahore with nothing. It would have been in both countries interest to have a full exchange of population. In my view it's still not too late.
Its late now if partition will happen in future but on the basis of 1947 muslim population.
Same here My great grand father had to live Dhaka and come to Kolkata in 1940 with literally nothing
Now Indian muslim population is way more than their minorities
If partition must happen, full partition.
If indian muslims, still fear in India then they are requested to migrate to their own made country- Pakistan. I think they will be much more safe there.
Lindu teree maa, indian muslims seperate countey banahngay, india bhi shrink ho ga 😂😂😂
That's a very silly thing to say. Most Pakistanis didn't even want to be in the British raj, in fact most Pakistanis aren't even related to most Indians. So to say movie to a muslim land from central India is a joke.
@@_.belladonna_ source - madarasa
No riot can happen without political backing.Make no mistake.
souvik bhattacharya may this hatred that has taken over the country soon disappear
More dangerous is religious backing
But humans don't fight, citizen fights
There are 57 Islamic countries, and none Hindu. And they called Hindu communal...what a joke.
mayur sir khash aapki bhi family Direct action day me hoti
fir aap ye pyaar bhara massage de pate (koi baat nhi kuch payre logon ne meri ,mother sister ka rape krke unko huk se latka diya pr seculirisam to bach gya )
Persons like Abdul kalam, Zakir Hossain, Jaheer Khan never told that they are living in fear...they have become legends instead...
Poonam Abbi fuck offff
mainak misra pataudi sab Azhar
@@poonamabbi7448 get lost,
You are really an expert at FABRICATING LAME EXCUSES for your sis=nister agenda to BREAK UP THE BHARAT... THE LIKES OF YOU have been trying it for 1000 years.... invading Bharat to ROB & OCCUPY... YOU WILL NEVER SUCCEED. What do you know about me? I am AGAINST ALL FAKUS like you who come in ... the virulent pathogens invading from OUTSIDE.
@@poonamabbi7448 sis terrorists don't have any religion
Muslims supported muslim league and pakistan before independence 😂 how this can be possible that in only 1 night they have changed their minds 😂🤦🏼♂️ said by our beloved iron man of India Sri sardar Vallabhbhai Patel ❤️
Muslims are not Indians. Full stop
Very true. Indian Muslims were not driven out from India (except Punjab). And so they could stay back and retain their homes and properties and wealth. Their Lives. While Hindus and Sikhs in Pakistan were given the stark choice to Leave or Convert. So most of them fled. Leaving behind homes. Wealth. Property. Their Lives. They had no choice. They too wanted to stay back and not leave the comfort of home and accumulated wealth. But No Choice. But Yes. Tens of Thousands did convert to Islam to stay back and save their homes and lives. This was not a choice which Indian Muslims had to face. Much Easier for them.
What??? Ten of thousands of conversions to islam from which sources do you heard about that???
I think you should also make a video on the minorities of Pakistan like the Hindus Sikhs Christians and so on who existed at the time of partition but are either shrinking considerably or no longer exist, their stories are extremely painful too, In India the Muslims and their culture still thrived their population has grown not shrinking at least.....😳
then the wire will have to close down their shop
@@taahashaikh3046 because they got three nation and still playing victim card,,,so may stories but can't denied that india is divided,, and those who voted for pakistan still leaving here
@@taahashaikh3046 nope,,, you r totally wrong 90% voted for pakistan,,, even imran khan told yesterday,,, it is known fact,, ambedkar was full support of total population exchange,,, khoon karke desh toda hai ,,,,direct action day mein aapne jinnah ka saath diya aur kuch logo ne silent support kiyatha
@@taahashaikh3046 nahin,, lekin arabic culture follow karna band karein ,, kisi keral muslim ko dekho,, pehchaan nahin paoge,,, kyunki uska keralite identity hai rather than arabic,, aur gazwa e hind ka khwab choro
@@taahashaikh3046 hum apna culture acche se follow karte hain,, modernisation mein nahin jeena to hai to pakistan hi nikal jaate naa,, aap kisi dharam ko kahenge bhi kaise,, jinke khud ke ghar sheeshe ke ho wo dusron patthar nahin fenkte,,, itna hi 1200 saal purana cult follow karna hai to afghanistan ideal hai aapke liye,,, 3 tukda to kar diya desh ka aapne aur kya chahiye
My grandparents left Rawalpindi and came down to Hyderabad , India .
Man, they say we were so damn rich there ...they left all and came over here.
Weird but true !
Same. My grandparents owned lands in Pabna, Bangladesh. A lot of lands. They were rich. People around him loved him for being so helpful to the poor. But in 1971 war the Pak troops were looking for him. The local risked their lives to shelter them and take him out of Bangladesh.
No body care about Pakistan Hindus
Wow. My family was Anglo Indian, very poor and lived just within India’s borders. We are proud Hindus, and are proud to be Bharatiya.
Muslims got 3 homelands, Hindu got none.. so sad to know that Hindus of Pakistan is shrinking at a rapid rate..
My grandfather served British Indian army
After 1945 he join Indian National army under subhash chandra bose
After 1947 he join Indian army
He lived in india with faith and dignity
Jai Hind
Muslimo tum apne desh chale jaana tha islamic desh pakistan me 1947 me
Abe tum logo se jyada kurbaniya muslmano ne di hai azadi ki jang me
Humari jamine aur daulat sab kuch luta di humne
1857 me sirf delhi ke 500000 musalmano ne kurbani di hai!
Us din delhi ke har ek ped pe laashe latki hui thi muslmano ki !!
Rss ne nahi dilayi azadi tumhe!
@@ayaan_khatib Chal be Lahore Karachi ye sab indian muslims nhi they kya? Aur ye bta ye kya hai . How did Muslim League win 429 out of 492 Muslim majority areas in the 1946 British Indian Provincial Elections and 30 out of 30 Muslim seats in 1945 General Elections?Bcz they were voted by the Malayali, Tamil, Telugu, Kannad or even Marathi etc Muslims too not just the Muslims of Northern and Central India. Jinnah was a Gujarati and guess what? Pakistan indeed have some Biharis and Gujarati muslims . Once a gaddaar always a gaddar
@@tarakbhatt493 Dude stop it ,we have to co exist with 200 million Muslim, it's okay to criticize Islam but find a nuance way to co exist with them in our society
@@ayaan_khatib are u adult
@@pranshuaggarwalji8253 lol
They should have been thrown out of India at that time so people can live in peace today
Before the Idea of Pakistan there is no Hatred at all between Hindu's & Muslims I had watched many videos of old age people of both religion's saying that they lived a very normal & peaceful life before.
