I love the way Paul killing the Baron is essentially the gom jabbar test, he stabs him in the neck and says "you die like an animal", great way to tie it back to the book as Alia kills Baron with the gom jabbar
A fitting end. The desert takes the weak. Also nice and refreshing to see movie villains dying like this. It’s not some cinematic demise of exploding (like Sauron) or turning into dust in CGI (like Thanos) instead he’s left to rot and decompose like a dead animal.
That's how Voldemort was supposed to die too in the Books. Reduced to a normal being, just flopping over and dead. Then some dumb director thought it's better if he turns into some black flying stuff (?). wtf.
i saw the numbers, i wish i could find where, but sean bean is still only like 8th in the list of people who have died a lot in movies. Vincent Price is quite a bit ahead of Bean in that score card.
@@EchelonBlue Actually, I looked it up too after making the comment. There is a website called Movie Mortality that lists Danny Trejo with the most screen deaths at 65. Surprisingly, Sean Bean doesn't even make the top 10.
@@mrquirky3626 holy s$!t, Cunningham's Law of the Internet only needed five minutes to smack me on that one! Cunningham's Law of the Internet: The best way to get the right answer on the internet is not to ask a question; it's to post the wrong answer. I didn't even have time to look myself!
The insult of not keeping his water, not letting it join the tribe's- when even a found stranger's would have been harvested. It says: 'We'd rather die than ever drink the water that has been in your body'. I don't think the Imperial court knew what he was saying, but the Fedaykin did.
Harkonnen water can't be drunk due to the toxic industrial environment on their planet, although they can use it for cooling systems and whatnot so it still applies.
The water won't really be lost. It's going to those ants at the moment, but the system of Arrakis will keep it somehow. It just won't stay with the tribe.
@@Ben-jl2rh Well. There's a future plot reason Herbert had Alia kill Vlad. It was, uh, ironic. In the context of future story events. Obviously in DV's adaption, Alia isn't born yet, so she couldn't do it.
I just find it so funny how the Dune book can de depicted as camp like the 84 version but so cinematic and serious like here 😂 different ways to interpret/visualise the same story, it’s all about execution and it makes a HUGE difference
@@Nicholas_Chen_ Hollywood hasn't always respected soft sci-fi and high-fantasy as 'mature' genres. It wasn't until the turn of the century that that started to change.
AND a straight reference to David lynchs blue velvet, when I saw that shot in theaters I visibly looked around in awe to see if anyone else noticed that, that's how you pay respect to a master. Dennis is the god emperor
You gave it more layers than I realised, I never realised Feyd’s acting had such a sexual undertone which I think is what makes his character so much better than your average villain
all chemistry is completely natural, its the concentration of substances that is toxic. given time, even the barons body would decay to where the desert would feast on him
This probably isn’t intentional but at 0:28 when the Baron rises with his long robe he kinda looks like a worm. A very evil worm ruler…kinda foreshadows Emperor Leto II
I watched the movie without reading the books, but I had some idea of the universe, so I thought Leto II was a common creature and the Baron was of his kind, a human worm. 😅
Nice of Villeneuve to put in such a clear visual homage to Blue Velvet, the film that David Lynch made off the back of the failure of his own Dune adaptation and which defined the rest of his career as a director.
Feyd-Rautha, inside his own head: "The stakes are so high right now, I kove it and I love Atreides for escalating *this* hard. Oh yeah and the head of my house is dead. Guess I'm in charge now."
Feyd-Rautha did briefly inherit the title of Siridar-Baron of Geidi Prime. Then he died. Then Count Fenring, Margot Fenring's eunuch husband, took it over. Shame we don't ever get to meet him. He was the only friend the Emperor had.
Paul, standing before those Sardaukar blades, ordering them to dispose of the body, is a different level of confidence! And they did as instructed, by the way!
You realize Paul is able to foresee most possible futures at this point, so the reason he's confident in front of those blades is that he literally already knows they don't attack him.
