The way this song ends 'early' is so moving. One of their best. Simple but so deep. "You could find better things to do, than to break my heart again". Showing such vulnerability and pain. 23 years old. Incredible.
Thank you so much Galeazzo Frudua. All your videos have really helped me out in singing. There really is no other videos like yours on all of youtube. I just wanna thank you for taking the time to do these. I've been watching these for over 2 or 3 years now and every time I wanna sing a Beatles song I go back to your videos to make sure I have it right. I love singing and I love harmonies. I believe music today doesn't really appreciates the beauty and importance of Harmonies. To me it's the best part of music. Thank you again.
My goodness, I was totally unaware of the 3rd high harmony for this song! I am a huge Beatles fan and I think you do an excellent job of teaching the harmonies! Why can't they write songs with prominent two and three part harmonies anymore? Thank you for your videos!
Thank you for choosing the Beatles for the most of your tutorials!!. I grew up with the Beatles music, play the songs on guitar and homerecording songs. For the singing part you are the perfect teacher. You do a very very good job. Thank you from Germany
Galleazzo...you do this song justice! Thanks for the amazing interpretation and breakdown of the 3 vocal parts...brilliant! Keep up the great work on these tremendous Beatles classics!
@westfield90 You can not have their voice but you can definitely learn their vocal techinques and perform with your own timbre and vocal colour. We will go through this in some videos later on.
Thank you Galeazzo, there is nothing like your tutorials on the net.. I do appreciate very much your work, it does help immensely when it comes to deconstruct harmonies and certainly one can learn a lot from it. Grazie.. chao..
Galeazzo, your videos are wonderful as is your singing and energy! My band is getting ready for a gig with lots of Beatles songs and I am very happy to have found these videos. Very helpful and very nicely done.
Hey Galeazzo, the site Beatlesebook says George has the high part: "It took thirteen more attempts to refine the arrangement to that of the finished product, which included switching to acoustic guitars so as to fit the melancholy mood of the song. George Harrison was given more to do, adding a single-note higher harmony on top of John and Paul's vocal parts, which created a lush atmosphere."
Interesting theory. Either it was George or they added Paul's higher single note vocal for the recording. It could be the latter as I've never seen them sing this live.
I really enjoy your work and how you break it all down into a science! As a fellow Beatles fan and musician I can attest that what you are instructing is completely accurate and is a highly entertaining way of studying and instructing others! Keep up the excellent work! Rgds, Wayne
Thanks A LOT David! RUclips has recently stopped allowing me to monetize my videos :( So I just rely on kind and generous people like you to support my work and have the chance to post more videos.
Brilliant work here man...very kind and generous to spend so much time breaking this stuff down and sharing it.Well done. I never could hear that Paul 2nd harmony on the record. Very hard to pick out as the 3 vocals blend like one.Thumbs up!!
Thanks friend. I love the harmony in that song, and was intrigued by that third high harmony that stays in the same key. Which I thought was George, but did think he sounded very Paul'ish. All three of the vocals sounds brilliant. I had figured Johns and Pauls vocals out, but that third, I really appreciate you doing the breakdown, cos I recognized how it went, a little, but would lose it while singing it
Beatlesebook says the high part is George, but it does sound Paulish, and I'm not sure George can sing that high. But my maybe he can, and Beatlesebook is very well-researched. So I don't know.
Very very nice. The Beatles' harmony is almost under mentioned because it is so flawless... and you do a great job of bringing it out so people can clearly understand the magic of the blending of the voices. I think you may also under-rate George... he provided the most difficult atonal type sound whereas Paul and John's harmonies were more basic (but very essential). In other words, John and Paul were the anchors and George provided the "wow" factor. I also love your song selections!
You sing so well and certainly the Beatles were amazing. I'm wondering if anyone can really learn to sing like this or is it that you just either have this natural talent or you don't. I tend you think you cannot learn this stuff and you either have it or don't. The Beatles certainly didn't take any classes but just had this natural talent.
@boliboy2299 I am trying to figure out hoe to make a video about this. There are a lot of factors that help. Having trained since I was 13 or so surely helped.
I'm sorry if there an unlike at your answer, I wanted to press the "like" button but the mouse got so short. Ah, and thank you for all of this videos, they're all powerful and useful to me singing "John's part", May I ask for more videos with Danni? They really gives an extra spacial part to this tutorials and Dan's voice is to closer to Lennon's. Greetings and a hug from México.
Fantastic job. One thing that would help me, and perhaps others would be extra trouble but maybe you would not mind trying it once. For the songs with three harmonies such as this one, if you could wear a different color shirt for each part it would be easier to see who was singing what in the final three-part version. Understand if you do not. Anyway, your work is fantastic, please keep it up.
