Modi Lacks Moral Leadership: Yashwant Sinha | Karan Thapar

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 фев 2025
  • Karan Thapar interviews former finance minister Yashwant Sinha on his overall assessment of the government and Modi, the economy, Kashmir, relations with neighbours and US, the undermining of institutions, the Karnataka crisis, the treatment of muslims and Dalits, Modi’s lack of moral leadership, how the western press views Modi, how the Indian press treats Modi, whether a weak Rahul strengthens Modi, Sinha’s apprehensions of what might happen in the next 365 days before the elections, and Sinha’s response to Amit Shah’s claim that BJP will do even better in 2019 than 2014.
    Click here to support The Wire: yt.orcsnet.com...

Комментарии • 2 тыс.

  • @sainair
    @sainair 6 лет назад +341

    This is how interviews should be conducted : Serious and Succinct. Two learned individuals engaging in proper polite discourse without any rhetoric or argument. Kudos to the Wire Team.

    • @sacchaaashiq1923
      @sacchaaashiq1923 6 лет назад +5

      Watch zee news you will be die of laughter's !Hahaha

    • @susanthomas7659
      @susanthomas7659 6 лет назад +4

      Sai Nair excellent comment

    • @madhudonaswamy7525
      @madhudonaswamy7525 6 лет назад

      Serious and succinct and u should have add one more thing that baised against present govt 😂😂😂

    • @rfnz3994
      @rfnz3994 6 лет назад +9

      I don't see bias. He was able to justify his answers quite well.

    • @rameshchandradas946
      @rameshchandradas946 5 лет назад +1

      Both Sinha n Thapar are in the big brackets of high tech intollerence.Any way Karan got a guest of same feather.

  • @Akshaykumar-bs9ml
    @Akshaykumar-bs9ml 6 лет назад +202

    15:57 (Reforms)
    18:01 (Land aquisations, labour reforms)
    18:59 (Banks)
    20:03 (Failings of the BJP Govt)
    20:37 (Demonitisation)
    25:18 (Kashmir)
    34:22 (Indias Realtionship with other countries)
    36:25 (Indias relationship with China)
    39:56 Indias relationship with US
    47:27 Elections in Karnataka
    50:30 Divison of states in India
    52:15 How BJP politicans think about Muslims.
    57:20 Foriegn media on Modi
    57:47 India Media on Modi
    59:40 Opposition, Rahul Gandhi.

    • @sayantanibhattacharjee.772
      @sayantanibhattacharjee.772 5 лет назад +8

      What kind of AKSHAY KUMAR r u ? Today the name AKSHAY KUMAR is too much in discussions.

    • @Modassirhassan10
      @Modassirhassan10 3 года назад

      Thank you so much for doing this public service!

    • @gladsonmathew3385
      @gladsonmathew3385 3 года назад +1

      I am surprised of low number of comments. Great and wonderful work of service and accuracy! Kudos to Akshay!

    • @Sc_529
      @Sc_529 3 года назад

      Wow

    • @hirokdasgupta3642
      @hirokdasgupta3642 2 года назад +1

      Everything was completed considerably after winning 2019

  • @Darknight_Syd84
    @Darknight_Syd84 6 лет назад +177

    Now that’s journalism for you. What a logical interview something I have rarely seen in the last 4 years.

    • @aruntyor1267
      @aruntyor1267 6 лет назад +8

      It was not an interview. Both of them are at same side and of same opinion. So I would say they were discussing their hatred for Modi and government. No contradictory questions for Mr. Sinha's views about Modi and government were asked.

    • @ladkkalpeshkumar201
      @ladkkalpeshkumar201 4 года назад

      Madar chodo,, salo, tumhari sonia kya, democratic government chala rahi thi, bhenchodo, salo sub , comments valo ka ma ka bhosda

    • @roguegenesis7020
      @roguegenesis7020 4 года назад +1

      @@aruntyor1267 so that means all of Modi's are not even discussions cuz interviewees are only concerned about what wallet he carries 🤣😂🍖🍪🔥

    • @ramkisanbhalsing9255
      @ramkisanbhalsing9255 3 года назад

      When two illogical persons meet it becomes logical?You be in darknight only.

  • @saikumargorantla
    @saikumargorantla 6 лет назад +307

    This is 1000 times more important than arnabs SOUND POLLUTION.

    • @ashitkamble1729
      @ashitkamble1729 6 лет назад +11

      Noise pollution,actually

    • @gogetter7963
      @gogetter7963 5 лет назад +5

      MR YASHWANT SINHA.. WHY DONT YOU ADMIT YOU ARE A MAOIST!!
      BUT YOU LOST
      BUT YOU LOST
      BUT YOU LOST
      SO GIVE UP
      SO GIVE UP

    • @1_übermensch
      @1_übermensch 4 года назад +2

      @@gogetter7963 looool

    • @swastik1nm
      @swastik1nm 4 года назад +1

      True that

    • @satishkapoor5538
      @satishkapoor5538 4 года назад

      @@gogetter7963 119191191191191q191913919111111119119111111911919111911919191991191991111199119191 the 1199191119191991199119911111199qq1119111911111119111111919919119191119191911191919119191911199191991111919119191111991919119111 i 1111119feet a day at my house in 1veg ¹ in veg for a while in 99my for everyone 99feet 1999999feet ¹¹¹¹ i was so--

  • @vinodpande7456
    @vinodpande7456 6 лет назад +26

    Absolutely outstanding. As usual Karan Thapar, among the top of the league interviewers in the world, at his sharpest and Yashwant ji unsparingly precise and poignant in his reflections on each of the questions. No dithering, no dodging; simply shooting from the hip. The interview was a treat.

  • @TauroChuck
    @TauroChuck 6 лет назад +217

    this man is 82 years old ,such vitality and energy great salute sir

    • @kumarjeevan3374
      @kumarjeevan3374 6 лет назад +2

      true

    • @raveeshtewary2505
      @raveeshtewary2505 6 лет назад +2

      Ranish Tauro very truly said! brother

    • @ramanayak9036
      @ramanayak9036 5 лет назад +1

      Yashwanth sinha very intelligent modifies would have made him or subramanian swami jee finance minister and only donating shouchalya is not grouth

    • @gmpatra5296
      @gmpatra5296 5 лет назад +3

      yashwant sinha is sour grapes.

