Why Speaker Om Birla interrupted Union Minister Hardeep Puri during Question Hour in Lok Sabha
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 дек 2023
- Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla interrupted Union Urban Housing Affairs Minister Hardeep Singh Puri during a Question Hour and asked him to reply to the MP’s query in Hindi if possible. BJP MP Manoj Tiwari asked about the implementation of PM Modi's flagship Ayushman Bharat Yojana in Delhi and West Bengal.
#OmBirla #HardeepSinghPuri #LokSabha #Parliament
Subscribe now and press the bell icon 🔔 to get new video updates: bit.ly/2UV4ygi
Join ANI's RUclips membership to get access to perks:
/ @aninewsindia
--------------------------------------
ANI is South Asia's leading Multimedia News Agency providing content for every information platform, including TV, Internet, broadband, newspapers, and mobiles.
Subscribe now! Enjoy and stay connected with us!!
☛ Subscribe to ANI News RUclips channel: bit.ly/2UV4ygi
☛ Visit our Official website: www.aninews.in/
☛ Follow ANI: / ani
☛ Like us: / aninews.in
☛ Email to: anicontent@aniin.com, internetani@aniin.com
☛ Copyrights © All Rights Reserved ANI Media Pvt Ltd.
Om birla is the toughest and most honest speaker we have till now, He is strict for both bjp and oppositions. Though I also respect and admire Hardeep ji 😊
Good joke
Om ji only requested. Puri ji took it personally. But Puri ji bounced back beating opposition!
*Okay happy ji* 🫡👍🏻
Hardeep Puri was over reacting..doesn't suit him. Speaker was simply requesting!
*Puri is high on power* 🚨😈🔥
He was normal..he was natural....beta u must be hindi speaker that's why you think that way...otherwise you'd empathise and enrage
wtf , one mp is rhyming and singing in the background 😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂
Om Birla only requested him to speak hindi he did not force him
Whatever said and done. The question of Manoj Tiwari ji is absolutely necessary one. As a doctor from Kolkata we are facing this issue with the patients from Bihar, Jharkhand etc. The patients are facing difficulty.
The politics is creating problems for the poor families.
The speaker wanted to let the public know that TMC n AAP havent helped in rolling the schemes in their states for which he asked Mr Puri to speak in Hindi as it understood in both the states. Mr Puri looked irked as he didn't understood the whole scene.
The question was asked in Hindi and the minister can speak very well in Hindi, so why not?
He will b comfortable with English.
@@pundalikwalke1590nothing wrong with it...he can nicely say that
@@pundalikwalke1590 He can do in both languages, I suppose.
Jisko jis bhi Indian bhasa me bolne ka man ho wo bole. Har bhasa sundar hai ❤
Om Birla is a real humble man, when even if he's schooling you then consider yourself beyond saving.
Puri shab ache minister h
This is a simple friendly exchange of a lighter moment usually seen in any office in semi-formal manner to amke a playful scene....but the way news has been sensationalised and captions given, it conditions viewers mindset that it's something negative going on in tussle form...psst...!!
This is not Hindi imposition
When the question was asked in Hindi by Manoj ji, then Puri ji should have answered in Hindi only (since he knows Hindi), Om birla was not wrong in requesting that
If Puri disnt know Hindi, thej it would have been wrong, but Puri us not a politician he is a diplomat, ans must be atrogant one for sure
He should have asked this question in English ! Since it is an official language of India. And should be used as a medium to communicate between non Hindi people !
@@Earthquake91 Shut up, Article 343 says Hindi is the official language. Period
@@bgborden6852when someone asked a question in English Peeyush Goel answered in Hindi and then argued. The person who asked the question did not know Hindi, so it was very disrespectful just as you are asking people to shut up. Arrogant twit!
@CoCo-qi5nr correct, by that logic also, Hindi is a abetter choice given max number of people can understand it
Also, this question itself was fro Delhi, where 100% people understand Hindi
Ye to gajab ho gaya. Kal tak BJP ke log speaker ji ka support kar rahe the, ab gariya rahe hai. Aur congress speaker ji ko kharab kahti thi, ab achnak prasann ho gai. Gazab hai.
Congress prasann nahi hui vo jaisi ki taisi hi ha
@@user-hz8db2dx6o bjp chuho ko bhot pasand karti ha.
@@user-hz8db2dx6o samjha nahi mujhse keh rha tha kya ?
