When the Earth Suddenly Stopped Warming
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 июн 2024
- PBS Member Stations rely on viewers like you. To support your local station, go to to.pbs.org/DonateEons
↓ More info below ↓
For decades, scientists have been studying the cause of the Younger Dryas, and trying to figure out if something like it could happen again. And it turns out that what caused this event is the subject of a heated debate.
Thanks to these wonderful paleoartists for their excellent illustrations!
Jack Byrley: / bedupolker
Fabrizio De Rossi: / artoffabricious
Julio Lacerda: / juliotheartist
Produced in collaboration with PBS Digital Studios: / pbsdigitalstudios
Super special thanks to the following Patreon patrons for helping make Eons possible:
Simon read, Reco Lee, Sean C. Kennedy, Eric Roberto Rodriguez, Charles Copley, Hillary Ryde-Collins, Facts Dinosaurs, Frida, YaBoiSam36, Matthew Donnelly, Yu Mei, Colleen Troussel, Dan Ritter, faxo, Gary Walker, Amanda Straw, Stephanie Tan, Anthony Callaghan, Minyuan Li, Ben Cooper, Leonid, Robert Noah, Matt Parker, Heathe Kyle Yeakley, Jerrit Erickson, Jack Arbuckle, Anton Bryl, MissyElliottSmith, Zachary Spencer, Stefan Weber, Andrey, Ilya Murashov, Larry Wilson, Merri Snaidman, Gabriel Cortez, Marcus Lejon, Robert Arévalo, Todd Dittman, Betsy Radley, Laura Sanborn, PS, Philip Slingerland, John Vanek, Eric Vonk, Henrik Peteri, Jon Monteiro, James Bording, Miles Chaston, Michael McClellan, Jeff Graham, Maria Humphrey, Daisuke Goto, Gregory Kintz, Chandler Bass, Tsee Lee, Robert Hill
If you'd like to support the channel, head over to / eons and pledge for some cool rewards!
Want to follow Eons elsewhere on the internet?
Facebook - / eonsshow
Twitter - / eonsshow
Instagram - / eonsshow
References: docs.google.com/document/d/1C... 
Наука
Hi all! A quick correction: at 9:17, our temperature conversion graphic mistakenly converts the temperature difference as an absolute temperature. A change of 10°C is equivalent to 18°F.
We apologize for the error and a big thanks to VUQuadrophenia for pointing this out to us!
Greeting from the St’át’imc First nation of BC Canada. Our people have stories of the great flood, and how we survived by tying canoes to a mountain top, afterwards repopulating the land
@@derrickbarney8731 thats really cool.
@@derrickbarney8731 Then your ancestors had more luck then the Clovis people. They exited together with the mastodon.
Its late and I m ight be dumb, but I dont understand what this is correcting? If it isnt absolute but relative, why mention the C-F conversion?
@@ttaibe it's correcting that while 10°C = 50°F, a change of 10°C is not equivalent to a change in 50°F.
Is it just me or do major catastrophes always seem to happen at the same time? Its always like "Its hard to determine the cause because there was a massive flood, a meteor impact, a volcanic erruption, a huge earthquake, Godzilla fought King Kong, and the Fire Nation attacked all at around the same time."
Misery likes company
All they're missing is a zombie apocalypse and a pandemic.
There is option that culmination of all that stuff around same time is what to blame.
It's probably because a massive impact would cause flooding earthquakes and volcanic eruptions!!!!
The meteor could have caused the flood.
I love how suddenly is such a relative term.
poor northeasterners
"suddenly"
*400 years later*
When I am telling anything about extinct things and use it, everyone is like, wtf suddenly doesn't come with 5 thousands of years
"When "suddenly" suddenly became a relative term"
in earth time it was. People judge time based on their life length. very egotistical
One of the things I love about this show? It is ultimately a story of connections. The story of a Flower is never *just* the story of a flower. The story of anything, the longer you look, is ultimately the story of Everything? And that’s a thing I feel like we forget, sometimes.
if you abstract for long enough, everything is everything
I read once that (paraphrased) "every flower implies the universe", a phrase that keeps coming back to me as I learn about the world we live in and its history.
