It can only be TY !! He can not be replaced!! TY & Amy's love for each other was what the first 13 years we all about. Bring them back together and you have meany more great years of a GREAT show!!
Bring him back there is only one Ty he can’t be replaced Him& Amy added a special romance to the show The show is still a hit Ty added to the show there has to be so way to reunite him & Amy
On Heartland Series 13th Should Have Been The Ended Of On Heartland Series With The Borden Family Living Happy Ever After With Their Daughter, Lindy Until The End! Love Story! Family! Legacy! ❤
Don’t think Ty could ever be replaced. He was too strong of a. Character and no one loved each other like they did. It was like he’s the handsome prince and she’s the beautiful queen. I think the only way he could return is Amy waking up from a coma. At least that could be plausable..
@@roselamanna559 Face it without Ty the storyline was less interesting. Tim and Lou's marriageable problems are not a crowd catcher. Bring back Ty is the best solution for fans and ratings.
Bring him back. Not as a twin. Lyndy needs to know who her daddy is and Amy needs her husband. They belong together and as a family. The show isn't the same since Ty left .
I think they should bring him back. Maybe those bad people could have had him all this time and he breaks free and comes back. Please bring Ty back as Ty
Then who did the hospital declare dead, and who was in the urn that Amy carried and threw ashes in the air. Not only that but it would screw up his daughter forever.
@wildaltarose they could have made it to be Ty and still have him somewhere. As far as his daughter I think she would be just fine if she got her dad back
Ty was the best actor of any on Heartland!!! Please bring him back. The writers could always say that he was in a coma or that it was a plot to be gone taking care of his mother, etc.
No...his mom has been on the show. The only way they can do it is, Amy or Lindy gets sick and in a coma and when they awake, it was all a horrible dream !!! That's the only way.
Ty cannot be replaced! The series is just not appealing without him! There were so many more lessons to be learned with him! The house they were going to build - “they were going to make it happen”; his “to be a great vet”; sharing the growth and caring of a couple who met in their teens and grew into the mature years together, etc., etc. - so much that was left undone. Such a loss of wonderful actors!
If Ty came back I would think Amy would be mad for not letting her know he was alive. She would have gone through all that grief for nothing. The show is not the same without him. I do live all the other actors though.
The writers of this show are good enough to make his return believable. Have faith in them. Remember the seasons 1 thru 13 when they would break up they always brought them back together again and it was always believable.
TY needs to come back, not as a twin but the father in which lyndy needs to have in her life. Amy needs to step in and tell the writer's and production crew we can come up with some good stories for our heartland followers. Not any other actor , Ty went thru he'll to marry Amy he deserves her People say Ty and Amy and lyndy for ever ,finish that in a happy ending. The way the show is all about love and happiness and beautiful relationship and horse being saved by Veterinary And Horse whisper. Can't wait to see 16 and 17 if it ever comes to Australia.
The best and most plausible scenario is the undercover one and could really re-energize the series. The twin scenario defeats the purpose of bringing Ty back. We can only have hope...
If he's a twin it's not him! She's in love with him not his twin! It's still not him! And it would open bad wounds every time she saw him! He could come back for 1 show. Happy ever after!! Then he could go back to his podcast! They could work it in. They r writers for God sake!!! A coma would be the best way for him to come back. Then maybe they leave heartland to live happy ever after somewhere else. Fans would be happy!!!!!!?!!
No. They can't replace Ty at all. We don't want his twin brother coming to the show and being so involved with everyone else including Amy and Lydy. Please bring him back and into the show. We really loved him alot and he's a wonderful man 👨 and is very helpful in the show. The show isn't the same without him and it's getting so very hard to not to have him on the show. It's so very sad 😔 that everyone has to deal with this including all the characters. Everyone enjoyed having him around and it really bothers everyone else that he's gone. With him passing away on that one episode, it's not the same thing as him being there now, especially for Amy and their daughter. Please bring him back to all of us. ❤. We really love 😍 this show alot. ❤. God bless the show and everyone else in it too. Hope this issue is resolved soon and they bring him back to all of us. ❤.
Heartland is not the same without t y is a great actor and really makes the show Eminem me are such a wonderful cute couple I cried and I cried and I cried and went I dyed it just about did me in I know it's just a show but it's a heartwarming show it makes you stop and think please come back to the show my family my friends got me to start watching it and I watched it until it I couldn't watch it and now I'm waiting for the next season so come back
What made Heartland special was that Amy & Ty stayed together through trauma. All of us what to see a love story that lasts a lifetime but the first place there was hope for that was Heartland. If he didn't die in the series he probably thought he couldn't be in other roles - - yet he still never got into other roles. The fact that his death was a fluke and strange it never felt like a real death. I think that him dying off to protect his family from evil poachers. If he successfully stopped all that and lived as a different person while doing it then his family could not be used to control him. Even in the world some of the things hurting wild animals have been resolved this year like the passage of the Big Cat Act stopping private ownership of Big Cats except those that were already owned privately but it stopped breading them in captuvity. They could have a resolution similar to that with the poachers he was fighting against. He could have won the battle the evil ppl died and now it's safe for Ty to return as his family would not be hurt. There has never been a storyline in all off TV that needed the love relationship to continue on through a normal lifespans than Ty And Amy. I didnt find out about Heartland until season 13 was released. After about two seasons I knew I didn't want to keep watching if Ty or Amy died or their relationship ended. So I watched all the released seasons when I knew he hadnt died and they were still together and had a child. Then season 14 I never wanted to believe it was the end of Ty even when we were told he died. I keep watching only on the hope he will return.
The glass is half empty. He's a vet, he's an abused child that survived, he's young man with a dream and living it. He's a wonderful caring friend, husband and is learning to be a father. In this world, especially now. Give us hope, a rainbow. Amy and Ty growing old together and teaching people on both sides of the screen. LIFE IS GOOD.
