I know this song wasn't supposed to be released to the public; It was meant to be confined to the hearts of a chosen few. I am sorry for Amy that it's been leaked to the world, but it is such a beautiful song. The first time I heard it, I knew it would always be special to me... It's been years since I first heard it and I still ache with emotion every time I hear it. I know Amy Lee would rather none of her fans heard it, but I can't imagine life without this song and would be shattered if I were restricted from listening to it anymore.
Zoey Lamoureux such a sweet story. This song will always have a special meaning to someone. Weather she wants us to hear it or not all evanescence songs are supposed to have a meaning for someone. And you will always have this to bring that good memory. 💕
"So many nights I cried myself to sleep. Now that you love me, I love myself. I never thought I would say that.. I never thought there'd be you." That part gets me everytime! almost 10 years later and this song is still easily my favorite.
that exact part always breaks my heart in two and i barely restrain tears. even if it's been so long since I used to listen to it every single day as a teen, even now i start crying.
If only angels like this existed. The kind that can rescue you from the deepest pits of hell and make you smile authentically. True love is dead anyway. This is just wishful thinking
@@libertiesbreathe5014 yeah, you're right. Humanity is dead. Philosophy, religion, science, art died- a couple of exceptions only. Still, many Muslim girls are great about these love, relationship stuff, trusting stuff alhamdulillah.
She wrote this about Ben Moody. They kept their relationship private because of how young they were, which is one reason they wanted the song to be kept private. They were still only teens at the time she wrote this.
I remember when I first heard this song, and I thought, "Wow..." It took my breath away. I still get that reaction every time I listen to it. This is more than just a song, it's a work of art, a masterpiece. Absolutely breathtaking
I've listened to this song for close to a decade now. Time and time again coming back to it. By far, my favorite song from Amy. Sorry she didn't want it leaked and listened to, due to it's personal nature (probably the reason it's such an amazing song), but I love the song all the same.
+ch0mper You might also like Afterglow by Chvrches... not sure why, it just reminded me of this song (btw, it's been (2 or 3, I think) years since I last listened to this but it sure feels like yesterday, wow ...I, too, used to come frequently here xD). Not saying they "copied" it, but even if they did borrow elements /were inspired, it's fine by me... I mean, they're good and it seems they did it right; it doesn't sound bad at all imo (not the same feel, or as good as EV, but hey).
hawkstrike18+ I just randomly saw my own comment and your reply after coming back to listen. I like chvrches too and enjoyed afterglow. Not nearly as much as this song though... Just always brings me back for some reason.
When I was little my sister used to sing this too me and I finally found it and I have listened to it a million times. Sweet memories. Now I'm 12 and and I love this song. ❤❤❤
This isn't an Evanescence song, and you probably haven't heard more than a couple Evanescence songs to call a song from Amy's young teen years as their most beautiful.
@@carpediemearth Couldn't be more wrong, actually. I own most of their albums and have seen them in concert 4 times, but do go off on how I don't know Evanescence's catalog. I like My Immortal, Lithium, Hello, Like You, Good Enough, Far From Heaven, Secret Door, Lacrymosa, and others, but this one is just gorgeous to me. And I think I am entitled to my opinion, thanks.
Anyone else notice that at 1:53 when she accepts the "proposal" the utter joy in her voice? The song takes such an optimistic tone at that point. Love it !!!!!!!!!!!
Even if you have never had the luxury of experiencing what she is singing about, this song almost puts you in that single solitary moment. almost to where you can say you have a pretty good idea what it would be like if you really experienced it for yourself. I can only hope my writing does that.
This song is probably the one that connects the most emotionally with me. Her voice is just so full of emotion and she sings with such passion. Her songs come straight from her heart. The lyrics are just so incredible and this song leaves me breathless every time. It's so sweet and loving and beautiful and all the good adjectives out there and more. I love Evanescence!
You Lyrics: The words have been drained from this pencil Sweet words that I want to give you And I can't sleep I need to tell you Goodnight When we're together, I feel perfect When I'm pulled away from you, I fall apart All you say is sacred to me Your eyes are so blue I can't look away As we lay in the stillness You whisper to me Amy, marry me Promise you'll stay with me Oh you don't have to ask me You know you're all that I live for You know I'd die just to hold you Stay with you Somehow I'll show you That you are my night sky I've always been right behind you Now I'll always be right beside you So many nights I cried myself to sleep Now that you love me, I love myself I never thought I would say this I never thought there'd be You ...
