Interview with Retired SSA Disability Judge: A look behind the scenes

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 окт 2024

Комментарии • 44

  • @dawnhughes9942
    @dawnhughes9942 9 месяцев назад +11

    Invaluable to hear from an actual judge. How kind that he shares his wisdom. I will feel a little less afraid at my hearing.

  • @AngelaDrapal
    @AngelaDrapal 9 месяцев назад +19

    I was hit by a semi 70 mph both husband and myself were ejected he did not live I broke everything except my left leg several surgeries including heart brain spinal I was in induced coma 1 month have been fighting for over 2 years I'm a mess physically and mentally I'm going for hearing in couple months I don't understand how it's even questionable as whether I'm broken inside and out

    • @vn3593
      @vn3593 6 месяцев назад

      Bless your heart😕 They should never make someone in your shoes wait and beg.

  • @JoseRodriguez-yr9uv
    @JoseRodriguez-yr9uv 3 месяца назад +1

    Excellent inside information for claimants like me. So helpful. Many takeaways but I heard
    - Be honest
    - Don’t piss off the judge
    - it’s 90% about your medical records

  • @LaurenTaylor-id4gp
    @LaurenTaylor-id4gp 10 месяцев назад +8

    Best ssdi podcast I’ve come across 🙌

    • @podaly
      @podaly 8 месяцев назад +2

      I was told there is almost always (99%) a denial first hearing. Go on to appeal. My best advice is get a disability lawyer. Also SSA gives great weight to VA disability award and vice versa.

  • @tomsangiuliano8032
    @tomsangiuliano8032 7 месяцев назад +5

    I had a phone hearing and my lawyer told me right before my hearing was to start he knew the judge and said he was a very fair person with favorable approval rating. He also said after the hearing the judge will let my lawyer know the outcome which he did!

    • @phil_so_good9642
      @phil_so_good9642 6 месяцев назад

      What were the questions the judge asked?

    • @tomsangiuliano8032
      @tomsangiuliano8032 6 месяцев назад

      The judge did not ask me any questions regarding my disability. He just summarized my health issues and did ask what i did at my 2nd time last job. There was a vocational job expert in on call also and the judge asked them what other jobs in my category woukd I still be able to perform

  • @christiandeltoro4114
    @christiandeltoro4114 2 месяца назад +2

    Hi Honorable Judge Is My Pleasure to Learn From You. We Built The Trust We The People.

  • @zxatl2003
    @zxatl2003 7 месяцев назад +1

    I really enjoyed watching this video. It gave me a great insight into the position of a social security judge. Thank you for providing us access to this unique information.

  • @kurikat
    @kurikat 8 месяцев назад +1

    SSA ended my SSI and SSDI after I moved from North Dakota to California. They started my short for CDR in ND in July, I answered the questions, was told everything is good nothing to worry about. Because I moved, California then said "No, we want to do a LONG FORM CDR", 2 months after I did my short form cdr. So that was in August/October that they started my long form CDR. By January, I was told I am no longer disabled based off a copy and paste reply saying they used my medical records and I don't have to be admitted to a hospital anymore. I'm beyond upset and losing everything and can't believe how generic the termination letter was and how untrue it was. Within 3-4 months they processed my entire long form CDR from start to finish immediately terminating me and giving me a copy and paste letter. I gave them my medical records in December, and by early January they terminated my benefits. How is this allowed? Shouldnt CDRs take longer than that, it doesn't seem like they really looked at my medical records either because absolutely nothing has changed and a new therapist I'm seeing recently diagnosed me with a personality disorder on top of everything else I'm going through. I have no recent work history since 2018 a year before I was approved. So it doesn't make sense. Where did they get the information that I have improved and I'm not disabled anymore? There's literally nothing that supports that, but medical records that support my case. I'm completely broken and lost and can't believe california would do this to me. I even checked their CDR approval rates and they are much lower than other states. Surely it's a budgeting issue?

