@@blindfire951and i understand him, its his most personal song he was on the edge when wrote this, and after all someone wants to sing a part of YOUR soul... its hard to take at first
Great reaction guys! In an interview Johnny's daughter Rosanne said, "When I first heard it I cried and told my Dad, it sounds like you're saying goodbye." Johnny replied, "I am."
I think this rendition is especially poignant to those of us of a certain age who realize there is more of life behind than ahead, and how looking back, we cannot help but see regrets.
That was the last time he played the piano. June died about 3 months later, Johnny 6 months after June. This is such a different song from the 9" Nails - the difference from youth and old age with all the regrets encumbered along the way. So beautiful, so haunting. I'm 72 and feel all those emotions. It was Trevor's song, had some regrets that he let Johnny do this. When he saw the video he changed his mind and said, "It's Johnny's song now". Johnny changed one word only.
Trent Reznor has said that this song belongs to Cash. This version absolutely beautiful and is seen as the best version of the song by many people. I do like that the original version and Cash's versions take on two different meanings though, great way to cover a song and make it your own
What’s so special about Johnny Cash is that it doesn’t matter what genre of music you love the most because everyone loves Johnny Cash. He went through a failed marriage, drug abuse issues and criminal charges and he came through the other side. He wore black to honor the poor and the downtrodden and the least of us. He was against the Vietnam War. He performed in prisons because he understood those people weren’t animals. They were human beings that were paying for their crimes like he did. And while I’m an atheist JC was a devout Christian who used his faith to reach people instead of passing judgment and hating people. This is the final gift JC left for us and I cannot think of a more precious gift. I’m new to your channel and subbed. I look forward to more of y’alls content!
Johnny Cash lived these lyrics. He had his own demons as much as any rock and roll musician ever. He made this song his own from the original by Nine Inch Nails. When his kids saw that video they said it sounds like you are saying goodbye and he said I am.
his wife died before him, he gave up he couldnt live without his wife, they never left eachothers side, and used this song to say goodbye, he just wanted to be with his wife, and went on his own terms, he didnt die of diabetes, Johnny died of a broken heart! God speed Johnny Cash, you did it right, we got your message.
The part that always gets me is at the end, when he closes the piano. There's just something haunting about the way he closes it and just sits there. Just such an amazing song all around.
Rollingstone had an article years ago titled something like ' the most self destructive artists of all time' Johnny Cash was high up on the list. multiple arrests, alcoholism, drug use. womanizing in his younger years. He illustrates that pain in this video. you can definitely feel it. He never recorded another song or did another video. I understand after closing that piano at the end he never opened it again. This really was the end.
It’s an amazing song that connects with so many people because we have all experienced heartache and loss and pain and regret. Man Johnny can make you feel it. I’m a grown ass man and I cry every time I see this. You can have my empire of dirt. It’s just stuff at the end of the day and it does nothing. When you get to where Johnny was during this all that stuff means nothing, only the relationships with you, God, yourself, your friends and your family are important. RIP Johnny Cash the Man in Black
Jonny’s last gift to us, it tells his life so sadly. It is said that when Trent saw this video, he cried, when Nine inch Nails, heard it, they said “it’s no longer our song, it’s Jonny’s!
The part with June Carter Cash in it was a happy accident. She just came downstairs while they were filming to check on Johnny and the producer liked it and kept it in the video.
It’s really interesting that I connected to this song so deeply as a teen and young adult who lost friends to the opioid epidemic. Now, as a woman creeping up on 50, I relate to this song in another way in looking back on the life I’ve led so far and the shorter time ahead.
Although he was only 71 when this video was shot, he looks to be 100. It was released in February 2003, 3 months later his wife June died, and Johnny died in September. He told his daughter this was good by. This video is the #1 watched music video in history. Even the original writer and performer of the song said it no longer belongs to him. It's Johnny Cash's. This %was Johnny's last big contribution to the music world and it was 100% first class.
When NIN did Trent Reznor's song, it was from the perspective of a young man raging against the world. Johnny flipped it around and sung it as the lament of an old man taking stock of his long and somewhat tortured life, he did 91 albums from 1953 to 2003, along with bouts of drug abuse etc. Gave it, what I believe, is the true meaning...maybe because I'm 75 and well aware of my mortality. I can see the end of the runway from here.