A little late to comment, but I walked down the aisle to this song. Didn't know it wasn't supposed to be listened to at the time. Such a beautiful song.
I can hear undiluted, pure love and beauty.. wish there were more songs like this. I haven't listened Amy Lee's or evanescence discography but i can tell this is the very best they have to offer
wdlkmpx this song was a very personal song that was not released to the public, but someone who was working for the studios got the copies and released those songs and created the album "not for your ears" and made a profit off the album for himself. This is a personal song for Amy and I feel sorry for her.
Wait, we weren't supposed to hear this? But its her best song... her voice sounds the best in this song... then again i feel bad. We should have respected her wishes :/
I agree, I also feel bad about it, I really would like to have got to respect the will of Amy, but it's impossible not to love this song and it's impossible not to hear this song, it's so perfect, after you hear this song once, is impossible not become addicted in it
I will never forget this song ❤️ I'll always associate it with my first great love... To this day I still have a hard time listening to the song. It's so beautiful and so sad at the same time...
Smh, super gets me every time because everything within this masterpiece is suitable. Tone, words, everything. It is singular, and reaaaally heard! By far one of the most angelic songs.
This song is the most beautiful, sincere and pure. This song wasn't supposed to be released, yet it's one of the most beautiful songs in the world, if not the only one that pulls at the heartstrings of anyone who tries to deny the feeling of love, she places you right in the center of what she's feeling and it's absolutely amazing that she can do that with her voice and her piano. She is amazingly talented and so original. Love her 🤗❤️
beautiful song. kinda nice to hear something this personal from evanescence. i like that. Not just seeing untouchable idols on stage but also hear :That are people who live and love like all of us. Okay most songs have a personal note, but this is something really private and well to share that. That´s something beautiful.
Sorry, personally I'm not sure the story around this song is fully true, but anyways, it's so lovely and tender that I can't imagine myself without it, and I'm so happy it leaked (if it did :) And I can’t imagine what it’s like to be the one to whom such songs are dedicated. Launched me to the Moon and won my heart forever :)
When I first listened to this song, it had 5000 views.. i thought that it is the best song, and that i will be one of the rare people to know it and enjoy it. And now after 4 years, i am still listening to it, and still thinking that i have privileges about it, and that i am one of the promotors of the song :) A AND STILL ONE HELL OF A SONG !!!
Memories are a pain, but they help us move on, this song reminds me of my best friend who passed away 2 years ago, lost in my arms forever, best brother i ever had...
This song always makes me sob. I feel like ill never have anyone to sing this to or lay down next to her while listening. All i can do is cry alone, in a bed alone and wish that i had someone
THIS ONE IS DEDICATED TO MY BOYFRIEND, NOAH. I want you to know that I love you more than anything in the whole world. You make me smile like no one else can. This song always comes to mind when I think of you. One of the several songs, actually.. NOAH. I love you. There, I said it. I actually l o v e you. I just thought I'd let you know. I want you to stay with me forever. It would mean everything to me.. just having you does.. you smile and I'll do the same. Sorry if this song is not your taste.. or whatever. I just needed to tell you. I l o v e y o u, N o a h. Thank you for walking into my life.. don't you dare leave me.
I remember listening to this song 12 years ago and had a special someone to share this with, that person may be gone but this still remains one of my favorite songs along with "where will you go", "anywhere" (i see what you did there) and "broken".
'You' is NOT an Evanescence song. It is a very personal song written by Amy Lee for her friends and family. This song was never meant to be released to the public. It is a song extremely personal to Amy Lee. Please respect Amy's wishes and delete this video.
dude, nothing personal but, are you idiot? if she wouldn't have wanted this song to go out she would have kept it for herself, instead she's making a whole load of money.....wake up!!
Its true, amy didn't want this song to be published.. But she doesn't mind now if people listen to it. Amy just doent want people to download it. Rant over.
This song never was released. A friend of a worker of the studio in which it was recorded stole the disc of this and other songs of hers and released it. Ben Moody himself said this.
