If I was shopping ONLY by swatches (NO PACKAGING TO DISTRACT ME), and you showed me those on your arm....I'd TOTALLY choose the originals. It just goes to show how motivated we, the consumers, are by pretty packaging. Too Faced KNEW that and so they used pretty packaging to try and renew interest in an older product. P.S. Although the outer packaging is undeniably beautiful, I actually hate a shiny gold inner palette. It not only detracts from the shadows, but it also just looks "cheap-y" to me. I'll keep my old "Natural Eyes" tin thank you, Too Faced 😘
I REALLY LOVE the new colors that are BETTER versions of the old TOO warm/orange/deep that are now SO much prettier!! They are MORE wearable and REALLY look more natural and like nude/neutral shades. I get SO tired of SO many brands ruining palettes with all the orange/"terracotta" or too deep murky colors that LOOK like TOO much and you can never get a NATURALLY PRETTY look with them. I for one am SO glad they improved those old (overused and obvious) colors. I have the old palettes and am SO happy they finally made something that is AS PROMISED, NEUTRAL/NATURAL colors. NOT everyone wants OBVIOUS , noticeable color but like instead to just look NATURALLY ENHANCED AND PRETTY. THANK you TOO FACED for the improvements!
Same! Also, Honey Butter is my favorite shade, hands down, so I'm so sad they let it go. I'm close to panning it and idk what I'll do when it runs out. Probs buy a single if available/dupe if not because I can't justify rebuying the palette just for one shade, honestly.
My sentiments exactly! Why change something that is so perfect! The Natural Mattes is an all time favorite of mine. I need a hands on look at these now before buying. I’m glad I waited for Emily’s review. 😊. The lipsticks are beautiful though!
I got the old Natural Matte at TJ Maxx for $15. Be on the lookout. I actually like the smaller tin packaging. I don't like the new gold interior. I just prefer a smaller palette. I'm going to use it for travel. As a cool tone lover I most certainly love the original! You are right Emily, the new one is so ordinary.
You are so articulate and just fantastic when it comes to reviewing products! I understand everything well, even though English isn’t my first language (but I do love the language so much, it’s like my second language), and your videos are so well thought off. I personally like the shades in the new palette, because I’m very fair and have blue eyes so I feel like the new palette would suit my eyes more. I don’t know. I didn’t try the old shadows though. But I’m definitely going to get the new Natural Matte palette because I need new brown matte shades for every day use. :) Thanks for the video, Emily!
I always wanted the Natural Matte palette but never got around to picking it up, now I probably never will. I prefered the old colors better. Oh well, the last thing I need is more makeup.
Amy Louwho same here I had it on my wl for a long time,I wanted to hit the pan on my UD basic 1 which I do not adore,I am using it but I wouldn't buy it again..and now I don't know what to do..definitely not be buying the new version..maybe I'll just buy new milani matte palatte instead , it has so many great reviews (both of them )
same...i've not yet own any too faced palette (though i love their estetics) it seems everytime i'm trying to buy from them i didnt end up buying them at all 🤣..palette wise i mean... i still prefer my juvias place and colourpop palette 😎😎..
I was just about to settle on that palette as my first neutral palette, but then the tarte in bloom palette released literally days before I was gonna pull the trigger! I love my tarte palette, despite recent tarte brand drama.
Last unicorn Yes, the new Milani palettes look amazing and I do love my mattes. As much as I don't care for Wal-Mart I'll probably get it there because it's $15 instead of 20. Thank you for reminding me that I can get those 2 and have money left over! 😉
Ohhhhhh I've been very curious about this collection! So happy that YOU reviewed it bc i know I can genuinely rely on what you say about products. Thank you!!! Xoxo
Okay - this might be me being silly, but I am kind of tired of makeup brands using "raunchy" names like sexpert or strip poker or, more famously, orgasm. Not because I personally care but because it means that I can't give this to my traditional grandmother (she'd have a heart attack) or to my younger relatives. Plus it is overdone shock value marketing.
@@kpeacock22 I love my Tarte In Bloom or the Tarte Maneater as a neutral palette. The names in maneater might be a little risque, but the ones in In Bloom are not. However, In Bloom is $46 while Maneater is $30 (both sold at Ulta). Id look in stores and see which one she might like best. Maybe even the Bare Minerals palettes with 6 colors? Gen Nudes palettes, I think theyre called. Also, all versions are $30.
What is up with the names of the shadows??? Sexpresso and sexpert. Seriously they could not think of better themes, then again this is the brand with the "better than sex" mascara. Great review as always.
ANA Gama If I remember correctly (someone can correct me if I'm wrong), Sexpresso is a shadow that has been around for years. I think it used to be in one of their duos that they sold way back when. But I agree about the names. It just kind of makes it weird and I'm not a fan of over sexualized names for makeup.
So a year later, I got this for my cousin and I didn’t realize the names of the eyeshadows lol! Oops , hope she doesn’t look at me all crazy for these names lol
I love the new packaging! I’ve never own any of those eyeshadow palettes before, so when I purchased the shimmer one, I absolutely fell in love with it. Perfect everyday eyeshadows, butter smooth and they easily blended out. Really glad I got it.
You are the absolute best beauty RUclipsr, Emily. Honest in the greatest and sweetest way possible, always so informed of the products and you test everything so thoroughly. Your work on your channel is impressive and appreciated. Thank you. Lots of love from Wyoming. Would really enjoy that lip swatch video as well!!
