Gravitas Plus: Is India prioritising rote learning over research?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- #GravitasPlus with Palki Sharma Upadhyay | This #NationalScienceDay, should India rethink its approach to teaching science? Make it about passion not compulsion. Research, not rote learning. Focus on Innovation in order to be truly #Atmanirbhar.
About Channel:
WION -The World is One News, examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to the politics of the world. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalised united world. So for us the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs as well as personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Bussiness:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps : bit.ly/ZeeNews...
Thank you Palki for covering this topic. As a kid in school, we are forced to learn things without understanding, write our exams, forget and repeat. Our teachers themselves don't know anything out of our book. In maths, we are forced to learn formulas without any proof, and even our textbooks promote rote learning by making us learn useless names and facts that are never going to matter in the future. We need more journalists like you to spread awareness about this.
Exactly. Its very relatable. Ever heard of Joseph Stalin or the Holocausts? Well, one person who denied was my history teacher :/
Smart indians are all in the west, leaving those not "very smart" ones in india 😂😂😂😂
We used to learn theorems, proof and formulas without even understanding it's importance and we still do even in Engineering.
@@yangleezhao5026 only indians get to mock india
@@RishabKhuba rip
I'm a brain researcher at NIMHANS. For the last 7 months I didn't get my due salary. How can government expect us to work without paying. I don't have a family support as well. Similarly there'll be thousands of researchers who are facing same problem just like me. Government must focus more into r & d then only startups will blossom. Thank you Palki for educating people on this most neglected area in India.
Not just NIMHANS, doctors and researchers in delhi face these issues as well...no payments, no assurance, no security ( literally )...
Even our chemistry Ma'am before teaching was in Research Field
Hang on brother
What ia brain researcher?
Am a doing research in physics Who face the same issue. Govt employees are lazy it drastically affects the growth of the country.
She really sounds like a passionate Indian not just like other news anchors. Respect for you.👏
We spend too much time in our glorious past and are absolutely clueless about our future. Thanks to our education system Indian students are highly risk averse and are almost always interested in taking the easy way out- the beaten path. We have never been encouraged to take risks and have assurance from our parents that it is okay to fail. Failure in something is a shame. We are highly conditioned by our parents and carry a heavy bag of false assumptions that have been fed to us throughout the 12 years of school life. If you don’t get admission in a prestigious college, you are already at a disadvantage and what not. We are constantly obsesssed with iits iims isb etc, as if they are the only way to success. We are churning out robots - corporate robots.
Indian mantra of success= prestigious college+ overhyped degree + job in an mnc
Written by a frustrated Indian student!
The equation of Indian success is still incomplete.
Agree.
Can't agree more
Even our history is written wrong in our text books 😒
Finally someone admitted that there is little value in talking about Indian science figures from 100+ years ago and Indians who immigrated to the West. We need to look to the future
"To have a safe and secure job and to avoid risks" Yes, that's why we won't succeed in innovation and research.
Yes correct, then what are the innovative jobs?
@@akshay7063 There is nothing like innovative job but one needs to find innovation in his job.
Innovation doesn't only mean that you need to make robotic appliances Or mechanical devices. Innovation stands for getting an ease of doing complex things in a sustainable way.
For that, one needs to look out of the walls of home and go and talk to people, discuss their problems and then get to your work facility like home or lab, think upon it, research on it with details and then execute it with the knowledge that one has gathered.
I am in Class 12 currently but definitely promising that whatever I can do for making this country more beautiful, I will.
We have lots of potential And we would secure that position again for sure.
And I hope you also do the same!
@@akshay7063 There is an Insta page called TheBetterIndia, do follow them.
They give their best to bring the real heroes of the country apart from our soldiers and frontline workers, to the limelight.
@@subratsahoo2171 Thank you for your informative reply.Then What should young generation should pick up their career apart from safe & secure jobs after their 12th?
@@akshay7063 I will list out the safe and secure jobs: The whole of IT industry, All govt desk jobs(Except for R&D institutes, Defense sector, Space research, Medical research institutes). The Majority of engg grads despite their depts(like mech, civil, electrical, chemical and such) join IT companies, if this is the case, what would be their 4 years of study worth? My suggestion would be that pick your field of interest and you shall venture into it, exploring new possibilities. :)
"We want safe and secure jobs."
