Nirmala Sitharaman explains GST on health insurance
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 сен 2024
- “...you blame the Modi government and protest here.” Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman responded to demands of a rollback on the 18% GST levied on health and life insurance premiums.
Brut India is the fastest-growing digital video publisher in the country. We're a young, independent platform producing compelling journalism in new formats.
You can also find us here:
Facebook: / brutindia
Instagram: / brut.india
Twitter: / brutindia
Snapchat: Brut India
Snapchat: Brut India Stories
Question is from physics but answer is history class.. wtf. 😅
you cannot expect ur answer from her. shes just stating the facts.
@@seemapayak5287 just lies not facts
She is talking nonsense
The tax has been increased to 18% from 15%
Instead of accepting it she is giving dumb excuse that even the state is collecting tax from it 🤦
yes you right. taxes are increased by 15% to 18%
9% going to state, and 9% going to centre.
average parliament session
someone : bjp why u did this?
bjp minister : but congress used to do it too
parliament : * chaos *
Yes there no logic in that 😂😂
In our language we call it (ch**ya katna)
Taxation is a necessity which cant be reversed at will. Everyone from every party knows it can’t be removed but some will spread lie just to put a blind fold
on people. So this statement is about that. Context samjho bhai log..
@@rajbos29 yes we cannot remove tax. But atleast we can reduce
@ShikhaYadav-wn1ni Precisely if you want to reduce, ppl taking the lion share should take a cut right? The states in this case don't want to do it but blame the Centre.
Woh sab to theek hai, but why are you burdening the common man with a high GST rate on something which is so essential? Honestly I am sick and tired of paying tax over tax over tax.
me too... and many of us going thru this burden
All finance ministers in the country, should reach a consensus on this.
Nimala Tai main Reason for defeat of Bjp in 2029
I Agree
Abhi se shuru ho gya😂😂
Election aane to de bhai
She should resign immediately
The question is why you are shamelessly taking gst on middle class essential.
Ask your state finance minister, the same question. It's a group decision.
Ask to cut petrol tax, because you are paying that, every day, and much more than GST on insurance.
@@rajx7120 health insurance and life insurance are precautions that we take for uncertainties in life, actually these should be provided by govt, because we our system we are buying private, why they are taxing on us for their inefficiency
Her voice started to annoyed me now. No logical discussion.
If you are expecting logic from politicians, I don't know where to start
what do u think logical answer would be?
Any Country should understand...... that essentials should not be taxed.... especially food health and education.... when will this commonsense be understood...
I think she's actually lost it
FM is a Perfect example of psycho
She explained well enough
We can't understand because it was said to normal people
@@matte67 she was angry because they are pointing useless points
@@lokeshloki8628 she did the same... not saying that previous govs did not implement taxes on insurance. But this is not parliamentary decorum for a minister of her stance. She is doing whataboutery while being in power. Opposition's whole job is to question. But it's not the ruling party that's doing the same
@@lokeshloki8628 and you are worse than FM 😂😂😂😂😂
Janata: Yaha hagana🐷 mana hai.
Political Parties : Nai Vo hage the🐷, Hum bhi hagenge 🐷
“People deserve the government they voted for.”
-Thomas Jefferson
Till for how many years they blame the previous govt 🥴
They are blaming your state govt also.
Achha kiya @@rajx7120
Madam is thinking she is the headmaster of the parliament 😂
I wish all these MPs and MLA's are just given salaries without any special privileges like house, car, communication, transportation, water, electricity, Education for thier children, medical benefits and their salaries totally taxable without any exemption to anybody...
How and why should they enjoy benefits of our taxes and do nothing for us...and on top of that, they treat us like our lives doesn’t matter...?
According to her medicine is a premium service so 18% and diamonds and gold are nothing so only 5%.. Great FM
This old woman is talking about 15% taxes pre GST era. You were chosen so that you bring that burden down, but you increased it and now you are justifying the increase. Another thing is 74% taxes may go back to the state, but the rest of 26% that the centre collects, that is collected from every state. So the centre is actually getting a major chunk of the taxes collected.
Question : Why you tax
Answer : Previous government also taxed
😂😂
Ok, but if you are taking tax, what makes you different than the previous government?
How many ppl pay taxes in india?hardly anyone..theyve got no choice
@@capteagle9 Jo tax de bhi Raha hai tab bhi use kuch returns nhi milte hai is desh me
Bhai running a country is not as simple as you think. Without tax, development is not possible.
