Just realized the beauty of the beat being produced by Kanye and the vid being made in Paris topped off with the "where we at [nigga? in Paris]" bar. Exquisite.
Imagine you're on vacation at Paris and you just see ASAP Rocky and Jaden Smith chilling in a car and Tyler the Creator on a children's bike doing loops around them
Ipuntbabies 03 it’s because they have some songs together and what not 😭 and carti is a straight up mumble rapper. matter of fact, carti is probably the only rapper with more adlibs then he has real words
@@blacksheep9278 Nah, he mentioned Carti* because he's a prime specimen of a mumble rapper and Rocky straight up disses mumble rappers in this song. But we still see Rocky making songs with him like New Choppa. So he's basically calling his friend talentless.
1:36 I love that rocky and Tyler always show love to lil b, that one concert back then where rocky randomly brought him out on stage was too fire, TYBG
I still laugh at tyler saying " that's hot and horny" and asap saying "don't say shit like that" I'm 🤣🤣🤣 I haven't listened to this in a while n I still love it a lot.
@@andreagarrett6429 oh no, I big time agree with what you say. It's already iconic and it always will be! Fantastic song. Hell back in 2018 when this came out I was listening to it all week.
@@andreagarrett6429 No doubt. Classic. Their styles and friendship mixes flawlessly. Before this song dropped, I was not aware of how truly good both of them are as hip hop artists. When I say Hip Hop, that's a huge compliment for anyone who knows what I'm stepping in here.
@@EnjoyLife-sg3kt they’re just friends, Jaden is there as a symbol for Tyler. Tyler is gay and has tried for YEARS to expose himself but nobody believes him.
Jaden wasn’t even supposed to be there. He was just chilling in Paris and saw rocky and Tyler filming so he just jumped in the car and they left it in the video
@@HistoryBuffoon Nope. But Kanye was talking about ur mom when he said the line “come in meet me in the bathroom stall” and she showed him why she deserved to have it all
as a frenchie who love technic french rap ( such as alpha wann or veust if you wanna look) the performance of tyler litteraly opened a whole new world for me : the technic american rap and in 1 month i will have completed tyler's discography multiple times
The verses are SO clever,the flows are catchy,the confidence in which such blasphemy is delivered is off the charts One of my favorite rap songs of all time
@@trenhen4311 honestly i myself thought the same way,but when i decided to give it a try,even though its not my favorite kind of sound,i can understand why somebody would listen to that
@@xurrasco_021_fanpage nah bro I love mumble rap lmao carti my second most played behind cudi. Jus sayin rocky contradicting himself there kinda stupid.
This is such a simple music video, but it’s better than like 90% of all music videos. It fits so much. I couldn’t imagine this song with a different music video, it’s so mellow and such a chill vibe.
When Jaden said: “ “
I felt that😔
Same
BJ z mo m
Shit went hard as well
Stfu or Tyler will make a salad outta you
Aravind Subhash I wouldn’t mind that 😉 (No Homo)
Jaden: What should I do in the video?
Tyler and A$ap: *no*
He prolly went to a store something
Carter720 great comment!
Facts
This literally gave me a brain orgasm 😂
And then both went and featured on his new album so wheres that shit talk now lol
Can’t believe Kanye and Jay Z made a song about these two back in 2011.
which song
edit: mannn you got me XD
░░░░░█░░░░▒▒▒▒▒▒▒▒▒▒▒▒░░▀▀▄░░░░
░░░░█░░░▒▒▒▒▒▒░░░░░░░░▒▒▒░░█░░░
░░░█░░░░░░▄██▀▄▄░░░░░▄▄▄░░░░█░░
░▄▀▒▄▄▄▒░█▀▀▀▀▄▄█░░░██▄▄█░░░░█░
█░▒█▒▄░▀▄▄▄▀░░░░░░░░░░░▒▒▒▒▒░█
█░▒█░█▀▄▄░░░░░█▀░░░░▀▄░░▄▀▀▀▄▒█
░█░▀▄░█▄░█▀▄▄░▀░▀▀░▄▄▀░░░░█░░█░
░░█░░░▀▄▀█▄▄░█▀▀▀▄▄▄▄▀▀█▀██░█░░
░░░█░░░░██░░▀█▄▄▄█▄▄█▄████░█░░░
░░░░█░░░░▀▀▄░█░░░█░█▀██████░█░░
░░░░░▀▄░░░░░▀▀▄▄▄█▄█▄█▄█▄▀░░█░░
░░░░░░░▀▄▄░▒▒▒▒░░░░░░░░░░▒░░░█░
░░░░░░░░░░▀▀▄▄░▒▒▒▒▒▒▒▒▒▒░░░░█░
░░░░░░░░░░░░░░▀▄▄▄▄▄░░░░░░░░█░░
@hellnoIdontwantmynameonyt Fr?