If they don't bring Ty back, who, besides me, would like to see Caleb live out Ty's legacy. He and Amy are close friends and would make a cute and awkward couple !!! I think it would be sweet. Would still rather have Ty, but if it's not going to happen, let something awesome happen in Caleb's life !!!!
No one ever 'identified the body'. As far as the cremation, that could be from ANY cadaver. Governments have pulled that stunt quite often. The time span is the difficult part. Even if in witness protection, that's a LONG time to be sequestered. I'm all for bringing him back. The series has seriously diminished since his absense.
All it showed in the beginning of season 14 was Ty falling to the ground it never showed him being in the hospital after that only Doctor coming out to say he didn't make it so therefore we don't know that Ty is really dead I believe he's in federal eyewitness protection so I think he can come back because he was never dead
Dude they said he died, multiple times in the 15th and 16th season multiple times over what are they going to open up season 17 Amy in a coma living the nightmare of having lost ty
Yes bring him back to Heartland, if he comes back no no not as a twin brother, but as himself as Ty Borden There are a few opinions to let him come back. Amy has a dream about Ghost and Ty. The next day Ghost is on Heartland, that horse felt when Ty or Amy are hurt. Ty is taken out hospital by poachers.he escaped from them and goes to the police, Amy has tot indentive Ty for who say who he is.or he finds his on way back to Heartland. Ty is reunited with Amy and their daughter Lindy.Amy has lost and found her one and true love Ty and maybe they have a second child a baby boy. The as they have sprinkled was from an other person.
He could do both, the podcast cast if that’s what he likes and also come back to Heartland. Was thinking maybe he could have amnesia and disappeared somehow and gets spotted somewhere by Amy or someone. Please come back, Graham!
I don’t think Ty will go back to Heartland!, It would be nice but I don’t think it’s going to happen ! I miss him so much !, Hes a great actor and a beautiful man !, I have stopped watching Heartland because he’s not there !, Miss you Ty !, ❤️👍
Love the show and the core cast but the show is not the same without grahm wardle plus after 16 years the stories have become repetitive and a little stale I stopped watching in season 15 but still watch the earlier seasons
@@aspendavy6510 Me too, also the song...And at the break of day you sink into a Dream...you Dreamer... lol. Just didn't seem right for his story to end like that. 😕
She was dreaming for 4 years? So, in her dream she did everything with Lyndy and also had a dream about Finn. And the big question, have the reasons Graham left changed? Does he want to return with that storyline?
Unfortunately, Graham seems to believe his podcasts are satisfying his Heartland fans. This could not be further from the truth. He should return to acting with a fresh new series with Amber that is different from Heartland.
The way they could bring Ty back is , by saying Hudson’s old mayor had a Dr . At the hospital hired to get revenge on the family (Lou ) and used Ty death but really he was kept hostage, or something like that .
It is a shame that he wanted to leave the show, but he had to do what his heart wanted a change. I am sure if he wanted to come back it could be possible as the writer could do it. I do have an idea that with the story like for ty to come back on the show could be something like this: Ty did not really have died, but was put in a coma state for a long to to build back up his body since he lost so much blood and had a blood clot build up in his body and it was only way for him to come back and be alive again. As he finally woke up from the long state of being in a coma his memory has lost and he even didn't know who he was or even who Amy or his daughter were and had to work on his memory a little at a time to gain back from what he had lost. I think that this would be a great story line in order to bring Ty back to the show.
@@patriciaelg1464 have you read “Heartland Reimagined?” It follows the long term coma idea; with his daughter’s faith and daily prayers, he does return from the coma, slowly regaining his memories and the family continues to grow……
Come back as ty best storyline about in protection amy will be remembered by ty when he returns that she still is always his soul mate meant she to be her only love 4:03
@@joanheckel8305 I’m just saying it’s super unrealistic that this show gets involved in fake deaths and security and possibly fbi, it’s not the type of show that has like crime in it
Heartland, ended in the 13th season, as it was already difficult to watch the episodes in which he did not act, without him the series became boring. With Ty (G.W) the series had humor, adventure, always a new challenge for the couple. George and Quim don't have chemistry, to overcome Ty and Amy and much less Amy with another, it totally lost the charm of magic. Fans expected Ty and Amy to replace Jack and Lisa, what a shame, I'm sad because it was the best series I've ever watched. If G.W. returns to act as Ty Borden, we'll be back to watch.
