Elon Musk - My Opinion on the Existence of Alien Life

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 апр 2024
  • Elon Musk discusses the possibility of alien life existing in the universe.
    Buy my book, Thomas Paine: A Lifetime of Radicalism:
    📘Personalized copies: davidbenner.square.site/
    📘Amazon Paperback: amzn.to/3VicR3I
    📘Amazon Hardcover: amzn.to/3v7JnuT
    Buy my book, Compact of the Republic: The League of States and the Constitution:
    📘Personalized copies: davidbenner.square.site/
    📘Amazon Paperback: amzn.to/43ekhr0
    📘Amazon Hardcover: amzn.to/4a0QvrI
    Buy my book, The 14th Amendment and the Incorporation Doctrine:
    📘Personalized copies: davidbenner.square.site/
    📘Amazon Paperback: amzn.to/3TaREX5

Комментарии • 71

  • @Liberty-Vault
    @Liberty-Vault  2 месяца назад +2

    Do you believe alien life exists? Why or why not?6
    To buy my books, including Thomas Paine: A Lifetime of Radicalism, check out my online bookstore: davidbenner.square.site

    • @sitindogmas
      @sitindogmas Месяц назад

      50/50 life exists outside our realm of comprehension

  • @juicedawell2402
    @juicedawell2402 Месяц назад +14

    Just what an alien would say...

  • @robertscheidt2076
    @robertscheidt2076 Месяц назад +2

    He is one smart, extremely smart human being. We are watching brilliance unfold before us

  • @MrShysterme
    @MrShysterme Месяц назад +2

    You can't judge the probability of intelligent life forming elsewhere based upon our current observations. You can't even say it must not be super rare event. We literally have close to no information on the probabilities elsewhere based upon it forming on Earth. I think the only information we have is "it is possible, and it happened here." Even if we could trace the exact path here and determine the conditional probabilities, then it would only be the probabilities for one among potentially many paths to intelligent life (and we can't even do that, really at all, other than "it was a super rare thing").
    Imagine a Powerball winner thinking "the odds I won are so low that I must have been chosen" when in reality a winner was eventually inevitable given the number of trials and any person that won could have thought the same thing. It could be that the odds of intelligent life forming are so low that it happened only once. It didn't have to have happened on Earth (this is where the inversion of "common sense" happens). If it had happened instead on a distant planet and taken a different evolutionary path, then the intelligent entities on that planet could also think "gee, it must not be the rarest thing if it happened here." So, the thinking of "it must be relatively common in the Universe because it happened on Earth" is faulty. Also, the thinking that any planet similar to Earth is equally likely to have life is also faulty because there are many things we don't know about that happened that are not totally dependent upon Earth's composition, distance from a star, etc.
    If everyone on Earth rolled a many-sided die simultaneously and your die came up "winner" or whatever, it is not possible to deduce the overall odds based upon only your observation of "winning." Unless you know more about the situation (number of trials, number of other "winners", etc) then you know next to nothing about the underlying odds.
    If anyone has a counter to this, I'd like to hear it. Probability problems are interesting because they are often counter-intuitive and invert our "common sense". What I've written is, I believe, so fundamentally true that I'm surprised that more folks don't discuss it in this context. It should be the basic framework of the probabilistic discussion. I've seen a counterargument as "but come on, do you really think we were that lucky?" but that is a faulty one because you are assuming the "we" (meaning Earthlings) and so you haven't yet understood the overall logic. It's very egocentric thinking. I think this might be glossed over in discussion by people that should know better simply because it is not an interesting solution to consider, but it is the simplest one.

  • @VeniVidiVid
    @VeniVidiVid Месяц назад +4

    They could just be too far away or too long ago. Spacetime is inconceivably huge. The odds of two civilizations arising, being able to communicate, and being close enough to communicate while both still exist, may just be too low.

  • @ChristianJaredful
    @ChristianJaredful 4 дня назад

    The Earth has existed for 4.54 billion years, with consciousness emerging just 0.0066% into its history around 300,000 years ago, and while human knowledge has grown exponentially, the rapid and accelerating advancement of alien civilizations makes it highly unlikely that human consciousness and alien development phases would coincide, preventing coexistence.