@@Fyre0 lol! Seen it 3 times; probably 10 times all together with the clip channels. All I meant was Paul took over. He was giving the orders, to all the Houses, and saying it in front of The Emperor's Blades. (The Emperor's New Clothes!) LITERALLY! The Power-shift in that scene is AWESOME! But, yeah....I could've phrased it better.
A nice thought, but Paul probably wasn't there to hear the Baron say that. I say "probably" because there is a chance he could've seen it in a spice vision or something
@@Fyre0He technically was. After the water of life sequence he's given the memory of all of his ancestors, male and female. This would include the Baron.
For those who are intrigued by the shot of the Baron's head covered with ants that slowly pans down towards his ear, I'm pretty sure that this is an hommage to David Lynch's Blue velvet. I wouldn't be surprised if this scene's purpose was just to pay tribute to Lynch since Denis Villeneuve obviously admires his work and he also adapted Dune. Here's the scene from Blue Velvet below if you want to make up your mind about this theory! ruclips.net/video/BeYx_CBH700/видео.html
The score in this scene is very nice. Something about that high note held while the Baron is getting his neck stuck, mouth agape-it’s all very evoking.
Am I the only one who feels like the shot with the ants crawling around the Baron's ear is a nod to David Lynch? The ear from Blue Velvett is so fucking iconic, this simply cannot be an accident, right?!?
I love how he just tells them to kill the Sardukar. The power dynamic between the Atredies and Harkonnen's in the first movie helped bolster the image of strength from the Sardukar, and yet Paul tells only a few Fremen to kill the guard like he needs milk from the store, it really helps reinforce the idea that this force could not only combat the great houses but also stand a decent chance as we'll see in the next movie. This from someone who's NOT read the books.
Thing is, this would explain how the Baron is able to possess Alia (if they end up going there). The Sandworms are connected to one another via the spice & the sandtrout, so devouring the Baron could imbue that worm with something of his essence.
Given that Denis was willing to stray a little from the source material, I would have loved to hear Paul say, "hear I am, here I remain," right before sticking the knife in Baron's neck. Invoking Leto's final words would have been a poetic way to signal Paul's identity to Baron (and Paul's genetic memories for the audience).
Except the idea of Paul's "genetic memories" making him special is part of the whole "divine chosen hero" trope that Herbert was directly trying to subvert, so doing "Dune: but we take the blind hero worship part seriously " sounds like a step backwards.
His "grandfather" comment right before stabbing Baron in the neck essentially did the same thing: signaled his identity to Baron and reminded the audience that Paul has genetic memories after drinking the water of life. Right? I just think quoting Leto's last words would have been more satisfying, by placing the emphasis on Paul being Leto's son instead of being Baron's grandson (although he is obviously both). I do see your point though; I suppose the reason why I think my version would be more satisfying is the same reason why you think it would be more problematic (an even greater "Go Paul" moment?). Is that what you were getting at?
@@bryantaylor2427 Yes, you summed up my position on it very well. I get why "Go Paul" is the more narratively and psychologically satisfying for people who just want a good story, and from that standpoint, your idea for the line ties all those plot points you listed elegantly, so it's good writing on that front, I grant you, but as someone who identify's with the author's intended political theme more than the protagonist's journey in the fiction, my preferences are as they are.
I don’t think it would have changed the outcome of the Baron’s helper here lived but when Duke Leto died he took this one guy with him and the guys who replaced him afterwards were far less intelligent and capable So Duke Leto’s final breathe did end up helping Paul and his wife live and probably saved many Fermen lives as more would have died if this guy were around to counter them with better strategies.
Is it crazy for me to think this was a good ending for him? He was freed from himself and his form given to the creatures of the desert, even if it was against his will.