You summed up the video there ma'am.
No. They are leaving India because of reservation.
@@subramaniamp.a5178 yeah yeah not because of lack of support or resources just because of reservation
Change ur thought , jobs will come towards u , u don't go towards them
@@subramaniamp.a5178 reservation is one of the reason
Not wholw
@@dwrako8039 I am in an NIT and even we don't have proper instruments.
You are the journalist that is need of the hour. Your neutral approach and precise focus on the topic leads you distinctly ahead.!! Thank you ma'am
When indians become smart, they go to the west, never to return 😂😂😂😂 that's why you don't see Indian tech giants like Huawei or ZTE 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao5026 india is 6th wealthiest country & world's no 1 pharmaceutical industry
@@yangleezhao5026 yeah but in our country we can criticize the government. China u say something the next day ur in jail
@@yangleezhao5026 and yet chinese are the highest number of demographics in the west. As if your situation is any better in this regard
@@yadukrishna1007 same with Disha Ravi right ?
Imo a very important point is that we waste ALOT of human resources talent, hardwork and crucial time for clearing competitive exams. The top cream of guys capable of innovation spends their prime years in preparaing to get into colleges but hardly even a fragment of that works hard when they get into the college. IIT-JEE prep is somewhat even understandable but here people even prepare to get into MBA colleges, thats ridiculous, spending years cramming English vocabulary! And then the UPSC prep, guys invest multiple years for that. What's the outcome as a society do we get out of all the preparation? It's like pushing a car from inside, work done is always zero. UPSC prep programs would just increase the cutoff and make some people very rich but that doesn't add to Indian's productivity at all.
@@kaanramatt37 right.
You are correct. IITs/IIMs should start offering bachelor degrees in Financial Engineering, FinTech, Computational Economics, Actuarial Sciences from the JEE rank list. Doing PG diploma in management, after studying mechanical engg, civil engg from IITs seems to be ludicrous. Better these guys who are good in math, logic, reasoning get the selection of their bachelor degree correct.
Did you win your case against WHJ
@@yashrawat9409 not yet. the next hearing for the case is on 9th April.
The civil services in India needs to be trashed entirely. What is the end goal of a bureaucrat? Is it policy making? If that is the case then remember that there is no developed country in the world that relies upon policymakers who are selected based on one exam and an interview. Policy making in developed countries is the forte of subject-matter experts. A subject-matter expert would typically have a PhD plus 10-15 years of experience in his/her field. This is why most find subject-matter experts are in their 40s-50s while cut-off age for UPSC is 30 years (33-OBC, 35-SC/ST). If the goal is to attract subject-matter experts into policy-making positions UPSC needs to set a minimum age cut-off of 45 years rather than a maximum age cut-off of 30 years.
Indian education system: if you are able to learn the whole book, to top your exams, you'll be successful 😑
@alan hembrom No it hasn't
@@sohamdhumal5710 yap. .
Day by day it's changing ....
Who said you this. I never saw this not a single teacher till now in my life told me this that if you Want to successful you have to only read books.. First understand why they tells us to read books.. Book is the only way who teaches us to be patience,yaa we have to make habit of reading books.. It's a good quality.. I think everyone should have to practice this..but i never saw a teacher saying read whole book to top in a exam or to be successful
@@atashiupadhayaya1762 i won't completely agree with you 😅 there are teachers who are advising students to read the books(not understanding) in order to excel the exams..... But I have also seen the teachers who are focusing more on understanding than mugging(my college professor)
not the case in competitive exams
Before independence, Calcutta was the heart of many scientific innovation , but now it is completely different...
Left and tmc ruined our bengal😭😭😭
Left and communism destroy progress
Mamta 🙃
@Aman Singh Nationalism differs from jingoism.
@@steeldragon410 No one cares about your liberal labels.
This video along with the one on kids getting dragged to coding says it all. A couple more of similar stories have the potential to be meaningful and eye-opening series.
When indians become smart, they go to the west, never to return 😂😂😂😂 that's why you don't see Indian tech giants like Huawei or ZTE 😂😂😂😂
Sir, at this point in human history, coding is a basic skill on par with the traditional five basic skills - reading, writing, listening, speaking, and arithmetic. Before the printing press a few centuries ago, less than 1% of the population could read. When the first computers were invented very few could write code. That scenario has changed now and everyone will need coding literacy. This includes even those in non-STEM fields.