But after the Idea of a seperate Muslim nation the communities started hating each other.
The Idea was a big mistake which resulted in unnessary hatred, loss of millions of life's, many people become homeless needlessly and many are living in fear till now only because of that idea.
Different Religion is not an enemy the person himself becomes the enemy of his own.
The present condition of Pakistan's economy is the biggest proof of it.
You're delusional to say that. Go and read some history of British India and hindu Muslim riots.
Oh please. Hamesha samasyaen theen.
@@mohtaramusama4992 you are delusional so was Jinnah sharabi
I was watching a recent video of a Hindu shopkeeper in Pakistan few days back. He was without his moustache, his eyebrows, his hairs on head (shaved off). This was done by Pakistan police to humiliate the man for selling the vegetables to the locals on credit(earning interest). Thinking of that man and many many kidnaps, forced conversions, marrying and selling of girls to brothels stories in Pakistan, I feel both communities have suffered and will continue suffering due to hate as i think the partition is still not over. It is ongoing but bit slow as the hate remains. The leaders whether of political parties or religion love building more hate. So, fate of both communities seem to be heading for a catastrophe. It seems just round the corner - a nuclear holocaust. After that whoever will be left from both communities will say that we both are brothers and we don't believe in religion any more. So until then, let's carry on the hate..
Watch less khoti Media.
Its PAKISTAN not BJP Ruled lndia.
@@whiteholeeducationcenter yes it's ruled by HAIFZ SAYID LASHKAR JAISHE
Muslims who are opposing Pakistan will live the rest of their live,proving their loyality to India
Muhammad Ali Jinnah,1947
Ji atleast they aren't labeled as a citizen of a terror supporting nation, they live in communal harmony here.
Irony is that most of them demanded Pakistan but never went there.
Lol 😂 nobody wanted to stay in India they were left here all the rich and middle class left only poor remained also the muslim who voted for jinnah were from UP bihar and madras dont make these propaganda videos
and you made India as secular too curb muslim majority areas like East Punjab , Delhi, WestUP, Rohilkhand, Bengal/Assam even would have no claim on kashmir and Hyderabad.
We were from india but we migrated in Pakistan and we are living freely
That’s awesome are you muslim
❤❤❤
These kind of stories are those that we used to listen from our grandparents.
Salute to the theme makers and all those people in this video.
Happy Independence Day in advance. 😊
@Rajvansh singh Sir madam ji ka fault toh nahi hai na. Respects those muslims whose family contributions for our Nations armed forces. Pls ignore Poonam Abbi and PS for all you know both are pakistanis using fake id to divide indians.
Our blessed nation had Jaichand and Mir Jaffer who sold the nation to invaders. We also have hindus, muslims, christians who are part of Communist Party who refused to give blood to Indian soldiers in 1962 china war. So we have the good and bad both among us. We need to be careful these hateful people dont divide us. I assure you RSS is proud of those muslims who are faithful to the Nation. We know some Hindus are also sold out so we need to be together as Indians, against all the divisive forces.
i also had the chance to ask about partition to my grandparents, they remembered how they chose to say saying this is our land as they are born here and spent all their lives here, they were not ready to leave, but one of my grand aunt left because her husband pressurised her, and she is now in pakistan, we dont have contact with her, my late uncle was the last one to have their contact, its so weird that even in this age of instant contact we still are strangers because they chose to leave. I have only seen a picture of my grand aunt and her daughters with my late uncle when he went to pakistan to visit them and that too is of late 90s when things were better between the two nations.
@@shh11111 Jinnah was appointed by the British as goveror General of Pakistan, he exchanged letters with churchill and now these letters are unclassified in UK. In my view British never left our country they merely outsourced their own agents.
Meanwhile India mein Nehru and congress party was puppet of British and the congress party till date has all media in their pocket, they use them to do fake news and anti hindu propaganda against modi and rss, this has kept BJP out of power for 65 years . The rss were the ones to go after army to save kashmiri muslims during earth quake, they saved muslims, gave them medication, but pro congress media will not show this. In kerala also rss went to kerala saved muslims and christians, during the floods, but again media will say negative and fake news. did you know RSS is the only ngo in India with a muslim wing, and the muslims of RMM are very nationalistic. But Indian media will not show this, else congress will not win in elections.
But congress uses fake news and propaganda to defame them, congress party uses same strategy as british, divide and rule to keep hindus and muslims divided and in fear. the reality is in India there is lot of harmony between common man, but congress fake media will show fake hindu terrorism by way of fake news and media. I will go as far as to say congress party of India and pakistan army/ ISI are partners in crime along with British and USA left parties. In fact the hindus have been complaining that Modi has only done more for muslims and put more budget money for muslim development. but media will not show these parts as they want to promote only congress party.
Now coming to partition of india and pakistan, the partition of India and pakistan was a fake. the provisional elections in 1946 were rigged. The nwfp voted to join India but nehru ignored them as british were not interested they should join India The British put their own puppets in power in pakistan and India. After the British seen muslims and hindus uniting in 1857, the british decided to employ divide and rule policy. They used . ex-Hindu ancestry Jinnah who was pork eater and alcohol drinker was placed in pakistan, ex-muslim ancestry Nehru was a womanizer and beef eater was placed in India. While Jinnah family business was interest taking and he never went to haj, Nehru was a british man in India, the british called gandhi to england put pressure on him to put nehru as PM of India. Even as congress workers elected sardar patel gandhi asked him to resign from candidature and placed Nehru to the post of PM. Nehru was corrupt from day one. British were not interested in India , they were not bothered even if they got divided into 50 pieces, it was more interested in pakistan due to geographical location. for another 10 years from 1947-1958 british generals were in charge of pakistan army, so the british generals were in charge at the time of 1st war with India. Nehru was told to stop Indian army from pursuing the pakistan army and to take the issue to UN, so that USA and British and congress party, nehru family, Pakistan army/ISI could make money over weapons business. Till date the poor people of pakistan cheated by Pak army/ ISI and the poor people of India cheated by congress party. Now BJP came 1st time they almost did peace with pakistan but they did not trust pervez musharraf and pakistan army. the BJP now with modi, he came to meet sarfaraz nawaz, modi will never do deal with pakistan army, or ISI or with puppet PM. BJP and modi will only do deal with people elected democratic leader of pakistan, So this is the unfortunate situation of both pakistan and India where both nations are looted by USA, British till date. If you check British documents you will see British never gave independence they gave dominion status. Subash chandra bose was removed from congress for seeking independence. In INA army his close aides included who went to Pakistan cause they had no choice , the circumstances were created in this way.