Why sardaukar has less time then Atreides fighters? Isnt it should be THE BEST of THE BEST of them close to Emperor? I just cant imagine that they apaeared so badass at Salusa Secundus with Mongol Chant , Just to have ONE proper fight when they were on atack against Atreides. Second battle is Research center when Duncan died. AND THATS ALL. Both Atreides and Sardaukar were the best Emperium had aside of Freemen. BUT THEY DIDNT SHOW THEM IN ACTION. Abomination..
Baron wasn't nasty enough in this. I've never read the book so I have no idea which is closer but the David Lynch Baron is much much more enjoyable and a truly horrific man.
Why? Why did he had to kill him? This is in complete contradiction to the book, and will have massive consequences for the story in the future, IF there is a continuation of the films. It's unnecessary, it's bad, and it's harmful for the entire story. The way they depicted the baron is bad enough, although it can be explained as "artistic vision" and isn't critical to the story, but this... this right here invalidates the entire Alia story arc.
I disagree, personally, the Baron’s death in the books would have been extremely difficult to adapt on to screen without it looking comical. They are saving Alia for later
@@nemrasetrail6332 Yes, it's EXACTLY the same thing because there was a Fallout movie in 1984, a SciFi Channel miniseries in 2000, and it was the award-winning science fiction novel that inspired the entire Star Wars universe. Oh, wait. That would be DUNE.
the story in itself contains a lot of elements ranging from psychology to ecology to politics to philosophy and everything in between. It's incredibly rich. However, what @AgentMercer said is problably one the major points of the whole story.
The book and other film versions are so much more effective and meaningful, with little Alia killing the big Baron with a gom jabbar. This version ruins this important moment.
A couple of minutes before the Emperor killed his bodyguards and cut the support that kept him floating, so he crawled like an animal, certainly he wanted him dead. The Emperor was an evil man, indeed.
Paul and his army bested thousands, if not millions of Saudarkar and Harkonnen soldiers before making it to the Imperial Tent. At this point, they become unstoppable and i doubt the remaining saudarkars can do anything
Also consider the fact that the Emperor basically left him to die already. If Paul didn't kill him, he probably would have suffocated to death shortly after.
Ultimately the Sardukar were zealots for the emperor, not any of the houses, and with the situation unfolding the emperor was their priority, and I would agree with others in saying the Barron was likely not well received by others but only necessary because they controlled the spice
I can't believe that Paul committed a hate crime by killing an unarmed, disabled and helpless LGBT soul like that, without empathy or remorse, in front of witnesses. That's messed up, people 🤬
@@enceladus3318if you read the novels, you would know that paul sees two main paths after gaining prescience: the one where alia kills the baron, and one where he himself does. In the books, Paul is repulsed by it and actively trying to avoid the jihad, which is why he decides against it. So the movies actually stay true to herberts plot while slightly changing pauls path. It’s a great adaptation.
Noticed how they changed many things for Lord of the Rings? And most of those things were for the better. One cannot keep the book exactly the way it was. It would be incompetent and unfun for the cinema.
@@enceladus3318 I understand where you are coming from, but Villeneuve stated this is a trilogy with Messiah as the last part. Children of Dune is mostly irrelevant to his story.
Развлечения
Benevolent aristocrat heroically feeds his domain's wildlife by any means necessary.
Mass media these days
All hail the selfless Baron Vladimir harkonnen
Dumb
And a generous quantity I might add.
😂
Like he said, it's his desert,his Arrakis, and his Dune
and this is the hill he died on!!
Went from “My desert. My Arrakis. My Dune” to “My desert. My Arrakis. My Dune: Part Two (2024).”
And the desert takes the weak
@@Ysckemiano he died on the emperor’s throne
And starts duning all over the sand
I love the way Paul killing the Baron is essentially the gom jabbar test, he stabs him in the neck and says "you die like an animal", great way to tie it back to the book as Alia kills Baron with the gom jabbar
A fitting end. The desert takes the weak. Also nice and refreshing to see movie villains dying like this. It’s not some cinematic demise of exploding (like Sauron) or turning into dust in CGI (like Thanos) instead he’s left to rot and decompose like a dead animal.