All those who are ranting unnecessaril, Harddep puri isnt angry or irritated. That is his way of speaking and his face is like that. Secondly, the speaker requested, it was not a compulsion. Third, he requsted because Puri knows hindi well and it becomes easy for people whom the answer is concerned to understand what he spoke. And lastly, the question was asked in Hindi and the general directions of the parliament state that the answer has to be given in the language in which the question is asked, but if the person who answers the question doesnt know of the language he or she must have to give it to the speaker in writing so that a translator is arranged prior to the proceeding.
Piche se kon bhokh rha hai ye batamizz
Hoga koi pet
abbe yr 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. I laughed so hard. Got the reference from Welcome.
Hardeep Singh Puri is right in this case 😊😊😊
He and speaker are Both correct, its just friendly banter.
Looks like Mr. Puri's ego had gotten the better of him.
What is that ringtone in background?😂
Hardeep : Muje mirchi lagi toh mein kya karu 😂
One of the most educated and talented minister in modi ji's cabinet (Hardeep Singh Puri sir)👏🏻 🇮🇳 but Who is shouting from the opposition ?
Speaker should avoid all these useless things🎭
ye background mai konsa breed ka kutte bhoke ja rahe hai?
"jo democratic discussion" ka Dhol bajate hain. ₹138 wale
Minister should be polite to Speaker... No need to be so rude!!
And what about speaker when speaker is biased then voice raise against him
Speaker is rude
Unnecessary
Om Birla is right here... If the question is asked in Hindi and when Mr Puri knows Hindi he should have replied in the same language.
Chair just made a request and Mr Puri got rattled. Disappointing to see.
@sigma_01460no i don't want to learn.
You can't force anyone to speak a particular language in a democracy cause that will be the death of freedom on its base. If you look at history it's a habit of colonialism . You are behaving none other than colonial Britishers.
The solution is to conduct the sessions in every language with translators. Just like leaders talk on a global stage
Better if we can accomodate all of the languages of India under Sixth Schedule , providing the right for people of every community. Our new parliament has latest technologies , we can easily provide a transcript for the same
Nice background music 😂
Sometimes when things are going BJPs way, the people within BJP mess up things. Let Mr.Puri reply in any language he sees comfortable. But MP Manoj Tiwari's question is irrelevant. Doesn't he know that this scheme is by health ministry. However, through this debate, people atleast know that Delhi and West bengal governments have not implemented the Ayushman Bharat scheme. Shame on TMC & AAP
Who is the idiot shouting in the background? It is very difficult to listen to what the ministers are saying.
Because aap is smart to reject Ayushman crap
Yes...BJP will surely lose if it restarts this old syndrome..people across languages vote for BJP but if starts this b.s...people will think twice
Train wali haalat hai. Pichhe kuch log chai, chana bech rahe hain.. idhar kuch log baat kar rahe hain.😅
Both the Chairs are inclined a bit one side...we know that.
Yes they always support Rahul Gandhi,shame on them
stop clickbait
Om birla is not fit for this post
Tor Babu ka sadhu thode h jo tor mausi se btiyana h 😅
Elected hai।।।। constitutional authority hai tum chup hi raho😂 bhai
Who is singing in the background.🤣🤣
When opposition will be vacant ,these ppl will ask questions to themselves and answer them 😂😂😂😂😂😂
they will play question answer round, among them.
Puch sakte hai bhai jab opposition k members bhi hote hai toh bhi puchte hai
Yes at least it will be like a classroom rather than a joker field
Sir sir on background😂I wanna see his face😂😂and the one singing
Singh is King 👑
isiliye adha punjab Pakistan me he 😂😂
😂😂😂😂
Aayushman Bharat is not available in Mumbai also, what is the reason is not known
But 20 rs kaat liye account se
Minister Puri is asking speaker to give direction in Hindi but Honourable Speaker did not even understand the simpl Hindi from Minister Puri even after asking minister to speak in Hindi.
Height of hearing but not listening and understanding the words of the minister. Minister being a expert diplomat was crisp and smartly responded.😊
Ye accha h pehle opposition ko nikal do fir aapas me lado .. democracy maata teri sada hi jai❤
one in a millennia when ruling MPs get some sort of order from the speaker. 😮
Ye to bada hi jagab ho gaya lok sabha mein. Lag raha hai Speaker and Puri ji mein baat ban nahi rahi. Kuch toh gadbad hai. Ya phir bjp se speaker ki kuch baat bigad gayi hai.
