12 Angry Men (1957) - movie reaction - BRITISH FILM STUDENT FIRST TIME WATCHING
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 окт 2024
- Instagram: / ryan_watching
or
Twitter: / ryanwatching
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL BY GETTING SOMETHING COOL
www.redbubble....
Hello and welcome to another Movie reaction video!
I know my uploads are still sporadic but I am still recording and dripping them through, appreciate you lot sticking around!
This one has been suggested for a while and I finally got round to it.
This was a real treat for me, it was like watching a master of the discipline just show off and it was perfect.
I hope you enjoyed this reaction and there are more films coming as well as the regular series. Just hold tight and I'll see you when I see you.
Appreciate all the support as usual! 
Кино
Many decades later, and this film is still brilliantly engrossing. Top notch film.
Fun fact: The guy with the high voice (John Fiedler) is the voice of Piglet on Winnie the Pooh. 🐷
He did a lot of voice work in a lot of films and TV shows. He was also on Star Trek:TOS...he was in the episode where Scotty appears to have murdered a woman, but it turns out it was the alien spirit of Jack the Ripper that had been moving from person to person. 💯✌😁
He was a regular on Bonanza too
He was also in True Grit with John Wayne, he played the lawyer.
He was also in The Munsters.
Also played Vinnie in the film version of "The Odd Couple." Maybe not so coincidently he also appeared with Jack Klugman (seen here in this movie) in the TV version, but as a couple of different characters, other than Vinnie. ..Winnie The Pooh's voice was done by Sterling Holloway, who voiced, and acted in many films, and TV shows..One was The Adventures of Superman..Another as the voice of The Cheshire Cat in Disney's "Alice In Wonderland."..Really too many to list here, though...Both terrific character actors throughout their long careers.
I was on a jury once where 2 NYPD detectives were charged with stealing bearer bonds from a lawyer's office where they were investigating a break-in .The first vote was 10 to 2 for acquittal ,I and one other juror voted guilty .We discussed it for hours and finally convicted them .
Do you think you could have stood strong if it had been 11 against you at the start? Thank you for bringing Justice.
@@RLucas3000 It amazed me that people could sit and listen to testimony and see exhibits and not understand the significance ,or lack thereof ,of evidence .There were 6 bearer bonds of $5,000 each stolen . The bank records of the two detectives were presented as evidence ,both of them showed three $5,000 deposits starting about a month after the burglary and spaced out about a month apart .All of the ones who voted for acquittal said they didn't believe that NYPD detectives would steal , LOL
If there ever was a film that could considered to be a master class in acting, this is it !!!
The only movie where 99.9% is shot in 1 room. High dollar cast but minimal set budget. Brilliant writing and Directing.
Detective Story (1951) is another one like that. It stars Kirk Douglas, and it's a hell of a movie. I've read that it also inspired the show Barney Miller to some degree; that show was mostly set in a squad room, too.
@@oliviarogers3559 Dial M For Murder 1954, Lifeboat 1944.
Rope. Not only one room, but each take was a full reel of film (about 11 minutes) then edited together with transitions such as panning across a pillar so it looks like all one single take.
Man from earth. its just as good
Wait Until Dark with Audrey Hepburn.
The blocking, long take monologues, etc., it's all the value of theater experience. Many of the actors had extensive on-stage careers in plays and in vaudeville acts (as well as being in films). 12 Angry Men is excellent material for stage actors. Characters all have their nuances in how they act alone as well as with others. They are all totally believable personalities made dynamic by the fact they're all forced to be together in this one room, in the heat, debating a trial where a life hangs in the balance... everything bubbles up: animosities, prejudices, raw nerves... There's a good reason why it's consistently viewed as one of the best films of all time.
twelve angry men was originally a stage play, so not surprising
Nicely put. It's a flawless film & I only know one other.
I found it interesting that the walls were all moved inward as it progresses.
THIS IS ONE OF MY FAVORITE FILMS OF ALL TIME! I always just loved the story line and character development. The “simplicity” of the movie was something I always loved, but after having been watching this channel, I can definitely see that it’s not simple at all. Great reaction! Love to see the post analysis and cool post edit notes too! *applause* 👏🏽
It is one of mine now too! The simplicity of it's one location and concentration on performance and dialogue is so beautifully complimented by the expert cinematography. Thank you for the suggestion, you were right about how much I would like this one!
@@WatchMeMovie I’m so glad you did this and I can’t remember who commented before that this movie was “a love letter to rationality” but I thought it was a perfect comment that encompasses this film.