@@princewillchris1330 lmao
@@wombat7961 wait no that was sarcastic 💀
Underrated comment tbh
Just realized the beauty of the beat being produced by Kanye and the vid being made in Paris topped off with the "where we at [nigga? in Paris]" bar. Exquisite.
Yup, the original song from Ye is "Apologize"
@@TimeStampGuy1was looking for someone who noticed
Rocky’s verse on this is the scrapped verse from Simulation Baptize, wonder if that’s how Kanye got involved
Jaden be that one friend who gets high and don`t talk for 2 hours
Ight Imma head out
that’s me 🤦🏾♂️
Anton Cvetkov bruh there always That one
That's me smh
Haha thats ME
Tyler and A$ap: the smart kids
Jaden: the kid that did nothing but still got a A
SNMtv underrated comment
Yup, so true.
Jaden is the kid who did all the work but tyler and asap are the extrovert who presented the project.
@@tempest9744 no Jaden isnt that talented
apantard am not saying he is so talented but he is totally a better artist then these rappers now like overrated jack boys and roddy richh
they both were playing while jaden's controller wasn't connected
Parv Mittal
I love how this comment is original
I love to see something not stolen 🤣
10/10
Man should neva joined the game
triangling yo nose but jaden wasnt
Jaden playing with tylers controller at now
This song is so timeless, its been on my playlist for like 5 years now and i'm still not bored of it.
Gonna be an OG song
This song came out 4 years ago 💀
This is what 90s sound like
@@captjohnson5452 dude did say it was timeless 😂
The BEAT is timeless, thats why.
This beat was made when music was still being made w soul
Jaden is like an easter egg
FakePingu underrated
Bruhhhh 😂 im dying idek why
don’t get it😑 explain
@@haroldbean433 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Jayden smith is in the vid, hes at the back of the car
Talent : 100%
Nudity : 0%
Jaden : 0%
fax
Fr tho
who is jaden
@@gratitude7407 Jaden smith is in the video
Jaden is actually fire I'm not even gonnalie
I wish Tyler rapped like this more...
666lickaclip 666 fr huh
Keep that
666lickaclip 666 same I miss this tyler
@@fartballsackpoopgamer4914 he the same nigga both him and asap just experiment like crazy doing different shit they can't stick to one type of music
big facts i love this song for that reason
0:13 - Kanye and Jay-z had predicted it in 2011 💀💀🗣🗣
??
@@grippie0504 they are in Paris...
You guys won’t realize how iconic this song is until in a few years
RIP WANGSAP
Gray K ?
Agreed
nxmb wangsap never existed 💔
@@MetalZoomer why u sayin that
Rocky: Mom Can I go to Paris with Tyler?
Mom: Take Jaden with you
Duuuude, didn't even notice until I read your comment :D
I saw him thinking no one noticed then saw this comment
+1
@@subhan6802 me too
Mans verse was cold tho🥶🥶🥶
When the 2 smart kids in the class work together on a project
underrated lol
just pure gold
jadens the one kid who doesn’t talk and do shit for the project but still cops the A wit em
@@seanleahy9446 bro I wanted to say this. Took the words out of my mouth my guy
@@seanleahy9446 bitch stole my comment
Still one of the best flows to ever exist
For real
Makes me smile when I see these two rapping together
Forrreeaalll who dat boy was fire
Fareel, makes my soul feel better.
trevonm2000 just *together ❤
Tyler verse is FIREEEEEEEeeeeeEEE!!!!🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥!!!Love ya....
