For those who haven't, you must read mr Khalidi's "100 years' war on Palestine". It will shock you beyond comprehension even if you think you have seen it all at this point. Remarkable historian.
Ironically, it is comforting to hear there are MSM journos talking to Mr. Khalidi & letting him know their hands are tied re reporting the facts of Gaza.
Once again, thank you for bringing Mr. Khalidi on your platform , who has such immense knowledge and analytic wisdom to bring to the conversation. Propagada stands no chance when confronted with real information and historical context!
he talks bullshit like any other jewhating racist arab out there. also there's no genocide, Halper and this Ahmetdude spread hatespeech and misinformation. "genocide in gaza" is such an evil smear.
@@alangould7154 Talking of bias. Now, I read your apologetic comment for levelling buildings and civilans on the ground. Your criticism of Khalidi is a text book case example of the reviewer who blames a historian for presenting his own account instead of the idiosyncracies of the reviewer.
i'm glad i read it as well cuz there is history i learned, he is erudite and writes well. but he also shows how to ignore so much that will derail his narrative. when i read the amazon reviews, an amateur historian pointed out that he immediately starts calling "pal" a "country." but few will notice this as he proceeds to show that he's not interested in unveiling accurately the history. he's interested in winning converts to his narrative but sighs and speaks of his frustration that many don't buy it. that's been his whole life.
This is a really excellent and very compressed series of important points. So much in just 15 minutes. Excelleht from Prof. Khalidi: - the declining influence of the legacy media, with the resulting bans on new and alternate media such as TikTok. - common misconceptions and delusions about the founding of Israel and Zionism, and the antisemitic motivations of the 'great powers' who supported the formation of Israel. - the geostrategic role of Israel today (which is beginning to change as Israel becomes seen as a pariah state and weaker than originally thought) - the gerontocracy that predominates our political system - Biden's abject weakness as far as dealing with Israel: the USA is looking more like a client state of Israel rather than the other way around. - Biden's commitment to Zionism and his weakling and sycophant senior staff unwilling to challenge him. - the political implications for Biden of being seen to be challenging Israel. Biden is more fearful of the Republicans than his own base.
I am just a guy from an Italian town, not an expert and not a journalist, let’s say the common “man in the street”… in my opinion Israel had a strategy to control media and narration, in the first months there was a journalist targeting in Gaza (i remember that the number of dead journalists was higher than the number of Israeli dead soldiers) and this added to the fact that non foreign journalist are allowed and added to the ban of Al-Jazira, make me think that they knew what mess they were doing…
He is spot on! But it’s not only young people, lots of seniors are not watching mainstream tv!! I am 72 and will not watch regular tv except for the weather!!! Lol!
AIPAC wouldn't have given Biden so much money if he wasn't going to do whatever the government of Israel wanted. It's how donors select candidates, so voters have to choose between candidates who largely agree on many issues.
@@l23918 I think technically it's AIPAC among other lobbies, but they basically copy and paste the Israeli government's talking points anyway. But yes, they support candidates from both major parties, as long as they are sufficiently loyal. They'll also campaign against candidates who they don't consider sufficiently loyal. Zionists are more likely to get their support, so they're more likely to get elected. That's why a disproportionate amount of politicians are so pro-Israel. You have to play the game to get elected. If you don't play the game, it's that much harder to get elected. Basically all republicans are overseen by AIPAC "babysitters" as well as several democrats. Only people who have overwhelming electoral support like Bernie Sanders and those who are outspoken and passionate like Rashida Tlaib and AOC can really risk being so vocally against Israel's actions or policies.
We live in a dualocracy, they all have the same donors they're colored differently in the media. we're just choosing between different employees of the same company. And that's the 1 would government across The US the UK Canada and Australia. We don't know who our leaders are. We have democrat and Republican UK has conservative and Labor, Canada has Conservative and liberal, Australia has labor and liberal. Where Pro-israel is all you can vote for.
@danielleannet8024 yep that's pretty much the story! Not just for pro-Israel, but also for pharmaceuticals, defense contractors, oil and gas, among others. I'm sure other countries have their own forms of lobbying and donating for elections, or even just running ads for or against candidates or parties generally, but much of the "West" is heavily influenced by pro-Israel groups. Makes it hard to discern the reality in the conflict since media is also fed the same narrative from the top down (and also because Israel is pretty adamant about not letting outside journalists in without a military escort, and discrediting local occupied journalists who oppose them).