I agree everyone has a different opinion on taxes and that's fine, but the comment you did astonished me 😅😅
@@HarshPatel5940 You are right, but BJP promised that we are different from the previous UPA government and according to my opinion, we shouldn't give tax on life insurance since right of life is our fundamental right and so I think we shouldn't tax life of the people except if your taking premium life insurance.
@@capteagle9 Umm.. everyone pays GST btw.
She will Bed ridden in the Hospital with no one to take care. Modi and Shah will not be there
true that .. dil se haay niklegi to lagni to hai hi
She's not explaining.....she's protecting herself
but did she give an answer to Gadkari's mail, that GST should be removed on Health and Life Insurance Premiums. I think Gadkari meant to say, that any kind of tax should be removed on Health and Life Insurance Premiums.
If GST is removed, States should also not apply their own VAT on Insurances.
After GST introduced why talk about VAT?
The FM doesn't have the power to take sole decision of scrapping the GST on anything. All the FM's of their respective states are present in the GST council meeting,every decision about GST is finalised or passed only if 2/3rd states agree with the decision. This is what Niramala didi was trying to explain.
@@shubhamchougule7270 true that
But she is FM in centre. She should initiate the discussion with the states.
Atleast topic should be discussed.
Come up with a better way.
Nimmi is just playing blame game here instead of answering the question. What is the difference between BJP and INC when both are doing the same thing?
Tax for raising question, issue is solved..
so , what is the difference between two ....................
Drama queens Nirmala and Kangana.
mohua mitra is also Doing Only Drama with Energetic Voice!,
I feel sorry for the people who voted BJP 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
How does she not get it??, its not about the letter or who did it first, its about how tf are taxing on life? Sounds pretty fair huh, Taxing the very will to live, thats amazing, kudos bjp,
Shes just exposing their hypocrisy....as she said theyve already discussed this 3 times and their finance ministers never said anything..
You need to understand how tax is being used for development first. Watch the whole video before commenting, understand it.
And Camon mann, grow up.
@@capteagle9I'm not denying that at all, they have been worst and growth is on a different scale in this govt, but this is bad, they show their hands to the other side, but take credit if they are the stuff the opposition suggested, I'm not here to talk about that, but don't you think it's crazy that you are taxed for trying to stay alive?
@dineshshrihari6313 what i gathered was that the overall tax was similiar to this new one before...but after gst it got reduced..so now to compensate theyve brought it back..while it is kinda unfair ,as a growing nation we have limited options...i believe every country has some sort of tax on insurance...
@@dineshshrihari6313 but ya they can reduce it ig
So basically a lot of time was wasted in explaining something that everyone was supposed to know already
Aunty ne apne awkward se voice me kuch bhi bolke chalegayi...lekin answer nai diya na solution diya... Kohi bhi GST hatado nai bolraha unka matlab tha 18% mat dalo it's too much karke....
12% OR 14% is Actually Good iThink ,
She is talking only about health insurance but not life insurance. In the country your bjp and alliance states are more than the opposition states so you can abolish the gst on all insurance. Don't do politics on this because you are not providing good medical facilities to the people so the people have chosen the other way support people or provide the facilities
i just hope from bottom of my heart, that their will be a institute to make these ministers actually capable and let them know, they are their to SOLVE the problems, NOT to point fingers. its SAME with ALL PARTIES, they are all simply incompetent, and we NEED to seriously CHANGE that.
If 73 percent is going to states, what is the problem?
Just reduce GST on Health Insurance Premiums immediately.
To jo pehle tha woe karna hai to aap q aaye ho
Matlab unhone kalesh kiya toh tumko bhi right mill jaraha hai kalesh karne ka? We voted for you thinking you'd act different, there is nothing different between both the parties. It hurts that we dont have any good party left to vote for.
What they did because of that they are in opposition.. what are you guys are doing.... After paying income taxes we tax payers are getting zero social security... And we are buying medical insurance policy and for that also we have to 18%gst. What a shame 😡..
Can someone explain me why additional 41% is going to states? (5:20)
15th finance commission recommendation
Actually the question is from ECONOMICS and answer is from POLITY . what the heck why are people choosing other political party so that they can make changes, and what they actually are doing is same and even worse they are burdening normal people in they political competition,,,,
In other countries citizens are getting free medical … here we are paying extra over and above the premium …
And which of the countries u mentioned is developing ...name it
@@anshusaini9916 Bhutan, Albania, Algeria, Argentina, Brazil, Costa Rica, Cuba, Maldives, Mauritius, Malaysia, Phillipines and many more
Basically, it was always there before...so we can do it.