So dont trust what you see in media it is all fake propaganda to keep hindus and muslims scared they are paid puppets of congress and USA. .
The 1947 riots were manufactured by British, the person who started the riots in Nakholi west bengal by burning alive 5000 hindus in factory, his name was gulam sarwar, his family migrated to UK and became members of parliament in UK. The riots spread naturally due to fear of each other. It is human behaviour to attack others to protect ones own self, British used our hatred for each other against us. .British used oue own corrupt people to divide us, exactly as they did to defeat first indian emperor in battle of plassey, using Mir Jaffer the army commander of the Indian ruler.
It is taughtt in history Jinnah wanted to create islamic state for muslims, but this is not correct , if you listen to his first speech after pakistan was formed , in that speech he said he wanted a pakistan for all minorities and muslims, If he wanted to make secular nation then why he separated from India, this is because he did not have choice the british were making all decisions they were to follow only. another point gandhi told jinnah to become PM but Nehru refused, so these two had setting with the british, both jinnah and nehru. churchill was writing private letters to jinnah without any ones knowledge. The muslim league was created by british themselves in 1906 and its charter was loyalty to the british crown.
@@rjhaveri8bh tl;dr
I dont support jinnah and his idea of two nations, i cant imagine myself agreeing with someone who supports the idea of two nation, what happened was the worst that could happen to the people of india, and till date these politicians are trying to milk out of what happened 70 years ago. But hat doesnt mean we start hating people blindly, there are people across the borders who are like us who want peace, and reply love with love in return, the past cant be changed, but surely we can learn from the past and make sure it is not repeated again. If we want india to reach to the heights of development, unity is the only way to do it. People here are trying to take it backwards to the point where it all began, but we have the power to tell them that the times are changed and people are not that gullible anymore.
For those of us who were born after independence should know these stories. In today’s world people just like to dwell on hate .
But the bitter truth is more than 90% muslims voted to Jinnah's muslim league party for partition of Pakistan supported jinnah in 1946election and many of them remained in india by choice.., no one knows why
87% of Muslims were won by Jinnah. And they included the people that were in Today's Pakistan and Bangladesh too.
Also, most of the muslims who didn't vote for AIML were the educated ones, cuz they knew how to think rather than blindly voting on the name of religion.
The journey to Pakistan was very dangerous,so the opted to stay
Reason for partition : Islam
Guilty of partition : hindus
reason for partition: jinnah
The way he said fascism and attack yogi and modi bcz of their agenda and saying they are being afraid to talk. I mean sir how you do these things. Multiple people are killed most recent a boyfriend of Muslim girlfriend Ankit Sharma. In this country muslim have been given everything equally as to others. People loved you made you star and what not in 70 years. But in the end you said you r being fearful in this country. Cos it is lead by a party not ideological as yours.
Ps : this is not about hating any muslim man it is just about saying that everyone in this country is peaceful except few of yours and mine religion.
There is a very serious lesson to be learnt from hatred.
We missed to send leftover radical islamism taughts Wala mulla community which is going against India and constitutional laws....
@@ishainsaan2877 as usual this type of attitude breaks Indian sub continent that's a good thing partition happened.
@@noumanabbasi9547 Yes, but it wasn’t a full partition, was it?
1946 election spoke everything.
Exactly 💯
The only difference is that after partition both East and West Pakistan became Islamic nations but India was forced to become a secular and socialist nation.
so unfortunate that muslims have 57 countries but hindus dont have even one
They didn't stayed back . They all voted for the creation of Pakistan. 95 percent voted for pakistan .
Hatt
Tumhe kisne bola ya?
Zyada sapno me rahte ho
@yaminivishwakarma9928 tu abdul ka bistar garam kar
95% Muzlem voted for Pakistan Creation and Partition of India
but their ancestor voted Jinna to create pakistan and the lyed here to grow population sale bakwas .
So you mean every Muslim voted jinnah? By your logic every hindu supports rss
@@nikhilhadbe271 All these constituency were reserved for muslim candidates and there were also another contesting party Jmate ulema e hind who were against partition but their candidates defeated and Gandhi Nehru compelled to accept Jinna as a sole representative of Indian muslmans, and If every Hindu supports RSS then India can rule world.
@@sanjayjoshi6982 seems like you are just a teen
@@nikhilhadbe271 history remains as it is and those who ignore it deserves its repetition.
@@sanjayjoshi6982 now i know why India lost its status of being "free"
Muslim league got their ancestors vote but they remained here to claim for another partition.
Aisa nahi hai Bhai hum partition ke khilaf the hamen nafrat thi pakistaniyo se
@@daniyalpasha4638 partition k khilaf he hote to muslim league central province,mumbai,bihar and bengal se high majority se 1946 election jeet k nhi aati.tumhare baap daada ne Pakistan ki demand ko he vote kiya tha wo bhe gaddar the or tum bhe gaddar ho. Tum log ne bhe CAA peotest me tumhari asli sakal dikh di h. Tum ko jinnah jaisi aajadi chiye,aasam ko alag kar dene,pakistan jindabad,hinduo ki kabar khudegi shaheen baag ki dharti pe, saale gaddari ka khoon phle bhe tha ab bhe h tumhare ander. Ye truth h , tum moka milte he desh ko toodoge ye sach h.
@Mha PAK ye he to muslims k propaganda h. Delhi riots muslims ne suru kiya. Corona check up me doctors police ko muslims ne pathro lathiyo se maara, lady medical staff se in logo ne batmizzi ki.fir bhe bolte h wo to danga nhi karte h. Saale susro k religion ka respect nhi karte h un ko galiya dete h to phir tum dusro se kyu ummed karte ho. In ko cow slaugher kar k hinduo ko hurt karna h,kya kabhi kisi hinduo ne in ki quarn ko jalaya ya feka kya?? Hindu kabhi nhi karte h har baar ye he suru karte h. Hinduism me jeevo pe daya karna sikhaya h. Animals birds and trees are equal partners of earth and earth is our mother these are the thinkings of hinduism.hum har ek jeev ki respect karte h,lakin ye to saale cow slaughtering karenge wo bhe hum ko chidda k. Owaisi k bhe speach sun le wo kaise muslims ko bhadkata h.
@Mha PAK really communal hatred is finished in Pakistan. Are you sleeping from years. Yes it is decreased because there are no minorities left in Pakistan to commit any genocides or atrocities. They are already finished due to your extremists mind set.
@@daniyalpasha4638 why is that ? And look at the Hindustan now ? You guys deserve everything which is going on in Hindustan , otherwise you have to start demand for a new muslim homeland in Hindustan.