I live in Canada and I have never seen any journalist in Canadian TV news also as focused as confident and as Natural as you. I am proud to see you, Palki Ma'am, doing a great job on Gravitas plus. Your Channel Deserve Billions of Trillions of Subscribers who can learn something true and important from you. I Have seen Dhruve Rathe Channel, The Lalantop Channel but you are ahead of everyone. You are the world's No.1 Journalist, a Journalist from India. Proud.!!
Chest thumping anchor
goose bumps allover my body on hearing about our legends happy science day..
When indians become smart, they go to the west, never to return 😂😂😂😂 that's why you don't see Indian tech giants like Huawei or ZTE 😂😂😂😂
huawei and zte both are banned in us and many other European countries and PRC is famous for reverse engineering for most of theirs products than making on their own...😁
@@yangleezhao5026 what Indian tech giants.........contribute for the world not for your country
This woman is something else. Love from Africa🖤
A system inspired by vedic system is the way to go.
😂😂😂. Vedic system my ass. Modern system is the best
watch praveen mohan channel .he is doing an outstanding work for dharma ..he needs your support .
We will send u back to vedic era lol
Smart indians are all in the west, leaving those not "very smart" ones in india 😂😂😂😂
No it is not
What you say is truth, after completing my Btech I landed a job of handling customers and working on Excel sheets. 2 years down I left my job to prepare for Gate and apply for Renewable Energy systems(MS) and have cleared my Gate exam and currently applying for Research program in various IITs. I have taken a risk and Happy with my choices.
Now education is a business 🥺😓😰
Just for getting a good college and good job and not in innovation
*The Sooner we will understand, the better it will be, 'Govt jobs are not future'*
Exactly
Yes 💯💯
Right. Govt. Jobs are shit. I am myself in Govt. Job.
@@sachinrana1482 No they are good in job security but govt can't provide job to a billion people and world is innovating and becoming capitalist open and creating giant private organisations but in our country people are running rat race for govt jobs and criticizing capitalist policies.
@@satyendra6587 without proper labor laws and stringent regulations..capitalism will only make the situation worse. Even in the US look at the minimum wage culture. In Amazon they don't get pee breaks. Without proper planning and infrastructure the line between capitalism and crony capitalism is very narrow and might seem non existent. Now you may ask what the hell our govt institutions and industrial authorities are doing about it? And I won't have any answer unfortunately.
I passed diploma in electronics from a govt polytechnic in delhi. We were around 62+ students in single class, and non of them(including me) were even not close to call ourself junior engineer.
And I got 80%.
It was shame to called ourself diploma, so I chose to call my self 12 pass. To avoid being embarrassed.
what are you doing now?
Cheer up buddy...if people think patent is the only way...it's not... people have created nuclear bomb and if you feel it's good for earth...it's not
Degree don't count on long run...it's ur attitude & thirst for knowledge & work will carry u to zenith
@@biswanathhalder7498 you didnt get it, institution in india, wasting time and money of indian student.
Plus such treatment makes embarrassed of your education and kills the interest in study, and field of study.
I have felt that, I know that kind of awkward moment.
This is the kind of journalism India needs😍
I am addicted to Gravitas plus reports and videos.
"Ratta Maar" is the key to success in our exams.
PS - Not criticizing memorizing formulas
Who is providing you people this info, yes I was ratta maar always during bca and mca, and was able to remember entire book in my.brain.
And I always studied just one or two days prior to exams. Sometimes when some topics were left for prepration I even made chits of them , theoretically I was weak while in programming I was way good at that time.
Indian school education sucks...
@@Tech-Inside and you're proud of what you did?
I definitely do. You don't need to memorize formulas if you actually get to apply them practically. It makes sense if you get to put the building blocks yourself.
dislike wale - unacademy , allen , resonance, vibrant, nucleus etc
😂😂
i hate unacademy
I myself am a aakash student. While preparing for NEET I used to have so many questions which was not related to exams but to the subject. But I was also made to shut up by my coaching or school teachers and they used to say that jo exam me aayega uspe focus Karo. I feel disgusted by this rat race where the one who mugs up the best and not questions anything wins the race.
Byju's??