Well Thanos is far more noble than this pig. Plus, Marvel is family friendly Disney production…
"May your water be spilled and nourish nothing."
That's how Voldemort was supposed to die too in the Books. Reduced to a normal being, just flopping over and dead. Then some dumb director thought it's better if he turns into some black flying stuff (?). wtf.
kinda of a dumb take tbh
The desert didn't really take him. He was already dead before he got there
"you die like an animal" was a cold ass line to deliver as hes dying.
But he is not dead 😂
@@jquid2337ants were literally feasting on his corpse, he’s dead
@@jquid2337 he is
@@xdarkxskullzx Spoilers)
@@jquid2337 You’re literally watching a video that spoils the ending. Why are you here?
I haven't checked the numbers, but I feel like Stellan Skarsgard is slowly get up to Sean Bean's level of death scene totals.
i saw the numbers, i wish i could find where, but sean bean is still only like 8th in the list of people who have died a lot in movies. Vincent Price is quite a bit ahead of Bean in that score card.
@@EchelonBlue Actually, I looked it up too after making the comment. There is a website called Movie Mortality that lists Danny Trejo with the most screen deaths at 65. Surprisingly, Sean Bean doesn't even make the top 10.
@@mrquirky3626 He is probably just the best and most popular doing it
@@mrquirky3626 holy s$!t, Cunningham's Law of the Internet only needed five minutes to smack me on that one!
Cunningham's Law of the Internet: The best way to get the right answer on the internet is not to ask a question; it's to post the wrong answer.
I didn't even have time to look myself!
Hey, don’t spoil Andor season 2!
I love how it’s assumed the Sardaukar were slaughtered effortlessly offscreen
no shields so they're easily picked off
@@andyborelandand vastly outnumbered lol
It’s very true to the book
“And then they fought” 😭
Did you see how many Sardaukar there were vs how many Fremen?
Since these are the very best sardaukar they would be equal to duncan idaho. But they are outnumbered and thus never had a chance
The insult of not keeping his water, not letting it join the tribe's- when even a found stranger's would have been harvested. It says: 'We'd rather die than ever drink the water that has been in your body'. I don't think the Imperial court knew what he was saying, but the Fedaykin did.
Outsiders water never joins the tribes. In the movie stilgar says they use it for machines and other stuff.
Harkonnen bodies are so contaminated by industrial chemicals that the Fremen can not drink it, their water can only be used for the coolant systems
Harkonnen water can't be drunk due to the toxic industrial environment on their planet, although they can use it for cooling systems and whatnot so it still applies.
The ultimate display of hatred, when even a Fremen spurns your water.
The water won't really be lost. It's going to those ants at the moment, but the system of Arrakis will keep it somehow. It just won't stay with the tribe.
Feyd looks at Paul like "Where have you been all my life?"
Feyd was into it lol
The moment the Baron was killed, Feyd became the number 1 Harkonnen.
a little too into it.
@@joshuajarod1909too bad he died like 30 minutes later
@@joshuajarod1909Then Paul became the #1 Harkonon after he killed Feyd
Feyd was like "MORE, GIVE ME MORE!"
Feyd be like: That was the option instead of kissing?
To be fair, he pondered to drown the Baron in his tub.
I liked that it was Paul that killed him in the movies. His book death wasn’t satisfying at all imo.
The creepy little girl that slashed at him in the 1984 version was cheesy & campy as heck
@@Ben-jl2rhthat’s how he died in the books
@@Ben-jl2rh Well. There's a future plot reason Herbert had Alia kill Vlad. It was, uh, ironic. In the context of future story events.
Obviously in DV's adaption, Alia isn't born yet, so she couldn't do it.
I just find it so funny how the Dune book can de depicted as camp like the 84 version but so cinematic and serious like here 😂 different ways to interpret/visualise the same story, it’s all about execution and it makes a HUGE difference
@@Nicholas_Chen_ Hollywood hasn't always respected soft sci-fi and high-fantasy as 'mature' genres. It wasn't until the turn of the century that that started to change.
