The Real REASON why SAARC Failed
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- It’s been 8 long years since the last SAARC summit was held and there is no certainty, when it will happen next. At the heart of this conflict is the Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi. When he became the PM for the first time in 2014, he was very vocal about his interest in SAARC and how he wanted to transform it. But things have changed a lot in last 8 years and it seems SAARC is headed to an unavoidable demise.
Lets connect :
If you are facebook type: / dipesh.tripathi.35
If you are twitter type: / nepalicomment
If you are instagram type: / dipesh.trip
If you are interested to know more about me, watch my story at Storyyellers called " 84 Pages of Disappointment"
• Mr. Dipesh Tripathi (S...
Sources:
[www.livemint.c...]
[www.eastasiafo...]
[www.brookings....]
[thediplomat.co... became an observer state,to the SAARC Development Fund]
[www.jstor.org/...]: India’s Paradigm Shift from SAARC to BIMSTEC
[www.statecraft...]
[www.sspconline...]
[www.jstor.org/...] : Pakistan at the Heart of SAARC’s Failure
[timesofindia.i...]
[thediplomat.co...]
[www.newslaundr...]
[www.thenews.co...]
[www.strifeblog...]
[timesofindia.i...]
[thewire.in/dip...]
[www.bbc.com/ne...]
[www.ndtv.com/o...]
[www.hindustant...]
[indianexpress....]
[ratopati.com/s...]
[www.thehindu.c...]
[theprint.in/op...]
This video features materials protected by the Fair Use guidelines of Section 107 of the Copyright Act for the use of criticism, comment, reporting and teaching. All the footage belong to their respective owners.
Videos from:
CCTV America
NTV
ABP News
India TV
ET
King and Generals
DD News
New China: Xinhua Video
CRUX
TIMES NOW
The WORLD TODAY
BBIN
The QUINT
Aljazeera
WION
NDTV
RSTV
What I said in the video is actually happening: ekantipur.com/news/2022/03/31/164868808069532733.html
Logical china yo video ma bakwas video ho. Saarc unsuccessful reason Pakistan ho. Hami le logic ma kura gare bhane.
tum anti modi ho, qki tumhe uss smey ki pak. ki baatein nahi dikh ri,
pehle china ke debt trap se bach jao
@@vaas4403 Did u even watch video till end to talk shit
Just wanted to tell u....
This topic deserves a long vedio....
Why USA i pretending to be ally...
Reason behind BRI and modi idea and contradiction
The reason behind the taking control in harbour in srilanka
The contract between taliban and USA and their left behind equipments.
And soo no.
Nothing personal kid, just geopolitics. Deal with it.
Good to see someone is finally making sensible content from Nepal. Great job!
So proud that someone is uoloading this well edited, quality Nepali video. Tried the same a year ago, but no results.
Thank you so much @TheStony. I looked at your videos and I really liked it specially those with map animations. What do you use to create those animations? After effects?
I am from India, and I could understand some of what you were saying, its good to hear a different viewpoint, very informative.
It is utterly sad to see that PM Narendra Modi was trying his best to setup a viable conglomerate within SAARC but this infighting and squabble is tearing Nepal apart.
You know what, initially Pakistan didn't joined SAARC because it was representing itself as a Middle East country. Also, there's no point in running SAARC.
Very informative content. I believe Nepalese leaders must weigh their options very carefully and opt for the best way for betterment of its citizens.
I Don't know what's happening between India And Nepal but I just wanted to see these both nations as friends because we have much more cultural similarity than any other nation.Love from India 🙏🙏
Not only cultural but we have a very close relationship with inter border marriage. We are basically cousins.
@@kayreeves2000 actually brothers bro
@@kayreeves2000 don't love indians. They r very obsessive and suppressive they've Always been that way. We nepali r too innocent
Same... When did nepal and Indian ko bich ma yo Wall ayo...
Because India capture our land that's why and your godi media ✊
I don't understand Nepali but I enjoyed watching ur video
Love from india 💕
you can turn on caption "CC" and watch with english subtitle
Bruh it's almost same
Quality content as always. DAMI DAMI DAMI!!
I'm from Bangladesh, I don't understand all of ur word... bt I agree on ur point
Shouldn't Pakistan be blamed rather than India? Modi did whatever he could in his fullest capacity.