    • @gogetter7963
      @gogetter7963 5 лет назад

      touch wood

  • @bimaldeep251
    @bimaldeep251 6 лет назад +147

    It's a joy watching d learned speak and that too without fear

    • @MandeepSingh-kj4jt
      @MandeepSingh-kj4jt 6 лет назад +4

      Bimal Deep exactly. He is being allowed to speak and make his statements without being interepted for having anti national views just cause he does not support modi.

    • @ladkkalpeshkumar201
      @ladkkalpeshkumar201 4 года назад

      Madar chodo,, salo, tumhari sonia kya, democratic government chala rahi thi, bhenchodo, salo sub , comments valo ka ma ka bhosda

  • @saleemhashmi4131
    @saleemhashmi4131 6 лет назад +64

    Mr. Sinha , we are thankful for your X Ray analysis of B J P government working , which we could not do . Please continue to educate the nation and open their eyes .

  • @middle.class.traveller
    @middle.class.traveller 3 года назад

    Thanks

  • @kunalpawar2517
    @kunalpawar2517 6 лет назад +152

    This video should be translated into hindi so that it can reach more people.

    • @2024rush
      @2024rush 6 лет назад +3

      kunal pawar I agree. Hindi mein hi interview hota toh accha. Zyada log samajh paate. Saare acche intellectual politicians sirf English channels mein hi interviews dete hain 🙁

    • @malvikasharma1276
      @malvikasharma1276 6 лет назад +2

      kunal pawar: he is a English journalist. For Hindi journalist please watch ravish Kumar from NDTV.

    • @sumitjoshi4557
      @sumitjoshi4557 6 лет назад

      yes i also thought that.......... because very few people can understand English

    • @yourlittlefriend861
      @yourlittlefriend861 6 лет назад

      He has given interview to ndtv

    • @donaanngeorge3534
      @donaanngeorge3534 6 лет назад

      They should add subtitles at least.
      But yay English interview! :D

  • @desilad3912
    @desilad3912 6 лет назад +30

    Salute to the guts of Yashwant Sinha ji to speaking the truth. He is too good when you compare him with any cabinet minister of current government of India, including chaiwala.

  • @Muktijit
    @Muktijit 6 лет назад +136

    This is the real debate.... Not like Sambit Patra, Arnub goswami stuffs

    • @gopalkrishnanramanathan794
      @gopalkrishnanramanathan794 6 лет назад +2

      Exactly.

    • @abhyudaykanoje
      @abhyudaykanoje 6 лет назад +7

      This is not a debate, but a proper interview.

    • @VacuumFluctuation
      @VacuumFluctuation 6 лет назад +2

      Lol. This is an Interview not a debate. Kuch Bhi....:p

    • @paulamrana8981
      @paulamrana8981 6 лет назад

      Goswami must have thought his surname consists of the acronym of Swamy so he too has started the fakeism to just generate TRP's otherwise he doesn't has nothing to do with the nation because you see just by screaming , slamming and shunting English by arranging meaningless and pointless debates has became the ultimate showdown solution for this nation well honestly every common man has had enough of this two dangerous political party's one is the BJP and other is the Congress who appear to be like they are entirely separate party's but the hard cold real fact is they are both hand in gloves with each other because you see the Congress has not done anything to stop Modi or BJP from preventing the destruction which the BJP has done in this 5 years you see the proof is in the pudding itself no resignation no country wide agitation to remove this government for good and once it for all nothing has been done only press conference , media , sloganning and meaningless debates that's it.

    • @bluesque9704
      @bluesque9704 6 лет назад +1

      Who watches that shit... I may have in total over many years watched 2-3 minutes of that shit. I couldn't bear to listen the irrationality and irrelevance of their crass talk.. I mean it's no use, just pollution.

  • @MegaAnurag786
    @MegaAnurag786 6 лет назад +32

    MR.Karan Thapar is best English journalist in india.

  • @oraculosrecords
    @oraculosrecords 6 лет назад +44

    India's ranking in Global Hunger Index
    2010: 67
    2011: 67
    2012: 66
    2013: 63
    2014: 55

    • @bhargava4933
      @bhargava4933 6 лет назад +2

      Source?

    • @abirdutta8000
      @abirdutta8000 6 лет назад +3

      Bhargava,scource is internet

    • @viralhathi4394
      @viralhathi4394 6 лет назад +8

      That seemed shocking... so had to check it further... incorrectly reported...
      Include footnote portion from Hunger index reports
      2011:108/122
      2012:106/120
      2013:105/120
      2014:99/120
      2015:93/117
      2016:97/118
      2017:100/119
      source scroll.in/article/854242/fact-check-did-india-fall-45-places-in-global-hunger-index-rank-from-2014-to-2017

    • @Punerentalsolution
      @Punerentalsolution 6 лет назад +2

      Bhakto.....humne apne aankh kaan khol liye hn😂😂

    • @dariadaria9255
      @dariadaria9255 5 лет назад +1

      @@bhargava4933 🐄this cow wants to slap you

  • @livegurprit
    @livegurprit 6 лет назад +41

    finally a real interview in a very long time.

    • @ladkkalpeshkumar201
      @ladkkalpeshkumar201 4 года назад

      Madar chodo,, salo, tumhari sonia kya, democratic government chala rahi thi, bhenchodo, salo sub , comments valo ka ma ka bhosda

    • @jibran4794
      @jibran4794 4 года назад

      @@ladkkalpeshkumar201 dude your comment has not achieved it's purpose.

  • @hasratmkhan
    @hasratmkhan 6 лет назад +20

    Great interview.. excellent assessment of BJP and Modi by Karan Thapar, my favourite, and the most versatile and concerned leader Shri Yashwant Sinha...We salute you both

  • @naziransari4992
    @naziransari4992 6 лет назад +46

    Yashwant ji, thanks for the crystal clear portrayal of Mr Modi's tenure. We Indians are strongly resilient and peace loving. It is my request to you that take the charge and bring back our beautiful country to its very glory. Let the national forum vibrate at its peak.

    • @alexmercer866
      @alexmercer866 6 лет назад

      Although i don't like modi but Yaswant sinha was a disaster as an fm. It was jaswant singh who succeeded him under whom the Economy boom and prospered.

