Less locations, RUclipsrs hardly anyone knows, forced agendas and shitty music result in the 2018 disaster. Can't wait to see how they somehow make it worse in 2019, assuming they even make one
It genuinely breaks my heart that this is where RUclips has ended up. There’s no creatives, just personalities trying to be rich. I miss the sketches and the authenticity of it all
I honestly think that is one of the reasons why TikTok has been blowing up. It feels like it is bringing back the DIY feeling of very early RUclips and YT now feels like highly-produced old media TV.
They aren’t even “personalities” anymore just empty husks of the people they used to be or sell their souls to the devil and make bad videos for a living
*Exclusively youtubers, they do have channels, but some of them are not as impactful as a certian person who wasn't invited... And the rest are litteraly unknown
Detached silicon valley companies pushing their political agendas and narrative. did you expect them not to waste money on something no one wants or will actually like? Even the 'journalists' and influencer parasites don't really like what they shill for....
Yep, pretty much what I thought too. The rest is just whatever they pulled out of their asses, most important memes and youtubers from the year are not even there! And half the video is to talk about LGBT stuff and how cultures are supposedly stopping to be oppressed. Just plain political crap pretty much.
Hopz not really most viners actually loved making things that would be controversial now adays... but then the advocates hit and youtube wanted to turn all corporate.
They also just shot themselves in the foot by framing the whole thing as "what would happen if the people controlled Rewind" and then giving the people the exact opposite of what they wanted lmfao
You never know. Could have been the group that put it together longed for the old days & knew the approving executives were so clueless they'd never see it right before their own eyes.
@Rekken and Yu Yea yea just keep trashtalking... I can't wait for next rewind, to prove you were wrong! OF COURSE THEY CAN DO WORSE! I still believe in RUclips if you don't... 😌
RUclips doesn't put RUclipsrs in their RUclips rewind. They put celebrities, twitch streamers and the same people year after year. At least there was plenty of animators
That girl in the cart hasn't uploaded in almost a year and superwoman took a break for mental problems then pushed her merch about how "humble she was" i think we can all agree youtube rewind was full of top notch youtubers
@@flossyjay7280 the use of the word 'gay' was unnecessary and hateful towards gay people. Now I understand there's free speech and all but there's other words that would convey the meaning better, and would not offend a mass amount of people. I would greatly appreciate if you consider changing the word gay to something else.
What i dont understand, these youtubers who were not mentioned should do their own! Rewind! Put in on pewdiepie channel and that would be the ultimate frrruck u to RUclips
@@aoifek9709 holy shit.. Thats so sad... Kinda funny how white guys are in minority in rewind, but they are biggest group on the yt... It feels like so wrong......
Because collaborations are supposed to be FUN, which the rewind ultimately lacks completely. Everyone there was just working for a paycheck, not having fun making videos with friends.
@@guidetoanything if im not mistaken from emma blackery's video about the last rewind she did (2016? 15?) They didnt get paid. They were there standing in the cold waiting to pour and play with slime in the middle of nowhere and she said they weren't being paid for it. It was voluntary.
@@Dany_lop Damn that's even worse, I figured at least the youtubers were paid to be in it. I would assume with things like the 2012-2013 ones they were fun and youtube just covered production so people volunteered and were fine with it so they just kept it that way.
Funny how that’s almost directly, RIGHT before YoTube went to shit in many ways... unfair, stupid, and unannounced major changes to the algorithm and site design that everyone hated, the beginning of “fascist China RUclips” where they censor those they disagree with, constant pressure to force 50% diversity hires when the pool of women in tech, for example, is 1/20 that of men and it’s literally impossible to meet the “sexist/racist’’ quotas, and obviously extremely unfair... the list goes on. She’s cancer and an embarrassment to women CEOs and directly damaging women’s rights by being outlandish and extremist (and directly, unabashedly promoting dis-equality as the new goal of feminism, because diversity quotas are nothing but racism and sexism in policy form, like Harvard only allowing a certain number of Asians into the school so they don’t dominate the student population), and causing the other side to backlash. UGH!
Remember when the biggest RUclipsr on the platform and the face of the company made anti-Semitic jokes and went around using the 'N' word which eventually led to the Adpocalypse and RUclips becoming super-PG? Honestly, why isn't anyone calling out PewDiePie for ruining RUclips for everyone else?
That’s what happens when you put a Jew at the head of something. They’ll try to work in their agenda into it. Even my boy h3h3, he’s been a sneaky Jew from time to time. He had that money grab mobile app, but I can’t blame him
More like in a comatose state where all we can do is grieve for the good old times. If Google didn't buy RUclips, I bet Microsoft would have. If either of them hadn't bought RUclips, I bet Yahoo!, Facebook, or Myspace would have.
It looked to me like one of the dysfunctional chicken dances from the original "Arrested Development" series. I wonder if Fortnite lifted it from that. I feel like Arrested Development parodies are more John Oliver's speed.
I wonder when RUclips will understand how lost they are. They successfully produced the most hated video on the site. Maybe karma for all the crap they have been landing on producers for the last few years.
Its kinda hilarious though.. "Give a moment to the people who put aside their differences" - Meanwhile in the youtube comment sections. Either they have no clue what's going on or they are trying their best to suppress/ignore it to death, i'm guessing the latter.
