Did We Get A Happy Ending? | Insomniacs After School

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 дек 2024

Комментарии • 57

  • @a3ptx_myarmygame227
    @a3ptx_myarmygame227 Год назад +7

    Wait..... so they broke up and did not come back together in the final chapter?

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  Год назад +3

      Well it honestly depends how you want to look at it since Ojiro left it up to interpretation! How I see it is that they're still together but perhaps Ganta was reminiscing the past here and that would explain some of the panels.
      If you really are looking for an answer though perhaps wait for the volume release (Oct 12), she might add an extra epilogue/chapter.

    • @a3ptx_myarmygame227
      @a3ptx_myarmygame227 Год назад

      @@Sadacado yo thanks bro, haven't heard anything since I read the last chapter

    • @vini0798
      @vini0798 Год назад +1

      ​@@Sadacadojá saiu o cap extra? Eles ficam juntos?

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  Год назад +2

      @@vini0798 Hey! So the volume did come out (in Japan that is). The extra chapter was not really content for the main 2 characters but rather Shiromaru. Other than that, the only difference I could find in the volume release is that the final chapter's name was changed from Kuyo no Hoshi to Fuku Hoshi(福星), which I'm pretty sure means lucky star or star of luck. There might be significance there with a Chinese 'deity' called Fuxing but I don't think so.

    • @vini0798
      @vini0798 Год назад +1

      @@Sadacado tomara que no futuro o autor lança um cap extra pra tirar nossas duvidas

  • @mr.gamerkabir8142
    @mr.gamerkabir8142 3 месяца назад +5

    Honestly
    I feel they are together
    The tweet by ojiro is a nail in the coffin. Even if we ignore the tweet ... the final arc's theme only was nakami finally overcoming his childhoos trauma and self depracation and coping up with trauma.
    Its hopeful thematically and wonderfully concludes both the characters arc. I mean the entire sequence of ganta with shiromaru,kurashiki and his dad means that nakami has finally fixed his "flaw" which can prevent any sort of mishaps in their relationship(ie naivety and putting burden on himself)
    Ganta matures to learn to live with magari and his disease meanwhile also overcoming his presure and childhood trauma.
    Magari realises that it is ok to rely on others and her condition doesn't mean she is being left out.
    I feel it would be odd writing to have magari dead after such profound character arc or them breaking up.
    Because both of em got their shit together and apologized.
    Theres no "flaw" left in their relationship (because they overcame it) for them to break up.

  • @ZazzilasArden
    @ZazzilasArden 11 месяцев назад +21

    SPOILER:
    Magari is at least confirmed to be alive by the Mangaka herself on Twitter. She also said that they are living happily together, though whether she means as partners or as friends is anybody's guess. Also the kanji used for Kuyo is not the same as the one that is used for the buddhist Kuyo memorial ceremony. The Kuyo used is actually in reference to the Kuyo Tamoe, the spiral symbol that represents the reunification of the nine stars in Japanese Buddhism.

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  11 месяцев назад +1

      I've seen the tweet yea. I do talk about the fact that it's not the same Kanji in the video.

    • @requiemforameme1
      @requiemforameme1 11 месяцев назад +1

      Her tweet sorta ruined the ending for me personally. If they’re at best still together and unmarried (and at worst separated but still friends) then many of the ending details don’t make much sense other than just to be vague.
      For an impressively realistic depiction of a relationship, them separating (but surviving) would have likely been accepted (and made it one of the most unique romance manga endings). But it felt like the ending wanted to be open to interpretation at the cost of not satisfying anyone.
      Reading the tweet literally, I guess they never married (not impossible given Nakami’s view on marriage from his mother) and just don’t take photos together (?). Also, dude seems to be doing well in his Arcteryx jacket. So either Magari’s ballin enough to not need shared health insurance, or they suddenly became grossly irresponsible adults.