These people chose to live in India only because they did not want to lose their wealth
To rule on India , Political Party still use Divide & Rule Policy😢
So true.
Very true.
Divide and rule and also nowadays alot of divert and rule
Just like congress had been doing for the past 70 years
There are 57 Islamic countries, and none Hindu. And they called Hindu communal...what a joke.
We fought for freedom to have a concept of free India. India's concept covers many classes, color and creed. We are going through a difficult time. It is not only in India but also rest part of the world. I wish, abyss of sinusoidal curve completes its cycle sooner before a breakdown.
people like you are mixing with the hindus alhamdulilah i am not indian but pakistani people like you should not be muslims for supporting a hindu movement and not a islamic movement shame on you
@@syedabdan6895 don't lie quran says to follow the rule of the land so being secular is the best
@@syedabdan6895 fake id andh bhakt spotted 😂😂..
There are 57 Islamic countries, and none Hindu. And they called Hindu communal...what a joke.
I think.. it not correct for you to just spread your negative viewpoint.. India is still secular.. how can there be any doubt in that.. even me as a hindu.. will appeal only to the state.. and there is no guarantee that they would listen just because I am a Hindu.. a very biased and unjust video.. in my view.. I would love to see a video where you show the prosperous side of muslims.. come to bangalore.. equal number of businesses are owned by muslims.. why dont you all show that.. why harping on the old line that muslims are a deprived lot.. i think this kind of video would just divide the country further..
Agree fully
They chose to live in India because the option either to leave or get converted to Islam was not given to them. Freedom of religion was respected. But this wasn't the case for Sikhs and Hindus migrants from Pakistan Puniab. They either had to leave or accept Islam. Leaving Pakistan Punjab financially ruined them. They had to start life from scratch. Property which was alloted was far less than what they had in Pakistan Punjab.
Ab India ko dekho 😎😎😎
We successfully made a great nation ❤️
Irrespective of differences
Make one on the Hindus in Pak too with all recent occurrences.....I dare you.
they might not be treated that good in my country
but they're surely treated somewhat good
Hindus live their lives like equal citizens in Pakistan, nobody is afraid to follow their beliefs over here.
@@malircanttproperties-01 Are you sure about that? Your Karachi's ex-mayor has revealed that Balochis, Hindus and many more are tortured. Get your facts right and don't randomly say shit.
@@malircanttproperties-01 Hey Hey Hey.....nice emotional one
@@indianpatriot1039 when did he say that?
My Father leave india in 1947...... my Uncle live in india Nanotay, Uttar Pardesh. when i compare both brothers life ... i stand with my father bcoz my uncle is not well in india ..
Pakistani govt gave fertile land to Indian Muslims and money
Sab thik hain lekin 95% musalman pakistan ke liye vote kiyu kiya tha😡😡😡
That’s not true, not all of them voted for Pakistan. Elections were only held in certain areas. And there was also incidents of electoral fraud. Turnout was also maybe around 50%.
@@wanderingnomad1 also not all muslims voted...Mainly upper class muslims voted..
They not choose. Nonsense Neharu do this politics for political benifit.
Marathi shouldnot speak for North Indian Muslim...
@@shaad1628 i am North Indian i don't want any muslim in india go Pakistan
@shaad1628 94% Muzlem voted for Pakistan Creation and Partition of India.
It's Muzlem who shouldn't speak about India's affairs, let alone belittling a Marathi, yes I am an Indian from North
Amazing narrative feed to Hindus that Muslims decided to stay back. Here is the reality: 90%+ Indian Muslims in 1946 voted for formation of Pakistan and took 50% of land. Only 50% left for Pakistan and remaining 50% are now 3x in size. Real story is that It was extremely tolerant and secular Hindus who let those 50% stayed back and live peacefully and Muslims community is not at all thankful for that.
Indian muslims k baap dadao ne 1946 election me pakistn ki demand k name pe muslim league ko vote kiya tha. 1946 election result check karo, muslim league mumbai, UP,bihar,bengal se majority me jeet k aayi the. United punjab me to jamindara party ka CM tha or un name sir chootu ram tha. Indian muslims k baap dadao ne he Pakistan banaya tha. In logo ne he hinduo k against muslim league k direct action day ko support kiya tha or bengal UP bihar me hinduo ko marna suru kiya tha. Jab Pakistan ban gaya to ye Pakistan nhi gaye,in k baap dada bhe gaddar the or ye aaj k indian muslims bhe gaddar h. Ye sab CAA protest me dekh bhe liya hoga. Jinnah jaisi aajadi k slogans, aasham ko alag kar denge, hinduo ki kabar khudegi shaheen baag ki dharti pe, Pakistan jindabad. Agar kisi ko in gaddaro ki shakal pahchan me nhi aayi to yaa to wo andha h yaa phir andha hone ka drama kar raha h.
Muslim ke demands poori kaarte kaarte..Hindu aapne jagah aur jameen aur usulon se Bharat pe heee saalo preerit hona pada hai...uske baare maen koi nahi bata hai
"we are afraid to openly speak" then proceeds to openly criticise bjp lmao next joke please
Well said🤣✔️
Muslims who moved to Pakistan on Jinnah's call did the right thing...Hindus( the extremist ones / bhakts)would never let us breathe in India..ALHUMDULILLAH FOR PAKISTAN
Jai Hind! Hindustan Zindabad, shame on those who thought these two religions can't co-exist.
We live here in communal harmony 🇮🇳
Pakistan Zindabad 🇵🇰🇵🇰❤️
I wish all Muslims Jihadists would have left India then we would have been living in peace.
We Pakistani thanks Jinnah for giving us an independent country
*Traitors they were back then, traitors they are, traitors they will be.*
@@shaad1628 This is a public platform. One is free to say whatever one wants as long as it makes sense, unlike you. Why don't you go and f#*k yourself along with your opinion ? Truth hurts, doesn't it, TRAITOR ?
@@adriangaming4853 to me so called secularists are the worst
am proud of my grand-parents who migrated from UP to Pakistan..
And am proud of my great grand parents that they chose to live in India
Proud on Pakistani
Worst mistake ever.
@@Geek1633 just now baj-rang-dal attack a Muslim family in kanpur.. my grandparents took the best decision & save their future generations from Ram-raj
@@makahmed7130 I’m from south side, Kerala. 101% peace guaranteed
Most of the Muslims were jinah and Pakistan supporters in 1947 mainly from central india up bihar mp tn kerela but when Pakistan created they never went there 😄😃😂😀😆hypocrisy ki seema.