    • @aleemshaikh7527
      @aleemshaikh7527 6 лет назад

      bougain vill

  • @manasmohan5987
    @manasmohan5987 6 лет назад +270

    Congratulations to Yashwant sinha for exposing the BJP ,alienating himself from the party and forming National Forum.
    You were the first person who enlightened me that GDP numbers are fake(200 basis points was added).
    Thanks for the fighting for democracy in this facist era.
    First to comment

    • @rocksolid1952
      @rocksolid1952 6 лет назад +5

      MANAS MOHAN .. Very nice observation..

    • @bejugam9
      @bejugam9 6 лет назад +4

      true

    • @manasmohan5987
      @manasmohan5987 6 лет назад +2

      Pankaj Kudos to Modi to say Karan that DOSTI BANI RAHE
      WARNA "MORNING WALK" BHI KARWA SAKTA THA.
      YA SHADI ATTEND KARWATA(JUDGE LOYA JAISA)
      HAHAHA...

    • @prateekgoel4342
      @prateekgoel4342 6 лет назад +1

      MANAS MOHAN sir it is basis points, not bonus point

    • @manasmohan5987
      @manasmohan5987 6 лет назад

      Prateek Goel Exactly,i as wrong.Infant in the interview Yashwant Sinha tells that it was 180 basis points when they calculated the GDP figure of 2013 with the new formula

  • @wanigulzar191
    @wanigulzar191 5 лет назад +1

    Really impressed by the maturity and statesmanship of yashwant Sinha sahib. And what to say about a mature anchor and interviewer like Karan Thappar ji? Once again a grand salute to the vision of sinha ji!!!

  • @toni3323
    @toni3323 6 лет назад +6

    Such an eloquent assessment. The transcript to this interview is gold.

  • @vishal_32
    @vishal_32 6 лет назад +51

    Good to see Yashwant Sinha on the wire. Good analysis by ex-finace minister. Love to watch.👏👏👏👏

  • @AshokSingh-qh7ig
    @AshokSingh-qh7ig 6 лет назад +78

    Very fine interview. Mr. YASHWANT SINHA has explained each & every issue with complete clarity and honesty.

  • @ashutoshmanwal2085
    @ashutoshmanwal2085 6 лет назад +78

    Waooo .... what a ground knowledge about our country ... he is truly a minister material..... unlike any current ministers who are just busy in rallies and propagandas

  • @GhulamMustaffaDar
    @GhulamMustaffaDar Месяц назад

    Very engrossing discourse,Mr Sinha offers convincing arguments in support of his viewpoint.He has been a very successful Finance Minister.The country holds such people in the highest esteem.Very cool,very calculated in his overtures.

  • @apnoone
    @apnoone 6 лет назад +3

    Now that's what I call an interview. Precise and honest. All hope is not lost. 😊

  • @BobbyChauhan-drifter
    @BobbyChauhan-drifter 6 лет назад +508

    kudos to you for speaking up the truth yashwant ji ! salutes !

    • @gogagoga1593
      @gogagoga1593 6 лет назад +12

      Very bad and it seems it is our country's bad luck to miss the benefits came through petrol low prices by Modi's bad governance which came to him by nature and people

    • @sy-en
      @sy-en 6 лет назад +10

      Ram reddy Liking your own replies won't make your statements true.

    • @gogagoga1593
      @gogagoga1593 6 лет назад +2

      Ram reddy what do you mean by joker? Do you agree with Sinha?

    • @RahulKumar-ng2gh
      @RahulKumar-ng2gh 6 лет назад +3

      Lie, the blatant lie and the first lie is that jaitley promised MSP 1.5 times from RABI, But the reality is he promised it from kharif, that mean from this year
      www.livemint.com/Politics/oiI6cvlsm3lhoXC6HKkUrK/Budget-2018-Govt-to-promote-agriculture-commodity-exports.html

    • @DT-eg4ip
      @DT-eg4ip 6 лет назад +6

      Sinha is a loser..he did not get a berth in Modi cabinet and now criticizing him whole day and night. This chutiya won't go anywhere from here.

  • @javineind
    @javineind 6 лет назад +417

    Mr. Yashwant Sinha is such an intellectual. We need people like him in the Government of India.

    • @shyamgarg6562
      @shyamgarg6562 6 лет назад +1

      Pahale badaya aab Kam Karo Bhaiya vachan nibhao.adv ka kharch Kam karo

    • @colddaniel4266
      @colddaniel4266 6 лет назад +9

      The wire got exposed..
      the founders of The Wire -
      Siddharth Varadarajan, an American citizen of Indian descent, was earlier editor of The Hindu newspaper, a publication known for its Marxist/Maoist ideology anti-Hindu slant. Varadarajan is a known Modi-baiter in the Lutyens’ Delhi media ecosystem. His brother Tunku Varadarajan, a US-based writer and journalist, has also been called out for his vitriolic Hindu-bashing. His wife Nandini Sundar is a DU professor who has been accused of deep links with Maoist terrorists.
      Sidharth Bhatia is a journalist and writer based in Mumbai. He frequently disses the ‘Sanghi mind’ on twitter and cheers when history textbooks in California denigrate Hindu Dharma, or when our ex-colonial masters in UK plan to introduce a dangerous law against ‘caste discrimination’ that would pit Dharmic communities against one another.
      M.K. Venu is another ex-The Hindu journalist who shot to national fame in the infamous Radia Tapes episode that exposed the corrupt journalist-corporate-politician-bureaucrat nexus that was UPA’s gift to the country. Venu is also believed to have a role in the dubious infusion of funds to NDTV that is related to the ongoing bank fraud investigation against NDTV promoters.
      The Wire‘s coverage
      near total lack of positive or balanced reporting of any act by the Modi Government,
      silence over Mamta Banerjee’s pandering to her Islamist votebank (on the contrary articles blame BJP for ‘communalizing’ the state),
      air-brushing CPM’s violent tactics to silent political opposition in Kerala (one article terms it as ‘Majoritarian Violence’
      and absolves communist ideology chillingly stated by CM Pinari Vijayan), equivocation of the ethnic cleansing of Kashmiri Pandits with
      the civilian deaths in J&K during the 27-year battle against terrorism.

    • @SudhirSingh-zv8fb
      @SudhirSingh-zv8fb 6 лет назад +3

      Javed Ahmed katue bhai tumko to Hafiz aur Osama BHI intellectual lagte h

    • @sy-en
      @sy-en 6 лет назад +1

      cold daniel Akshay Kumar bhi madharchod canadian hai

    • @ageless1003
      @ageless1003 6 лет назад +3

      @javed ahmed - You would be surprised that there are many intellectual politicians and beaurocrats in India but they all are sidelined by internal petty party politics and asshollery because it's soo damn easy to fool people of India.