Fitjee
When I just see these kind of tuitions ,an anxiety would come
correction: His name is pronounced as Raaman just like we say Ram as Raam
When indians become smart, they go to the west, never to return 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao5026 a Pakistani bot
@@yangleezhao5026 Indians are born smart😎
Indians are CEOs of tech giants in the west, Chinese are creators of tech giants which can challenge the west 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao5026 we can at least agree the west needs to be destroyed
90% of engineers in India forget much of it after passing the degree because they were forced to write "submissions"
Many science students didn't even know today was national science day including me🙄
@krish... the same here... but .. Feb 28 is Science Day... I promise that I will make a post in the same post on the next year on same day... to inspire and to motivate for future Gen Nxt'
But I knew, class 11th NCERT, chapter 1, CV Raman wala Box 😁
me too :')
Well, I can say from my personal experience that many of my classmates fled to the US to do PhDs there. They're working there on very marginal money according to US standards (around 30k). That's why the US is good in research & innovation. There are hardly any Americans doing phds and research, they're all Asians, mostly Chinese and Indians. Sad thing is many of the Chinese share the knowledge they gained by going back to their home countries, but the Indians prefer to stay and look at the thought of going back as some kinda failure. Ya, our mentality is still colonized.
This is gonna take some time but I trust the current govt for reforms like the NEP.
Bro Chinese government have made some kind of Rule
That those who go to foreign country for studying or researching after the completion they have to return to China
That's why mostly Chinese go back to China and also Chinese government also provide some great environment for them
But Indian Government____
Also there is Huge remittance Came from USA
Is this maybe a reason??
Bruh NEP is trash for us students as it's only on Paper in reality nothing has changed, when is the government going to implement it? I know everything takes time but Man we're already late... They just leave it on paper only, Implementation is everything... Baatein to koi bhi bana le! 😐
The Chinese have incentives to go back. They have autonomy and accountability in research. Frightening red tape is our forte though.
The reason Chinese & Japanese go back but Indians don't is because those Indians are from the "General category".
Japan & China don't have reservation systems. Their countries are based on merit, not reservation.
Happy national science day🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
When indians become smart, they go to the west, never to return 😂😂😂😂 that's why you don't see Indian tech giants like Huawei or ZTE 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao5026 Why would Indians need data stealing companies, eh?
If we say anything different than our parents think they say we are mad, because they want us to get in a job and look after them safely.
This is the Hippocracy of family system.
In India now all pseudo intellectuals ,leading india towards foolish nation where ppl depend on others in all fields,i got 10th positon in ph.d entrance but i did not make it cause they sold seat to other affluent person ,where is reaserch ,innovation ?
When indians become smart, they go to the west, never to return 😂😂😂😂 that's why you don't see Indian tech giants like Huawei or ZTE 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao5026 this is the first time I agree with you
Seriously, India is doomed
We need to get on the right track
@@yangleezhao5026 nah china has good protectionism policies as it does not comes under external pressure...look at it in this way as soon as a new social media becomes popular in west china bans it...even amazon is planning to leave china because of geo-restrictions...another thing is china almost does not respects international law with this china is able to keep it from falling into what i call r&d trap if you look at apple earlier when apple lisa was launched it costed astounding 9000 dollar to 10000 dollars and it was an epic fail but when it comes to china it wont bother to spend on r&d as its the job of apple, samsung and some European names...and huawei and ztc dont even have to worry about intellectual property theft as chinas domestic consumption and exports are equally large and at the same time government is ready to shield them even if international organisations would penalise them...thats why there cant be china in a democratic world...but i do agree with you every indian would run away the as soon as he gets professional degree from good college
Who else just noticed ALL Scientists of India come from South India....
@@yangleezhao5026 The PRC was given tech & capital support by the US during the Nixon administration, to exploit the Sino-Soviet rift that was developing. This is why you see Huawei & ZTE in the PRC.
That the PRC was able to use this to its advantage, eventually out-growing its US-designated role as the sweat-shop of the world, is it's real accomplishment.
Also, the PRC being an unapologetic strong State can afford to mow through the IP theft & various other criticisms made by the US (a historic IP thief & brutal human rights violator itself).
There are certain things India can learn from this. But an industrial comparison of the PRC & India, that doesn't factor in US assistance would be too narrow to be useful.