Facts
jaden‘s probably sitting there thinking about the political and economic state of the world
🤣
lmfao
@TrumpsDaddy True
Lmao never noticed Jaden was in the video
He alway’s thinking about that shi 🙄
Jaden literally was the person in the group that just clicked the next slide
That's why his name isn't in the presentation
@@JamFlexx haha
Lmaooooo I’m dead 💀
😭
didn’t even realize he was there
This shit fit so well on the Otis beat its crazy
Ok but Jaden didn’t have to go this hard
ruclips.net/video/2vhFLROLs7k/видео.html
His best shit yet 👐💯
Jaden was goin off 😂
i wish they let him spit a verse on this
@@illumililium best sarcasm ive seen in a minute lmao
Finally some Rapping..
Beat Lounge boy to do I got a rapper for u g listen to Mf doom
what’s OKRA?
Your first and last step to playing yourself like accordion
Javier Urena some real shit, exactly what I thought
from one of them at least
Tyler the creator: "I got back pain"
Me at 30 years old : " this man spittin!"
B Francs You suppose to get back pains at like 60 not 30
@@liltree8382 some ppl get it earlier depends on ur lifestyle
B Francs 14 years old*
me with back pain at 13: 👁👄👁
20 years old here, and I already got back surgery done
I love how enthusiastic they are. makes me realise hey. I'm alright. I don't need to quell my enthusiasm. that's me. that's real. thats tight
Judge: You're looking at 53 years
6ix9ine: Rocky's satchel is actually a purse
Don Eme nope.
😂😂😂😂
I’m weak 💀💀💀
😂😂
Another underrated comment
Jaden part was so fire I couldn’t hear it
hes not on this song tgats travus scott
drake*
@@epicfacts4130 he's on the MV watch carefully
Fuck jaden
@@stronk9760 Why
Judge: That'll be 47 years
6ix9ine: I can tell you where Jadens verse is in potato salad
Seems fair
Lost in translation
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Jinx Klapzz so funny i forgot to laugh
3:16
Tyler and A$AP Rocky need to collab more, hopefully Rocky is on Tyler's new project in 2023.
Edit: Wharf Talk is amazing 🔥
And hopefully Tyler Is on Rocky's new project
ك
Comment need to be pinned dead ass!
@@pelipappaa318 rocky confirmed he is 🙏
Called it 🎉
No one gonna talk about Tyler’s sick hop at 1:51
Taku he just went up and down
I thought I was bouta see Tyler pull a barspin 360 tailwhip seat grab toboggan x up flair manual 180 fakie
he shoulda pulled a bar, oreven just a pull up bar
@@yellowsupercar366 Yes. That's how hopping works.
@@gdhallow3047 well then hopping is lame
Rocky: The oldest child
Tyler: the middle child
Jaden: the youngest who tries to hang with his two older brothers lol
literally
Jaden's me
J cole is the middle child
😕
Broh j Cole is like 40
@@t.uri.2836 *35
-Two- Three years later and this is still some of jadens best work
Yea I know what you mean. I wish he'd just keep his mouth shut in all his songs.
Lmao
Jack Blaisdell whats wrong with jaden 😢
Yall sleeping on Jaden.
Y’all clearly hatin on jaden buh hey fuck it 😂
Need more from these two the big difference in personality
Makes the duo so entertaining
While tyler and rocky were spittin
Jaden was sittin
🤣🤣🤣
Damn poet, what s ur name?
Bars
@@erikalenoeye8925 His name is clearly bigUziVert. Dont ever disrespect master poet bigUziVert like that again 😤
nibb you might should elon for a small loan of a billion dollar
Rocky: 🎶👝👜👛💣🧠🎶
Tyler: 🎶🎮👖🧦🧢👽🎶
Jaden: 😶
Tf this mean.
@@sIurppn how tf is that relevant here.
@@sIurppn the fuck you mean luminous, do you even kno what that mean.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@pspctv.1921 it means u dumb
Imagine you're on vacation at Paris and you just see ASAP Rocky and Jaden Smith chilling in a car and Tyler the Creator on a children's bike doing loops around them
Why you do BMX like that
Аркадий Паровозов this gotta be the most underrated reply in history
jaden is trash
@@sondonkey835 What
I couldn’t tell if that was comethazine or jaden😂
Never ever get old this masterpiece
tf you talking? gomunkul 6 > any of your favorite rampper
Tyler: Jaden you wanna hop in on this song?