I agree. But I simply mean, PM Modi isnt favoring SAARC. And I think I have clarified inside the video how Pakistan is the reason behind it. It's just that Modi isnt agreeing for summit while all other country are more or less willing.
@@TheNepaliComment even if India agrees, nothing's gonna come out of that summit because of pakistan
@@TheNepaliComment Modi is not willing just because of pakistan.
@@TheNepaliComment saarc is dead, not one cares about it in India.
@@AkashChSahu just like modi raise mawowadi then madhes with 2015 econmic blockade. Modi is main villian
Man your content is out of the world though kudos to you and keep making this kind of stuff ❤️
Thank you so much for such encouraging words.
Defnitely not out of the world but I respect your research effort
Loving your content brother ❤️
Thank you brother.
Great job man you need a lot of support. You deserve more keep grinding! Loved the content Btw
Thank you so much. The next video is releasing this week.
@@TheNepaliComment modiji ne Pakistani terrorist group aur Pakistan ko dhamki di aur tum Nepal ko bata rahe ho views ke liye kuch bhi kar shakte ho
Only India and Bangladesh are two countries, economically and politically stable, rest are just politically stable atm. Pakistan and Afghanistan are both economically and politically unstable countries so SAARC failure was inevitable. If we look at BIMSTEC, except for Myanmar, all are politically stable countries so I think BIMSTEC will be successful since there are little to no political tension among countries.
No India or Bangladesh is only economically stable not politically don't say this kind of joke 🤣🤣🤣
@@SumitSharma-gy1fv I am not talking about Bihar & UP poliitics. It's largely stable compared to the rest of SAARC. Nepal gets new PM every year or so. Pakistan PM never completes full term.
@@nikhilkay1 oh bro bhihar and up is also not stable politics, if stable politicians has in bhihar and up, then both state are developed than other states of India, so not blindly believe in politicians, they are currupted first you gain education and do reasearch.
@@SumitSharma-gy1fv please, put comma, period when you are replying. It's too hard to understand what you are trying to say.
@@nikhilkay1 ok bro I edited reply read reply hope you understand
I think focusing on SAARC and reviving it will be the same because politicians of both india and pakistan benefits from their rivary. And their enemity was main cause for SAARC to die .For now BIMSTEC seems approachable and beneficial.
BIMSTEC is garbage and a waste of time
man i love your content, can you make one about 2019/20 first lockdown and how/why it was effective compared to the delta spread lockdown last year. we had almost no cases for a week/ two weeks iirc while italy suffered a lot in the same time.
Glad that you liked it. I will definitely research about it. Thanks
Negative comment given by modi is to Pakistan. Video is cropped and added, against Nepal.
Machiknay!! Mailay yo video heray ko chu jaba jaba kasmir ma terrorist attack Huda modi lay Pakistan Lai Gali Garda.
@@rabindas2086 the video clearly shows that modi statement was against Pakistan. maybe it's only u who took it against Nepal.
after understanding these fact I think that we must have to focus BIMSTEC instead of SAARC.
BIMSTEC is a better group of sovereign and democratic countries, rather than a group with ill-fated beggar extremist-islamic countries.
As long as there will be bullying nature of India and think all the other country should worship india like god and accept it as greatest nation of all, BIMSTEc will be as failurr as saarc
@@kapil4417037 India is not like that, India's policy is give respect take respect.
@@VitaminProtein4256 that is understandung of you people. But that does not apply in political level.
@@kapil4417037 you can't imagine how difficult to run a democracy of 1.4 billion people.
I have to say that the idea of SAARC and proposal of SAARC was given by Bangladeshi president Ziaur Rahman
.
What a fabulous video . Keep going brother .We will always support you
India knows Pakistan wont let SAARC to function properly, that why India is more focused about BIMSTEC
Please continue making such good videos. Content and Presentation is international level
Hey brother
I am your new subscriber
Love your content and keep uploading this kind of content.
Hope to see you soon in millions of subscribers
🙏
Let's understand the fact that Pakistan is like a snake you don't want in your backyard and moreover china-pakistan tagging along is a serious no under any circumstances and the resent development in Afghanistan has made adverse this situation, so maybe yah saarc is unofficially dead but still standing on paper.
Btw nice analysis and great content love and support from India. 🇮🇳
we hate dhoti .
you are no better than pak for us. backstabbing always
@@herohera3497 keep crying.