Well said fam
Well stated!
@@corvuscallosum5079 "To make a pie from scratch, you first have to make the Universe" -Sagan
Alternative Title:
"The Day the Earth Stood Chill"
🤦♂️
This is fantastic, thank
🤣🤣🤣
“Suddenly”
“Recent”
“Not too long ago”
Makes me feel less bad about saying last week when I mean 6 months ago
My personal favorite is "the other day" it means any day other than today. Could be yesterday, last month, a few years ago, it all works. :)
Still far more accurate than "religion"(cults).
@@lyreparadox and thats why it's my favourite to use! Idk what day it just the other day... Some time ago... Take my word for it.
Time is relative
Or “the other day” which could be the other day or a month ago! 😂😂
wherever he is I hope Steve is fine, especially in this pandemic time.
He's my favorite hominid
@@mohammadhooksit a long time supporter of the show
I MISS YA STEVE! WHERE YA AT!
Steve dead
@@abhishekparmar6702 Really?
The benefit to being in bed sick all day is you're early to videos... hi Blake 👋
Hope it’s not COVID !
Hi, I hope you feel better soon! (BdeP)
I hope you feel better soon.
Get well soon
Aw, you even got well wishes from Blake! If he says to feel better soon, then you gotta! Lol
His speaking speed seems to have slowed down with the lower temperatures. Such a delight.
Unfortunately the planet is warming and he'll speed up again.
Blake when it's 0°C: Normal human
Blake when it's 40°C:Breaks the sound barrier with his lips
“Has” or just “seems” to have? You sure is not just you getting used to his talking speed?
LOL! No offense to him, but his speed-talking is my biggest complaint about PBS EONs. It's also my only complaint! He's definitely improved of late, which is great. :)
@@thepiper5522 Maybe your brain can't keep up with his speed.
Scientist : how this happens
Me who know damn well its that damn squirrel : pathetic
lol, Scrat was cool, his luck not so much. then again, to have survived all that, Scrat had to be damn lucky as well, sooo, maybe, lol.
@@Zarcondeegrissom he wasn't lucky,all of that was planned
Eliminate Moose und sqvirrel!
Comet breaks up and hits squirrels and ice sheets all over the planet. A world ends with flood, fire and ice depending on location.
Even worse is the fact that one day he will break free of his icy prison and cause a massive eruption
Had final exam, see PBS Eons = Happy days! :) Stay safe everyone!
*stays dangerous*
I had 0 finals today. Instead, i slept in until 1030am
Same here!
Same!!!
Hope everything went well with your exam :)
It's weird to not see Steve at the end of the eontologists. I wonder what happened to him.
Have the same feeling about it.
Yeah i hope Steve is doing ok
He stopped donating and bought hookers instead
He had to have his furnace tuned up and paid for the first 500 gallons of fuel oil for the season ;P
@@stant7122 oh nu
Who else misses Steve 😔 🤚
Omg I always wait and get disappointed when they don't mention Steve
It's like, "All these cool names, and Steve." It really stuck out, and now I'm expecting it, and it's not there.
I think we all do.
“And, Steve!” Is how it should end. I miss the man I’ve never met
Today's episode just didn't have that closure I so desire... (ಥ﹏ಥ)
8:20 Hunting tortoises, eh? Finally, a culture that's more my speed...
Way more anticlimactic than it sounds
Nice
Now they will feel the full power of the Dark Side
😂
What is interesting is the name for the volcano: Laacher See. It is named after the abbey close by, Maria Laach. But Laach itself means lake, and See means lake too. Basically, it's the lake's lake.
As a small addendum: The Latin name of the abbey, the one in the deed of foundation, is Abbatia ad Lacum, Abbey at the Lake, from which the German name is derived from. And the lake is the Lake of (Maria) Laach, the Lake of the Abbey at the Lake. This makes this the Abbey at the Lake of the Abbey at the Lake of the Abbey at the Lake of the Abbey at the Lake...
The Maria Laach Abbey is very beautiful too!