*Do people not know that the dead man Logan filmed wasn't even real? It was an actor & Matty Debunk exposed this so Logan actually didn't do anything wronh coz it's fake...*
RUclips has forgotten what they were all about. A place for amateurs to share videos they made with the masses. Now it's been commercialised, the community is dead.
James Lovejoy the community isn’t dead it’s just more of a spectator then a broadcaster these days everyone likes a good witch hunt but it isn’t healthy to only thrive on the negativity
@Foxtrot It's not just about money. The ranking algorithms for search results and suggested videos heavily favour channels that upload consistently (such that it's their full-time job). This crowds out new content creators who have little to no hope of their content getting noticed.
The saddest part is, RUclips and its executives probably concluded that the millions of downvotes are from _"alt-right trolls"_ and actually thinks they nailed Rewind this year.
agreed, it's starting to become very PC and safe much like tv. I don't mind that but the beauty about youtube is YOU choose what to watch and what is recommended. If you don't like raunchy stuff you can tailor it to what you like. But now youtube is forcing all the more risky youtubers off the platform because they want it like tv because that's what corporate people like. tasteless, generic, and bland.
Fake Name I can say with pretty good confidence that it’s a mistake to think their data model is detailed enough to make specific judgements about content.
@@JoeJoe-lq6bd sorry dude, but they absolutely have to capabilities, meta user data collection and exploitation is absolutely worth its weight in platinum, especially to commercialized operations like RUclips (and Google at large, FaceBook, your internet and mobile service providers, advertising companies, the literal government, etc.)
all the raunchy youtubers need to make a youtube rewind. we need one with codyko, h3h3, idubbbz, danny gonzalez, & more. GMM even stepped out of youtube rewind bc it’s cringey and they’re literally in their 40s in a PG show. we want a youtube rewind with good youtubers!!!
I recognize Ninja, but only because he has that hair and I've seen him in memes where he loses control and screams at people. Also, I might see Lele "I'm latina!" Pons on the right, but I'm not sure, cause the image has been photoshopped/filtered to death, and it mostly looks like a generic instagram "comedian" girl, so it really could be anybody. Edit: Why is that one guy cosplaying as Johnny Depp?
@@johnnyboi331 RUclips is pretty damn popular, they are not small, because they are at the top of one of the biggest thing, the internet. So for them to be something else they are not is damn retarded, not because they are small, but they forget their identity
@@johnnyboi331 if you want to talk companies then youtube is owned alphabet which is the third biggest company following amazon and apple U realize youtube is owned by google a search engine whos name is synonymous with searching for anything on the internet?
The 2013 RUclips Rewind had a soul. The 2018 one doesn’t. That’s the difference. RUclips shouldn’t endlessly pander to try and be emotional. If they’d appeal to people’s nostalgia instead like they did in 2013 by creating something that’s actually true to the events and trends of that year, then it becomes timeless. Losing sight of heart in favor of money has backfired for them in every way possible.
That pandering thing i think is very politically motivated in the section where they talk about drag, women, asians and things that are more politically biased. We don't want political shit, we want entertainment.
This years rewind was so ironic. On the one hand, they're emphasizing *diversity* and basically saying _"everyone is a part, no matter how strange you are"_ , and _"It takes a lot of bravery to be that vulnurable"_ . On the other; they actually play it extremely safely to make themselves invulnerable, and only show the mainstream shit.
Also, the fricking people started narrating shit for forever... Instead of just featuring the people they were talking about... Tell a story through music and video instead of just TALKING.
Most people can agree they pretty much did it to avoid embarrassment of what some creators done in the past and tried to sell themselves to advertisers, but man being the soon to be most disliked video on your own platform is a million times more embarrassing than any creator you could have put in.
@@capablanc Yes, I'm sure he got those subscribers because of the quality of his videos and not because he's fucking WILL SMITH. I mean, he probably could have not posted any videos and get near a million sub.
Well, Jaiden Animations threw one back at them by putting Pewd's chair in them, along with other easter eggs. At least she's trying/tried to be subversive towards this corporate crap.
Well if they listen to the comments, then maybe just maybe, we would get a animator, however maybe just the ones who they see can pander to kids. Object Shows vs Storytimes would be the only thing people would come for?
RUclips is trending towards becoming exactly what they shouldn't be. The reason ppl love youtube is because it's so independent, and you can actually make a name for yourself, by yourself. It's dumb when they're just promoting their poster-boys/girls.
agree, the whole reason I started watching youtube years ago was because cable TV was lame and sanitized, but trending is basically that. I hope some CEO changes are coming but I doubt it..
@@blazzzeboy herding all the sheeple onto the trending page and putting tons of targeted ads on those videos is some of the highest and easiest income youtube makes. YT and google have good products but they are trashing them for their bottom line
2013 RUclips rewind also lacked the cringe-ass dialogue that has riddled the last few rewinds. Ugh. It hurts to listen to the RUclipsrs stumble their way through delivering those lines.
efwefwef stop blaming SJWs for everything.Anti-SJWs have become just like SJWs please stop blaming these people that pretty much only exist into your mind for everything.