  • @sagarprasad9817
    @sagarprasad9817 6 лет назад +93

    Karan sir in wire good going wire keep the fourth pillar of democracy alive .

    • @colddaniel4266
      @colddaniel4266 6 лет назад

      The wire got exposed..
      the founders of The Wire -
      Siddharth Varadarajan, an American citizen of Indian descent, was earlier editor of The Hindu newspaper, a publication known for its Marxist/Maoist ideology anti-Hindu slant. Varadarajan is a known Modi-baiter in the Lutyens’ Delhi media ecosystem. His brother Tunku Varadarajan, a US-based writer and journalist, has also been called out for his vitriolic Hindu-bashing. His wife Nandini Sundar is a DU professor who has been accused of deep links with Maoist terrorists.
      Sidharth Bhatia is a journalist and writer based in Mumbai. He frequently disses the ‘Sanghi mind’ on twitter and cheers when history textbooks in California denigrate Hindu Dharma, or when our ex-colonial masters in UK plan to introduce a dangerous law against ‘caste discrimination’ that would pit Dharmic communities against one another.
      M.K. Venu is another ex-The Hindu journalist who shot to national fame in the infamous Radia Tapes episode that exposed the corrupt journalist-corporate-politician-bureaucrat nexus that was UPA’s gift to the country. Venu is also believed to have a role in the dubious infusion of funds to NDTV that is related to the ongoing bank fraud investigation against NDTV promoters.
      The Wire‘s coverage
      near total lack of positive or balanced reporting of any act by the Modi Government,
      silence over Mamta Banerjee’s pandering to her Islamist votebank (on the contrary articles blame BJP for ‘communalizing’ the state),
      air-brushing CPM’s violent tactics to silent political opposition in Kerala (one article terms it as ‘Majoritarian Violence’
      and absolves communist ideology chillingly stated by CM Pinari Vijayan), equivocation of the ethnic cleansing of Kashmiri Pandits with
      the civilian deaths in J&K during the 27-year battle against terrorism.

    • @sy-en
      @sy-en 6 лет назад +2

      cold daniel Akshay Kumar Bhi Canadian Hai

    • @gary6395
      @gary6395 6 лет назад

      The fourth pillar of democracy is not as honest as you think. Nira Radia tapes comes to mind.

  • @nafeesasyed7176
    @nafeesasyed7176 6 лет назад +1

    Yes very comprehensive interview.I haven't seen this kind of journalism from last 4yr till now on any mainstream media.very well conducted by wire team.

  • @rahimunnisabegum5673
    @rahimunnisabegum5673 3 года назад

    I am extremely pleased to watch this program and felt Proud we have very sincere people like Mr.Sinha.

  • @reymat978
    @reymat978 6 лет назад +28

    We need educated & well formed minded people like you in politics

  • @dhoomketu731
    @dhoomketu731 6 лет назад +27

    Identifying oneself with the right doesn't necessarily make one a bigot. Hear this man speak and ask yourself whether he sounds like a communal bigot? For as long as one believes in the fundamental tenets of freedom, democracy and secularism, it doesn't matter whether one associates himself with either the Left or the Right. People like Yashwant Sinha and Arun Shourie will remembered as heroes of the Indian Right in the days to come. No one else has spoken with the kind of conviction and objectivity with which these two gentlemen have spoken against spectre of fascism that has been unleashed on our motherland since 2014.

    • @alexmercer866
      @alexmercer866 6 лет назад

      Lol check out the statement that they had made when they were in power.

  • @tauheedhaqqani4534
    @tauheedhaqqani4534 6 лет назад +32

    One of the best interview i have ever seen. Karan thapar is best

    • @colddaniel4266
      @colddaniel4266 6 лет назад

      The wire got exposed..
      the founders of The Wire -
      Siddharth Varadarajan, an American citizen of Indian descent, was earlier editor of The Hindu newspaper, a publication known for its Marxist/Maoist ideology anti-Hindu slant. Varadarajan is a known Modi-baiter in the Lutyens’ Delhi media ecosystem. His brother Tunku Varadarajan, a US-based writer and journalist, has also been called out for his vitriolic Hindu-bashing. His wife Nandini Sundar is a DU professor who has been accused of deep links with Maoist terrorists.
      Sidharth Bhatia is a journalist and writer based in Mumbai. He frequently disses the ‘Sanghi mind’ on twitter and cheers when history textbooks in California denigrate Hindu Dharma, or when our ex-colonial masters in UK plan to introduce a dangerous law against ‘caste discrimination’ that would pit Dharmic communities against one another.
      M.K. Venu is another ex-The Hindu journalist who shot to national fame in the infamous Radia Tapes episode that exposed the corrupt journalist-corporate-politician-bureaucrat nexus that was UPA’s gift to the country. Venu is also believed to have a role in the dubious infusion of funds to NDTV that is related to the ongoing bank fraud investigation against NDTV promoters.
      The Wire‘s coverage
      near total lack of positive or balanced reporting of any act by the Modi Government,
      silence over Mamta Banerjee’s pandering to her Islamist votebank (on the contrary articles blame BJP for ‘communalizing’ the state),
      air-brushing CPM’s violent tactics to silent political opposition in Kerala (one article terms it as ‘Majoritarian Violence’
      and absolves communist ideology chillingly stated by CM Pinari Vijayan), equivocation of the ethnic cleansing of Kashmiri Pandits with
      the civilian deaths in J&K during the 27-year battle against terrorism.

    • @sy-en
      @sy-en 6 лет назад

      cold daniel Akshay Kumar Bhi Madharchod Canadian Hai

    • @RahulRahul-xm5pv
      @RahulRahul-xm5pv 6 лет назад

      Dost watch every interview or discussion of Mt sinha on you tube.. you will certainly like all of them😊

  • @MrDeepsgj
    @MrDeepsgj 6 лет назад +2

    Respect to both of you for discussing the most core present political & economic situation. We miss this kinds of interviews in our regular tv channels.

  • @akshayherur6963
    @akshayherur6963 4 года назад +1

    Absolute "Baloney" !!! The Honourable Yashwant Sinha cracks me up. Hardcore conservatives have been alienated by this government. I still can't believe Modi found space to the right of Advani.