Medical should be freely offered, instead they expect commoners to pay their own insur + pay GST, it's sad the people are being burdened with expenses!!
Nirmala hi reason hogi for their defeat in 2029
but why not remove it now aunty huh 😒
If in three gst meeting health insurance gst issue was discussed. What was the conclusion of it. Majority of the state at present are BJP Governed. What was their stand. She could have told on her speech. But instead of the blame game is played by the Minister.
She never answers question but diverts 😂
Sitha Raman is the address to someone being adament with pure arrogance and to debate on nonsense. She always leaves the topic of discussion and just says what she has been prepared of... Indian salaried section is bleeding and she doesn't want to listen.
Really good to see that BJP is using facts to oust opposition. Opposition is important but they should follow protocols as well instead of playing blame game.
Other than just saying opposition is also doing it is there any answer. What is the reason to not scrap the tax on the premium?
मैडम वित्त मंत्री, अगर 75% (approx) राज्यो को चला जाता है तो आपके लिए बहुत आसान है GST हटा देना
Please mam,I am a middle class whether state or centre pocketed the tax, major expense of middle class living in city you know is education and hospital bills. It is a request to reduce the GST on health insurance premium.
Instead of GST removal, they should cut petrol taxes. That will have more impact.
How does it help, if you remove tax on one item, when you are taxing something you are using every day?
If Peedai has a face then its none other than GSTraman.
Please recommend to Nirmala Sitaraman for a best actress award
Very informative Mam!
This is what happens when you force hindi on others … what a disaster
if protest is "natak" in a democracy, congratulations.
the job of mps who are not ministers is only to shout and support ministers' speech (Sometimes without even listening to what she/he is saying)
She is explaining why we should take your hard earned money.
Bjp is right, if middle class people support and voted for this government then why they can't pay taxes...poor and rich people's should pay less taxes, rich can support during elections and poor can vote on 5kg rashan
वितमंत्री के अनुसार 74% राज्य सरकार को जाता है , सभी को राज्य के वितमंत्री को चिट्ठी लिखनी चाहिए, वगेरह वगेरह
आपने बजट में जो भी घोषणाएं करी ही वो सभी को पूछ कर करी है, नही ना तो इंश्योरेंस के केस में क्यों
क्यों इलेक्शन के समय मोदी की गारंटी में जो घोषणाएं करी वो सब घोषणाएं सभी को पूछ के करी क्या, नही ना तो फिर इंश्योरेंस के केस में क्यों
क्या मोदी सरकार ने नोटबंदी का फैसला सभी राज्य से पूछ कर लिया था , नही ना तो फिर इंश्योरेंस के केस में क्यों
जब सभी चीजे पर gst आपंकी party ने लागू कर दिया , पर पेट्रोल पर नही, जब भी पूछो तो राज्य सरकारें पर बहाना बनाकर टाल देते हो क्यों
जब सभी डिसीजन वितमंत्री रहते हुए आप ले सकते हो, क्या आप अगर इंश्योरेंस पर GST कम कर देते तो उसके लिए सबसे पूछने लिए आपको किसने बोला, आप फैसला ले सकते थे, ले सकते हो, पर आपको इंश्योरेन्स पर gst पर कोई फैसला लेना ही नहीं है , उन सबके के बहाने बता रहे हो
That shows she doesnt knows problem of common man. Bye bye bjp
Still don't know why she is not understanding the GST 😂
This is so damn ignorant. On one hand, India has so poor insurance penetration. The govt still taxed 18% GST.
THIS IS SO DISCOURAGING.
Madam is going through menopause and letting the whole country suffer through menopause 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
The FM doesn't have the power to take sole decision of scrapping the GST on anything. All the FM's of their respective states are present in the GST council meeting,every decision about GST is finalised or passed only if 2/3rd states agree with the decision. This is what Niramala didi was trying to explain.
And what she said at the end of this video about "out of ₹100,₹74 goes to states and remaining goes to central" this is exactly how income tax payers feels. So i guess this is a Karma to the central government.
I think it's time to have south India as a separate entity.