Om birla ji, you gave speech in Hindi in Karnataka assembly. You should have atleast spoke one liner Kannada like modi
Om birla said "agar aapko aati hai toh"
Bro english is not national language, it's fine to speak hindi
Hain kuch hua hi ni yahan to 😂normal conversation hai thoda bohot mazak tha bas
Hardip Puri ji should have said I don't know Hindi and m not comfortable in Hindi at this moment
Kitna disturbance hai background me...😢
50 kat overacting ka
Educated speakers like Puri, Jaishankar or once Jaitley are useful mascots for the party otherwise full of riff raffs
if only u knew about the skill a and achivement of jai shankar, he can speak 7 different languages btw
Same for Congress and tmc MPS... And when DMK mps are speaking English it seems like they are from Mars....😂
@@sabyasaci the little english they learned was for reading labels of liquor bottles...
Tiwari ji asked right question to unrelated minister😊
Congress be like: yahi to Qayamat hai"
Kitna bewkuf hai ye speaker
Honourable Speaker asked it very politely.. And even though i respect Honourable Petroleum Minister, But why he is very cocky about it? He should have just said it in Hindi.
Sikkhis usually have a very big ego, that's a problem
@@Prathmesh77not really ...this is just the only way
@@Prathmesh77 Don't go down this route and make racist remarks for no reason. He had the answer prepared in English. It is annoying when someone does that to you for no apparent reason. The speaker was in the wrong here.
I think bjp is playing this on next level😂😂...felt like this was all scripted to grab attention on the topic they were discussing...misson passed!😂
Hardeep Singh Puri's ego made him react like this. Speaker sir merely requested.
Position and opposition both !!!!!😂😂😂😂
पीछे ये कबाड़ी चिल्ला रहा है
Kitna ghatia click bait dala hai .
स्पीकर सर ने रिक्वेस्ट किया था ना की फोर्स।
Wo bhi galt hai
@@mountolympus1098koi punjabi mai puche to inke punjabi mai ya unki choice ki koi language mai hi jabab dena hota hai its rule
Worst speaker ever nalla
Speaker ko indirectly aukaat dikha diya
ho jata hai miscommunication kbhi kbhi
2:05
Minister pagla gya hai. Isko rest do or koi ache youth ko chance do jisko job ki ijjat ho. Jyada din kursi milne se charbi aana laazmi hai.
Hindi hi Hindustan hai ❤
Education is very important brother। Please take it
@@MOONLight-py6dj Already PhD in Hindi my kid...
I teach Hindi to Kids like you on a daily basis
If You are frustrated than join Family
Not Social media....
Learn some etiquette too...
Hope You understand
@@MOONLight-py6dj90% people in India do not understand English. It is better to speak in Hindi so that everyone can understand what is being said and what is not.
A big NO! ভারতে 22 টা অফিশিয়াল আছে ।
@@MOONLight-py6djAnd education in Raj bhasha is more important dhruv tatee
Wtf... He can reply in any language recognised as national languages of our nation...
Why Speaker forced him for hindi...
This is absolutely wrong...
Kalya tu halala chi paidaish ahe ka
R u blind ?
The speaker never forced him
He didnt forced. He is just encouraging the use of hindi. And I feel its very imp as it is our common Identity
@@uditchavda08 Hindi isn’t common Identity.
This is called drama
Rajasthan Royals vs Kings XI Punjab 😂😂😂😂
Do BJP k member Question Answer kr rhe. Badhiyaaa. Aur vipaksh kya kar rha. Sirf bakwas
North Indian should be able to understand Punjabi.🙏
Kyun Bhai ....Hindi kyun nhi aani chahiye sb ko.
@@infra_hub actually this is their plan to weak this country once again
Good...
Bring political entrance test, bring point based weightage in voting, bring blockchain technology in storing crucial data, make mandatory to mention full ingredients in food
राजनीति के अलावा तुझे और कुछ नहीं सूझा, दिल्ली कोलकाता की बात करेगा, UP, Bihar, झारखंड, MP, Rajasthan, CG में ही इतना काम है कि बगैर लूट के करो तो जनता का इलाज हो जाए,
Dutch or jhoot ka fasla karega kon ham sab ke lia politic plan hai hum sub hani bher-bakariy.political mahan ha.