Exactly.. I am a Nepali and I agree with you
@@krish4134 chup dhoti machikne
I think, Nepal should quit SAARC
Because Nepal is not going to progress joining SAARC.
Also, the tourist (SAARC) have to pay less in Nepal to visit various places which leads to less income.
Better to focus more in BIMSTEC
Economically BIMSTEC is a much better option. SAARC has always underperformed, but sometimes I think, is economics all that matters? Location wise, SAARC is much compact than BIMSTEC and if SAARC were to be functional and India-Pak conflict solved, this region would be a great hub. But till then BIMSTEC is the way to go. ❤️
@@TheNepaliComment it never gona solve.
Not only modi but Indian leaders had high hopes for saarc. The Vision is clear integrate South Asia and make it like ASEAN and EU so it have better negotiations with rest of the world.
It was idea of former PM Indira Gandhi after Ussr invaded Afghanistan. India and Russia are friends but India don't like that Russia expand in South Asia thus saarc born and if India has suggested that, then Pakistan gonna reject it. So, India done through Nepal.
But India being major power and not Allied with any block means everyone want to check its influence and they all done through Pakistan.
Now, if we consider the economic situation of Pakistan it would have defaulted long ago but just to poke India they all give huge Aid to support it in exchange of harassing India.
When modi came he tried his best to stabilize it but failed due to both US and China don't like that.
Saarc was fiasco now India tried luck with BIMSTEC but China strikes again and Myanmar cough happens leading to sanctions. This ruins Indian's plans to connect India, Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh, Myanmar, Laos, Vietnam, Malaysia, Singapore via road. And chinese debt bankrupt Srilanka. Although due to maritime border not everything got ruined and still hopes remains.
Now India again tries to test his luck on Arab countries with help of UAE and US. But then Biden came to power and ruins Arab-US relations (bit tricky to think why).
Still good news is India-Bangladesh are connecting each other in rapid pace followed by Nepal. Hope others get prosperity too.
@@pratikkalotra88 Well said facts.
@@nawanitsharma8353 INSHORT SAARC is just thriving because of pakistan and China`s intervention .
As if that would make a difference. Your performance is dependent on your strength and strategy not your international friends. What is Nepal's strength and when will we have a strategy?
Hey it’s really fun to watch your videos and informative. If you could cover on first organic state in world (Sikkim) also recognised by world books of record London but currently it’s been heard due to change in government of Sikkim this tag of organic state has been slightly degraded or affected. And it would be really great of you.
Thank you for the important information! This is the kind of information and representation of Youth we need for the development of the country.
Crucial Reason:
PM Modi rejected the Taliban regime in Afghanistan.
Indo-Pak ongoing rivalry has a direct impact in the SAARC.
Territorial water disputes between India and Nepal.
The regional power politics, poor connectivity, trade embargo seen in recent developments.
Increasing influence of superpower (china) in the SAARC.
your content is off the top brother ❤️ keep up the good work
Thanks
Pakistan is the main reason for less development in South Asian region!!! All South Asians should ignore Pakistan and work collectively for their infrastructure and trade development !!!!
First of all, idk if u agree or not India doesn't wants it's dominance over SAARC ..Doesn't need to. We demands equality and peace among nations ..When we say we have relation of brotherhood with countries , we mean of equal brother not big -small brother (said by India many times)
Second , Having connectivity among SAARC nation meant more trade ,which not only helps India ,it helps other countries more
third , Adding China doesn't means India losing power , it means sharing power with a enemy ..
fourth , what is happening in Srilanka and Pakistan is evident
fifth , SAARC can never be bad of India even in long run ..That's why BIMSTEC is there , also having major booming economy such as Thailand and Myanmar is more beneficial for everyone
I don't know why you Hate Modi (that is the feeling I get from your video maybe I'm wrong) and as for me I don't support his party either but he is PM of my nation and he deserves more respect
He didn't hate modi and I agree on your points.
He is not against Modi, infact I think the villain is pakistan supporting taliban gov't and bhutan backing out.
No offence to india but ......
Coldwar between india & pakistan has led SAARC to dark unknown journey.
Nepal: wait and watch.
We knew it. It's not fault of Pakistan's leaders they are forced by others to take on India.
Until they get out of debts of others normalization will not happen.