Jaden: maybe
Jaden: Can i hop on this song ?
Tyler: Maybe
Perhaps
@@maxencereynaud8758 stop hatin him man
I think one of them said in an interview that jaden just happened to pass by and saw them record a music video
@@frejalms niggas in paris
I want this on gta 6 radio
These are by far the best lines I’ve ever heard of rocky I’m a true fan since live love asap
GTA6 might be in the 70's/80's so, i don't think so 😪
Lucas Roa it could literally be in any decade
Faaaaaaaaaccts💯💯 #GTA6
@@Kunshi_ all fans are fans
Tyler's hair really said "⚽"
😂🤦🏽♂️
That’s actually hilarious.
@@seanlightning9634 IS IT YEAH???
The Milkman why are you mad?
@@seanlightning9634 IS IT *ACTUALLY* HILARIOUS THO? Tell us bro
On the old iPod days it was lit when you sync the songs to make it louder while y'all walking down the road... Core memory
They should make a whole chill album like this, it’s so nice ☀️🍙
they said a wang$ap album was coming soon but this was made 3 years ago, idk what they mean by soon 😭
@@dygitalanimations42 it's not coming. tyler has talked about it and he said that the project was scrapped but a couple songs leaked
@@chromso really? that kinda sucks
ruclips.net/video/dUNnQ2kyrQI/видео.html
..... Listen..
@@chromso i’m still so disappointed that they scrapped it, i’d be bumpin a tyler and rocky album forever
Rocky: Mumbling & Rambeling, I find it hard to find actual talent
Carti: *Am I a joke to u?*
*erdi* what does carti have to do with this
Ipuntbabies 03 it’s because they have some songs together and what not 😭 and carti is a straight up mumble rapper. matter of fact, carti is probably the only rapper with more adlibs then he has real words
Kaleb Lewis he just mentioned Cardi cuz of Earfquake
@@blacksheep9278 Nah, he mentioned Carti* because he's a prime specimen of a mumble rapper and Rocky straight up disses mumble rappers in this song.
But we still see Rocky making songs with him like New Choppa.
So he's basically calling his friend talentless.
Ipuntbabies 03 bud this was released way before igor
I'm 50...and very seldom stray from the "golden era" of hip hop...but these cats dope.
Name an old-school rapper that isn't biggie or 2pac then
Lil uzi vert
@@vaughnhartzell8037 young thug
Lil B The Based God
@@zerobsweekly4622 yung lean
I love their friendship & this timeless song ♥️
2:58 when Jaden realises that he doesn't get a verse
Lol
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
MTP7 GAMING 🤣🤣🤣😭
I just became ur 400th like
just because ur 644th like 😀
21 savage: issa knife
A$AP Rocky: Issa satchel
Tyler : dass hot and horny
Dundee: "That's not a knife!"
erlis fazliu you cant say shit like that
chase dow fucking legend why does that have no likes
@@maxanderson2925 Because nobody gets the reference and even you didn't like it lol.
So this is what Paris looks like after the Coronavirus
Bruh underrated comment
underrated as hell
:(
I live in paris and this comment is so true 😂
Lol imagine every time you said something in Paris there was a cool edit
1:36 I love that rocky and Tyler always show love to lil b, that one concert back then where rocky randomly brought him out on stage was too fire, TYBG
song wouldnt exist without the based god
Jaden forgot his mic was muted
lets keep it that way
Lmao
jaden would have murdered this beat honestly
@@illumililium FACTS
@@thevillageidiot6969 wish he got a verse instead of t's second verse which imo is kinda weak
One of the most underrated rap songs this year
I still laugh at tyler saying " that's hot and horny" and asap saying "don't say shit like that" I'm 🤣🤣🤣 I haven't listened to this in a while n I still love it a lot.
You guys won’t realize how iconic this song is until in a few years
@@andreagarrett6429 oh no, I big time agree with what you say. It's already iconic and it always will be! Fantastic song. Hell back in 2018 when this came out I was listening to it all week.
💀
@@andreagarrett6429 No doubt. Classic. Their styles and friendship mixes flawlessly.
Before this song dropped, I was not aware of how truly good both of them are as hip hop artists. When I say Hip Hop, that's a huge compliment for anyone who knows what I'm stepping in here.