Yes, lip swatches and review please! Love your unbiased reviews. They are always so thoughtful. Sometimes it’s hard to find reviews on work appropriate make up. I love all the fun stuff too but I need to expand my work collection so I can enjoy putting on make up in the morning just as much as I do with all of the fun colors and such on the weekends.
Reading your random thought...I never thought I would care so much for a furry friend. My kids (I have 4) have begged forever to get them one. I finally caved 3 months ago n got them a yellow lab. She is so adorable and loved by all, especially yours truly 😉
This was so helpful! Natural Eyes is a staple palette for me. I was wondering how the new one compared. As always, you were so thorough and thoughtful with your review. Thanks Emily! 💕
I am new to the Too Faced products and love their eyeshadow palettes and this face palette. Since I never had the originals, I really love the packaging of the new palettes; and the products all seem to perform very well. I enjoyed your comparison video and appreciate how informative you are. Thank you.
Emily, I'm always so in awe of how professional you are when describing products. I keep trying to get there myself. When I grow up I want to be an amazing RUclipsr like Emily! Lol. Thank you for reviewing these. I've been wondering, they look so pretty!
The Too Faced palette design is gorgeous. Might want to get the face palette. Not feeling really excited about the eye palettes since I already have a similar existing palette. I do enjoy Too Faced eyeshadows though, and I am a sucker for attractive packaging. Haha.
the old palettes are on nordstrom rack today along with other items that have the old packaging... sun bunny, chocolate bronzers, beach bunny, and pink leopard. i rewatched this video and am so excited to pick the palettes up for only $12!
Awesome video, I have yet to see anyone else review these! I think everyone assumed they were exactly the same, just newer packaging! I always turn to you for accurate, honest & in depth info on products. I know researching all of these things take time quite a bit of effort, so please know it is noticed & appreciated! I would love to see the lipsticks if you feel they are worth swatching. It would also be interesting to hear what you learned and did at the ULTA conference (if you are allowed to talk about it)!! You looked beautiful in your jumpsuits! Thanks again for sharing with us! Love IN..🤗💜
Linda Espinoza It's possible that you won't miss out Linda. I've seen the Natural Mattes/Eyes palette numerous times on discount websites recently, and not knowing about the repackage thing, couldn't understand why. I'm in Australia and I'm not sure if you have the same site available, but surely you have something similar; I'm referring to a website I frequently use called "Catch of the Day", which is a discount website offering often HUGE markdowns on items. I think they bulk buy products which are being discontinued or possibly nearing the end of their 'use by' date. Anyway, I hope this helps. Oh, possibly you can find them on Nordstrom rack (?? not sure I've got the name completely right) but they seem to offer something similar. I saw the Tarte Clay Play Face Shaping Palette, version 1, marked down on there around the time they were releasing the version 2 of that palette. I think you basically sign up for email alerts because they only offer these discounts for a limited time. I'm sorry I'm not more clear on the details but I decided not to follow through with any of their offers because their shipping to Australia made it not worth my time. I hope you find your palette! Cheers, Alison
I got natural eyes for Christmas and it’s my absolute favorite and now I’m CRYING this collection isn’t available! I’m so jealous! Absolutely adore these shadows the formula is amazing and colors so gorgeous- and the pigmentation is amazing. Not to mention the smell ❤️
I have been wanting the natural matte eyeshadow palette and always talked myself out of it. Even after I learned that the palette was changing, it took about a month for me to decide to go ahead and buy it before the older version is out of stock and discontinued. The newer version of the same palette is slowly growing on me but it will be awhile before I would get it. The dusky rose color is my kind of color and that is a selling point for me. Thank you for your reviews!
My second ever high end eyeshadow palette was the natural love palette and I LOVE it! It was just simple, but very thin and sleek cardboard packaging with that BEAUTIFUL springy print and details standing out in velvet, and it’s SO good. I’m obsessed with face palettes and I want the natural face palette so badly!
It is criminal that my girl Emily doesn't have more followers. She really been out here giving us important, accurate information on makeup of all prices ranges. She doesn't mess with passing trends or challenges, just always out here grinding and giving us that tea. GO YOU EM! thank you for the YEARS of content and you still don't mess with petty stuff. sending all the love and support your way. I hope you get more widespread recognition and get some collab deals or something bc I would definitely buy that shit.
You know what I love about your reviews? I love that you go into so much detail, a lot of other youtubers don’t do that. You really put so much effort and dedication into your videos and I love that! I own the original palettes so I won’t be purchasing now thanks to your video. Also I would love to see a video of the lipstick swatches! Thank you!!
Emily, you should do a side by side, one eye with old pallette and one with the new one.i do love your ability to analyze the products, not just this particular one but all the products that you show us. You are so nice to watch. I just love you to pieces. You seem just as beautiful on the inside as on the outside and that is what I've always loved about you. Thank you for taking your time to give us quality, worthwhile material. I live with 3 sons and my husband, so sitting down with you is my 'girlie time' and I always look forward to it. You definitely are, the best of you tube.
Do you think there might be a slight coating on the surface of the new shadows, perhaps needed because of the surface embossing? Maybe once you get into the pans they will behave better. Love the packaging!