You will also loose the elections like congress did
Never in my life I though I will support congress and that too papu bhai( Rahul Gandhi)
But looking at how BJP is trying to screw middle class, all the incomplete promises that they have done. Really looking for next election I will definitely vote against BJP and them out of the parliament
If the Tax was collected before also and to the state then why can't the govt remove it completely, why are they running behind common people blood money.
Guys when Jayalalithaa was there people were reacting like this with half knowledge, you'll know the moment you miss
Such a sick mind...
Dumping the burden on the past. How sick.
The ball is in her hands now. It is her responsibility to do something about it now.
जो भी ये सोचते है की वो टैक्स दे रहे है और ईसीसे सरकार चलती है और देश चलता है तो ये भी जान लो की अगर आप टैक्स देने लायक अमीर हो तो वो भी सरकार की वजह से ही हो, अगर देश मैं सुरक्षा और सुविधा नही दी जाती तो बहुत सारे लोग आज भी खेतो मे काम कर रहे होते, इंफ्रेस्टुक्चर और आगे सोच और नई तकनीक नही अपनाती तो आज भी देश 2g पर चल रहा होता और हम लोग दिन का सेकड़ो mb डाटा को इस्तेमाल नही कर पाते आज भी हमे दुनिया की खबर 24 घंटो बाद मिलती, खास कर IT वाले जो अभी अभी कमाने लगे है और उनसे टैक्स वसूला जा रहा है , तो 2008 से 2014 तक IT मैं को सैलरी मिल रही थी वो ITI हुए बंदे से कम थी, उस वक्त लोग IT छोडकर दूसरी कोई इंजीनियरिंग करने को प्रिओरिटी दे रहे थे, तो जो भी सरकार ले रही है वो आपको पहले कमाने के काबिल बनाती है और फिर लेती है अमेरिका 40% tax देना पड़ता है 100k डॉलर कमाने वाले व्यक्ति को
Arey O mahan buddhi. The problem is not tax entirely but too much tax on particular group of people aka salaried people. I know most of the local traders and shop keepers who earn equal to a salaried guy but pay way lesser tax or sometimes none.
If everyone is getting the benefit of infrastructure, safety and security then why not everyone is contributing the equally.
Arey unpadh aadmi, jio is not govt company. Govt has zero to none role in it. If they really wanted nation to have faster 3G and 4G then they had BSNL to do it but they didn't do and didn't care. Hence Private company did it. We are still paying for all the data that is being consumed and not that it is free.
If nation doesn't run on tax money then whose money is it then it runs. Why even collect tax from salaried people of it doesn't make much diff.
Idiot.
Shouting unnecessarily doesn't make wrong as right madam
Worst karnataka government.. finance minister is not doing anything in state.
GST 90% he kardo revolutionary Nirmala Tai
TAX 90% he kar lo
There should be no gst on any essentials ..
We don't need these blame games. We don't care if there was tax for insurance during UPA or not. We just want you to remove tax on health insurance.. that's it lady.
Every year i pay 30 k premium for medical Insurance, but Not getting Any facilities, In my opinion 18 % Gst is too High .. should be minimise the rate
yuck. so pedestrian.
and, just so you know, this is considered top place to debate a our nations future pretty much, and that's how these people do it.
Justifying amount goes to state so central also will take?
Shameless finance minister
He statement and her career is built on the fundamental: “I am not doing anything new, this was well before in the BJP government”
So what new is she doing: Serving same wine in a new bottle with label, “Nothing New”
Shameless
Her incompetence is only exceeded by her arrogant attitude. Instead of considering the merits of Gadkari’s suggestion, she is getting into middle school brawl and shaming state governments to be a bigger thug. Does not bode well for the BJP.
Dumbest FM ever
India's step towards 20 trillion economy...
By fleecing common people's hard earned money by burdening them with un necessary taxes India will reach its goal of becoming 20 trillion economy...
We all should be happy about this...
By doing this FM and ruling party is trying best to create atleast 2-3 cr jobs by end of this year..also by giving taxes the roads and infrastructure will be also improved..and also Education and medical facilities for common people will be provided at a very less rate...so ya We all shoud be happy that India is soon going to be DEVELOPED NATION and will compete with USA,UK,UAE,KSA,Japan,China,Germany,Australia etc etc in terms of development ,infra, and Literacy rate etc etc...
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Saarey Jahan se Acchaa Hindustaan Hamara..🇮🇳
What is a middle class person gaining from this??