    • @AmericanNomad82
      @AmericanNomad82 7 месяцев назад

      Why would anyone ever move to COMMIfornia in the first place? I'm sorry about what happened to you but California is by far one of the most terrible places in the whole entire country... To believe that anything about that place is honest or fair is your first mistake. I hope you leave there and get things fixed some how.

  • @Dave-nz5jf
    @Dave-nz5jf 8 месяцев назад +1

    It's really nice of this judge to do this interview, as he says humility is so important. But he's obviously so different he can't possibly be useful, though he's amazing to listen to.

  • @MrScampy1231
    @MrScampy1231 11 месяцев назад +4

    Thank you for wisdom

  • @golferpro1241
    @golferpro1241 6 месяцев назад +2

    I had a tough judge. I had a good law firm ( very good attorney) appealed…got in front of him again..ignored the evidence again..appealed to a federal court and it was remanded to another ALJ and I won. MAKE SURE YOU HAVE REPUTABLE ATTORNEY WHO WINS CASES! Took a few years. Don’t give up.

  • @joshhubbard8285
    @joshhubbard8285 9 месяцев назад +7

    The judge in all 3 of my hearings was a jerk and denied me anyways even though doctors agreed I couldn't work and had several conditions that according to SSA qualified me for disability

    • @AngelaDrapal
      @AngelaDrapal 9 месяцев назад +4

      I'm going through he'll with all of this

  • @standingovation3092
    @standingovation3092 4 месяца назад +1

    How often will an ALJ make a decision without going to a hearing? I have submitted new medical evidence that now shows I have been diagnosed with 2 additional impairment listings. My initial claim was for back, neck and knees. New MRIs show my condition has worsened since my surgeries. Now I have CVI and Rheumatoid arthritis as well as carpal tunnel. They've been reviewing my medical evidence step 3 now for over a year. So everything has been submitted as well as my continued treatments are all current. Wouldn't the system run faster if the ALJ eliminated the strongest cases before the hearing? Especially if medical is 85% 90% part of winning the case. Ive been waiting over 3 years now and thats unacceptable in any type of field. Legal or otherwise. The backlog I've been hearing about over the years is a bunch bull. They could have ordered my medical records and read them 100 times over in the amount of time I and so many others have waited. My attorney scans and sends it directly into my file. Its easily accessible for review. No mailing or paper shuffling. I am sorry for venting and I really do enjoy your videos. I think they're the best on RUclips hands down. I just wish things were different. The SSA system is broken and its breaking the people now caught up in it. I am now on antidepressants because dealing with my failing health and struggling financially is not a good combination for any human being. I am now broken in so many ways.

    • @evansdisability
      @evansdisability  4 месяца назад +1

      Great question. ALJ's (and attorney advisors) can award a Fully Favorable decision without going to hearing. The frequency is judge dependent. We have some Judges who rarely/never do this and other judges who often call our office and cancel the hearings because they have decided to grant our client a Fully Favorable decision based off the medical records. One thing we do is that if we believe our client can be awarded a Fully Favorable decision we will write the ALJ a legal memorandum called "Request for On The Record decision." In this memo we outline why we believe the case is strong enough based off the medical records that our client does not need to have a hearing. Many times this request will trigger either the ALJ or Attorney advisory to look at the clients file. I would encourage you to reach out to your attorney and see if they believe your file might be one they would be willing to write a request for an On The Record decision for. Hope this information helps and thank you for the question.

    • @standingovation3092
      @standingovation3092 4 месяца назад +1

      @@evansdisability Thank you so much. You guys are wonderful.

  • @AmberShotter-di5jy
    @AmberShotter-di5jy 4 месяца назад +1

    Lawyer ignored me, was rude AF said she would do a mock hearing and waited all day for the phone fall, "oops i forgot he he" afterward never answered the phone.