I grew up on a radio station 97.1 with Delilah. I heard this song so long ago. I was still a kid. Used to listen to all those old songs . I'm 36 now. And I have lost names of all those beautiful songs now. All I know now is Johnny cash and someone named Fleetwood Mac
Hi Souls, Animal calls this ‘Country music’. Is this really Country? His newly amazing arrangement, voice and tone makes it ‘his Requiem’ and in the Netherlands we call it probably ‘levenslied’, song of life. Incredible lyrics turned in a amazing song
For a look behind the scenes here, look up on here Hurt Behind The Scene. I heard he was in pretty good spirits during the recording but he knew anyway, knew this was his goodbye, his wife June wasn't supposed to be in this but out of concern, she came downstairs to check on him and that look of concern on her face on the stairs was genuine. Cash lived 100 lifetimes of regret and sorrow and it showed on his face and yet he overcame it all and in the end achieved total redemption. The video was shot in bitterly cold weather in Nashville in February 2003. Three months later, June Carter Cash, the musician's wife of 35 years, died. Johnny Cash himself died on 12 September 2003, I think he just didn't want to be alone anymore, I saw the 2 of them live June 1980, they did a set in NJ at some kind of festival concert and I walked an hour to the stadium and made sure I got close, about 30-40 feet away I think and there he was, the legend, the man in black with his wife and his band, The Great Eighties /8, I remember being just awestruck and feeling Holy Crap, It's him. Just a highlight of my entire life.
In the San Quentin show, he made a joke about a briefcase backstage with "all the songs he stole in it". He only took other people's songs and redid them bettrr.
This is his goodbye. The Man in Black is one of the first triple threats, member of the Country Music Hall of Fame, Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Gospel Music Hall of Fame.
This song always makes me cry it's such a great cover. BTW thank you for not being another one of those annoying reaction channels that pauses the video every ten seconds to talk. Just enjoy the music!
June died after they created the video but before it was released and Johnny died a few months after June died. I read he watched the video with one of his daughters and she said it sounded like he was saying goodbye, and johnny said that was true, he was saying goodbye.
Yep this is JC song now, and it "Hurts" to watch him sing it. Thank you ya'll for watching this. Have an awesome weekend, enjoy to the max! Subscribed long time ago but liked this reaction as requested! Need a "love" button!
Johnny Cash is the only artist that is in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the Country Music Hall of Fame, the Songwriters Hall of Fame and the Gospel Music Hall of Fame
Masterful, comes to mind. American masterpeice. Biographical. A humble, powerful warning to anyone who is has not reached to the zenith of success that Johnny Cash has reached.
Great reaction video. Saw a comment on another reaction to this elsewhere that said (paraphrasing a bit) the difference to this and the NIN version is that Trent sings like hes angry and annoyed about his demons whereas Johnny has made peace with his. Something different you have a look at is Paolo Nutini - Iron Sky (Live at Abbey Road Studio). That and the Hurt video are among the very few songs I never tire of watching and revisit frequently as both have massive meaning to me
In one interview Trent Reznor said he was mad at first to hear that Johnny Cash was going to record his best song. But after hearing the song, he was not so upset but once Trent saw the video, he said I wrote a good song, John Cash just made it a great song. I have to agree, I loved the original Nine Inch Nails version, but Johnny's version takes it beyond great, he made it immortal.
The most powerful imagery in the video as well as Cash’s most intense emotions come with the images of Jesus, who he sang about often throughout his career. Grimacing while Jesus is being nailed to the cross knowing that his own sins were some of those that Christ died for along with all those who repentant believe. Johnny believed and believes even more fully now the true saying that “Only one life, it will soon be passed, only what’s done for Christ will last.” Thanks for the reaction.
Great reaction, honoring The Man in Black and a great song. Theres another you guys should check out, a cover of Metallica's Nothing Else Matters by a acapella group called Voiceplay. It is amazing. Thanks again!
It means. If he could start over somewhere else and try to do it all again a better way, he would turn out the same because he would find a way to screw it up again..
After hearing this Trent Reznor said with total respect "this isnt mine anymore, it belongs to Johnny now"
It's funny because Trent didn't want Mr. Cash to cover it at first but then later changed his mind and the rest is history.
@@blindfire951and i understand him, its his most personal song he was on the edge when wrote this, and after all someone wants to sing a part of YOUR soul... its hard to take at first
One hell of a tribute indeed
Great reaction guys! In an interview Johnny's daughter Rosanne said, "When I first heard it I cried and told my Dad, it sounds like you're saying goodbye." Johnny replied, "I am."
Rest in peace to a legend
Your comment made me cry just like this version by Mister Cash did🙏✌️🕊️💯
I think this rendition is especially poignant to those of us of a certain age who realize there is more of life behind than ahead, and how looking back, we cannot help but see regrets.
Well said.
The things we cannot fix anymore
This will be played at my funeral. It's like the story of my life. One I could not have written better
Kinda makes me want to make some changes in my life.