I hope this can be true and Graham Wardel wants to return and the Heartland set, CBC executives wants him back with open arms and huge apologies behind the scenes on this heartland set. They can save the train wreck to this tv series what they did to it in season 14,15 and 16. 15 and 16 they have no heartland tv series it is dead. The only way to save this tv series is to find a way and they can bring back Ty to Amy, Lynde in the script that it was a fake death, kidnapped by poachers, in witness protection or Amy has been in a coma dreaming her and Lynde's life without Ty? No one can replace Ty character or give Amy a new husband to raise Lynde. There was so much more storyline with Ty and Amy legacy love story and they are each other's 1 true love. They can continue with Ty finds out what is truly more important to him is spending more time with Amy, Lynde and saving animals at his doorstep and continue to grow Scott's and Ty's vet practice so they can be big enough to add a 3rd full-time vet besides Cass so Scott and Ty can do more work outside of the clinic and spend more time with family , they hire 2 vet assistants in vet school that care about putting the animals first. Also Ty finds that he needs to give back for what Jack and Heartland ranch, Amy and family because he would not have had a successful life without them or found forgiveness. He and Amy start to foster, adopt other kids that don't have parents or have a troubling past work on finding closure and forgiveness to their troubling past and able to become successful like Ty coming to Heartland ranch that was tough on him but it felt like family. There is many more seasons out of this storyline or at least give a happy ending finale season or 2 hour ending movie of Ty's life and Amy's love story 1 true love legacy of Heartland ranch with this TV series so the actors can move on to other projects. With so much death in many people's families lives in the last 3 years this storyline of Ty and Amy needs a happy ending of them living happily ever after on Heartland ranch with their Daughter, have another child a son, adopted and temporary foster kids. If they really wanted to they can fix the storyline damage from season 14 and bring it back, Ty did not die, back to the older heartland seasons and episodes. The best humorous line in season 11 episode 18 when Calib helps Ty find another long horn that looks identical to Jacks who Jack gave up to get Ty's money back from the lemon truck he purchased from the neighbor. Ty and Calib swap out the Long horn on the neighbor in dark of night and get Jack's long horn back. The neighbor did not even notice he did not have Jack's long horn was missing. That episode was so funny and the best! Jack was so happy to get his black and white long horn back and that he was going to find out how Ty and Calib pulled that one off. They need more humorous moments back to heartland tv series if it can continue in season 17? They need more of that back and less dysfunctional family life and keeping relationships strong with ups and downs. Like Ty and Amy took them two break ups, took 8 seasons for them to get married, risk of Ty going back to Jail and they strengthened in their relationship with truth makes a long lasting friendships and long lasting marriage can work and continue to love one another even when things change throughout married life. My Gut tells me Ty (Graham Wardel ) is not coming back. I bet they are going try now and recast his character with another actor. So disappointed I loved Graham Wardel what he added to Ty Character and gone just like that after they have a child and be temporary foster parents and we the fans were still watching and the show was still going strong till the end of season 13. What pure shame what has happened to this show and how powerful and popular Graham Wardel made Ty's character besides the good writing to the script for 13 seasons. The worst thing they did was causing death to ty and erasing him even in memory with Amy and Lynde was the worst thing they could have done to Heartland tv series. They should have done it in a way just in case after Graham had some time way that he can come back to the show in full character and Ty was not a dead character and still stayed married to Amy Fleming. I am not watching anymore new episodes of Heartland without Graham as Ty. Amber as Amy Fleming cannot overcome the loss of Ty chracter and cannot move on past the strongest storyline and acting from Graham and Amber together cannot be duplicated with other actors the put with Amber Marshal as Amy Fleming. I love the old episodes up to the last season 13 with Graham Wardel in them with Amber Marshal. The show is taking it's course and ending badly. No new love story as Georgene and Fin or Lou and Mitch will never work period! Sad it was a good show at one time and now it is failing world wide fans who invested 13 seasons to this show to make it a #1 family drama series.
I agree with you 100%. I did the same as you did I watch season 1-13 and never go farther, so I don't know about 14,15,16.whether they were good or bad but from what I have seen on Facebook I believe the majority of fans want Ty and Amy back together again if the producers pay any attention to the general public they will be back together, or there will be a finale of the show.
it's NOT True these Stupid channels keep Talking about Ty Returning & the video is filled with a bunch of talk about TY. I agree Ty was Great & Graham should have Not left the show, a very DUMB Move on his part
Agree, I don't think i will either or he would have been back in season 15 or the latest 16. I believe he won't be in season 16 either. So disappointed!
He should have never left the series. Any rational human being that had this great opportunity should have been smart enough to stay with it. Shaun Johnston knows the importance . I wonder if anyone on the series tried to encourage Graham to stay. The producers were disappointed in Grahams decision to leave, that’s why they killed him off. If I had been born a prince, I would have done my duty as expected and not disappointed. I wonder if Graham has any regrets. He now has a podcast? How does that compare to a major role in a CBC series that has 16 seasons with the high likelihood there will be a season 17? I was blessed enough to get a great job a a power company when I was young. I retired after 32 years service. Good luck Graham. You gonna need it!
Ty has to come back!! I mean I know he wants to move on but all the fans would die for him to come back. I think it would be perfect for Amy to wake up out of her coma and it all be a dream and ty is still there. They could film one last season and then they can all move on. I think all the fans would die if ty comes back. The show isn’t as good with ty and Amy together. I could not imagine the show ending without ty and Amy together that’s the only ending most fans would want. There is no one else in the world that Amy can be with besides ty. The fans just need to know that Ty will still be there to raise their kid and be the perfect dad like he always wanted
I really hope he can figure out his next move and get back in to his acting career where he excels in every way he portrays his character. He is profoundly believable as an actor. His podcast has included so many very fine individuals exposing us to truth, faith, passion, as well as humor and wholesome fun. He is indeed a very solid actor with great people skills! Miss him so much but don't think returning to heartland is the answer. He should just get involved in movies wherever and whenever they present for him and he likes the role he can play in making a solid believable project. He should just keep going as an actor and not worry at all about how Heartland plays out in the coming seasons. BUT we need him in the movies forthcoming!!
I am so glad that Ty is back. I’m so glad Amy and Ty is getting back together. They had such a beautiful Love Story. When you find the Love of your life and your soulmate hold to them forever.😢
I think Heartland has really become depressing and boring without Ty Borland aka Graham Wardle. The story lines just aren't the same. Remember the show Dallas. Actor Patrick Duffy who played Bobby Ewing wanted off the show so they killed him off in Season eight. Patrick Duffy was asked to come back so they made the whole thing a bad dream that Bobby's wife Pam had had. Bobby's wife woke up to find Bobby in the shower. I think Amy should know all about Ty and be surprised that Ty is back from his safari to save the lions in Africa or something to that effect and the poachers were mad and Ty had to fake being killed to save Amy. Happiness on the show would be an asset. Please come back, Graham.