_Baby : 9.7million Dislikes in 8 Years_ _RUclips Rewind 2018: Hold My Beer_ _Creates History for Being The Fastest Video Achieving 10_ _Million Dislikes_ *_Gud JoB_*
This video has aged very well for 2018. Hard to believe it's been almost a year and still nothing has changed with youtube rewind 2019. Great moves Ethan keep it up. Proud of you.
I do enjoy the commentators that call out all the bullshit, though, so I shouldn't have said ALL RUclipsrs. They bring some needed sanity to this fucked up world. It keeps me hopeful.
*Do people not know that the dead man Logan filmed wasn't even real? It was an actor & Matty Debunk exposed this so Logan actually didn't do anything wronh coz it's fake...*
Corporate, cringey, and pandering to advertisers? That’s a pretty good representation of what youtube is in 2018. I don’t know what people are complaining about.
RUclips producing content reminds me back at school, when the principal and the teachers would organize "fun" activities for the students.
Brilliant analogy
Perfect comment lmao.
😂
Literally copied a comment exactly from yt rewind
Lol u stole this comment
I didn't recognize 95% of the people in that garbage pile
Donut Operator same
Ooft, donut be here
Only recognized jaiden animations tbh
Why are you all surprised? Donut has always said he's a fan of Ethan's work and enjoys his content
same lol
Less locations, RUclipsrs hardly anyone knows, forced agendas and shitty music result in the 2018 disaster. Can't wait to see how they somehow make it worse in 2019, assuming they even make one
2019 youtube rewind be like t-dab with them partner owned companies
Dolan Dark Hi Pewdiepie!
Ayy what is up baby girl Dolan Dark
Hey felix .
Dolan Dark hey dad stop hitting me
It genuinely breaks my heart that this is where RUclips has ended up. There’s no creatives, just personalities trying to be rich. I miss the sketches and the authenticity of it all
youtube is just gonna be a fucking business instead of actual creativity
@@sarvinravinthiran7208 it’s already headed that direction with RUclips boxing ....
I honestly think that is one of the reasons why TikTok has been blowing up. It feels like it is bringing back the DIY feeling of very early RUclips and YT now feels like highly-produced old media TV.
They aren’t even “personalities” anymore just empty husks of the people they used to be or sell their souls to the devil and make bad videos for a living
_Papa blessed us with not 1, but 3 videos within 2 weeks_
🙏 PAPA BLESS 🙏
kremit the frog I see you everywhere just2good
When I saw the video I was like.. it couldn't be, could it? So stoked!
couldn’t believe it
Your uncle.
How is he doing?
I love how half of these people were not even RUclipsrs
*Ninja*
and the other half are unknown youtubers
Theyre actually all youtubers for the record, I dun like the rewind either but you gotta hit em in the right places lol
@@SGR5150 there was at least 2 or 3 actually good ones besides the animators
*Exclusively youtubers, they do have channels, but some of them are not as impactful as a certian person who wasn't invited...
And the rest are litteraly unknown
They wasted their whole budget to get will smith to say he likes fortnite
Detached silicon valley companies pushing their political agendas and narrative. did you expect them not to waste money on something no one wants or will actually like?
Even the 'journalists' and influencer parasites don't really like what they shill for....
Imagine if they used that money to make something great
Vexa 12 youtube: woah there that’s dreaming too big
So many likes but so little replies.
Yep, pretty much what I thought too. The rest is just whatever they pulled out of their asses, most important memes and youtubers from the year are not even there! And half the video is to talk about LGBT stuff and how cultures are supposedly stopping to be oppressed. Just plain political crap pretty much.
imagine if a Korean entertainment company made their idols scream “AMERICAN MUSIC”
Lmao
Pyxis Black So basically, they would just use the uno reverse card then. Interesting.
@DipsZ I wasn't trying to force it....I mean, what else CAN I say...?
@DipsZ Oh okay, then I'll just hit you up with ol'...
😂😂😂
@DipsZ No u
Not even Flex Tape can fix this rewind.
Prove it, oh wait after watching it I now understand
D A N K
PhilSwiftDaily that’s why you need Flex Seal stoopid
It’s already sunk too deep
That must be a lotta damage
It used to be about RUclips
Investing Book Summaries Well put.
Now it's all political BS
now it's about normies misenterpreting memes to advertise kpop and fortnite
Tyde Stix
He means without the “U” as in “You” because being creative and being yourself on the platform means nothing anymore
800th like I think
To quote IHE "what are we even celebrating at this point?"
Honestly though. What the hell is rewind even for anymore, it’s basically just a celebration of dead memes and RUclipsrs nobody knows
We're celebrating the breaking of the world record for most cringe in a youtube video
To quote me: "How is your uncle doing? IS HE OK?"
@@Yes-vj5dc I thought it was similar to a 2018 year in review... like the articles, videos, and news we look back on during New year's eve
Ur on the scott the woz video too nice
Let's be honest. RUclips changed the day viners joined.
That's not the reason advertisers started pussying out right?YT changed because of the adpocalypse,and I fucking hate it.
Hopz not really most viners actually loved making things that would be controversial now adays... but then the advocates hit and youtube wanted to turn all corporate.