Soon GST on breathing and even walking than blame something happened long long long back..
Indian governement can tax how much every required. Provided they have the capacity to achieve the below:
There is a safe place to walk, cycle and wheelchair access in public places not just in malls, tech parks and gated communities.
Have world class public transport - AC buses, Trains and Airports.
Have world class government education system.
Have world class safety 24*7 phycially or digitally.
Have world class healthcare not just for the poor.
FSSAI should gade each product's nutrition value and inspect resturents fequently.
Insead of banning 10 and 15 years old vechciles have good traffic rules and infrastructure. Like speed limit of 100+ Kmph.
Promote tourism not just for Indians.
Increase government employee's salary and make it impossible to bribe them.
Most importantly have vision, plan and implement. Instead of planning and implementing in a cycle. Have mindset to move from developing country to developed country.
Silly logic. Speak about the future on what can be done to reduce GST on at least health insurance premiums.
Medical inflation is at an all time high.
Kindly remove this gst otherwise 2029 me opposition me baithne ka mauka nhi mileage itni kam seat milegi....
Madam Sitaraman is only taking a Political position.
Please be sensible and reduce GST on Health Insurance immediately.
Don’t carry on with blame game.
Congress did it but BJP can remove it. But they won't. More tax on cigarettes and alcohol. Similar tax on medicines and hospital expenses and insurance 😅
When NDA can remove article 370, madam why can't the NDA government correct this GST or Tax issue. When madam you know it is wrong you could have corrected it,even you are also into blame game.The end customer is impacted very badly,who is suffering medically.why should any government be so cruel.
What kind of logic ... then why one nation one tax
I don’t have prejudice on BJP I talk positive when they do something commendable but here the logic of our honourable FM is - I’m not a culprit because we are following opposition. Democracy sometimes is restricted to just competition with the opposition and not focusing on issues to solve for. All blame game!
Satya gayi hai
Tax is killing middle class
Upto 5lakhs tax relief if u taking gst on all items
Then 7.5 lkhs 5% n so on
Most of the states in India are ruled by the BJP or with allies. Let them reduce it in their states and show examples for the opposition to follow. If you have no answer for a genuine concern, blaming the opposition ruled states is not fair when your own minister Gadkari demands it.
Tax like England & service like Somalia
Everytime I see my groceries bill the gst & inflation hitting my money but in name of facility even govt school take money for admission & my colony road is made by donations from residents not by government. Now they want medical insurance gst. Worst FM
I request all the haters to listen carefully what she is saying. Just don't jump in angry only because others are doing. She is saying the state tax should be reduced by respective states of our country!! Many MLA and state ministers loot the peoples money in a way of state taxes. But the central gov is just taking some amt as tax and trying their best use of it for people, but the middle eaters of the state ministers put their own high taxes on everything which makes the prices higher. Simply the people who are shouting oh tax tax, only because others are saying. If the state taxes reduces by the respective state gov everyone will be happy by the prices of products. Everyone is just falling in well just because the front one is falling. If some hate people see this comment he/she will call be 'Andhbhakt '. 😂😂😂 so what is happening is good only. By the way I am also a middle class family❤❤
She is literally talking nonsense sometimes and not considering gravity of the situation. We being 20% bracket,
- give tax to the government,
- then invest our money which is also taxable on return,
- spend of daily wages which is also taxable,
- If want to travel on roads then submit toll fee and road tax (mumbai's road conditions are worst in rainy season and by any other means also)
- if by train and by travel insurance with ticket.
- then to secure family and self medical condition buy health insurance which is also taxable,
In return we are getting, inflation in groceries such as
- pulses, ghee, milk, curd, tea powder, sanitari pads also
- education fees are getting high on daily basis which education system is still following legacy methods.
- No security of the jobs at workspace
Suppose, one middle class earning person in his tenure of 10 years suppose, submitted 12-15 lakhs of Tax to the government. In return,
- will government secure our family is something happens to that earning person?
- will it provide jobs?
- will it provide basic expense to the family?
- will it take care of their families medical condition?
In other countries, if an employee is paying 36% tax to their government, his own and his family health has been totally taken care by the government. Even normal general physician visit get covered in that plan. Also if got jobless, Government is standing with him.
In our country, if we become jobless, we have to go on the roads and beg for the jobs and food to serve to the family. Our government and FM should rethink on their Tax piece also Ask one question to ownself, are they seriously contributing to anything to the country?