Toa Zahrok He never said that it was released. It's true the song was wrongfully taken and released, and Amy asked for mp3's and lyrics to be taken down, however, I do believe I recall some interview where she said that she didn't mind people hearing the song, she just didn't want it downloaded. I do not know where I heard that, and I could be wrong, however, there are many many "You"s on youtube, and you will never succeed in getting them all down. I hate it was released against her wishes, and wish it hadn't been, but as it is, and will obviously remain so, I will continue listening to it.
OH MY GOD she is sooo amazing this is such a beautiful song .. her, her voice? its like an angel singing from the heavens she has a gift from above ! sooo amazing
We must win most dedicated fans of the decade! -.-" It's been 10 years since fallen, and 5 years break in between, YET we still love Amy and the band to death? WE DEMAND AN AWARD!!!
I listened to this song over an over again round 10 years ago.. Thankful to be able to listen to complete perfection.. Never wished this song would b singled or leaked.. But also find it to real not to.. I'm sure so many people haven't listened to this song who could have took something from it.. Happiness sadness.. Amy your a god in my eyes and this song will be in my heart untill I die.. Thank you
I love this song so much. I haven't listened to it in awhile. But this time I cried because the last time I listened to this song I sang it a million times right before I went over to my crush's house to hang out with his sister (we all played BlackOps). He was so nice to me back then. Its been a month.. He has treated me so differently since around then, and I don't know why... All I know is he will never love me as much as I love him.
I didn't know about the release issue but I feel I'm blessed cause this song has touched my soul and I cry every time I play it sometimes tears of sadness and sometimes of JOY!!' thank you for not snatching it away
regardless of what amy wanted im sure this song has changed many lives in my opinion it is a miracle that this song was leaked i know she didnt want it to be but its happaned and to say the least i owe this song my own life thank you amy lee for reminding us how love is worth living for each and every day in this cruel world
This song brings me to tears of joy every time that I hear it. It reminds me of my beloved Landon. I love him so much, and this song is exactly how I feel for him. It's so overwhelming, but in a good way.
i fell in love with this song....amy lee is such an amazing singer, pouring out all of her feelings in her songs she writes....thats what a good song is, where other ppl can relate to it
Who pushed the dislike button cannot seriously understand what a real masterpiece is! Who pushed the dislike button do not feel the magic inside this song. Who pushed the dislike button do not know what love is...
Well... it also has a meaning to me. someone very special sang this to me long time ago.. and this is how I like to remember those moments. so thanks Amy lee for this beautiful song.. :)
I know this song wasn't supposed to be released to the public; It was meant to be confined to the hearts of a chosen few. I am sorry for Amy that it's been leaked to the world, but it is such a beautiful song. The first time I heard it, I knew it would always be special to me... It's been years since I first heard it and I still ache with emotion every time I hear it. I know Amy Lee would rather none of her fans heard it, but I can't imagine life without this song and would be shattered if I were restricted from listening to it anymore.
Millipup Goat ...we are only human...
They are genius - Amy, Ben, David...so sad...
Evanescence you lyrics - 📺
ruclips.net/video/H2-vf1mwk7/видео.html
Zoey Lamoureux such a sweet story. This song will always have a special meaning to someone. Weather she wants us to hear it or not all evanescence songs are supposed to have a meaning for someone. And you will always have this to bring that good memory. 💕
Such a pity, its one of the most beuatiful songs she every wrote in my opinion. She should really release this song.
I first heard this song in 2003, I was just 18. Now 20yrs later I find myself crying hearing it. A lot has happened in 20yrs.
Something similar happened to me, too. Lost feelings coming back. This... is so powerful
"So many nights I cried myself to sleep. Now that you love me, I love myself. I never thought I would say that.. I never thought there'd be you."
That part gets me everytime! almost 10 years later and this song is still easily my favorite.
Eh.... it was written about 20 years ago. It's an outtake on their original EP, back in 1998.
I meant I heard it 10 years ago..
lauregui Ah...
I also first heard it in 2006... I feel the same. I love this song.
that exact part always breaks my heart in two and i barely restrain tears. even if it's been so long since I used to listen to it every single day as a teen, even now i start crying.