Or better yet, read a book by a real historian who is taken seriously by historians in Israel rather than an anti-Zionist and therefore antisemitic hack.
Ilan Pappe is more than a real historian. He was a zionist, and as an Israeli fought in the IDF as a solid patriot. Pappe is respected worldwide as a very honest, fair, unbiased accurate historian respected by every serious real historian on planet Earth. Other Israeli historians are obfuscating EXTREMELY biased EXCEPT for Uval Noah Harrari. Another world expert acknowledged authority on Gaza is another Jewish historian, Norman Finkelstein. Read his books. Read also Edward Said, born in Jerusalem a Christian Palestinian. So, I'm afraid that you are so wrong on so many levels. Good luck and best wishes in your support of genocide, extermination and war criminals as the settler colony called "Israel" self destructs.
@@mozartsbumbumsrus7750 "There is no more antisemitism than by ant-Zionism, as anti-Zionism is merely a fig leaf for antisemitism." There, I fixed it for you.
Professor Khalidi, your families historical background in Palestine is a profound testament of your blood ancestors speaking. Thank you for your clarity and truth! We were sincerely brainwashed in our little US Christian church cultures of the myth of the chosen Jewish people. We wondered why…of the invasion of the original Natufian citizens. What was failed to be prioritized was these invaders were chosen ONLY if following Gods laws which the Bible itself shows was not followed, ever. Zionism worships the golden calf plain and simple as do we in the US blinding us of our atrocities to ancient cultures.
Graham is so blind with greed and belligerence, that in his latest speech on the resources of Ukraine, he forgets even to mention human beings and the cost in terms of their lifeblood.
She needs to remove it. No one wants to hear him. I dislike him. I avoid this channel more often due to that. Katie doesn't get it, no sound is better than his.
The Jewish journalist Antony Loewenstein wrote well documented book “The Palestine Laboratory “. A good resource to learn more about the conflict related to Palestine land
Unfairness is hurtful. Benjamin Mileikowsky is asking more sacrifice from the kids of the nation, .His son far from WAR, living a luxury life in Miami since mid-January 2024,
Dear heart, his name is Benjamin Netanyahu. Here's a secret: we Jews don't give a rat's ass whether you think our last names are our "real" last names. Any name a Jew has is a Jewish last name; O'Grady, Chang, and McIntire are Jewish last names if a Jew has them. You don't get a vote on what, or who, is authentically Jewish. If the Mileilkowsky family chose to change its last name to Netanyahu upon emigrating to Israel, they had every right to do so. And people like you think they don't can fuck off.
CORAN mentions SONS OF OUR PROPHET ISRAEL ...THERE WERE NO STATES, NOR RELIGIOUS COUNTRIES .. THE HOLY LAND WAS FOR ALL THE PEOPLE OF THE BOOK..DIVIDED IN TRIBES..OF WHICH THE 12 TRIBES OF JEWS....ALWAYS MANIPULATING ..
how can you allow picture of nudity appear in your channel (comments section) , that may affect the credibility of your news. Also, it ca repulse people to come back to your channel.
i haven't read the latest NYT investigation that illustrates hamas' uise of civilian shields. i wonder if it delves properly and addresses the questions (why they don't allow gazans to use the tunnels for safety for one). i've always known this was the pal modus operandi. i recently heard that all terrorists use this tactic to garner more int'l optics. i'll have to look into it. i saw rashid voice anger that hamas unleashed this on gazans. i'll have to see if he elaborated on it. even an anti-zio would have to acknowledge that israel has to protect itself. it has no choice but to make sure it's not attacked again which means destroying the tunnel network and hopefully crippling hamas. biden is correct in acknowledging this, but undoubtedly didn't expect so much destruction. i wonder what rashid envisioned. i haven't listened to this yet and may not. below is a link from a bethlehem christian who saw the tactic of encouraging carnage first hand. it's 17.50 in length and fascinating. ruclips.net/video/k3zZ6mDr1PM/видео.html
The jewish religion forbits to have or creat a nation. Listen for excample to rabbi Weiss or Shipora. TRT World has a Interview in two parts hier on youtube. He is Interviewed by another well known jew.
![GEEK TIMË [OFFICIAL AUDIO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ry-6RvkH880/mqdefault.jpg)
thank you Katie. thank you Rashid
Great guest and show! ❤❤
For those who haven't, you must read mr Khalidi's "100 years' war on Palestine". It will shock you beyond comprehension even if you think you have seen it all at this point. Remarkable historian.