  • @chloehood6355
    @chloehood6355 Месяц назад +2

    We are still trying to secure
    intelligent life on earth ! R

  • @user-mz8dv9cx4z
    @user-mz8dv9cx4z Месяц назад

    Addoro,quando ride 🕊🫂🥰🪷♾️❤️❤️‍🔥

  • @victorguay7737
    @victorguay7737 Месяц назад

    There are billions of galaxies we can’t even communicate with, so there is a very strong possibility that intelligent life is or has happened beyond our reach, that has to be considered.

  • @krivvysann5091
    @krivvysann5091 Месяц назад +1

    Our existence gives a sign that there may be some alien life thriving beyond the cosmos.👽❤🙂

    • @gustavomurillo2033
      @gustavomurillo2033 День назад

      Obession of wishing life existed it lol we are thr only oness designed to exist here

  • @futuresmkt
    @futuresmkt Месяц назад +1

    To do that, we have to redefine the laws of physics and/or physiology

    • @babacalouche
      @babacalouche Месяц назад

      exactly...this is really an agenda to spend billions of dollars to explore an hypothetic escape possibility to a very hostile planet whereas, with those billions we could spare the destruction of our own planet...how stupid and biased you need to be to waste, destroy your own habitat to just justify the space exploration in a long distant future ...At the moment, the best way to explore planet without risking human life is only through probes and machines.

  • @ComputerTechNL
    @ComputerTechNL Месяц назад

    This year will be crazy also we will meet this year the first one type off alien.😊

  • @rubycourey6370
    @rubycourey6370 Месяц назад

    What about signs of other beings before man on Earth?

  • @edwardlewis1963
    @edwardlewis1963 Месяц назад

    @1:16 "since civilization started "
    When did civilization start?
    Has civilization completed getting started?
    Maybe that's where we have to get to.

  • @robtennapel78
    @robtennapel78 Месяц назад +5

    I find it perplexing when individuals assert that we are alone in the vastness of the universe. Our understanding of the universe, including concepts like gravity, time, and space, remains limited. Dismissing the possibility of extraterrestrial life appears as a display of extreme egotism. Just as historical figures once believed Earth was the center of the universe, assuming humanity holds a singular position seems equally shortsighted. Even esteemed figures like Elon Musk, despite their expertise, may overlook this broader perspective. Our inability to detect extraterrestrial life doesn't negate its existence; perhaps alien life exists abundantly, even within our own planet.

    • @dudestien
      @dudestien Месяц назад

      We are the only conscious beings brother we are the gods

    • @robtennapel78
      @robtennapel78 Месяц назад +1

      @@dudestien we are gods I give you that but we are not alone…

    • @NigelTufnel612
      @NigelTufnel612 Месяц назад +2

      @@dudestien No, God is God, and we are his creation.

    • @dudestien
      @dudestien Месяц назад

      @@NigelTufnel612 the two smart people were tlaling

    • @Andy-wn6wm
      @Andy-wn6wm Месяц назад

      There are more galaxies than grains of sand on this planet...

  • @stuarthdoblin
    @stuarthdoblin Месяц назад

    Who explained consciousness to Musk as a limitation? Why did Musk agree to believe it?

  • @markanderson9772
    @markanderson9772 Месяц назад

    I have to think that aliens exist but that does not mean they are like humans nor are they likely visiting our rock.

  • @davidgkirk
    @davidgkirk Месяц назад +5

    The aliens are fattening us up before they eat us

  • @belliappa9031
    @belliappa9031 Месяц назад +3

    Civilisations started way back 10.000 years ago…. Come to India we show it in our temples and scripts

  • @NJTremblay-dp4gr
    @NJTremblay-dp4gr Месяц назад +4

    we are the aliens, we are what Graham Hancock said .. a species with amnesia

  • @sitindogmas
    @sitindogmas Месяц назад

    my aunts fight over perks

  • @gregorysagegreene
    @gregorysagegreene Месяц назад

    How does he *know* the dinosaurs didn't have spaceships?
    "If aliens exist my rockets are super-passe."
    Why is he blatantly ignoring military admissions?