@@EnjoyLife-sg3kt they’re just friends, Jaden is there as a symbol for Tyler. Tyler is gay and has tried for YEARS to expose himself but nobody believes him.
Classic ❤
everyone who disliked can’t distinguish between a purse and a satchel
@Alijah Newman they’re also playing games so they get passed the controller
@@kaphizmey6229 and they mad the dont gotta laser with the big beam and they dont gotta green bitch
They also don’t whip cream and cop boys
They also don’t fill em with Leonardo DiCaprio’s and Cole Sprouse’s nigga
I’m your one thousand like
BRO I LOVED WHEN JADEN SAID " , , . , , "
Underrated comment
fax
Faxxxxx
Who dat
BARS
It's funny how Jaden appeared for 5 seconds, said nothing and still everybody talks about him.
say nutting
daaaww iz rewond taam
i think they expected him to have a bar or two
Cuz he a Goat
Icon
AYO WANG$AP WE NEED NOTHER BANGER IN 2024 !!!!
Jaden wasn’t even supposed to be there. He was just chilling in Paris and saw rocky and Tyler filming so he just jumped in the car and they left it in the video
Fr🤣🤣🤣
Yo actual?
yall really stupid
@@jek_skunz no
Funny if true
I just realized they were hyped at the beginning because they synced the music on their phones
I didn't notice that. Wow.
@Ulwazi Mzulwini wow! you're cool
@@Minnevan why you hating?
Brothers: ASAP rocky , Tyler the creator
Mom:where are you going?
Brother : recording a song
Mom: take jaden with you
Why everyone so negative in these comments
Rocky and Tyler always bringing out the best in each other frfr
Relationship goals most marriages not that solid
4 years later still dope as shit
this duo needs to get together more often🔥🔥🔥
They droping an album together
Lioneljstn WHEN??
XXX The Slump God in february 2019
They made songs together before the songs aren’t that famous tho
채널에 타일러좀 많이 소개해주세요ㅠㅠ
For some reason the way he says ''This ain't a purse it's a satchel'' is the coolest thing ever
AdzBrandMusic fax
First time I bumped this I kept repeating that line lmao definetly facts
Mumbling and raming mumbling and rappin, mumble rappin?
Issa purse
Indiana Jones wears one
Still waitin' on an ASAP & Tyler collab album.
it was cancelled iirc
Jedi Master Joe nah rocky said they were working on it
I’m waiting on that ski mask and juice wrld collab album
Boskoe58 Ddjdjd 😴
James Harvey just listen to Igor
I'm telling my childs this two were the ones who were in Paris
Kanye and Jay did it first
@@rswazey123 jayz and kanye were talkin about rocky and and tyler forsureeeee
@@HistoryBuffoon Nope. But Kanye was talking about ur mom when he said the line “come in meet me in the bathroom stall” and she showed him why she deserved to have it all
@@rswazey123😭
@@_imreallylikethat Why are you being rascist? Don’t you care about the environmental state of the world?
A$ap and Tyler: _Spit fire_
Jaden Smith: _Slides into the Music video somehow_
STFU
@@jezuzgomez6190 shut up
Gavin Wahl shup up
@@sploinkbob your gay
I love how this reply section is so polite.
this is absolutely masterpiece. Hope they produce an album together soon.
yea!!!
They aint friends anymore 😞
@@g99_b8 what!? fr? who said that
@@hy7204 rocky ghosted tyler for like 5 months or something
It’s a joke bruh
Rocky always raps his best when he teams up with Tyler.
no.. Tyler always raps his best when he colabs with rocky
Art by Atlas your troll game strong my friend 😂😆
Truth my dudeyyyy
Lmao this ain’t his best
Best music released during my whippet erra god bless all those reading this
damn, tyler really snapped with his controller verse.
SHUT UP
George Perwick nigga you good?
@@tamily4663 he on crack
@@georgeperwick7728 you gotta be off the perc
yo can you shutup??
Drop it on spotify already
Matthew Becker need it bro!!!!
Matthew Becker YES
RIGHT
It’s not their beat but yeah they need some approval stat
Matthew Becker For real man!!!