The Only Logical Way that He Could Come Back Would be as A Stranger Who Looks Like Ty and Lyndi was to See Him and Tell Amy that She Saw Daddy Walking By Her School..... So Amy Would Visit Lyndi's School and See Him For Herself.....Wouldn't that Be a Shock and then Scott would See Him in Hudson and then Lou Would See Him in the Diner and so Would Georgie When She Would Take his Order
Please bring him back,I love the witness protection idea. Awesome idea. Love him and Amy ,perfect family. We love this Awesome beautiful show... Bring Ty back!!!!❤❤
Think it could be wrote in as a dream all along . Amy was hurt worse than they thought and in a coma . Happens in shows all the time . Look at the notebook series it happens in one of the books . Ty was such a huge part of Heartland and understand why he moved on but it definitely hurt the show . I myself find it not as interesting . I watch season 15 was definitely not the same . The chemistry between Ty and Amy was almost completely natural . You don’t see that often in shows. Ty coming back would be a huge improvement to the show and the ratings would sky rocket . Amy not meant to be with anyone else but if she moves on it’s understandable but would not be the same as if show brought Ty back
I used to watch this show with my dad. He says it isn't the same without Ty, I still watch it but would absolutely be thrilled to have him back. Dallas has done coma scenes and the bold and the beautiful has done countless scenes too. I think something like protecting the family is a very Ty thing to do or being in a coma and not knowing who you are until he did
Oh, something else is true, since Ty left the show, it lost something, something went missing, it was that unique special relationship between amy and Ty- that was taken away- heartland needs that back.
Bring him back or recast him shouldn't have killed off the character. I had been avoiding this show thinking it would be boring I took a chance an glad I did I am glued love love love the show.
I was looking for this show, because of the love story between Ty and Amy, a match made in heaven. I don't want to look at the show anymore, so please bring Ty and makeup, whatever story you want to explain his absent!
I like to think he faked his death to protect his family. He had to go underground to help get the people that were threatening him and his family. He did it for them! It is time to bring him back!! Sure Amy with be upset, but in the end she will see him as her hero. They have a strong love. Love conquers all! Please don't do the twin thing....The writers can make better scripts by bringing him back from the dead.
Best way for Ty to come back- Amy wakes up from a coma…. Realizing everything from season 15+ has only been dreams, that she fell into a coma during the shooting, and Ty was alive the whole time taking care of Lyndy, and being by her bedside 🙌🏼
Love his podcast but would enjoy seeing him back on the show. He seems to have a good soul and would be great at anything he does. I don’t think it is fare to him for you to say he wouldn’t be known if it weren’t for Heartland there is no way for you to know that.
I think you guys shouldn't have had Ty die and had him and Amy were going to separate for a while at least that would have given him some way to return instead of trying to bring him back from the dead
Yes I want to see ty Berlin back add heartland with Amy and his daughter. Heartland is not the same without my Ty. Come Back Ty, we miss you and love you
What do you think about Graham Wardle's return? Can Heartland replace Ty? Let us know what you think in the comments below.
It can only be TY !! He can not be replaced!! TY & Amy's love for each other was what the first 13 years we all about. Bring them back together and you have meany more great years of a GREAT show!!
I don't believe it
WHY DO YOU PEOPLE KEEP TALKING ABOUT GRAHAM WARDLE RETURNING TO THE SERIES WHEN WE ALL KNOW HE CANT OR WONT.
Seems like they did that in Dallas, the infamous shower scene where the the past two seasons of Bobby Ewing being dead were just a fantasy.
Bring him back there is only one Ty he can’t be replaced Him& Amy added a special romance to the show The show is still a hit Ty added to the show there has to be so way to reunite him & Amy
Omgoodenssss Yes bring Ty back , doesnt matter how just do it!
So many of us would be so happy 😊
Loved Ty and Amy, they made the show with their love story. Please bring Ty back and put him back with Amy.
Never even seen his podcast but would welcome him back to Heartland
On Heartland Series 13th Should Have Been The Ended Of On Heartland Series With The Borden Family Living Happy Ever After With Their Daughter, Lindy Until The End! Love Story! Family! Legacy! ❤
Thank you for your reply and God Bless you and your family!
This whole season is someone's dream. Ty is alive and well!!!! It can be done!
Graham Wardle is extraordinary as a person, and actor. He is very much missed in the show. I hope his return is true ❤❤❤
Please bring Ty back on heartland as his self.
Bring him back
Don’t think Ty could ever be replaced. He was too strong of a. Character and no one loved each other like they did. It was like he’s the handsome prince and she’s the beautiful queen. I think the only way he could return is Amy waking up from a coma. At least that could be plausable..
Please bring him back 😢😢😢❤
Amy had bad dream Ty didn’t die.
Si il est mort ty borden
It is time for his return, just mentioned due to the poachers.this would be a great story line. If returned 20 seasons could happen.
The best would be in hiding now ambers 4:03 back, or back after. 🎉
@@roselamanna559 Face it without Ty the storyline was less interesting. Tim and Lou's marriageable problems are not a crowd catcher. Bring back Ty is the best solution for fans and ratings.
Bring him back. Not as a twin. Lyndy needs to know who her daddy is and Amy needs her husband. They belong together and as a family. The show isn't the same since Ty left .
The reality is that Ty died and sometimes life is just not very fair.
Fabulous reality based outlook lol
I love this show and Ty and Amy ❤
I think they should bring him back. Maybe those bad people could have had him all this time and he breaks free and comes back. Please bring Ty back as Ty
Back after Hiding in protection , there is no other way to make show good, Amy is love with only Ty. No love with someone else
Then who did the hospital declare dead, and who was in the urn that Amy carried and threw ashes in the air. Not only that but it would screw up his daughter forever.
They may have been threatened by the said guys i'm sure there's a way. I'd help write a scenario if needed lol@wildaltarose
@@AbbASongs1 me too
@wildaltarose they could have made it to be Ty and still have him somewhere. As far as his daughter I think she would be just fine if she got her dad back
Ty was the best actor of any on Heartland!!! Please bring him back. The writers could always say that he was in a coma or that it was a plot to be gone taking care of his mother, etc.
That wouldn’t make sense.
There is no way that makes sense it’s been stated for an entire season he is dead and they scattered his ashes.
