Indians are crying for more taxes , see other countries in state of world war and crisis all over the world prices of all things are very high and taxes are high in other countries compared to india
Sir, for the time being, citizens must just understand and be happy that we as INDIA are moving in the direction of self sufficiency. We are not carrying a begging bowl and asking funds to IMF or WORLD banks, especially during natural calamities. Do you remember CYCLONES and flood scenarios before 2014. Any disaster and there used to be " DONATE GENEROUSLY" messages flashing across the media. SIR, Natural calamities are the same, but there are two major differences, human life loss in such calamities have reduced due to advance alert and the CM's and PM's begging messages have disappeared.......isn't it
sorry to inform you but middle class screw hota tha, hota hai aur hota rahega until some other revenue stream for govt pops up. The only thing we can do is switch our employee mindset to business mindset.
Jaab tak reservation rahega taab taak middle class sab kuch zhelega. Dukh hota hai is baat ka Parr kya kare 70 saal se yahi hota tha aur agle 70 saal yahi hoga.
How come metaphor ? Your respected RG was showing halwa ceremony photo and asking why there are no SC or OBC caste guy in the photo !! What kind of childish question was that ?
@@Mandar1209 I appreciate your question and am ready to answer it. Provided you tell me how you ended up stating, “Your respected RG.” What do you mean by that?
@@ranendas73abe chu vahi papu is fighting for middle class people... What justification she gave about increase of taxes... Nil... And you have no problem with it
@@s-qc9ns Why are you taking this to 100%? All he is talking about is equal or common-sense representation. 1 in 20 is definitely not common-sense representation. That is all. Ghuma ghuma kar baat kyun karna, my friend?
@@PALY_LIKE_EGALE Sirji, this halwa distributor has done some miracle I suppose. Earlier any disaster like cyclone or floods, first thing that used to happen was CM relief fund and PM relief fund use to open. Not for distribution of funds but sorry to say, begging for funds. Where are those messages post 2014? Defense and road ministry used to cry , NO FUNDS. Those things are unheard of post 2014. Sir, andhbhakt na बनने के डर से आप तो MANDHBHAKT बन गए......
@@krishnaakalkot absolutely correct sir But that's her duty to manage our funds in the right way I don't have any problem with spending money but collecting taxes from people is very rubbish especially in this budget.18 percent GST in insurance government has to give reassurance to people but it's collecting 18% form the insurence money is it's a good move absolutely not and increasing STT in F&O profitable traders not that impact but for loss making trader's it's very bad and removing indexation benifit for the real estate and many more these are all is good for the people please if you give a valid explanation about these statements I'll remove this comment
What is a good budget? 0 taxes? Majority of the welfare schemes is benefiting poor SC/ST and OBC farmers only, from upper caste money. On top of that Rahul is asking caste of those officers.
Scr* ew your false propaganda.. what is ur qualification to talk about this? Do you even know the capabilities or qualifications of those in budget? What u r talking people can’t afford halwa? And u can’t afford halwa but can afford Internet and electronic device to comment? don’t exaggerate or spread false propoganda.. what’s good budget for you? u want tax free and free monthly pocket money to all from Government and sit idle like a lazy oaf and make such useless comments? And as a result of which India has to go beg around for money again as it did during CONgress rule? or make taxes corruptive people friendly so that corrupt people can evade taxes? the uproar in Parliament by Opposition is not for people it’s because they can’t launder money or evade taxes.. we want to work and get dignified income and don’t expect freebies which dampen economic growth of India and also the productiveness of people of India..
FM, come out on street and see how hard life is for poor people here. Sometimes come out of your fancy car and bungalow to witness reality. You budget lacked empathy and compassion. You have screwed the life of poor and middle class. You are just a voice of top brass of BJP.
@@dikshantupadhyay552loafer that's the reason u people never cultivated land.created caste untouchablity and religiously denied education to obc sc st. Ultimately u urself become slaves of invaders. Mehenat Karo in positive direction.
Ma'am a request to you! Pls list out the list of Honest officials across the Country, across all departments with a written promise that they have never taken a penny of Bribe! Unfortunately corruption is at its peak today and no reporting is helping! Horrible state of the country ma'am!
@@usodhi what an idea Sirji......very innovative. Did you question something like this before 2014 or you feel Corruption has been discovered in India after 2014?
Before 2014 everybody from peon to higher officials, ministers were corrupted, now only top riches and ministers are corrupted and the lower officials doesn't even have a clue, small businessman doesn't get contracts as all the contractors are the friend of governments, and the remaining middle class doesn't have a clue but pay taxes and more taxes and the freebies for the poor section people donot get the freebies facility 100 percent as they are been eaten up by the middleman brokers of the government itself..and this is all going in the country, nice
FM doesn’t eat onion, but loves to take time to discuss about halwa, while taking away money by way of taxes from the middle class people. She & treasury bench didn’t get that it was a metaphor. Dumb Speaker is smiling all the time when his party speaks, and looks grim when opposition members speak.
Sir, u missed the whole juice of the speech and instead of drinking the juice you threw it away and are drinking and sharing the garbage that was not even a part of the speech. Listen to it again and before that listen to Shri Rahul Gandhi's speech in parliament to which the FM is replying.
