ohmygod what you said at the end broke me completely. 'when she had no one she had joe, but now when she has everyone by her side, she doesn't have joe' thats so true and just ironically heartbreaking😭😭😭😭
:( poor girl omfg. She looks so empty when she sings about him. In general tbh. Incredibly talented woman, but in sm pain bc of this breakup. And I hope that in some way she can heal from this. Its crazy how sometimes we ruin the best thing in our lives :( And it’s all happening while she’s at the park of her career 😭
My heart hurts for her to sing these songs that meant so much. And then time goes on, and change has to happen. She has to have some super powers to sing these songs over and over every show and give her fans the most authentic expression possible, even when she has to heal and move on. I want to give her a huge hug and tell her only sing the songs that bring you joy. But, she helps so many "see" "hear" and feel these heart songs and it's truly a gift that she puts her heart in songs and shares them with all her fans. All of this is pretty special! Bless her!
I wouldn't say she wrote 5 albums about Joe. I would say she has various songs ON 5 albums about her relationship with Joe. #2.13-2.18, was exactly what I was going to say! I write my comments as I watch- so even if others have written the same thing, I take it that we have a similar interpretation, but at least I know I'm trying to be objective and non biased, by another person. The fact that you also saw her trying to rush through the most important and happy songs about Joe, makes me happy. NOT because of the breakup and heartbreak, I have to add! I meant "happy that we made the same observation, so I AM NOT, going crazy". I have Netflix and have watched her joy, when she performs "CIWYW". I think she did the acoustic version in Paris too, which was also great- vocally, musically and emotionally, with joy. I personally suspect that they broke up a couple of months prior to the official public announcement, but after several years, and the reason for the break up, if one person wanted out, it does not necessarily mean that there's a hero and a villain who broke her heart- it could be a change in feelings and growing apart. It also makes sense, that even if she chose to leave, it doesn't mean it doesn't hurt. Sorry for the rambling! I wouldn't say necessarily that Joe didn't want to marry her. Just if certain songs on Midnights ARE about Joe. If you look at Midnight Rain from that pov, the chorus says, "He wanted a bride, I was making my own name, chasing that fame he stayed the same." It fits with what her team has said in that they grew apart and it was amicable.They wanted different things, and especially the comments about him not being able to handle her fame. We Brits are like that generally and privacy is something as a culture, that most of us hold dear to out hearts. Well I am very pleased with your conclusion, and I hope you can see from what I've written that we may disagree on little details, but as an overall picture, we're on the same page. I think a few final important things to point out, 1. She had somebody who "liked her for her", "loves her like she's brand new", when she needed that support. 2. "There was happiness before her, there was happiness because of her...there was happiness because of him, there'll be happeniness after her". Her story of falling in love, and later on breaking up, is not unique to her. I think people put celebs on such a high pedestal, that ANY pain they go through, is like a witch-hunt for someone to blame for the pain. Of course it is heartbreaking and I wish them BOTH well. She seemed to mature, be more creative, and found someone to love and be loved for a while, to let those processes happen. It's a sad part of the human experience. We've all been there at some point. I know I have. I feel sad for anyone in the middle of that experience. Interesting video, so I like you shall get 😉
As someone who is here almost a year after this video was made I have some perspective. It seems to me that Joe gave her a place to hide when the whole world was crashing due to Kanye and Kim. And that was nice of him. Shelter from the storm. But, from what I have seen and heard the relationship was on the rocks for over two years. They tried working it out but, wanted and needed different things. She was going crazy stuck in the house all the time and no social life. He despised social life. He seemed like a nice guy and was a fun collaborator for songs but, they were too different and wanted things where there was no compromise. Taylor just past her year anniversary with Kelce. They are going super strong. He has been very good for Taylor. He has her laughing and having fun. He is supportive and caring. He buys her a lot of gifts. He just remodeled the kitchen in his mansion just for Taylor when she comes as stays there for a few months before wrapping up her Eras tour completely. Taylor and Kelce seem to be much better suited. They are extroverted. Love to laugh and be with friends. They seem to be on the same wavelength. It's a good match
I'm hoping it works out with Travis Kelce. But I don't think it will ever rise to the love she had for Joe Alwyn. That happens often. She seems like a lovely girl, I hope she finds happiness.