Ur lesson is really really useful, tks! My netbook may be weak in speakers, but I could hear some interference between the guitar and John's vocal part - was ur John's version clear 100%?
bravo galeazzo ! hai scelto bene. i beatles hanno un impasto vocale incredibile e le loro canzoni possono essere accompagnate da una sola chitarra in quanto le parti vocali sono cosi' potenti , perfette , armoniose ( come tu dimostri molto bene ) Una domanda : che tu sappia i beatles andarono a scuola di canto o erano fenomeni naturali. su questo determinante particolare non ho mai letto niente. ciao grazie
Wow! I'm shocked. In all the years I've been doing this song, I never knew there was a third part. Paul is doing two parts?? I'm disappointed in my ear, I always thought it was just the one part each, John on the bottom & then Paul's part over him. I know that's an expensive mike your using, but do you have some kind of software that separate's voice tracks off the original recordings?
Loved this so much I was inspired to donate! But one quick question: What convinces you that Paul is singing that third, high harmony part? Many other sources agree that it was George singing this part.
How was Paul able to sing two different harmony parts on songs like this, And Your Bird..., and Wait? With only four tracks available, and the Beatles using two for instruments and two for vocals (the second often used for doubling), I don't see how they could have recorded three voices and doubled them all.
THESE BEATLES LESSONS MAY END! PLEASE DONATE TO KEEP THEM ALIVE!: ➡ goo.gl/ldPTmk -- WATCH HOW I RECORD MY VOCALS! ➡ bit.ly/2B7kgZU
This is one of my favourite Beatles tunes. That major-to-minor change throughout the song just blows my mind. SUCH an underrated song.
I know! So many underrated Beatle songs ! People need to listen to the albums, I know every word of every song 🙏🙏
The way this song ends 'early' is so moving. One of their best. Simple but so deep. "You could find better things to do, than to break my heart again". Showing such vulnerability and pain. 23 years old. Incredible.
Love the fact that he included the high E note Paul sings as a drone ...
Thank you so much Galeazzo Frudua. All your videos have really helped me out in singing. There really is no other videos like yours on all of youtube. I just wanna thank you for taking the time to do these. I've been watching these for over 2 or 3 years now and every time I wanna sing a Beatles song I go back to your videos to make sure I have it right. I love singing and I love harmonies. I believe music today doesn't really appreciates the beauty and importance of Harmonies. To me it's the best part of music. Thank you again.
Thanks a lot for your nice comment THANKS EVERYBODY for the likes the comments and for the support !
I'll make your words mine. Music today should really appreciate the beauty in vocal harmonies!
I'm amazed that you can hear three distinct voices. I wish my ears were that good.
My goodness, I was totally unaware of the 3rd high harmony for this song! I am a huge Beatles fan and I think you do an excellent job of teaching the harmonies! Why can't they write songs with prominent two and three part harmonies anymore? Thank you for your videos!
Fantastic. Hadn’t noticed Paul’s high harmony before.
Can't get enough of your passionate teaching!
Thank you for choosing the Beatles for the most of your tutorials!!. I grew up with the Beatles music, play the songs on guitar and homerecording songs. For the singing part you are the perfect teacher. You do a very very good job.
Thank you from Germany
Thanks again for this. I also never realised there was 3rd harmony… you're the man Galleazzo!
This song is a masterpiece. Very early one.
These vids only further highlight the Beatles genius. Great work!
Galleazzo...you do this song justice! Thanks for the amazing interpretation and breakdown of the 3 vocal parts...brilliant! Keep up the great work on these tremendous Beatles classics!
@westfield90 You can not have their voice but you can definitely learn their vocal techinques and perform with your own timbre and vocal colour. We will go through this in some videos later on.
Thank you Galeazzo, there is nothing like your tutorials on the net.. I do appreciate very much your work, it does help immensely when it comes to deconstruct harmonies and certainly one can learn a lot from it. Grazie.. chao..
It's so hard to pick a favorite because I love 98% of all their songs, but if I had to choose one or two it would be this one and "I Feel Fine" :)
Galeazzo, your videos are wonderful as is your singing and energy! My band is getting ready for a gig with lots of Beatles songs and I am very happy to have found these videos. Very helpful and very nicely done.
i am amazed the you have that ability to hear those harmonies. we play some beatles music and you have been a great help! thank you, jim
Brilliantly done, yet again Galeazzo. This is one of my favourite Beatles songs, I especially like John's vocal in this one. Great job!