Sir, counting the persons and drawing conclusions on the basis of CASTE of the people in the photograph, was not a metaphor.......it was an effort of some caste based research where Congress is trying to again divide the community who had just started coming together after forgetting the past.
Halwa tau sirf finance minister khud aur apne बीजेपी leaders ko khilana chahti hain woh bhi middle class जनता se cheen kar kyuki yeh onion mehnga hone pr onion 🌰 khana chor deti hain yeh sirf english courses krke sirf english mei bashan dena janti hain finance mei tau yeh kuch nahi janti kyuki aam loggo ko lutna tau hr bajat mei krti hain yeh
@@VenkatachalamA-vj8smHe is not against that halwa ceremony . . Rahul Gandhi context is to give importance to daliths , obc and middle class people . . In that way he said halwa is not circulated to 72% of Indian people . . He doesn't mean that original halwa
@@nareshchityala8950 he only wants to bring caste in every matter... Here FM asked the right question about how many Dalits, obc and adivasi people present during upa governments halwa ceremony
@@sahilnaik6693 Halwa ceremony is not the issue here . . How FM screwing middle class people's life in the name of taxation is the main issue . . And Rahul also not asking her about their halwa ceremony or taste of halwa . . He is saying that taxation benefits are not reaching the 72% of indians
Is the FM stupid enough to not understand that Rahul spoke metaphorically of Halwa.. He meant the budget actually.. This lady is totally incompetent & good only for her arrogant talks
No .. he did not speak metaphorically... He spoke about the halwa ceremony that precedes each budget presentation… asking where is the OBC, where is the Dalit.
He indicated halwa as budget metaphorically only.. even we see as what you say, then why were there no OBC or dalit officials or officers in BUDGET HALWA ceremony (meaning Budget team members/officials) officials
@@shivaramprasadpulagam6655 Just like you who are stupid enough to ask a stupid question like you did. Supporting is good but blindly supporting is stupidity. Open your ears and brain and think why Rahul Gandhi actually brought up this question. Then you'll get your answer. Why are you acting like our current FM? One is enough we don't want more like her.
Hallelujah 🙌🏻!!!!! The daily jesus devotional has been a huge part of my transformation, God is good 🙌🏻🙌🏻. I was owing a loan of $49,000 to the bank for my son's brain surgery, Now I'm no longer in debt after I invested $11,000 and got my payout of $290,500 every month…God bless Mrs Susan Jane Christy ❤️
I've always wanted to be involved for a long time but the volatility in the price has been very confusing to me. Although I have watched a lot of RUclips videos about it but I still find it hard to understand
The fact that she is commenting about halwa for 15 mins means RG's speech hit real hard. She is defensive about a useless budget and now cannot hide because finally there is strong opposition. Stop talking about Nehru and Indira. Pretty soon your legacy will be only halwa!!
They decreased the interests on PPF from 8 to 7.1 They increased the tax on capital gains This government just doesn't want people to save any money whatsover bas inko tax bharte raho.. shameful
@@DeepakKumar-el4bm Sir, this is what she explained in her address in the parliament. That for the budget preparation everyone involved, are locked up in a building. Earlier days it used to be 8 days now 5 days. No telephone lines, no going out of the building and no connection with the outside world. So from initial days itself it was a ritual for HALWA CEREMONY, as it's considered auspicious to begin with eating something sweet before the start of any good work. Neither BJP has started this trend not Ms.Seetharaman. Nothing scientific only traditional.
@@krishnaakalkot it means that the budget is prepared in 5 days ? Why don’t they work on it throughout the year. Maybe it could help them create better budgets
@@DeepakKumar-el4bm What a joke u are cracking Sir. System samjho. Parliament ke full speeches suno. Shorts dekho gey toh yahi haal hoga sir. Poora samjhaney ke liye likhoonga toh log boltey hai kitna lamba likhta hai. Shorts mein likhta hoon. Bhai, saal bhar ki tayaari hoti hai. Last mein jab usko final document ke roop mein laana hota hai, toh yeh procedure hai. Nahi toh business class and media pehle hi uska benefit legi aur प्रचार कर लेगी। और अब अच्छे कम्प्यूटिंग एंड प्रिंटिंग टेक्नोलॉजी aagaye है तो 8 days ki jagah 5 days kar diya hai........ aagey chal kar shaayad aur 1 - 2 days kum hojaye
Nirmala sitaram is not fit for the finance minister.Nimala must step down from her position and give finance ministry to young talent candidates in india like The Great ManMohan Singh and chidambaram. If she continues as finance minister soon india will face bankruptcy.#ResignNirmala #ResignFinanceMinister
she says don't work , don't earn , don't save. don't pay TAX or if you want to work hard and earn money then you have to leave this country. if you work hard in this country you will punished with high TAX
@@cyrus676 Germany is a developed nation my guy and history for Germany is way different than India. Compare what India was when it got freedom and what was Germany having already at that time. Comparing India to Germany is odd and I think this comment was only talking about high tax lol as if other countries don't charge tax. Germany per capita income was 12000$ approx back in 1950s and India was approx 200$ at the time of independence. There's no comparison boss. India has grown really fast and even now it is doing it. its just coz of past India is already at a disadvantage.
