JAY WEINBERG vs. JOEY JORDISON | PT. 2 | Battle Of Music #7

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
  • ►►►►►►►►OPEN/ABRE◄◄◄◄◄◄◄◄◄
    Hi! Comment your favorite one :) Please Subscribe and rate the video if you like it!
    Hola! Comenta cuál es tu favorito :) Por favor suscribete y likea el video si te gusto!
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ► Likea y suscribete si te gustó. ¡Saludos!
    ► Thumbs Up and subscribe if you like it!
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ►TWITTER: / franchernobyl (follow x follow)
    ►INSTAGRAM: / fran_blitzk. .
    I DO NOT OWN ANY SOFTWARE USED IN THIS VIDEO!
    ALL RIGHTS TO THE AUTHORS PROP

Комментарии • 1,4 тыс.

  • @_frvn_
    @_frvn_  3 года назад +236

    RIP Joey Jordison (1975-2021)
    I can't believe this...

  • @nyonyaherlambang
    @nyonyaherlambang 4 года назад +1182

    Jay is awesome, joey is Legend

    • @zildjianborromeo9256
      @zildjianborromeo9256 4 года назад +5

      Tanga tanga bobo buwenas fuck you how can you say hes legend

    • @dereks.1719
      @dereks.1719 4 года назад +21

      Zildan calm down

    • @zildjianborromeo9256
      @zildjianborromeo9256 4 года назад +6

      @@dereks.1719 wtf did you just say

    • @edodarma2259
      @edodarma2259 4 года назад +8

      Jay is better

    • @Justadudeisall
      @Justadudeisall 4 года назад +13

      Zildjian Borromeo He said calm down you can’t read that simple sentence? I would imagine your brain is that of a caveman’s since you result just to cursing at people don’t hurt yourself tiny brain man

  • @zombreon6021
    @zombreon6021 3 года назад +247

    Imagine how jay felt joining slipknot knowing joey is his predecessor

    • @GizmoWasNotHere
      @GizmoWasNotHere 3 года назад +11

      if nothing else he sure as shit had his work cut out for him

    • @ryanlawrence8305
      @ryanlawrence8305 3 года назад +13

      @@GizmoWasNotHere agreed to disagree slipknot music is a cake walk for jay, being the son a Max Weinberg that’s been drumming since the 60s. So jay been drumming since he was a child and jay knows his stuff!

    • @GizmoWasNotHere
      @GizmoWasNotHere 3 года назад +5

      @@ryanlawrence8305 All of that is very true, but at the same time if you have ever watched any joey drum cams even though the quality of the videos were pretty dog shit you could still see that he flew right threw the songs easily, jay can do joeys part better but he has to actually try.

    • @ryanlawrence8305
      @ryanlawrence8305 3 года назад +6

      @@GizmoWasNotHere yes I have watched a lot of joeys vids and to be honest this is just MY opinion a lot of joeys vids is sloppy. But I’ve seen videos of him I was like wow he’s good. It sucks that the original drummer is gone but they couldn’t find any better replacement than jay! Jay fits right in with those guys

    • @dxshawn532
      @dxshawn532 3 года назад +1

      @@ryanlawrence8305 Yawn

  • @NotExplicable
    @NotExplicable 4 года назад +756

    Joey flows effortlessly probably because he created the sound.

  • @Raivazz
    @Raivazz 4 года назад +976

    joey was a damn psycho on the drums. but jay earned my respect and I really can't say anything bad about him

    • @maccasclips6357
      @maccasclips6357 4 года назад +18

      Raivazz this comment is perfect

    • @osbaldohernandez9174
      @osbaldohernandez9174 4 года назад +8

      Joey did more shit that’s why he is the best drummer in the world

    • @noahb1383
      @noahb1383 3 года назад +5

      Joey is awesome and I won't take that away from him. But jay is just better. He grew up with the sticks

    • @deanb4799
      @deanb4799 3 года назад +3

      I tried to hate on Jay but failed miserably. I get my Joey fix from VIMIC and SCAR THE MARTYR now.

    • @TheWalonja
      @TheWalonja 3 года назад +1

      only thing i noticed is that joey had this puls like in some parts he has to hit out of the box that made the songs kind of escalating and jay has more grove and they did some fkn nice stuff with him 🎊 i mean if slipknot works how it should than the ll still be in 200 years with other members and if every new member will always ignite the next fire 🔮 im just pumped for this guys

  • @vlravengedsevenfold2158
    @vlravengedsevenfold2158 4 года назад +349

    Joey - like
    Jay - comment

    • @noahb1383
      @noahb1383 3 года назад +2

      Jay

    • @zullu4321
      @zullu4321 3 года назад +1

      Jay

    • @rustyshackleford9452
      @rustyshackleford9452 3 года назад +5

      They're both great

    • @tukului9623
      @tukului9623 3 года назад +4

      Can i like both? Am i gonna get my head on pike if i choose both?

    • @lukebilyeu2038
      @lukebilyeu2038 3 года назад +3

      Jay an Joey both monsters on drums no doubt both different but both bad ass

  • @tevinterry2794
    @tevinterry2794 4 года назад +168

    Joey is a speed drummer. Jay is a groove drummer. Both total badasses

    • @seanfothergill4039
      @seanfothergill4039 3 года назад +18

      Yet Joey played faster and grooved better than anyone

    • @lf906
      @lf906 3 года назад

      This

    • @megadeath098ajb
      @megadeath098ajb 3 года назад +5

      They both do that well.
      I just hate comparing them they're both good at what they do, Joey is self taught, and an absolute power house, metal drummer, Jay in contrast was brought up with Jazz influence under his dad's wing you really hear the dynamics in how he plays love them both, RiP Joey!