Its totally fault of pakistan
You will have millions subscription of civilized youtube watchers for sure.. best wishes 🔥🔥❤️❤️
Gonna share this with all my friends
this is something great I saw, research garda dedicated huna k garnu parchha hola, kasto patience vayera banako
Thank you so much
great informative video. lovely to see such good content coming out of Nepal.
binge-watched all the videos on your channel. great content, keep doing such great work!
Thank you so much. The next one is releasing this week.
Jhonny harris nepali version yaar babaal bro keep it up dami lagyo content
You just earned a subscriber
🙏🙏🙏
i just love the clips that u have compiled. great stuff. just keep bringing out more.
Watching from Assam India..really loved the content keep it up bro 👍🏻
India-Pak are the biggest hurdles for the development of SAARC.
content ramroo cha ..long term sustain huncha hola yo channel
Too much researched video brodaa kepp making video we will always with you😍😍😍👏👏👍👍
Nepal is permanent Chairperson of SAARC
SAARC should be closed , because the intervention of CHINA AND PAKISTAN is not good.
Every Part of this Video is debatable.
Modi does not want to destroy Saarc. No PM in the right mind would want to destroy a regional grouping.
The major issue is India has always been perceived is a bad light. All our neighbors feel like we are acting like a ''big brother'' trying to bully and assert our dominance in South Asia. Even our development effort have been scrutinized with a lot of suspicion. eg Pancheshwar Dam in mahakali river.
The Fatal blow to Saarc was when Nepal and the other members fearing India's emergence as a regional leader (big brother) decided to back Pakistan's motion of making China an Observer state and subsequently a member.
Moreover the event that followed with Pakistan facilitating Uri and Pulwama, abrogation of 370 and Salami slicing of the Chinese, there is no way we can all sit down at one place and talk, there is too much of bad blood.
The bottom line is, Saarc has become dis-functional by Regional Geopolitical situation and not by Mobi devising a scheme to render it so. Also all nations in that grouping except for us(India) have piled up huge amount of Chinese Debt, have opted for Belt and Road Initiative and its only a matter of time that one after the other they will have to deal with economic as well as a sovereignty crisis. I m sure you are seeing the state of Sri Lanka and Pakistan. There is So much of Trust deficit that nothing will be taken up in good spirit.
Although you have your creative freedom and can present with anything you want. I am just here to give a glimpse into our side of the story.
The content is too good but the title is quite misleading ... destruction and negligence aren't same thing ......
Ekdam manpayro video bahi.. good job ani keep it up...millions of like..
Right action taken by PM. Modi
I love your content. I just found this channel and has been watching it in loops
Thank you again
This is called journalism.shame on you so called "journalists of NEPAL", your statement are backed up by the facts. Hope you will not be influenced and do the real journalism, good luck.
🙏🙏
Lets be Good and do Good.
Ajai yestai video halnu paryo bro 😋♥️
Hardwork for any topic . Appreciated bro 🙏
the voilent thing is about Pak and china because they kept attacking India its not about Nepal.
Most under rated channel
Finally someone is speaking. We have to be independent. Why do we always look after India/foreign Countries???😔
You have to because of your geography
we can be independent only if we have sea port and dont need to be dependent on any on regarding trades.. we are land locked and this is the reason our politicians will always lean towards china or india.. leaning totally one sided is not good, we must have balanced relation with both.. but when oli comes in power he hails china, and when deuba comes in power he hails india.. we need politicians who keep neutral approach and show our importance to them.. which was possible only during the Monarchy time.. Only Monarchy can keep relations balanced.
@@love4ever026 why nepal got rid of monarchy by the way?
@@shreyangshumodak8923 Nepal didnt got rid, it was foreign powers who were behind the massacre of royal family and 17000 people.. People never wanted secularism and democracy.. protest was paid in so called "jan andolan" most of the protesters were paid.. and it took fire when politicians and so called intellectuals who started narrating that King Gyanendra was behind the royal massacre.
@@love4ever026 if it was bjp in power back then we would have surely intervened in this but sadly it was congress
Most underrated RUclips channel
Sigma Modi Ji 😎
you make really good content bro...keep it up...we all are getting so much info from your videos 😊👌👌
Thanks for letting us know !
i love my country
but i'm ashamed of my government
i have subscribed after watching this video!!!
Welcome aboard. 🙏
Very interesting research chai khatara 😍😍😍big fan brother
Thank you so much 😀
U r wc 😍🙏🙏🙏
Wow so much information and Interesting Interesting
Its time to remove SAARC chapters from our social studies book.