  • @jeniferschultz1804
    @jeniferschultz1804 8 месяцев назад +1

    Does the ssa dr. Get my medical records to date of 2024 and previous years ? I can see tgat mine show the progression of my disabilities

  • @jeniferschultz1804
    @jeniferschultz1804 8 месяцев назад +2

    Ive slso have heard so many horror stories about ssa Dr's and im scared at what the out come will be 😮

    • @chartmann43
      @chartmann43 8 месяцев назад

      Watch the videos from a disability doctor! He is amazing! Tells you exactly what to expect and what to do and not to do during your physical exam.

    • @chartmann43
      @chartmann43 8 месяцев назад

      Jdave Foster is his name on RUclips! He’s amazing!

  • @bazurk_dot_com
    @bazurk_dot_com 8 месяцев назад +2

    I had my hearing a few days ago, while I don't know the verdict, the judge was compassionate and empathetic. I was scared out of my mind and he made it go as easy as possible.

    • @dede_ramirez
      @dede_ramirez 8 месяцев назад

      I have my hearing next month, may I ask you what where the questions you were asked? I’m terrified about it😬

    • @golferpro1241
      @golferpro1241 6 месяцев назад

      @@dede_ramirezdon’t be terrified. Be honest. The record is the record. What you say really can’t change the medical records

    • @AmberShotter-di5jy
      @AmberShotter-di5jy 4 месяца назад

      Not mine, he seemed annoyed

  • @seank4148
    @seank4148 8 месяцев назад +7

    My judge denied me due to one comment during a 15 minute SSA doctor government. Everything my doctors was basically ignored.
    Social security is a scam

  • @TheScapegoat420
    @TheScapegoat420 10 месяцев назад +7

    Great interview. These judges seem far over worked. That's not fair to them or the people.

  • @gknicks71
    @gknicks71 10 месяцев назад +2

    I want that 70 to 80 judge. I would be super sad with the 10....😢 I wonder what's my area

  • @gknicks71
    @gknicks71 10 месяцев назад +3

    Good luck to us all. 😅

  • @chartmann43
    @chartmann43 8 месяцев назад

    Can you tell us what the 5 questions are? Please 🙏🏼

  • @jeniferschultz1804
    @jeniferschultz1804 8 месяцев назад +1

    Im trying to get ssi not ssdi

  • @jeniferschultz1804
    @jeniferschultz1804 8 месяцев назад

    I have a dr appointment with the dds ssa dr. In march 2024,im scared to death that he or she will say im not disabled , i would love to still be working at my good paying job thaþi had and it was very physically demanding and i loved it however over time i got to where i couldn't do what i was able to do anymore and its very upsetting, i have learned from one person online says hes a dds ssa dr and to not bring any kind of medical records with my to only bring my medication and id , what should i really bring ?

    • @RuckCatz
      @RuckCatz 8 месяцев назад +3

      First, at your consultative exam in March, just be honest about the symptoms you experiece and how they affect your ability to function in normal daily life.
      Secondly, if you have had trouble with symptoms at a previous job that interfered with your ability to perform your job, be honest about that as well.
      And finally, the SS doctors are not judging you as a person they are assessing the symptoms you have, how frequently you have them and how the symptoms you have interfere with your ability to perform work like activities on a regular basis in a work setting.
      Hope this is helpful.

  • @BillB-x6g
    @BillB-x6g 6 месяцев назад +2

    Why does a social security administration treat everybody like they are a criminal I am 58yrs old I have had over 20 surgeries on my arms and end my legs.I have the scars to prove it I have paid into the system of my whole life And yet they make me feel like a criminal that money is mine

    • @evansdisability
      @evansdisability  6 месяцев назад +1

      I'm sorry to hear that SSA has made you feel that way. What was created to be a life boat for people who are disabled is more like an island "mirage" way off in the distance that SSA makes you swim miles and miles for.

  • @CatinaMccain
    @CatinaMccain 10 месяцев назад

    What this judge approvel rate? U tlking with now

  • @jacksonlee3771
    @jacksonlee3771 9 месяцев назад +3

    Ambulance chasers.