14% muslim voted mainly nawabs , jagirdar , rich ppl and left.
@@shaad1628 Source: Trust me bro ?
@@shaad1628 86% of Muslims had voted for the Muslim League in the 1946 provincial elections.
@@adriangaming4853 why muslim major states are in India then?
@@shaad1628 Only Kashmir and Lakshadweep are Muslim-majority territories. Jammu and Kashmir became part of India dur to the Instrument of Accession, and Lakshadweep became because Pakistan didn't stake claim on it. Nevertheless, India never officially accepted the two-nation theory, and that's why Muslim-majority territories are part of India. If India does accepts, then all the millions of Muslims may have to leave.
indian Muslims whose stay in India has real hero. I love & Salam
there not real hero you know who are real hero people who migrated to Pakistan
@Sherlock Holmes i dont blame you well hope your safe there
@@syedabdan6895 real hero is APJ Abdul kalam who is a legend and he is my god.
Why do u hail them as hero ?
@@syedabdan6895 people who migrated from India are called muhajir in pakistan . As per local PUNJABI and SINDHI people came from UP, bihar etc etc are muhajir not a hero.
The Wire waalon, this was heart touching. Muslims are an integral part of India, and constitution treats everyone equally. Lets also make a documentary on the other side, title shall be "pakistani hindus who chose to stay in pakistan". The narrative is incomplete without figuring out the other half.
Baat tho Sahi he
Finally, a sensible comment!!
Haha..waha bache nahi koi ..jallado ne maar dale
There were also Muslims who came to India from Pakistan including the great singers Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan and Muhammad Rafi, writers including Rashid Jahan, Qurratulain Haider, and Ismat Chugtai and more. On the other hand, the Hindus of Amarkot / Umerkot chose to be with Pakistan, as did a huge number of Hindus of the erstwhile East Pakistan. Partition is not entirely the Black and White narrative that both Indians and Pakistanis have been fed.
They all came before independence......
Mohd rafi was born in amritsar and he decided to stay in india he was not born in any part which is now pakistan he worked in lahore for sometime but so did many hindus before 1947
Agreed
@@ubaidshariff4302 No not all of them many of them to went India after independence
My cousins Farah and Tabu left lahore in 1970 for India,Jamil Hashmi is my second uncle
agar muslim India me nhi rehta to khokhla kaise hota India?
Apne religion mai bhi lower caste aur upper caste hai politicians ko politics hi karna hai
@@nikhilhadbe271 baat to sahi hai lekin casteism dhire dhire khatam ho raha hai,aur mulle din prati din kattar ho rahe hai,mai yadav hu mai bhi koi brahman nhi hu
@@amankumar-xk8je are bhai agar Muslim nahi hote toh hamara desh kaisa hota toh shayad se thoda aur behtar hota lekin ek dar ye hota hai ki agar ek religion hi bohot jyada number mai ho toh uss religion ke priest apni chalane lagte hai politics mai unke fayde ke liye
@@nikhilhadbe271 aisa kuch nhi hai abhi bhi 80% hai lekin kaha hinduo ki jyada chalti hai
@@amankumar-xk8je kyuki opposition is trying to do minority appeasement rahul gandhi is accused of it so many time if there is no minority the leaders of our religion will have profit 100%
23% of minorities in Pakistan shrunk to 2% they didn't get to choose 🙏
Ok then why did Muslims vote for a separate country if they didn't want to leave?
Hinduo ko chutiya banane ke liye aur nehru liyakat pact.in 1945 election nearly 95%muslim voted for muslim leage.in 1945 muslim population in United India was 24.6% and they got nearly 25% land still nealy most of muslim stayed in India except punjab.
@@bhaveshtontiya7152 exactly ye musalmaan aisa nahi hai nahi jaa rahe the Transportation Facility nahi thi uss samay hum Hindu bewakoof the aur aaj bhi hai ye maine Troll karne ke liye nahi likha ye sach hai uss samay jaativad aur zyada mazbut tha Hindu Tolerant bhi hai issliye humne nahi nikaala inhe maarke aur ye apni properties ko chhordna nahi chahte the aur ye uncertain the apne future ko leke isliye aadha parivaar idhar rehta tha aur dusra half udhar chala jaata tha to find Property and living agar pakistan ya India me kisi bhi ek Country me Situation acchi kharab hui to ye waha chal jaayenge jaha Situation acchi hogi ye log urdu impose kar rahe the aur Nehru liakat Pact ke baad galti thi humari jo ye yaha bach gaye inhone Doctor Apj Abdul Kalam bahut kam diye hai osama zyada paida kiye hai Baluchistan se Assam aur Kashmir se Tamilnadu pure United India ka 30% Land inhe mila jabki ye the 24% kuch something aur uske bawajud bhi 16% muslims pakistani citizen bane yaani bacche hue 8 ya 9 percent yahi reh gaye partition jo hua Indian muslims ke liye seperate country banane ke liye jab ban hi gaya tha pakistan to idhar rehne kyu diya gaya inhe pakistan bana tha ki dar ul islam aur islamic ruke caliphate ke liye ye ek religious struggle islamic seperatism tha uss samay ye 24 percent the pure United India ke aaj ye phir United India banao ye 45% hogaye hai to aakhir me murkh aur bewakoof kaun bana Hindu aur Sikh hi na Sikho ka Ancestral aur Holy Land chals gaya ye Sikh Afghanistan se leke Bihar tak phelle hue the aue ek Fact batata hu aaj ke jo pakistan ke areas hai yaha major demand nahi thi pakistan ki kabhi Sindhi Punjabi Pathan Baluch aur to aur Kashmiri ne pakistan nahi maanga tha aur yaha bhi kuchh Support mila hoga baad me Sindh Punjab me par jo ek dum Clean Majority aur Major Support hota hai wo nahi tha aur Khyber me Pashtuno ne Congress ki sarkar banai thi ye wo ilaaka hai jo 99 percent musalmaan hai baluchistaan alag Desh banna chahta tha Basha Khan Abdul Ghaffar joki Frontier Gandhi ke naam se Famous hai unke baare me pado
@Hitman yes
My great grandparents decided to stay back in India at partition. But they never thought their futuregenerations will have to pay the price for their mistake with their blood. This is a completely different India which was promised by Nehru and Gandhi. Communal hatred is on the rise and is slowly destroying the country.
So bye then
All you see is religion
Then go to your pakistan
while history proved that the people who moved to Pakistan, were right in their decision.
Tu bhi ja
Ok If you feel better and secure there than you can also leave india no body stops you.