Can you imagine being the guy she wrote this about, and hearing her sing it to you for the first time?
Wow...
This guy has a name it is Ben ..
Trust me they both craves to forget about this song..
Jérémy Libeskind Amy Lee doesn’t really care that it’s been leaked cuz it’s been so long
If only angels like this existed. The kind that can rescue you from the deepest pits of hell and make you smile authentically. True love is dead anyway. This is just wishful thinking
@@libertiesbreathe5014 yeah, you're right. Humanity is dead. Philosophy, religion, science, art died- a couple of exceptions only.
Still, many Muslim girls are great about these love, relationship stuff, trusting stuff alhamdulillah.
She wrote this about Ben Moody. They kept their relationship private because of how young they were, which is one reason they wanted the song to be kept private. They were still only teens at the time she wrote this.
I remember when I first heard this song, and I thought, "Wow..." It took my breath away. I still get that reaction every time I listen to it. This is more than just a song, it's a work of art, a masterpiece. Absolutely breathtaking
Really? 😂 This is song from a young teenager and it's mid at best. "Good Enough" is one of many examples of an actually great ballad.
I've listened to this song for close to a decade now. Time and time again coming back to it. By far, my favorite song from Amy. Sorry she didn't want it leaked and listened to, due to it's personal nature (probably the reason it's such an amazing song), but I love the song all the same.
+ch0mper You might also like Afterglow by Chvrches... not sure why, it just reminded me of this song (btw, it's been (2 or 3, I think) years since I last listened to this but it sure feels like yesterday, wow ...I, too, used to come frequently here xD).
Not saying they "copied" it, but even if they did borrow elements /were inspired, it's fine by me... I mean, they're good and it seems they did it right; it doesn't sound bad at all imo (not the same feel, or as good as EV, but hey).
hawkstrike18+ I just randomly saw my own comment and your reply after coming back to listen. I like chvrches too and enjoyed afterglow. Not nearly as much as this song though... Just always brings me back for some reason.
When I was little my sister used to sing this too me and I finally found it and I have listened to it a million times. Sweet memories. Now I'm 12 and and I love this song. ❤❤❤
A piano and her voice is all she needs, beautiful
The most beautiful song from Evanescence, hands down. I just wish it was officially released and had a video to go with it.
well... sorry, is a personal song :\
This is technically not evanescence. It’s a solo Amy Lee song.
This isn't an Evanescence song, and you probably haven't heard more than a couple Evanescence songs to call a song from Amy's young teen years as their most beautiful.
@@carpediemearth Couldn't be more wrong, actually. I own most of their albums and have seen them in concert 4 times, but do go off on how I don't know Evanescence's catalog. I like My Immortal, Lithium, Hello, Like You, Good Enough, Far From Heaven, Secret Door, Lacrymosa, and others, but this one is just gorgeous to me. And I think I am entitled to my opinion, thanks.
I always wondered why I couldn’t find this song anywhere else.
Anyone else notice that at 1:53 when she accepts the "proposal" the utter joy in her voice? The song takes such an optimistic tone at that point. Love it !!!!!!!!!!!
Even if you have never had the luxury of experiencing what she is singing about, this song almost puts you in that single solitary moment. almost to where you can say you have a pretty good idea what it would be like if you really experienced it for yourself. I can only hope my writing does that.
yeh thats what it does for me , i just hope i can experience it one day, theres only a handful of songs that can capture emotion like this one can
Love ❤️ this band and been crushing on Amy Lee forever!!
THIS IS ONE OF THE MOST BEAUTIFUL SONGS I HAVE EVER HEARD IN MY LIFE!! IT MAKES ME FEEL WARM INSIDE..
If the speakers sound shitty at high notes then you know she is an amazing singer
It was originally recorded in a bathroom so it might be the recording quality
@@selinahoughton Now how the heck did you unearth that revelation?
@- that's what I heard I can't remember where from
@@selinahoughton to be honest i didn't know this before but yes it's crazy
This is the first time i heard this song in over 5 years, and i still know it will be the one playing on my wedding day. You rock Amy
This song is probably the one that connects the most emotionally with me. Her voice is just so full of emotion and she sings with such passion. Her songs come straight from her heart. The lyrics are just so incredible and this song leaves me breathless every time. It's so sweet and loving and beautiful and all the good adjectives out there and more. I love Evanescence!