If Travis could stay with her through this grief, he might have a chance. It is not easy, especially for men, to be with someone who's clearly still loves and grieves an ex. It takes a big humility to stay with her, to hold her hands, to console her. Even if the man would do that, it's not guaranteed that the woman would fully accept him at the end. Happened with Pete Davidson and Ariana Grande. I hope it would be better for Taylor though.
People assuming they know what this girl is feeling,,why keep bringing up her exs when shes in a relationship i dont think you all know the damage this can cause,,shes with travis now just leave them to sort things out,before you all ruin her life with crazy assumptions.
It is heartbreakingly true. The same woman who, 13 years later, put John Meyer on blast *again* with devastating lyrics like "I regret you all the time" has not written a single bad word about Joe. Somehow, that's worse than if he had done something awful.
She is having fun with Travis, he is head over heels for her. She is trying. I'm not sure if she loves him or ever will. I think she loved Joe and probably still does.
She loved and adored Joe but she couldn't breathe with him, because he always had her on her tiptoes, he was breadcrumbing love to her. I think she loves Travis in a more relaxed way in which he already feels like her family, her husband.
Now she can sing these songs with joy and happiness bcuz she has Travis kelce who isn’t intimidated by her superstardom. She can sing these songs and think of Travis instead.😊
Taylor looks completely different now. She messes up and her face looks robotic. No tender eyes, they are gone. I’ve never seen Taylor end a relationship and it's over. Don't get it, it's Taylor Swift. Taylor’s less than emotional expressions. DO NOT GET IT AT ALL. And I think her being brought to the stage in a black box is also really weird. Do not understand her anymore.
@@lynn8836right? It just means the emotions behind them were real. If she would just make generic bubblegum-pop, she could sing them without getting emotional, but would that be better? I don't think so. Genuine songwriting based on own experiences comes at a cost, but it is totally worth it imo.
ohmygod what you said at the end broke me completely. 'when she had no one she had joe, but now when she has everyone by her side, she doesn't have joe' thats so true and just ironically heartbreaking😭😭😭😭
Thank you for noticing! ❤️
Anyone here when I can do it with a broken hear was released for TTPD?
👇
I know that’s so cool that she really put she can do it with a broken heart and I could do it with a broken heart is one of my favorites
Omg she named a song after this video!
wasn't this video made after the song?
@@Valentina-km6gpno. the somg was released 4 months ago and this vid was posted 11 months ago. it was just a coincidence lol
the song wasn’t even made then
Are you still alive taylor literally wrote a song "I can do it with a broken heart"?!?!
Whoa. Your comment realized me that this video has been uploaded before ttpd 😮 what a coincidence.
Yah I miss the giggles and excitement same as before when she sings the songs about him
:( poor girl omfg. She looks so empty when she sings about him. In general tbh. Incredibly talented woman, but in sm pain bc of this breakup. And I hope that in some way she can heal from this. Its crazy how sometimes we ruin the best thing in our lives :( And it’s all happening while she’s at the park of her career 😭
My heart hurts for her to sing these songs that meant so much. And then time goes on, and change has to happen.
She has to have some super powers to sing these songs over and over every show and give her fans the most authentic expression possible, even when she has to heal and move on. I want to give her a huge hug and tell her only sing the songs that bring you joy. But, she helps so many "see" "hear" and feel these heart songs and it's truly a gift that she puts her heart in songs and shares them with all her fans. All of this is pretty special! Bless her!
I wouldn't say she wrote 5 albums about Joe. I would say she has various songs ON 5 albums about her relationship with Joe.