I am so glad I found your video. I love singing in harmony and this one explained everything so well and simply. Thank you.
I have loved all these songs for 50 years :)
Thanks Ryan!
Thank you so much!! I've always wanted to know, how do you figure out the harmonies? :)
Hey Galeazzo, the site Beatlesebook says George has the high part:
"It took thirteen more attempts to refine the arrangement to that of the finished product, which included switching to acoustic guitars so as to fit the melancholy mood of the song. George Harrison was given more to do, adding a single-note higher harmony on top of John and Paul's vocal parts, which created a lush atmosphere."
Interesting theory. Either it was George or they added Paul's higher single note vocal for the recording. It could be the latter as I've never seen them sing this live.
HI it was 99% Paul overdubbing but I'll gladly check it agina and incase I'll add a note here.
@TheBeatlesVocalHarmony love your page by the way🙏
I really enjoy your work and how you break it all down into a science! As a fellow Beatles fan and musician I can attest that what you are instructing is completely accurate and is a highly entertaining way of studying and instructing others! Keep up the excellent work!
Rgds, Wayne
Great job ! And wuggiedougies' remarks are right on . George did provide "wow " on the harmonies !
Thank you Galeazzo. After learning six beatles song harmonies from you I decided to donate! Hope you can come to UK and sing over here sometime!
Thanks A LOT David! RUclips has recently stopped allowing me to monetize my videos :( So I just rely on kind and generous people like you to support my work and have the chance to post more videos.
The Beatles Vocal Harmony That is insane... all the beauty gurus get money. Is it because of the rights of the songs?
I don't know the videos just stuck under monetization review forever.. insane yes... considering it's free stuff.
Brilliant work here man...very kind and generous to spend so much time breaking this stuff down and sharing it.Well done. I never could hear that Paul 2nd harmony on the record. Very hard to pick out as the 3 vocals blend like one.Thumbs up!!
This is musical gold. I am a Beatles fan and voice student. Grazie mille!
Thanks friend. I love the harmony in that song, and was intrigued by that third high harmony that stays in the same key. Which I thought was George, but did think he sounded very Paul'ish. All three of the vocals sounds brilliant. I had figured Johns and Pauls vocals out, but that third, I really appreciate you doing the breakdown, cos I recognized how it went, a little, but would lose it while singing it
Beatlesebook says the high part is George, but it does sound Paulish, and I'm not sure George can sing that high. But my maybe he can, and Beatlesebook is very well-researched. So I don't know.
@gregfarleyeverst69 THe other parts are like these ones here. Only the words change.
May be a good chance to renew the guardrobe!
You’ve done an excellent job on this! It’s one of my older Beatles favorites! Thank you!
wow incredible,,, we can see how simple and complex... very good. thanks
Such an awesome song. I think it's in their top 5
simply beautifoll my friend, congratulations, you be genial.
@legolas35653 Thanks corrected now!
Excelente un saludo desde URUGUAY
That's interesting - fist time I've seen a harmony breakdown tutorial too.
Again, outstanding. You really sort it out .
Great job on the tutorial. Lennon and McCartney were two of the greatest classical musicians masquerading as '60's rock stars.
Great harmony vocal tutorial. Thank you so much for the much needed help in singing this song the right way!
Very very nice. The Beatles' harmony is almost under mentioned because it is so flawless... and you do a great job of bringing it out so people can clearly understand the magic of the blending of the voices. I think you may also under-rate George... he provided the most difficult atonal type sound whereas Paul and John's harmonies were more basic (but very essential). In other words, John and Paul were the anchors and George provided the "wow" factor. I also love your song selections!
Sorry what I mean is: while your singing alno I mean not over the record or my tutorial under your voice, then can you stay in tune?
You sing so well and certainly the Beatles were amazing. I'm wondering if anyone can really learn to sing like this or is it that you just either have this natural talent or you don't. I tend you think you cannot learn this stuff and you either have it or don't. The Beatles certainly didn't take any classes but just had this natural talent.
THANKS FOR THIS VIDEO. SUPERB INSTRUCTION. IT WILL HELP ME A LOT.
BIG BEATLES FAN.
@gregfarleyeverst69 Hi this is not for showing me thi sis for all of you who wants to learn :)
Fabulous. You are Wondeful
I'm Looking Through You please Galeazzo
Carlos Kroll yesss
Yeah, the third voice was always a bit hidden, until your excellent tutorial clarified its existence. Many thanks!
Excellent!
grande lavoro, molto bello !!!
siete una cover band ? dove posso vedere dei vs video ?
ciao
@boliboy2299 I am trying to figure out hoe to make a video about this. There are a lot of factors that help. Having trained since I was 13 or so surely helped.