I bought a copy and looking forward to reading the many ugly truths.
❤❤❤
Why the Apartheid Israel lobbyists are not yet registered as Foreign Agents whom they are?
*who they are
Ironically, it is comforting to hear there are MSM journos talking to Mr. Khalidi & letting him know their hands are tied re reporting the facts of Gaza.
Thank you for pursuing and showing the people the truth
It is a useful idiot show.
It is a useful idiot show.
Coward why did you delete my true comment.
Brilliant guest, great interview!
Once again, thank you for bringing Mr. Khalidi on your platform , who has such immense knowledge and analytic wisdom to bring to the conversation. Propagada stands no chance when confronted with real information and historical context!
The propaganda has failed though. Gaza has been leveled.
See you at the Hague, denier!
he talks bullshit like any other jewhating racist arab out there.
also there's no genocide, Halper and this Ahmetdude spread hatespeech and misinformation.
"genocide in gaza" is such an evil smear.
Reminds me of Naomi Klein’s comparison of Zionism to the Golden Calf.
John Kirby is our Goebbels
That's a very accurate company!
Lloyd Austin is our Heinrich Himmler .
Great guest, thank you Katie
Thank you, Katie, for doing your best to shed light on such an important tissue and for inviting Professor Khalidi, who I've learned so much from.
save gaza
I'm reading his book right now. For anyone reading, this it is dense but extremely thorough & well worth the effort.
i read it and agree it's worthwhile. but he distorts, leaves out things that work against his cause.
@@alangould7154that's how leftist historian works.
@@alangould7154 Talking of bias. Now, I read your apologetic comment for levelling buildings and civilans on the ground. Your criticism of Khalidi is a text book case example of the reviewer who blames a historian for presenting his own account instead of the idiosyncracies of the reviewer.
@@justinhawk835 Luckily, historians are only accountable to their peers.
i'm glad i read it as well cuz there is history i learned, he is erudite and writes well. but he also shows how to ignore so much that will derail his narrative. when i read the amazon reviews, an amateur historian pointed out that he immediately starts calling "pal" a "country." but few will notice this as he proceeds to show that he's not interested in unveiling accurately the history. he's interested in winning converts to his narrative but sighs and speaks of his frustration that many don't buy it. that's been his whole life.
Huge Halper fan
Razor sharp
Professor Rashid Khalidi is a remarkable scholar, man of truth and integrity
Merci
🙏🏼🕯🕯🙏🏼
Paris
This is a really excellent and very compressed series of important points. So much in just 15 minutes. Excelleht from Prof. Khalidi:
- the declining influence of the legacy media, with the resulting bans on new and alternate media such as TikTok.
- common misconceptions and delusions about the founding of Israel and Zionism, and the antisemitic motivations of the 'great powers' who supported the formation of Israel.
- the geostrategic role of Israel today (which is beginning to change as Israel becomes seen as a pariah state and weaker than originally thought)
- the gerontocracy that predominates our political system
- Biden's abject weakness as far as dealing with Israel: the USA is looking more like a client state of Israel rather than the other way around.
- Biden's commitment to Zionism and his weakling and sycophant senior staff unwilling to challenge him.
- the political implications for Biden of being seen to be challenging Israel. Biden is more fearful of the Republicans than his own base.
Thank you, please keep sharing more information Ike this.
Thanks I keep learning.
Very good!! Thank you Katie and Prof Khalidi
I am just a guy from an Italian town, not an expert and not a journalist, let’s say the common “man in the street”… in my opinion Israel had a strategy to control media and narration, in the first months there was a journalist targeting in Gaza (i remember that the number of dead journalists was higher than the number of Israeli dead soldiers) and this added to the fact that non foreign journalist are allowed and added to the ban of Al-Jazira, make me think that they knew what mess they were doing…
great interview
He is spot on! But it’s not only young people, lots of seniors are not watching mainstream tv!! I am 72 and will not watch regular tv except for the weather!!! Lol!
🇬🇧 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸
AIPAC wouldn't have given Biden so much money if he wasn't going to do whatever the government of Israel wanted. It's how donors select candidates, so voters have to choose between candidates who largely agree on many issues.