You Lyrics:
The words have been drained from this pencil
Sweet words that I want to give you
And I can't sleep
I need to tell you
Goodnight
When we're together, I feel perfect
When I'm pulled away from you, I fall apart
All you say is sacred to me
Your eyes are so blue
I can't look away
As we lay in the stillness
You whisper to me
Amy, marry me
Promise you'll stay with me
Oh you don't have to ask me
You know you're all that I live for
You know I'd die just to hold you
Stay with you
Somehow I'll show you
That you are my night sky
I've always been right behind you
Now I'll always be right beside you
So many nights I cried myself to sleep
Now that you love me, I love myself
I never thought I would say this
I never thought there'd be
You
...
Sweet words
Pain feeling
All I want is to have this song playing as my first dance with my future husband 💓 Its always been so beautiful and pure to me.
A little late to comment, but I walked down the aisle to this song. Didn't know it wasn't supposed to be listened to at the time. Such a beautiful song.
My wife sang this song to me on our wedding 😍
Way late for this comment, but my wife and I actually did have our first dance to this at our wedding 16 years ago. Such a beautiful song.
How to tell your loved-one what you feel in one song... It touches my soul... Thx Amy for this little piece of heaven...
I can hear undiluted, pure love and beauty.. wish there were more songs like this. I haven't listened Amy Lee's or evanescence discography but i can tell this is the very best they have to offer
wdlkmpx this song was a very personal song that was not released to the public, but someone who was working for the studios got the copies and released those songs and created the album "not for your ears" and made a profit off the album for himself. This is a personal song for Amy and I feel sorry for her.
The most beautiful song that i've ever heard. It always makes me cry.
And people ask me why I love evanescence
+caprisunsamuraii you couldn't even spell it right lmao gtfo
Connor Katchmarik corrected myself, thanks. and i'm sorry for your loss.
@@caprisunsamuraii397 You're an immature child dude, grow up..
Wait, we weren't supposed to hear this? But its her best song... her voice sounds the best in this song... then again i feel bad. We should have respected her wishes :/
I agree, I also feel bad about it, I really would like to have got to respect the will of Amy, but it's impossible not to love this song and it's impossible not to hear this song, it's so perfect, after you hear this song once, is impossible not become addicted in it
Jessica Maria what was her wish?
Filiz Yenice That this song was only for a couple of people close to her heart. It wasn't supposed to be leaked.
she wasnt married when she wrote this song she was dating the lead singer of seether at the time
Robert Dye i thought it was actually written for ben moody. I dont think shaun morgan has blue eyes :P
This was my first dance song at my wedding when I got married almost 11 years ago. I had found this song 2 or 3 years before that and loved it.
That's what I want to do!
Amy marry me, promise u ll stay with me ..... oh u dont have to ask me, u know u are all that i live for ...... THIS is so sweet, i love this song :)
too late
+Isabelle Henson she's married and has a child 😊
+Isabelle Henson Uhm... I'm pretty sure he/she just quoted the lyrics of this song. Don't think it was an offer, buddy :-)
Marvin Gonzalez oh xD
Of all of the celebrities, Amy would be the one who I would wanna marry.
I will never forget this song ❤️
I'll always associate it with my first great love... To this day I still have a hard time listening to the song. It's so beautiful and so sad at the same time...
Esta canción es perfecta ... Amy sabe como llegar al corazón con sus letras y su voz ..
Smh, super gets me every time because everything within this masterpiece is suitable. Tone, words, everything. It is singular, and reaaaally heard! By far one of the most angelic songs.
Then why the smh?
Her voice is absolutely beautiful in this. She is an angel sent from heaven.
Love , love , love this track .. the power .. the essence of beauty and love .. we as men and women can feel in our hearts 🙏🏻
One of my favorite songs. I always try to sing along and match my voice to hers. It still gives me chills after all these years.
AMEN! It makes me cry Everytime
She reaches a super high note and it's so awesome!
Where?
@@caseyj5637 - 2:45 ?
i can never listen to this song without crying..always makes me think of someone i loved so much..
This song gives me such a sense of calm and peace that can’t be matched with any other song. This is one of Amy’s most beautiful pieces of art.