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  11 месяцев назад +3

      ​@@requiemforameme1 Mhm, I honestly did not expect her to straight out tweet that; perhaps she really just didn't have a concrete conclusion in mind. I think that also might just be her style of doing endings as I've heard.
      I'm not sure how you arrived to the conclusion that they're not married though. x.com/nekoteraphoto/status/1725347608213041399?s=20

    • @requiemforameme1
      @requiemforameme1 11 месяцев назад +1

      ⁠​⁠​⁠@@SadacadoIt was the focus on their hands (especially Nakami) in the ending chapter. They could just not wear rings, but it’s pretty uncommon in Japan.
      They could of course just be together and not engaged, but it feels unlikely given the length of the timeskip.
      Still a fantastic anime and manga, but the ending just felt rushed. I wanted best bro (Ukegawa) and Nono to get a good ending together. 😩

    • @mr.gamerkabir8142
      @mr.gamerkabir8142 3 месяца назад

      ​@@requiemforameme1I kinda think they haven't married yet?
      They are dorks,night owls and do some weird things in their own way, right?
      Ending was kinda rushed but i felt ojiro tried to be a lot more fancier with vague endings.
      It isn't bad but honestly it was unnecessary.
      Still a near perfect ending if you ask me

  • @KATTARHINDU-BJRANGBALIKIJAI
    @KATTARHINDU-BJRANGBALIKIJAI 6 месяцев назад +4

    I recently read the whole manga and the last chapter was just full of uncertainties that's why i searched to see whether author or someone have something to say but i guess everyone is as confused as i am i was thinking reading it do not pull the your lies in April here.

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  6 месяцев назад

      I mean she did kinda just drop this x.com/nekoteraphoto/status/1725347608213041399

    • @KATTARHINDU-BJRANGBALIKIJAI
      @KATTARHINDU-BJRANGBALIKIJAI 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@Sadacado well that explains everything . Thanks bro

    • @Kaoriwashappy
      @Kaoriwashappy 19 дней назад

      ​@@Sadacado Peak male happiness ❤

  • @C0nnie
    @C0nnie 9 месяцев назад +5

    I’m writing this having only finished the show, and started the manga - but there’s a ton more that wasn’t animated right ?

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  9 месяцев назад +3

      Yes. If I remember correctly the anime only adapted 55ish chapters

    • @C0nnie
      @C0nnie 9 месяцев назад +2

      @@Sadacado I finished book 1 gotta go buy the others lol. I have a full pdf but the real book is drawn gorgeous-ly. Thanks for the reply

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  9 месяцев назад +1

      @@C0nnie Yeah. Ojiro's art is amazing. Hope you enjoy the rest of the manga!

  • @letdestinydecide
    @letdestinydecide 2 месяца назад

    Well ig they're together no need to confuse💗

  • @antoine-oliviermartel9151
    @antoine-oliviermartel9151 7 месяцев назад +11

    seem to me that the 12 year skip is the dream she have for the future to be still together with ganta.
    that would explain with we dont see her face since she probably can't imagine her own apparence 12 year later

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  7 месяцев назад

      ooh i like this!

    • @zachmurzonadziewczyna1176
      @zachmurzonadziewczyna1176 7 месяцев назад

      Omg this is sooo goood interpretation!

    • @p.svistulkin
      @p.svistulkin 5 месяцев назад

      Thanks. I was not ready to accept theory about her death. My anxiety after the manga ending was so high, that i spend about 3-4 hours to find different explanations of this. Your one is sounds great. Now i feel better.

    • @thinhvo8863
      @thinhvo8863 5 месяцев назад

      thanks god that I saw your comment ❤‍🩹

    • @walmky
      @walmky 2 месяца назад

      this is the most beliavable speculation for me

  • @inspirashamul
    @inspirashamul Год назад +4

    The copium...THE COPIUM IS REALLL

  • @たた-x6q4v
    @たた-x6q4v 3 месяца назад +1

    日本語にて失礼します。自分の意見を述べると、卒業式の日以降はパラレルワールドだと思います。なぜなら卒業式の日だけMagariがリボンを着用しているからです。リボンを着用している世界がMagariが生存する世界線で、ネクタイを着用している世界がそうではない世界線だと思います。また、最後の7つ橋渡りのシーンは卒業式の直後ではないと思います。卒業式の日は昼間ブレザーを着用してましたが、7つ橋渡りをするときは上着を着ていません。日本で卒業式はふつう3月末ごろに行われますが、この季節は夜まだ寒いです。上着無しは不自然です。さらに作中述べられていますが、7つ橋渡りの願掛けは通常9月に行うべきものです。つまり7つ橋渡りを実行したのはリボンを着用している世界線の秋に起こった出来事です。リボンの世界では願掛けをやり遂げています。だから生き残ります。でもネクタイの世界では願掛けを途中で断念しています。だから彼女は生き残れませんでした。