Hi Palki, You need to cover "Yes Madam, Yes sir culture" ingrained in our tradition. We all have to cater to people's dumb egos to get the work done. It is the same story from an attender to a Scientist....unfortunately several times it is the same issue between kids and parents. What is lacking is the professional approach. Our Sastras tell us that a 16 year old kid should to be treated like a friend but we love to control. You are the best person out there to present this without hurting anybody's sentiments.
The even more scarier thing is that due to rise in automation, by making our jobs more on desk work, we might not even get them by the time most children here graduate, meaning that the only job opportunity in a few years might just be research. Maybe then people will realize the downsides to menial jobs
4th Generation Industrial Revolution involving AI robotics automation driven by 5Gs or even 6Gs will never happen in India simply because India haven't even gone through its 1st generation industrial revolution. India's share of manufacturing to GDP is just 12%, a drop from 18% since Modi took over
In the year 2020,350 scholars were awarded PhD in IIT Madras only! Any idea of How many PhDs awarded all over India? Is India having enough space to host these researchers???! India's job market for research is very small!
@@swamyswaroopBS More than 25000, PhDs graduate every year in India. A majority of these are under faculty-improvement programmes where the PhD candidates already have a teaching job and simply want the Ph.D. degree in order to become HoD in his/her college. In the West, the minimum qualification of a university lecturer is a PhD, and getting an academic position requires completion of 2-3 postdocs and 5+ journal publications. That being said, less than 20% of PhDs in the West work in academia. The remaining work in industry or in startups. This is how these countries are able to innovate as (1) students learn from PhD holders who have a decent research record and can teach better (2) universities are hubs for research with many more PhD researchers (3) industrial research benefits with a more educated workforce. I think all PSUs in India and organizations such as DRDO / ISRO / BARC should start recruiting PhDs.
@@MrLee-gj2jz True that! But majority of these PSUs are into strategic research. I don't disregard or disrespect strategic research as it is equally important for the country. But India's funding is very skewed that these Strategic research sectors are receiving 3 times as much funding as medical research is receiving. India has been convincing non Science Indians with rockets for years! (I don't disregard the dedication, hardwork and determination of ISRO) . But most of the strategic research is applied research. The fundamental research often takes place in Educational Institutions ( This is the case in US, Japan and any other Scientifically developing countries). But neither are there many Institutions that cater the research environment (that innovations need) nor are there many faculty positions available!
@@MrLee-gj2jz Yet another problem, which I think affects innovation is bifurcation of research institutions and teaching Institutions. Many teaching Institutions - which offer degrees at undergraduate and postgraduate level - do not have anything called research at all! Research and teaching should essentially go hand in hand!
i say absolutely yes as a 12th student rn.
we are priortizing rote learning over understanding.
Ironically tomorrow is my physics exam and am learning formulas 😂
well, i have a solution for you after exams to memorize it for a long time. Practicality. Look up on why the formula is the way that it is and also look up how you can change the variables and get different results. That engagement probs will let you remember the formulae for the entire semester.
Best of Luck!
Indians are CEOs of tech giants in the west, Chinese are creators of tech giants which can challenge the west 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao5026 Shut up bot.
@@yangleezhao5026 with nill freedom of speech
And also we need more reporters like you, Unbelievable Palki 👍
Their is another side of story I guess "most of Indians go abroad for research and settle down forever"
Bhai in west dey study to be a researcher while in india we study to have a bank job
When indians become smart, they go to the west, never to return 😂😂😂😂 that's why you don't see Indian tech giants like Huawei or ZTE 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao5026 We have Infosys, Tata, ISRO and so on😁😁😁
@@yangleezhao5026 I tried to pronounce your fucking name and my furniture started floating
@@elik2386 ISRO is very neglected in the govt. They're literally given bare minimum, with bare resources to launch satellites and do astronomy. That's the sad part. Most politicans are very uncomfortable using taxpayer money on something that's truly useful for india. As for the ISRO, i'm surprised at the number of thing's they've done only with that much money
Very painful report yet a real one !! Indians love stability more over Greatness 🤦! How can we grow with such mentality ?
She is so smart. Always well prepared
I m not going to uk under any circumstances, why should I leave my country , what I did wrong with you people , I am just trying to save my relatives from any kind of damage that's it.