And when pewdiepie said the n word then also when Joji left the platform
You called?
yeah...
They also just shot themselves in the foot by framing the whole thing as "what would happen if the people controlled Rewind" and then giving the people the exact opposite of what they wanted lmfao
@@ok-xn4nv You mean 10-12 year olds?
yeah lol it’s pretty ironic
@puca But if they want Jake Paul they surely want this - and they will enjoy it!
morti271 I can assure you not all 12 year olds want Jake Paul is like half of them that do.
It almost feels like RUclips TRIED to make the worst rendition of a Rewind this year could have produced.
You never know. Could have been the group that put it together longed for the old days & knew the approving executives were so clueless they'd never see it right before their own eyes.
HOLY CRAP ITS SENPAI!
Yeah, it actually feels like they went through a checklist of the biggest trends of the year.
@Rekken and Yu Yea yea just keep trashtalking... I can't wait for next rewind, to prove you were wrong! OF COURSE THEY CAN DO WORSE! I still believe in RUclips if you don't... 😌
@@niroracoon2981 youre just a hater. its very obvious that they did this on purpose. no one is this tone deaf.
How awkward must it had been to film that campfire scene.
so awkward it transcended to the final edit.
that was such a pointless scene.
You know who should be here?:
*F I L T H Y F R A N K*
Theskxinnygrxzzly. Oh my dude you just got PRANKED
FILTHY FRANKED
PRANK BABY
ill see myself out now
Why
All of these people have been disconnected from the platform
Frank should smite all of them
@Jason P Because he’s a legend
Satirical. I was ur 700 like
RUclips doesn't put RUclipsrs in their RUclips rewind. They put celebrities, twitch streamers and the same people year after year. At least there was plenty of animators
That girl in the cart hasn't uploaded in almost a year and superwoman took a break for mental problems then pushed her merch about how "humble she was" i think we can all agree youtube rewind was full of top notch youtubers
Dont Forget K-POP
Animators are gay
@@flossyjay7280 the use of the word 'gay' was unnecessary and hateful towards gay people. Now I understand there's free speech and all but there's other words that would convey the meaning better, and would not offend a mass amount of people. I would greatly appreciate if you consider changing the word gay to something else.
Despite my appreciation for these animators, it was still cringy af (except for jaiden's part of course)
did we really get blessed with 2 videos in less than 6 months?????
2 videos in 6 months, never done before
What i dont understand, these youtubers who were not mentioned should do their own! Rewind! Put in on pewdiepie channel and that would be the ultimate frrruck u to RUclips
YoungBlaze exactly
Frrruck?
Omg that’s such a good idea
Rewind costs millions the production value wouldn't be as good
Golden idea
Will Smith is 100% the first person I think of when someone says 'prominent youtuber'
Ah yes, Will Smith is the best and most popular youtuber only known for his RUclips channel
When RUclips thinks they’re doing something good for the community but the video gets enormous backlash.
You are the new Justin Y
Where’s Alex Jones haha
How to properly clean your metal computer , ima reply every time i see you in the comment section now dude, I swear like 15th time
Nice
RUclips did an oopsie
"It's time to read the comments." -- RUclips, after deleting all the negative comments in the RUclips Rewind comment section last year.
Robin and this year. All the top comments only have like 200 likes because they're deleting the negativity which happens to be the top comments
@@aoifek9709 holy shit.. Thats so sad... Kinda funny how white guys are in minority in rewind, but they are biggest group on the yt...
It feels like so wrong......
@@aoifek9709 No, they're not . Top comments have hundreds of thousands of likes and they are critical.
Edit: Maybe they did and stopped.
RUclips didn't mess up rewind, youtube messed up youtube.
josiahct which messed up rewind
They literally said Asian representation in media was important and didn’t even bring up joji
Bad V1b3s they didn’t invite the pioneers of the platform and instead invited random people.
Because he was filthy frank
Boohoo
:((
Will you shut up man?
Wait, ANOTHER H3 VIDEO IN THE SAME MONTH? Ethan you absolute madman
And you jinxed it.
*madlad
How To Basic’s face reveal was a better rewind than the actual rewind
Because collaborations are supposed to be FUN, which the rewind ultimately lacks completely. Everyone there was just working for a paycheck, not having fun making videos with friends.
He had a face reveal?
@@guidetoanything if im not mistaken from emma blackery's video about the last rewind she did (2016? 15?) They didnt get paid. They were there standing in the cold waiting to pour and play with slime in the middle of nowhere and she said they weren't being paid for it. It was voluntary.
@@Dany_lop Damn that's even worse, I figured at least the youtubers were paid to be in it. I would assume with things like the 2012-2013 ones they were fun and youtube just covered production so people volunteered and were fine with it so they just kept it that way.
How To Bistic
Filthy Frank. That is a name I haven’t Heard in years
joji is lit man
Right
Blueberry M *Chromosomes
Pocketoli pocketoli what’s in the ravioli
Makes me cry when I think that younger generations grow up without knowing who filthyfrank is
Ok but Ethan with the box of tissues had me ROLLING
That sequence with Felix in the 2013 rewind is so classic. I'm glad you went back to talk about that one. 2018's was such a joke.