This song is the most beautiful, sincere and pure.
This song wasn't supposed to be released, yet it's one of the most beautiful songs in the world, if not the only one that pulls at the heartstrings of anyone who tries to deny the feeling of love, she places you right in the center of what she's feeling and it's absolutely amazing that she can do that with her voice and her piano. She is amazingly talented and so original. Love her 🤗❤️
beautiful song. kinda nice to hear something this personal from evanescence. i like that. Not just seeing untouchable idols on stage but also hear :That are people who live and love like all of us. Okay most songs have a personal note, but this is something really private and well to share that. That´s something beautiful.
Metalhammer1993 She didn't share it, it was leaked.
I'm sobbing so hard right now 😭😭😭😭
Doesnt matter if from experience or just the song itself anyone listening gets that amazing feeling that just makes you weep
She's just amazing. She makes me happy.
I still listen to song around bed time... Her voice is so haunting....
only 19, and already decided this is gonna be my wedding song. So beautiful
I'm not crying. That's just sweat running from my eyes. I'm not sobbing, it's just really cold out in the middle of the sun in the mid afternoon.
my bf showed me this song as my name is Amy i literally sobbed its such a meaningful song
Essa é a música mais linda que eu já ouvi na minha vida *-*
a tremendously moving romantic song. Amy has the voice of an angel.
Stunningly emotive and beautiful song.. One day.. one day.....
Every time I sing this song out loud to myself I change Amy to baby, sometimes I do keep Amy in the song when I sing
~Somehow ill show you that you are my night sky ill always be right behind you ill always be right beside you~
I sing this song to my baby every night. I love this song qwq
Sorry, personally I'm not sure the story around this song is fully true, but anyways, it's so lovely and tender that I can't imagine myself without it, and I'm so happy it leaked (if it did :)
And I can’t imagine what it’s like to be the one to whom such songs are dedicated. Launched me to the Moon and won my heart forever :)
I spent $645 today just so I could mute the tv from bed. Im doing very well, thankyou. Im happy.
I like this music, no one can tell me any different, She is always there
Now that you love me I love myself..I never thought I would say that. I never thought there'd be you.❤️
very special song....
When I first listened to this song, it had 5000 views.. i thought that it is the best song, and that i will be one of the rare people to know it and enjoy it.
And now after 4 years, i am still listening to it, and still thinking that i have privileges about it, and that i am one of the promotors of the song :) A
AND STILL ONE HELL OF A SONG !!!
So beautiful!! My husband and I use to lay at night and listen to this song before we got married at least once a week
This song is perfect....
One of my favorites
Almost as beautiful as Amy herself...
Her voice is out of this world. Nobody can't get even close, Amy has just so beautiful voice.
Memories are a pain, but they help us move on, this song reminds me of my best friend who passed away 2 years ago, lost in my arms forever, best brother i ever had...
Today I am 27, in 10 years I will come here and tell you if I actually got married and sang this on my wedding day.
crying°
she didn't want this song released, or so I heard. it was leaked
This song always makes me sob. I feel like ill never have anyone to sing this to or lay down next to her while listening. All i can do is cry alone, in a bed alone and wish that i had someone
THIS ONE IS DEDICATED TO MY BOYFRIEND, NOAH. I want you to know that I love you more than anything in the whole world. You make me smile like no one else can. This song always comes to mind when I think of you. One of the several songs, actually.. NOAH. I love you. There, I said it. I actually l o v e you. I just thought I'd let you know. I want you to stay with me forever. It would mean everything to me.. just having you does.. you smile and I'll do the same. Sorry if this song is not your taste.. or whatever. I just needed to tell you. I l o v e y o u, N o a h. Thank you for walking into my life.. don't you dare leave me.
Did he leave you?
All you say is sacred to me ,
2:55 is where it is at.
The voice of a broken angel
The most beautiful song I have ever and probably will ever hear.
2023 anyone? ❣️
I’m looking for a high quality version of it, any ideas ?
2024!
I miss you every night Jeanne. RIP my beautiful love
I remember listening to this song 12 years ago and had a special someone to share this with, that person may be gone but this still remains one of my favorite songs along with "where will you go", "anywhere" (i see what you did there) and "broken".