    • @BusyBeeOne
      @BusyBeeOne 3 года назад +3

      Joe was originally a guitarist who became a drummer, because he could do it better (speed and strength phenomenal but timing changes not as nuanced) IMO. Jay is a drummer through and through. This is evident in his care with timing changes. Joe was perfect for Slipknot, and so is Jay.

  • @Letsdonothingtogether
    @Letsdonothingtogether 3 года назад +61

    RIP Joey, you will be missed.

  • @bigmike9558
    @bigmike9558 4 года назад +421

    Jay is cleaner, Joey though has that raw speed and just psycotic flow that is just savage

    • @shanksmcnasty6650
      @shanksmcnasty6650 4 года назад +7

      You're right but he damn sure wasnt cleaner in this video

    • @ratpiss9004
      @ratpiss9004 3 года назад +9

      The only reason jays drumming sounds “cleaner” has to do with two things. First, the fact that his kit is mic’d up and the heads he is using on his kit mainly the snare are different.

    • @dxshawn532
      @dxshawn532 3 года назад +5

      @@ratpiss9004 Audio quality also

    • @MrHartApart
      @MrHartApart 3 года назад +3

      could not have said it better. joey has that natural garage band excellence to him, jay, you can tell is trained which isn't bad.

    • @coltthegamer5758
      @coltthegamer5758 3 года назад +1

      yes

  • @VolBeat2412.
    @VolBeat2412. 4 года назад +586

    0:04 , 0:10 , 3:31 Duality
    0:15 People=Sh*t
    1:17 Eyeless (intro part)
    1:52 Eyeless (final part)
    2:18 Prosthetics
    3:41 Unsainted
    4:45 Killpop
    6:00 Solway Firth

    • @yngpenny3436
      @yngpenny3436 4 года назад +4

      VolBeat 2412 I would hope that everyone would know the name of the song before they clicked but hey 🤷‍♂️

    • @ragelight2601
      @ragelight2601 4 года назад +2

      3:31? why duality?) that's unsainted

    • @theo1807
      @theo1807 4 года назад +3

      RageLight no that was duality

    • @deamondrumm3r355
      @deamondrumm3r355 4 года назад

      0:04 is pshchosocial

    • @SK23.
      @SK23. 4 года назад

      @@ragelight2601 no its not...

  • @MrDiamonddriller
    @MrDiamonddriller 4 года назад +195

    As a drummer myself I love both styles. Joey was the original and slipknot wouldnt be who it is now without him. Jay is an Incredible drummer for his age and I'm a massive fan of his style, love What he has bought to slipknot and in my opinion it was what was needed. He's changed the dynamic of the band for the good. Technically and artistically he is the next Joey already looking forward to see how he goes. The last 2 albums of his have been fuckin mint!

    • @tudyrock6074
      @tudyrock6074 4 года назад +4

      I am a drummer too, and I can just say that you are damn right fam

  • @eshaandaksh2968
    @eshaandaksh2968 4 года назад +474

    You can't compare Joey and Jay, but they both have the same hunger, excitement, and energy for Slipknot and music itself.
    Jay although has an overall cleaner playing, being from a jazz background

    • @travisspaulding9540
      @travisspaulding9540 4 года назад +18

      Crizy ED Joey started off in jazz......

    • @fiachra6052
      @fiachra6052 4 года назад +29

      And what does that tell you? Joey is a beast and a way more creative, natural, sick and intense as fuck drummer but technically jay is way cleaner and tigher but I'd still prefer Joey's style to jays all day

    • @senorgarcia4071
      @senorgarcia4071 4 года назад +5

      jays dad is a beast at jazz i honestly don’t thing jay has jazz chops, he can’t hang with his boomer dad

    • @eshaandaksh2968
      @eshaandaksh2968 4 года назад +1

      @@travisspaulding9540 I actually did not know that, thanksd

    • @travisspaulding9540
      @travisspaulding9540 4 года назад +3

      Crizy ED I just saw a video, Jay isn’t a jazz drummer at all. His dad taught him the basics of playing but he doesn’t play jazz, he’s just a metal drummer.

  • @med5.2s8
    @med5.2s8 4 года назад +117

    Joey Joey Joey Joey Joey, the best, miss him 😔

  • @sebastianmahecha8173
    @sebastianmahecha8173 4 года назад +183

    Jay Is good
    Joey Is god

  • @pinchnloaf
    @pinchnloaf 4 года назад +170

    I’d say Joey but jay really came into his own on we are not your kind. Both are great.

  • @NMages20
    @NMages20 4 года назад +390

    Honestly I love Jay as a replacement. I don't think they could have gotten anyone better

    • @labexe5373
      @labexe5373 4 года назад +1

      Betto Cardoso

    • @19145_hw
      @19145_hw 4 года назад +4

      Drummer from Lamb of God

    • @aprilpadul6781
      @aprilpadul6781 4 года назад +2

      Chris turner

    • @gofigure84
      @gofigure84 4 года назад +9

      @@19145_hw Chris Adler I don't feel would be right for slipknot. Lamb of God is a different kind of metal than knot.

