Yes, a lot of throws are not "perfectly" executed, i.e they do not look like the throws you see in randori or in a dojo, but you must understand when you face a live opponent, they are going to resist your attacks, and when they do one has to adjust the motion of a throw in order to execute them. It is difficult to do a proper throw with someone moving and squirming around. I don't think adjusting the motion of a throw makes it a bad style.
look at 0:18 or 2:44, this are not throws are : pull the opponent making him roll on shoulders and later on back. This is not what i consider a judo throw: serach on youtube for Koga, the first video explain what i mean. Or ''Sasae Tsurikomi Ashi by Muneta Yasuyuki''
But she do what the actual rules created: just make your opponent touch the ground with the ass and you've won. with a juko you can start a passive mode and, waiting for sanction, wait for the time passing and you win. I did some experimental competition with victory only for double ippon and only ippon and waza ari. Much more attacks, much more ''do something'' instead of ''extreme defense''.
Perfect video!
Yukaaa 3
Yes, a lot of throws are not "perfectly" executed, i.e they do not look like the throws you see in randori or in a dojo, but you must understand when you face a live opponent, they are going to resist your attacks, and when they do one has to adjust the motion of a throw in order to execute them. It is difficult to do a proper throw with someone moving and squirming around. I don't think adjusting the motion of a throw makes it a bad style.
look at 0:18 or 2:44, this are not throws are : pull the opponent making him roll on shoulders and later on back. This is not what i consider a judo throw:
serach on youtube for Koga, the first video explain what i mean.
Or ''Sasae Tsurikomi Ashi by Muneta Yasuyuki''
If this is "bad style" then what is your definition of good style? I think dropping ppl on their asses on a regular basis is pretty good style to me.
But she do what the actual rules created: just make your opponent touch the ground with the ass and you've won. with a juko you can start a passive mode and, waiting for sanction, wait for the time passing and you win.
I did some experimental competition with victory only for double ippon and only ippon and waza ari. Much more attacks, much more ''do something'' instead of ''extreme defense''.
really really bad style.