I really enjoyed the post analysis on this reaction and was wondering if you ever thought of doing a video essay on your favorite films. Say one film for lighting, one for dialogue, blocking, etc. I’m interested to hear your thoughts on films you’ve seen a few times and why they’re your favorites. Again, great reaction, great channel, and I just adore your voice! 👍🏽♥️
@@alyssaramirez7014 Yeah that really is a perfect description and I do remember the comment. I have been toying with the idea of doing commentaries on my favourites which I think I would really enjoy. I hadn't considered doing it in that way though and really like the idea! Thank you as always for your input, I appreciate it
@@WatchMeMovie one thing that impresses me that I just thought about is that Henry Fonda is obviously the protagonist but a lot of the other characters have valuable contributions. In a lot of movies and tv shows only the protagonist ever has any good ideas.
Not only that but their contributions make perfect sense. The short guy talks about how awkward it would be to stab a taller man like that. The guy from the ghetto tells them how a switchblade is used. Etc.
Next time you watch this, note how the camera starts above the actor's heads, comes down to eye level later, then towards the end, is below eye level, looking up, increasing the feeling of tension and claustrophobia. Such a high quality film.
This movie is about prejudice we all have. People judge others unfairly based on their ethnicity and the economic class. This is true today as much as it was back then. It's also very difficult to stand up against injustice when you're in the minority. Most people will go along with the group.
The very best of American Cinema - I love watching people react to this for the first time ;)
Same here!
This is a perfect movie, i have seen it well over 50 times... That cast were some of the best actors of that time...
I knew you'd love this one. a masterpiece in filmmaking for sure!
This movie is a masterclass in filmmaking, and the remake is not even a quarter as good.
If you mean the tv movie from i think '97 i actually enjoyed it a lot... i had seen it before the original though.
To me one of the best films ever. Great acting from an all star cast starting with Henry Fonda. All filmed in a 12 foot room. I love that it was filmed in black and white. Gives it that old time filming. Imo movies were better back in the day as weee the actors.
Extraordinary screenplay. And Acting. And cinematography.
Lee J. Cobb is best known as Willy Loman in "Death of a Salesman" on Broadway.
I watched the 1997 remake first, but loved the original. It’s insanely relieving to finally hear Juror #3 say “Not guilty” after ninety minutes.
This film is a Rembrandt. All art, depth, brilliantly blocked---and actors who were flawless. In a category by itself.
These jurors spend a great deal of time going over just about everything about the case, which is exactly what they're supposed to do.
I remember watching this movie in my high school English class. Watching all of the character development in one room the entire movie was really impressive!
Henry Fonda always played the good guy--except when he played a vicious killer in Sergio Leone's excellent "Once Upon A Time In The West". It put a lot of fans into shock.
Also, the angry belligerent juror was played by Lee J. Cobb. One of the last roles he ever played was the calm enigmatic detective in "The Exorcist". A huge difference in tempers.
I loved Cobb in this.
Well, in "You Only Live Once" (1937) the second film Fritz Lang made after getting out of Nazi Germany, Hank Fonda is an ex-convict who runs into problems trying to go straight. Lang's first American picture, "Fury" (1936), featured another good guy, Spencer Tracy, in a similar role (framed for a crime he didn't commit). Each movie featured Sylvia Sydney as the loyal gal who loves her man.
I adore this film. Thanks so much for the review, and I'm so glad you enjoyed it.
No action, no special effects, nothing fancy. Just 12 fantastic actors in a room with some of the best dialogue ever written. One of the best films ever made
I saw that movie at 13 years old when it first came out. I was riveted.
You were born in 1944?
@@alyssaramirez7014 yes
Excellent choice, and reaction! I didn't sit down to watch this until I was in my 30's, and afterwards regretted not having watched it sooner. The evolution of every character, and the subtle draw of the viewers eye with simple lighting is just spectacular.
P.S. from one curly haired person to another: love the lack of beanie.
Thanks! Yeah this was such a refined piece of film and theatre. It was such a treat to watch
I’ve loved this movie ever since I first saw it in a middle school social studies class.
Excellent commentary. I've been watching this film for 40 years and with each viewing I pick up something new. Although some of the dialogue now seems dated and stilted -- it works. Thanks for reminding me it's time to see it again!
Originally written as a teleplay for America's CBS Network back in '54.
I love the overhead shot during the closing credits with eleven jurors seated at the table and Juror #10 in a chair by the wall. Clearly that was Sidney Lumet's way of saying that all viewpoints were welcome except that of the bigot. It's also interesting to see how the progressively lower camera angles increase the tension as the deliberations progress.
Justin Fries May seem obvious, but I love how Ryan's knowledge and intense occupation with film techniques prompt commenters to notice those things too.