#2.13-2.18, was exactly what I was going to say! I write my comments as I watch- so even if others have written the same thing, I take it that we have a similar interpretation, but at least I know I'm trying to be objective and non biased, by another person. The fact that you also saw her trying to rush through the most important and happy songs about Joe, makes me happy. NOT because of the breakup and heartbreak, I have to add! I meant "happy that we made the same observation, so I AM NOT, going crazy". I have Netflix and have watched her joy, when she performs "CIWYW". I think she did the acoustic version in Paris too, which was also great- vocally, musically and emotionally, with joy. I personally suspect that they broke up a couple of months prior to the official public announcement, but after several years, and the reason for the break up, if one person wanted out, it does not necessarily mean that there's a hero and a villain who broke her heart- it could be a change in feelings and growing apart. It also makes sense, that even if she chose to leave, it doesn't mean it doesn't hurt. Sorry for the rambling!
I wouldn't say necessarily that Joe didn't want to marry her. Just if certain songs on Midnights ARE about Joe. If you look at Midnight Rain from that pov, the chorus says, "He wanted a bride, I was making my own name, chasing that fame he stayed the same." It fits with what her team has said in that they grew apart and it was amicable.They wanted different things, and especially the comments about him not being able to handle her fame.
We Brits are like that generally and privacy is something as a culture, that most of us hold dear to out hearts.
Well I am very pleased with your conclusion, and I hope you can see from what I've written that we may disagree on little details, but as an overall picture, we're on the same page.
I think a few final important things to point out, 1. She had somebody who "liked her for her", "loves her like she's brand new", when she needed that support.
2. "There was happiness before her, there was happiness because of her...there was happiness because of him, there'll be happeniness after her".
Her story of falling in love, and later on breaking up, is not unique to her. I think people put celebs on such a high pedestal, that ANY pain they go through, is like a witch-hunt for someone to blame for the pain. Of course it is heartbreaking and I wish them BOTH well. She seemed to mature, be more creative, and found someone to love and be loved for a while, to let those processes happen. It's a sad part of the human experience. We've all been there at some point. I know I have. I feel sad for anyone in the middle of that experience. Interesting video, so I like you shall get 😉
You are absolutely being subjective and biased. You are defending Joe.
She did heal though out the eras tour. remeber how she was when she was preforming champain problems but vs now she look so hapopy
i remember katty perry during her concert and she broke up w/ her bf and cried a lot on back stage.
Just saying Taylor won’t cry about the breakup but the way she expresses the songs will make us realise how sad she is
As someone who is here almost a year after this video was made I have some perspective.
It seems to me that Joe gave her a place to hide when the whole world was crashing due to Kanye and Kim. And that was nice of him. Shelter from the storm. But, from what I have seen and heard the relationship was on the rocks for over two years. They tried working it out but, wanted and needed different things. She was going crazy stuck in the house all the time and no social life. He despised social life.
He seemed like a nice guy and was a fun collaborator for songs but, they were too different and wanted things where there was no compromise.
Taylor just past her year anniversary with Kelce. They are going super strong. He has been very good for Taylor. He has her laughing and having fun. He is supportive and caring. He buys her a lot of gifts. He just remodeled the kitchen in his mansion just for Taylor when she comes as stays there for a few months before wrapping up her Eras tour completely.
Taylor and Kelce seem to be much better suited. They are extroverted. Love to laugh and be with friends. They seem to be on the same wavelength.
It's a good match
I’m worried about when the tour is over.
Now she has another lover to sing for ❤
I'm hoping it works out with Travis Kelce. But I don't think it will ever rise to the love she had for Joe Alwyn. That happens often. She seems like a lovely girl, I hope she finds happiness.
If Travis could stay with her through this grief, he might have a chance. It is not easy, especially for men, to be with someone who's clearly still loves and grieves an ex. It takes a big humility to stay with her, to hold her hands, to console her. Even if the man would do that, it's not guaranteed that the woman would fully accept him at the end. Happened with Pete Davidson and Ariana Grande. I hope it would be better for Taylor though.
I can do it with a broken heart!
I don’t know how she does it
Which one?
@@Mike-t2c7u singing all of the songs she wrote about Joe. Especially Lover and Cornelia Street
Performing amd connecting with fans is part of her therapy.