She discussed halwa in parliament but not the inequality issue. She is acting like teacher of a govt school like she wants to teach what she wants but not what is important and actually required. 😂
That job is created by them because BJP has given power and allocating projects only to them .. if they were not favoured even some PSUs need not be sold and they would have provided jobs.. even BSNL is not upgraded to 4G by government so that BSNL (a govt company) doesn't compete with Airtel or JIO .. 4G had been introduced 10years back but why is it still not updated in BSNL .. Because it is the scam of Modi government not to update BSNL and thereby give profit to Ambani , while he updates till 5G and earns more and more
Who make A1 n A2...pappu isliye utha Raha hai ki....paise nahi mil raha hai....but is Pappu se pucho Congress ke state me inhi se dealing kaise ho jati hai....sab paise ka khel hai...aur garibo ko bewakoof banana...Modi sabhi Indians ko apne pairon pe khada karna chahta hai...n Pappu chahta hai ki ye ho gaya to vote kaise milega
the matter raised by rahul was a halwa or did he said that oc bc people are not in halwa ceremony ?... i mean what a joke.. finance minister is now taking time to polish her politics with a name of halwa.... depressing non sense....
@@sps7770 Jd seelam from ST and Namo narain MEENA from SC in halwa pic with chidambaram. BJP ke ab tak ke kisi bhi halwa pic me 1 bhi dhund k dikhado ab aap.maine 2 to sirf photo me dikha diye. Nai yakin to google karle. Ye 2 photo me hai boht sare log hai list me ST sC obc google kar list surname se pata chal jata hai gawar bhakt. Congress ke adhyaksh kharge ki jaat pata hai? BJP me konsi uchi post pe SC sT hai? Presindent mat bolna wo BJP ka nahi hota🤣
you must be a big fan of Pazhaniswami Chidambaram. Yes no FM can match him in terms of scams and all the money he and his son have looted from the Indian exchequer. You need to call and get your share of his loot before he forgets you.
Politically BJP is correct, but on Economics both BJP and Congress have the same ideology more or less. The Finance minister was mentioning that the tweak to Capital Gains was done more for uniformity and not for increasing the tax revenues. I would ask if uniformity was the goal, why not have indexation for all assets. My problem is not with the increase in the rates itself but negating the impact of inflation by removing indexation. Does not make any logical sense for me and many I am sure. Bureaucrats in the finance ministry may know better.
Where is Om Birls's objection to every 2nd word while Nirmala ji speaks, unlike he does it to the opposition? "Mananiya sadas.... Mananiya sadas!! Nauuuuuuu (*It's a long freaking NO. This is how it sounds*)!!!"
It Pains the Middle class of this Country to know this one concrete individual is demolishing their lives forever 😢! She never ever felt any pain; her only emotion is anger with arrogance 😡!
I am not rich, but a middle-class citizen paying 30% tax overall, in return what i am getting? nothing. ok someone says we are getting road infra in return etc, but is that free for you atleast who is paying 30% tax?. still paying high road toll tax. Even in USA they dont collect that much toll tax. This is seriously unacceptable.
@@venkatg3492 …..we have LOP advocating for more divisions & concessions for SC,ST,OBC ,Farmers etc . Instead ,shouldn’t the leaders try to encourage & uplift ppl to more financial freedom & better ,wider participation of tax payment ? Hardly 2 or 3 % of Indians only pay direct taxes .
What ever she says it doesn't make any sense why India collects taxes like england and have facilities like Somalia. She must resign and listen to her husband.
FM is talking about the halwa making process but not about the content in the halwa, what is the point in the halwa making process if halwa cannot be digested by common people.
And the nation is not interested in knowing what Nehru, Indira or Rajiv said abt reservation.. We wanna know this govt’s response regarding reservation & social justice is needed in all sectors
FM aapka kaam se aam janta ko muh meetha karne ke avasar nahin tha. Garib aur garib ho gaye. Aam janta ke khwaab ko ujaad diye. Mehengayi aur zyada badh jayegi. Logo ka neend uda di. Aur app jaake halwa kha rahen hain aur khila rahein hain humare mehnet ke paiso se.
Why does BJP always get into the whataboutery tangles and ties its own hands ? If the question was about conducting caste census, say if you will conduct it or you will not conduct it.
Rahul: Let's talk about equal representation and the poor, the dalits, and the middle class - Did they get anything? No only you got halwa. FM: I will talk about the history of halwa, and if time permits I will also share the recipe.
FM is a doctorate in "not answering to the point and beating behind the bush" when it comes to responding questions of fact! Her idiotic extension to the halwa story is making my appetite lose interest in all halwas.
Nice that she stood up to reply to the Halua note. How about replying to the more significant points raised as well? Or, will you only reply when your ego is wounded?
This man never do any research, his own grand ma main man PN Haksar who controlled everything during emergency was kashmir pandit, current finance secretary TV sominathan was additional secretary at Manmohan singh pmo for 3 years, bg Deshmukh cabinet secretary during indira gandhi was another upper caste ias officer, someone ask him to which caste pc alexander belong to his father right hand man, he just throw anything in media and his pr merchant make it narrative, bjp claim to be biggest party in the world with all sources can't even form proper team of fact check and rebuttal
Finally calculation is middle class and poor people's of great India will suffer and rich polititian and rich business men will live like a king and drain blood of Indian citizens in name of taxes.... 😴😔
now days parliament is more interesting than Big boss , Netflix, web series 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ms. Finance Minister has not answered the question of equity
ST VALMIKI fund looted like in Karnataka by congress like that please give Rahul Gandhi chance to loot every where then we got equality.