My man, nice overwatch content
Nerf Jeff
It's even crazier for me because I actually live in Brighton, the city Felix was in lol
Nateson lol never taught I would see u here Xd
H3H3 getting back into their old 'fascinating' formula is the best Christmas present I could have asked for.
I just want Ethan to do his emotional dance during my wedding and my funeral.
Technically your wedding will also be your funeral, since that's when your soul dies and you become a empty shell of the past you
@@CezaMVO That's even more reason for him to be there
Everyone: PEWDIEPIE!!!
RUclips: did somebody say fortnite?
Raid shadow legends. Thats what ive heard.
Legitttt XD
To be fair, fortnite was a huge deal that year, but it was displayed in an awful way
"How do you do, fellow kids?"
~ RUclips
Justin Y. Justin Justin Copying comments?
Justin Gay *dab
You shouldve been in youtube rewind
Oh look its you again
Here we go again..
Thank god ethan is making more of this type of content. missed it so much
Reminder that Susan W. became CEO of RUclips in 2014... Keep that in mind.
Wonder if her middle name begins with J.....
SJW!!!!
Funny how that’s almost directly, RIGHT before YoTube went to shit in many ways... unfair, stupid, and unannounced major changes to the algorithm and site design that everyone hated, the beginning of “fascist China RUclips” where they censor those they disagree with, constant pressure to force 50% diversity hires when the pool of women in tech, for example, is 1/20 that of men and it’s literally impossible to meet the “sexist/racist’’ quotas, and obviously extremely unfair... the list goes on. She’s cancer and an embarrassment to women CEOs and directly damaging women’s rights by being outlandish and extremist (and directly, unabashedly promoting dis-equality as the new goal of feminism, because diversity quotas are nothing but racism and sexism in policy form, like Harvard only allowing a certain number of Asians into the school so they don’t dominate the student population), and causing the other side to backlash. UGH!
Remember when the biggest RUclipsr on the platform and the face of the company made anti-Semitic jokes and went around using the 'N' word which eventually led to the Adpocalypse and RUclips becoming super-PG? Honestly, why isn't anyone calling out PewDiePie for ruining RUclips for everyone else?
@@jayanths1221 he didnt cause the adpocalypse, it was going to happen anyway.
That’s what happens when you put a Jew at the head of something. They’ll try to work in their agenda into it. Even my boy h3h3, he’s been a sneaky Jew from time to time. He had that money grab mobile app, but I can’t blame him
In the next rewind, i hope we'll see Jake and Logan Paul getting taken out by the Yakuza
Good day sir! I'd like to buy five front row seats.
I would pay to see that.
Having both Felix and Ethan calling Lily Singh "Lily Sings" is all I ever wanted. Very emotional.
Amen to that
Lily Sings, the Miscarriage of RUclips
I noticed that too
*(EMOTIONAL)*
Lilly*
3 uploads in less than a month, it’s a Christmas miracle
He needs to afford those presents....even though he's jewish.
@@JonnyUnderrated he could just upload another podcast
Its his Christmas gift
Just trying to regain favor mate they were losing subs out the ass
Our Lord and Savior hath return ❤
2013 = Actually celebrating RUclips.
2018 = Giving ourselves a pat on the back while this website continues to slowly die.
I loce scrarchin my back!
More like in a comatose state where all we can do is grieve for the good old times.
If Google didn't buy RUclips, I bet Microsoft would have. If either of them hadn't bought RUclips, I bet Yahoo!, Facebook, or Myspace would have.
2013 = celebrating youtube and its creators
2018 = ha ha memes ha ha fortnite *our website is dying help*
I remember the 2014 one being the best for me :p
SLOWLY DIE!????¿¿¿
Is there any other video platform as big as it?
NO
"why is casey kpop godzilla"
-ethan klein 2018
He sounds so defeated when he says it too.
3:04
When Ethan realizes Jon Oliver is doing a fortnite dance is hilarious. He seemed so destroyed lol
It looked to me like one of the dysfunctional chicken dances from the original "Arrested Development" series. I wonder if Fortnite lifted it from that. I feel like Arrested Development parodies are more John Oliver's speed.
I was in tears, he looked so upset that it took him that long to realize
I rewatched that part 6 times 😂
jonathan sparks gig
H
I would payy a fortune to be in that room lmfao
*I miss this channel please upload more*
AMEN!
*what's the point of typing like this*
@@BlahBlah-zb7es emphasis, i''m guessing?
venawartmander :3 on some platforms, that makes the text bold
That's some one sided mindset shit, mah boi.
Remember when youtubers were so pumped to be in Rewind...
Now they get pumped not to be in it😂
Lia Dors yeah me neither
“Trevor noah flossing...is what we all knew would be here but dreaded this moment.”
I wonder when RUclips will understand how lost they are. They successfully produced the most hated video on the site. Maybe karma for all the crap they have been landing on producers for the last few years.
Its kinda hilarious though.. "Give a moment to the people who put aside their differences" - Meanwhile in the youtube comment sections. Either they have no clue what's going on or they are trying their best to suppress/ignore it to death, i'm guessing the latter.