People assuming they know what this girl is feeling,,why keep bringing up her exs when shes in a relationship i dont think you all know the damage this can cause,,shes with travis now just leave them to sort things out,before you all ruin her life with crazy assumptions.
It is heartbreakingly true. The same woman who, 13 years later, put John Meyer on blast *again* with devastating lyrics like "I regret you all the time" has not written a single bad word about Joe. Somehow, that's worse than if he had done something awful.
Yeah . I think they just fell out of love and thats fine
"Has not written a single bad word about Joe" - yet...
@@arnold3768 But i gotta say one thing, no one can make me hate that man 🗣️🗣️
@@Darlingiamscared I don't hate him but it was so clear to me that they were not compatible with each other.
@@arnold3768 Thats true
She is having fun with Travis, he is head over heels for her. She is trying. I'm not sure if she loves him or ever will. I think she loved Joe and probably still does.
She loved and adored Joe but she couldn't breathe with him, because he always had her on her tiptoes, he was breadcrumbing love to her. I think she loves Travis in a more relaxed way in which he already feels like her family, her husband.
Like you said he is head over heels for her. Joe never loved her like that.
@@laclochardshe loves Travis have you not seen her with him....how she looks at him
That False God performance on SNL is one of her best.
Leaveing joe kid was the best move ever
2:57 it's like in the fortnight music video
She's happier now than she's ever been. Let's hope Travis is forever.
Now she can sing these songs with joy and happiness bcuz she has Travis kelce who isn’t intimidated by her superstardom. She can sing these songs and think of Travis instead.😊
No Video ever broke my Heart that heard, I‘m so glad she‘s on Tour and she has her swifties with her 😭😭❤️❤️💔💔
She has Travis now 😍
I was there when she sang daylight!!
yah it's heartbreaking to tay2x imagine singing that song reminds him you really forgot the nxt lyrics bcoz of it.
Is it just me or do I feel like Travis is the one, I know we would have all felt this for all of her other boyfriends but this just feels right.
She's with Travis Kelce now. Smiling all the time.
Omg you manifested this
The best part is that I didnt even know that taylor dated joe alwyn because i didnt know who he was. And now i still only know him as "lover guy" 💀
She was the most inspired (5 albums), the prettiest when she was with Joe.
As an artist who rights deeply personal songs she knows it’s a cross she has to bare.
It’s so sad 😭
Joe never came up to scratch but that's ok because Karma is the guy on the Chiefs, coming home to her.
im hoping that they get back together one day
And she literally has a song “I Can Do It With A Broken Heart”
I AM STILL NOT OVER THIS 😭
Wish her the best ❤️
I love Taylor
She didn't want to marry him. Not the other way around.
@DominqueGarofolo
That was the impression I got too.
@@npats550 no offense to him but WHY would she be tied down like that when she's embarking on a world tour and she can have ANYTHING she wants?
Taylor looks completely different now. She messes up and her face looks robotic. No tender eyes, they are gone.
I’ve never seen Taylor end a relationship and it's over. Don't get it, it's Taylor Swift. Taylor’s less than emotional expressions. DO NOT GET IT AT ALL.
And I think her being brought to the stage in a black box is also really weird. Do not understand her anymore.
Well that's not what she tells us in her songs tho.
you’re losing me says otherwise
Travis shouldn’t waste any time cuz uk good ones never wait 😉
3:52 the eeeras toor
💀💀💀💀💀
I love her but if she can’t sing these songs without getting emotional why write them?
Why she can't sing It while getting emotional? That's not wrong
@@lynn8836right? It just means the emotions behind them were real. If she would just make generic bubblegum-pop, she could sing them without getting emotional, but would that be better? I don't think so. Genuine songwriting based on own experiences comes at a cost, but it is totally worth it imo.
because... art is about the human experience; and a large part of the human experience is emotions?
I'm glad she finally has the man she deserves hopefully 😂
Oh my GOD this video makes me cry a lot!!!🥺🩷