Because it was a senseless question which had to be answered senselessly.
U shud do ur schooling again
Indians are crying for more taxes , see other countries in state of world war and crisis all over the world prices of all things are very high and taxes are high in other countries compared to india
Sir, for the time being, citizens must just understand and be happy that we as INDIA are moving in the direction of self sufficiency. We are not carrying a begging bowl and asking funds to IMF or WORLD banks, especially during natural calamities. Do you remember CYCLONES and flood scenarios before 2014. Any disaster and there used to be " DONATE GENEROUSLY" messages flashing across the media. SIR, Natural calamities are the same, but there are two major differences, human life loss in such calamities have reduced due to advance alert and the CM's and PM's begging messages have disappeared.......isn't it
It pains me respected FM to know that the middle class is getting screwed again and again.
sorry to inform you but middle class screw hota tha, hota hai aur hota rahega until some other revenue stream for govt pops up.
The only thing we can do is switch our employee mindset to business mindset.
Why dont u talk about removing reservation by congress.
Jaab tak reservation rahega taab taak middle class sab kuch zhelega. Dukh hota hai is baat ka Parr kya kare 70 saal se yahi hota tha aur agle 70 saal yahi hoga.
The average Indian income is 18k per family . Now re think who is actually middle class
Remote control 😂
Oh god... She didn't get that Halwa was a metaphor. I thought she had better intellect.
Stupid , It's not metaphor , it's actually Halwa , she cooked 🤡👆 its tradition
How come metaphor ?
Your respected RG was showing halwa ceremony photo and asking why there are no SC or OBC caste guy in the photo !! What kind of childish question was that ?
@@Mandar1209 I appreciate your question and am ready to answer it. Provided you tell me how you ended up stating, “Your respected RG.” What do you mean by that?
better than sonia+pappu and her watever sister
@@ranendas73abe chu vahi papu is fighting for middle class people... What justification she gave about increase of taxes... Nil... And you have no problem with it
Everyone knows halwa was a metaphor! Lack of common sense by the FM!
Rahul can't speak any facts because facts need evidence. So he speaks in metaphors which don't need more than 2 braincells to generate cheap laughs.
Making mockery out of herself.
@@s-qc9ns Why are you taking this to 100%? All he is talking about is equal or common-sense representation. 1 in 20 is definitely not common-sense representation. That is all. Ghuma ghuma kar baat kyun karna, my friend?
@@s-qc9nsJust 70 years of reservation will not equalise the crimes done by higher caste against lower caste for 1000’s of years.
Balak buddhi bafoon pappu can't understand even this.
This Birla, does he even know tbat he is expected to be neutral?
He is completely biased
He knows that he was not chosen for neutrality.
Birla nahi Billa hai ye toh
@@Thepunamvlogs11 po-teh-to, po-tah-to, same thing when it comes to these people
Pappu 😂
Finance minister ❌ halwa distributor ✅
😂😂😂
@@PALY_LIKE_EGALE free rice bag distributor ✔️
😂😂
@@PALY_LIKE_EGALE
Sirji, this halwa distributor has done some miracle I suppose.
Earlier any disaster like cyclone or floods, first thing that used to happen was CM relief fund and PM relief fund use to open. Not for distribution of funds but sorry to say, begging for funds. Where are those messages post 2014? Defense and road ministry used to cry , NO FUNDS. Those things are unheard of post 2014. Sir, andhbhakt na बनने के डर से आप तो MANDHBHAKT बन गए......
@@krishnaakalkot absolutely correct sir
But that's her duty to manage our funds in the right way I don't have any problem with spending money but collecting taxes from people is very rubbish especially in this budget.18 percent GST in insurance government has to give reassurance to people but it's collecting 18% form the insurence money is it's a good move absolutely not and increasing STT in F&O profitable traders not that impact but for loss making trader's it's very bad and removing indexation benifit for the real estate and many more these are all is good for the people please if you give a valid explanation about these statements I'll remove this comment
Screw your halwa story. First assemble a team that knows economics and make good budget. Middleclass cannot afford to buy halwa you get free halwa
What is a good budget? 0 taxes? Majority of the welfare schemes is benefiting poor SC/ST and OBC farmers only, from upper caste money. On top of that Rahul is asking caste of those officers.
Jobless idiot you are commenting here freely post-Covid, bcoz of this FM, or else you would be suffering like people in other countries...
Scr* ew your false propaganda.. what is ur qualification to talk about this? Do you even know the capabilities or qualifications of those in budget? What u r talking people can’t afford halwa? And u can’t afford halwa but can afford Internet and electronic device to comment? don’t exaggerate or spread false propoganda.. what’s good budget for you? u want tax free and free monthly pocket money to all from Government and sit idle like a lazy oaf and make such useless comments? And as a result of which India has to go beg around for money again as it did during CONgress rule? or make taxes corruptive people friendly so that corrupt people can evade taxes? the uproar in Parliament by Opposition is not for people it’s because they can’t launder money or evade taxes.. we want to work and get dignified income and don’t expect freebies which dampen economic growth of India and also the productiveness of people of India..
@@rajx7120padu tujhe?
@@rajx7120are you a complete idiot or are you just pretending? I think it’s the former, nevertheless not your fault.