No...his mom has been on the show. The only way they can do it is, Amy or Lindy gets sick and in a coma and when they awake, it was all a horrible dream !!! That's the only way.
Way to much time has past for Ty to have gone away or died
Yes bring him back, he and Amy belong together.
The show is not the same without Ty. The love story needs to continue. Please give him a story to comeback. Amy is lost without him.
Yes I fill the same way
Bring him back as Ty... he was on witness protection from the prochers...
😂😂😂😂Good one
I agree Ty's twin is a stupid idea
Except we saw him drop dead on screen! He made his bed.
How many peeps did die on the screen, and yet get rivived ❤ do it i say get him back
@@cyptejana Witness protection program is a good one, no twin, I like the bad dream.
Ty cannot be replaced! The series is just not appealing without him! There were so many more lessons to be learned with him! The house they were going to build - “they were going to make it happen”; his “to be a great vet”; sharing the growth and caring of a couple who met in their teens and grew into the mature years together, etc., etc. - so much that was left undone. Such a loss of wonderful actors!
I would like for both to come back
I would like Ty to come back he's a good Actor and him and Amy could be friends,and Lindy should know her Daddy
I agree. I said if Graham don't want to come back then someone to play him part. But Ty needs to come back.
100% agreed
It's just a TV show
Please Ty return action at heartland & don’t twin I will happy please Ty action with Amy & kid
If Ty came back I would think Amy would be mad for not letting her know he was alive. She would have gone through all that grief for nothing. The show is not the same without him. I do live all the other actors though.
The writers of this show are good enough to make his return believable.
Have faith in them. Remember the seasons 1 thru 13 when they would break up they always brought them back together again and it was always believable.
Please no twin, Ty is one of a kind, bring Graham Wardle back.
Please come back
Thrown out adhesive was it 😅h
TY needs to come back, not as a twin
but the father in which lyndy needs to have in her life. Amy needs to step in
and tell the writer's and production crew
we can come up with some good stories
for our heartland followers.
Not any other actor , Ty went thru
he'll to marry Amy he deserves her
People say Ty and Amy and lyndy
for ever ,finish that in a happy ending.
The way the show is all about love and
happiness and beautiful relationship
and horse being saved by Veterinary
And Horse whisper.
Can't wait to see 16 and 17 if it ever comes to Australia.
The best and most plausible scenario is the undercover one and could really re-energize the series. The twin scenario defeats the purpose of bringing Ty back. We can only have hope...
If he's a twin it's not him! She's in love with him not his twin! It's still not him! And it would open bad wounds every time she saw him! He could come back for 1 show. Happy ever after!! Then he could go back to his podcast! They could work it in. They r writers for God sake!!! A coma would be the best way for him to come back. Then maybe they leave heartland to live happy ever after somewhere else. Fans would be happy!!!!!!?!!
No. They can't replace Ty at all. We don't want his twin brother coming to the show and being so involved with everyone else including Amy and Lydy. Please bring him back and into the show. We really loved him alot and he's a wonderful man 👨 and is very helpful in the show. The show isn't the same without him and it's getting so very hard to not to have him on the show. It's so very sad 😔 that everyone has to deal with this including all the characters. Everyone enjoyed having him around and it really bothers everyone else that he's gone. With him passing away on that one episode, it's not the same thing as him being there now, especially for Amy and their daughter. Please bring him back to all of us. ❤. We really love 😍 this show alot. ❤. God bless the show and everyone else in it too. Hope this issue is resolved soon and they bring him back to all of us. ❤.
Bring him back as her husband
Heartland is not the same without t y is a great actor and really makes the show Eminem me are such a wonderful cute couple I cried and I cried and I cried and went I dyed it just about did me in I know it's just a show but it's a heartwarming show it makes you stop and think please come back to the show my family my friends got me to start watching it and I watched it until it I couldn't watch it and now I'm waiting for the next season so come back
What made Heartland special was that Amy & Ty stayed together through trauma. All of us what to see a love story that lasts a lifetime but the first place there was hope for that was Heartland. If he didn't die in the series he probably thought he couldn't be in other roles - - yet he still never got into other roles. The fact that his death was a fluke and strange it never felt like a real death. I think that him dying off to protect his family from evil poachers. If he successfully stopped all that and lived as a different person while doing it then his family could not be used to control him. Even in the world some of the things hurting wild animals have been resolved this year like the passage of the Big Cat Act stopping private ownership of Big Cats except those that were already owned privately but it stopped breading them in captuvity. They could have a resolution similar to that with the poachers he was fighting against. He could have won the battle the evil ppl died and now it's safe for Ty to return as his family would not be hurt. There has never been a storyline in all off TV that needed the love relationship to continue on through a normal lifespans than Ty And Amy. I didnt find out about Heartland until season 13 was released. After about two seasons I knew I didn't want to keep watching if Ty or Amy died or their relationship ended. So I watched all the released seasons when I knew he hadnt died and they were still together and had a child. Then season 14 I never wanted to believe it was the end of Ty even when we were told he died. I keep watching only on the hope he will return.
The glass is half empty.
He's a vet, he's an abused child that survived, he's young man with a dream and living it. He's a wonderful caring friend, husband and is learning to be a father.
In this world, especially now. Give us hope, a rainbow. Amy and Ty growing old together and teaching people on both sides of the screen. LIFE IS GOOD.
What do you mean we were told he/Ty died,we all saw him fall to the ground and died on the show on season 14
@@deborahrowland7488 Right on!
If they don't bring Ty back, who, besides me, would like to see Caleb live out Ty's legacy. He and Amy are close friends and would make a cute and awkward couple !!! I think it would be sweet.
Would still rather have Ty, but if it's not going to happen, let something awesome happen in Caleb's life !!!!
I’m still hoping
Ty hear my plea--come back
Amy need you and your fans need you.. peace
Would be nice to have him back however he was buried. I can't imagine how he could come back without seeming strange. Just bring him back.