Im sure they really care. Cause the masses will stop bitching and actually go to another site. LOL
@@OldManNutcakez Yeah right, good luck competing with youtube, it's just so damn convenient.
Please destroy more knockoff toys I miss those videos
I’m waiting till a new site representing what RUclips should’ve been is created so I can forget the mistake this platform has become. smh
Each rewind, they rewind the quality of the video.
What we Do Here is Go Back..Back..Back..
Smart Made Marketing don’t steal comments
iDubbbz should Content Cop RUclips lmao
Waiting for RUclips Rewind Content Cop
Ayyyyyyy lmaaaaoooo
This is perfection. I think I love you
I’m kinda pissed as the camp site thing wasn’t in the suicide forest.
THAT CHILD or was it????? :o
Da da daaaaaaaaaaaa
fkn missed op
*Do people not know that the dead man Logan filmed wasn't even real? It was an actor & Matty Debunk exposed this so Logan actually didn't do anything wronh coz it's fake...*
@@cripplingdepression9968 stapppppppp
Every time Ethan said kpop it sounded like cake pop
Hugh Jass Which is a lot better that Kpoop :D
Hell yeah
RUclips has forgotten what they were all about. A place for amateurs to share videos they made with the masses. Now it's been commercialised, the community is dead.
Yes
James Lovejoy the community isn’t dead it’s just more of a spectator then a broadcaster these days everyone likes a good witch hunt but it isn’t healthy to only thrive on the negativity
@Foxtrot money in a way corrupts, too bad we need it
@Foxtrot It's not just about money. The ranking algorithms for search results and suggested videos heavily favour channels that upload consistently (such that it's their full-time job). This crowds out new content creators who have little to no hope of their content getting noticed.
RUclips is no longer a community, it is a business.
When google purchased it, it became a business. Ever since RUclips Red, it became a company.
ion yep and it’s sad when you think about how RUclips use to be compared to now.
It's been like that for years...
@@ionthegreat13 *corporation
And none of these big RUclipsrs talk about it. Us mere normals are nothing.
The saddest part is, RUclips and its executives probably concluded that the millions of downvotes are from _"alt-right trolls"_ and actually thinks they nailed Rewind this year.
if they actually believe that then the people running youtube are a bunch of morons
How did you manage to make this political? You’re part of the problem on this platform.
@@lildmckay He is not right you know.. look what happened with Star Wars and the answers of the executives
@@lildmckay except he's right. Are you saying it isn't true?
lildmckay RUclips made this political by forcing their ideologies into rewind. Ethan literally pointed that out
"I'm so winded, it's embarrassing."
I can't think of a more relatable thing this man has said.
RUclips is slowly turning to TV
A shitter less competent one
TV had it's golden beauty decades, YT was dead as soon as felix signed up. Felix and Gangnam destroyed YT.
*gags*
agreed, it's starting to become very PC and safe much like tv. I don't mind that but the beauty about youtube is YOU choose what to watch and what is recommended. If you don't like raunchy stuff you can tailor it to what you like. But now youtube is forcing all the more risky youtubers off the platform because they want it like tv because that's what corporate people like. tasteless, generic, and bland.
The great irony is that RUclips is so huge because it's not TV.
RUclips Rewind is a great reminder of how out of touch they are with their audience
insert principle skinner meme
No, RUclips has logistics up the ass, they realize all the money is in pandering to 12 year olds
Fake Name I can say with pretty good confidence that it’s a mistake to think their data model is detailed enough to make specific judgements about content.
They all basically became what they were trying not to be : television !
@@JoeJoe-lq6bd sorry dude, but they absolutely have to capabilities, meta user data collection and exploitation is absolutely worth its weight in platinum, especially to commercialized operations like RUclips (and Google at large, FaceBook, your internet and mobile service providers, advertising companies, the literal government, etc.)
*petition for all the non cringey youtubers to make their own youtube rewind*
Cool, can’t wait to see Jake paul in it
Theres no such thing. Being a youtuber by itself is cringy.
Yes
@@sbravo3761 Then how are you watching youtube if you're too busy cringing?
You mean TANACON
the *really* put ethan in the rewind 2019 trailer LMAO
You know it is cringey when you cant even tell whether it's Ethan's edits or the actual video...
I was just thinking this lmao
Lmao I was thinking the same thing.
I’m dead lmfaoo
OOF!
BURN!!!
Lol so true
all the raunchy youtubers need to make a youtube rewind. we need one with codyko, h3h3, idubbbz, danny gonzalez, & more. GMM even stepped out of youtube rewind bc it’s cringey and they’re literally in their 40s in a PG show. we want a youtube rewind with good youtubers!!!
Gotta love GMM
What did H3H3 even do in 2018?
Noah Koelmeyer facts
Joe Johnson good point
Ehh idk bud. Iddubz has changed alot he isn't the same anymore idk what happened to him. He used to be so funny now it appears that shit got to him
I didn't recognize a single person in the thumbnail. I feel like that's a good sign.
RobinMcBeth you should check out swoozie then, he‘s pretty funny and one of the OGs
Come on not even ninja what r u doing with your life
Normal EU4 player but T series
if you were brazilian you would surely know whinderson, whos actually one pf the best in my country, in my opinion.