I have the face palette and the shimmer eye palette. I was playing around with them last night as I just got them in the mail yesterday. The eye palette doesn't have tons of choices of colours. I got a beautiful eye look from it and it was as good as any youtuber out there. I am not a makeup artist but just a makeup junkie. I found the shadows to be very creamy, felt wonderful, nicely pigmented and a win. The face palette is also very nice. I like the blush, highlighter and bronzer that I used. I give it full marks. I had no fallout on my face from the eye shadow. The smell of the palettes is amazing. I got a whiff in my mother and it tasted good, too. I am not a big Too Faced fan and haven't had a ton of success with them in the past but this is a definite win. If you are on the fence I would say you will probably be very happy with them.
I happened to be browsing through the makeup department at my local TJMaxx this past week and ran across several packages of the original Too Faced Natural Eyes! What a treat having it back in my collection and at a great price point.
Emily, thank you so much for your real, honest reviews. Some influencers sound like they are doing a commercial for products and I always look at those videos with a side eye. Thanks again for being wonderful!
What a great video! You did the best job at comparing the old to the new palettes. It would have been cool to see a demo using the old on one eye and new on the other and using the same "listed" shadows. Anyway, I truly enjoyed this video!
I love the Natural Mattes original version! It's one of my favorites and I've even given it as gifts a couple times too because loved it so much. I also prefer the smaller tin packaging on the original too. Much easier to store... oh well there's so many eyeshadow options out there now it's ok. I won't be purchasing the new version needless to say lol. Thanks for the video!!!
You give us an investigative report on these pallets and I really like that. More information than just a first impression type video. Please don’t change how you review products! As Always Much Love to You 😘💋😍❤️❤️❤️
Thank you so much for this video!! I was worrying about what I’d be missing out on with the newer natural matte palette...after watching this, I’m pretty glad I’ve got the original!
Yayyy! I’ve been waiting for your review on the Too Faced eyeshadow palettes redux! I haven’t been that excited about new Too Faced eyeshadow palettes in a while. My last purchase was their Sweet Peach palette but last real love was the Semi-Sweet palette. I hope their quality doesn’t continue to drop because they truly are my favorite eyeshadow brand. I fee like your Honey Butter is my Tartelette in Bloom’s Smarty Pants. It’s a gorgeous warm transition color that changes my whole eye look. I’m wondering if you feel the same way about that color too. Thank you for the review!
I didn't want to buy (although tempted) anything from this collection without hearing your thoughts. Thank you, Emily. Please do lip swatches. My mother-in-law and I were in Sephora on Friday, and she wanted a rosy-neutral lipstick, and we ended up with UD Vice Sheer Liar. I think the TF Natural Nude Lipstick would be such a cute little gift for her too.
I am not the biggest natural lover and didn’t own the old palettes but found the old natural mattes at TJ Maxx and am excited to seemingly have the better formula for less than half the price! Thanks for the comparison!
Thank you so much for doing this. I've been eyeing this collection but needed to hear from you whether you liked it or not (not all RUclipsrs are as honest as you are)
Satin Sheets is my all time favorite all over eyeshadow from from toofaced. I had an old discontinued palette and was heart broken until the boudoir eyes palette brought it back! I was a little surprised when I saw it as a highlight. I used to use it as a highlight though way back in the day when I first got hard core into makeup my jr. Year.
Alina A - it is! Thank you for reminding of that palette! I just pulled it put and I LOVE LOVE LOVE it! I don't know how it got pushed to the back ~ probably all of the new palettes I just •have• to have lol! I'm going to use my boudoir eyes much more often now 💄💟
Ah I am so happy you did a review of these revamps! All the questions I had about the new launch were answered! I definitely miss the OG boxed eye palettes from Too Faced!
I used to have the tin packaged natural eyes palette and some shades I loved, others lacked pigment (the cream shade) I gave it away. Loved the gold flecked brown shade. It was my first high end palette. Ahh those were the days!
The original Natural Matte pallet is my favorite and have hit pan on several of the colors. I’m not loving the purple replacement colors. This was a great side by side review, answered all my questions! Yes to a lip swatch video 💄💋
I've been on the fence about the lippies - I'd love to see the shades for comparison purposes AND to know how creamy and comfortable they are. Yes please!!
Natural Face is a re-do also. It's been a number of years. I have one, mostly cream products, now is pretty much unusable and smells like clay! But do an image search in google if you're curious about it. What it looks like with the new palettes is that they don't STACK, and that's a definite minus.
Seriously APPRECIATE how thorough you are with your videos! Very well informed, executed to perfection, honestly love your videos! Great job Emily 👌👌👌 ❤️
I would love to see the lipsticks swatched! Thanks so much for your honest review. I went and quickly got my hands on the original palette before it was gone forever!
Emily you always do such a good review. The swatch tip about the spreadabiity of the shadow and it's meaning really is helpful. I had not thought about that. I think I would like the original better but the packaging is better. Those lipsticks look lovely. I would love to see a video swatch on those.
You definitely gave me some things to think about regarding these pallets. So informative. Thank you!. I can't wait to see what you have to say about the lip collection!
I love how you put so much love and heart for your review. When I can respectfully disagree your opinion about the new Natural Eyes (with the matte and shimmer), I feel like it worked lovely on me and I loved it just the same with the version 2 one. I love you so much. ❤️
Emily I watched the video when you left the TV station the other day as it randomly popped into my RUclips feed!! It made me cry a bit, everyone was super sweet in their farewell wishes. It also made me laugh because I thought it was hilarious you had them all doing chipmunk faces back then. 😂
The original cardboard natural eyes palette was the first "real" palette I got back when I was 11 years old and it started my love for makeup. To this day, I still love it the most of all the too faced palettes and I'll pull it out occasionally for old times sake.