  • @DILLIPKUMARSAHOOIITM
    @DILLIPKUMARSAHOOIITM 6 лет назад +18

    Thank you Karan and The Wire for such an eye opening interview. Treat to listen to the wisdom of political stalwarts like Yashwant ji. The people of India are awakening. The intellectuals have already, the general masses just need to. We will se revolution in 2019.

  • @wisetry72
    @wisetry72 6 лет назад +16

    Mr. Sinha Spoke. Spoke like a true leader without fear! Now it is up to the people to be fearless and uplift themselves.

  • @prakashraj7112
    @prakashraj7112 6 лет назад +79

    Karan Thapar is always a treat to watch. Would Love to see him interviewing Modi and Co.

    • @alaneus
      @alaneus 6 лет назад +10

      As if Modi would ever face him xD

    • @ravin2363
      @ravin2363 6 лет назад +21

      dosti bani rahe bas :D

    • @targaryenXoolf
      @targaryenXoolf 6 лет назад +6

      We should have live TV debates between PM candidates, with Mr Thapar as moderator. Modi will be absent if that happens.

    • @mitaroy9415
      @mitaroy9415 6 лет назад +5

      ravindra bhandari yes I remember. Ha ha

    • @nisubinny6002
      @nisubinny6002 6 лет назад +5

      PRAKASH RAJ in your dreams modi will give ny uncomfortable interviews

  • @khalidiqbal314
    @khalidiqbal314 6 лет назад

    In actual Yashwant Sinha is a intelectual and great leader. This is our badnasibi that this type of people must be the P.M of India. He is the cream of the country and who had work in Govt. As an officer.I am not pro BJP but I respect the people who are well educated,learned and having no hesitation to say the facts irrespective of any party,cast or creed. I salute again to him who is the real best wisher of the country and know very well that what is good and what is bad. At last i have to say that interview was awesome.

  • @kumarpradeep6668
    @kumarpradeep6668 6 лет назад +3

    Great Interview Mr Karan Thapar as always. Yashwant Sinha too outspoken. Hope the Modi's party(No more BJP) is fully exposed and kicked off from power to save our precious Institutions and even the very constitution.

  • @gurvinderpalsingh9929
    @gurvinderpalsingh9929 6 лет назад +22

    Very beautiful conversation between two learned persons.

  • @sandeepkumarsinha5684
    @sandeepkumarsinha5684 6 лет назад +85

    Great interview..
    Mr Thapar is very bold

    • @KalpShahGSTClasses
      @KalpShahGSTClasses 6 лет назад

      Does understanding and speaking English has anything to do with the problems of public? Karan is highly opinionated guy. Always against Modi. Karan thanper is the intellectual dumbo who knows manything but can do nothing for the good or can never be positive in life.

    • @sandeepkumarsinha5684
      @sandeepkumarsinha5684 6 лет назад +2

      Kalp Shah GST claases U can see any of Karan Thapar's interview..It is his style to ask critical questions.. U can see this in his earlier interviews especially of Sitaram Yechury and P.Chidambaram..

    • @saikumargorantla
      @saikumargorantla 6 лет назад +1

      He is not bold. This is how weak we are as a country. In US it is very common to criticise government and president and get away with it. In our country though it is mentioned in Constitution, the goons who have been ruling us didn't empower people with those rights and privileges.

    • @kesavakrishna8384
      @kesavakrishna8384 6 лет назад

      Sandeep Sinha no no app. ft app to CL NC BL NC. ex

  • @IBM1111
    @IBM1111 6 лет назад +22

    Yashwant Sinha shows reality.

  • @sunilmahajan2489
    @sunilmahajan2489 4 года назад +2

    Does anyone here Miss the old BJP which used to work for the people? Atal ji , sinha, advani, arun shourie, sushma swaraj , pramod mahajan 👌

  • @madhuShio
    @madhuShio 6 лет назад +2

    Dil khus ho gaya...yashwant ji put Each and every point very very​clear

  • @alisir-mechanicalengineer534
    @alisir-mechanicalengineer534 6 лет назад +40

    Yashwant Sinha JI you are really doing great job.....

  • @archnatuli4389
    @archnatuli4389 6 лет назад +43

    Excellent analysis on the current state of our nation.
    We Indians are actually living in a fools paradise created by majority of our politicians in the last seventy years be it of any party.
    And these good for nothing fellas without any moral values call themselves nationalists.
    Look what have they made out of such a hard working Indian race.
    But hope should not given up.
    Thanks.

  • @melvinfernandes8265
    @melvinfernandes8265 6 лет назад +5

    The true face of Narendra Modi Government!
    Thank you Mr.Yashwant Sinha!
    Brilliant interview.. as always Mr.Karan Thapar

  • @jmrashmi4961
    @jmrashmi4961 6 лет назад +2

    we need people with morals, intelligence, loyalty, and content.Mr. Yashwant Singh is one of that rare gem of the Indian Politics. we need such approach from other politicians and parties !!! Great Interview

  • @kaustubhkambli874
    @kaustubhkambli874 6 лет назад +2

    These videos needs to be translated in all regional languages so that it can cover large masses.
    Great work done by the Team Wire.

  • @manasmohan5987
    @manasmohan5987 6 лет назад +146

    We should learn from Karan Thapar and Shashi Tharoor on how to speak english such gracefully
    They both speak and write english very well.

    • @x12624
      @x12624 6 лет назад +3

      That's very true. Two gems of India

    • @honestamar
      @honestamar 6 лет назад +5

      Sir pc chidamabaram also speaks very well

    • @manasmohan5987
      @manasmohan5987 6 лет назад +4

      ayesha Mateen Hi,Ayesha.
      We should be fearful that even in our worst nightmare,we don't meet a person with such a pathetic pronunciation skills.
      He says weed energy (wind),ईज instead of is.His recent statement to Karnataka governor would had been
      "Give us pipeteen (15) days to prove our STREANH (for strength) in the assembly. Hahaha. Do u know that he uses teleprompter to deliver his speeches. Google it
      ruclips.net/video/DLfZKZuf_DI/видео.html

    • @KalpShahGSTClasses
      @KalpShahGSTClasses 6 лет назад +2

      Does understanding and speaking English has anything to do with the problems of public? Karan is highly opinionated guy. Always against Modi.