Tyler the creator the type of dude to eat candy on his way to the dentist
@Hidan who made you mad lmao
@Hidan cant tell if sarcastic or not
🔥 ruclips.net/video/7PHav78gZQE/видео.html 🔥
Lol I did that once
@@aes6739 yo u a deisel fan 😳
this is such a good song they needa make more songs like this.
you could easily have this song be called Ni**as In Paris 2
@Snowy_ lucie you literally can’t be serious rn right?
The beat is way better than the actual Niggas in Paris beat
@Snowy_ lucie shut up nigga lol
@Snowy_ lucie nigga you tripping
@Snowy_ lucie Shut the fuck up and leave him alone, is it so hard to appreciate a comment
WTF this collab 🔥🔥🔥🔥
It was about time they always kickin it and shit
nobody you know they are about to drop an album together, right?
This is like their 3rd or 4th collab tf
nobody Tyler went in
COLLAB ALBUM INCOMING LIL NIGGAS
got that old school rap vibe
FearZe hell yeah
Yea its from knock knock by j cole
Hyan Rand nope, Monica Knock Knock prod by Kanye
Kanye produced
FearZe Black peoples rap!
I was 18 when this dropped life changed so much
In a couple of years this song will be called a legendary rap song
Yes
@@chris_producing yes
Yes
Yes
Already
song fire, video fire
sos un capo tyler
Temazo, si o no?
@@akldnxk SI
Wtf?
Rimotas del asap
proximo ft. con tyler? o queso?
rocky is always floating on the beats he raps on 💯🔥 2:21 is such a crazy smooth flow
You guys are special for this
Things flexed here:
Old car
Chains
Bicycle
Not purses but Satchels
satchels*
ReeEeEEeeeE that’s not a purse that’s a satchel
Yes sorry 💀
@@reeeeeeeeee7192 hahahah
You forgot the Eiffel Tower
How many people love ASAP & TYLER?
BLAQK ! Travis Scott can’t do this type of music even more with someone with Tyler. There collabs are just another world
who doesnt love this duo?
BLAQK ! It's Rocky and Tyler. Hate when people think say A$AP instead of Rocky. Get yo shit right.
+000🔥000+
i prefer Tyler and Earl
a$ap rocky must be protected at all costs
“I have nothing cool to do” 😂 love these guys
WANG$AP
"I got back pain"
Never related to a rap lyric more in my whole life
I’ve never heard a single person hate on Rocky
The government lol
Taekwondobbk aka Swedish government
Taekwondobbk wrong for that 💀
Taekwondobbk childish lol
Sgp
It’s 100% game over when these 2 link up 🔥
This is beautiful
Amazing
as a frenchie who love technic french rap ( such as alpha wann or veust if you wanna look) the performance of tyler litteraly opened a whole new world for me : the technic american rap and in 1 month i will have completed tyler's discography multiple times
this video dropped a year ago yesterday and I’m still waiting for wangsap
Might take a while now lmao
Its not happening
We ain't ready
some songs got leaked so don't be waiting
@@borutouzumaki6456 why??
This sounds like a freestyle
They killed it🔥🔥🔥.
Are you crazy that can't be a freestyle.
@@blanjorieatkinson8577 i like how you cant understand shit what Lil Nigerian said 😘😍
fuck u, u smell bad idiot.
@@ProZombies100 it is
THIS IS SO UNDERRATED
The Beat is legendary...
The verses are SO clever,the flows are catchy,the confidence in which such blasphemy is delivered is off the charts
One of my favorite rap songs of all time
Same
Rocky contradicts himself so hard tho he says he hates mumble rap then signs carti. Still go hard tho.
@@trenhen4311 honestly i myself thought the same way,but when i decided to give it a try,even though its not my favorite kind of sound,i can understand why somebody would listen to that
@@xurrasco_021_fanpage nah bro I love mumble rap lmao carti my second most played behind cudi. Jus sayin rocky contradicting himself there kinda stupid.
@@trenhen4311 “Carti my second most played behind Carti” 💀 facts tho lol
Please put this jam on spotify
It is ?
Des-Juanito The First this comment is 9 months old
This is such a simple music video, but it’s better than like 90% of all
music videos. It fits so
much. I couldn’t imagine this song with a different music video, it’s so mellow and such a chill vibe.
Tylers verse, flow and delivery = sick, and that’s coming from a 80’s kid
this like a classic hip hop song,
boom bap rap is the greatest sub genre to ever exist