FM, come out on street and see how hard life is for poor people here. Sometimes come out of your fancy car and bungalow to witness reality. You budget lacked empathy and compassion. You have screwed the life of poor and middle class. You are just a voice of top brass of BJP.
if you stay poor and middle class...you will be f=kd..not just in india but in any country...who asked u to stay poor godddamitt..
मेहनत करो और पैसे कमाओ
It is because of the 75year congress rule
@@dikshantupadhyay552loafer that's the reason u people never cultivated land.created caste untouchablity and religiously denied education to obc sc st.
Ultimately u urself become slaves of invaders.
Mehenat Karo in positive direction.
@@dikshantupadhyay552loafer then stop 10 percent ews quota to 15 percent baniya brahmin businesses oriented people😂
If you are following Indian culture then why bringing foreign tax policy
Why so many details... halwa was a metaphor...
Bz dumb Rahul Gandhi is pointed out
Really? Check the photo upon which Rahul gave his statement.
Ma'am a request to you! Pls list out the list of Honest officials across the Country, across all departments with a written promise that they have never taken a penny of Bribe! Unfortunately corruption is at its peak today and no reporting is helping! Horrible state of the country ma'am!
@@usodhi what an idea Sirji......very innovative. Did you question something like this before 2014 or you feel Corruption has been discovered in India after 2014?
Before 2014 everybody from peon to higher officials, ministers were corrupted, now only top riches and ministers are corrupted and the lower officials doesn't even have a clue, small businessman doesn't get contracts as all the contractors are the friend of governments, and the remaining middle class doesn't have a clue but pay taxes and more taxes and the freebies for the poor section people donot get the freebies facility 100 percent as they are been eaten up by the middleman brokers of the government itself..and this is all going in the country, nice
crying to def ears... who is blind and heartless, lately gone mindless..
FM doesn’t eat onion, but loves to take time to discuss about halwa, while taking away money by way of taxes from the middle class people. She & treasury bench didn’t get that it was a metaphor. Dumb Speaker is smiling all the time when his party speaks, and looks grim when opposition members speak.
daam and she is the one who is fm, what a shame like this kind of people will ridicule and look down on you for eating non veg food.
Sir, u missed the whole juice of the speech and instead of drinking the juice you threw it away and are drinking and sharing the garbage that was not even a part of the speech. Listen to it again and before that listen to Shri Rahul Gandhi's speech in parliament to which the FM is replying.
Sir, counting the persons and drawing conclusions on the basis of CASTE of the people in the photograph, was not a metaphor.......it was an effort of some caste based research where Congress is trying to again divide the community who had just started coming together after forgetting the past.
Halwa tau sirf finance minister khud aur apne बीजेपी leaders ko khilana chahti hain woh bhi middle class जनता se cheen kar kyuki yeh onion mehnga hone pr onion 🌰 khana chor deti hain yeh sirf english courses krke sirf english mei bashan dena janti hain finance mei tau yeh kuch nahi janti kyuki aam loggo ko lutna tau hr bajat mei krti hain yeh
Because caste system involved it hurts people
Speakers are supposed to be neutral. This clown has no shame in supporting his own party folks while debating.
All he can say to the opposition is "Nauuuuoooo!!"
Rahul Gandhi never say anything against Halwa
Who show photo
@@VenkatachalamA-vj8smHe is not against that halwa ceremony . . Rahul Gandhi context is to give importance to daliths , obc and middle class people . . In that way he said halwa is not circulated to 72% of Indian people . . He doesn't mean that original halwa
@@nareshchityala8950woh apne samay kitna sc st obc ko halwa ceremony me rakha tha chamcha German Shepherd ka chela😂
@@nareshchityala8950 he only wants to bring caste in every matter... Here FM asked the right question about how many Dalits, obc and adivasi people present during upa governments halwa ceremony
@@sahilnaik6693 Halwa ceremony is not the issue here . . How FM screwing middle class people's life in the name of taxation is the main issue . . And Rahul also not asking her about their halwa ceremony or taste of halwa . . He is saying that taxation benefits are not reaching the 72% of indians
What a disgrace ? She sounds like a disgruntled Mother-In-Law nitpicking on her daughter-in-law (Us Middle Class) 🤣🤣
Shameless FM😂😂
What's shameless about it???
Shameless FM
Actress butti.. Shame
Are you pasmanda muslim or ahamadiya muslim??
Yes bond lady
Worst arrogant FM of india😂
sonia g will be very happy with ur performance...f perfromace
She will take many families down financially single handedly.
Good Job FM Madam... बराबर ठोका
@@nitinkumar-iz5uxwhat was the tax slab during the congress regime? If your family didn't go down then, it definitely won't go down now...
@@ranendas73modi too😂
Is the FM stupid enough to not understand that Rahul spoke metaphorically of Halwa.. He meant the budget actually.. This lady is totally incompetent & good only for her arrogant talks
No .. he did not speak metaphorically... He spoke about the halwa ceremony that precedes each budget presentation… asking where is the OBC, where is the Dalit.
He indicated halwa as budget metaphorically only.. even we see as what you say, then why were there no OBC or dalit officials or officers in BUDGET HALWA ceremony (meaning Budget team members/officials) officials
@@anirutha_te So budget team should be comprised of lower castes and not by people on merit. Got it, thanks. 👍🏾
is it not stupidity that Rahul Gandhi counting number of obc and sc&st among the officers who prepared budget ?