    • @manasmohan5987
      @manasmohan5987 6 лет назад +1

      Kalp Shah GST claases No,Karan is not ,he plays devils advocate in his interview.He asks tough questions to Congress and BJP and all other persons ,who hrle interviews in a opposing manner.
      I've read his articles,he and Advaniji are very good friends. He even wrote that BJP should make Advani as the President of India.

  • @kabeerkhan2747
    @kabeerkhan2747 6 лет назад +30

    Salute to Mr. Yashwant Sinha for speaking so boldly and openly against pradhan sevak.
    Mr. Karan Thapar you are fearless and crisp as usual, one of the best interviewers we've ever seen on Indian television.
    All thanks to The Wire channel for bringing up such interesting interviews, you guys are doing an amazing job 👍👍👍

  • @rayez60
    @rayez60 6 лет назад +35

    Greatest Respect!!!

  • @amandeepsaini11
    @amandeepsaini11 6 лет назад

    Wow this the perfect analysis of our country's situation. Well explained with balance Mr. Yaswant sinha. Ur decent and opinions are now written in history, coming generation will be proud of your wisdom. Thanku very much Jai Hind

  • @kiransahni100
    @kiransahni100 3 года назад

    Great well informed serious discussion, salute to Mr.Sinha ,he is a great thought provoking personality

  • @shock-t3768
    @shock-t3768 6 лет назад +47

    One of the most honest journalist of our time. Thank you for raising such important questions.

    • @shock-t3768
      @shock-t3768 6 лет назад +4

      If you trust Arun Jaitley's words you are a bigger fool. He can't keep any of his promises when it came to GST. We all have seen it first hand. Now, about what you said about Karan Thapar, anyone who speaks for the good of India and exposes BJP, you term him as pakistani agent. Who is the anti-national? A paid IT cell worker or Mr. Karan Thapar? Please do not sell your motherland for a few rupees. Stop promoting lies and hate against those who are truly working to uplift India.

    • @Vajjika_Vidyapeeth
      @Vajjika_Vidyapeeth 6 лет назад

      Hahaha

    • @ArjunSingh-wl9dc
      @ArjunSingh-wl9dc 6 лет назад

      lol.. ha ha ha ha .. Honest .. Any one who is Anti Hindu and support Gajwa - E Hind is honest..

  • @terminator7541
    @terminator7541 6 лет назад +439

    Mr.thapar you are awesome 👍

    • @KalpShahGSTClasses
      @KalpShahGSTClasses 6 лет назад +11

      Does understanding and speaking English has anything to do with the problems of public? Karan is highly opinionated guy. Always against Modi. Karan thanper is the intellectual dumbo who knows manything but can do nothing for the good or can never be positive in life.

    • @jairajsingh2228
      @jairajsingh2228 6 лет назад +23

      Mr kalp shah, those are true patriot who are anti modi, bcs modi is making fools to the country by his fake speaches .

    • @terminator7541
      @terminator7541 6 лет назад +11

      Ananda D..thanks for ur kind words

    • @gogagoga1593
      @gogagoga1593 6 лет назад +4

      Mr. Sinha's fareness irrespective of his attachment with BJP.

    • @groot1408
      @groot1408 6 лет назад

      Mr thappar a dumbass

  • @anikyt7570
    @anikyt7570 6 лет назад +101

    BJP Government (not party) spent 4000 crore tax payers money for their publicity. This is outrageous.

    • @prabchen
      @prabchen 5 лет назад +2

      anikyt7570 outrageous and true

    • @rachanathakur5203
      @rachanathakur5203 5 лет назад +7

      They did only publicity nothing else . Won the elections by PR of Modi and the PRO is Amit Shah.

    • @ladkkalpeshkumar201
      @ladkkalpeshkumar201 4 года назад +2

      Madar chodo,, salo, tumhari sonia kya, democratic government chala rahi thi, bhenchodo, salo sub , comments valo ka ma ka bhosda

  • @satishvarghese803
    @satishvarghese803 4 года назад +1

    Been loving Karan’s interviews. This one in particular with Yashwant Sinha is excellent

  • @ritwiksalavsharma4184
    @ritwiksalavsharma4184 6 лет назад +3

    I am so grateful for finding this particular news channel in this age of paid news and fake news. Amazing and huge fan of Karan Sir

  • @Nadd108
    @Nadd108 6 лет назад +65

    Yashwant Ji keep on saying that they will be judged by the promises they made but I don't think that will happen in 2019. The only thing that these Gujju brothers had managed to do successfully for the first time in India is that they have successfully changed the perception of the people, they put so much of work in making fools of people that no matter where you look even after so much distress & unfulfilled promises people still blindly supporting them so ppl have already forgotten about the promises. People still believe still after 4yrs that Congress is responsible for ever bad thing. It's terrible state of affairs but unfortunately true !!

    • @abhinavsrivastava2319
      @abhinavsrivastava2319 6 лет назад +7

      I agree with you on another level brother. They have shown that their excellent marketing and brainwashing campaigns have yielded result. Future India seems scary if this megalomaniac stays in power.

    • @rachanathakur5203
      @rachanathakur5203 5 лет назад +3

      You were right . Even educated people like doctors voted to BJP for Modi knowing they're electing Pragya Thakur or Gautam Gambhir . Who don't even understand e of economics.

    • @tgsaravind
      @tgsaravind 4 года назад +1

      unfortunately this still holds true.

    • @tgsaravind
      @tgsaravind 4 года назад +3

      @@rachanathakur5203 Pragya Thakur stepping her feet in the Indian parliament is a collective shame for the entire country. Unforgivable. Irrepairable damage.

  • @naveensolanky6170
    @naveensolanky6170 6 лет назад +24

    Great analysis and true analysis. Please people be united to save country and democracy.

    • @mailmazhar
      @mailmazhar 6 лет назад

      They are not ‘Bhakts’. They are ‘Modi Fools’. They are not aware, they are being fooled in the name of religion.

  • @surajnaslapur2949
    @surajnaslapur2949 6 лет назад +14

    Fantastic interview
    Thank you the wire!

  • @ishanjaiswal6446
    @ishanjaiswal6446 6 лет назад +1

    We are grateful to both Mr Thapar for the pin point relevant questions and Mr Yashwant Sinha, for his honesty and insight.. This Interview should be on air for all the masses.

  • @MohamedAnsari_H
    @MohamedAnsari_H 6 лет назад

    wow, great job by Karan and the wire Yashwant Sinha is such a great intellectual and a statesman who understands the country, Such clear questions and answers, Time well spent. This should be watched in the millions the whole country should watch this.