    • @gofigure84
      @gofigure84 4 года назад +1

      I would be curious to see Aquiles Priester play slipknot. Outside of Mike Mangini he was the best option for Dream Theater in place of Portnoy. He is a endless book on fills.

  • @vickylegrand2605
    @vickylegrand2605 4 года назад +42

    Can we please take into consideration of the sound quality between the two, old footage (1999-2006) sounds like it was recorded with a chalk board. Makes Joey sound less of quality compare to HD recorded sounds of today. Hence why Jay sounds cleaner/crisp, both great drummers btw, but I love Joeys speed,and on stage performance ( spinning drum solo and head banging while playing).

  • @Medievalfan94
    @Medievalfan94 3 года назад +45

    Joey is more of a endurance drummer. He gets into the tunnel and just lets loose, becomming the animal, achieving insane speed.
    Jay is way more technical. The polyrythmic lines from unsainted would never have happened with joey. I love how slipknot gained so much more musical depth with Jay.
    As a drummer I really love the classic songs, Wait and bleed, Duality, Before I Forget, People=Shit etc. All those classics can be learned quite easily. The hard part for most of them is building the endurance and the speed. But with the songs that Jay played, unsainted, not your kind etc. the drum parts are way harder, not because of speed but for complexity.
    Joey drums hard, Jay drums smart. Both are in their own right just absolute geniusses on the drums. Love'em both.

    • @PapaShubz
      @PapaShubz 3 года назад +4

      Did you skip past the parts of Joey playing Eyeless and Prosthetics? That shit is way more technical than anything on .5 and WANYK

    • @b-bopeddie1290
      @b-bopeddie1290 3 года назад

      Oh bullshit.......

    • @torrotorch7068
      @torrotorch7068 3 года назад

      @@PapaShubz two different time periods man. Back in those days that was the style of Slipknot. ..they're older now and don't need all of that speed playing. Sometimes less is more.

  • @nightdevil22666
    @nightdevil22666 2 года назад +7

    With Joey, you can feel the drumkit heating up and burning lol. He is incomparable.
    RIP legend.

  • @jesusflores8299
    @jesusflores8299 4 года назад +206

    Los dos son unas bestias de la batería, pero en lo personal prefiero a joey, para mi es el mejor en cuestion de originalidad y su desenvolvimiento es épico, esa es mi opinión, cada quien piensa diferente.

    • @br0kenheartz14
      @br0kenheartz14 4 года назад +8

      Exacto

    • @alejandroom9616
      @alejandroom9616 4 года назад +11

      Apoyo al desconocido

    • @m4x1thevo1d3
      @m4x1thevo1d3 4 года назад +13

      No pensé ver el día en el que JJ sea reemplazado, pero bueno, hacia rato se lo veía con ganas de tener su propia banda. Los dos son impresionantes, pero apoyo que Joey Jordison es mejor.

    • @br0kenheartz14
      @br0kenheartz14 4 года назад +3

      @@m4x1thevo1d3 una leyenda

    • @yeduyory3380
      @yeduyory3380 4 года назад +3

      De acuerdo hehe

  • @Prod.Germ00
    @Prod.Germ00 4 года назад +73

    I find Joey's sound to be more unique than Jay's. Joey is one of those drummers you know it's them by just hearing them. Yeah Jay's playing is more clean but Joeys has more overall energy in his tracks

  • @Lendir_unboxing_19
    @Lendir_unboxing_19 4 года назад +32

    Always and forever Joey Jordinson...

  • @darien9456
    @darien9456 4 года назад +76

    Their both amazing. But Joey is the roots and jay picked it up from Joey and added to it to make it his own.

  • @faustfrost2426
    @faustfrost2426 4 года назад +245

    Just Joey Jordison

    • @batflipbaseball5983
      @batflipbaseball5983 4 года назад +6

      Ok I’m sorry but stop complaining about jay your just mad jay is here but guess what Joey is gone and jay is a freaking psycho on the drums and Joey really just played simple beats so zip it about Joey cause he is gone

    • @jeremykeithgonzales1278
      @jeremykeithgonzales1278 4 года назад +3

      They're still both great livin legends of the drums

    • @leonchee
      @leonchee 4 года назад +4

      Let's just say I want all the original band members back.

    • @thissguytorzclawson7116
      @thissguytorzclawson7116 4 года назад +6

      @@batflipbaseball5983 now that's some bullshit😠

    • @ded8435
      @ded8435 4 года назад +1

      @@batflipbaseball5983 uhmmm not hating on jay, but from what you said jay is the psychotic one? Clearly you don't know what the word "psycho" means

  • @riverdeep399
    @riverdeep399 4 года назад +116

    Joey was hungry for it and artistic.
    I also think he got shafted. So when you grew up with Joey, you feel he was owed a little more respect in how things went down.
    Not Jays fault, but there's allegiance there.
    Jay is good. Hard at it..