I have no enmity towards anyone.
But will not accept money under any circumstance. There is reason behind this, that I can't tell and will remain inside me and me.only till I am alive.
When indians become smart, they go to the west, never to return 😂😂😂😂 that's why you don't see Indian tech giants like Huawei or ZTE 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao5026 i respectfully disagree. I would say she is as smart as anybody
This is the only news channel in India which is non biased.
Spot on......The thing is I am again going to memorise Physics!!!Reason:Forcefully Isolated from alternatives.
I am overjoyed that you have lent your voice on this issue. Much appreciated 🙏
Hi mam i am your fan and you are great journalist.
*S I M P*
@@42069TV bruhhhh
@@42069TV 😄👍
We the citizens of Bangladesh, neighbor country of Great India,feel proud of India and its multi dimensional culture and ancient history as well as heritage.We also expect Indian same feeling about My Dear Motherland , Bangladesh...thanks to you and India...
0:06 This is absolutely not my case.
I used to go in such details, the teachers and my mates would be shocked.
I had a team of 3-4 friends who used to research, learn, and create.
Tried to make a lot of projects some worked, some failed.
Now I'm a C.A. student(lol) but I did research in this profession too
CA is still desk job. It mainly relies on manipulation.
@@shikharjain6357 Wow kya baat hai sirji.
Ekdum hi stereotype kar diye aap to.
C.A. is NOT a job. It's a PROFESSION.
Exactly teachers are shocked but shocked to discourage such students
I hope u still have those research feelings and still find ways to get to the top and invent something new in your field, if you are not thinking of inventing anything new then you are no different
genuine request from this 16 year old...please make some good innovation from your research in CA as well ;)
all the best bhaiya
WION News/Palki Please keep such videos (with in depth research and positive, pathbreaking intent) coming so that they can be used to spread the right awareness. 🙏
I like the cloth you wear always .. indian culture .. lots of love from uttar pradesh Palki ji
This whats happened with us. Like him we do BSc and MSc in physics and do clerk job.
There are no jobs for physics postgraduates outside teaching so it's not a surprise,
Your redefining journalism u deserve to be the face of journalism...love you ♥️
I get transfixed looking at palki mam delivering an absolutely amazing gravitas episodes. So mind simulating and informative
Reservation is killing talents. We have to look for greener pastures outside.
Reservation is for correcting the mistakes of the past!
Fulfill Abdul Kalam vision of Providing Urban Amenities to Rural Areas, remove caste system and do away with reservations. If every person is provided equal opportunity and accessibility, then only rule of meritocracy can be a norm.
@@ArulMoorthyM It is also in a way punishing meritocracy .
Financial subsidy based on economic disposition of the student/family for education is understandable but otherwise it's not an effective system .
That is why the smart ones leave the country and go abroad.
We should stop calling people like Pichai Indian.. they are American now . That is his nationality now .
@@ArulMoorthyM We don't need reservations. We just need a more unbiased society, knowing us will never happen
Indians study and work hard so they can make a name for themselves and be offered a high paying job in the west 😂😂😂😂
When children are encouraged to express themselves and take risks in creating art, they develop a sense of innovation that will help produce the kind of people that society needs to take it forward.
Dr A.P.J Abdul Kalam
What a marvel quotation to use as a guideline for education!
I am a Researcher. it's sad to say but when I look at my future in Research in India, it looks nothing but bleak. The best option is to go abroad and pursue my PhD.
✨🇺🇸 Excellent Reporting & Historic Research Presentations ✅
I am studying in Sweden and I think of this topic very often. Creating an environment free of fear is very important for innovation. Providing resources is one thing and building a carriculum around it is another. Both of which is missing from the system.A simple blackboard learning can never be enough. A good guidance is also missing so people often end up doing what they never wanted in first place. We get job not based on passion but based on other things. We need to invest a lot in our primary and secondary education and I think that is the key.
Wrong.
No need for money.
Enforce merit & end reservation system.
That's all that's needed.
Taking a huge stride in talking this out!! India needs reforms in its Education System. Thanks again for bringing this up!!
eye opening conclusion.. that without innovation - make in india , self reliant india, and $5t economy wud be a failure.
and also excellent presentation..
thanks WION.
You are doing great job not only for us but for our future generations too.