  • @abdulrehmangaihlot5319
    @abdulrehmangaihlot5319 6 лет назад +11

    Mr. Karan Thaper interviewed very well, equally well delivered by Yashwant Sinha ji.

  • @NidzShah-ps6kr
    @NidzShah-ps6kr 6 лет назад +4

    I think every Indian must watch this interview. Yashwant Sinha is such an amazing speaker. He answers questions with such clarity, succinctness and calm. Listening to this man will dispell this disease some of us suffer from called political illiteracy.

  • @sr-gc6vh
    @sr-gc6vh 6 лет назад +22

    Long live Yashwant Sinha and Arun Shourie.

  • @yesafarnaama
    @yesafarnaama 6 лет назад +1

    its always nice to listen to views of leaders like Yashwant Sinha. Great interview.

  • @likithabh3944
    @likithabh3944 6 лет назад

    Cannot believe such a honest person was part of our Indian government! Thank you restoring faith on Indian government!respect for yaswanth Sinha!people of India have to switch of their TV's and start watching the wire on RUclips! Hope this video goes on trending

  • @sreeniala4603
    @sreeniala4603 6 лет назад +109

    Vajpayee ji 's cabinet consisted of intelligent , responsible bureaucrat . Look at our state now , choose between the lesser of the evils !😢- once a upon time BJP admirer to a frustrated Indian now....this interview should be dubbed in all languages of India and telecast in every place . Whole of India needs to watch this !

    • @hinausmani3688
      @hinausmani3688 6 лет назад

      music gives life hope all

    • @rccapur
      @rccapur 6 лет назад +1

      that is why vajpai was thrown out

    • @rajValath
      @rajValath 6 лет назад +2

      Except Kerala as Kerala is the last bastion to be conquered by BJP. They dont have a chance here anyways.

    • @saneenmustafa8339
      @saneenmustafa8339 6 лет назад +1

      That is why, Mr. Vajpayee Govt was widely appraised.

    • @INDIANOIL100
      @INDIANOIL100 6 лет назад

      music gives life hope
      Ke pe iq ke ka ka ka ms nv bcz bbc va na ke

  • @farooqkakroo7529
    @farooqkakroo7529 6 лет назад +11

    There are few top most journalists in whole india and Karan sir is toping the list.

  • @swamiprasantananda3115
    @swamiprasantananda3115 6 лет назад +10

    As usual, a great interview. Kudos to both Karan and Yashwant Sinha.

  • @sumanverma6274
    @sumanverma6274 3 года назад

    Amazing interview. How decently two big men are discussing this government. Patra can watch this..

  • @ruchijain6878
    @ruchijain6878 6 лет назад +1

    superb interview...looking forward for many such real and not scripted interviews...

  • @amitavapaith5522
    @amitavapaith5522 6 лет назад +46

    I firmly believe Modi-Shah not only destroying future of our country but these duo destroying BJP also.The 56” should be thrown to save India.

  • @zameerullashariff2369
    @zameerullashariff2369 6 лет назад +50

    I still remember when Mr Karan thapar made modi sweat and run away from the interview... That's y modi is so afraid of original media..

  • @musaifkhan7531
    @musaifkhan7531 6 лет назад +24

    Awesome interview

  • @rajValath
    @rajValath 6 лет назад +5

    The state of India reminds me of 1945 Germany. Looking at the war ruins, carnage and destruction and poverty, the people of Germany wondered " Is this the condition of a much civilsed Germany and its people?, was it for this the huge majority of Germans supported their Fuhrer. Modi certainly has the makings of Fuhrer - even though he is inside the democratic confines- , but if the Indians, elect him next time, he would makes sure he dont have to tackle the democratic confines any more.

  • @eunicechristianchristian1424
    @eunicechristianchristian1424 6 лет назад +2

    PJ. Sri Yashwant ji , you are an honest person in Public service and have ample knowledge of the ministry you were entrusted with , we need your service God Bless You ! 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍 😇 !!!

  • @abhayvsbm10
    @abhayvsbm10 6 лет назад +24

    Good work mr. Thapar your are real journalists

  • @sunnysingh4nitr
    @sunnysingh4nitr 6 лет назад +18

    Very graceful interview with one of a good intellectual leader of our country about what's current situation of our country and what our current government has done and achieve...... Lot's respect to Mr.yashwant sinha ji..... After mr.vajpaaye i saw a really great leader in Bjp which our current government has couldn't be able to use for our countries benefit......🙏🙏

  • @MohyuddinShaikh
    @MohyuddinShaikh 6 лет назад +7

    Simply Awsome interview. Hats off mr Yashwant Sinha for exposing bjp....

  • @Faizy_Ahmad
    @Faizy_Ahmad 4 года назад +1

    Two great personalities...glad i found this video.

  • @gosmikarlo6594
    @gosmikarlo6594 4 года назад +1

    Wire, always bringing best of informative interviews.

  • @nehalakhter625
    @nehalakhter625 6 лет назад +5

    Only possible on the Wire --- two eminent personalities under one roof discussing on national problems,economy,problems of farmers,unemployment,political manners etc. It's our bad fortune that country is not using the talent of Shri Sinha, Raghuram Rajan and many others like them.