    • @cricket9474
      @cricket9474 4 года назад +3

      Didn't he leave because of health issues? I believe he said that in an interview

    • @sidddd29
      @sidddd29 4 года назад +14

      Cricket he got kicked because the others thought he was doing drugs because of his disease I think, his performance deteriorated and that disease ended up almost taking his legs

    • @travisspaulding9540
      @travisspaulding9540 4 года назад

      Sidd- but luckily he’s playing in 2 hands now :)

    • @bahe_4058
      @bahe_4058 4 года назад +11

      He didnt get shafted. He had a neurodegenerative disorder in his legs that was preventing him from playing well, you can tell in a lot of 2013 clips. He left the band because they weren't playing at their best with him in it anymore and hes gone on interview saying he has no hard feelings for the decision made

    • @nickh3499
      @nickh3499 4 года назад +5

      Didn't joey also take Paul's passing the hardest and also found it hard to carry on without him? And yea I've watched and read more about joeys disease and him needing to be carried off stage

  • @franzabana5242
    @franzabana5242 4 года назад +9

    the reason why both drummers are great is because their first name starts at letter J and ends with Y.. they are true beast..

  • @LarrySmokeProductions
    @LarrySmokeProductions 4 года назад +73

    That Eyeless Breakdown Video is iconic

    • @swanky3368
      @swanky3368 4 года назад +4

      thats the intro not the breakdown

    • @crazylegs85
      @crazylegs85 3 года назад

      Look me in my brand new....

  • @LorriSanga
    @LorriSanga 3 года назад +9

    While Jay is an awesome drummer, it's Joey's creativity that sets them apart.

  • @KetoFitChef
    @KetoFitChef 4 года назад +50

    I’m gonna have to go with Joey for sure! IMO, Joey and Chris Adler are the two greatest drummers.
    Jay is a great drummer and a much “heavier” hitter than Joey, but Joey has such blazing speed and a crazy energy level while playing. Jay is a great replacement, but I miss Joey!

    • @RIFFSandBLADES
      @RIFFSandBLADES 3 года назад

      Danny Carey is better imo

    • @liamsguitaring2296
      @liamsguitaring2296 3 года назад

      yeah chris adler is probably the best drummer ive ever seen

    • @cosmic_JAV
      @cosmic_JAV 3 года назад

      @@RIFFSandBLADESdef 1 of the greatest

  • @UltimaSphera1
    @UltimaSphera1 3 года назад +6

    RIP Joey ❤️

  • @atmanegara.6662
    @atmanegara.6662 4 года назад +29

    Jay Weinberg : " I'm the best metal drummer in the world
    Joey Jordison : " i'm the best metal drummer 4ever !!!
    George Kollias : " Interesting ..."

    • @lexengle
      @lexengle 4 года назад +3

      Who is JOY Jordison???

    • @ivannieuwenhuizen73
      @ivannieuwenhuizen73 4 года назад +1

      jep

    • @grizzlymanverneteil4443
      @grizzlymanverneteil4443 4 года назад

      Maybe the should join metal bands then

    • @regorf
      @regorf 4 года назад

      @Captain Swantown Because WANYK totally sounds like SS, get your head out of your own ass.

  • @faizismail2627
    @faizismail2627 4 года назад +59

    \m/ Team Joey Jordison \m/

  • @ll3yWanTeD
    @ll3yWanTeD 4 года назад +5

    Both are amazing, intense and unique. I just miss the legendary drummer (Joey).

  • @denver3113
    @denver3113 4 года назад +79

    JOEY JORDISON

  • @leandrolima9998
    @leandrolima9998 4 года назад +77

    You can't see Weiberg's drumming without Joey fanboy eyes

  • @tye7791
    @tye7791 4 года назад +26

    Let’s remember Joey is an all around good musician , played guitar for the murderdolls , and also drums for scar the martyrs , Joey also has his own promark signature sticks , which I personally fukin love

  • @canvey100
    @canvey100 4 года назад +121

    I love both equally, If anything I have grown too prefer jay

    • @tjboylan20
      @tjboylan20 4 года назад

      Ellis jones-hawes me too i like the newer songs like unsainted and solway firth the drums are great

    • @travisspaulding9540
      @travisspaulding9540 4 года назад +5

      tj boylan that’s not just the drummer tho, the entire band has grown to be more proficient than they were.

    • @DarkKnight-q2d
      @DarkKnight-q2d 4 года назад +2

      The earlier years of Slipknot will always be the best. Iowa will always be the best time for Slipknot as a whole, in my opinion. That's the sole spirit of what Slipknot is and always should be. Since Joey left the band, I definitely have seen a massive decline in the band. They're just not the same band I became obsessed with and that actually saved my life. That being said, I have nothing against Jay. Both drummers are great, but I will always prefer Joey.

    • @Fj3llis
      @Fj3llis 4 года назад

      @@DarkKnight-q2d yeah, its a thing called age you know...

    • @BiggieCheese01
      @BiggieCheese01 4 года назад

      Zach Pohlman Okay I love Iowa but saying that it was the best time for them as a whole is pretty stupid, I think it was one of their best times music wise right next to WANYK. Corey has said that he drank a bottle of Jack before almost any show and smoked a lot of cigs. Most of the other members were on some pretty hard drugs too, especially Joey which is likely what caused his disease. I have nothing against Joey and I’m not saying he’s a bad drummer by any means but his form at times was a bit awkward and he wasn’t a very technical drummer but he had speed and put soul into his sound. Slipknot all together have gotten more mature and have tamed the beast that controlled them in their younger days.