@@dethledr and the meat they sell in the abbey's shop is awesome :D
Reminds me of The La Brea Tar Pits, which means the the tar tar pits.
It’s like the Sahara Desert and the Gobi Desert, both of which mean “desert desert.”
@@PlainsPup I had always thought Sahara was moon
Most scientists won’t even discuss the impact hypothesis so I certainly appreciate seeing this 🙏🏻
yessir
It's always meteors!
tbh they are youtubers not scientists, although yes there are scientists who don’t like the impact hypothesis, there’s also a lot that at first didnt like it but are now on board with it
@@aff77141
No its not. But the idea that the Earth is part of its cosmic environment and never interacts with it it is equally stupid.
lol where do you think they get information? Cleary scientist are talking about the impact. But being focus on is weird.
I like this guy. Doesn't say certain hypothesis are dumb simply because of who they are associated with. Keeps an open mind. Great video!
03:33 That huge glacial dam collapsed because Scrat tried too hard to stick his food into the ice, which is the plot of The Ice Age 2.
“It was about the size of a dog”*do u have any idea how little that narrows it down*
That's the plot of the Ice Age 2 XD
Thank you guys for these videos, I usually watch them after studying for palentology at the University of Cincinnatti. Only 2 more years till my paleontology degree!!
Go Bearcats! Speaking of which, the channel Bizarre Beasts has a video on the binturong or "bearcat," "The Bizarre Beast That Smells Like Popcorn."
And then what? Masters and doctorate then become a university professor? How else can you earn a living with a paleontology degree?
I would either work at a museum or in the geology department of some university. I have so much fun doing it, I don’t care that I wouldn’t be making very much. And the average salary for a paleontologist is $60,000 a year, so I’d say putting food on the table isn’t that much of a problem
@@SkylerHamm587 Cool. I wish you well!
@@1stAmbientGrl the same way you would with any other degree. By finding a job in your field and working on it
Can we all appreciate how beautifully Eons present material that isn't usually accessed by common folk?
So I looked up the dryas flower, and apparently in Norwegian its name is "Reindeer-rose". Neat.
Earth: I think I like being warm
The Universe: I think not
When my uncle must have turned down the heating
Do you think he's made of money?
More like left the fridge/freezer open 😆
Aye
Is anyone going to talk about this guy’s style is unmatched in every single episode?
he's a dilf if I've ever seen one
Yeah, I've been picking up on that. From the looks of it, he's pretty jacked too.
whats better than a shirt? two shirts
Instead of asking if anyone is going to talk about it, talk about it.
@@mvl71 it's a figure of speech
Last time I was this early, there were still wooly rhinos in Europe.
Pretty early 🤔
I like the word wooly. 😊
Aaah I see you are a prehistoric man yourself
@@albinakemet2728 they are more early then You.
@@albinakemet2728 Time does not pick sides. U need help.
I really feel like you should still give Steve a shout out at the end just out of general principle.
@Moonlit Fae Get used to it. This show is all about the constant changes the Earth has gone through. Maybe Steve will have his own Era named after him...or at least a playlist. 🤷♂️
Very well done. I'd run across the younger (and older) Dryas in other paleontology vids, but starting with the flower giving the period its name is just superb writing. Well delivered too.
Me before watching this episode: This better has the Laacher See eruption in it!
Me after watching this episode: :D
Remember that movie 2012, that’s basically what happened during the younger Dryas. “They didn’t listen”.
You mean "The Day After Tomorrow"?
What happened to Steve? Is he okay? WHERE IS HE?!
Which one was Sreve? The handsome Chicano by any chance?
*Meteorite came to earth in Cenozoic era
Birds and Reptiles: Oh, please...NOT AGAIN!
Love the mention of the Impact Hypothesis
Please...do an episode on how animal venoms evolved.
That sounds really intersting
I think it's because of warmer climates if not then they evolved it to scare predators away
@@Star_light568 Most of them started development with sea life, I would think. I want to know more of the chemistry/biology/genetics angle for the evolution here.