@@shivaramprasadpulagam6655 Just like you who are stupid enough to ask a stupid question like you did.
Supporting is good but blindly supporting is stupidity.
Open your ears and brain and think why Rahul Gandhi actually brought up this question. Then you'll get your answer.
Why are you acting like our current FM? One is enough we don't want more like her.
She is from Tamil Nadu, I know in Tamil nadu we say sarcastically Halwa to fool someone 😡😡😡
Hallelujah 🙌🏻!!!!! The daily jesus devotional has been a huge part of my transformation, God is good 🙌🏻🙌🏻. I was owing a loan of $49,000 to the bank for my son's brain surgery, Now I'm no longer in debt after I invested $11,000 and got my payout of $290,500 every month…God bless Mrs Susan Jane Christy ❤️
Hello!! how do you make such monthly, I’m a born Christian and sometimes I feel so down of myself 😭 because of low finance but I still believe God
Thanks to my co-worker (Carson ) who suggested Ms Susan Jane Christy
After I raised up to 525k trading with her I bought a new House and a car here in the states🇺🇸🇺🇸 also paid for my son's surgery….Glory to God, shalom.
Can I also do it??? My life is facing lots of challenges lately
I've always wanted to be involved for a long time but the volatility in the price has been very confusing to me. Although I have watched a lot of RUclips videos about it but I still find it hard to understand
Shame on Indian Government and Finance Minister 😢
Budget ceremony ❎
Halwa ceremony ✅
Speaker is the biggest mc the way he is commenting he is so biased always fo
Does the Finance minister pay Tax?
As an individual, Yes!
@@snehanandi7130 But I'm sure No Income Tax?
The fact that she is commenting about halwa for 15 mins means RG's speech hit real hard. She is defensive about a useless budget and now cannot hide because finally there is strong opposition. Stop talking about Nehru and Indira. Pretty soon your legacy will be only halwa!!
It's painful FM halwa is taken away from middle class
halwa sehath ke liye achchi nahi, tax thandurusthi badhayegi, buke sona achchi baath hai, cronies ke tax maaf karna punya ka kaam hai.. aayi baath samaj mai..
Halwa was never an issue is this the IQ level of finance minister
They decreased the interests on PPF from 8 to 7.1
They increased the tax on capital gains
This government just doesn't want people to save any money whatsover
bas inko tax bharte raho.. shameful
How many times did they cut to the speaker when she was speaking?
Bekar ki FM hai spoiled the middle class Market real maam you the worst of this government 😢
What he said and what she is saying. He said that there is no sc, st, obc. He meant to say they are missing that reach
Please hear it completely, she did spoke about it.
She said everything about the Halwa but about it's distribution which she was asked she said zero
From the past few days parliament has gone crazy 😂
Rahul Gandhi is 100% Right.
how? lol
I had sent a mail to modiji in 2020. That I lost my job, but still there is no reply
How is halwa distribution an emotional moment ? Please someone explain
@@DeepakKumar-el4bm
Sir, this is what she explained in her address in the parliament. That for the budget preparation everyone involved, are locked up in a building. Earlier days it used to be 8 days now 5 days. No telephone lines, no going out of the building and no connection with the outside world. So from initial days itself it was a ritual for HALWA CEREMONY, as it's considered auspicious to begin with eating something sweet before the start of any good work. Neither BJP has started this trend not Ms.Seetharaman.
Nothing scientific only traditional.
@@krishnaakalkot it means that the budget is prepared in 5 days ?
Why don’t they work on it throughout the year. Maybe it could help them create better budgets
@@DeepakKumar-el4bm
What a joke u are cracking Sir.
System samjho. Parliament ke full speeches suno. Shorts dekho gey toh yahi haal hoga sir. Poora samjhaney ke liye likhoonga toh log boltey hai kitna lamba likhta hai. Shorts mein likhta hoon.
Bhai, saal bhar ki tayaari hoti hai. Last mein jab usko final document ke roop mein laana hota hai, toh yeh procedure hai. Nahi toh business class and media pehle hi uska benefit legi aur प्रचार कर लेगी। और अब अच्छे कम्प्यूटिंग एंड प्रिंटिंग टेक्नोलॉजी aagaye है तो 8 days ki jagah 5 days kar diya hai........ aagey chal kar shaayad aur 1 - 2 days kum hojaye
After eating halwa digestion problem caused me pain.😢😢😢
Her Hindi is better than her answer.RG spoke metaphorically and she began with how the halva is being made and by whom.
Halwa is a British tradition please change it..
Indian constitution is almost taken from Beitish, then we must change😂😂 kya bhai😂😂
Ignorant comment
@@MashupVibes-hw1xp It's copy-paste from American constitution, including "We the People".
Then don't learn english plz learn Sanskrit 😂😂😂😂😂
Purana walas untouchablity creator walas.1000 yrs slave walas commenting On one of the finest literature of india .British boot lickers
Nirmala sitaram is not fit for the finance minister.Nimala must step down from her position and give finance ministry to young talent candidates in india like The Great ManMohan Singh and chidambaram.