  • @anthonygrilli4919
    @anthonygrilli4919 4 года назад +48

    Joeys got more swag and flavor.

  • @anginbarat1662
    @anginbarat1662 4 года назад +7

    Slipknot = JOEY MACHINE
    LOVE JOEY FROM INDONESIA 🇮🇩🇮🇩

  • @beeorfinada3882
    @beeorfinada3882 3 года назад +3

    You can't compare these two, they're both great on their generations🔥

  • @ZoltanvamosOfficial
    @ZoltanvamosOfficial 4 года назад +21

    As a drummer, Joey seemed to have degraded pretty quickly. His technique was great at first, his style was very straightforward and he had a decent amount of precision. Jay is much more technical, has fluid fills and drum patterns, and his style changes based on the song they play. Jay is the obvious winner, he is more technical, he is less straightforward and he played the songs Joey played, but in his own way. That's something that should be praised.

    • @TrainersToLeaders
      @TrainersToLeaders 4 года назад +1

      Venus Productions I just commented like the same thing hahaha totally agree

    • @hsolomon9058
      @hsolomon9058 4 года назад

      I agree

  • @marisanaguilar9291
    @marisanaguilar9291 4 года назад +9

    Jay é muito bom, mas JOEY é JOEY! Era a alma da banda, um monstro ❤❤❤❤

  • @mc2120
    @mc2120 4 года назад +12

    Joey for sure. Remember the songs Jay is playing Joey wrote. You can't say Jay has better tempo or range as it's not his songs, he's playing Joeys songs. The band was way harder with Joey as well. Joey is a machine...Jay is a good drummer.

    • @taylordunn3256
      @taylordunn3256 4 года назад

      M C but jay can play joeys stuff he came up with and slipknot hasn’t got rid of jay

    • @florianvolk2901
      @florianvolk2901 4 года назад

      the sound of the band going softer hasn't got anything to do with just Jay, it's the fact that the band had to change and that they grew older. personally i feel like they both managed to perfectly match the sound the band was going for at the time and amphesize the energy

  • @nasku2506
    @nasku2506 4 года назад +60

    Ok. I like Jay more than Joey. I like Jays style of playing more than Joey. But Joeys posture on the drums is so badass when he plays.

    • @TheTrueJesusChrist
      @TheTrueJesusChrist 4 года назад

      What style lmao

    • @nasku2506
      @nasku2506 4 года назад

      @@TheTrueJesusChrist drumming style. Look at their different styles. Different way of playing. do i need to explain more?

    • @TheTrueJesusChrist
      @TheTrueJesusChrist 4 года назад +2

      Nasku I know what style is I’ve drummed my entire life lmao. I think jay is a good player but his writing is awful

    • @nasku2506
      @nasku2506 4 года назад

      @@TheTrueJesusChrist how is his writing awful?

    • @TheTrueJesusChrist
      @TheTrueJesusChrist 4 года назад

      Nasku reusing the same fill a bjillion times in one album

  • @JulesBox
    @JulesBox 4 года назад +6

    Joey was one of the main reasons for me to pick up a pair of drumsticks, bur gotta admit that I enjoy Jay a lot more.

  • @12Jsilva
    @12Jsilva 4 года назад +6

    dude.. joey for playing and also how his hair goes swirling like crazy!!!

  • @18idlesuggest
    @18idlesuggest 4 года назад +12

    After hearing alot more songs from them (both AHIG below and .5 above)
    I can definitely say Joey is better for me, you can feel the intensity in his style.
    Jay is great though but I do hope in the next album he can make better stuff, no offense though

  • @NewFoundLove
    @NewFoundLove 4 года назад +2

    They are both great drummers, hard choice for me. I’d be equally happy if I had either of them in a band.

  • @Criticalr6
    @Criticalr6 4 года назад +5

    i love jay he’s definitely a badass and the best replacement for slipknot but i pick joey bc first of all when i think of slipknot joey comes to my mind and something ab joeys sloppy style just always makes me happy and joey is one of my biggest inspirations for drumming but jay is too i love both of them i just prefer joey

  • @reynnishii9021
    @reynnishii9021 3 года назад +2

    Joey’s drum sound is massive, raw and fits Slipknot. I miss the songs that were in his times. Something about his choice in chops is so magnetic and fierce!

  • @order66dotexe
    @order66dotexe 4 года назад +33

    Obviously they're both great but Joey would be in the band still if it wasn't for his health issues at the time.

    • @DragonOxys
      @DragonOxys 4 года назад +3

      The thing is that u need alot of stamina to play drumms... and Joey would be 44 by now... Joey is a legends but for now Jay is better cause he is alot younger and plays very well

    • @order66dotexe
      @order66dotexe 4 года назад +1

      @@DragonOxys Obviously.

    • @goldenltd1970
      @goldenltd1970 4 года назад

      Jay playes more like joey did when he was younger
      In his later years it was either blastbeats or fast double bass and for me it was anoying, there was no groove and feeling anymore
      Jay brought that all this back into the sound

    • @ekoseli7225
      @ekoseli7225 3 года назад

      No one who can't replace the blood in slipknot bodies

  • @matiasaguilera3922
    @matiasaguilera3922 4 года назад +12

    Joey siempre, aunque jay en este último disco si me gustó, pero igual Joey es mejor, almenos hasta antes de enfermarse

  • @marvinwatson2749
    @marvinwatson2749 4 года назад +4

    Joey is one of the small few og drummers that is super entertaining to watch. Great sound but as a fan he head banging with you while playing gives him my vote. Might not be as crisp as jay but i feel like joey is more playing while partying with you than playing for you while you party

  • @jirkakux8910
    @jirkakux8910 4 года назад +31

    my vote is for Joey, cuz he is faster and more technical than Jay, but Jay is monster in drums too.