I heard Israel supports both parties and lobby them
@@l23918 I think technically it's AIPAC among other lobbies, but they basically copy and paste the Israeli government's talking points anyway. But yes, they support candidates from both major parties, as long as they are sufficiently loyal. They'll also campaign against candidates who they don't consider sufficiently loyal. Zionists are more likely to get their support, so they're more likely to get elected. That's why a disproportionate amount of politicians are so pro-Israel. You have to play the game to get elected. If you don't play the game, it's that much harder to get elected. Basically all republicans are overseen by AIPAC "babysitters" as well as several democrats. Only people who have overwhelming electoral support like Bernie Sanders and those who are outspoken and passionate like Rashida Tlaib and AOC can really risk being so vocally against Israel's actions or policies.
We live in a dualocracy, they all have the same donors they're colored differently in the media. we're just choosing between different employees of the same company. And that's the 1 would government across The US the UK Canada and Australia. We don't know who our leaders are. We have democrat and Republican UK has conservative and Labor, Canada has Conservative and liberal, Australia has labor and liberal. Where Pro-israel is all you can vote for.
@danielleannet8024 yep that's pretty much the story! Not just for pro-Israel, but also for pharmaceuticals, defense contractors, oil and gas, among others. I'm sure other countries have their own forms of lobbying and donating for elections, or even just running ads for or against candidates or parties generally, but much of the "West" is heavily influenced by pro-Israel groups. Makes it hard to discern the reality in the conflict since media is also fed the same narrative from the top down (and also because Israel is pretty adamant about not letting outside journalists in without a military escort, and discrediting local occupied journalists who oppose them).
to be funded so enthusiastically, has to be full US policy .
Read professor Ilan Pappe's latest book, "Lobbying For Zionism On Both Sides Of The Atlantic". Excellent honest factual truth with all sources given!
Or better yet, read a book by a real historian who is taken seriously by historians in Israel rather than an anti-Zionist and therefore antisemitic hack.
Ilan Pappe is more than a real historian. He was a zionist, and as an Israeli fought in the IDF as a solid patriot. Pappe is respected worldwide as a very honest, fair, unbiased accurate historian respected by every serious real historian on planet Earth. Other Israeli historians are obfuscating EXTREMELY biased EXCEPT for Uval Noah Harrari. Another world expert acknowledged authority on Gaza is another Jewish historian, Norman Finkelstein. Read his books. Read also Edward Said, born in Jerusalem a Christian Palestinian. So, I'm afraid that you are so wrong on so many levels. Good luck and best wishes in your support of genocide, extermination and war criminals as the settler colony called "Israel" self destructs.
@@jeffreywilheim5970PS. There is no more antisemitism than by zionism. FACT
@@jeffreywilheim5970 Now repeat after me: "I must NOT abuse self victimization to silence criticism of political motivated crimes and persecution."
@@mozartsbumbumsrus7750 "There is no more antisemitism than by ant-Zionism, as anti-Zionism is merely a fig leaf for antisemitism." There, I fixed it for you.
Thank you.
Love you Katie!!!
THERES another spokesmen on Middle Eye who speaks from Muslim anti capitalist perspective Hes great
☝️ GOD help palesrine🤲🇵🇸❤🌹🇦🇲❤ thanks so much katie and Rashid
Thank you Dr Khalidi. Thank you Katie.
Jeffrey Sachs says he's stopped reading the NYT. I have too, for many years
Israel is the largest US military base in the region.
Katie's questions were absolutely astute. And Khalidi's analysis laid things open like a patient undergoing heart surgery.
Professor Khalidi, your families historical background in Palestine is a profound testament of your blood ancestors speaking. Thank you for your clarity and truth! We were sincerely brainwashed in our little US Christian church cultures of the myth of the chosen Jewish people. We wondered why…of the invasion of the original Natufian citizens. What was failed to be prioritized was these invaders were chosen ONLY if following Gods laws which the Bible itself shows was not followed, ever. Zionism worships the golden calf plain and simple as do we in the US blinding us of our atrocities to ancient cultures.
as one of them said "I don't care if they complain that we control the media, as long as we do"
Rashid is a great spokesman for anti west capitalism and imprrialism from perspective of Muslims
You are the right person to but the truth the hall truth many thanks
The Israeli journalist Ben White wrote the book “Israeli Apartheid A Beginner's Guide”
That book is no doubt one sentence long: "There is no apartheid in Israel, end of story."