If she continues as finance minister soon india will face bankruptcy.#ResignNirmala #ResignFinanceMinister
she says don't work , don't earn , don't save. don't pay TAX or if you want to work hard and earn money then you have to leave this country. if you work hard in this country you will punished with high TAX
you think foreign countries dont charge tax XD youre about to learn whole new world my guy haha
What does that mean. Taxation is only in India
@@KidGoku-g4vyes 40 percent tax in Germany,and also they give world class service free education and free Hospital facilities unlike here.
@@cyrus676 Germany is a developed nation my guy and history for Germany is way different than India. Compare what India was when it got freedom and what was Germany having already at that time.
Comparing India to Germany is odd and I think this comment was only talking about high tax lol as if other countries don't charge tax.
Germany per capita income was 12000$ approx back in 1950s and India was approx 200$ at the time of independence. There's no comparison boss. India has grown really fast and even now it is doing it. its just coz of past India is already at a disadvantage.
@@KidGoku-g4v funde dena bandh karo ande do, tax paying is our duty, but We can not ask for rights like basic infra, where is the balance?
She discussed halwa in parliament but not the inequality issue. She is acting like teacher of a govt school like she wants to teach what she wants but not what is important and actually required. 😂
Worst budget ever only benefited A1 and A2
A1 and A2 create jobs not you and me
That job is created by them because BJP has given power and allocating projects only to them .. if they were not favoured even some PSUs need not be sold and they would have provided jobs.. even BSNL is not upgraded to 4G by government so that BSNL (a govt company) doesn't compete with Airtel or JIO .. 4G had been introduced 10years back but why is it still not updated in BSNL .. Because it is the scam of Modi government not to update BSNL and thereby give profit to Ambani , while he updates till 5G and earns more and more
Who make A1 n A2...pappu isliye utha Raha hai ki....paise nahi mil raha hai....but is Pappu se pucho Congress ke state me inhi se dealing kaise ho jati hai....sab paise ka khel hai...aur garibo ko bewakoof banana...Modi sabhi Indians ko apne pairon pe khada karna chahta hai...n Pappu chahta hai ki ye ho gaya to vote kaise milega
@akshaytakkar6747 Our msme create jobs 10times than your A1 and A2 then don't tell too innocents about them
A1's and A2's rise began from Raul Vinci's father's government. Raul Vinci will never speak about this.
the matter raised by rahul was a halwa or did he said that oc bc people are not in halwa ceremony ?... i mean what a joke.. finance minister is now taking time to polish her politics with a name of halwa....
depressing non sense....
She has no common sense. Halwa is just a metaphor. 😂
This lady should just stop trying 🤦🤦🤦
Isko batao koi hinglish me ki rahul gandhi ka swal halwe pe nai tha usme sc st dalit kitne the ye tha
Lol Gandhi pehle ye data dein ki unke 10 saalo ke budget me kitne sc st dalit the.
@@sps7770 Jd seelam from ST and Namo narain MEENA from SC in halwa pic with chidambaram. BJP ke ab tak ke kisi bhi halwa pic me 1 bhi dhund k dikhado ab aap.maine 2 to sirf photo me dikha diye. Nai yakin to google karle. Ye 2 photo me hai boht sare log hai list me ST sC obc google kar list surname se pata chal jata hai gawar bhakt. Congress ke adhyaksh kharge ki jaat pata hai? BJP me konsi uchi post pe SC sT hai? Presindent mat bolna wo BJP ka nahi hota🤣
this is the most stupid FM Minister i have seen 😂.
you must be a big fan of Pazhaniswami Chidambaram. Yes no FM can match him in terms of scams and all the money he and his son have looted from the Indian exchequer. You need to call and get your share of his loot before he forgets you.
She had an elaborate answer to Halwa, but budget ke questions pe she couldn't say anything
Politically BJP is correct, but on Economics both BJP and Congress have the same ideology more or less. The Finance minister was mentioning that the tweak to Capital Gains was done more for uniformity and not for increasing the tax revenues. I would ask if uniformity was the goal, why not have indexation for all assets. My problem is not with the increase in the rates itself but negating the impact of inflation by removing indexation. Does not make any logical sense for me and many I am sure. Bureaucrats in the finance ministry may know better.
They wan more trading than investments
Very very indisciplined parliamentarians
😂😂😂i love the lok sabha ...... I love THIS party ..... This is epic more entertaining than a hollywood movie
Congress is a group of jokers😅😂
Our F.M. is Excellent and so Good. Jai F.M.
Comedian Rahul action so humourous
One of the strong Leader. Like the dialog. Dont bring idiots in the name of reservation.
Before halwa is cooked in their kichen according to their taste anything saved is given to people now its for indians so how shesada will like
Bjp lost a voter in me because of this wtch!!
I did exit last 11years after Vajapeyiji. all my old bjp friends said good bye already. nothing left in principle.
@@sateeshum394 only looting now in the name of govt
@@rose7777Karnataka me hame lootkar freebies derahe hai
The smirk on Rahul's face is driving them crazy. Btw did anyone notice Anurag slip ghutka into his mouth?
Worst finance minister in history of India
In tamil giving alwa is metaphor for cheating someone.. it is very apt for this budget 2024 for middle class people
Modi is cruel , You are also very cruel to Lower Middle class
School kids are very well mannered than these people..OMG
😂
I am tremendously "not sorry" that my sense of humor has offended your utter lack of it.
why so much noise?
they just want to disturb FM but she is never disturbed!
