Bloodborne Fear the Old Lore - Make Contact Finally Explained? - Hotei and the Moon

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 июн 2023
  • Join the Discord!
    / discord
    I've thought about making a video on this topic for a long time, but it always felt a bit too farfetched for me to really advocate for it, but since the topic came up in my reaction to Smoughtown's "The Choir and the Eldritch Truth," i figure why not edit down what I said about the "Make Contact" gesture in Bloodborne into an easily digestible video of its own.
    Article about Hotei & the Full Moon Zen:
    www.huffpost.com/entry/full-m...
    Link to Smoughtown's video "The Choir and the Eldritch Truth":
    • Bloodborne Lore | The ...
    And link to my full reaction of said video:
    • A Madman's Wisdom - La...
    ---
    Link to my Japanese to English Retranslations of Bloodborne and assorted Dark Souls text:
    docs.google.com/spreadsheets/...
    ---
    Do you like the content and want to help support the channel more?
    Patreon profile:
    / lastprotagonist
    Buy a drink or coffee with ko-fi:
    ko-fi.com/lastprotagonist
    Donate via Paypal:
    www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_...
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 28

  • @mossyashromancer4301
    @mossyashromancer4301 Год назад +42

    I remember hearing something along the lines of "It's a reference to some scientists trying to think of ways to communicate with aliens and going with mathematical formulas, in this case a right angle, because it's a rare thing in nature to find one so it might suggest intelligence or purpose to an alien mind"

    • @LastProtagonist
      @LastProtagonist  Год назад +17

      Right, that's a common theory, so I thought I should post this to give people an alternative perspective to consider

  • @10hawell
    @10hawell Год назад +41

    Who also unironically praises the sun and makes contact with the moon in real life?

    • @user-zp8kj2cl9g
      @user-zp8kj2cl9g Год назад +1

      __0/

    • @intboom
      @intboom Год назад +1

      Pagans, probably

    • @agxryt
      @agxryt 7 месяцев назад +1

      I was just gonna post that. Bloodborne opened my mind. Do it all the time, midnight at the beach. No contact yet

  • @Eldagusto
    @Eldagusto Год назад +22

    They done experiments and some animals do understand reflections are reflections. Like they’ve used those apps that give you dog ears and cats have acted confused because they think the screen is supposed to be a reflection

  • @ProLaytonxPhoenix
    @ProLaytonxPhoenix Год назад +15

    Bloodborne is such a fucking masterpiece!

  • @Supercohboy
    @Supercohboy Год назад +11

    The more we try to decode the "Make Contact" gesture, the less it makes sense. I think it's a purposefully original invention for the BB world. The character ticks their 2 arms like a clock or something after a minute. The 2 parts of Make Contact's gesture make 2 squares/1 rectangle, if we consider possible geometric symbolism. It could be interpreted as a philosophically-driven symbolic gesture to prove our intellect as a species. You can even throw in theories regarding the Golden Ratio into the mix, and I'm sure that this arm-waving act is similar to something historical.
    But the problem is that there aren't enough leads to give us an answer. It seems to be one of the purposefully-mysterious things in the game imo. I think that what your theory is very interesting though, and there could have been some cultural influence that lead to specifically "pointing gestures" and "the Moon Rune" being connected so intimately in-game.

  • @Eldagusto
    @Eldagusto Год назад +6

    There is also an argument that they are the school of Mensis as in table as in dissection table.

  • @Kid_Naps
    @Kid_Naps Год назад +6

    Its the weirdness of the right angle, as it is almost impossible in nature, but I think the story of a buddhist monk capturing the Moon in his hands is more interesting and perhaps more related. I remember it being something like this :
    A buddhist monk laments about not being able to ever fathom all the intricacies of life, but a second monk says something like
    "I can never hold the Moon in my hands, ..."
    and proceeds to reach for the Moon, which is of course, too far. So he goes down to his knees, takes water in hands and stands up. Then he finds the right spot, so the Moon is being reflected on the surface of the water in his hands.
    "... yet, here it is, in my palms."
    So yeah, thats how you catch the Moon mofos ...

  • @bingoboppins9875
    @bingoboppins9875 8 месяцев назад +2

    Nice videos. I definitely don’t think that’s a coincidence. And the switching of the hands with Make Contact almost seems to symbolize man’s desire to bring the moon down to themselves, while also ascending their nature.