That was the last time he played the piano. June died about 3 months later, Johnny 6 months after June. This is such a different song from the 9" Nails - the difference from youth and old age with all the regrets encumbered along the way. So beautiful, so haunting. I'm 72 and feel all those emotions. It was Trevor's song, had some regrets that he let Johnny do this. When he saw the video he changed his mind and said, "It's Johnny's song now". Johnny changed one word only.
Thorns... That one word made all the difference between a 20-something-years-old's regrets and a 71-year-old's regrets.
Johnny died 4 months after June not six
Btw it's Trent Reznor not Trevor
Give the man respect. 4 months after June he passed
Seing him close the cover of the piano over the keys makes me cry every time.
If this doesn't make you cry you have no soul. Awesome reaction guys.
🇫🇮❤This is an amazing cover & even Trent Reznor admitted in one interview that "Hurt" is no longer his song, but belongs to J.C..
Trent Reznor displayed alot of respect and humility by stepping aside and saying this song is now JC's song.
@@wilsonwarner6903 Yes he did. 👍
Thing is, no matter what genre you relate to, Cash is still the man
Trent Reznor has said that this song belongs to Cash. This version absolutely beautiful and is seen as the best version of the song by many people. I do like that the original version and Cash's versions take on two different meanings though, great way to cover a song and make it your own
This was heart wrenching. Especially since Johnny had addictions issues too so he really understood the original song.
What’s so special about Johnny Cash is that it doesn’t matter what genre of music you love the most because everyone loves Johnny Cash. He went through a failed marriage, drug abuse issues and criminal charges and he came through the other side. He wore black to honor the poor and the downtrodden and the least of us. He was against the Vietnam War. He performed in prisons because he understood those people weren’t animals. They were human beings that were paying for their crimes like he did. And while I’m an atheist JC was a devout Christian who used his faith to reach people instead of passing judgment and hating people. This is the final gift JC left for us and I cannot think of a more precious gift. I’m new to your channel and subbed. I look forward to more of y’alls content!
Johnny Cash lived these lyrics. He had his own demons as much as any rock and roll musician ever. He made this song his own from the original by Nine Inch Nails. When his kids saw that video they said it sounds like you are saying goodbye and he said I am.
Johnny was a Rock Star before rock and roll.
his wife died before him, he gave up he couldnt live without his wife, they never left eachothers side, and used this song to say goodbye, he just wanted to be with his wife, and went on his own terms, he didnt die of diabetes, Johnny died of a broken heart! God speed Johnny Cash, you did it right, we got your message.
The part that always gets me is at the end, when he closes the piano. There's just something haunting about the way he closes it and just sits there. Just such an amazing song all around.
Mr.Cash had more Rock n roll in his little finger than 99% of any “metal head” etc…he was as real as it gets …and AWESOME man of Jesus
I first heard Johnny as a kid in the sixties with my parents. I heard NIN’s version but when Johnny did it made me reflect on my own life now.
Rollingstone had an article years ago titled something like ' the most self destructive artists of all time' Johnny Cash was high up on the list. multiple arrests, alcoholism, drug use. womanizing in his younger years. He illustrates that pain in this video. you can definitely feel it. He never recorded another song or did another video. I understand after closing that piano at the end he never opened it again. This really was the end.
But in the end he gave his life to God, and all that was washed away...
Johnny transcended genres.
Yes He did. Thank you for watching.
It’s an amazing song that connects with so many people because we have all experienced heartache and loss and pain and regret. Man Johnny can make you feel it. I’m a grown ass man and I cry every time I see this. You can have my empire of dirt. It’s just stuff at the end of the day and it does nothing. When you get to where Johnny was during this all that stuff means nothing, only the relationships with you, God, yourself, your friends and your family are important. RIP Johnny Cash the Man in Black
Amem
Jonny’s last gift to us, it tells his life so sadly. It is said that when Trent saw this video, he cried, when Nine inch Nails, heard it, they said “it’s no longer our song, it’s Jonny’s!
The part with June Carter Cash in it was a happy accident. She just came downstairs while they were filming to check on Johnny and the producer liked it and kept it in the video.
It’s really interesting that I connected to this song so deeply as a teen and young adult who lost friends to the opioid epidemic. Now, as a woman creeping up on 50, I relate to this song in another way in looking back on the life I’ve led so far and the shorter time ahead.
Cash is the country music loophole for metal heads.
Johnny Cash was the MAN.
