Linguistics Isn't 60 Years Old!: Pāṇinian Approaches to Language

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 дек 2024

Комментарии • 66

  • @ImperatorGrausam
    @ImperatorGrausam 4 года назад +55

    I'm into this. A channel about technology, philosophy and linguistics? Luke, this channel is a dream come true.

  • @oddbob6230
    @oddbob6230 6 лет назад +70

    I often wonder if you're the only person in the conference who uses a terminal for presentations.

    • @_chip
      @_chip 6 лет назад +24

      Odd Bob “can you read this? I can switch the colors....”

    • @captainet8315
      @captainet8315 6 лет назад +8

      wascas15 the gnu/linuxman strikes again

  • @lolvivo8783
    @lolvivo8783 4 года назад +24

    Grammar is just one of the 6 vedangas- a must for understanding the Vedas apart from bonafide Guru-Shisya parampara

    • @zyphos9444
      @zyphos9444 4 года назад +9

      Phonetics/pronunciation and etymology are two of the other Vedangas, and they fall under linguistics in the Western conception too. So really 3 of the 6 Vedangas concern linguistics (as we modern Westerners understand the term) in some way.

    • @SantaClaauz
      @SantaClaauz 3 года назад

      Why do you need those things?

    • @travisheyoka6333
      @travisheyoka6333 2 года назад

      @@Deepak_Dhakad I always see you on the same language videos I watch

    • @travisheyoka6333
      @travisheyoka6333 2 года назад +2

      @@Deepak_Dhakad are you Indian? I'm a white dude from Australia but I find Sanskrit and Devanagari fascinating. I've been learning about Kashmiri tantrism lately.

    • @travisheyoka6333
      @travisheyoka6333 2 года назад

      @@Deepak_Dhakad yeh i was learning a bit of siddham and sharda too. I'm interested in the philosophy behind the inherent meaning of each sound of the varnamala and the root dhatu meanings as well as the philosophy that went into the design choices of the symbols used in each script such as the 5 divisions of the circle that were used for devanagari. Can you share what you know about that?

  • @hixann
    @hixann 6 лет назад +43

    more linguistics, please.

  • @rafmaninoff
    @rafmaninoff 6 лет назад +16

    Came here for the Linux/computery stuff and ended up finding linguistics, couldn't be happier !

  • @Aaronstotle
    @Aaronstotle 6 лет назад +13

    I actually didn't know this, thanks! I'm a philosophy major so I always thought Linguistics formed as an academic subject after the work of Wittgenstein, Ayer, Russell.

  • @Clutter.monkey
    @Clutter.monkey 6 лет назад +5

    Fascinating presentation from a non-linguist perspective. Well presented (on the interwebs) as well, and easy to follow. I think the concept works very well: there is nothing worse than finding themed PP presentations without any annotation littered about when you’re looking for info on any subject.

  • @theelodgeovkeku
    @theelodgeovkeku 6 лет назад +14

    Luke confirmed for colourblind.

  • @krisdabrowski5420
    @krisdabrowski5420 4 года назад +5

    Can you give a presentation on Part 2, or perhaps do another version of the presentation for us?

  • @iluan_
    @iluan_ 6 лет назад +2

    Your linguistics videos are the best.

  • @AarshParashar
    @AarshParashar Год назад +2

    Didn't knew my favourite Linux RUclipsr have knowledge about Sanskrit!

  • @6saber9
    @6saber9 6 лет назад +6

    Click on a video from Cypher from the Dark City reboot,
    Somehow find an informative video on how indo-europeans also had to learn shitposting properly. Neat.

  • @maya-cc2sx
    @maya-cc2sx 2 года назад +2

    I'd love to see a similar video on nirukta by yaska! Philology is really interesting to me personally

  • @thingyee1118
    @thingyee1118 6 лет назад +3

    Very good presentation man. You are a natural. Also is this a pandoc slideshow thinger?

    • @LukeSmithxyz
      @LukeSmithxyz  6 лет назад +1

      Yup. I wrote it in R Markdown and coverted it with pandoc et al.

  • @ikaros4203
    @ikaros4203 6 лет назад +66

    >muh features
    edit: holy shit i just realized that luke uses memes so much because theyre like a new approach to language...
    am i retarded for not realizing this sooner?

    • @rexevan6714
      @rexevan6714 6 лет назад +10

      IKAROS 420 No, That means you are new to the party.
      Anyway, Welcome to the party.

    • @ikaros4203
      @ikaros4203 6 лет назад +3

      Rex Evan aww ty

  • @Melpomenex
    @Melpomenex 6 лет назад +3

    YAAAAAS!!!