    • @thrashhero9804
      @thrashhero9804 4 года назад +4

      Joey is faster yes but not technical
      In his solo, there are 0 technique and 0 creativity unlike Jay

    • @travisspaulding9540
      @travisspaulding9540 4 года назад +1

      TrashHero where do you figure that?

    • @travisspaulding9540
      @travisspaulding9540 4 года назад +6

      TrashHero no creativity ???? You realize he wrote a number of the Slipknot songs even down to the guitar parts right?

    • @travisspaulding9540
      @travisspaulding9540 4 года назад +6

      ElBuenCharlyyy you’re an idiot, I hope you know that. Seriously.

    • @ididntmeantoyt3864
      @ididntmeantoyt3864 4 года назад +3

      @@travisspaulding9540 as much as I like Jay I have to agree that eibuencharlyyy is an idiot

  • @bubblesiff5246
    @bubblesiff5246 4 года назад +38

    Joey

  • @intie8367
    @intie8367 2 года назад +1

    They are both amazing, its pretty impressive that joey was also self taught, but jay is a great new drummer, i miss joey tho!😢

  • @alex_willow01
    @alex_willow01 3 года назад +3

    Joey es una leyenda y Jay es digno de ser su sucesor en Slipknot.. Los dos son unas bestias en la bateria

  • @fobo3361
    @fobo3361 Год назад +1

    from what I'm seeing idk much about music but Jay seems to be alot more rhythmic, he repeats movements with a rhythm to it over and over, almost taking a back seat to the song, where as Joey was just pure chaos, he was all over the damn place, all while rocking out head banging and shit, its genuinely insane to see how fast his arms were moving, Joey was the song

  • @abstrati8118
    @abstrati8118 4 года назад +113

    Joey is Faster than Jay
    Jay is more technical than Joey

    • @andyk2607
      @andyk2607 4 года назад +19

      I wouldn't say Joey is faster. Jay can play everything that Joey ever did perfectly live (speed and all) if not faster dependent on how fast the rest of the band are playing a certain song

    • @mikelegofan
      @mikelegofan 4 года назад +13

      Joey sucks. Maybe, for common guy it is not obvious, but any professional drummer would say, that he is not technicall at all (live), and he has a terrible feel of time. One good thing, that I could say about him, is that he was very creative with his parts(first three albums), and the first two albums were pure madness

    • @DiegoGallegosGiles
      @DiegoGallegosGiles 4 года назад +5

      A good fucking comment finally; and two fucking good answers too.

    • @travisspaulding9540
      @travisspaulding9540 4 года назад +6

      LEGOMIKFILMS Lego animations you’re an idiot 😂😂

    • @travisspaulding9540
      @travisspaulding9540 4 года назад +6

      Andy K and Joey is definitely faster; or at least he was when he was Jay’s age.

  • @efrainferrari5799
    @efrainferrari5799 3 года назад +2

    Lo que ayuda mucho a Jay es la calidad de sonido qué hay en estos días. Pero los dos son muy buenos!!

  • @Javier-bh6sv
    @Javier-bh6sv 4 года назад +24

    Joey forever 🤘

  • @magda-de3ps
    @magda-de3ps 3 года назад +1

    it’s like watching the master vs the student, joey has that pure energy and creativity whilst jay follows cleanly

  • @jandilsonsilva4930
    @jandilsonsilva4930 4 года назад +72

    Joey 55% x Jay 45%

  • @deanwicks1896
    @deanwicks1896 3 года назад +2

    Jay grew up listening to joey and you can tell that from the way jay plays. He carries joeys legacy well

  • @josejairo7762
    @josejairo7762 4 года назад +11

    O Jay toca com técnica como podem ver ele sempre toca um pouco mais duro, já o Joey tocava com o coração por isso se tornava mais insano, isso não quer dizer que o Jay não toque com o coração afinal ele é um fã da banda, mas o Jay toca com um certo cuidado

    • @diegovieira4468
      @diegovieira4468 4 года назад

      A bateria na epoca do Joey eram nais exploradas isso pq as musicas exigiam mais

  • @RyosukeKai
    @RyosukeKai 2 года назад +2

    It's Joey Period. A legend.

  • @juniordrums9743
    @juniordrums9743 3 года назад +6

    JOEY JOEY JOEY o Melhor Eternamente!

  • @dewbahka3166
    @dewbahka3166 4 года назад +2

    For me it is like comparing Apples to Apples, they are both amazing in what they are capable of doing.

  • @TrainersToLeaders
    @TrainersToLeaders 4 года назад +11

    As a 15 year drummer myself overall both hit hard and are energetic. When it comes down to being in the pocket or clean playing jay takes the cake by a long shot. Joey takes innovation in terms of drum Riffs. But then again jay does that just not to the extent of Joey. Overall as a drummer I have to go with Jay based on technique and overall skill.