Imagine a job that requires you to study and be around such animals. Talk about a toxic workplace.
@@davidanderson_surrey_bc
The door is right there.
Shoutouts to Steve. Hope you're doing ok wherever you are
That joke was pretty good. Well done, Lulu.
The impact hypothesis is finally getting mainstream recognition
Right? They better catch up or they are going to be more and more embarrassed as time goes by.
Do they follow the explanation of a massive ice melt by the impact changing the salinity of the oceans? I just wonder if that would not mean that the tropics get hotter, as the heat does not spread to the arctic regions. Is It the growing ice albedo that then results in a *global* decline of temperatures?
Was it ever not famous?
I mean you can't get more flashy than an impact event.
I mean, they found the asteroid itself a couple years ago
Carolina Bays! I have a lot of trouble thinking the bays were created just by wind and water...the way they stack...doesnt make sense.
This channel never forgets to be awesome.
I had to rewind and rewatch a few sections on this one, but I mostly got it. Comprehensive, complex, and cool.
Where is Steve? During this pandemic world, we need to know if he’s well?
I rarely comment on RUclips, but I wanted to tell y'all that this is by far my favorite channel on RUclips. Such fantastic and interesting content.
Small flowers answering big questions.
aha I love it
Nice to see Randall Carlson's theories getting some shine.
Doesn't the younger dryas coincide with the end of the Clovis culture, too?
Yes, that's why it is called the Clovis Comet, the Younger Dryas Impact Theory is real ! Its remnant is the Taurid Stream which we cross twice a year and one produces the Halloween Fireballs which brought destruction of fire from the sky and deluge.
@@bardmadsen6956 All a theory has to do to be real is have someone theorize it.
There's an error at 9:17 or so. A temperature of 10 C is equal to 50 F, but a change of 10 degrees C is only a change of 18 degrees F. The extra 32 is the difference in how the temperature of water freezing is expressed.
So a change in average annual temp from 20 C to 30 C is equivalent to a change from 68 F to 86 F
Was coming to say this!
Thank you for pointing this out to us! We're going to pin a correction to this comment section.
They manipulate the figures to support their guesses .
Wtfvexcuse me ? 23 seconds? I literally JUST opened RUclips to get ready while watching 😂
Wtfvexuse me 41 minutes? I literally have been on RUclips for a hour to be ready watching 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
Don't pull up with 60 men to clap on my cheeks
I added the while in there 😆😆
@@Isaacthemaniac 😂 damn it
@Baldhina Asnake however not invalidated 😆
I have been discussing this paradigm for many years. As an archaeologist, anthropologist, and sociologist, a lot of my Studies have taken me into climatology. It is a major contributing factor to who We are and why we are that way in this particular moment in Time. What you are discussing right now is what I have been discussing for several years now.
Thank you for providing a simple argument that suggests the proponents of this theory as pertinent.
This is one of the many reasons I love this program. Please continue this programming. We need more formats of empiricisms like this. Kudos.
It's amazing how much you can learn from a simple little flower. And a bunch of fossils. And ice cores. And a crater. And a layer of platinum. And ancient stone tools.
I love how hard you guys try to laugh at the cheesy jokes.
The thing I find the most fascinating about the younger Dryas hypothesis is trying to find out which humans / other hominids adapted to climactic mass extinction because we will need that kind of adaptability very soon
This is probably one of my favourite RUclips channels. I love that there are just all of these informative videos here for curious children and adults to watch about the ancient world. I'm seventeen, haven't watched PBS on TV since I was like eleven, but I still occasionally watch the shows because they're educational and entertaining.
Thank you for using Celsius and the metric system. Now we can understand what you are saying 😉👍
5:08
I was born around there.There is an abbey by the lake (it's out of frame unfortunately) where I was baptized.
We learned about the Younger Dryas and that an eruption of the Laacher See Volcano may have caused it in elementary school.
Cool to see it on one of my favorite YT channels.
Seems 14,000 years ago was the 2020 of it's time.
Actually, 2020 is the 536 of it’s time.
@@jeremybyington, how?