  • @LPFan33
    @LPFan33 6 лет назад +14

    My paninian approach is usually a nice panino with salami, mozarella and tomato. mmmm panini

  • @0felex01
    @0felex01 6 лет назад +1

    My fucking eyes when you inverted the colors.

  • @infinite5795
    @infinite5795 2 года назад +7

    Proud of Rishi Panini, our illustrious Hindu sage.
    Proud of being Hindu 🕉.

  • @FKLinguista
    @FKLinguista 6 лет назад +1

    Hey, you could make Part 2 a RUclips exclusive!

  • @tokisuno
    @tokisuno 2 года назад

    hooked on this video omg

  • @slightlygruff
    @slightlygruff 2 года назад

    which language do you think can become a global one in the next 50 years? Can it be some mix of Chinese and English?

  • @CM-sj9pb
    @CM-sj9pb Год назад

    Latin was an international language in the European, middle east and Asia area, and it was transmitted orally and in writing by tens of thousands of people (monks, businessmen, students, workers etc.), also monks and kings sciencemen servants were writing translation books with words and letter sounds from all the countries the king had affairs with. All the books are kept in monasteries, museums and personal collections.

    • @parassaini9748
      @parassaini9748 Год назад +1

      😂😂😂

    • @mtarkes
      @mtarkes 7 месяцев назад

      Latin was more West and North Europe. Latin usage in East Europe is not so much as Greek remained the liturgical even to this day. Middle east, Asia? That's pushing it too much.

  • @fcouperin
    @fcouperin 5 лет назад +3

    *svatantraḥ kartā

  • @gdefrei
    @gdefrei 6 лет назад

    20:42 "kartṛ-hood"

  • @tagged5life
    @tagged5life 5 лет назад

    Using Rmarkdown, my man!

  • @efenty6235
    @efenty6235 5 месяцев назад

    "prolixity and sounding really big brained" haha classic luke

  • @thomasstein3774
    @thomasstein3774 6 лет назад +5

    Thank you Drake for that hilarious fortnite gameplay

  •  5 лет назад +8

    This woman constantly interjecting is quite annoying. Good talk, regardless.

    • @cortezphenix9569
      @cortezphenix9569 3 года назад +2

      she is supposedly an "expert" in her field, and the interjections are not that bad

  • @nly8286
    @nly8286 5 лет назад +2

    Закажите Маргиналу

  • @FKLinguista
    @FKLinguista 6 лет назад +7

    Who's the triggered "we knew that! :cry:" lady?

    • @FKLinguista
      @FKLinguista 6 лет назад +11

      And, "look at me, I can give unsolicited cognates of 'eight'"

    • @FKLinguista
      @FKLinguista 6 лет назад

      Never mind. Found out who she is.

  • @hindustanidevesh
    @hindustanidevesh 6 месяцев назад

    ॐ=MC²

  • @parassaini9748
    @parassaini9748 Год назад

    European insecurities.

  • @hugo54758
    @hugo54758 5 лет назад

    Not only it's obviously false as an idea but it's ridiculously false as well. In Europe, a lot of linguists consider de Saussure to be the modern starting point of linguistics.

    • @DipayanPyne94
      @DipayanPyne94 3 года назад +21

      Ferdinand de Saussure was influenced a lot by Panini. Panini has often been acknowledged as the Father of Linguistics. Modern Linguistics exists only because Europeans discovered Sanskrit in India a few centuries back. Actually, it's not just the History of Linguistics, but the History of Ideas, in general, that has been distorted for too long. Long story ...

    • @maya-cc2sx
      @maya-cc2sx 2 года назад

      @@DipayanPyne94 I'm late but what do you mean by the history of ideas? Is there somewhere I can read about this?

    • @DipayanPyne94
      @DipayanPyne94 2 года назад +1

      @@maya-cc2sx Many of my views have changed ever since my last comment. While there certainly has been distortion, it has not been as bad as I used to think. It's Right for the Historians of Ideas to have given more credit to the Ancient Greeks than anybody else ...

    • @maya-cc2sx
      @maya-cc2sx 2 года назад

      @@DipayanPyne94 ah alright, your comment prompted me to ask cause I always thought all ancient civilizations had more or less 'equal' contributions (exceptions being geography sometimes helping innovation I guess, like in the silk road), I'd never thought a task as big as objectively comparing them would be possible but I'll look into this myself ig

    • @DipayanPyne94
      @DipayanPyne94 2 года назад +1

      @@maya-cc2sx The BEST Ancient Civilization was Ancient Greece. There were other Great Civilizations as well, such as Ancient India, Ancient China, Ancient Egypt, Ancient Mesopotamia etc etc, but NONE of them were anywhere as good as Ancient Greece. If you compare their contributions objectively, it will become crystal clear to you that that is the bald truth.