Which episode was he buried? All I ever saw was Amy emptying his ashes which could not even be Tys.
No one ever 'identified the body'. As far as the cremation, that could be from ANY cadaver. Governments have pulled that stunt quite often. The time span is the difficult part. Even if in witness protection, that's a LONG time to be sequestered.
I'm all for bringing him back. The series has seriously diminished since his absense.
All it showed in the beginning of season 14 was Ty falling to the ground it never showed him being in the hospital after that only Doctor coming out to say he didn't make it so therefore we don't know that Ty is really dead I believe he's in federal eyewitness protection so I think he can come back because he was never dead
Lolol it's called being in denial
Agree
Dude they said he died, multiple times in the 15th and 16th season multiple times over what are they going to open up season 17 Amy in a coma living the nightmare of having lost ty
Yes bring him back to Heartland, if he comes back no no not as a twin brother, but as himself as Ty Borden
There are a few opinions to let him come back. Amy has a dream about Ghost and Ty. The next day Ghost is on Heartland, that horse felt when Ty or Amy are hurt. Ty is taken out hospital by poachers.he escaped from them and goes to the police, Amy has tot indentive Ty for who say who he is.or he finds his on way back to Heartland. Ty is reunited with Amy and their daughter Lindy.Amy has lost and found her one and true love Ty and maybe they have a second child a baby boy. The as they have sprinkled was from an other person.
Ty was such a huge part of heartland, not the same, also, eye wish they would release the seasons after 14 to stream.
Thank you.
He could do both, the podcast cast if that’s what he likes and also come back to Heartland. Was thinking maybe he could have amnesia and disappeared somehow and gets spotted somewhere by Amy or someone. Please come back, Graham!
I don’t think Ty will go back to Heartland!, It would be nice but I don’t think it’s going to happen ! I miss him so much !, Hes a great actor and a beautiful man !, I have stopped watching Heartland because he’s not there !, Miss you Ty !, ❤️👍
Same here but I've watched some reruns but I'm like hmm I've seen these episodes before and some are entertaining and some are not anymore
😊I love heartland . If Amy leaves what for Ty to come back to.
Think logic was he was in Hiding to protect Amy and daughter, he knows
Bring To back
Ty
No one can replace ty graham is the best actor for ty bring him back
Bring him back. No one is as good as Ty. I miss him on the show
Love the show and the core cast but the show is not the same without grahm wardle plus after 16 years the stories have become repetitive and a little stale I stopped watching in season 15 but still watch the earlier seasons
Be great have him back on Heartland.
Ty's death could just be a dream Amy had. At the beginning of the next season she can wake up next to Ty.
I have so thought of that scenario.... like she has been in a coma...its all a dream...wishful thinking...:(
@@amylynn8888 I have thought this since the very beginning. I would be so happy if he came back.
@@aspendavy6510 Me too, also the song...And at the break of day you sink into a Dream...you Dreamer... lol. Just didn't seem right for his story to end like that. 😕
@@amylynn8888 yeah I think it would make for a great plot twist and I think it would get more views.
She was dreaming for 4 years? So, in her dream she did everything with Lyndy and also had a dream about Finn. And the big question, have the reasons Graham left changed? Does he want to return with that storyline?
Unfortunately, Graham seems to believe his podcasts are satisfying his Heartland fans. This could not be further from the truth. He should return to acting with a fresh new series with Amber that is different from Heartland.
The way they could bring Ty back is , by saying Hudson’s old mayor had a Dr . At the hospital hired to get revenge on the family (Lou ) and used Ty death but really he was kept hostage, or something like that .
Amy could wake up from a dream…
Oh....definitely bring ty back. The show isn't the same without him.
It is a shame that he wanted to leave the show, but he had to do what his heart wanted a change. I am sure if he wanted to come back it could be possible as the writer could do it. I do have an idea that with the story like for ty to come back on the show could be something like this: Ty did not really have died, but was put in a coma state for a long to to build back up his body since he lost so much blood and had a blood clot build up in his body and it was only way for him to come back and be alive again. As he finally woke up from the long state of being in a coma his memory has lost and he even didn't know who he was or even who Amy or his daughter were and had to work on his memory a little at a time to gain back from what he had lost. I think that this would be a great story line in order to bring Ty back to the show.
Not believable
@@patriciaelg1464 have you read “Heartland Reimagined?” It follows the long term coma idea; with his daughter’s faith and daily prayers, he does return from the coma, slowly regaining his memories and the family continues to grow……
But they spread his ashes?
Amy or ty in comma
He can come back that he was undercover doing something to end poachers and had to stay low to protect his family.
Come back as ty best storyline about in protection amy will be remembered by ty when he returns that she still is always his soul mate meant she to be her only love 4:03
They spread his ashes
@@Sabllica but they might not have been his.
@@joanheckel8305 I’m just saying it’s super unrealistic that this show gets involved in fake deaths and security and possibly fbi, it’s not the type of show that has like crime in it
@@Sabllica I know it’s just wishful thinking 🤔
I stopped watching bc I want Ty back
La verdad, ya eh visto la temporada 15 y 16 y perdió un poco el humor y la trama :(
Yea same
Heartland, ended in the 13th season, as it was already difficult to watch the episodes in which he did not act, without him the series became boring. With Ty (G.W) the series had humor, adventure, always a new challenge for the couple. George and Quim don't have chemistry, to overcome Ty and Amy and much less Amy with another, it totally lost the charm of magic. Fans expected Ty and Amy to replace Jack and Lisa, what a shame, I'm sad because it was the best series I've ever watched. If G.W. returns to act as Ty Borden, we'll be back to watch.
No twin
Hopeful Ty return at heartland !!
The only way, is, it was a dream!
Bring him back as Ty… I have really missed him. The show is not the same without him.