@Will F hey don't be upset, it's just 2 short weeks to flatten the curve. I'm sure the pubs will be open and everything will be back to normal in no time! 😉😭 I swear this goes on much longer I'll be wishing for a series of large comet fragments to send us the way of the mammoths. Humans deserve it a lot more than the mammoths and the Dinosaurs did lol. Cheers from Florida
I’m always so excited when an Eons video pops up!
One of the best Eons videos I've seen.
Lovely that you made this vid. The one about ice ages and flood were not connected enough and I was struggling to match events
Someone messed with the Earth’s thermostat and there were no modern dads anywhere to change it back.
Great video, one question though. Did you ever think about presenting the black mat that lines up with the dates ending the Younger Dryas?
I think the note at the end about the Indigenous people is important and often glossed over, thank you for adressing it
I love natural history and this channel rocks!
Yay Eons! Wait he's talking about the Channel Islands!?! Eons mentioned my home! Amazing!
he also mentioned my home of New England
@@ecurewitz The joke also mentioned the La Brea Tar Pits, where I used to work. I second the sentiment of the joke, some places can hold you there forever!
Thank you! I have been waiting for an episode on this topic for awhile.
I've heard so much about The Younger Dryad from several sources over time, but this is the first I've heard of the origin of the (awesome and mythical sounding) name. You rock, Eons!
Nice episode. I had always wondered about these Dryas periods. Now I know more.
So glad you guys did an episode on the Younger Dryas!!! I believe it was the Greenland meteor impact but I'm excited to see what future research reveals.
It's now starting to look like multiple impacts at the same time like Jupiter and shoemaker levy.
@@mgman6000 no impacts have been identified, let alone many.
@@gravitonthongs1363
If they hit 2 miles of ice what would be left of them?
I'm going with the shotgun effect nothing big enough to leave a single crater
People disputed the dinosaur impact until they didn't
@@mgman6000 there would be impactor fragments, shatter cones, element spikes, magnetic signature, etc, but there is nothing. No evidence.
Scientists discovering evidence to promote a theory does not make every fantasy an acceptable scientific hypothesis.
@rickcharlespersonal - I thought that crater is way too old to have caused the Dryas periods. Are you saying that there is new evidence that it is far younger?
Paleo Daddy Blake back looking like a snack. We have been blessed.
I was wondering how much scrolling it would take before I found the thirst
@@DeRien8 didn't take long
This title is litterally what we're waiting for
So, you're waiting for
a sudden gigantic flood of glacial melt water?
or a meteorite?
or a powerful explosive volcano?
A combo of the 3?
I see... nothing.
@@a.randomjack6661 the earth stops warming =/= the events that caused the cooling
@@a.randomjack6661 there are other ways earth could cool off, every once in a while, the earth gets more tilted and we enter an ice ages that lasts 200-600yrs.
Theese ice ages only lower the global temperatures of 3 or 4 degrees.
I'd like to see a video on Doggerland, its sinking, and the effects of that.
Edit: And I wouldn't mind seeing a video on weird early theories and how they were ultimately rejected.
1:17 that lion is trying so hard to look like a lion lol
Yes I do agree , but I Spent three years investigating these impacts for my masters . The younger dryas impact is pretty compelling and quite conclusive
If it is safe for you? Lots of YTs would love an interview with a person like you. I suspect.
how does that flower pollenate in such cold? insects wouldnt be able to survive the cold.
nevermind i found the answer. they only flower during the summer and rely on arctic flies
The "Carolina Bays Ice Impact Hypothesis" provides a compelling answer to the question, "what would happen if a comet hit a mile-thick ice sheet 12,000 years ago?" I personally think it's much more convincing evidence than the Greenland crater.
See Antonio Zamora's channel for more videos, featuring some very cool lidar images.
Can't rule out the multi hit, whether at the same time or spread across years, or hitting multiple mediums. Rock, ice, ocean.
The bays are quite fascinating.
YES! I spend a lot of time around Carolina Bays and it just feels so...not normal...comet and secondary impact would explain the overlapping elliptical shapes.