Bugs crawling out and into his ears - a sign of things to come
how so?
@@jfayiiihis possession of Alia..his voice coming to her whispering in her ear her mind from the dark lol
AND a straight reference to David lynchs blue velvet, when I saw that shot in theaters I visibly looked around in awe to see if anyone else noticed that, that's how you pay respect to a master. Dennis is the god emperor
Bugs are the symbol for the Bene Tleilaxu, we also see this reference with Duncan Idaho. Duncan is heavily tied to the Bene Tleilax after book 1.
The Baron lived as an animal and later he died like an animal
How romantic that the good Baron gets to take an eternal nap on his desert, his Arrakis, his Dune.
Feyd beiing somewhere between shock, amasement and an orgasm from the looks of it was too much for me, I laughed so loud in the theater😅
I know right, sick pup was turned on 😂
"It better not awaken anything in m-nope, too late."
he likes pain
Brokeback Arrakis
You gave it more layers than I realised, I never realised Feyd’s acting had such a sexual undertone which I think is what makes his character so much better than your average villain
Honestly, the number of Harkonnens killing Harkonnens is too damn high! Not even Game of Thrones has this many kinslayers.
😂
Check out the books, it's kinda traditionnal for them.
I do love how they really are like dogs, it's in their blood. Just violent and savage.
Harks would kill a all the Siths in a week
It's hard to believe that any life form would want his rotting carcass.
all chemistry is completely natural, its the concentration of substances that is toxic. given time, even the barons body would decay to where the desert would feast on him
Something tells me anything that eats his body will likely die or be terribly sick
This probably isn’t intentional but at 0:28 when the Baron rises with his long robe he kinda looks like a worm. A very evil worm ruler…kinda foreshadows Emperor Leto II
I watched the movie without reading the books, but I had some idea of the universe, so I thought Leto II was a common creature and the Baron was of his kind, a human worm. 😅
Nice of Villeneuve to put in such a clear visual homage to Blue Velvet, the film that David Lynch made off the back of the failure of his own Dune adaptation and which defined the rest of his career as a director.
man some of those scenes could be a renaissance painting
Feyd-Rautha, inside his own head: "The stakes are so high right now, I kove it and I love Atreides for escalating *this* hard.
Oh yeah and the head of my house is dead. Guess I'm in charge now."
Feyd-Rautha did briefly inherit the title of Siridar-Baron of Geidi Prime.
Then he died.
Then Count Fenring, Margot Fenring's eunuch husband, took it over.
Shame we don't ever get to meet him.
He was the only friend the Emperor had.
ahhhh yes Harkonnen
You’ve been diligently uploading Dune part 2 clips. May your channel be free of copyright strikes.
1:20 Look at the nun's expression; what have we created...
Paul, standing before those Sardaukar blades, ordering them to dispose of the body, is a different level of confidence! And they did as instructed, by the way!
You realize Paul is able to foresee most possible futures at this point, so the reason he's confident in front of those blades is that he literally already knows they don't attack him.
He was talking to the fremen.
He tells the Sardaukar to kill the Sardaukar? Weird. It's almost like he was actually talking to the fremen he was facing toward....
@@Fyre0 lol! Seen it 3 times; probably 10 times all together with the clip channels. All I meant was Paul took over. He was giving the orders, to all the Houses, and saying it in front of The Emperor's Blades. (The Emperor's New Clothes!) LITERALLY! The Power-shift in that scene is AWESOME! But, yeah....I could've phrased it better.
i think it’s hard as fuck that he stood before the blades of the Sardaukar, and ordered their own death at the hands of the Fremen
Feyd looking at Paul is like:
"Can I touch your hair in a non-sexual way?"
Honestly Paul's last words to the Baron shoulda been "The desert takes the weak"
A nice thought, but Paul probably wasn't there to hear the Baron say that.