    • @TheTrueJesusChrist
      @TheTrueJesusChrist 4 года назад

      Joey in Vimic is super clean and technical now. He always was but the only really good audio clips of Joey in slipknot were in 2012-13 when his body was deteriorating

  • @johnfulton2672
    @johnfulton2672 4 года назад

    Liking one over the other doesn't mean the other is shit both are amazing and awesome to watch

  • @juliuscollantes5853
    @juliuscollantes5853 4 года назад +4

    1:12 just this part. End of the debate.

  • @johnnybigmac5756
    @johnnybigmac5756 3 года назад +1

    I have nothing against Jay but to me Joey WAS Slipknot. Imo the biggest reason I'd see them live was for him. I know Joey did it too but I feel that Jay is far more basic in his patterns especially during verses. Joey's unique style is what really got me into them and helped establish my love for drums. Joey just had this unique groove that was incredibly heavy and fit perfectly with the others. One of my top 10 drummers and why they ditched him the way they did is just beyond me.

  • @jpenglish1748
    @jpenglish1748 4 года назад +4

    I love both drummers but I like jay I think his style is better

  • @legendhustle503yt2
    @legendhustle503yt2 3 года назад +2

    In conclusion, Joey more metal and raw. No hate on Jay he's badass but Joey's double kicks and headbanging are brutal

  • @VolBeat2412.
    @VolBeat2412. 4 года назад +5

    I like both, but currently I like more Jay than Joey. He's doing an amazing work on the drums and he has improved a lot since his first shows with Slipknot. So if I had to choose only one of them, I would choose Jay.

  • @AQ3DDeathSpade
    @AQ3DDeathSpade 3 года назад +1

    they are both phenomenal drummers joey is legendary, he is the one who made slipknots drumming and music easily recognizable. jay is rare, he is talented he has his own unique drum style and still makes slipknot prevalent even tho joey is no longer in the band. great musicians,great talent,great sound😎

  • @levyxavier97
    @levyxavier97 4 года назад +6

    Joey🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @rjgregorio406
    @rjgregorio406 2 года назад +2

    Joey's aggression vs Jay's tempo. Both amazing

  • @bscrim4-1alicaboclarksteph9
    @bscrim4-1alicaboclarksteph9 4 года назад +26

    they're the same so good at drums, I want joey back to slipknot then they have 2 drummers now🤟

    • @necs7021
      @necs7021 4 года назад +4

      Just imagine them playing live with 2 drummers i would be (sic)

    • @necs7021
      @necs7021 4 года назад +1

      @@mystic1160 Clown and Tortilla Guy are not drummers, they are percussionists

  • @kodemasterx
    @kodemasterx 3 года назад

    Joey inspired Jay to be who he is today, from a big fan to being the drummer of the band, what a dream come true...
    RIP JOEY JORDISON

  • @rickneal4967
    @rickneal4967 4 года назад +79

    Winner: Lars

  • @ckla1101
    @ckla1101 4 года назад +1

    มือกลองวง Slipknot คือ Joey คนเด่ยวเท่านั้นที่ดีที่สุด ผมฟังทุกอัมบั้ม ตีได้หนักน่วงแล้ว แล้วรุ้จังหวะกลองว่าสมควรตีแบบไหนของเพลงแล้วแต่ร่ะเพลง ตีได้ทรงพลัง ผมรักมากคับคนนี้ Joey Jordison มือกลอง Slipknot สับกระเดื่องเทพสุดแล้วหาตัวจับยากบอกดลยคับ

  • @scottmcbride2237
    @scottmcbride2237 4 года назад +3

    Their both good but i think joey blows jay out of the water. He just seems more skilled and faster, his speed is flawless and he just performs it so well that you can hear every note and it isnt muddy.

  • @slipknot2092
    @slipknot2092 3 года назад +1

    Joey is the original and legend. But Jay is an excellent replacement though. I dont think anyone else could of filled them shoes. But jay was born a drummer and his dad is legendary

  • @camilarodrigues514
    @camilarodrigues514 4 года назад +3

    Jay é um excelente baterista...mas acho q falta um pouco daquela emoção e paixão que eu via no Joey ao tocar. Joey sempre fará falta!

    • @Bruno-vb1qz
      @Bruno-vb1qz 3 года назад

      Concordo contigo. Jay é incrível, mas Joey tem um feeling que faz parte da música, parece que tudo toma uma única forma. E gosto mais da agressividade dele tbm.

  • @morganefourmanoir4390
    @morganefourmanoir4390 3 года назад +1

    I love Jay but I grew up with Joey and I'm a huge fan of his talent.🔥 Their styles are different but both great so we can't choose . And as we say stay (sic)!!! 🖤🤘

  • @nickhernandez4429
    @nickhernandez4429 4 года назад +18

    Jay = more crisp and organized
    Joey = fast and unorganized

  • @FranciscoSilva-ip3zl
    @FranciscoSilva-ip3zl 4 года назад +1

    Não têm comparação entre quem é melhor. Eu curto o slipkont desde de meus 15 anos. Hoje tenho meus 34 anos.
    . Em meu tempo de rock, para mim os 2 bateristas são muitos muitos bons e merece meu reconhecimento como fã e como curtidor do rock in roll....
    Para mim os 2 bateristas são bons de mais muito, os 2 estao de parabens.