Hardeep Puri is great!
Totally unnecessary
bihar se koe delhi treatment lane ku aata he. why cant you provide goo health care there. 15 saal apne JDU ke saath waha government chalaye he
Speaker is arrogant
Baby beer peke naache bole thamak thamak tham 😂😂😂
Om Birla didn't 'school' him.
हिंदी भाषा राष्ट्र भाषा नही हे
Angrezi bhi nai hai
yes nhi h but jabki majority mps know hindi so hindi is common lang that are used there .. there is no force to speak a particular lang but before that a translation should be submited ... so he is just telling that u have not submited any translation so please speak in hindi
INDIA ME Rhna H Toh HINDI BOLNA PDEGA NA Toh chod ke chla ja.
@@Rishaank-bh9wr han aur hindi se hum baki Indian languages ko promote kar sakte kyonki english saari languages ko khatam kar rhai hai
सभी भाषा का प्रसार होना चाहिए
Kya bewakoof hai rinkiya k papa ...yh bhe nhi pta ki kiss ministry se puchna hi ...yhi reason hai BJP ko modi saba k naam p vote lene pdte ....khuud he koi audacity he nhi hai
😂😂😂😂
Shameful click Bait
Over empowerment of hindi
Ab mantri bhi ankh dikhane lage.shameful.
🤔
Om Birla Jindabaad 🙏🙏🚩🚩
Iss sardar ko pta nhi kahe ki ego hai....kbhi bolta rohingyas ko bhr nikalenge kbhi bolta ghr denge........yh lg he duniya m g ra hai
Piche kaun bhauk raha hein ?
Khangress ka chuchu chilla raha hain
Haha😂
😂😂
When did Manoj Tiwari became BJP MP?
Manoj Tiwari ji ne sahi questions kiya h
Piche kon hai 0:57 to 1:37 😂😂 man of cultural attendance here
Nawazuddin siddique? Ya fir varun dhawan?
Don't bring up hindi all the time to ruin it's identity. It played a significant role during independence, it unites us. Plus it's relatively new/modern and an official language.
They are jealous of Hindi they want PPL of India does not Unite under umbrella of Hindi and fight among each other 😢
Lag gayi lag gayi.... aag lag gayi lag gayi 😂
inmein se ek koi toh jayega..apni jhadap idhar nikaal rahe hai..
Piche kaun bhok rahe he?
Kharge/Rahul ka naukar
What a drama 😅
AI Bhashini?
जब भाषा आती है तो AI Bhashini का use करना ज़रूरी है क्या
Yeah peech se Knon bhook raaha hai.
When exposureless politician debate with EX DIPLOMAT INDIAN FOREIGN SERVICE SERVANT 😅
With all respect to Puri ji.
There are some rules of parliament bro.
Are ? He is not illeterate, it is his job to direct.
No where in rules of parliament it is written to speak in Hindi both English and Hindi are national official languages and it is individuals choice to speak
When direction is meaningless and point less it becomes satire of irony
Chutia will start speaking spanish and italian also
The entire parliament and democracy has become a joke, this nothing compared to past events, ye to bas aise hai ki kuch dikhana hai news ke naam pe toh chala diye ye clip. The news channels have become like those celebrity gossip channels, both the question and answer were from members of the same political party, ab opposition nahi hai beizzat karne, so there least performing unit ka head ko bali ka bakra bana diya…….just for context
😂😂😂😂 burnol moment
Productivity kitna hua yeh dekho tumhari MP ko suspend kar ne ka baad thoda janlo 😂😂
Sir, does all the hospitals are entertaining Ayushman Yojna... I know that RGCI and R C does not entertain this Yojna.
Google kro.. list of empanelled hospitals is available of online
Sardar ji se panga mat lo .
1984 zindabad 💪
@@VM03936masumo ke katl pe kyo has rha hai tu
@@devendrasinghgurjar9836 kyunki wo jyaada hi ainth me aa raha hai . Likha hai Sardar ji se panga mat lo. Ye cheez kisko bol raha hai wo ? iska matlab hindu log kamzor hai?
@@VM03936 are wo khud hindu hai aur tujhe itna serious hone ki kya jarurat hai bhai video me koi war thodi chal rhi hai jo tu uske comment ko seriously le rha hai