  • @arukimania
    @arukimania Год назад +7

    Very interesting. So the idea would be something like this: The Brain of Mensis recognizes that the Moon is the underlying truth behind the character's gesture, because as a Great One it can discern reality from the reference. Then it speaks the word Moon, which is represented visually in the mind of the hunter as a rune, which fits because we know Caryll runes represent the speech of the Great Ones. Meanwhile, the gesture itself comes from the work of art and the Buddhist teachings presented. Is that about right? Based on the language involved, up to this point I've been partial to the radio signal analogy myself, but I admit I'm intrigued by this interpretation.
    Also, as something of a tangent, I've always wondered if there's something to the angle that "mensis" is meant to have a short-term/time-based component to it. After all, it doesn't strictly mean "moon" either. It's a reference to a single lunar interval, which is why it's the word for "month" in Latin, and why it's the plural form (menses) that's more directly associated with menstruation. Of course, I've not yet been able to come up with something that satisfyingly explains that distinction, but I do wonder about it.
    Anyway, thanks for posting the video! It's nice to see you do more work on Bloodborne.

    • @LastProtagonist
      @LastProtagonist  Год назад +3

      I think by doing the gesture, we're pointing to a symbolic "moon," and reveal that we're trying to follow The Way to Enlightenment. The Brain might recognize that and it says "Moon" in acknowledgment of what the gesture is supposed to symbolize. It could just be a not-so-coincidence that the "enlightenment" the School of Mensis seeks is tied to the moon in their eyes...pun intended.

    • @arukimania
      @arukimania Год назад +2

      @@LastProtagonist Got it. Thanks for the clarification!

  • @fatherrat9020
    @fatherrat9020 Год назад +3

    Went eepy right before this, thanks for making this a video!

  • @abacabdk3490
    @abacabdk3490 11 месяцев назад +1

    Thanks
    Now if only there was a "Mooning" gesture to make true contact with the brain

  • @beansnrice321
    @beansnrice321 Год назад +1

    I remember hearing one person thought that the make contact gesture is supposed bto depict the moon traveling across the night sky

  • @ALushPair
    @ALushPair 10 месяцев назад

    A: it looks like "praise the sun" when it's changing from one side to the other
    B: you make the hunters runs with your body when it's changing from one side to the other

  • @lucamckenn5932
    @lucamckenn5932 9 месяцев назад +1

    To draw the attention of that which is not human one must show a devotion to a strange dedication that i like to call alternative communication. Not necessarily a mathematical thing. That's not mentioned in the slightest ever in game as far as i know. Perhaps it's man trying to make its own rune? What could they possibly be doing? This curiosity might draw the attention of great ones perhaps? Who can possibly understand something as esoteric as a pro alien organization creating a specific gesture with such unclear motives.
    Personally i enjoy the mystery remaining unclear, but the insight is fascinating.

  • @troycoley-cn5bb
    @troycoley-cn5bb Год назад +1

    Another Amazing Video!!

  • @daviddixon8674
    @daviddixon8674 Год назад +2

    It's been a year since a bloodbourne vid, I'm very grateful lol
    We getting an updated video on the architecture?

  • @hhowdy
    @hhowdy Год назад +8

    Pretty sure Mensis means Mind but Bloodborne will probably stay the most mysterious games ever 8 years later there are still mysteries that will never be answered

  • @diespurpura
    @diespurpura 11 месяцев назад +2

    I think it is based on the book of the hounds of tindalos, in which these beings live in the angles of reality and we live in the curves, they enter our world through the angles, so the choir seeks to establish contact with an angle of 90 degrees (also reminds me of how the protagonist uses the Pythagorean theorem to communicate on the planet of the apes).
    Edit: this book was written by an author in lovecraft's circle so I think it may have been an influence.

  • @TroyTheCatFish
    @TroyTheCatFish Год назад

    Another Incredible Video!! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ 💖💖💖💖💖

  • @Erox006
    @Erox006 8 месяцев назад

    it's just a Kamen Rider reference ............

  • @andrewwalden2005
    @andrewwalden2005 Год назад

    Mergo
    Morgot
    Make contact
    Golden order poses
    Mensis
    Manus
    Mohg
    Mohgwyn
    Godwyn
    Gwyn