My first palette ever was the natural eyes in the cardboard box. I still have it and use it. There were 2 glittery colors that I hate. Glad 1 was taken out. I want to see the bronzers in another video.
You share the most USEFUL information for me thanks so much. I don’t purchase TF products anymore, but I enjoyed watching this whole video. That’s a testament to you! Look forward to whatever comes next. Blessings.
Following Stephanie Marie led me to you. I really enjoyed this video, the clear comparisons you made, and the clarity you used. I will continue to follow. Thanks 👍
How could anyone thumbs down a video from Emily?! I'll never understand it. I find it funny that the "haters" don't realize that they are still helping. YT doesn't count it as good or bad they count it as interaction...that's a good thing! 😂😂 Thank you for reviewing these palettes for us Emily. I've been curious about these but haven't seen anyone I trust 100% give their opinion of them. You, I trust 100% with everything. I love you Emily
Luanne Santos I weeded out everyone I don’t trust 100% in my subscription list. 😂 Emily and JenLuvsReviews are some of the most honest larger influencers on RUclips. 💜
Luanne Santos My theory is that the thumbs down (because they appear so darn fast) are from other YTers who are jealous of Emily's ethical & honest approach to reviews, and her original ideas. While the "big names" are taking money to promote companies and being overly dramatic with silly tags, Emily is a rock. Plus she has the most loyal fans on the planet - maybe even the universe - if I lived on Jupiter, I'd totally watch her shop her Caboodle.
Too Faced does have beautiful packaging, it draws you in. But, thank you, Emily, for your honesty. Every video you make, I buy what you like, and I skip what you aren't wowed by. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!! Ooops, forgot to say, yes please on the lip swatches!!
The Natural Eyes Palette is actually version #3---the original was in cardboard packaging. The tin packaging is version #2 and has different shades than the original #1.
Loved your review. The natural palatte was one of my first high end makeup purchases Except for Lancôme when I was in my 20s to 40 I didn't discover you tube beauty until at least 5+ years later. I don't even know why I chose it. But it was s great palatte then and I got it out and used it after your video. I kind of wish I could get a replacement for my original one after your review. The face palatte is so beautiful and I was attracted to it right away. Maybe for Mother's Day?
I bought the Face palette and the Overexposed shade in the new lipstick line IMMEDIATELY when it launched and I am not disappointed! I love them! I will probably pick up the Natural Eyes palette because I gave away the older version to a good friend and I'm a sucker for packaging lol. Thanks for anotber great video Emily❤
![SahBabii - Viking [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/D37cL92JX0I/mqdefault.jpg)
Lip swatches: yes please! This video was very informative and well done, thank you 👌
If I was shopping ONLY by swatches (NO PACKAGING TO DISTRACT ME), and you showed me those on your arm....I'd TOTALLY choose the originals. It just goes to show how motivated we, the consumers, are by pretty packaging. Too Faced KNEW that and so they used pretty packaging to try and renew interest in an older product.
P.S. Although the outer packaging is undeniably beautiful, I actually hate a shiny gold inner palette. It not only detracts from the shadows, but it also just looks "cheap-y" to me. I'll keep my old "Natural Eyes" tin thank you, Too Faced 😘
Heather Elana okay well ...the inside packaging TOO then lol 😉
Heather Elana Yes, I love the small versions because rheir size is so travel friendly
I REALLY LOVE the new colors that are BETTER versions of the old TOO warm/orange/deep that are now SO much prettier!! They are MORE wearable and REALLY look more natural and like nude/neutral shades. I get SO tired of SO many brands ruining palettes with all the orange/"terracotta" or too deep murky colors that LOOK like TOO much and you can never get a NATURALLY PRETTY look with them. I for one am SO glad they improved those old (overused and obvious) colors. I have the old palettes and am SO happy they finally made something that is AS PROMISED, NEUTRAL/NATURAL colors. NOT everyone wants OBVIOUS , noticeable color but like instead to just look NATURALLY ENHANCED AND PRETTY. THANK you TOO FACED for the improvements!
Please please please swatches of all those lipsticks....I bought 'pout about it' thinking it was pinkish...but turned out to be a browny shade
The original natural matte is my absolute favorite all matte palette!! Bummed that they switched it up 😔
Patrice Bailey The original Natural Mattes has my favorite shadows of all time which makes me dread when I have to replace it. :(
Same! Also, Honey Butter is my favorite shade, hands down, so I'm so sad they let it go. I'm close to panning it and idk what I'll do when it runs out. Probs buy a single if available/dupe if not because I can't justify rebuying the palette just for one shade, honestly.
My sentiments exactly! Why change something that is so perfect! The Natural Mattes is an all time favorite of mine. I need a hands on look at these now before buying. I’m glad I waited for Emily’s review. 😊. The lipsticks are beautiful though!
Ana R. I may have to troll Ebay and see if I can find another one of the original. :(
Does anyone know if these are scented?
I got the old Natural Matte at TJ Maxx for $15. Be on the lookout. I actually like the smaller tin packaging. I don't like the new gold interior. I just prefer a smaller palette. I'm going to use it for travel. As a cool tone lover I most certainly love the original! You are right Emily, the new one is so ordinary.
I really appreciate how you get really detailed at times. It helps me get better technique. Thank you
You are so articulate and just fantastic when it comes to reviewing products! I understand everything well, even though English isn’t my first language (but I do love the language so much, it’s like my second language), and your videos are so well thought off.