Yes he needs to come back it's not been the same and we would love him back
No they can’t replace him at all
I hope this can be true and Graham Wardel wants to return and the Heartland set, CBC executives wants him back with open arms and huge apologies behind the scenes on this heartland set. They can save the train wreck to this tv series what they did to it in season 14,15 and 16. 15 and 16 they have no heartland tv series it is dead. The only way to save this tv series is to find a way and they can bring back Ty to Amy, Lynde in the script that it was a fake death, kidnapped by poachers, in witness protection or Amy has been in a coma dreaming her and Lynde's life without Ty? No one can replace Ty character or give Amy a new husband to raise Lynde. There was so much more storyline with Ty and Amy legacy love story and they are each other's 1 true love. They can continue with Ty finds out what is truly more important to him is spending more time with Amy, Lynde and saving animals at his doorstep and continue to grow Scott's and Ty's vet practice so they can be big enough to add a 3rd full-time vet besides Cass so Scott and Ty can do more work outside of the clinic and spend more time with family , they hire 2 vet assistants in vet school that care about putting the animals first. Also Ty finds that he needs to give back for what Jack and Heartland ranch, Amy and family because he would not have had a successful life without them or found forgiveness. He and Amy start to foster, adopt other kids that don't have parents or have a troubling past work on finding closure and forgiveness to their troubling past and able to become successful like Ty coming to Heartland ranch that was tough on him but it felt like family. There is many more seasons out of this storyline or at least give a happy ending finale season or 2 hour ending movie of Ty's life and Amy's love story 1 true love legacy of Heartland ranch with this TV series so the actors can move on to other projects. With so much death in many people's families lives in the last 3 years this storyline of Ty and Amy needs a happy ending of them living happily ever after on Heartland ranch with their Daughter, have another child a son, adopted and temporary foster kids. If they really wanted to they can fix the storyline damage from season 14 and bring it back, Ty did not die, back to the older heartland seasons and episodes. The best humorous line in season 11 episode 18 when Calib helps Ty find another long horn that looks identical to Jacks who Jack gave up to get Ty's money back from the lemon truck he purchased from the neighbor. Ty and Calib swap out the Long horn on the neighbor in dark of night and get Jack's long horn back. The neighbor did not even notice he did not have Jack's long horn was missing. That episode was so funny and the best! Jack was so happy to get his black and white long horn back and that he was going to find out how Ty and Calib pulled that one off. They need more humorous moments back to heartland tv series if it can continue in season 17? They need more of that back and less dysfunctional family life and keeping relationships strong with ups and downs. Like Ty and Amy took them two break ups, took 8 seasons for them to get married, risk of Ty going back to Jail and they strengthened in their relationship with truth makes a long lasting friendships and long lasting marriage can work and continue to love one another even when things change throughout married life. My Gut tells me Ty (Graham Wardel ) is not coming back. I bet they are going try now and recast his character with another actor. So disappointed I loved Graham Wardel what he added to Ty Character and gone just like that after they have a child and be temporary foster parents and we the fans were still watching and the show was still going strong till the end of season 13. What pure shame what has happened to this show and how powerful and popular Graham Wardel made Ty's character besides the good writing to the script for 13 seasons. The worst thing they did was causing death to ty and erasing him even in memory with Amy and Lynde was the worst thing they could have done to Heartland tv series. They should have done it in a way just in case after Graham had some time way that he can come back to the show in full character and Ty was not a dead character and still stayed married to Amy Fleming. I am not watching anymore new episodes of Heartland without Graham as Ty. Amber as Amy Fleming cannot overcome the loss of Ty chracter and cannot move on past the strongest storyline and acting from Graham and Amber together cannot be duplicated with other actors the put with Amber Marshal as Amy Fleming. I love the old episodes up to the last season 13 with Graham Wardel in them with Amber Marshal. The show is taking it's course and ending badly. No new love story as Georgene and Fin or Lou and Mitch will never work period! Sad it was a good show at one time and now it is failing world wide fans who invested 13 seasons to this show to make it a #1 family drama series.
I agree with you 100%. I did the same as you did I watch season 1-13 and never go farther, so I don't know about 14,15,16.whether they were good or bad but from what I have seen on Facebook I believe the majority of fans want Ty and Amy back together again if the producers pay any attention to the general public they will be back together, or there will be a finale of the show.
Excelente a volta de Ty
Heartland is definitely not the same without Ty. Pay him more and make him come back. It was all a nightmare and now we all get to wake up!
Pretty Please bring Ty Back.
14 and done
I truly hope he returns to heartland in season 17. 🙏 show isnt the same without him.
it's NOT True these Stupid channels keep Talking about Ty Returning & the video is filled with a bunch of talk about TY.
I agree Ty was Great & Graham should have Not left the show, a very DUMB Move on his part
Heartland isn't the same without Ty. I stop watching it when he died. Amy is a great actress and Ty is a great actor. Their chemistry is awesome. ❤❤
I would love to see him comeback, but I do not believe it will ever happen.
Agree, I don't think i will either or he would have been back in season 15 or the latest 16. I believe he won't be in season 16 either. So disappointed!
He should have never left the series. Any rational human being that had this great opportunity should have been smart enough to stay with it. Shaun Johnston knows the importance . I wonder if anyone on the series tried to encourage Graham to stay. The producers were disappointed in Grahams decision to leave, that’s why they killed him off. If I had been born a prince, I would have done my duty as expected and not disappointed. I wonder if Graham has any regrets. He now has a podcast? How does that compare to a major role in a CBC series that has 16 seasons with the high likelihood there will be a season 17? I was blessed enough to get a great job a a power company when I was young. I retired after 32 years service. Good luck Graham. You gonna need it!