I say "probably" because there is a chance he could've seen it in a spice vision or something
Wouldn't make sense. He wasn't there to hear that line when the baron said it.
Disagree. The “grandfather” line was perfect.
@@Fyre0He technically was. After the water of life sequence he's given the memory of all of his ancestors, male and female. This would include the Baron.
@@TheRikkarikna Baron wasn't dead yet
Let the desert have what it can take!
Love the irony of his death and his disposal.
For those who are intrigued by the shot of the Baron's head covered with ants that slowly pans down towards his ear, I'm pretty sure that this is an hommage to David Lynch's Blue velvet. I wouldn't be surprised if this scene's purpose was just to pay tribute to Lynch since Denis Villeneuve obviously admires his work and he also adapted Dune. Here's the scene from Blue Velvet below if you want to make up your mind about this theory!
ruclips.net/video/BeYx_CBH700/видео.html
I noticed that too! I also think it is a tribute to Lynch.
The contempt that Paul had when still holding the impaled knife through the Baron's neck, and said, “You die like an animal”.
Feyd was happier than paul
Desert mouse looking at the Baron's body: "Nope."
The worms crawl in! The worms crawl out! The worms play backgammon on your snout! 🎶🐛👍😁
Once those bugs are done with the Baron they’re not gonna need feeding for another year
If they survive the toxic Harkonnen body water. Remember that the Fremen view water taken from Harky corpses to only be good for stillsuit coolant.
The score in this scene is very nice. Something about that high note held while the Baron is getting his neck stuck, mouth agape-it’s all very evoking.
Would have been nice to see the one Fedaykin take out the remaining Imperial guards.
He finally felt the Atreides’s gom jabbar *big chrysknife poke*
The way they managed to make a dead corpse stylized is amazing
They didnt even bother to take his water. I'm not 100% on Fremen lore but that definitely seems like a grave insult.
Am I the only one who feels like the shot with the ants crawling around the Baron's ear is a nod to David Lynch? The ear from Blue Velvett is so fucking iconic, this simply cannot be an accident, right?!?
I would have looted his finger shield device as a trophy at least. And his anti gravity spine, but that was broken.
I love how he just tells them to kill the Sardukar. The power dynamic between the Atredies and Harkonnen's in the first movie helped bolster the image of strength from the Sardukar, and yet Paul tells only a few Fremen to kill the guard like he needs milk from the store, it really helps reinforce the idea that this force could not only combat the great houses but also stand a decent chance as we'll see in the next movie. This from someone who's NOT read the books.
Why kill the last of saudakar? His bodyguards are defeated and impossibly outnumbered. In the old film there were a few of them at the duel
I felt bad for those who carried Baron's deadbody all that way. 😆
He will be back, don't worry
Is 1:37 a nod to David Lynch and what he has brought to the Dune universe? Seems like a throwback to the ear in Blue Velvet
Thing is, this would explain how the Baron is able to possess Alia (if they end up going there). The Sandworms are connected to one another via the spice & the sandtrout, so devouring the Baron could imbue that worm with something of his essence.
Idk why but that simple line, “MY DESERT”, is so imposing
Feyd Rautha enjoying all the deaths in Part Two (possibly including his own) is honestly a mood
In IMAX you heard Feyds stiffy
Imagine the Sardaukar knows language Paul is speaking and when hears he is sentenced to death they behead him as he is ten inches from theirs blades.
Given that Denis was willing to stray a little from the source material, I would have loved to hear Paul say, "hear I am, here I remain," right before sticking the knife in Baron's neck. Invoking Leto's final words would have been a poetic way to signal Paul's identity to Baron (and Paul's genetic memories for the audience).
Except the idea of Paul's "genetic memories" making him special is part of the whole "divine chosen hero" trope that Herbert was directly trying to subvert, so doing "Dune: but we take the blind hero worship part seriously " sounds like a step backwards.