I personally like the shades in the new palette, because I’m very fair and have blue eyes so I feel like the new palette would suit my eyes more. I don’t know. I didn’t try the old shadows though. But I’m definitely going to get the new Natural Matte palette because I need new brown matte shades for every day use. :)
Thanks for the video, Emily!
I always wanted the Natural Matte palette but never got around to picking it up, now I probably never will. I prefered the old colors better. Oh well, the last thing I need is more makeup.
Amy Louwho same here
I had it on my wl for a long time,I wanted to hit the pan on my UD basic 1 which I do not adore,I am using it but I wouldn't buy it again..and now I don't know what to do..definitely not be buying the new version..maybe I'll just buy new milani matte palatte instead , it has so many great reviews (both of them )
same...i've not yet own any too faced palette (though i love their estetics) it seems everytime i'm trying to buy from them i didnt end up buying them at all 🤣..palette wise i mean... i still prefer my juvias place and colourpop palette 😎😎..
I was just about to settle on that palette as my first neutral palette, but then the tarte in bloom palette released literally days before I was gonna pull the trigger! I love my tarte palette, despite recent tarte brand drama.
Last unicorn Yes, the new Milani palettes look amazing and I do love my mattes. As much as I don't care for Wal-Mart I'll probably get it there because it's $15 instead of 20. Thank you for reminding me that I can get those 2 and have money left over! 😉
manic hispanic really? Is it on their website still? Cause God forbid I should just go look myself. Lol
Ohhhhhh I've been very curious about this collection! So happy that YOU reviewed it bc i know I can genuinely rely on what you say about products. Thank you!!! Xoxo
Okay - this might be me being silly, but I am kind of tired of makeup brands using "raunchy" names like sexpert or strip poker or, more famously, orgasm. Not because I personally care but because it means that I can't give this to my traditional grandmother (she'd have a heart attack) or to my younger relatives. Plus it is overdone shock value marketing.
Melissa Stephan I hate the names too.
I agree. Not only that, but it puts me off the whole product sometimes; ie if the name is such a gimmick then the whole product might be too.
Me too, I'd never buy it for my younger sister because of this, even though I've been wanting to get her a nice, neutral palette. (She's 14)
@@kpeacock22 I love my Tarte In Bloom or the Tarte Maneater as a neutral palette. The names in maneater might be a little risque, but the ones in In Bloom are not. However, In Bloom is $46 while Maneater is $30 (both sold at Ulta). Id look in stores and see which one she might like best. Maybe even the Bare Minerals palettes with 6 colors? Gen Nudes palettes, I think theyre called. Also, all versions are $30.
What is up with the names of the shadows??? Sexpresso and sexpert. Seriously they could not think of better themes, then again this is the brand with the "better than sex" mascara.
Great review as always.
Ha! exactly. The names didn't impress me... and at the same time didn't surprise me either!
ANA Gama If I remember correctly (someone can correct me if I'm wrong), Sexpresso is a shadow that has been around for years. I think it used to be in one of their duos that they sold way back when. But I agree about the names. It just kind of makes it weird and I'm not a fan of over sexualized names for makeup.
I can just imagine little kids being around, and some that love to read everything, reading that and wondering what it means. Cringeworthy
I could have done without the sexy names myself.
So a year later, I got this for my cousin and I didn’t realize the names of the eyeshadows lol! Oops , hope she doesn’t look at me all crazy for these names lol
I love the new packaging! I’ve never own any of those eyeshadow palettes before, so when I purchased the shimmer one, I absolutely fell in love with it. Perfect everyday eyeshadows, butter smooth and they easily blended out. Really glad I got it.
Milica Marsha Stefanovich me too! Love it!
You are the absolute best beauty RUclipsr, Emily. Honest in the greatest and sweetest way possible, always so informed of the products and you test everything so thoroughly. Your work on your channel is impressive and appreciated. Thank you. Lots of love from Wyoming. Would really enjoy that lip swatch video as well!!
Yes, lip swatches and review please! Love your unbiased reviews. They are always so thoughtful. Sometimes it’s hard to find reviews on work appropriate make up. I love all the fun stuff too but I need to expand my work collection so I can enjoy putting on make up in the morning just as much as I do with all of the fun colors and such on the weekends.
Reading your random thought...I never thought I would care so much for a furry friend. My kids (I have 4) have begged forever to get them one. I finally caved 3 months ago n got them a yellow lab. She is so adorable and loved by all, especially yours truly 😉
Also, I can't believe they got rid of Nudie in both palettes... That's such a great contouring color for the crease.
Alex H right?! Nudie is the BEST transition/crease shade. I’ve hit pan on mine and now can’t replace it! 😢
Total y agreed! Love New package but prefer the old shadows! 😕
Millie Ortiz-Estrella .... Yes old shadows were DEFINITELY BETTER!!!
This was so helpful! Natural Eyes is a staple palette for me. I was wondering how the new one compared. As always, you were so thorough and thoughtful with your review. Thanks Emily! 💕
I am new to the Too Faced products and love their eyeshadow palettes and this face palette. Since I never had the originals, I really love the packaging of the new palettes; and the products all seem to perform very well. I enjoyed your comparison video and appreciate how informative you are. Thank you.
Emily, I'm always so in awe of how professional you are when describing products. I keep trying to get there myself. When I grow up I want to be an amazing RUclipsr like Emily! Lol. Thank you for reviewing these. I've been wondering, they look so pretty!