The only people who will be suffering from this new budget is the middle class, nothing more than that. Its true cruelty
when people did not understand sircasam
this happens
This is the same women who told that trading is not for middle class.
Finance minister is too much selfish....
Wu personally aisa karrhi hai kiya ??nhi na phir
Where is Om Birls's objection to every 2nd word while Nirmala ji speaks, unlike he does it to the opposition?
"Mananiya sadas.... Mananiya sadas!! Nauuuuuuu (*It's a long freaking NO. This is how it sounds*)!!!"
It Pains the Middle class of this Country to know this one concrete individual is demolishing their lives forever 😢! She never ever felt any pain; her only emotion is anger with arrogance 😡!
It pains me sir. It pains me for not reducing corporate taxes to 20% and increasing taxes for common man upto 50%
FM of india is just not fit for anything, not even for making halwa. A new finance intern can do a better job then this old lady
I am not rich, but a middle-class citizen paying 30% tax overall, in return what i am getting? nothing. ok someone says we are getting road infra in return etc, but is that free for you atleast who is paying 30% tax?. still paying high road toll tax. Even in USA they dont collect that much toll tax. This is seriously unacceptable.
@@venkatg3492 …..we have LOP advocating for more divisions & concessions for SC,ST,OBC ,Farmers etc . Instead ,shouldn’t the leaders try to encourage & uplift ppl to more financial freedom & better ,wider participation of tax payment ? Hardly 2 or 3 % of Indians only pay direct taxes .
What ever she says it doesn't make any sense why India collects taxes like england and have facilities like Somalia. She must resign and listen to her husband.
FM is talking about the halwa making process but not about the content in the halwa, what is the point in the halwa making process if halwa cannot be digested by common people.
She is just like her leader Godi. Neither he understood the metaphor “Shakti” nor FM understood “Halwa”… 🙏🏼
Giving pain to the entire Indian minority poor ... For poor people she is not feeling pain shame
And the nation is not interested in knowing what Nehru, Indira or Rajiv said abt reservation.. We wanna know this govt’s response regarding reservation & social justice is needed in all sectors
Why speaker not telling don't talk about 2013,2014...... like told to Abhishek
FM aapka kaam se aam janta ko muh meetha karne ke avasar nahin tha.
Garib aur garib ho gaye.
Aam janta ke khwaab ko ujaad diye.
Mehengayi aur zyada badh jayegi.
Logo ka neend uda di.
Aur app jaake halwa kha rahen hain aur khila rahein hain humare mehnet ke paiso se.
Why does BJP always get into the whataboutery tangles and ties its own hands ? If the question was about conducting caste census, say if you will conduct it or you will not conduct it.
Rahul Gandhi halwa speach😂😂😂
Rahul: Let's talk about equal representation and the poor, the dalits, and the middle class - Did they get anything? No only you got halwa.
FM: I will talk about the history of halwa, and if time permits I will also share the recipe.
FM is a doctorate in "not answering to the point and beating behind the bush" when it comes to responding questions of fact!
Her idiotic extension to the halwa story is making my appetite lose interest in all halwas.
My favorite Indian dessert is halwa.
Unfortunately our FM is educated illiterate
Nice that she stood up to reply to the Halua note. How about replying to the more significant points raised as well? Or, will you only reply when your ego is wounded?
What she is really saying 😟?
Please make a separate budget for politician and charge them heavy taxes.
She knows pain😂😂😂A1 and A2 budget minister😂😂😂
She is a gentle ,genuine women , with culture and class .. Respect ✊ 🙏
Y congress wont talk about ban of reservations. Bcz of reservations india is worst affected. Reservations should be stopped.
Ews quota also should be banned
@@user-rx7my4zo7cyes of course
No caste no reservation 😍all are equal
Yes. First ban religion/caste system . Then they will no longer need reservation
Few haters of Indian Economy all over the place, please do not fall for comments. Wishing India good financial country and support taxations.
Caste reservation is not the need of the time. It should be driven out.
People are in Huge Pain Due to High GST Products Rates Affecting Big Time for Middle Class & Poors.
All those stupid MP’s keep shouting & interrupting Treasury benches should be thrown out for 1 to 2 weeks 👎🏿👎🏿
Yours.. Willing.. Is.. Always... Mine.... Don't... See.. Back..,. No.. One.. Can.. Stop.. Wishing you.. All.. The. Best👍💯
This man never do any research, his own grand ma main man PN Haksar who controlled everything during emergency was kashmir pandit, current finance secretary TV sominathan was additional secretary at Manmohan singh pmo for 3 years, bg Deshmukh cabinet secretary during indira gandhi was another upper caste ias officer, someone ask him to which caste pc alexander belong to his father right hand man, he just throw anything in media and his pr merchant make it narrative, bjp claim to be biggest party in the world with all sources can't even form proper team of fact check and rebuttal
Finally calculation is middle class and poor people's of great India will suffer and rich polititian and rich business men will live like a king and drain blood of Indian citizens in name of taxes.... 😴😔
Jitna halwa ka history janti hai Tai, agar thoda finance ,economics etc bi janti to better Hota.
Finance Minister should be like that but her argument logic on "Halua" as baseless as PNPC.
Nothing about Budget reply, all rubbish!
Rahul Gandhi 💙💙