@@ralphficker167 I so agree. When he pointed out a long take of the jurors ending to show Henry Fonda by the window, to show that Juror #8 is somehow apart from the others, or mentioned the camera movements I wasn't paying attention to, or explained how a particular framing of the juror's faces was meant to reinforce some tension or emotion, I felt almost as if I were in a film appreciation course. Truly superior commentary on one of my favorite movies ever!
@@principals16842 Well said!
I remember watching that a young man in the 70s. It had a long lasting impact on me.
You sure are right about the shot blocking...these all were top-of-the-list actors - not a newbie in the bunch - and they understood implicitly how to hit marks and know their and everybody else's lines!
In 1953, there was a live TV version of this movie. In fact, a couple of the actors in the movie were in that earlier live TV version. Anyway, the live broadcast was about 50 minutes and can be seen on RUclips. It was almost like watching a live play.
Even the costuming was brilliant. Henry Fonda in a white/light-colored suit while everyone else was in darker clothing, the lone initial voice for acquittal when everyone else was ready to convict. Have seen this film multiple times over 50 years and never even noticed that until just now.
This movie should be mandatory viewing for every trial juror before deliberating
Liked this since childhood,im 66 now.back when I saw it first,I thought the kid was found innocent.but at some point I realised,he was really found not guilty.took time to understand the difference.
This might be one of the greatest ensemble casts of all time. But, you must also see Fail Safe. Also directed by Sidney Lumet, it's the serious version of Dr. Strangelove. PS these actors are the epitome of professional actors. The didn't need much in the way of rehearsals.
IMO this should be on the list of Top 20 , 15, or even 10 best movies of all time. Cause this movie is still relevant today.
One of the greatest pieces of cinema ever produced.
What a movie I'm now 60 yrs I only saw half the movie first time because I had to go to bed for school the next day WOW
when I saw the full movie a masterpiece. To Kill a MOCKINGBIRD is also great .
Yup. Big time. Thanks for sharing.Glad you saw this.
Great reaction vid. Really appreciate your comments on how well the movie was crafted. I've always believed that this is a perfect example of an attempt to make a play into a film. Originally conceived as a television play to a stage play then to a movie for the silver screen. This movie also holds up to modern times in it's relevance to the attitudes and preconceived notions of people. Thanks so much for reviewing what I consider to be a cinematic masterpiece. You've earned a new follower in me. Keep up the good work.
Thank you very much for the comment Larry! Yes this was such a treat to watch through and as soon as I have time I will be watching again
@@WatchMeMovie If you don't mind subtitles, which I think you won't, please try any of Akira Kurosawa's movies. Like Ran, Throne of Blood, or
7 Samurai.
Or if you just want some fun try out
Shogun Assassin. It's not KURASOWA , but it's a trip.
Love these older film reactions. The classics. Please do more! Anatomy of a Murder and Rear Window are some of my favorites that I think could pair well with this one.
I enjoy watching films with people who understand filmmaking - I don’t. Your observations make it interesting. Thank you…
Juror #7: "You a Yankee fan?"
Juror #5: "No, Baltimore."
Juror #7: "Baltimore? That's like being hit in the head with a crowbar once a day."
(As an Orioles fan, I sadly have to agree with this exchange.)
I've read the room was made smaller, by moving the walls in slightly, as the movie progresses. It added to the closeness, along with the many close ups, to the scenes as the climax approached.
In the US system, the jury is a check against the power of the state, which has sole jurisdiction to prosecute crimes.
I can tell you're very engrossed in this movie. Respect. 👌
I've seen this film so many times I've lost count. It's a timeless classic and it never gets old.
Weird that I vividly remember Jack Klugman and yet totally forgot Henry Fonda was in this movie.
This is a group of some of the finest New York stage actors. Henry Fonda went back on Broadway often. Lee J Cobb was the original Willie Lowman in Death of a Salesman.
All of them had fine careers on TV, Stage and Screen.
This is a great movie.
Have you reviewed FAIL SAFE?
I LOVE the original Fail Safe and like the remake!
This is an excellent movie. It's also an excellent example of jury misconduct.
I've lost count of how many times I've seen this film, yet I never tire of watching it even though I know exactly what's going to happen. This, really, makes no sense. Perhaps it's the pleasure of certain great moments. e.g. "He's an old man, he was confused, how can he be sure of anything?"(d'oh!) Man who says he never sweats wipes sweat from his forehead after being questioned about the movies he saw. The perfect delivery of the line "you don't really mean you'll kill me, do you?" when we realize Fonda's character was just baiting him into saying it. Perhaps it's just the pleasure of a perfect screenplay, perfectly acted and directed.