I've been binge watching all of your old videos all morning ♡
The Too Faced palette design is gorgeous. Might want to get the face palette. Not feeling really excited about the eye palettes since I already have a similar existing palette. I do enjoy Too Faced eyeshadows though, and I am a sucker for attractive packaging. Haha.
the old palettes are on nordstrom rack today along with other items that have the old packaging... sun bunny, chocolate bronzers, beach bunny, and pink leopard. i rewatched this video and am so excited to pick the palettes up for only $12!
Awesome video, I have yet to see anyone else review these! I think everyone assumed they were exactly the same, just newer packaging! I always turn to you for accurate, honest & in depth info on products. I know researching all of these things take time quite a bit of effort, so please know it is noticed & appreciated! I would love to see the lipsticks if you feel they are worth swatching. It would also be interesting to hear what you learned and did at the ULTA conference (if you are allowed to talk about it)!! You looked beautiful in your jumpsuits! Thanks again for sharing with us! Love IN..🤗💜
Rebecca Ude I totally assumed it was the same just repackaged. Bummer. I always wanted to pick up natural mattes and now I’m missing out.
Linda Espinoza It's possible that you won't miss out Linda. I've seen the Natural Mattes/Eyes palette numerous times on discount websites recently, and not knowing about the repackage thing, couldn't understand why. I'm in Australia and I'm not sure if you have the same site available, but surely you have something similar; I'm referring to a website I frequently use called "Catch of the Day", which is a discount website offering often HUGE markdowns on items. I think they bulk buy products which are being discontinued or possibly nearing the end of their 'use by' date. Anyway, I hope this helps. Oh, possibly you can find them on Nordstrom rack (?? not sure I've got the name completely right) but they seem to offer something similar. I saw the Tarte Clay Play Face Shaping Palette, version 1, marked down on there around the time they were releasing the version 2 of that palette. I think you basically sign up for email alerts because they only offer these discounts for a limited time. I'm sorry I'm not more clear on the details but I decided not to follow through with any of their offers because their shipping to Australia made it not worth my time.
I hope you find your palette! Cheers, Alison
Rebecca Ude in
Omg please do a lip swatch no one else has done it and I really wanna see it!
I still have natural eyes in the cardboard box. It was my fav eyeshadow palette ever!
Classic!!
I'm all for natural makeup. Love neutral and warm tones for eye makeup so I might consider buying Too Faced, the packaging is so beautiful ❤
I got natural eyes for Christmas and it’s my absolute favorite and now I’m CRYING this collection isn’t available! I’m so jealous! Absolutely adore these shadows the formula is amazing and colors so gorgeous- and the pigmentation is amazing. Not to mention the smell ❤️
I have been wanting the natural matte eyeshadow palette and always talked myself out of it. Even after I learned that the palette was changing, it took about a month for me to decide to go ahead and buy it before the older version is out of stock and discontinued. The newer version of the same palette is slowly growing on me but it will be awhile before I would get it. The dusky rose color is my kind of color and that is a selling point for me. Thank you for your reviews!
Your descriptions are amazingly detailed. Seriously! I’m in awe.
My second ever high end eyeshadow palette was the natural love palette and I LOVE it! It was just simple, but very thin and sleek cardboard packaging with that BEAUTIFUL springy print and details standing out in velvet, and it’s SO good.
I’m obsessed with face palettes and I want the natural face palette so badly!
While the packaging is quite pretty, I'm not fond of some of the shadow names.
Thank you so much for explaining the “drag technique” on the swatches to figure out how well it blends. It was super helpful.
Please have Tyler do some more unboxing, he's hilarious! 😁
I really like the natural face palette! Very surprised by the highlights. I think this will be great in the summer. When I’m more tanned
Yali Perez did the scent hit you hard?
It is criminal that my girl Emily doesn't have more followers. She really been out here giving us important, accurate information on makeup of all prices ranges. She doesn't mess with passing trends or challenges, just always out here grinding and giving us that tea. GO YOU EM! thank you for the YEARS of content and you still don't mess with petty stuff. sending all the love and support your way. I hope you get more widespread recognition and get some collab deals or something bc I would definitely buy that shit.
You know what I love about your reviews? I love that you go into so much detail, a lot of other youtubers don’t do that. You really put so much effort and dedication into your videos and I love that! I own the original palettes so I won’t be purchasing now thanks to your video. Also I would love to see a video of the lipstick swatches! Thank you!!
Please review the new Kokie Cosmetics artistry palettes! They have them available on their website and they look gorgeously colorful
sincerelyalex Yessss I saw them at my Walmart recently and I’m so curious about them!
Emily, you should do a side by side, one eye with old pallette and one with the new one.i do love your ability to analyze the products, not just this particular one but all the products that you show us. You are so nice to watch. I just love you to pieces. You seem just as beautiful on the inside as on the outside and that is what I've always loved about you. Thank you for taking your time to give us quality, worthwhile material. I live with 3 sons and my husband, so sitting down with you is my 'girlie time' and I always look forward to it. You definitely are, the best of you tube.
Do you think there might be a slight coating on the surface of the new shadows, perhaps needed because of the surface embossing? Maybe once you get into the pans they will behave better. Love the packaging!