  • @daaaniel21
    @daaaniel21 6 лет назад +168

    Great interview

    • @IamRanJos
      @IamRanJos 6 лет назад +5

      Ram reddy Don't troll yourself buddy, you sound ridiculous

    • @avisheksingh544
      @avisheksingh544 6 лет назад

      imp. interview Karan g

    • @bhagawanaupadhyay3833
      @bhagawanaupadhyay3833 6 лет назад

      31-5-2018
      1-उत्तर प्रदेश: महिला ने भाजपा विधायक पर लगाया बलात्कार का आरोप, मामला दर्ज thewirehindi.com/45039/uttar-pradesh-budaun-bjp-mla-booked-for-rape/ via @thewirehindi
      2-जन गण मन की बात, एपिसोड 251: पेट्रोल-डीज़ल के दाम और गौरी लंकेश हत्याकांड thewirehindi.com/45102/jan-gan-man-ki-baat-petrol-price-hike-and-gauri-lankesh-case/ via @thewirehindi
      3-हम भी भारत, एपिसोड 36: क्या कैराना उपचुनाव में आचार संहिता का उल्लंघन हुआ है? thewirehindi.com/45074/hum-bhi-bharat-kairana-bypolls-election-commission-model-code-of-conduct/ via @thewirehindi
      4-
      30-5-2018
      1-मोदी सरकार के चार साल पूरे होने पर शिक्षा, रोज़गार और कृषि क्षेत्र को क्... ruclips.net/video/-e26ZI8Nj5w/видео.html via @RUclips
      2-मीडिया बोल, एपिसोड 51: कोबरापोस्ट स्टिंग और तूतीकोरिन हिंसा ruclips.net/video/RNhx4692gzY/видео.html via @RUclips
      3-आखिर Baba Ramdev ने लॉन्च कर दिया Patanjali Sim l The Lallantop ruclips.net/video/asWd8k5snuE/видео.html via @RUclips
      4-पड़ताल: क्या Varanasi में जो पुल गिरा, उसका ठेकेदार Nitin Gadkari का बेट... ruclips.net/video/JjzdZ1IttM4/видео.html via @RUclips
      5-द वायर बुलेटिन: तूतीकोरिन में वेदांता समूह के स्टरलाइट कॉपर संयंत्र को ब... ruclips.net/video/ei7geMo6XX0/видео.html via @RUclips
      6-Jan Gan Man Ki Baat, Episode 250: EVM Malfunction and Public Discourse i... ruclips.net/video/FPw3-9EiZ0Y/видео.html via @RUclips
      7-भारत का हर युद्ध लड़ने वाले Lt Gen Zorawar Chand Bakshi के मरने पर PM Mo... ruclips.net/video/EDyQygfUN8M/видео.html via @RUclips
      8-क्या देश में वाकई ‘भगवा’ लहर चल रही है? thewirehindi.com/44878/is-there-a-saffron-wave-or-modi-wave-in-the-country/ via @thewirehindi
      9-चुनाव आयोग ने स्पष्ट किया, राष्ट्रीय पार्टियां आरटीआई क़ानून के दायरे में thewirehindi.com/44933/political-parties-under-rti-election-commission-contradicts-cic-directive/ via @thewirehindi

    • @cslr123
      @cslr123 6 лет назад

      Ram reddy yes modi and shah

  • @ranjanazad01
    @ranjanazad01 6 лет назад +38

    yanswant sinha is one of few bjp leaders, who is morally strong, and speak truth.. respect for him..

    • @chimugeorge2354
      @chimugeorge2354 5 лет назад +1

      Why don't tell your son to leave this useless party

    • @chimugeorge2354
      @chimugeorge2354 5 лет назад

      He is very educated. He is a waste for uneducated people.

  • @pepy7779
    @pepy7779 6 лет назад +1

    Yashwantji is a great intellect. Thanks for clarifying so many issues so well.

  • @farookhmansoor
    @farookhmansoor 6 лет назад

    I feel so proud and happy to get in this interview.. Wish people of India listens to intellectuals.

    • @melodicnostalgic3823
      @melodicnostalgic3823 6 лет назад

      No such thing as Intellectual.
      Those who parade themselves to be Intellectuals and above others are promoting Absolutism, Power only in their hands.

    • @farookhmansoor
      @farookhmansoor 6 лет назад

      MelodicNostalgic I mean listens not to so called chaiwala ( I respect real chaiwala)

  • @swapniln8904
    @swapniln8904 6 лет назад +24

    Such interviews must be broadcasted in all news channels.

  • @shabashachi1238
    @shabashachi1238 6 лет назад +104

    I am not so much against Modi to rise petrol tax .
    But when Modi was in opposition, he did drama to reduce petrol tax.

    • @sreeniala4603
      @sreeniala4603 6 лет назад +7

      Shabashachi 123 hypocrite feku is

    • @skpro2050
      @skpro2050 6 лет назад +13

      Fual prices are not a big issue but how he trying to control democracy is totally horrible and will give us terrible results in future if it won't be stopped.

    • @shubh12345B
      @shubh12345B 6 лет назад +4

      You should have problem...cz prices are not justified....i am not saying there should not be tax. But they are using 5petrol products(high speed disel, motor spirit, aviation turbine fuel, natural gas, crude) to cover the decline in govt revenue due to gst that is why these products are not taxed under gst they are taxed in old tax laws!
      The benefit in reduced price which should be passed on to us they are taking that benefit!

    • @shabashachi1238
      @shabashachi1238 6 лет назад +8

      Sukhdev Kamboj , if all parties will unite against BJP , then feku will loose. Don't worry.

    • @jugo3558
      @jugo3558 6 лет назад +9

      Same regarding Aadhar. He was loudly against it when he was in the opposition. We saw how fearmongering tactics were used to enrol people when he came into power. When UPA was in power, BJP had opposed GST as well. Modi takes credit for everything but responsibility of nothing.

  • @doodlinglives
    @doodlinglives 6 лет назад +14

    Every bit and part is very true...

  • @drpoorvakulkarni8473
    @drpoorvakulkarni8473 6 лет назад

    An excellent interview with an intellectual conversation. No nationalistic jingoism and chest thumping. Music to the ears.

  • @abhisingh1836
    @abhisingh1836 6 лет назад

    Great job the wire. You people are brave and couragious. I am a student right now but once i start earning i will donate to your cause. You and India deserves it.

  • @rameshgoswami9682
    @rameshgoswami9682 6 лет назад +13

    One of the finest discourses I heard in recent times.

  • @bharatsharma2482
    @bharatsharma2482 6 лет назад +8

    This is how you conduct an interview.
    Not what the mainstream media is doing.

  • @rockedbottom
    @rockedbottom 6 лет назад +27

    That 56 inches refers to Dear Leader's waist.

  • @kiyas999
    @kiyas999 6 лет назад

    Yashwant sinha is very frankly speaking honest leader... very good interview mr. Karan Taper you are one of the best journalist around the world.. lets all india knows about the truth.. jai hind..

  • @martinguite369
    @martinguite369 Год назад +1

    Gujarat model was implemented on MANIPUR that is why ,we the tribals payed the most with our suffering & blood itself. History will remember of this injustice done on us just because we were CHRISTIANS!!?? & for our whole country,it's on its lowest point ever...BJP are not just an agresser but also murderer & criminals...wish AAP cum next and improve our critical level for the low financial people like us tribals😢❤✌️☮️🤬