I recognize Ninja, but only because he has that hair and I've seen him in memes where he loses control and screams at people.
Also, I might see Lele "I'm latina!" Pons on the right, but I'm not sure, cause the image has been photoshopped/filtered to death, and it mostly looks like a generic instagram "comedian" girl, so it really could be anybody.
Edit: Why is that one guy cosplaying as Johnny Depp?
I would like to see ricardo milos in rewind 2019
*Ricardo the lagend
u know they're not gonna
Ок Милане опалићу
I would like to not see Rewind 2019
Sadly he wasn't there
My lack of interest in RUclips Rewind at this point is so high
Leigh-Anne Marie just like my rent
I didn't even know it happened until now
ikr I literally go only to dislike............ and go back to verify my dislike......every day
In 2013, Rewind made fun of mainstream media, while highlighting what made RUclips different. In 2018, Rewind tried to be mainstream media.
they dont realise that they are still a small platform and mainstream media is still way more popular.
@@johnnyboi331 r u dumb fox news is the most watched channel currently at 1.8M daily viewers, compare that to pewdiepie who averages 4M a video
@@undeniablybaked fox news isnt a company. were talking about the actual companies here. otherwise people would just call youtube mainstream media.
@@johnnyboi331 RUclips is pretty damn popular, they are not small, because they are at the top of one of the biggest thing, the internet. So for them to be something else they are not is damn retarded, not because they are small, but they forget their identity
@@johnnyboi331 if you want to talk companies then youtube is owned alphabet which is the third biggest company following amazon and apple
U realize youtube is owned by google a search engine whos name is synonymous with searching for anything on the internet?
ethans new tissue dance has to be a top tier h3h3 meme
KPOP
That’s hot
That shit was on point.
RUclips is now doing that dance.
No Lilly singh is RUclips's miscarriage
Frasburn Now she has a late night show
@@jakobrosenberg7943 actually???
@@Freeeeeeeee27 unfortunately yes she does
Lel
@@Freeeeeeeee27 yeah drew gooden has a great vid breaking down how terrible her late night show is
2018 was will smith
2019 will be ethan klein
That would be cool af
Sorry bud, this comment has a profile pic, original name, and >500 likes. RUclips won't use it.
why are you verified
@@RealDistantz Bruhhhhh actually though
2020 will be read by Erik Hoffstad
"Casey is like K-Pop Godzilla" lmao
The 2018 RUclips Rewind was a good way to showcase how fake RUclips is, nowadays
TeeMakesBeatz truth.
I want 10 hours of Ethan dancing to high hopes
*Who also only knew like 4 people in this RUclips rewind?*
Bizarre Beats I knew like 3 and one of them was Will Smith so I don’t even count that. 🤷🏾♀️
I knew a few and also half of them were not youtubers (Ninja, Will Smith, John Oliver).
Markiplier was the only guy for me
Yeah that’s the 3 people anybody would know. And one was a twitch streamer and other hollywood actor.
I knew one person. Will 'sellout' Smith
The 2013 RUclips Rewind had a soul. The 2018 one doesn’t. That’s the difference. RUclips shouldn’t endlessly pander to try and be emotional. If they’d appeal to people’s nostalgia instead like they did in 2013 by creating something that’s actually true to the events and trends of that year, then it becomes timeless. Losing sight of heart in favor of money has backfired for them in every way possible.
The 2018 one being 'Soul-less' was the best analogy I've heard so far. It's been like that for a while too :(
That pandering thing i think is very politically motivated in the section where they talk about drag, women, asians and things that are more politically biased. We don't want political shit, we want entertainment.
RUclipsrs should get together and make a new rewind
Larry King that's genius
:O thats actually an amazing idea
only mr beast can do that
Grandaays version is a gem
Larry King there is already a good Meme Rewind like Every year. It cant be that hard
I like how Ethan’s eyebrows react to the video too
Jaiden Animations, is the last finger holding on the the cliff for RUclips rewind, because of that PewDiePie chair reference.
Plus all the references on the shelf in the background.
@@abstract7026 sub 2 pewdiepie
Thanos Snap
PewDiePie's Chair is the main star of that RUclips Rewind.
who is justin y
This years rewind was so ironic.
On the one hand, they're emphasizing *diversity* and basically saying _"everyone is a part, no matter how strange you are"_ , and _"It takes a lot of bravery to be that vulnurable"_ .
On the other; they actually play it extremely safely to make themselves invulnerable, and only show the mainstream shit.
@@CL3EE As long as your topic promotes the following disadvantaged groups:
Yeah, and screw Lilly Singh
Also, the fricking people started narrating shit for forever... Instead of just featuring the people they were talking about... Tell a story through music and video instead of just TALKING.
YUP!
This is how social virtue signalling works. Anyone could have predicted this happening.
Ethan had a mental breakdown when *John Oliver did Take The L*
Scoobicide I died when Ethan started doing take the l
That was my reaction too and I’m glad I got to share it with someone
Sudden hit of realization
“You know who really needs to be in this rewind”, ETHAN KLIEN
Most people can agree they pretty much did it to avoid embarrassment of what some creators done in the past and tried to sell themselves to advertisers, but man being the soon to be most disliked video on your own platform is a million times more embarrassing than any creator you could have put in.