Vese bhi pakistan muslim logo ke liye hi banaya gaya tha.
you also welcome to leave India now.
Go to Pakistan or we will kick u out by NRC, CAA
Its very touching as a documentary but the hard fact is that for 99% Muslims all around the world, nothing is more important then their holy book. No country, no constitution, no peace and no law. Now mix it with the hyper illiteracy and there you have an highly explosive material. The problem is not with Muslims but with their interpretation of Qur'an. They are all stuck with medivial age mind set and due to zero reforms in their theocratic religion, you will never see any improvement. Its a problem with a mindset and whenever and wherever that mindset start multiplying in majority, you start seeing oppression and conflicts. Anyhow, Peace to the entire humanity !!🙏
And I bet if a video like that is made on non migrating Hindus in Pakistan, it can only be done through planchet....
@Apurva Kumar planchet mtlab 😃... Jisse vut bulate hai... Candle jalake, hath pakadke etc..
Par pakistan bnva lia aur Ab ise bhi kabza krna chahte h
Can't thank Allah enough for creating Pakistan and making our ancestors migrate to Pakistan
Yes even we are thankful to your Allah. He took all the garbage to Pakistan
Desh ka sher thoda reh gaya yahan jo bahut badbu karta hai india me, unhe bhi le jao yahan se
get lost now!!
We are secular and always will be .inshallah
You dont need to say Inshallah to prove secularism
Great.. We will become the greatest country in the world... Burnol to Pakistan
Inshaallah.....seriously man.
Chup boss DK
What a secular who do shastra puja on rafale fighter but didn't let any other minority to do like this with jet what a secular country with changing names of historical sites and cities from Muslims to Hindu
Plant trees, be vegetarian & kind to animals.
@Bhanu Pratap Singh dikkat kya hai aapko.. ki log jeena chahte hai apne watan me apni marzi se apno ke sat sukoon se.. bardasht nai hota dusro ka chain sukoon.. fir wo hindu ho ya Muslim... tum tumare jaise log zindagi bhar bhugtoge.. bhagwan chodega nahi tumhe tumne jo khoon bahaya begunaho ka us ke liye
Anuj Verma they will boycott you first 🙁
Very Good my brother ,keep it up .Your ideas are the silver lining among the dark clouds of communalism and hated.
It is sad n disgusting that riots were happened in BJP, congress n almost in all parties govt n so does the mob lynching..... Now who to elect???
Do you know what is direct action day moment started by muslim league?? Did you read about sorabhvardi he was mayor or Kolkata he dis the genocide of 40-50k innocent hindus. It was bigger mass killing compare to hitler did against zews. This is acknowledged by British parliament but its yet not acknowledged by indians. Read about nookhali genocide by muslims. And one this punjab sindh and khyper pakhtunkhwa disnt support muslim league demand and they didn't vote muslim league in 1946. Jinnah"s constituency was mumbai aub area bhaykalla and mumrah. And muslim league wins in majority in up,bihar,mumbai and bengal. Aaj k indian muslims k baap dadao ne he direct action day ko support kiya tha .
The first thing Indian Muslims must do is stop dressing as Arabs and having Arab names. Dress like Indians, Speak like Indians, Have names like Indians, You will be recognized as Indians !!! Indian Muslims had their Unique Mughal identity for over 1000 years but lately since past 50 years, Wahaabi and Sunni Islam is creeping in from Middle East.
There are more Muslim women wearing Burqa (A Foreign dress) in India today than anytime in Indian History, Mughal women wore beautiful Salwar Kameez (A Fusion of Veil and Saree), Not Burqa.
So Hindus fear they are losing the identity of their Nation and finding themselves living in a strange country.. How will you like it if a Guest comes to your house and lives with you and starts changing your furniture and doing what he wish in your house without asking you ? This is the same feeling Hindus have for Muslims today !!!
To make it better, Muslims must be the ones to compromise and learn to adopt to Hindu culture and values (I'm not talking about converting to Hinduism but to have mutual tolerance and respect to Basic Hindu customs and food habits). And please don't tell me India is Secular Nation, It might be but Majority of India is still Hindus, One needs to accept this fact without any Prejudices ! Do this and before you know it, Maybe in 100 years from now, Islam would be known for its own unique version - "Indian Islam", Which will be Great and unique in its own way :)
Just my suggestion, As an Indian Atheist.
MelodicNostalgic more like American culture is coming to India lol. But what u are saying is spot on
Media is a very powerful tool. In an hour long interview if they must have spoken 45 min good about India, how they like India, and 15 min about how and why they dont like it here.. the editor must have smartly choosen only what it wants from those 15 mins and happily ignored the rest 45 mins.
It is our duty not to get influenced with such videos and start posting "hate" comments. They want you to do this so that they can use it and prove their point.
Instead, what we can do is, post few interviews or video links which show that these guys have shown only one sided view and they are not doing a good thing.
I’m an Indian Muslim living in the uk , really interesting story
Same I’m an Indian Muslim living in Uk as well for some reason we get a lot of hatred from Pakistanis but I don’t understand we’re the complete same but their ancestors chose to leave India mine didn’t
@@shujathmasood4185 I'm Pakistani living in the UK and I have never given you guys hatred in my eyes we are one and the same. I feel a lot of pain when I see what is happening to my brother's and sisters under BJP
Cerulean Stallion thank you my brother we are all the same at the end of the day we were all one country at once but separated by British my prayers go out to you my bro🙏🏾
@@CeruleanStallion Its sad you still go on religion and feel sad for muslims. We as Indians feel bad and stand for every wrong done to every indian, whether its Muslim / sikh/Christian/Hindu.. it does not matter, this if the hard core difference between Pakistani's and Indians. Hindus stand with muslims for all protest, Hindu lawyers take up muslim cases for free and fight for them, muslim hindus make groups together and fight any equality and injustice. We stand together inspite of religion, as humans, as one, as indians.
You should start feeling bad and raising your voice for your minorities there, who are fleeing to India and asking for protection even in 2020. Your pain is limited to your religion, which is an even sadder thing, and that also in bits and pieces, no pain for balochi muslims, no pain for ahmediya muslims.. who are under muslim leader. .
@@AnonymousChaos10 the sad thing is you have no religion my religion is Islam i stand with equality but as Jinnah said Hindus where killing Muslims and British where too and still are the Christians are killing us everyday too the french are killing us too everybody is killing us we want peace but you guys hate us everybody hates even animals are not treated this badly then us and the one thing is even if you say you support us who knows in your heart you might hate us so there cannot be peace and i do not know why is it because of our religion we get killed everyday
Alhamdullilah Muslims have a shared a great living with Hindus and other communities in India. This is a phase the whole country is going thru. India has a history of more then 5000 years and nothing will happen to this beautiful nation. People who stayed back made the right choice, muslims thrive in India unlike in Pakistan. We as a community should be blamed for the poverty as we didn't give education the priority but still you see muslims of India contributing in science, sports, education, medicine, islamic scholorly work, arts, etc. Insha Allah, things will alright soon.