That's why we need privatisation, see who made vaccine for India, a private company
How many Indians are taking the vaccine
@@jo-vj6pe more than 10million have received already
I am a science teacher, and doing and will continue to do what ever it takes for my students to become more and more interested in science. But i think more resources should be provided at higher lever for research in science. May be aatma nirbhar bharat policy will increase funding for innovation.
It's great. Please keep going.
Man this hits too colse to heart as someone who has done Masters in technology and ending up in a Software company
Hard hitting journalism..Badly needed in India
Honestly I have stopped caring about this anymore. This has and will be a never ending problem so just focus on making money
Someone knows the language of mine.
I am almost overwhelmed by the paradigm shift in India's education system. In Germany, with its supposed "innovative drive", we can actually only dream of something like that, in the moment. The debate is on, but still a long way to go. If you are this far now, and manage to exercise this kind of policy effectivly: Then India is unstoppable, I truly believe. We need a strong, divers, wealthy, democratic and creative India! I wish you all the best success, greetings from Germany.
Besides all this, Indian education is highly COMMERCIALISED. A very small small percentage of students ( nearly 2 to 3%) make it to top colleges without spending lakhs on a coaching institute. This is injustice being done to financially weak students
You actually made us realise how important Science day is, Ms. Palki
Hopefully, the society will show better improvement
Actually I am having advertising of byju's while watching this video...
XD
your voice is strong and gives us hope that things can change. I want WION and Palki to be the mainstream media
When we learn in our mother tongue innovation will start
New Education Policy stresses on that
@@furyxtv5540 then why do u need 3 languages isn't mother tongue and English not enough???
Why r u putting more stress on students by making them learn another language?
@@snaik9141 3rd language is optional in NEP,try reading completely with a stable mind.
Can't we just have one language for everything Official things like sanskrit
@@sumreensultana1860 Sanskrit would be the best choice as the official language for us in India and it would be much more easier to learn, than English, and understand since maximum of our languages have their roots in Sanskrit. English is causing inferiority complex in some and unnecessary pride in others as it is being considered as a parameter of intelligence.
Oh thats how a news outlet should report the News. Best wishes from Ziro, Arunachal Pradesh, India
I am currently pursuing a Master's degree in Electric Vehicle Technology which is considered to be highly innovative field in today's world but I look at the curriculum and subjects and I ask this same question everyday, and unfortunately for our country I always get the ill-favored answer.
Thank You so much for voicing my concerns and Hopefully Some people sat at influential places watch and understand the need for rapid change especially in Technical courses as this is also a huge reason for Unemployment.
Palki Sharma Upadhyay mam has actually highlighted the problems of every student. As a student I have also heard exams are important than understanding. Don't take risk of learning and writing wrong in exams is what I have heard. I'm a student of class 10th and I hate these barriers.
Root of rote is chanting of vedas almost from time immemorial
Last line ok palki is also soo amazing ,,I really love gravitas plus 🤩😍😍
YES YES YES I'M AN IITan we do that even in prestigious colleges.
Finally the real and naked truth revelaed, bitterly truth and honesty people say and no body has guts to follow
Great appreciations to WION and Palki for covering the issues so nicely.
Its time to change our perceptive of learning
I was about to sleep happily today as i got my salary yesterday, now im depressed after watching this video
And I am worried for tomorrow because I need to bow and listen to what exactly my manager would ask me to do( even if I have my own set of ideas).
What a beautiful news channel with beautiful anchor.. really.. I learn a lot about everything from Gravitas .. world class reporting
Hope this govt do investments in research and development 🙏
@Anurag Chakraborty aaj Kya huaaa pta h???
@Anurag Chakraborty kha se itna dimag lata hai bhai .
Indians study and work hard so they can make a name for themselves and be offered a high paying job in the west 😂😂😂😂
Indians are CEOs of tech giants in the west, Chinese are creators of tech giants which can challenge the west 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao5026 haha how many of your "tech giants capable of competing with the west" stole tech from different countries to do so
Pretty eye opening. I think our education ministry should do something in this regard.
We dont have time to explore science
Our syllabus thats an achievement for us
In usa there are jobs for 12-17 yrs old and they gain experience.
While INDIA does not have jobs for older people.
Respected mam.
U r absolutely correct.
I'm fully agree with you.