Nepali bhaasa ma pani yesto babaal reasearch garera content banaune hajur matrai hola, yestai video banaudai jaanuhola, mero purna sahayog hunecha
🙏
Exactly a poor Indian will ask for peace and friendship but a rich one will ask for war and revenge
Pakistan is not a big power or big economy than anyone dying to do peace with them
@@divya9951 😂😂typical dumb Indian, yes it is, Pakistan is actually really powerful why do u think both china and america want it , plus nukes
@@Pouytrwwq124 😂😂very peaceful and kind indeed
I really loved your content 🥰❣️
Great job
Love you bro, its was very much informative
Glad it helped
SAARC should be resurrected ASAP
Great video, bro.
Thank you so much. You have really supported the channel a lot from day 1
Bro you are doing something best. Provide us best videos
Thanks
Keep going 👍👍👍
very informative video. keep up the good work
Honorable prime minister narendra modi said nothing wrong. That speech was right after Pulwama attack where 50 and more armed police personnel were killed with a car bomb in kashmir. And frankly there are few countries with which bridges can't be built in lieu of border. Countries like China and Pakistan.
But yeah. Few cuts here and there , you can make anyone look bad.
Dipesh, you have done constructive analysis. Well done!. But ajhai deep ma gayera analysis garna sakyou vane ajhai ramro hunchha ki vanne mero opinion chha.
Dhanyabad
Good Research...
What a content👏👏Hatts off🙏🙏
🙏
Truly Informative
Thank you so much bro
hait dai esto khatra content haru banaunu huda raixa ta👏😯
Thank you so much bro. Glad you liked it
Love your presentation
Nepal is in bimstec. So why it is worrying. Yes saarc has problem but bimstec could be promoted. We don't Pakistan to be included in the meeting
Informative video ❤️
bhotey shi content dai ...🔥🔥
Having 2 countries or two giant i.e India and china in saarc is a must for reducing monopoly of Indian interest .
Remember our blockade done by indian government .
Remember those faces very well .
Never forget what they do
Don't think they are ally .
So monopoly must be broken
Two is good
Just like Intel and AMD
03:04 glad to see my hometown 😎
u r gem bro. keep up the good work.
I think its better for Nepal to stay away from the political tussles in between China, India and Pakistan !
In this world of connectivity, where the economy of a country is greatly linked with other countries. That's simply not possible. Tackling its diplomacy properly is the way to go. But, be sure that the current political leaders just adopt polices whichever benefit them, than the country. So, the future doesn't look too bright.
You can't...When big power involve in fight..you have to pay...And yes India and China is that big power...not Pakistan
@@raunak7461 Pakistan is a regional power
@@erenscott6176 Sorry. .You are wrong and me too...Pakistan is a superpower...and No 1
@@raunak7461 I'm spitting facts and now you come up with this? Indian moment asf!
Amazing content keep up the great work 👍
Always rock and interesting content ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Short & informative information. 👌👌👌👌👌👌
so i guess modi's ambition with SAARC was to use it as a tool to develop indian hegemony over the south asian region, but due to tensions with Pakistan concerning them wanting China to join SAARC and also terrorism basically meant India was no longer interested in SAARC leading to the demise of this institution? It's an interesting video, I am not Nepali so it is interesting to have a different perspective on these things. I wonder if it will ever be possible to develop an EU-type organization between the South Asian countries without it imploding due to political tensions...
Due to regional disturbances SAARC is inactive at the moment.
We must know and understand the geopolitical situation of its member countries - India, Pakistan and China.
However, Nepal as an economy must realise that it's under acute recession.
Basic economic reformation is required in the country and its ministers try to look forward for economic growth and prosperity.
This is good idea that Modi bypassed the Pakistan, and initiated Bimstec
Nice topic 👍👍
Awesome knowledge!!
Thanks for watching!
धोती त हो धोती त जताफाइदा उतै धोती को भर हुदैन त्यै नी यो धोती को के कुरा माग्ने राजा भएनी जात जनाइहाल्छ
Yup very informative....
Glad you liked it
3:30 I love how rishee dhamamla is everywhere
Hahhahah. There's no escape from Rishi Dhamala. I have a video planned on the him called," The CURIOUS CASE of Rishi Dhamala". He is such a unique character.
Keep posting such video pls🙏🙏🙏