Are these clips older or new from a full show
Graham is so blind with greed and belligerence, that in his latest speech on the resources of Ukraine, he forgets even to mention human beings and the cost in terms of their lifeblood.
This has dollar signs all over it.
💗
You need to change your intro ....Biden does'nt sound that "pirky" anymore 😂
She needs to remove it. No one wants to hear him. I dislike him. I avoid this channel more often due to that. Katie doesn't get it, no sound is better than his.
Ive been subscribed to ypur channel for.months ive just realised youtub has unsubscrobed me
Jewish thankfully don't control young people who are changing attitudes ❤
🌷🦋🍃
We must not be silent while witnessing injustice. Israel is committing war crimes and US is complicit in those crimes.
This is showing bad judgment and policies on the pres
The Jewish journalist Antony Loewenstein wrote well documented book “The Palestine Laboratory “. A good resource to learn more about the conflict related to Palestine land
Here's a famous quote: "I wouldn't join a club that would have me as a member." -Groucho Marx was a Jew!
Was that supposed to say sycophants?
Unfairness is hurtful. Benjamin Mileikowsky is asking more sacrifice from the kids of the nation, .His son far from WAR, living a luxury life in Miami since mid-January 2024,
Dear heart, his name is Benjamin Netanyahu. Here's a secret: we Jews don't give a rat's ass whether you think our last names are our "real" last names. Any name a Jew has is a Jewish last name; O'Grady, Chang, and McIntire are Jewish last names if a Jew has them. You don't get a vote on what, or who, is authentically Jewish. If the Mileilkowsky family chose to change its last name to Netanyahu upon emigrating to Israel, they had every right to do so. And people like you think they don't can fuck off.
biden and netanyahu are competing for the warmonger of the year award. It's going to be a close contest this year.
+
😊 Lo sing Awar that you started is NOT g e noc ide.
Sychopats?
Blind followers who support and make excuses for someone.
@@Use_fediverse-7814 Sychopats?
@@ptolemyauletesxii8642 RUclips censors that word wen I spell it correctly. Syco, and like of elephants, -phants. Dictionary it.
@@Use_fediverse-7814 I know what sycophants are. I just don't know what a sychophant is.
Instead of arming Israel, Ukraine and Taiwan; US tax payer money should be spent on infrastructure, healthcare, education, homelessness ...
He ain’t no scholar
You clearly are 😂
Hogwash as usual.!!!
RK needs psychiatric help.
Quran mentions Israel 🇮🇱 43 times.
There is no palestine in quran.
Does the name of the region really matter?
There is no Craig Prince in Quran either. I guess that means Craig Prince has no right to exist, either.
CORAN mentions SONS OF OUR PROPHET ISRAEL ...THERE WERE NO STATES, NOR RELIGIOUS COUNTRIES ..
THE HOLY LAND WAS FOR ALL THE PEOPLE OF THE BOOK..DIVIDED IN TRIBES..OF WHICH THE 12 TRIBES OF JEWS....ALWAYS MANIPULATING ..
@@har3036 Palestine is a historic anecdote. It matters no more than just label on a map. The name of the region that matters is Judea.
how can you allow picture of nudity appear in your channel (comments section) , that may affect the credibility of your news. Also, it ca repulse people to come back to your channel.
i haven't read the latest NYT investigation that illustrates hamas' uise of civilian shields. i wonder if it delves properly and addresses the questions (why they don't allow gazans to use the tunnels for safety for one). i've always known this was the pal modus operandi. i recently heard that all terrorists use this tactic to garner more int'l optics. i'll have to look into it. i saw rashid voice anger that hamas unleashed this on gazans. i'll have to see if he elaborated on it.
even an anti-zio would have to acknowledge that israel has to protect itself. it has no choice but to make sure it's not attacked again which means destroying the tunnel network and hopefully crippling hamas. biden is correct in acknowledging this, but undoubtedly didn't expect so much destruction. i wonder what rashid envisioned. i haven't listened to this yet and may not.
below is a link from a bethlehem christian who saw the tactic of encouraging carnage first hand. it's 17.50 in length and fascinating.
ruclips.net/video/k3zZ6mDr1PM/видео.html
NYT isn't a credible scourse anymore.
The jewish religion forbits to have or creat a nation.
Listen for excample to rabbi Weiss or Shipora.
TRT World has a Interview in two parts hier on youtube. He is Interviewed by another well known jew.
Thanks!
Thanks!