  • @emmanuelans9493
    @emmanuelans9493 4 года назад +4

    Joey siempre será el mejor baterista que allá tenido Slipknot 🤷🏽‍♂️

  • @wolfpackhustler
    @wolfpackhustler 11 месяцев назад +1

    Joey paved the way for modern metal, Jay has stepped into those shoes really well, but nobody is Joey Jordison.

  • @hforero79
    @hforero79 4 года назад +10

    Jay is definitely a more solid cleaner drummer. Joey wrote some sick drum lines but always plays sloppy and can’t hold a tempo. Plays way to fast and loses the pocket. Final =Jay is the better drummer

    • @thereaper2433
      @thereaper2433 4 года назад +2

      Joey is more aggressive drummer than jay thats why he sometimes looses his tempo. But still original is always be the best

    • @coreyekstrom3248
      @coreyekstrom3248 4 года назад

      I'm sorry but Joey stays in time better then most drummers his timing is amazing you can't play in bands like Rob zombie especially ministry of you didn't have time or tempo

    • @hforero79
      @hforero79 4 года назад

      Not so much 🤦‍♂️ Joey was a naturally gifted percussionist but he lacked precision in tempo and sharpness in his strikes. Even on most of the studio albums (Iowa was his tightest) with the help of quantizing and other MP&E tricks the sound is very rushed and muddy. They’re better off with Jay who has a more comprehensive sounds and feel. Joey could better his skills by taking notes from tighter drummers like Vinnie Paul or Matt Grenier. #facts

  • @m-h1269
    @m-h1269 2 года назад +1

    Joey: Plays extremely fast with beats focusing heavily on rhythm, which then transcends into fills directly directed towards rhythm and the beat aswell. The fills radically change intensity often, making the drums switch between high and low moments frequently, which then keeps a constant high pressure in the song without feeling like untechnical intensity. Utilizing double base drums and a variety of rolls at ridiculous speed.
    Jay: Focusing more on groove and melody, with fills to spontaneously change intensity from stalemates to create high areas. This creates more highlights in the drums. This results in overall rhythm being less interesting, with fills being the focus to lift the song.

  • @hsolomon9058
    @hsolomon9058 4 года назад +5

    Joey because jay took Joey's power and used the power to make his own

  • @charlo8890
    @charlo8890 3 года назад +1

    When we all heard slipknot, we all thought Joey Jordison......we all dont think about the drummer anymore when we hear slipknot. Thats really enough said.

  • @theelder5542
    @theelder5542 4 года назад +6

    Joey my Love

  • @codyforbes7670
    @codyforbes7670 4 года назад

    Joey is a legend. He set the bar...shit he created it. I am forever a huge fan. Having said that...i frigging love jays playing. He found a way to adapt joeys crazy style to suit his own. I personally am loving the progression of Jay Weinberg. Hes got a funky, addictive playing style that blends metal and jazz...and its nuts. Hes a one of a kind...and is still so young who knows where his peak is

  • @lagmetal
    @lagmetal 4 года назад +9

    Jay IS phénoménal 😍

  • @gokusan3135
    @gokusan3135 4 года назад +2

    2019: Jay melhor batera do mundo considerado por várias revistas sobre metal 💪💪
    Respeitem o cara, FABOYOLAS do Joey

    • @mikhayahudim
      @mikhayahudim 4 года назад +1

      Jay não faz 30% dos rolos e groves do Joey mais serve como severino.

    • @nygynymarcos8592
      @nygynymarcos8592 4 года назад +1

      O Joey era a essência viva do Slip, deu pra notar a diferença de quando ele saiu, sem mesmo saber que ele havia saído

    • @leandrolima9998
      @leandrolima9998 4 года назад +1

      Falou tudo. Os caras parecem que gostavam mais do Joey que da própria banda em si, o Jay toca tudo que o Joey tocava, ñ sei pra que esse mimimi

    • @nygynymarcos8592
      @nygynymarcos8592 4 года назад +1

      Mano, muita gente passou a admirar a banda por causa do Joey, até mesmo que não curte o gênero se rende á genialidade do cara, não é desmerecendo o Jay, mas o Joey é outro patamar

    • @coreymaggot9158
      @coreymaggot9158 4 года назад +1

      @@nygynymarcos8592 tão outro patamar que foi mandado embora. Ele parou de tocar em 2011, lento pra cacete

  • @P1nkman
    @P1nkman 4 года назад +36

    Joey is a natural, exceptional playing and ideas. Jay is technically OK, but his drumming is pretty boring and generic, no offense to his fans.

    • @adrianflorean4012
      @adrianflorean4012 4 года назад +2

      Kuba D go look at skeptic drum cam and the negative drum cam and try saying that again bud

    • @eezadeijat6413
      @eezadeijat6413 4 года назад

      yup

    • @lenuboi8829
      @lenuboi8829 4 года назад +1

      Drum triggering is not natural drumming.

    • @fx4549
      @fx4549 4 года назад +1

      Lenu Boi i think he talked about natural talent

    • @DiegoGallegosGiles
      @DiegoGallegosGiles 4 года назад

      Kuba D Are you a drummer? Cuz if you were one you could say what you said without being argued...

  • @juniorocp6826
    @juniorocp6826 4 года назад +1

    A presença do Joey na batera, faz muita diferença, não desmerecendo Jay, que toca absurdamente bem.