Ty has to come back!! I mean I know he wants to move on but all the fans would die for him to come back. I think it would be perfect for Amy to wake up out of her coma and it all be a dream and ty is still there. They could film one last season and then they can all move on. I think all the fans would die if ty comes back. The show isn’t as good with ty and Amy together. I could not imagine the show ending without ty and Amy together that’s the only ending most fans would want. There is no one else in the world that Amy can be with besides ty. The fans just need to know that Ty will still be there to raise their kid and be the perfect dad like he always wanted
I really hope he can figure out his next move and get back in to his acting career where he excels in every way he portrays his character. He is profoundly believable as an actor. His podcast has included so many very fine individuals exposing us to truth, faith, passion, as well as humor and wholesome fun. He is indeed a very solid actor with great people skills! Miss him so much but don't think returning to heartland is the answer. He should just get involved in movies wherever and whenever they present for him and he likes the role he can play in making a solid believable project. He should just keep going as an actor and not worry at all about how Heartland plays out in the coming seasons. BUT we need him in the movies forthcoming!!
He should never have left I know he wanted to try new things but this season was gonna go into the history books imagine 20 seasons of peak
Bringing him back will be a mistake for the series and for his career.
I am so glad that Ty is back. I’m so glad Amy and Ty is getting back together. They had such a beautiful Love Story. When you find the Love of your life and your soulmate hold to them forever.😢
Ty tem que voltar para os dois cuidar do rancho🙏🙏🙏
I think Heartland has really become depressing and boring without Ty Borland aka Graham Wardle. The story lines just aren't the same. Remember the show Dallas. Actor Patrick Duffy who played Bobby Ewing wanted off the show so they killed him off in Season eight. Patrick Duffy was asked to come back so they made the whole thing a bad dream that Bobby's wife Pam had had. Bobby's wife woke up to find Bobby in the shower. I think Amy should know all about Ty and be surprised that Ty is back from his safari to save the lions in Africa or something to that effect and the poachers were mad and Ty had to fake being killed to save Amy. Happiness on the show would be an asset. Please come back, Graham.
The Only Logical Way that He Could Come Back Would be as A Stranger Who Looks Like Ty and Lyndi was to See Him and Tell Amy that She Saw Daddy Walking By Her School..... So Amy Would Visit Lyndi's School and See Him For Herself.....Wouldn't that Be a Shock and then Scott would See Him in Hudson and then Lou Would See Him in the Diner and so Would Georgie When She Would Take his Order
Please bring him back,I love the witness protection idea. Awesome idea. Love him and Amy ,perfect family. We love this Awesome beautiful show...
Bring Ty back!!!!❤❤
Think it could be wrote in as a dream all along . Amy was hurt worse than they thought and in a coma . Happens in shows all the time . Look at the notebook series it happens in one of the books . Ty was such a huge part of Heartland and understand why he moved on but it definitely hurt the show . I myself find it not as interesting . I watch season 15 was definitely not the same . The chemistry between Ty and Amy was almost completely natural . You don’t see that often in shows. Ty coming back would be a huge improvement to the show and the ratings would sky rocket . Amy not meant to be with anyone else but if she moves on it’s understandable but would not be the same as if show brought Ty back
There will always be only one Ty
Welcome back you have been missed
I used to watch this show with my dad. He says it isn't the same without Ty, I still watch it but would absolutely be thrilled to have him back. Dallas has done coma scenes and the bold and the beautiful has done countless scenes too. I think something like protecting the family is a very Ty thing to do or being in a coma and not knowing who you are until he did
Maybe it was his twin that faked the death while he was in hiding for safety of the family.
Oh, something else is true, since Ty left the show, it lost something, something went missing, it was that unique special relationship between amy and Ty- that was taken away- heartland needs that back.
Bring him back or recast him shouldn't have killed off the character. I had been avoiding this show thinking it would be boring I took a chance an glad I did I am glued love love love the show.
It would be great for him to come back that would be the best part of season 17 can’t Waite to watch it
I like the MEMORY periods where Ty comes back to different people in their memories.
Já ansiosa pela próxima temporada
I was looking for this show, because of the love story between Ty and Amy, a match made in heaven. I don't want to look at the show anymore, so please bring Ty and makeup, whatever story you want to explain his absent!
On Heartland Series Lindy going to have a dream about her dad, Ty and It’s going to be so sad !
They need Ty back it’s not the same without him
I like to think he faked his death to protect his family. He had to go underground to help get the people that were threatening him and his family. He did it for them! It is time to bring him back!! Sure Amy with be upset, but in the end she will see him as her hero. They have a strong love. Love conquers all! Please don't do the twin thing....The writers can make better scripts by bringing him back from the dead.
I love Ty so so so so much ❤❤
Best way for Ty to come back-
Amy wakes up from a coma….
Realizing everything from season 15+ has only been dreams, that she fell into a coma during the shooting, and Ty was alive the whole time taking care of Lyndy, and being by her bedside 🙌🏼
Love heartland its not the same without Ty init,i dont follow their personal lives etc can someone enlighten why he left in the first place?
How can people in the US watch the new seasons of Heartland??? I haven't been able to watch past season 15.
Miss Ty very much . Please bring him back !!!!
Love his podcast but would enjoy seeing him back on the show. He seems to have a good soul and would be great at anything he does. I don’t think it is fare to him for you to say he wouldn’t be known if it weren’t for Heartland there is no way for you to know that.
Please come back TY . 😢 love you and miss you on the show . ❤
I think you guys shouldn't have had Ty die and had him and Amy were going to separate for a while at least that would have given him some way to return instead of trying to bring him back from the dead
Maybe have him come back as a doppelgänger or someone that seems familiar
Nobody cares how the writers bring Ty back. Just bring him back!! We all love Ty and Amy.❤
Yesssss plssss bring Ty back but NOT AS A TWIN!
Captured ( fake death ) yesss to protect his family Yesssss what a twist that could be!!! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼😍
They should have him wake up from a coma. That’ll explain it all.
Yes I want to see ty Berlin back add heartland with Amy and his daughter. Heartland is not the same without my Ty. Come Back Ty, we miss you and love you