India should give due recognition to scientists.
India gives , but parents dont. they need secure jobs for children.
I did my kindergarten till 12th in India and then moved to US to do a bachelor’s in computer science. The main difference I saw was the emphasis on deep understanding rather than solving puzzles. It helped that US has infrastructure to support hands on learning on a mass scale. In US the books and quizzes exclusively focus on deep understanding. For instance, I understood Calculus 3 by imagining three dimensional objects rotating on axes.
Lately i have picked up meditation and I have done a lot of study on the Upanishads and the Pali Canon. I think our emphasis on rote learning comes from these times when monks were required to memorize everything by the time they turned 17. It was only after that they learned to apply the learning and really understood the Canons.
Mam, your my favorite journalist
Way of conveying the news 👌
Unique personality
Unique personality?? Miss mono tone more like 🤷♂️
Indians are CEOs of tech giants in the west, Chinese are creators of tech giants which can challenge the west 😂😂😂😂
Very revelaving and well compiled presentation..hard facts, bitter truth 🤔🤫😴🙄😦💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐👏👏
As a kid I feel studies quite bored. And I am not a backbencher at all. I am a topper. I don’t like to study in school or about school. I like to learn from encyclopaedias, google, RUclips, and the outer world.
never went to tuitions in my school life, always read about the topics from the internet and somehow always scored 90%. this is the way in future
@@arnavgoel Nice.
The best analysis I have seen from any Indian Journalist....
5:37 - 29,846, some of which are stolen from U.S. companies.
Yes 😆😆😂😂🤣🤣
You know what's *hurts* the most
that this country was a leader in science
WHEN WE STAND IN OUR ROOTS INNOVATION WILL HAPPEN
Our past roots had MERIT, not reservation.
Do you think India is ready ?
Great madam... You are motivating leaders... Keep it up. World requires you.
Thats true... I also feel like i spent years to just gain few certificates which can help me in getting corporate job. But deep inside i know i learnt and innovated nothing. Our education system needs improvement.
You are an amazing person.
My love and support is always with you. Wanting to work with your service/company.
The worst part is even the present day teachers have very little interest in teaching. One only gets a job if he or she has a B.Ed degree, which is literally of no use in enhancing their knowledge. I've seen people without B.Ed degree having great teaching skills than those with this waste 2 yr "essential" course.
Very encouraging
We are indians , and we know how to kill innovation and creativity 💪🇮🇳😂
When indians become smart, they go to the west, never to return 😂😂😂😂 that's why you don't see Indian tech giants like Huawei or ZTE 😂😂😂😂
Not really if try to do something on your own no one can stop you, but many of our younger generation have a habit of asking everything without any effort. That's the problem, do you know that majority of the companies don't want to hire newbies as in people without any experience which is mainly because we as individuals lack knowledge
@kanwaljeet Singh bhai ek auto generated comment ko jawab deke kya fayda ?
@@abhisheknautiyal8877 not talking about opportunities , but the will to do something in lacking becoz of the mentality , most people in our country dream of becoming a government employee and doing the same unproductive job their entire life . This is due to the crap fed to young Indians from a very small age
This is crude message
We need to focus on our ancient knowledge and compete.
Excellent 👍,I don't understand why people dislike this,may be they don't have common science
The reason Indian students are not inclined towards research is the fellowship money or stipend being provided to them is too lower than fellowship money in USA or Europe. This is much less than a investment banker earning or a journalist like you ma'am.
Increase the fellowship money we are ready to go.
No amount of money can compensate for the end of merit.
Meritocracy alone will end the problem in India.
@@subramaniamp.a5178 will you do research even if your family has not enough food to eat?
In this situation what would u do? A high earning job first or reasearch with stipend only enough to pay your personal expenses only?
@@Ritikkumar-mq3fm My research $$$ is granted by the US department of defense & DARPA with a lot of stipend - millions of $$
In India I couldn't because Indian politicians play reservation politics.
Here in Dept of defence USA, MERIT holds value.
Why do you think Sundar Pichai & Satya Nadella came to the US ?
Both were general category students.
@@subramaniamp.a5178 i got your point. There is no meaning to talk to you.
@@Ritikkumar-mq3fm Oh there is. You just don't WANT to acknowledge the truth.
Reservation is the death of India.
Excellent Analysis