I have the face palette and the shimmer eye palette. I was playing around with them last night as I just got them in the mail yesterday. The eye palette doesn't have tons of choices of colours. I got a beautiful eye look from it and it was as good as any youtuber out there. I am not a makeup artist but just a makeup junkie. I found the shadows to be very creamy, felt wonderful, nicely pigmented and a win. The face palette is also very nice. I like the blush, highlighter and bronzer that I used. I give it full marks. I had no fallout on my face from the eye shadow. The smell of the palettes is amazing. I got a whiff in my mother and it tasted good, too. I am not a big Too Faced fan and haven't had a ton of success with them in the past but this is a definite win. If you are on the fence I would say you will probably be very happy with them.
🙏🏻please do a lip swatch video!!!!!
I happened to be browsing through the makeup department at my local TJMaxx this past week and ran across several packages of the original Too Faced Natural Eyes! What a treat having it back in my collection and at a great price point.
You really are the best at what you do! Everyone loves you! The epitome of RUclips! What it should be and what it stands for!
Emily, thank you so much for your real, honest reviews. Some influencers sound like they are doing a commercial for products and I always look at those videos with a side eye. Thanks again for being wonderful!
Do you think you can do full face with face palette? Use some colors on eyes as well.
i definitely could!
SO thankful for this video!!! Been waiting for a trustworthy review!
What a great video! You did the best job at comparing the old to the new palettes. It would have been cool to see a demo using the old on one eye and new on the other and using the same "listed" shadows. Anyway, I truly enjoyed this video!
I love the Natural Mattes original version! It's one of my favorites and I've even given it as gifts a couple times too because loved it so much. I also prefer the smaller tin packaging on the original too. Much easier to store... oh well there's so many eyeshadow options out there now it's ok. I won't be purchasing the new version needless to say lol. Thanks for the video!!!
You give us an investigative report on these pallets and I really like that. More information than just a first impression type video. Please don’t change how you review products! As Always Much Love to You 😘💋😍❤️❤️❤️
I absolutely LOVE the face palette and both of the new eyeshadow palettes. I get compliments every time I use them. So pretty!
Thank you so much for this video!! I was worrying about what I’d be missing out on with the newer natural matte palette...after watching this, I’m pretty glad I’ve got the original!
I have to make it official. You are the best reviewer. So thorough and thoughtful. Thanks.
Yayyy! I’ve been waiting for your review on the Too Faced eyeshadow palettes redux!
I haven’t been that excited about new Too Faced eyeshadow palettes in a while. My last purchase was their Sweet Peach palette but last real love was the Semi-Sweet palette. I hope their quality doesn’t continue to drop because they truly are my favorite eyeshadow brand.
I fee like your Honey Butter is my Tartelette in Bloom’s Smarty Pants. It’s a gorgeous warm transition color that changes my whole eye look. I’m wondering if you feel the same way about that color too.
Thank you for the review!
I didn't want to buy (although tempted) anything from this collection without hearing your thoughts. Thank you, Emily. Please do lip swatches. My mother-in-law and I were in Sephora on Friday, and she wanted a rosy-neutral lipstick, and we ended up with UD Vice Sheer Liar. I think the TF Natural Nude Lipstick would be such a cute little gift for her too.
I am not the biggest natural lover and didn’t own the old palettes but found the old natural mattes at TJ Maxx and am excited to seemingly have the better formula for less than half the price! Thanks for the comparison!
Thank you so much for doing this. I've been eyeing this collection but needed to hear from you whether you liked it or not (not all RUclipsrs are as honest as you are)
I'm sick in bed so this is exactly what I needed!
Hope you feel better soon!
Satin Sheets is my all time favorite all over eyeshadow from from toofaced. I had an old discontinued palette and was heart broken until the boudoir eyes palette brought it back! I was a little surprised when I saw it as a highlight. I used to use it as a highlight though way back in the day when I first got hard core into makeup my jr. Year.
I got the Natural face Palette when Macy's had their beauty sale and I am obsessed!!! It's SO pigmented and beautiful. ❤️💗🙌🏼
I think "satin sheets" is an eyeshadow in the "boudoir eyes" palettes
Alina A - it is! Thank you for reminding of that palette! I just pulled it put and I LOVE LOVE LOVE it! I don't know how it got pushed to the back ~ probably all of the new palettes I just •have• to have lol! I'm going to use my boudoir eyes much more often now 💄💟
Ah I am so happy you did a review of these revamps! All the questions I had about the new launch were answered! I definitely miss the OG boxed eye palettes from Too Faced!
I used to have the tin packaged natural eyes palette and some shades I loved, others lacked pigment (the cream shade) I gave it away. Loved the gold flecked brown shade. It was my first high end palette. Ahh those were the days!
I just got the Natural Matte palette.
That natural packaging really is gorgeous, especially when all shown together.
The original Natural Matte pallet is my favorite and have hit pan on several of the colors. I’m not loving the purple replacement colors. This was a great side by side review, answered all my questions! Yes to a lip swatch video 💄💋
loved your explanation of swatching eyeshadows to see how well it'll move that was super helpful thanks!!
I've been on the fence about the lippies - I'd love to see the shades for comparison purposes AND to know how creamy and comfortable they are. Yes please!!
Yes.. Would love a video with the lip swatches and bronzers please. I have never tried too faced bronzers, and so I'm curious about them...🤔
Natural Face is a re-do also. It's been a number of years. I have one, mostly cream products, now is pretty much unusable and smells like clay! But do an image search in google if you're curious about it. What it looks like with the new palettes is that they don't STACK, and that's a definite minus.
I have an original natural eyes in a cardboard box. This is a 3rd go round on the pallet. Thank you for showing us.