  • @petermaingi6268
    @petermaingi6268 Месяц назад

    Archeology.. what is Elon's opinion on Peruvian tridactyl mummified bodies (govt sent a special police unit to disband doctors and archaeologists gathering in Peru in April, 2024).. other tridactyl bodies, one with breastplate are being investigated by the Mexican govt. Why do these tridactyl bodies (3 legs and 3 toes) look human?

  • @juicedawell2402
    @juicedawell2402 Месяц назад

    Does the burning ash leave the fire to start another?
    Does it burn out in the air?
    Or never leave the fire?

  • @medievalknievel
    @medievalknievel Месяц назад +1

    We are all guests on this planet you may be in $1 million Beverly Hills mansion or a Slum It doesn’t matter you’re still a guest and your stay will be short Until the next world

  • @sukender99
    @sukender99 22 дня назад

    We haven’t been able to fully send a satellite out of our galaxy yet. We are not intelligent enough to understand the universes’

  • @quantumac
    @quantumac Месяц назад +2

    I think I see the formula here: First, laughingly and completely disregard any evidence which *_MIGHT_* indicate we are being visited by more-advanced non-human intelligence and refuse to look into the subject further, because of course it's all "laughable". Second, ask "where are all the aliens?" Finally, conclude we are alone in the universe because you don't see any evidence otherwise. Nice bit of circular reasoning there.

    • @gregorysagegreene
      @gregorysagegreene Месяц назад

      Highly suspicious such an axiomatic intelligence is so much in denial or closed-minded? 🤔

    • @user-jc2rp2he6z
      @user-jc2rp2he6z 21 день назад

      Exactly, this is something that I have been saying almost my whole life, the idea of dismissing a very important possibility like this all on the basis of ‘it sounds weird/crazy’ is just completely absurd, all while claiming to be rational person in the room which is ridiculous because terms like weird or crazy are inherently subjective. I’m obviously not against disproving claims that are objectively wrong but you’d better have an argument other than ‘it’s weird/crazy’ (which isn’t really an argument because of the aforementioned subjectivity) funnily enough you need to actually understand what’s being stated and then objectively prove why it can’t be the case. Because what you’re really doing when you put those labels on someone is you’re saying “look at this person they’re so stupid, who’d want to be like them/agree with them” preventing any kind of discussion from taking place and actually getting to the bottom of it, it’s simply a way of posturing your supposed intellectual superiority as opposed to actually contributing anything useful. Weirdness, craziness or whatever term you want to use, these are not some sort of objective unit of measurement that can be used to tangibly describe reality. Then of course there’s the reluctance to actually investigate the issue because firstly you’ll be asked for evidence (which is obviously understandable) but then when you say you don’t have any that is apparently enough to just shut the whole conversation down and never look into this topic again (especially in a practical way) which if you’re goal was to lessen people’s suspicions, well congratulations they’re even more suspicious now and it is hardly irrational for them to be.

  • @babacalouche
    @babacalouche Месяц назад

    oh hello dear human beings fellows, shall we do some things like other human beings do to have fun tonight ? just like...regular human beings that are absolutely not aliens under disguise ..ok ?

  • @chocolate-teapot
    @chocolate-teapot Месяц назад

    There probably were other conscious beings, but we exist at a different time. Aliens don't exist.

  • @j.d.7444
    @j.d.7444 Месяц назад

    Wrong!
    7:20

  • @anthonymichaelwilson8401
    @anthonymichaelwilson8401 Месяц назад

    Any Alien life out there would laugh at what we class as intelligence still walking out of the caves lol 😂

  • @LHVMleodragonlamb
    @LHVMleodragonlamb Месяц назад

    maybe Russia knows about aliens

  • @TheScaryTruthCatalyst
    @TheScaryTruthCatalyst Месяц назад

    Elon is a deep thinker for sure.

  • @xentaatnex8261
    @xentaatnex8261 Месяц назад +1

    If aliens exist in this expansive universe, i would say that human beings on planet Earth are the example of an alien civilization.

  • @ZionistWorldOrder
    @ZionistWorldOrder Месяц назад

    no sumerians anymore... who you been bombing in iraq for decades?

  • @jonnyutah3180
    @jonnyutah3180 Месяц назад

    Dogs are aliens , we feed them house them , care for them. 🐶