His "grandfather" comment right before stabbing Baron in the neck essentially did the same thing: signaled his identity to Baron and reminded the audience that Paul has genetic memories after drinking the water of life. Right? I just think quoting Leto's last words would have been more satisfying, by placing the emphasis on Paul being Leto's son instead of being Baron's grandson (although he is obviously both).
I do see your point though; I suppose the reason why I think my version would be more satisfying is the same reason why you think it would be more problematic (an even greater "Go Paul" moment?). Is that what you were getting at?
@@bryantaylor2427 Yes, you summed up my position on it very well.
I get why "Go Paul" is the more narratively and psychologically satisfying for people who just want a good story, and from that standpoint, your idea for the line ties all those plot points you listed elegantly, so it's good writing on that front, I grant you, but as someone who identify's with the author's intended political theme more than the protagonist's journey in the fiction, my preferences are as they are.
there have always been female sardaukars...
I don’t think it would have changed the outcome of the Baron’s helper here lived but when Duke Leto died he took this one guy with him and the guys who replaced him afterwards were far less intelligent and capable
So Duke Leto’s final breathe did end up helping Paul and his wife live and probably saved many Fermen lives as more would have died if this guy were around to counter them with better strategies.
Didn't want the Baron's water polluting theirs. Sensible.
0:34 The realization in his face that Paul must be son of his daughter.
Don't worry, he'll be back.
I'm surprised that Paul was able to stab through the Baron's neck fat
Was the suggestion about killing the Sardaukar that it was the duty of the One Fremen Paul tapped on the shoulder? Must have been a Fedaykin....
Wait a minute, i didn't see this scene
The Quote is from part 1
Sandbox in the playground on the recces be like:
Were you guys finding hd quality scenes
Tortuga.
I never knew there were ants in the desert.
He's just sleeping, the fat absorbed the knife.
Like the prophet to his own doom.
Ichi jimmy.
Womp womp
Ironic
Is it crazy for me to think this was a good ending for him? He was freed from himself and his form given to the creatures of the desert, even if it was against his will.
Do the ants really like Harkonnen meat? Stilgar said, they are full of chemicals.
Why sardaukar has less time then Atreides fighters? Isnt it should be THE BEST of THE BEST of them close to Emperor? I just cant imagine that they apaeared so badass at Salusa Secundus with Mongol Chant , Just to have ONE proper fight when they were on atack against Atreides. Second battle is Research center when Duncan died. AND THATS ALL.
Both Atreides and Sardaukar were the best Emperium had aside of Freemen. BUT THEY DIDNT SHOW THEM IN ACTION.
Abomination..
Baron is not dead)))))
actually Paul was merciful towards his Grandfather,he could have placed him in the desert alive to suffer from the elements 🤔
It is a much quicker death than he deserved. But this book was written long before GOT.
Why is bro is so tall
He's fat, so he uses anti-gravity harnesses to get about. That's why they break it, and he just lies there, waiting to be killed.
An oil spill in the desert.
Baron wasn't nasty enough in this. I've never read the book so I have no idea which is closer but the David Lynch Baron is much much more enjoyable and a truly horrific man.
"My Desert."
"MY Arrakis!"
"MY DU-"
*(Cuts to the baron's corpse in the desert)*
The only decent thing the Baron ever did....
I take this as a nod to the classic Dune PC adventure game.
No one understands the Fremen language. Not even the subtitle 😂
I didn't see this part. Must have being in the bathroom. darn.
What were you doing in the bathroom?
@@douglasrodriguez9762Giving away his water
@@maxim196 very generous of you!
Why? Why did he had to kill him? This is in complete contradiction to the book, and will have massive consequences for the story in the future, IF there is a continuation of the films.
It's unnecessary, it's bad, and it's harmful for the entire story.
The way they depicted the baron is bad enough, although it can be explained as "artistic vision" and isn't critical to the story, but this... this right here invalidates the entire Alia story arc.
I disagree, personally, the Baron’s death in the books would have been extremely difficult to adapt on to screen without it looking comical. They are saving Alia for later
It doesn't invalidate anything and it works better for this story. It detracts only slightly from the Alia story, which I won't add to the spoilers of
who is he?