Still looking forward to seeing you and your brother!!!👏👏👏
These were all such well done characters that truly seem like real people. I would be interested to see who people identify most with. I personally see myself most in juror number 4. I’m a mathematician and statistician and his logical systematic way of thinking, while not being emotionally tied to his beliefs is very relatable to me
One of my favorite films.
You're like the most chilled RUclipsr I've ever seen. Definitely not a criticism, by the way. I hate people who act hyperactive all the damn time.
But yeah, this film is one of the greatest in my opinion.
If only any modern jury took this process as seriously. I sincerely hope that they do. I was on a jury for D.U.I.. We argued constantly. Not an easy process. As it should be.
When the vote goes to 6-6...the fan comes on and rain begins to fall.....been heating the audience up for half their movie and now comes the cool down and rebirth
Best film ever. It combines the best aspects of a play with everything cinematography has to offer. (Well, it doesn't have any special effects but special effects wouldn't have served any purpose)
Classic Film that began its life as a Play . Acted by 12 great actors
One of the things that's the most brilliant thing about this movie is the boy may have been guilty all along. It's interesting how an 11 to 1 vote to convict goes to a 12 to 0 vote for acquittal in under two hours. We are not lead to believe there is any additional dialogue that was left out of this process. So perhaps they were a bit quick to get all on the same page to simply end the process so they could go home.
In reality, trial deliberations in murder cases can take weeks to resolve. But this film is amazing at showing that entire process in a short time period. Everyone should see it at least once in their lifetime.
I haven't watched this film in over twenty years. It was a pleasure to revisit it with you! Thanks for reminding me of what a great film this is!
I love this movie. It's truly a masterpiece of film making. Not just as a piece of entertainment (because it's riveting) but also as a piece of art. Very rarely do movies manage to pull of both perfectly. We go through the movie without ever learning the character's names (except for two at the very end) and yet their characters and personalities are constructed so brilliantly over the movie.
Brilliantly written. Brilliantly directed. Brilliantly acted. It's perfect. There isn't a single part of the movie where I didn't think the character speaking believed what they were saying and felt what they were feeling.
The range of emotions that flow throughout the movie are what helps make it so good. It hits on so many levels.
Sidney Lumet, before the devil knows you’re dead,
Phillip S Hoffman, Ethan Hawk, Albert Finney, and Marisa Tommey (2007)
His last film I think?
Sidney Lumet rehearsed the actors in all his movies for 2-3 weeks. That's not taught in film school but as a professional actor I can tell you it's highly recommended. There is so downside and it does NOT kill spontaneity. It actually breads it.
A really great film. Regarding the long take and blocking that you noted at the opening here, I would recommend seeing Hitchcock’s film Rope for a remarkable sequence along these lines.
Brett V I hadn't thought of it but you're right. Rope would be a perfect follow-on to 12 Angry Men. Rope takes place in a tight space as well. It has the same claustrophobic feel.
Great suggestion Brett, Rope is one of my favourites ever for that exact reason. Might do a commentary at some point
Classic flick. You might want to investigate more influential B & W films: Casablanca, Dr Strangelove and the Maltese Falcon come to mind.
Sidney Lumet has plenty worthwhile stuff to say about the cinematography of _12 Angry Men_ in his book, _Making Movies_ (1996).
one of the all time great movies
Watching 12 Angry Men blazed is a good shout
Too many ways to say how brilliant this film is. And a cast of legends. Another one from this era that I recommend. And also featuring Lee J Cobb. On The Waterfront-1954(Marlon Brando, Carl Malden, Rod Steiger, Eve Marie Saint). A drama of dramas.
If you enjoy classic courtroom dramas, check out *"Inherit The Wind" (1960)* with Spencer Tracy, Frederic March and Gene Kelly.
My absolute Favourite Courtroom Film! .... Also Judgement at Nuremberg!
That is a great movie one of my favorite Spencer Tracy movies.
Bad Day at Black Rock is also very good.
Brilliant writing, directing, camera work and actors. Just about perfect.
Hey so glad you like it. Old movies are great. You should explore some more. Try Casablanca, Double Indemnity, and Psycho (perfect for October)
Try "The Children's Hour" (1961) starring Audrey Hepburn, Shirley MacLaine, and James Garner. (Shirley is 97 and still with us---she is also Warren Beatty's sister).
If you like serious dramas with mature themes then this is for you, my transatlantic friend!
Great reaction. You helped me appreciate a movie I’ve never finished watching. Maybe he voted not guilty as a power trip, to see how many men he could get to change their mind. I could never accept that more of those men wouldn’t say, hey, slow down, we have an important job to do here.