Well done, very well done on the brake down, great research.
HI not sure I understood what you mean, when you gys sing alone can you saty in tune?
I'm sorry if there an unlike at your answer, I wanted to press the "like" button but the mouse got so short. Ah, and thank you for all of this videos, they're all powerful and useful to me singing "John's part", May I ask for more videos with Danni? They really gives an extra spacial part to this tutorials and Dan's voice is to closer to Lennon's. Greetings and a hug from México.
Awesome video for awesome song!
Thanks Galeazzo, good job!
Amazing!! Thank you
Beautifull
I toally agrere with you!
make one with ps i love you harmonys pls!!!!! love you
Thank you for posting these videos!
Bravo!
Thanks for the vocal lesson again Galeazzo!
Amigo....seus vídeos são muito bons....
valeu!
GREAT lesson! Thanks.
Fantastic job. One thing that would help me, and perhaps others would be extra trouble but maybe you would not mind trying it once.
For the songs with three harmonies such as this one, if you could wear a different color shirt for each part it would be easier to see who was singing what in the final three-part version.
Understand if you do not. Anyway, your work is fantastic, please keep it up.
So glad you have done this song * _ * Thanks you Gale!!!
Ur lesson is really really useful, tks!
My netbook may be weak in speakers, but I could hear some interference between the guitar and John's vocal part - was ur John's version clear 100%?
Excellent Bro.. I'm interested in knowing what microphone you are using and recording gear? You sound great. Thank you.
I totally missed the single note fifth line. Feck! Well done, nice one!
Wow, that is a brilliant tutorial. Thanks for sharing!
Awesome learning tool. Thanks, we're recording this song next week. Great job!!
There's just some of the default reverb of Garage Band about 30/35%.
So good.
Thanks dude, you're the best!
brilliant
bravo galeazzo ! hai scelto bene. i beatles hanno un impasto vocale incredibile e le loro
canzoni possono essere accompagnate da una sola chitarra in quanto le parti vocali
sono cosi' potenti , perfette , armoniose ( come tu dimostri molto bene )
Una domanda : che tu sappia i beatles andarono a scuola di canto o erano fenomeni naturali. su questo determinante particolare non ho mai letto niente. ciao grazie
Thanks a lot for video !!!
are you in tunnel be honest. PS me and the boyz have been digging and using these vids for literally 8 years. love you Galeazzo *does finger guns*
HI I confirm that the vocals are correct :)
Good job
I moved from Whitmore lake to omaha, and Nebraska is much nicer than Michigan. :)
Grazie!!!! Sei fenomenale!!!! Hai "Because"???? E credevo che piacevano a me!!! ha!
According to the session notes from the song's recording, the "high note" vocal is actually George Harrison, not Paul.
Yeah, I can hear George on the album track. Strange that so many people think Paul is doing two vocals here.
Grazie mille !!!!mitico
@cong404040 I ma trying to understand how to make a video about this... :)
O like It Very much!!! 👏👏👏👏
@chachabooom5 That's what I ask myself everyday too...
Make ''in my life'' or ''eight days a week'' please, you are amazing
Wow! I'm shocked. In all the years I've been doing this song, I never knew there was a third part. Paul is doing two parts?? I'm disappointed in my ear, I always thought it was just the one part each, John on the bottom & then Paul's part over him. I know that's an expensive mike your using, but do you have some kind of software that separate's voice tracks off the original recordings?
+MR. Kite 053 No I do it by ear Sir :)
+The Beatles Vocal Harmony You are incredibly talented my friend. Great ear!
+MR. Kite 053 Ditto.
Where can one acquire such an ear, sir? We could all do with one like yours!
Olá, bom dia.,,, Bela apresentação. Sugiro se puder, cantar a música inteira e depois fazer apresentação em partes.
Parabéns 👋👋👋👋👋
Thank you !
very handy !!! thanks a lot!
Paul's second vocal could be George. George is credited as singing harmony vocals so this could be it.
Loved this so much I was inspired to donate! But one quick question: What convinces you that Paul is singing that third, high harmony part? Many other sources agree that it was George singing this part.
Thank you! It's usually Paul :)
IT'S GREAT MAN!
How was Paul able to sing two different harmony parts on songs like this, And Your Bird..., and Wait? With only four tracks available, and the Beatles using two for instruments and two for vocals (the second often used for doubling), I don't see how they could have recorded three voices and doubled them all.
Because the third voice is George. 😆
What is your plugin for your voice effect back vocal harmony