I'm so glad you said the tropic like it's hot shade is not a bronzer cause I tried it that way and was horrified!! Will definitely try as a blush!!
Seriously APPRECIATE how thorough you are with your videos! Very well informed, executed to perfection, honestly love your videos! Great job Emily 👌👌👌 ❤️
I would love to see the lipsticks swatched! Thanks so much for your honest review. I went and quickly got my hands on the original palette before it was gone forever!
Will you do a video on how to work with big pores or textured skin ? Maybe do a skin care favorites video ?
Emily you always do such a good review. The swatch tip about the spreadabiity of the shadow and it's meaning really is helpful. I had not thought about that. I think I would like the original better but the packaging is better. Those lipsticks look lovely. I would love to see a video swatch on those.
I like the colors in the new matte palette so much more, they’re much much more flattering on me. Love the new packaging so much more as well.
You definitely gave me some things to think about regarding these pallets. So informative. Thank you!. I can't wait to see what you have to say about the lip collection!
I love how you put so much love and heart for your review. When I can respectfully disagree your opinion about the new Natural Eyes (with the matte and shimmer), I feel like it worked lovely on me and I loved it just the same with the version 2 one. I love you so much. ❤️
I love that you take the time to compare and the in depth info you give us. Emily you are the best!!
Emily I watched the video when you left the TV station the other day as it randomly popped into my RUclips feed!! It made me cry a bit, everyone was super sweet in their farewell wishes. It also made me laugh because I thought it was hilarious you had them all doing chipmunk faces back then. 😂
A. M. I just watched that yesterday. It appeared on my feed too. It was sweet and sad.
The original cardboard natural eyes palette was the first "real" palette I got back when I was 11 years old and it started my love for makeup. To this day, I still love it the most of all the too faced palettes and I'll pull it out occasionally for old times sake.
I like the Natural Eyes palette. It’s like a basic. I also like that the shimmers aren’t too over the top.
I love the way these look so much! I'd never pay that much for a palette, but I like seeing them.
Such a great video. I really appreciate all of your attention to detail! Wish I could get my hands on the "old" version of the natural eyes pallette.
Best detailed and down to the core honest reviews - thank Emily you are the best!
My first palette ever was the natural eyes in the cardboard box. I still have it and use it. There were 2 glittery colors that I hate. Glad 1 was taken out. I want to see the bronzers in another video.
OMG I love this collection! I already have the Sunny Bunny Bronzer but that Natural Face Palette is to die for! I Love your channel! you're gorgeous!
You share the most USEFUL information for me thanks so much. I don’t purchase TF products anymore, but I enjoyed watching this whole video. That’s a testament to you! Look forward to whatever comes next. Blessings.
Following Stephanie Marie led me to you. I really enjoyed this video, the clear comparisons you made, and the clarity you used. I will continue to follow. Thanks 👍
How could anyone thumbs down a video from Emily?! I'll never understand it. I find it funny that the "haters" don't realize that they are still helping. YT doesn't count it as good or bad they count it as interaction...that's a good thing! 😂😂
Thank you for reviewing these palettes for us Emily. I've been curious about these but haven't seen anyone I trust 100% give their opinion of them. You, I trust 100% with everything. I love you Emily
Luanne Santos I weeded out everyone I don’t trust 100% in my subscription list. 😂 Emily and JenLuvsReviews are some of the most honest larger influencers on RUclips. 💜
Luanne Santos My theory is that the thumbs down (because they appear so darn fast) are from other YTers who are jealous of Emily's ethical & honest approach to reviews, and her original ideas. While the "big names" are taking money to promote companies and being overly dramatic with silly tags, Emily is a rock. Plus she has the most loyal fans on the planet - maybe even the universe - if I lived on Jupiter, I'd totally watch her shop her Caboodle.
I started to think that some of the thumbs down come from people not liking the product or the brand, instead of not liking the video itself.
Authenticity makes others feel threatened. Emily is simply amazing
Luanne Santos I
Aww, love the old Cashmere bunny color! Hit pan on my current Natural Matte palette, so will enjoy it while I can.... Thanks for your take on this!
Too Faced does have beautiful packaging, it draws you in. But, thank you, Emily, for your honesty. Every video you make, I buy what you like, and I skip what you aren't wowed by. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!! Ooops, forgot to say, yes please on the lip swatches!!
The Natural Eyes Palette is actually version #3---the original was in cardboard packaging. The tin packaging is version #2 and has different shades than the original #1.
Loved your review. The natural palatte was one of my first high end makeup purchases
Except for Lancôme when I was in my 20s to 40
I didn't discover you tube beauty until at least 5+ years later. I don't even know why I chose it. But it was s great palatte then and I got it out and used it after your video. I kind of wish I could get a replacement for my original one after your review. The face palatte is so beautiful and I was attracted to it right away. Maybe for Mother's Day?
Thanks for the in depth comparison between the old and the new eyeshadow palettes. I would actually love to see a swatch video on the new lipsticks 💋💄
I’d love to see a video with swatches of the new lipsticks. The more info, the better!! Thank you 😊
I bought the Face palette and the Overexposed shade in the new lipstick line IMMEDIATELY when it launched and I am not disappointed! I love them! I will probably pick up the Natural Eyes palette because I gave away the older version to a good friend and I'm a sucker for packaging lol. Thanks for anotber great video Emily❤
Thank you for the fantastic review! 💗 I'm sad that the eye palettes fell short but I appreciate your honesty as always!