2021؟
'You' is NOT an Evanescence song. It is a very personal song written by Amy Lee for her friends and family. This song was never meant to be released to the public. It is a song extremely personal to Amy Lee. Please respect Amy's wishes and delete this video.
dude, nothing personal but, are you idiot? if she wouldn't have wanted this song to go out she would have kept it for herself, instead she's making a whole load of money.....wake up!!
Its true, amy didn't want this song to be published.. But she doesn't mind now if people listen to it. Amy just doent want people to download it. Rant over.
This song never was released. A friend of a worker of the studio in which it was recorded stole the disc of this and other songs of hers and released it. Ben Moody himself said this.
Toa Zahrok He never said that it was released. It's true the song was wrongfully taken and released, and Amy asked for mp3's and lyrics to be taken down, however, I do believe I recall some interview where she said that she didn't mind people hearing the song, she just didn't want it downloaded. I do not know where I heard that, and I could be wrong, however, there are many many "You"s on youtube, and you will never succeed in getting them all down. I hate it was released against her wishes, and wish it hadn't been, but as it is, and will obviously remain so, I will continue listening to it.
Cause deleting this video is gonna make all of the other ones go away. Noob logic.
447 person as deaf as a doorpost !
This song is so special. It says everything. Everything.
OH MY GOD she is sooo amazing this is such a beautiful song .. her, her voice? its like an angel singing from the heavens she has a gift from above ! sooo amazing
Some of Amy's best music is her "secret" music. "You" and "Anywhere" are awesome, imo.
A song such as this can portray such strength, borne of fragility. Beauty personified.
This song is beautiful. I adored it the first time I heard it many years ago.
We must win most dedicated fans of the decade! -.-" It's been 10 years since fallen, and 5 years break in between, YET we still love Amy and the band to death? WE DEMAND AN AWARD!!!
The last verse is so powerful. Probably my favourite verse of all time :)
I listened to this song over an over again round 10 years ago.. Thankful to be able to listen to complete perfection.. Never wished this song would b singled or leaked.. But also find it to real not to.. I'm sure so many people haven't listened to this song who could have took something from it.. Happiness sadness.. Amy your a god in my eyes and this song will be in my heart untill I die.. Thank you
I love this song so much. I haven't listened to it in awhile. But this time I cried because the last time I listened to this song I sang it a million times right before I went over to my crush's house to hang out with his sister (we all played BlackOps). He was so nice to me back then. Its been a month.. He has treated me so differently since around then, and I don't know why... All I know is he will never love me as much as I love him.
I seriously cannot comprehend how somebody could dislike a song so achingly beautiful.
I didn't know about the release issue but I feel I'm blessed cause this song has touched my soul and
I cry every time I play it sometimes tears of sadness and sometimes of JOY!!' thank you for not snatching it away
My wedding song. My wife and her family cant even listen to this without crying in ten seconds.
This song brings me to tears every time I listen to it... so beautiful
regardless of what amy wanted im sure this song has changed many lives in my opinion it is a miracle that this song was leaked i know she didnt want it to be but its happaned and to say the least i owe this song my own life thank you amy lee for reminding us how love is worth living for each and every day in this cruel world
This song brings me to tears of joy every time that I hear it. It reminds me of my beloved Landon. I love him so much, and this song is exactly how I feel for him. It's so overwhelming, but in a good way.
Came across this song and... mind completely blown away
This song is the perfect song. It's their best song by far.
You ARE MY night sky - love this
i fell in love with this song....amy lee is such an amazing singer, pouring out all of her feelings in her songs she writes....thats what a good song is, where other ppl can relate to it
this song makes the ". . . " charming!!! best song ever!!!
gives me chills. discovered this at a wedding during the bride and groom's first dance. almost had me crying. just beautiful.
Who pushed the dislike button cannot seriously understand what a real masterpiece is! Who pushed the dislike button do not feel the magic inside this song. Who pushed the dislike button do not know what love is...
Just listened to this for the first time in a while. I remember listening to this video a lot when I was a teen. Thank you
Well... it also has a meaning to me. someone very special sang this to me long time ago.. and this is how I like to remember those moments. so thanks Amy lee for this beautiful song.. :)