Leonardo DiCaprio's brother.
@@SamBrickell who is he?
@@SamBrickell who is he?
Are you f kidding me... Why you spoiler the whole movie in your f title.
The ending's been "spoiled" for 59 years.
@@colormedubious4747 what a bullshit. its like to say i spoil you all fallout game endings "actually its bin spoiled for 10 years!"
@@nemrasetrail6332 Yes, it's EXACTLY the same thing because there was a Fallout movie in 1984, a SciFi Channel miniseries in 2000, and it was the award-winning science fiction novel that inspired the entire Star Wars universe. Oh, wait. That would be DUNE.
So Apparently this whole movie is a supposedly a symbol of capitalism?
and terrorist guerillas....
Not at all, the story of Dune is a warning against prophets, messiahs and charismatic leaders, and the deadly following they accumulate
the story in itself contains a lot of elements ranging from psychology to ecology to politics to philosophy and everything in between. It's incredibly rich. However, what @AgentMercer said is problably one the major points of the whole story.
The book and other film versions are so much more effective and meaningful, with little Alia killing the big Baron with a gom jabbar. This version ruins this important moment.
No, it doesn't, it's better, indeed.
Both are impactful, just in different respects and different reasons
Why did no one even try to stop him killing the Baron? Seems like a huge plot hole.
A couple of minutes before the Emperor killed his bodyguards and cut the support that kept him floating, so he crawled like an animal, certainly he wanted him dead. The Emperor was an evil man, indeed.
They all hated the Baron.
Paul and his army bested thousands, if not millions of Saudarkar and Harkonnen soldiers before making it to the Imperial Tent. At this point, they become unstoppable and i doubt the remaining saudarkars can do anything
Also consider the fact that the Emperor basically left him to die already. If Paul didn't kill him, he probably would have suffocated to death shortly after.
Ultimately the Sardukar were zealots for the emperor, not any of the houses, and with the situation unfolding the emperor was their priority, and I would agree with others in saying the Barron was likely not well received by others but only necessary because they controlled the spice
this version of dune is so boring
The lack of blood at the baron’s death was cringe
Why would there be blood? The knife was deep in his throat therefore preventing any blood from coming out.
@@Rymaja there would still be some, and when he withdrew the knife there should be blood everywhere, but there was none
the movie was pg 13
@@Lucy-yc4bc still cringe
@@blackoutninja Cringing over the lack of blood, are you an animal?
I can't believe that Paul committed a hate crime by killing an unarmed, disabled and helpless LGBT soul like that, without empathy or remorse, in front of witnesses. That's messed up, people 🤬
Paul is the winner. In his world, he is the law.
And an Alabaman too. Can't believe someone as moral as Paul who never did anything wrong up to this point would commit this.
Alia kills the Baron. All style this film, no substance. Typical for today's audience.
All complains, no appreciation. Typical for today’s comments.
@@elliotyip9844Alia killing the Baron sets up his possession of her mind out of revenge in the next two books. Bruh, read the novels.
@@enceladus3318if you read the novels, you would know that paul sees two main paths after gaining prescience: the one where alia kills the baron, and one where he himself does. In the books, Paul is repulsed by it and actively trying to avoid the jihad, which is why he decides against it. So the movies actually stay true to herberts plot while slightly changing pauls path. It’s a great adaptation.
Noticed how they changed many things for Lord of the Rings? And most of those things were for the better. One cannot keep the book exactly the way it was. It would be incompetent and unfun for the cinema.
@@enceladus3318 I understand where you are coming from, but Villeneuve stated this is a trilogy with Messiah as the last part. Children of Dune is mostly irrelevant to his story.
The desert indeed took the weak 😏
Im just burnt you dont see the fremen dispatch those sardakar, wouldve been dope.
In the books he is killed by Alia, not Paul. . . with a Gom Jabbar.