    • @たた-x6q4v
      @たた-x6q4v 3 месяца назад +1

      Please excuse my Japanese. If I were to express my own opinion, I would say that after graduation day it is a parallel world. This is because Magari wears a ribbon only on the day of graduation. I think the world where Magari is wearing a ribbon is the world line where Magari survives, and the world where she is wearing a tie is the world line where she is not. Also, I don't think the final scene of crossing seven bridges takes place immediately after the graduation ceremony. On the day of the graduation ceremony, I wore a blazer during the day, but when I crossed the Seven Bridges, I didn't wear a jacket. Graduation ceremonies in Japan are usually held around the end of March, but the nights are still cold during this season. It's unnatural to be without a jacket. Furthermore, as mentioned in the story, the wish to cross seven bridges should normally be made in September. In other words, the seven bridge crossing was an event that occurred in the fall of the world line where the ribbon was worn. In the world of ribbons, wishes are fulfilled. So survive. However, in the world of neckties, people often give up on their wishes. So she didn't survive.

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  3 месяца назад

      @@たた-x6q4v Very interesting! Thank you for your insight
      とても興味深い。あなたの洞察に感謝する!

    • @たた-x6q4v
      @たた-x6q4v 3 месяца назад +1

      @@Sadacado One more thing. There is a saying in Japan that says, "He who believes will be saved."

    • @mr.gamerkabir8142
      @mr.gamerkabir8142 3 месяца назад

      So
      Are you implying magari died?
      Or is she alive and still with ganta?

    • @たた-x6q4v
      @たた-x6q4v 3 месяца назад +1

      @@mr.gamerkabir8142 両方の世界があり得たということです。これはシュレディンガーの猫のようなものです。Magariが自分の生存を信じれば、そのような結果になり、Magariが自分の生存を疑えば、それに応じた結果になる。

  • @hi_riku
    @hi_riku 8 месяцев назад

    Alright alright so when the next season will come?

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  8 месяцев назад

      One day...😪

  • @shobro160
    @shobro160 4 месяца назад +1

    I think it's a happy ending,, although I am not sure i just want to belive she survived... Maybe she did survived the mangakar did it on purpose 😐they said the surgery was a success right? Maybe she survived another 12 years.. If we take that in simple way or maybe it's just a simple ending! We are overthinking it just because her face was not shown at the end.. It's been one year since the last chapter arrived and yet I have re watched the series and completed the manga again and hell no! The ending still can't get over it.

  • @amyrhrith
    @amyrhrith 10 месяцев назад +3

    Bro ruined my day

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  10 месяцев назад

      must share the pain

  • @hi_riku
    @hi_riku 8 месяцев назад

    Someone please give the Twitter of oijiro 🗿

    • @Sadacado
      @Sadacado  8 месяцев назад

      twitter.com/nekoteraphoto

  • @Token_Nerd
    @Token_Nerd Год назад +5

    Ganta…why couldn’t you mature

  • @lokrj
    @lokrj 2 месяца назад +3

    I finished watching the anime yesterday and immediately read the entire manga afterward. I thoroughly enjoyed every moment of the story until the very end, but I cannot help but feel a sense of discomfort due to the open-ended conclusion.
    The final chapter felt rather peculiar. The author tweeted that the characters are living happily, but whether they are a couple or just friends remains a mystery known only to her. The panels and artistic choices employed in the final chapter did not resonate well with me. It seemed as if the author intended to conclude the story with a tragic ending but felt pressured to avoid upsetting the readers. As a result, the ending was left as open-ended as possible.
    In my opinion, a bittersweet ending where Isaki passes away and Ganta moves on to have a successful career would have been preferable to the ambiguous and unsatisfying conclusion that the author ultimately provided. Unfortunately, it appears that this story has fallen victim to the dreaded "blue balls" ending.