Don't worry dear we are very very happy in our beautiful Pakistan and are contributing to our country in a positive way..we love Pakistan....you worry about your country....
😂😂😂
I’m friends with many Indian Muslims in UAE. Those who live in South India says that everything is fine nothing to worry being Muslim in South. Similarly, North Indian Muslims says that they have pretty much normal lives like other Indians although some fear in mind is always there. Not because we are being harassed or threaten but we see some incidents on TV or hate speech which may trigger riots or clashes.
I challenge you 'the wire'make on video on 1946 elections and their results.
Muslims overwhelmingly supported pakistan and were central to the loss of a large part of traditional Bharat. The well to do left. The majority of those who stayed behind were actually unable to make the journey. They was no anti pakistan movement or protests amongst the muslims of India. INDIAN Muslims believe Hinduism to be a false set of beliefs and draw a majority of their philosophy from middle ages Arabia. Many of their ancestors supported the destruction of Indian temples, the imposition of jazia and conversion. Now they want the love of the majority! They speak of tolerance and secularism which they have enjoyed in India. Muslims have provided neither to anyone where they are in a majority. Partition was the best thing that happened. India would not have set a course for intellectual technical and economic progress with a significantly larger Muslim population. These are facts. Deal with them.
After voting for Pakistan in 1947 you choose to stay !
Partition agar religion ki vajah se hua tha to pak ko muslim desh milgaya par hindu ko kya mila? Secular islamic desh?😃 kyuki majority to yaha desh me minority banke reh gayi hai
1946 ki voting percentage dek lo kiskis area mei jita tha muslim league ne....ap hindu loge research karo pata chal jayga porkistan ke germs kinke andar bhare the
Love seeing loyalty from Indian Muslims towards India. I wish if your forefathers were as loyal as you are showing here. During election 1946, Muslim league swept elections from northen india with the promise of a promised land. While Muslim league struggled in the election from present areas in Pakistan. My question is why did they vote in favor of division while they knew that the new state won't include Muslim minority areas of India? Do you know that still we whose parents migrated to Pakistan, are considered as Hindustanis?
Muhajirs were given a lollipop of “riyasat-e-Medina” but alas it was dominated by the punjabis. Mujahirs would have fared better had they stayed in India. It left a vacuum in muslim leadership in north India, and so muslims suffered there. The Muhajirs were considered as “Indian” in Pakistan. So muslims of UP suffered on both sides.
I have met a lot of Muhajirs outside India and i feel connected to them. We still speak the same Lucknawi language, eat the same foods and have the same culture. But I live in my homeland whereas they live far away, disconnected with their identity.
BJP has proven the Concerns of Quaid E Azam was right.
Jinnah's predictions were still proven wrong. He thought there won't be oppression in Pakistan.
No its not , they re still living here, dont woryy we will make them flee and make jinnah right . R u happy now
Muslims are very well off and prosperous in Deccan and south India when compared to the hateful and communal North India..
They are predominant in Hyderabad (Deccan) which has a very strong muslim presence throughout the city.
So that is the reason Owaisi said he will kill Hindus in 15 min
Because south suffered less from invasions,....U can't i ignore past. Past always have an People behaviour, society structure
@@pavankiran4719 exactly. Some people are just too naive to understand the reason behind the regional behaviors. While the whole of north fought for the freedom without caring for their lives and education, the south, mostly, was chill. This is why north lacks education. Also the riots were way higher in north India during partition. Whole of north was under Islamic rulers for a long period of time. During this time the Hindus, although being majority, suffered atrocities by the Muslim rulers.
Shivang Yadav Hyderabad was under the rule of tipu isn’t he?
@@comictube1831 Hyderabad has no connections with tipu.. Asif jahi dynast ruled over Deccan.
Divide the country and choose to stay , nice move sir!
Why didn't they migrate to Pakistan now they're living with fear 😨😨
@@mohyuddinattari8698 there grandparents had to remember for their childrens future
@@mohyuddinattari8698 bhaii plss 🙏🙏 jaoo na Pakistan tere zaroorat bhi nahi hai india ko
Kabhi Pakistan me jaake hinduon se bhi poochlena unke saath kya hua tha. Oh wait. Unhone to Hindu chore hi nai uncle.
Akash Chhikara ...akash mai yai nahi kahuu ga k pak mai sarai hindu buhat achizindagi guzaar rahai hain.....hindu ju sindh mai business mai hain wo buhat achi life huzaar rahai hain...hah ju loog thar ki taraf hain wo hindu ho ya muslim wo zada tar gareeb hain q k waha oppurtunities kam hain...ab wo hi loog india ki taraf abhi bhi migrate kartay hain...samjhtain hain k wo jannat hai..waha taraki kar lai gain likin waha bhi unhai kuch nahi milta..same jab partition huwa tha ju muslim indian mai gareeb thai unhu nai us tym pak mai akar buhat taraki kari...likin ab koi ayai ga tu koi faida nahi...
Tum documentary search karo interior sindh mai buhat educated aur business walai sindhi hindu beshumaar hain ju kabhi bhi apni zameen chornai ka tasuwar bhi nahi kartai..
achcha kitni bar pakistan gaye ho miya?
\
Tum ney dekhaa haa jaker,
If they are living very well , why are they coming to india and not going back . And i can see news whwere their daughters are kidnapped and raped , married and converted
Satya Sarma sanghi chutiya
Uncertainty? We have almost 19 crore muslims.. Do they all live in fear?
Pakistan had 10%+ Hindu population now it's less than 1%. If we weren't secular ppl story would have been different.
And those beef problem and all nothing like that happens in South India all we need is to educate more people.
@Ankit Kumar Yeah, Muslims in India are more than in Pakistan. let's say it's around 25-30 Cr. then indian muslim's are defenitly 30-40 Cr. (Lot's of illegal's like rohigya's are being bought in by people like Mamta and Owasi).
the comment i made was 3 year's ago. Now i know the That muslim's are between 30-40 Cr.
Love and Respect are never demanded.. They are earned.. Why doesn't Muslim family(specially Sunni) allow their girl to get married to a hindu? Why does few Muslim try to scare off people other religions in the name of Jahannum and Jannat? Why is Religion above the country? Why does few mufti give fatwas against almost anything?