18:41 nice spider in the wall xD
A bit of trivia, the director had the walls moved in closer as the tension built in the film. The 1997 is a quality remake with excellent acting and direction like this one.
This was an excellent stage play before adapted to this film. This play would never be made today into a film of the same type unless they included flashbacks with car explosions, etc. in them. A story with a plot and dialogue heavy? What's that?
This dude sounds like a PBS Radio Deejay.
Lee J Cobb ! All great thanks for sharing your thoughts and reactions!
I think this is the first video I've watched of yours with no hat, lol. Nice hair :) Great reaction to a great film.
Mine is a very late commentary on your reaction, but I was so impressed by it that I decided to write this anyway. Easily the best reaction that I've seen out of about a dozen heretofore. I really appreciated how you didn't nonsensically blather away every .07 scds like the VAST majority of the other self-important, imbecilic reactors who quite plainly, and delusionally, fashioned themselves as the second coming of Hitchcock. My grandparents on my Mom's side were born, raised, and spent most of their lives in Belfast, so I have a fondness for Irish, English, and Scottish reactors (and people in general). I've heartily subscribed to your channel!
Please, please, please..."Night of the Hunter"!!!
This movie was shot in only two weeks!!!
the first time I watched this, I loved it so much I made me housemate watch it with me the next day.
I'm a big fan of film noir and old movies in general. This film had me captivated. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
My username is a film noir starring Joan Crawford. I think it would be a good film for a young filmmaker to watch.
Nice, thoughtful reaction. You mentioned blocking and other technical aspects a couple times. I strongly recommend Sidney Lumet's book "Making Movies." It's a fascinating and illuminating look behind the scenes told from a longtime director's POV. As director he works with everyone: producers, writers, actors, casting, all manner of crew. One of the things I remember most is the role serendipity plays. You have this amazing collection of talent in front and back of the camera, seasoned professionals, yet a lot of the time the magic comes down to luck (of course the odds of capturing the magic moment are much better when the people working on it are really good at what they do.)
Great reaction👍You must watch The Ox-Bow Incedint. Another magnifint and similar film, that also stars Henry Fonda.
I first saw the remake that was made in the mud 80s perhaps. I was telling my mom how good it was and she told me it was a remake. Yes the original is better. My mom loved movies and I miss watching them with her 😊
Anyone that reacts to Sidney Lumet is worthy of subscription. Lumet is probably one of the most underrated geniuses in all of film history. The later version of this also has a stellar cast, but what Lumet did with it is timelessly classic in ways that no other version possibly could be. I hope you will check out Fail Safe, at some point...it is the serious counterpart to Kubrick's Dr. Strangelove...and an even better film than that classic, if you ask me. 🖖✌
I totally agree, Fail-Safe is a great movie, It was something like a shock when I discovered it, at the end of the movie, I just said woaaaa...
The juror who scolds the other about voting not guilty is a hypocrite. The first vote he waited to see what others voted and voted guilty without even discussing the case.
I would recommend The Exorcist, One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest and Children of Men.
this movie revolves around how the jury comes to it's verdict.juror # 8 says more than once that they might be letting a guilty man go free.the concept of reasonable doubt comes into play and by the end the original vote is completely reversed.
This was great acting from the whole cast. The last juror, Lee J Cobb, to me played the best part. I hated him from the beginning. When he broke down, that changed it for me. What acting from him, and the entire cast. I've heard some of the great directors say that this movie is in the top 5 great movies of all time. I agree.
Glad to see your appreciation for this top calibre movie. I was on a superior court jury once where on two of the charges I was the only dissenter. I thought at once of Henry Fonda in this film. As it turns out the others convinced me to change my vote and we had considered a total of five charges after which I really felt that justice was done and the process is a powerful one by a jury of one's peers.
The 1997 remake is excellent in its own right. You might enjoy watching it, too. I would also recommend The Manchurian Candidate (1962) with Laurence Harvey. Angela Lansbury, and Frank Sinatra.
An American classic, a let's face it they're few and far between. A nice analysis once again Ryan.
I love the way Lumet adapted the play into a film. As a one room play the audience is distanced and the setting is static but in film Lumet was able to use close-ups and move around the room, it never felt tedious or closed-in. There was a parody of this film for an episode of Amy Schumer's TV show shot in black and white with several well known actors playing characters deciding whether Amy Schumer was hot enough to have her own TV show that is f*cking funny. If you want to see some other great Sidney Lumet directed films I suggest "Dog Day Afternoon" or "Network".
How someone forcing people to stop and think can change the world… kinda timely if you ask me. 🤗