The lidar imagery is very compelling. Something catastrophic definitely went down to cause that. Impact on the ice sheet is the only explanation I can see.
Shoutout to you guys for putting that acknowledgement about the indigenous peoples of the Americas on your video.
I have known the term "Younger Dryas" for between 30 and 40 years, but I don't think I ever knew what "dryas" referred to, specifically.
Thank you for this fascinating and educational video, and also for the respect shown to the indigenous people on whose lands much of the research has been conducted.
Part of the impact hypothesis is there were multiple impacts over the northern hemisphere, causing multiple events.
Thank you for presenting a logical revue of the Younger-Dryas period complete with the rational explanation for the energy input needed to rid this planet of so much ice.
I grew up near Laacher See, awesome to see it featured here. Beautiful place, used to do a run around it on the weekends. Come visit, also the abbey right next to it!
One of my favorites from this channel so far. Really great.
I just want to say I really appreciate these videos. I'm usually more into animals, especially invertebrates (somewhat shown by my major in marine bio and minor in paleobio). i had to take paleoclimates for my minor, and it didn't fit in my schedule until my final quarter of college, and i took it pass/fail instead of for a letter grade, so while i did pass it and get my minor with my degree, i don't remember a ton. it's been like 5 years and i still wish i had taken it earlier before senioritis hit because this stuff is just as fascinating to me as taxonomy/cladistics and whatnot. i even still have my textbook from that class, like i'm gonna read it someday lol. these videos are much easier. so thanks :)
Love you all at PBS Eons so much
and Steve
Wonderful series! Thanks for the upload very educational and fun for all.
OMG as a channel islander its great to have a shout out. Fun fact, the plant shown in the image of the north coast of Jersey is Hottentot fig, a prevalent invasive species
I love your episodes about plants, and I would love to see more of them!
I was having a rough day, and Eons came to the rescue!!! 😁
Data from GISP2 brings back memories. I was on that expedition!
"Hey! That flower just sprouted."
"That would be a younger Dryas."
“Hunted tortoises..” that’s a hard job....
Not if you work for a shell corporation.
0:08 : Where have I heard that name...?
0:47 : aaah...
1:02 : OOOH so THAT's why is called that way!
Me too!
As always great content! I really appreciate you slowing down a little bit when you speak. Thank you.
I really appreciate the recognition of the indigenous be people and their land. They are often forgotten. It is important to me that they and their land is recognized.
Was I the only one who have noticed that there is an old painting of marine reptiles behind the narrators?
I was wishing you'd make a video about this!
Happy (early) Saturnalia!
Hey, I wrote my paleoclimatology term paper on thermohaline circulation and the Younger Dryas, thanks for the throwback!
I love this channel, have been binging it a lot ever since I found it!
Always fascinated
Always enjoy your videos. Another possible topic for a show would be fossil reefs through time--not only (hexa)corals, but also tetracorals, archaeocyathids, rudists, etc.
There are candidates for impact sites on the ice sheet. A few places being looked at. Also air bursts could easily have generated enough heat.
At 4:25, the map shown has a narrow band of unfrozen lands between two massive glacial ice sheets. What I want to see from Eons is an in-depth video on the land bridge from Asia to North America, the development of the Canadian Shield, and how Siberian Asia was instrumental in the formation of animal and human life in the American continents.
A lot rides on either an inland or coastal path remaining ice-free to facilitate the migration of these lifeforms from one continent to another. I would love to see the physical evidence behind it, or why the hypothesis developed in the first place. So much of the Eons content is focused around the flashier topics; this is a topic that, while small, is crucial in the formation of the western hemisphere as we know it today. Basically, I want to see Eons, Voices, and Terra all melded into one glorious crossover collaboration.
"Platinum is rare on Earth, but it's more common in meteorites." Strictly speaking, there is just as much platinum on Earth than in meteorites, it's just that it's almost all concentrated in our planet's iron-nickel core, which separates it from surface geological processes.
It’s just like what is called “rare earth elements/minerals.” They aren’t necessarily “rare,” just highly dispersed over vast areas or concentrated in hard to access areas.