Although he was only 71 when this video was shot, he looks to be 100. It was released in February 2003, 3 months later his wife June died, and Johnny died in September. He told his daughter this was good by. This video is the #1 watched music video in history. Even the original writer and performer of the song said it no longer belongs to him. It's Johnny Cash's. This %was Johnny's last big contribution to the music world and it was 100% first class.
When NIN did Trent Reznor's song, it was from the perspective of a young man raging against the world. Johnny flipped it around and sung it as the lament of an old man taking stock of his long and somewhat tortured life, he did 91 albums from 1953 to 2003, along with bouts of drug abuse etc. Gave it, what I believe, is the true meaning...maybe because I'm 75 and well aware of my mortality. I can see the end of the runway from here.
Johnny and June both had a strong relationship with Jesus Christ....they been thru it!🤗🎆
Hope you come to the UK for a mini tour , especially in Scotland, I'll get the first ticket 🏴😊🤘🎶🎶🎶🎶
Everyone that sees this video & hears the words, can't help but be touched.❤️ for this to be the very last song,, you just know he was saying goodbye
I grew up on a radio station 97.1 with Delilah. I heard this song so long ago. I was still a kid. Used to listen to all those old songs . I'm 36 now. And I have lost names of all those beautiful songs now. All I know now is Johnny cash and someone named Fleetwood Mac
Brings out the tears every time without fail
Hi Souls, Animal calls this ‘Country music’. Is this really Country? His newly amazing arrangement, voice and tone makes it ‘his Requiem’ and in the Netherlands we call it probably ‘levenslied’, song of life. Incredible lyrics turned in a amazing song
This is how a legend passes into myth.
Hi souls, always loved Johnny. Apart from being a metalhead , I do like some country from time to time. 🤠
Dolly was inducted to the rock and roll hall of fame just last year. She even wrote a rock song just for the occasion.
For a look behind the scenes here, look up on here Hurt Behind The Scene. I heard he was in pretty good spirits during the recording but he knew anyway, knew this was his goodbye, his wife June wasn't supposed to be in this but out of concern, she came downstairs to check on him and that look of concern on her face on the stairs was genuine. Cash lived 100 lifetimes of regret and sorrow and it showed on his face and yet he overcame it all and in the end achieved total redemption. The video was shot in bitterly cold weather in Nashville in February 2003. Three months later, June Carter Cash, the musician's wife of 35 years, died. Johnny Cash himself died on 12 September 2003, I think he just didn't want to be alone anymore, I saw the 2 of them live June 1980, they did a set in NJ at some kind of festival concert and I walked an hour to the stadium and made sure I got close, about 30-40 feet away I think and there he was, the legend, the man in black with his wife and his band, The Great Eighties /8, I remember being just awestruck and feeling Holy Crap, It's him. Just a highlight of my entire life.
This has to be the greatest swan song to cap off a legendary career ever
Not ashamed to say that I cry like a blubbering fool every time I see this video. It’s like he’s signing about my life.
Fantastic, Song, his best
Deep, emotional to the bone
Love your long silence before speaking! ... Many Thanks for your sweet high sensibility!
I like watching these with all sorts of people -rappers, rockers, opera whatever - this song hits a primal note within us all
I cry every time I hear this song
Keep going dudes. Love from Bon Scott's home town in Scotland.
I appreciate that you let the music play out .
Powerful cover
In the San Quentin show, he made a joke about a briefcase backstage with "all the songs he stole in it". He only took other people's songs and redid them bettrr.
This is his goodbye. The Man in Black is one of the first triple threats, member of the Country Music Hall of Fame, Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Gospel Music Hall of Fame.
This song always makes me cry it's such a great cover. BTW thank you for not being another one of those annoying reaction channels that pauses the video every ten seconds to talk. Just enjoy the music!
the guy in the middle... you were me... your feelings were palpable.
God Bless 2ndhandsouls music, the United States of America, and the Man in Black, Johnny Cash!!!
I believe Dolly is in the Rock and roll hall of Fame now 😎
You in the middle. (I'm sorry, not a subscriber, don't know your names) You stopped singing, and just felt what he sang. Thank you for that.
I love the oldiest Dolly, Lorretta, Johnny, so many of that era.
June died after they created the video but before it was released and Johnny died a few months after June died. I read he watched the video with one of his daughters and she said it sounded like he was saying goodbye, and johnny said that was true, he was saying goodbye.
Yep this is JC song now, and it "Hurts" to watch him sing it. Thank you ya'll for watching this. Have an awesome weekend, enjoy to the max! Subscribed long time ago but liked this reaction as requested! Need a "love" button!
Shout out to the creator of this video for including Johnny Cash role in Columbo as Tommy Brown
The middle guy reacting is ALL OF US.