Stereotyping few instances of fear among Muslims to overall insecurity of Muslims is not fair..I have many muslim friends who have been playing among us since our childhood and also many who are working even at higher positions.
APJ Abdul Kalam, Azim Premji, Irfan Pathan, Mohammad Kaif,Adnan Sami , Syed Akbaruddin are all Indians and they have made India proud and I as an India am also proud of them.
Jai Hind
Pleased to see you have concern for Muslims and their condition post partition. Wish you make a similar effort on kashmiri hindus post their hounding and ethnic cleansing post 1990.
We must convert all hindus to muslims and make India as Central Pakistan and then capture East Pakistan and finally capture all the territories
That's such an absurd video, supporting only 1 side of the story, I am not saying that they didn't face the worst days. It was also the story of the other party (Hindus).
If it is such a non polarised video and was made with good intentions then why did they mentioned Yogi's and Modi's name in it? Did they forget the fact that they came by a democratic process? These people had their roots attached to Congress and no wonder why they are talking ill about Modi and Yogi. They talked about Aklakh, after the forensic report, it was proved that he was carrying cow beef in that bag/polythene, which according to Supreme court of India is illegal (I agree that mobocracy was not the right step, but wasn't he broke the law) and those media houses Barkha aur Rajdeep waale, where did they go after forensic report?
Anyway, about partition: It was the failure of Congress and Gandhi that Jinnah got away with a separate country like Pakistan. In my views Jinnah was a better leader then these 2. He was a better barrister than Nehru and Gandhi that he got what he wanted. Just to let u know some facts, Jinnah was a 2nd generation Muslim, his grandfather was a marwadi from Gujrat and his father got converted to Muslim.
Yes they came in power through democratic process but only if u knew 80% of India's population is hindu so u get my point..
Yogi and modis name because there was only 1 case of murder in the name of gau raksha in 2013 and 2 in 2014 but it is on a hype after 2014... so u know what changed in these years.. the government right...
Yogi openly supported the the cow vigilantes didn't he? They were supporting him in his rally right na?
Modi never criticizes his ministers or punishes them or removes them from power for creating violence against muslims does he?
Im talking about facts which u should know before passing statements!
@Chiinneikim Kipgen you don't read news my friend, besides that, action speaks louder than words
Having my roots from UP always wondered what happened in that time Line that made my Grand Parents migrate to Pakistan, certainly they made the right choice they had the vision for there future generations thanks a lot Grand Parents love you a lot
Long Live Pakistan
Yes brother ur grand parents were wise.Now hindus r killing us indian muslim.u r lucky to be born in pakistan.
@@asifasumi8189
May God bless you , protect you and bring you Ease Sis...If possible, try to migrate .
Joshi Sahib its evident that you are obsessed with Muslims and there rule in Sub Continent
May god ease your pain
Look whos talking one more mentally obsessed person
Stay blessed stay happy I pray for you to god
@@asifasumi8189 Thanks Asifa stay blessed stay safe time will change inshallaha
3 reasons for the independence of Pakistan 1 Islam 2 two nation theory that we both are entirely different from each other 3 is the majority of the hindus in India that they will always in power in a damocratic India PAKISTAN ZINDABAD I AM BALOCH AND I LOVE PAKISTAN PAKISTAN ZINDABAD
Don't think this article reflects reality just based on some random speakers. British suggested peaceful population exchange on the model of Turkish and Greek population exchange that happened right after the formation of modern Turkey.
Why would Jinnah not press for this model of population exchange? It probably would have repatriated the sale proceeds legally and people would have happily moved. Those who wished and did not move would be considered to be compliant with whatever model the country would later on adapt and not press for any special rights/privileges.
It clearly would have avoided the unnecessary bloodshed and animosity because of which our development is getting dragged down.
I love how these folks are involved in philosophical gibberish after cutting our country and literally threatening us in every way.
@Simm JJ Fighting what, man ? I'm just stating just some facts which are non-sugarcoated and non-appeasing. Can't really pretend to be delusional when things are all in front of you.
@Simm JJ Where the heck is "hate" here ? Truth hurts, doesn't it ?
This is a very old tactic of LWs. When persons of the opposite political learnings speaks something slightly provoking, you label it hate speech. However, when you folks speak something provocative, that's freedom of speech. You guys always think you have one thing but you don't have that - moral supremacy. This is textbook example of hypocrisy.
@Simm JJ This thing isn't about Muslim vs Hindu. This thing is about the Muslims, pro-Muslims and LWs vs the Nationalists, the non-religious RW nationalists. Stop portraying Narsinghdanand and his bigot party as nationalists. That's what the thing is, when Narsinghdanand, Waseem Rizvi aka Jitendra Tyagi, Kalicharan Mahraj said something, all of them are now behind bars on the charge of "hate speech" which is great and justifiable. Had similar things been said by Muslims, and LWs, all of you would have humped in to justify how it's not hate speech and comes under freedom of speech. No matter to how much extent one commits an act of treason, it will always be justified by you folks as an act of dissent. And by the way, if you go and researchers instead of engaging in fruitless debate with me, you would realize that this channel, The Wire, a pro LW news portal, has already reported vociferously against that so called _"Dharm Sansad"._
Sell your soul to these people, these folks have never been loyal to India, never will be. And the legacy of "Muslim betrayal" has got nothing to do with Hindu vigilantism. The current government came in 2014, Muslims and nationalists have been at odd with each other since 1947.
@@adriangaming4853 articulated very perfectly bro
Please make a video about erstwhile Hindu neighborhood of Lahore.
We dont have shits here
@@03217517675 You are the reason Mob lynching happening here. Thank you for showing your communal hatred
Indian Muslims are 4th class citizens and proud to be so. Tells you what kind of ambition these people have. Muslims being ghulams to Hindus. Even their pride is gone.
Yeah just several companies like Wipro and Cipla were founded by muslims, so what. What about the condition of the majority of muslims in India. Shows how narrowly you think, it is not a comprehensive development, but only few out of hundreds of millions. How many muslim students become doctors and engineers and scientists in India. Very few.
It happened for good that most middle-class and upper-class Muslims left as they were the ones who voted for the Muslim League. Their presence in India would have been harmful to the secular Indian state.
It's time for the Muslims living in India to leave their religion or reform it, and secular parties and media to stop being pro-Islam and anti-Hindu. Intolerance by the radical Muslim community and appeasement by the secular parties are the reasons for the rise of the Hindutva nationalism.
May God Bless india, Unite India. India for All