We can't let it overtake Baby as the most disliked video.
Ckrypto we can*
That Pewdiepie metaphor at the end is powerful.
I think it also predicts Bitch Lasagna.
RUclips Rewind 2019: T-series buries their curry in the gravel
Will Smith. You know that RUclips star.
@@capablanc 00
@@capablanc Yes, I'm sure he got those subscribers because of the quality of his videos and not because he's fucking WILL SMITH. I mean, he probably could have not posted any videos and get near a million sub.
lol they photoshopped out the teddy fresh logo on the sweater for the 2019 rewind
nice find
yt rewind 2018 was basically a giant fortnite ad wit a bunch of youtubers I don't care about
Love this! "Put our differences aside"... yet always the same 10 creators and never their top creators. Yes, especially Pewds.
You watch h3h3?? lit. love ya
Of course. They are hilarious and on point. @@milliesmith8084
Toys Unlimited :))
Black Tiger Agreed, but who are you talking about?
the best part of the rewind was where they put a bunch of animators in there as if youtubes been promoting animators anywhere on the platform
Well, Jaiden Animations threw one back at them by putting Pewd's chair in them, along with other easter eggs. At least she's trying/tried to be subversive towards this corporate crap.
We need more non storytime animators.
To be fair the odd ones out was on trending a few days ago
Well if they listen to the comments, then maybe just maybe, we would get a animator, however maybe just the ones who they see can pander to kids. Object Shows vs Storytimes would be the only thing people would come for?
Ethan: *throws tissues everywhere*
Coronavirus: hehehe yesssssss
Makes no sense
Man the hate for RUclips rewind is getting so popular that they should put it in the RUclips rewind next year
Varangian Guard haha ya that’s true
It's more like a live action advertisement for Fortnite than a youtube rewind.
Still can’t get over the fact that I know hardly any of them
who's here after the YT rewind 2019 video?
Oh hey Toby!
me
i cant upvote the strangler, you got 69
RUclips is trending towards becoming exactly what they shouldn't be. The reason ppl love youtube is because it's so independent, and you can actually make a name for yourself, by yourself. It's dumb when they're just promoting their poster-boys/girls.
we really need to get Susan to step down. she's the cause of all of our current issues
agree, the whole reason I started watching youtube years ago was because cable TV was lame and sanitized, but trending is basically that. I hope some CEO changes are coming but I doubt it..
@@blazzzeboy herding all the sheeple onto the trending page and putting tons of targeted ads on those videos is some of the highest and easiest income youtube makes. YT and google have good products but they are trashing them for their bottom line
2013 RUclips rewind also lacked the cringe-ass dialogue that has riddled the last few rewinds. Ugh. It hurts to listen to the RUclipsrs stumble their way through delivering those lines.
Nicole D Well 2018 was the year of the SJW so it makes sense I guess
Forced (and false) positivity 2018.
That’s a really good point. The dialogue adds so much cringe it hurts
efwefwef stop blaming SJWs for everything.Anti-SJWs have become just like SJWs please stop blaming these people that pretty much only exist into your mind for everything.
_Baby : 9.7million Dislikes in 8 Years_
_RUclips Rewind 2018: Hold My Beer_
_Creates History for Being The Fastest Video Achieving 10_
_Million Dislikes_
*_Gud JoB_*
lmao
Mr. ANGAD lol
XD
"hold my beer" hahaah nice one that's new
This video has aged very well for 2018. Hard to believe it's been almost a year and still nothing has changed with youtube rewind 2019. Great moves Ethan keep it up. Proud of you.
"Everyone who did something bigger than themselves this year"
Eh, Pornhub has plenty of chicks that fall in that category.
lmao
This comment is severely underrated.
I don't believe anyone on RUclips thinks that anything is bigger or greater than themselves.
I do enjoy the commentators that call out all the bullshit, though, so I shouldn't have said ALL RUclipsrs. They bring some needed sanity to this fucked up world. It keeps me hopeful.
They even did a rewind
RUclips Rewind 2018 beat "It's Everyday Bro" in dislikes... Just think on that
Saboiya next, let's beat "Baby" by Justin Bieber and make the 2018 Rewind the most disliked. PewDiePie vs T-Series, now 2018 Rewind Vs "Baby"
Ethan you left the fake bloody bottle cap in the frame we know this is a *prank*
*Do people not know that the dead man Logan filmed wasn't even real? It was an actor & Matty Debunk exposed this so Logan actually didn't do anything wronh coz it's fake...*
And this year isnt much better. Remember when RUclips rewinds weren't top ten lists ripped off from watch mojo
Apparently you haven’t seen the VERY FIRST rewind yet.
went from casey to K-sey
Underrated comment.
I like how Ethan can go from violently wiping away “tears” to giving real advice and a respectable opinion. This is why we love you Ethan, Papa Bless.
Papa, bless!
Corporate, cringey, and pandering to advertisers? That’s a pretty good representation of what youtube is in 2018. I don’t know what people are complaining about.
That is an amazing point.
2018: Pandering to Fornite tweens
2013: Sincerely honoring RUclipsrs