No words required. It is what it is.❤
what a way to go out with this great video.
Johnny Cash is the only artist that is in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the Country Music Hall of Fame, the Songwriters Hall of Fame and the Gospel Music Hall of Fame
Profound remake..... Cash knew he was about to die so much truth in the words.
A very good reaction. Lots better than I thought it would be. Actually surprised you knew June Carter. Thank you for such a good reaction.
Being a Brazilian I love Johnny Cash.
Great review guys. This performance would bring a tear to a glass eye.
No Doubt
First time watching you all….seem like great people, God bless you all and your families…ROCK ON!
This song.. Holy gift from Johnny 🌹 RIP to an American legend 🖐️
How I love these reactions of yours!
So much to say regarding this song and this brilliant rendition...This song carries a payload of a psalm.
May I suggest "Seven Nation Army", by Postmodern Jukebox.
Masterful, comes to mind. American masterpeice. Biographical. A humble, powerful warning to anyone who is has not reached to the zenith of success that Johnny Cash has reached.
Great reaction video. Saw a comment on another reaction to this elsewhere that said (paraphrasing a bit) the difference to this and the NIN version is that Trent sings like hes angry and annoyed about his demons whereas Johnny has made peace with his.
Something different you have a look at is Paolo Nutini - Iron Sky (Live at Abbey Road Studio). That and the Hurt video are among the very few songs I never tire of watching and revisit frequently as both have massive meaning to me
Love Johnny's take on this iconic song, may 12 liliac drops carousel 🎠 can't wait. All the extras in the video are liliacs fangs
In one interview Trent Reznor said he was mad at first to hear that Johnny Cash was going to record his best song. But after hearing the song, he was not so upset but once Trent saw the video, he said I wrote a good song, John Cash just made it a great song. I have to agree, I loved the original Nine Inch Nails version, but Johnny's version takes it beyond great, he made it immortal.
Trent wrote a Johnny Cash song.
Fellow metalheads,always no matter my age. Nursing home cranking Judas Priest,lol
Metal up and rock on soldier. lol
No Matter What Genre Of Music You Listen to, Everyone Respects The Man In Black Johnny Cash.
I'll need to get this album,the original singer said this is John song now♥️
And now Dolly IS in the Rock and Roll Hall of fame...
The craziest collab is Tammy Wynette singing with KLF, which is a CRAZY electronic hip hop group...but it works!
lemmy and ozzy????? ima searchin' that right now! thanks! i don't recollect that one, but...... thanks again .
About addiction and the pain it caused. Strangely the House of Cash a week later burned down . His wife died the week before he did.
One of the saddest most Beautiful songs ever.
It took 3times before he agreed to do it.
Butiyful song ❤
You?
Didn't know Johnny Cash played piano..... Johnny cash was A musician and a musician plays musical instruments.... All of them
The most powerful imagery in the video as well as Cash’s most intense emotions come with the images of Jesus, who he sang about often throughout his career.
Grimacing while Jesus is being nailed to the cross knowing that his own sins were some of those that Christ died for along with all those who repentant believe. Johnny believed and believes even more fully now the true saying that “Only one life, it will soon be passed, only what’s done for Christ will last.”
Thanks for the reaction.
Dolly Parton did do a pretty amazing cover of Shine by Collective Soul
At the risk of seeming to be ironic, if this cover doesn't make you cry, you have no soul.
If God had a voice it would sound like Johnny Cash...
Or Elvis
Have a listen to Johnny Cash singing “Man in White”.
When his daughter heard this song she said "Dad it sounds like you were saying goodbye" "I am he said.
Great reaction, honoring The Man in Black and a great song. Theres another you guys should check out, a cover of Metallica's Nothing Else Matters by a acapella group called Voiceplay. It is amazing. Thanks again!
AND this was his last record before he passed.
It wasn't the last, after June died he said he had to keep busy. The last he recorded was "like the 309".
Good song, lady 😢😢may I ask you name youse was favorite
try johnny cash singing "the man
in black"
IN SPANISH: CARAJO... PUTA MADRE! THIS IS SONG IS REMARKABLE! HERE IN MY COUNTRY THERE IS A GREAT METALHEAD (PAUL GILLMAN)... GREETINGS FROM VENEZUELA
Animal sang through the entire song.
And they say, "METALHEADS" Doesn't have feelings
❤😊
Johnny, and I( I think) Elvis, are th only 2 Artist, 2 be induced, N2, The Country Music, (and)Rock&Roll Hall Of fame😎😎👍👍
It means. If he could start over somewhere else and try to do it all again a better way, he would turn out the same because he would find a way to screw it up again..
💯